Kelly Clarkson-Beautiful Disaster

[thiagomellogodinho]

Beautiful Disaster is a song of album Thankful...

[ebethster]

This is the first time I have heard this song and I love it...... <3

[TheIsobel51]

@ebethster listen to the live version too, its amazing!!

[Tracey92101]

hes not enough but i can't get enough of him god i hate him and love him i hate that i love him hes just a disaster but so beautiful if only i could hold back the tears and tell him to stop laughing i need support like if i should ask him out

[batsibabe]

awesome hit!! thumbs up!

[MsDottie09]

This version is from her 1st CD. I like this version but like the version on Breakaway better. She also sang this song with Reba on their tour in 2008 - beautifully done. Love Kelly in whatever she sings. Can't wait for her next CD. But now I'm listening to her duet with Jason Aldean "Don't You Wanna Stay" and her new song "You Still Won't Know What It's Like".

[LeonaIsBack]

when i first saw this video i thought that this was gonna be a cover of 311's song..thank god its not or i would have had to kill somebody :D

[KLanonymoussinger]

i like the live one, because she seems to come alive, and the song means more and its simpler.

[Gretch19891]

@Flow3rFac3 To say the least there were just too many things that complicated things ,the biggest is that he is engaged to get married :-(((.........

[Gretch19891]

I found my beautiful disaster unfortunately nothing came from it*sad face*

[xT3knOpath]

@Gretch19891 mine too :'/

[Prissi20]

@Gretch19891

me too :'(

[Flow3rFac3]

@Gretch19891 what happened then?

[aashpunk]

yeah, i like the live version better :/

It's just more impactful when it's slowed down and with less music

[evilemogirl3058]

this version is way better than the live one the live one sucks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[AlexHossler]

A girl at work told me to look this song up. It reminds her of me...

[FullyRellyOnGod]

i like the piano version better

[volcrazy89]

This song is on Kelley's first album ("Thankful"), not "Breakaway", which is her second.

The live version is on Breakaway.

[singittotheskyx]

Live version, so much betterrr !

[panduski]

Hello, my name is Scythe, check out my new latest love single about ( KELLY CLARKSON ) called Brown Hair / Brown Eyes with lyrics on my channel..

And if you are liking the new song, feel free to add or subscribe

Thanks

-Scythe- xx

[MrChristopheFrance]

BEST SONG I LOVE IT

[ShowcaseOfStars]

this is amazing. Check out t youtube dot com/miaarose she has a beautiful version of this too.

Kelly is amazing

[Mythinkingbox]

i listened to the live version so much that i forgot there was an original version. i like the live version better. it sounds pure & beautiful. but then again, i NEVER heard of this original version 'til now so yes, it will sound & feel different... anyways, KEL rocks!!!!! xD

[mizzwatevsmanda]

this song explains almost everything that a typical girl is thinking../going through :) i love her voice and when i saw her live....shees jusst flawless

[peaceloveanna15]

i've never heard this version before.. the live one is soo real this one is way to poppy

[xSparkleSmilex]

that pic dosent look like her

[TwiPuccaFan1]

i like the live version better!

[scumbag64]

I think the lyrics and style of the song suit the live arangement much better. It makes the song sound much more "Kelly" x

[sampleswoman]

accidentally downloaded this song last yr never hearing it b4 but now i luv it.

[TheOneXethneX]

love this song

[MsDottie09]

Wonderful version but I prefer her live performance of this song. She's great!!!!

[101SCOUTfan]

llllooovvee it!<3

[singinginto2011]

Best song ever.

[capricornxxx123]

This just proves the point that live versions is showing so much more real singing than this fake voice that no one can live up to.

[at90percent]

Kelly obviously likes the live version better. It's the only way she performs it now.

I personally like this version better though.

[abmdckd]

@at90percent why????? this version has an upbeat extra music in the back round of a sad song!! her voice is awesome though but the upbeat back round music is kinda going against the song...

[at90percent]

@abmdckd Eh, what you see as upbeat, I see as intense pulsing and hard driving, which matches the frustration she feels about the situation. The slow song is a girl crying song. The fast one is more of an angry frustration song, which I happen to like better. Then again, I like The Who. They have lots of songs like that.

[at90percent]

@abmdckd Did you ever hear Christmas from the album Tommy? Very (as you would say) upbeat tune about a deaf, dumb and blind boy that has no clue that it is Christmas day sung from the point of view of his much frustrated father.

[batsibabe]

@at90percent

so true

[shareenskr]

@at90percent "She like the live version better. It's the only way she performs it now." How else could she perform it live?

[MissSassy071]

@shareenskr Lol...

[btatwo]

@shareenskr.............. Keepin' it real.

[at90percent]

@shareenskr In other words. When she started performing this song in front of an audience, she changed the song by slowing it down significantly and only being accompanied by piano. I would like to see her perform the full band version and faster tempo version on stage in front of an audience.

[TheKellyClarksonlive]

@shareenskr On Breakaway there was a live version of this (acoustic) and she always preforms it that way live, not with the drum and stuff, like this!! just her voice or just her voice and the piano... That is what @at90percent means with ''she likes the live version better''!!

[btatwo]

@at90percent Maybe I'm crazy but every time she performs it, she is live. YOU watch or listen to it recorded. Just sayin'

[at90percent]

@btatwo Cute, however versions normally considered LIVE are ones performed in front of an audience, not performed in the recording studio.

[TheKellyClarksonlive]

@btatwo Ofcorse she preforms live but on Breakaway there was a live version of this, and she preforms it always that way (acoustic) not like this, I mean she almost never does it with the drum and stuff.. Just her voice or only her voice and the piano and that is what @at90percent means!!!

[NiteShade99]

</3 im sorry... i don't like this version.. i love the live version better<3 i like the sorrow instead of the uppity like someone else said you know?

[TheRealDealReview]

53+ people are idiots

[lilymaymadden]

love this song.

[sweetsugar191]

Love this song

[protoville]

@JavaJunkie555  This faster version is the original from the album. The slower is the alt version.

[SuperLovebug8]

the live one is soo better its more heart filled and beautiful

[TheTwilightAmanda]

Now this version i like! The live verison is good to. But this is much better. It feels more real. And together

[teslafreeman]

live is soo much better! this music doesnt at all go with the lyrics. it just doesnt work!

[01jackofan]

love this song

[Fungirlbigheart]

i love the live version with the piano (:

[jaykamoum94]

2:32 - 2:56

LOVE THAT PART

[KellyRocksRSocksOff]

I like both versions. :)

[XYoungLadyLonelyX]

Personally I love this song live!! she sounds amazing when she sings it live. This beat doesn't really go with the meaningful lyrics so when she does it live it's like amazing!!!

[boomchickawowwow24]

i like both versions as long as shes singing:]

[RebaRoxxMySoxx13]

Yeah it is better live!

[starstuddedwishes]

i think the live version better cuz the music fits the lyrics better...they have more meaning.

[joedemijemi1]

KELLY IS AWSUME!!!!!!!!!

[BuddhaZenMind]

woo woo

[Renn148]

i luv both versions, the live version is more strong and emotional, but this version is more upbeat :)

[JosieMeta7343]

my moms a beautiful disaster, thats why i just put this song on for her tehe!

[AlvaroAndfriends]

WOW this song represent a mood i feel many times. AWESOME SONG.

[1996Sarusia1996]

To jest najfajniejsza i najpiękniejsza piosenka Kelly !!! ;*

[mmmbad]

I definitely like the live version A LOT better! It's SO emotional! The first time I heard it I cried, especially because it reminds me of a friend's relationship. The song fits her man perfectly.

[SimonaFanTH4ever]

I prefer from live..this i don't like at all

[sergeymuryhin123]

local talent show = cute girl + this song = epicness

[dj02tc5]

i love this song omgd so cute

[xxRENxTUxx]

i like this live better :) this is too like....happy......sounding? anyone agree? hahah

[4eva5]

i like it better when she was live with the piano. it brought more meaning to the lyrics.

[2212hannahxo]

defo prefer live version!

[liling96]

She look so teenage like in this album :) Her songs have always been soothing to my ears :D And her vocals did improved alot ! Her voice now is so POWEERFUL !!

ROCK ON KELLY \m/ always loving you and your songs <3

[protoville]

I like this version with those hard-driving guitars in the background contrasting with Kelly's sweet voice. And I like the vocal harmony on "beautiful"..."beautiful disaster."

[gfustel]

live is definitely better

[cookieflu]

It makes me wanna cry... I ♥ Him O=

this song describes me... he's dating my friends but i still find him beautiful... love you Joey Br****.. ( I censored his name for his privicy (=

[meganleigh1994]

Love Kelly, but i like the live version soo much better :)

[MissCsporty]

Love Kelly she has a great voice.

[Jazzmin586]

kelly klarkson is a weird wigger bitch who deserves to have a jar shoved up her ass then the jar gets broken so she gets a bleeding ass lololol

[aboo00oode992]

@Jazzmin586 fuck you !!

kelly is amazing and she is not bitch !

[CourtneyJH1]

i am singing this song in the talent show and i agree it sounds better live on the CD than it does in this Video

[KaizerHiwatari]

She looks so young in this picture...

[Lotjeentinus]

live is much better i love kelly but i like the version live better<3

[notyourgirlygirl]

Kelly I told you i was going to make you a "Honey Do List" Check it out on the

Jesse Nashville James channel. the video is going to start out with a soilders voice

saying " It is 130 degrees, when I think of you, your body is like a mirage rising up

from the heat" The soilder seals the envelope with a kiss and says "I made you

a honey do list. Let's do a duet... it is will a huge hit JESSE NASHVILLE JAMES

[TornHeartzIn2]

i like this song.

[aleilei1]

i like this song......alot!

[LuvTaylorLautner247]

i love the pic hahah

[zina623]

i like the live better, but still <3

[Londoncrazy3]

i love this song! the live is beter!

crw that was such a beautiful disaster

[luvromonkeys]

the live version is my fav, with the piano. (:

[AintNoOtherGeo]

is there a STUDIO ballad version like the live one?? plz let me know! ;)

[lucjehey]

Love the song <333

[anzieisawsome]

im goin to her concerttt

[SHAMZB]

when is it?? Please let me know as i would reallly like to see her!!!

[anzieisawsome]

@SHAMZB umm may8 but in macao

[Luuva1]

i love this song but i prefer the live version...it siuts the lyrics better than the upbeat version :P

but that's just my opinion :)

[arielagu33]

. i love this song !

[Jinka7]

I like the live version better...it seems to make the words more poignant, because they're not hidden by the unnecessarily upbeat music.

Just my personal observation. No disrespect.

[1iluvchocolate1]

@Jinka7 everyone agrees with you so there is no disrespect

[fallenangel8889]

@Jinka7

IKR... haha when i first heard this song, it was the live, and i got addicted to it. then i heard this somewhere else, and i was like, "this is probably the same song... but its just weird. WTF"

[Bridgirl11]

@Jinka7 I have the live version on my CD.

[xsultrysongstress79x]

@Jinka7 This has always been my favorite version and the one i heard first! Nothing wrong with the upbeat version, but it is just NOT the same. Takes away the meaning.

[Stilletos96]

@Jinka7 Completely agree.

[JustinBieberGirl04]

"I dont know.,.,.i dont know what he's after....but he's so beautiful, such a beautiful disaster...."

[Bollwoodlover26]

BEAUTIFUL, what a beautiful songg!

"he's just so beautiful, such a beautiful disaster, and if i could hold on thro the tears and the laughter, would it be beautiful, or just a beautiful disaster"

[Taylorfan10323]

yeah!

[Taylorfan10323]

NICE I LOVE U KELLY AND I HAVE 200000000000000000000000000000­000000000000000000000000000000­000000000000000 posters all over my wall and ur face 4 comp wall paper and i have all ur CD's and been to every concert!

[warmastah]

u traveled all over the world to see every concert?

[blackrosezredwheelz]

@Taylorfan10323

just askin'?

then why are you named Taylorfan10323?

[CherryBlossom1207]

@Taylorfan10323

O.O

[charliebergy101239]

one of Kelly's best!!!! without a doubt!

Kelly's a treasure and thanks goes to AI for bringing her to us!

And thanks to Kelly for building on her AI win to bring us such great music! GO GIRL!

[grlnblk16]

keep it up girl! i know jst what ur saying

[4everpawzzzz]

i luv kelly clarckson!

[TheHeartNeverLiesXx]

forgot how much i love this song <3

[TheFreeSpiritX]

"Oh and I don't know

I don't know what he's after

But he's so beautiful

He's such a beautiful disaster

And if I could hold on

Through the tears and the laughter

Would it be beautiful?

Or just a beautiful disaster"

-sigh- so true atm.

Love this song <3

[babyally95]

agreed, :)

[StephGala]

the acoustic version is so much better

[Kassidy003]

i like the slow

[musicfan4eva95]

This is the thankful version

[myLoniii]

i love this song but i like it more if miaarose sings it !

but its just my opinion...

[RebaMissers]

Kelly Rocks I love this song

[natsasupastar]

I like the live version more.

[appledumpling032]

It scares me all the time and freaks you out all the time wen U sleep at night. . .

[walerya20]

suas músicas são a trilha sonora da minha vida!!!!

[IWASBORN1985]

isn't it from the THANKFUL album?

[NothingNumbered]

I was just thinking that...

[fairyfay80]

Yes it is from Thankful!

[MusicLoverWeert]

she released 2 versions

the Acoustic Version and the Normal..

this the normal version..

[savannahrocks1000]

i love this song =]

[ivelostmimarblez]

I'm sure I'm not the only one but this song has so much meaning to me now that I see my ex for what he really is.

[CookieLuver1000]

same i don't know what i feel anymore.I'm feeling so many emotions i dont know wich one to follow

[TheUnknownQueen]

I realy like kellys songs but I got to say this is my fav.

[SuperParamoreFanatic]

Yeaa,crushesonlycrushyou,

Its like some rock version :P

[MegaNonoD]

I love this song :)

especcially the title beautiful disaster xd

reminds me of someone :P

[5zacefron]

this song definitely gives me emotion!!

[MsKawaiiGirl]

I think both versions are very nice.  Each version gives sort of a different vibe, so I like both of them separately.

[elise251522]

Anyone else think this is better live?

It's more powerful :)

[kellibbzxx]

Definitely!!!!! More emotion :P

[lindsaynicole19]

much better live

[LithiumLullabys]

@elise251522

yes better live definitely

[lani19941]

@elise251522 i agree i saw her in concert and this song is so amazing live the cd doesnt do the emotion justice

[JosieMeta7343]

@elise251522 yeah shes way way way better live! ! !

[crushesonlycrushyou]

anybody think the beginning of the song sounds like the tune from taylor swifts, you belong with me?

[kellibbzxx]

haha it actually does a bit!

[gaarasrulestheworld]

reminds me of a guy i know </3

[waybabelicious]

...this is the exact version on my Kelly Clarkson CD, "Thankful", ....in fact, this was my fav song on it...which CD has the live version?

[CHRISBPAGE]

breakaway last song

[kaldude8]

Breakaway has the live version, idk why they have breakaway art on this version cause this version is from Thankful.

[xaoxia]

No idea, but my sister gave it to me. I can throw it your way.

[knhgirl]

Breakaway has the live version.. If I remember right, it's the piano version too.