i dont understand! why should we be enemy towards each others.we both Shia & Sunni & others followers pray to the one & only god ALLAH.do you really think that ALLAH like to see us killing each other.We're suppose to be united as 1UMMAH.i dont think Prophet Muhammad & Maula Ali(a.s) want this to happen.Cant you people see that it has been hundred of year since Islam minority in NonMuslim country a being treated refugees in their own country.you know why?BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT UNITE AS ONE.
@suk0nepa So is this the ethics of a Sunni Muslim? I don't think so. This is not even the ethic of anyone who believes in the One God. What more someone who believes in Allah (swt). and the last of the prophets Rasulullah Muhammad (saw). When one is ignorant of his own religion this will happen. I pray that Allah forgive you for your words .
@MujheUnknownUSer What did u mean by lakum diin nukum waliya din? Did'nt u mean I hv a different religion that your's? Did'nt u mean I am not a Muslim? U called me a dog and this is your Islamic teaching taught by the Prophet of Islam?! If I am what you called me may Allah forgive me and If I am not may Allah forgive you! When u make accusations against Shia u shld also be prepared for rebuttal but sad to say u r not prepared for that! Calling me names will not change the fact u hv no answer!
I dont have to prove myself to u, when u instead of opening the opportunity for debate, just made accusations of me being a wahhabi and saying things like slumber will take me to hell. so, Lakum dinikum wa liya deen.
@MujheUnknownUSer IN that case just say you do not have answer to what I have rebutted. Your wahhabi views are ot new! Yes your accusations against Shias will take you to hell and Lakum aamalukum wa lana aamaaluna! Don't care to post more if that is the case >. But if you are searching for truth we can go on!
@MujheUnknownUSer This is the biggest lie that the enemies of Islam tried to do; putting lies into the mouth of Amirul Mukminin Ali bin Abi Talib (as). I will wait for your answers to what I have written before furnishing you with more proofs against your wahhabi ideas.
Regarding hadis that the forbidance took place in Hunain as narrated by An Nasai from Ali bin Abi Talib, besides having a weak narrator Rabi' bin Surrah there are differring report saying it was forbade during Hajjatul Wida. So MujheUnknownUser, don't just quote something that you are not familiar with. '
The hadis regarding the forbidance of mutah during fath ul makkah is weak because one of the narrators Abdul Malik bin Rabi' bin Surrah is considered weak by Ibnu Qayyum. Ibnu Hajjar Asqalani also considered him weak
.قال أبوخيثمة: سئل يحيى بن معين عن أحاديث عبدالملك بن الربيع عن أبيه عن جده فقال: ضعاف. وحكى ابن الجوزي عن ابن معين أنه قال: عبدالملك ضعيف. وقال أبو الحسن ابن القطان: لم تثبت عدالته، وإن كان مسلم أخرج له فغيرمحتج به
MujheUnknownUSer, Omar himself is a proof that mut'ah was practised during the time of the Prophet (saw) and he was the one who forbade.Read and understand. See the gievn references if you can read Arabic those were from Sunni books!
These are the words of Omar who forbade two kinds of Mut'ah
متعتان كانتا على عهد رسول الله وأنا أنهى عنهما وأعاقب عليهما
References if you know Arabic!MujheUnknownUSer تفسير الرازي 2|167، شرح معاني الاثار 374، سنن البيهقي 6|207، بداية المجتهد 1|346 المحلّى 7|107، أحكام القرآن ـ للجصّاص ـ 1|279، شرح التجريد للقوشجي الأشعري، تفسير القرطبي 2|370، المغني 7|527، زاد المعاد في هدي خير العباد 2|205، الدرّ المنثور 2|141، كنز العمال 8|293، وفيات الأعيان 5|197.
if we just remain silent or maintain a 'tolerant stance' towards all the lies, just imagine how it will evolve further in the future to conceal the truth behind more lies. However that doesnt mean we should be hostile to other religions/faiths.....that is another perspective altogether :)
Rasulullah mentioned about amar ma'ruf nahi mungkar......enjoin the good & forbid evil. And in line with that we have to uphold the truth and especially with the distortions that have existed that caused so much conflict and confusion among Muslims, we have to condone all the lies and distortions so that the future generation will insya Allah continue to uphold and know the truth :)
@absleg3 Yes he is. I'm from Malaysia. Ordinary (Sunni imam ) does not wear mullah's dressing but using gamis or plain shirt.
azuan01 4 months ago
subhanallah, i really like this video
toadster91 8 months ago
i dont understand! why should we be enemy towards each others.we both Shia & Sunni & others followers pray to the one & only god ALLAH.do you really think that ALLAH like to see us killing each other.We're suppose to be united as 1UMMAH.i dont think Prophet Muhammad & Maula Ali(a.s) want this to happen.Cant you people see that it has been hundred of year since Islam minority in NonMuslim country a being treated refugees in their own country.you know why?BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT UNITE AS ONE.
TIKUSHUTAN91 10 months ago
@suk0nepa So is this the ethics of a Sunni Muslim? I don't think so. This is not even the ethic of anyone who believes in the One God. What more someone who believes in Allah (swt). and the last of the prophets Rasulullah Muhammad (saw). When one is ignorant of his own religion this will happen. I pray that Allah forgive you for your words .
dpandaiboi 10 months ago 4
@MujheUnknownUSer It is good that someone is trying to be an ayatollah rather than an idiot!
dpandaiboi 1 year ago
may Allah help the shia there and all over the world !!
alimeksiki 1 year ago
ya ayyuhal muslimun stand united no matter what as yawmul kiyamah is near..dont let them seperate us..
muhammadn9 1 year ago
@MujheUnknownUSer What did u mean by lakum diin nukum waliya din? Did'nt u mean I hv a different religion that your's? Did'nt u mean I am not a Muslim? U called me a dog and this is your Islamic teaching taught by the Prophet of Islam?! If I am what you called me may Allah forgive me and If I am not may Allah forgive you! When u make accusations against Shia u shld also be prepared for rebuttal but sad to say u r not prepared for that! Calling me names will not change the fact u hv no answer!
dpandaiboi 1 year ago
الحق من ربك.
I dont have to prove myself to u, when u instead of opening the opportunity for debate, just made accusations of me being a wahhabi and saying things like slumber will take me to hell. so, Lakum dinikum wa liya deen.
MujheUnknownUSer 1 year ago
@MujheUnknownUSer IN that case just say you do not have answer to what I have rebutted. Your wahhabi views are ot new! Yes your accusations against Shias will take you to hell and Lakum aamalukum wa lana aamaaluna! Don't care to post more if that is the case >. But if you are searching for truth we can go on!
dpandaiboi 1 year ago
@MujheUnknownUSer This is the biggest lie that the enemies of Islam tried to do; putting lies into the mouth of Amirul Mukminin Ali bin Abi Talib (as). I will wait for your answers to what I have written before furnishing you with more proofs against your wahhabi ideas.
dpandaiboi 1 year ago
Regarding hadis that the forbidance took place in Hunain as narrated by An Nasai from Ali bin Abi Talib, besides having a weak narrator Rabi' bin Surrah there are differring report saying it was forbade during Hajjatul Wida. So MujheUnknownUser, don't just quote something that you are not familiar with. '
dpandaiboi 1 year ago
The hadis regarding the forbidance of mutah during fath ul makkah is weak because one of the narrators Abdul Malik bin Rabi' bin Surrah is considered weak by Ibnu Qayyum. Ibnu Hajjar Asqalani also considered him weak
.قال أبوخيثمة: سئل يحيى بن معين عن أحاديث عبدالملك بن الربيع عن أبيه عن جده فقال: ضعاف. وحكى ابن الجوزي عن ابن معين أنه قال: عبدالملك ضعيف. وقال أبو الحسن ابن القطان: لم تثبت عدالته، وإن كان مسلم أخرج له فغيرمحتج به
dpandaiboi 1 year ago
MujheUnknownUSer, Omar himself is a proof that mut'ah was practised during the time of the Prophet (saw) and he was the one who forbade.Read and understand. See the gievn references if you can read Arabic those were from Sunni books!
dpandaiboi 1 year ago
These are the words of Omar who forbade two kinds of Mut'ah
متعتان كانتا على عهد رسول الله وأنا أنهى عنهما وأعاقب عليهما
References if you know Arabic!MujheUnknownUSer تفسير الرازي 2|167، شرح معاني الاثار 374، سنن البيهقي 6|207، بداية المجتهد 1|346 المحلّى 7|107، أحكام القرآن ـ للجصّاص ـ 1|279، شرح التجريد للقوشجي الأشعري، تفسير القرطبي 2|370، المغني 7|527، زاد المعاد في هدي خير العباد 2|205، الدرّ المنثور 2|141، كنز العمال 8|293، وفيات الأعيان 5|197.
dpandaiboi 1 year ago
Tenkiu veri much for this.. i enjoyed this sermon \in english\ >.<`
KamikazeiOo 1 year ago
TRUTH will PREVAIL over falsehood, lies and baseless accusations :)
alizola86 1 year ago
if we just remain silent or maintain a 'tolerant stance' towards all the lies, just imagine how it will evolve further in the future to conceal the truth behind more lies. However that doesnt mean we should be hostile to other religions/faiths.....that is another perspective altogether :)
alizola86 1 year ago
Rasulullah mentioned about amar ma'ruf nahi mungkar......enjoin the good & forbid evil. And in line with that we have to uphold the truth and especially with the distortions that have existed that caused so much conflict and confusion among Muslims, we have to condone all the lies and distortions so that the future generation will insya Allah continue to uphold and know the truth :)
alizola86 1 year ago