Added: 3 years ago
From: newscientistvideo
Views: 90,447
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (288)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • DOH?

  • This video suggests that the big bang hypothesis is wrong. If everything we see really came from a tiny, spinning dot, then all of the celestial objects should today have that same spin as the original spinning dot.

    But, as this video shows, some things in the universe do not spin the same direction.

    It's time for the other explanation to get some credit.

  • @field16 That doesn't even make ANY sense.

    Assuming that the universe was created from a tiny spinning spot (no legitimate cosmologist i've ever heard of has said this is true, or even likely) why in the world does that mean that EVERYTHING in the universe needs to sin the same way?

    Do you not understand the simple laws of physics?

  • @jib1000 Sometimes the simplest laws are the hardest for people to accept.

    Do you not agree that massive objects in our universe are spinning? The Earth spins, the solar system spins, the galaxy spins... Cornell University has a web page stating the Universe is isotropic (the same in all directions).

    If everything exploded out of the same dot, would you expect all the massive objects to spin in the same direction? If not, you have a very complicated problem to solve, as this video shows.

  • @field16 Your just talking nonsense. First of all, an isotropic and homogenous universe does NOT assume that everything spins the same way. It assumes that the universe is GENERALLY the same throughout. Meaning that most of the mass/energy isn't on one side.

    Assume the solar system is like a clock. Everything spinning clockwise. If an extra solar body comes in from the left and starts to orbit around the 6 o'clock position it will orbit counterclockwise. That doesn't negate the big bang.

  • @jib1000 It's hard to argue with you, because your assumption is wrong. The solar system does not, as a whole, spin clockwise, as you lead us to assume. It spins counter-clockwise.

    If you never spoke nonsense yourself, it would be easier for you to slander others, and not get caught.

  • @field16 WOW

    First of all there is no way to say that the solar system spins clockwise or counterclockwise since that all depends on your frame of reference. Secondly it was an ASSUMTION to illustrate a thought problem in simple terms. My assumption being right or wrong doesn't change my hypothetical situation one bit. Clearly you know little to nothing about physics, cosmology, or even simple high school science.

  • @jib1000 There you go slandering me again. You do not appear to be willing to speak rationally. If you were seeking truth, I would have been happy to discuss this with you in a friendly way.

  • @field16 How am i to get the truth about cosmology from someone who doesn't understand what frame of reference or assumption means? I mean you don't appear to know much about the subject you're trying to debate. Then you tell me I talk nonsense? Prove me wrong, say something about cosmology that sound 's like you know what your talking about...

  • @jib1000

    hahaha oh quite pretending even though it's fun to lie about how much we know online. Just buy a telescope and have some fun with the universe rather than fuss over the basics, the big boy scientists know more than we can hypothesize.

  • @JFri4321 What am i pretending to know about? High school science?

  • @jib1000

    I apologize, after re-reading the conversation my comment should have been directed towards field. I agree, his logic is ludicrous. And it is absolutely the basics, i.e. high school ed.

  • @JFri4321 Ah ok i didn't think i was comming off as a PhD cosmologist or something... I do have a moderate college level understanding of science and was pretty sure i learned about what field is clearly misunderstanding in high school.

  • @field16 Gave up eh?

  • lol fun i there is "intelligent" life just behind the sun, and we been looking for years xD

  • this is the most amazing video i've ever seen in my entire life ! ! ! not really. i'm just being absolutely hilarious ! ! ! not really. but i can definitely see that distant object orbiting our sun backwards ! ! ! not really.

  • Dude, the average YT viewer only knows the reigning ' Dancing With The Stars ' champion. WTF makes u think they can decipher this ?

  • Nibiru

  • i heard this was just a drawing. is this true?

  • This picture of a stationary sun is all wrong, check out Nassim Haramein he shows you how the sun moves through space and it is all dynamic spirals.

  • No guy in a lab-coat? No weird synthesizer music playing in the background? This video proves nothing!

  • so, how would that orbit be represented three dimensionally as the entire solar system moves? the other planets create what looks like a spiral, what would that produce? my imagination is limited by years of TV and internet videos.

  • Interesting...Most people are saying the tenth planet is in the southern sky at it's closest. You depict it as in the northern sky. Assuming up is north in your animation.

  • So our Sun stole someone elses baby .. we must go there and discover alien life

  • That is! A tasty burger!!

  • cfeps.net/KV42_Press.html

    

  • Yes another object that kicks evolutionists in the face. HAHA! God-hating morons.

  • if a dropped a dog turd at 5000 ft. with 9.3 G's and a cat turd at 400 ft with 4.15 g's, which one would smell like shit when it hit the fan.

  • I have a penis :|

  • @T0mat0S0up LMFAO!!!

  • 2008 KVA42. somethings suspicious about it.

  • @ronaldli5 That is the "Extra-solar" body they found in 2008. They're saying it has a mass several times that of Jupiter, the largest planet in our solar system. If that is true, this body is second only to the sun. If this body comes into our solar system, it will wreak gravitational havoc.

  • @Kostly fuck i knew it. holy shit.

  • FAKE

  • Can I smoke crack in the 5th dimension?

  • @Jx8o5 LOL!!!

  • @Jx8o5 No. But, you would probably be able to experience that dimension with a proper dose of DMT.

  • danger Will Robinson!

  • But ... I have a better theory ! And sound like this " Is there is an UNCLESHIP there ... Or maybe :-s all FAMELYSHIP'S there ... "

  • asdlfjkas Of course, how do you think the small spaceships form? : )

  • It could just be an object that was passing by (like an asteriod) and caught in the gravity of the solarsystem, just like the planets are, but it is orbiting "un-naturally" because it is foreign... thats my hypothesis... its actually really simple. I wouldnt even worry about it (or make a youtube video of it either)

  • its getting crowded in our little plot of milky way. school books are going to turn into flyers,,hahahaha-the universe was so simple when I was a child.

  • pancake remix!

  • Planet X or Nibiru.. ..

  • yeah really cool and the point is??????

  • Comment removed

  • Looks like Bertrand Rusells Teapot has finally been discovered... or is it the FSM?

  • What if our whole solar system is orbiting around 2008 kv42. I think I'm right. Because if 4=x and 19x+(-log1.3X10^-11)=6.02(x^3)­-y.

    So y=3.3334X10^153. Am I right? Correct me if I'm wrong. Thank you.

  • @srtyhtm 2 plus 2 equalls 222 !!!

  • Time is a bi-product of space.If there was no point B to travel to from point A there would be no motion. Timekeeping is a method to take measurement of motion.

  • time exist in the same dimension as we do.. anyone saying otherwise is a loof

  • fake and gay dont understand shit numbers suck 1"&"31414512124124

  • Nibiru?

  • I'm tellin ya, it's a scientific fact: There's always one.

  • That one fellas... its a drunk planet D:

  • yea kinda... what a toolbag response..

    go back to ur menial job, sheep

  • sheep? all i said is it doesnt matter....who cares if theres another mini planet orbiting the sun ? why dont we focus on curing fucking aids ...

  • the problems of the universe are far more important than aids...unless u got aids.....

    Im more interested in exactly where we came from whether it be from another planet, GOD, alien genetics.. whatever it may be...plz dont respond.. u obviously like drifting sidewaysfcs0718 so dont make me hate you... peace

  • where we came from ?

    we got 2 fields of science dedicated to that

    abiogenesis and evolution , both are perfectly mutually compatable , and abiogenesis explain how life appears from simple chemical compunds

  • I think he means where we came from as in before the big bang, and time. It's much less of an interest to me the go about of matter turning into life, because some of the steps have been reproduced in a laboratory. It is just extremely complicated. No body knows what happened before the big bang. Some hypothesize that there was an imaginary state of matter, which shifted down into our state of energy. Only good theory I have heard of so far.

  • actaully u cant imagine what happened before the the big bang cus "our" time and space began at the big bang ...there is no "before"

    once u get into string theory and start talking about dimensions above 4d time has no more meaning .

  • First of all, wtf is 4d time? According to string theories, and M theory, there is only one time dimension. There are theories with multiple time dimensions, but they usually refer to forward/backwards for a total of 2 time dimensions. And, you infact can imagine what happened before the big bang if it happened in another time frame. We don't know that time began at the big bang, it only shows when our universe came into existence. There may be infinite universes, or other areas outside.

  • once u get above 4d , time has no meaning .....

    thats cus 4d space and what we feel as time are in fact 1 and the same ...so time only applies to the dimensions below 4d space , above 4d space, time has no more meaning ...

    i said "our" time began at the big bang ...

    time itself probably didnt have a beginning since 11d space doesnt have a temporant existence ...the 3d,2d,1d,and0d spaces below 4d time all have beginnings and ending , 4d space itself tehnically shouldnt ..since it IS time..

  • No, in any of the above spatial dimensions, or below, time is still the same.. hence space-time. We all feel one time dimension mixed into space, they all act as the same time. Time is "entangled" into space, and "extends" from 0 to 11 dimensions. And our time from pre-universe time may or may not have a distinct meaning, we don't know. It may be two separate times, or it may be simply equivalent to saying 200 years BC was not our time, because we are AD, infact though, .. obviously it is.

  • actually m-theory itself (the leading version of strign theory) says that time is actually a spacial dimension ..

    what u feel as the passing of time is actually you travelling throo 4d space (atleast i think it was 4d it could be 5) ..

    time is just another space dimension , dont bring einstein into this , his concept of space time doesnt consider 4d space ..m-theory does ...and lets not forget we are a long way from einstein ...if he was alive who knows what progress we would of made..

  • I will bring Einstein into this, seeing that his laws still apply. And to straighten things out, time isnt a 4'th spatial dimension, you misunderstood. Time is our 4'th ACTIVE dimension. We exist in dimensions 1, 2, 3 which are spatial, as well as 1 time which gets considered as "our 4'th dimension", hence a total of 4 dimensions that are active. M theory suggests 11 dimensions (10 spatial, and 1 time).

  • No where in the theory should lead you to beleive there are higher time dimensions, excluding people who consider forward and backward time travel as two separate dimensions. I am not saying time is not "mixed" into higher dimenional space, because it is, which is called space-time. Go back and review the theory, post summary of your statements, you do not have the theory well embedded.

  • who the hell said anything about higher time dimensions?

    i said theres 1 dimension of time ...its 4d ...but time and 4d space can be considered the same thing according to m-theory ...

  • no, time and 1d space can be considered same thing. spacetime cna be considered 4d. you fucking tard

  • Time is a single dimenion added to our list.. which is 1 (or some say 2) dimensional, forward/backward. Where do you obtain 4d? Time interacts with all dimenions of space, if you look at it from the perspective, it is 10d, or 11d if you consider the "zeroth" dimenion a dimension, 12d if you consider that plus the fact that time is 1 itself, 11 if you consider time one itself and not the zeroth, 1 if you see forward/backward, 2 if forward and backards are separate in your opinion, not simply 4d

  • Don't look up things about the universe, or anything along those lines until you pass first grade. And especially, don't comment please, it made me sad at how ignorant you are to the subject xD.

  • this short clip does not demonstrate anything.

  • @greatsilentwatcher

    actually yeah it does.

  • ahahahaha, I can tell it's fake. Nice try though. If the experiments at CERN go well,telescopes, and the equipment we use today to look @ stars will all change.

  • l like to sit on that and go backwards......maybe it would be make me years younger...lol...mmm...what goes up comes down....things go round and anti-clock wise....interesting....

  • It doesn't orbit 'backwards.' The correct way to say it is that the plane of its orbit is off by 'x' amount of degrees compared to the plane of the orbit of the other planets. Example: The plane of Pluto's orbit is 20 degrees off compared to the plane of the orbit of the other planets. BTW: There are MORE trans-Neptunian objects than just Niburu

  • actually it does orbit backwards.

    the term is "retrograde" orbit.

  • So it orbits clockwise (when viewed from overhead?)

  • There is apparently a good reason why it can't be "observed". You have not been researching the story on the web, not even YouTube.

    Seek and ye shall find.

    But different parties are fighting for your attention to take note or to disregard the NIBIRU story.

    It gets a bit confusing after a while.

    But try as I might, I cannot find anything to persuade me to dismiss the NIBIRU story outright.

    Trust me, I want to believe I can intelligently dismiss it as just a hoax or joke.

    Still, 2012 soon.

  • What if the Solar System proves to be a binary? That possibility still exists.

    In the old days, retards in Europe mocked Galileo about his observations too.

    Keep an open mind so that new facts that come up can be used to update and understand our world.

    "There are two kinds of men who never amount to much: those who cannot do what they are told and those who can do nothing else."

    ( Cyrus H.Curtis)

    We can add,substituting"dogma";

    There are two kinds of men who never love to seek the truth...

  • Our space buddies in Spain have found our system is binary and the Brown Dwarf is now in the Sagitario Pluto area. From Pluto to Jupiter many meteoroids have hit the outer planets as it moves out of the Orht Cloud into our system.

    Funny the guys from Spain are openly asking NASA why they have been so hush hush or missed it with all of their infrared telescopes.... some in multiple postions near the arctic where they would have been able to detect it years ago.... NEVER A STRAIGHT ANSWER

  • Please cite sources. You could be lying.

  • What is it with some people... they want thier thinking done for them... they also want their ass hairs combed for them too. I gave you enough info you can plug into any search engine and see for yourself. You should become familiar with the saying...

    I can give you a fish and feed you for a day, or I can show you how to fish and feed you for life.

  • this never happened, but there are quite a few scientists out there who do believe our solar system is binary with a second orbit of a few million years. This isn't really my field of interest but if any of our "space buddies" discovered this, regardless of NASA's stance I'm sure we'd all know about it and not just you smart ass, it was a good laugh though.

  • Comment removed

  • uh ever heard of a comet?

    halle-bop has a 4000 year eliptical orbit.

    halley has a 76 year orbit.

    not all orbits are circular with the sun in the middle.

    you silly billy.

  • NIBIRU WELCOME BACK...

  • is 2009 where's this so called Nibiriu if it can't be observed ?

  • I can be observed right now. Look towards Pluto or Sagitario, it is now causing meteoroid to hit Pluto and the outer planets including Jupiter as it makes its way closer. But you need a infrared lense to see it.

  • I do not have an infrared lens attachment right now. But do you have any co-ordinates? Even an indicative one will do. Maybe people who have quick access to the right equipment can pin point the approaching star system

  • There was an austrailian news paper that printed the cordinates along with all other relavent data including tradjectories of meteoroids, which was then forwarded to NASA...mind you they found this in July and have not recieved an answer from NASA. Do a seach and you should find the news paper... I cant recall the name of it right now. There is another version of the transcript but unless you read Spainish I suggest finding the translated austrailian version of the transcript.

  • @carusggg you wanna see Nibiru?? I have a vid of it

  • @carusggg it's just behind the moon... in a nearly impossible orbit... waiting for all the believers to stop believing... and then it will go around the moon and strike the person who came up with that bullshit idea.

  • pluto doesnt rotate like that.

  • Actually, it probably is Nibiru (the Vatican globe is designed in its image). Tough shit, guys. There's too much crazy shit in this world to rationalize. Although I can understand why people try to, it makes them insecure. Take a quick look into the Dogon tribe, as well. You'll shit brix.

  • It's probably my letter I wrote to New Scientist in 1988, re ball lightning and super conductivity, which wasn't even acknowledged.

  • please explain

  • look up the anunnaki

  • Its spethul.

  • This was fucking pointless.

  • Can a burrito orbit earth, land on my plate 3 years later and still have flavor?

  • @uoldphuk

    Yes it can!

  • @uoldphuk

    lol. good one

  • @uoldphuk No. The space-bugs will eat it.

  • @uoldphuk i personally believe, that, a burrito that orbits the earth for 3 years, would in fact still have flavor, because the people would personally believe that the burrito would be frozen and such as, retain flavor for the children

  • @uoldphuk

    Of course it would have flavor. Otherwise noone would be interested in eating them. Where do you think nebulae come from?

  • @uoldphuk and be microwaved!

  • @uoldphuk Yes you Brontosauruses dirty feet pads, now stop asking silly questions.

  • @uoldphuk yes.

  • @uoldphuk it would be crispy.

  • @uoldphuk depends on whether it was protected by a vehicle. Without some sort of burrito transport vehicle In the vacuum of space it would reach exceedingly hot temperatures frying it to a crisp.. then possibly exceedingly cold temperatures making it a frost bitten sack of crusty lard and pintos. Assuming it survived all of that without a vehicle.. it would have to make it back through the atmosphere leaving it more than likely a small black cloud of ash once it finally reaches your plate again.

  • Comment removed

  • Its the 10th.. or 9th.. planet.. since pluto was down graded.. Its on an approximate 3600 year orbit around our sun and another star some light years away.. its what the sumerians called nibiru and what our government is calling Planet X.. I take everything with a grain of Salt... but they say thats what 2012 is all about.. this planet coming back round causing Pole Shifts.. and all kinda end of Civilization.. but do some research.. ask some questions.. find some answers..

  • grid matrix12345687654321234

  • well SERIOUSLY WHAT THE FUCK AM I LOOKING AT????

  • lol

  • @dodow1234 You're looking at objects orientated to our star in the form of "orbits". LOL I believe that the largest, almost perpindicular orbit, is the object they're referring to. I could be wrong, because, like you, I have very little understanding of this "presentation".

  • Sorry about this. I think this must be where I parked. I couldn't see any space ports to park in.

    Can anyone tell me where your ports are. The maps didn't upload for this system for some reason. I can move it if its in the way? Let me know. Again sorry. I thought it would be all right there.

  • lol

  • What Is That Graph For?This is a Stupid Question But if There is a Mother Ship Could it Be Possible There Is A Father Child Or Baby Ship?

  • Don't forget grandma and the awkward uncle!

  • Dude, seriously, what the hell is the purpose of this video?

  • nibiru

  • I belive that is Sadam Hussem waiting for hes revange....lol burning hes ass in the solar hell...lool

  • kv42 doesnt appear to come any closer to the inner solar system than plulo.. I cant see how this could be planet x, nemisis or whatever... intersting but harmless to us I would say.

  • Planet X?

    o.O

  • the object probably originated from outside our solar system and was caught by the gravitational pull of the sun. by coincidence, it traveled with a speed equal to the escape velocity, so it remained in orbit around our sun.

  • the speed to remain in solar orbit must be less than the escape velocity...

  • no, an object traveling slower than the escape velocity would be caught in the sun's gravitational field, and the object's orbit would gradually decay to the point where it would collide with the sun.

    On the same basis, an object travelling with a speed greater than the escape velocitty would eventually leave the solar system. Therefore my statement.

  • well, I think we both are wrong. We're talking about escape velocity, and that should be only applied if the object leaves from the planet/star we're talking about... if that object didn't leave from the sun, we couldn't talk about escape velocity... could we?

  • We are already *in* the sun's gravitational field, and we are, in fact, falling into the sun, as a consequence of general relativity. It's just that the rate we're falling at is extremely slow.

  • no, no, it's Clarence. He got his wings! Attaboy!

  • its a comet...

  • It's a ufo mothership !

  • ok stupid question and ill probably get hated for this but if there is a mothership is there such thing as a fathership?

  • @asdlfjkas

    <3

  • @asdlfjkas lol sadly thats not stupid

  • @asdlfjkas Your right I hate you

  • @asdlfjkas Yea but you gotta watch out for them babyships..! thoses are the one that will get ya.

  • @asdlfjkas Yes, the one on top or behind the mothership...

  • @asdlfjkas There is. It's called a "fuel tanker"

  • no.... IT'S A FATHERSHIP!

  • uuhhh why cant i see this video. THE U TUBE IS HINDERING MY ABILITY TO HAVE A MIND OF MY OWN!

  • thats pretty sweet.

  • U never know whats out there. There could be a other planet or even a second star in our system.

  • oh yeah stars are really easy to hide

  • planet X is coming

  • say what?

  • damn was going to say the same thing, plus a LOL

  • Nibiru lmao...gosh conspiracies

  • OMG!!! NUKE IT!!!

  • nibiru lmao.... gosh conspiracies

  • nibiru for defos

  • omg its ma dad

  • Leave Jimmy Hoffa alone!

  • It is different because its big enough to have its own gravatationa pull even bigger than the sun and mabie the sun is getting its rotation from that object

  • What does this prove its just a map of some object going through our solar system. Where did that diagram come from and what is the object could just be a new asteroid,comet, or Nibiru (Not likely)?

  • Nibiru...

    That would be a site.

  • even in space u'll find religious conservatives

  • are u prepared for nibiru and the fakest alien invasion?

  • I guess scientist now classify "Nibiru" aka "Planet X" as KV42. Keep a mental note of it.

  • nibiru

  • Its God's Holy Spacefaring Cadillac!

  • This is obviously a teenage object looking for attention. Just ignore it.

  • a1jetasause xDDD lol that made me laugh

  • isnt that nibiru?

  • Why is it considered backwards and not us?

  • its a UFO!!!