Added: 2 years ago
From: CentricTV
Views: 139,807
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (151)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • you are just wonderful

  • nobody can top her.

  • this does NOT sound like whitney.. -_-

  • wtf this one's awful

  • Its all good until 1:30... she is much better off without that techno shit... or whatever it is.. 

  • @intro,I thot she had ths but you CANT disco Donny Hathaway,man.bad move WH!

  • She should NOT have made it a dance song-NO NO

  • omfg what happened to her voice!!! wtf

  • and now amy singing a song for you.. so beautiful...

  • A disco A Song For You? (._. )

  • Comment removed

  • She is the best,Ever..this remake song is awsome. Here her voice is still beautiful & powerful

  • DOOOOOOOOOOW WHAT THE HELL WITH THE SYNTH LINE??? WHY? WHY? Can't understand how they ruined the very spirit of the song and its lyrics, and at the same time the credibility of her (amazingly awesome) voice over the "melody".

  • everybody is being ridiculous, beside her challenges she has aged so has her voice, so stop saying she can't sing, she doesn't sound like her old self and jus shut up and appreciate her for who she is.

  • The magic's still there.

  • She's still the most have beautiful voice for me!!!

  • Weak! I like her old stuff best

  • @hypno63

    hmmm....probably till the new ones grow on you

  • Sounding more like her aunt than the old Whitney,but she is a professional and can pull off the song. 

  • is it speeded up :S

  • I have loved this song for years but , I don't like this techno version. Whitney does not need all of the extras she is extraordinary on her own.

  • Normally I love everything whitney does, but this is just not good, some songs should be left alone and this is one of them, this song is ment to be a slower song. The one by Donny Hathaway is so beautiful and haunting, not to mention his piano playing makes it that much more beautiful. You could feel his passion, his love and his pain, you could tell he put everything into this song. Just my opinion though.

  • AMAZING .........LOVE YA

  • AMAZING

  • whitney is a divaaaaaaa

  • I love this song! One of my favorites from the album.

  • Christina aguilera version is very very very very better!!!

  • @tarmoul1 opinions are like assholes......everybody's got one

  • @tarmoul1 Negative hahaha

  • no singer can point at her vocally

  • Nothing beats her 1991 version -- A Song For Ypu live WHH -- we love you Whitney

  • no singer has the abilty of the queen whitneyyy!!!!!!!!!! <3 x

  • This is awful, listen to this version, she gives it heart and reflects the original Donny classic, beautiful voice before she lost her way...youtube.com/watch?v=t_Un­Gxm3OPs&feature=related

  • Comment removed

  • What a discrace to the feel of the original song by Donny Hathaway. I'm dissapointed...

  • @Scray1 More like, what a discrace to the feel of Whitney's original take live at the Welcome Home Heroes concert. THAT makes me dissapointed given it is from the same voice.

  • Just one word...QUEEN

  • am huge fan of christina aguilera's voice but i gotta say that whitney huton is the queeen and aguilera is the princess

  • @poperline and while Mj is the king :D Xtina princess, whitney QUeen/empress,goddess and mariah is the kettle in the royal kitchen boiling up whistle notes, and madonna is just a plastic puppet for the royal children ahhaha.

    all this voice vice

  • i like the way she sounds now

  • Such a beautiful song sung by a beautiful woman.*****

  • Karen Carpenter ain't got JACK on Whitney Houston!! Under the word range in the vocal dictionary is Whitney's name!

  • @sourgrapism are u crazy Karen Carpenters version is like 100x better.also at the juliard school of music when the panel there was ask who they reconized as the best singer of all time Karen Carpenter was who they said. whitney didnt even make the list.Sarah Brightman was #2

  • @valkour22 You need to hear the original by Donny Hathaway. He puts all of them to shame.

  • @Scray1 the original was by leon russell in 1970 donny did a cover song in 1971

  • @sourgrapism Oh and by the way Karen Carpenter never had a voice lesson! When her parenets sent her teacher Frank Pooler said Her voice should not be trained that it was a direct gift of God

  • best vocalist

  • I love her latest album. Her voice has changed, but it sounds more mature and better. Welcome back, Whitney.

  • all whitneys haters must die soon amen

  • @mikki78654 lol you said it

  • Watch her 1991 version and you'll see how different her voice is now...makes me sad.

  • @niawest Most Whitney fans love her now sound. If you only like the old whitney, just stick to her past work! :) And besides, in concert she sounds better than her album (unless she is hoarse which was a problem of the tour sometimes due to bad scheduling) :)

  • @niawest THAT WAS 19 YEARS AGO. OF COURSE SHE SOUNDS DIFFERENT. SHE IS STILL BETTER THAN 95% OF TODAYS POPULAR ARTISTS.

  • I saw her on tour this year and she said that she was recording this song when MJj died! :/ She sang it for him and it was BEAUTIFUL! :) Love her voice these days! :) Desperate for her to return to Glasgow to perform! haha

  • Comment removed

  • i used to think whitney was quite possibly the best female singer there was but listening to karen carpeneters version of this song shows that the best of today are still light yrs away from kc

  • nowhere close to Karen Carpenters version in 72!!!

  • This is just wrong! Why did she feel the need to add a horrible beat to an already timeless song. :( The version she did in 1991 is untouchable

  • Beautiful.

  • Ms. Houston sang this song nearly 20 years ago at the Welcome Home Heros concert. I felt that performance had a lot more emotion and yes, soul than this artificially manufactured version.

  • LOVE  WHITNEY, 5******

  • sorry i like andy williams's one better

  • Actually this song was writen and sung by Leon Russel in 1970 and was done is a rock tempo. Donny Hathaway picked it up and did a very soul full cover of this but it was writen as a split between the two.

  • the beat ruins it, and shes singing wayyyyyy to fast.... calm down its supposed to be a ballad.

  • WHITNEY IS A TIME OF TESTAMENT THATGOD NEVER FAILS US. HE WILL DELIVER IF ONLY WE ASK & SOMETIMES WE DON'T HAVE TO ASK. JUST BELEIVE. SOMETIMES WHEN IT RAINS, IT POURS BUT, IT EVENTUALLY STOPS RAINING & THE SUN COMES OUT. GOD IS ABLE. LOOK AROUND YOURSELD & YOU'LL SEE. BLESSINGS!!!

  • Whitney aught to sing various rock genres that express her new tone; singing about innocent, fun love won't cut it for her anymore. She'd actually be a great singer within a rock band even.

  • I had know idea that Whitney sang this song years earlier live, it was great and although she is in her fortys it still sounds good.

  • My friend sang this in x factor but she didnt get though cos simon didnt know the song! how stupid hes he!

  • This sounds like she's rushing it way too much, I like the live version from 91, but this "Dance mix" really is a travesty....

  • nice remix! fresh!

  • i was really impressed with the version until the beat came. she should've just did it without the unnecessary beat. i'm quite disappointed.

  • look to all you out there hating on Whitney, she is back and in my opinion she is as good as ever, she made her mistake like any of us haven't made ANY, so get off her and listen to the music and the words

  • This song was messed up, should have stayed a ballot.

  • I'm glad she's back!

  • WHY HAS THIS NOT BEEN MADE INTO A SINGLE???????????????? IT SHOULD HAVE CAME OUT AFTER MILLION DOLLAR BILL. WOULD HAVE BEEN A NO.1 IN THE DANCE CHARTS, IMAGINE THE REMIXES..... WHY ISNT ARISTA DOIN THEY LOYALTY TO A WOMAN WHO BROUGHT THEM MILLIONS.... K SHE HAS NOT BEEN THE BEST, BUT SHE GETTIN BETTER, AND I THINK THIS SONG WOULD HAVE MADE HER ALBUM 1 OF THE YEARS GREATES

  • Christina did it better with Herbie Hancock

  • Great song ! Love Whitney !

  • I love this song and I love Whitney Houston but the techno-beat combined to this classic....It turned me totally off. Like Simon says, "not to be rude..." LOL Sorry, Whitney!

  • I like the elliot yamin version better . other's are saying it's not one of her best albums maybe there right i've heard it from my aunt as well as other family memeber's who use too listen to her . she isn't taking her time like she use too. she just writting now to make a quick buck just like most artist do now a day's like mariah carey as well write a ruthless remark and i'll spam u or delete you .

  • @blockfan2010 I respect your opinion, but I have to disagree. Whitney's voice has declined from nodule surgery in 2007 and drug use. I think people are disappointed in her vocals because they expected her to come back singing like she did in her 20's and 30's. Whitney has been through so much, I'm frankly suprised she still has a voice at all. However, there's a depth, a pain, emotion, and grit to her voice that never existed before. She sings with a bite in her voice.

  • @ThePharaoho Preach it brotha or sista - whoever you are. Boy did you hit the nail on the head a couple of times! That you say "she sings with a bite in her voice" is frickin' brilliant.

  • THE VOICE should have been part of the UNESCO World Heritage and a law should have been passed preventing her from smoking or doing crack

  • Ray Charles is much much better then her!!!

    It's just the truth!

    This songs is a feelings...and in her performance i couldent feel that

  • NOT A FAN OF THIS VERSION

  • I prefer the version she performed in 1991 to welcome back the troops from desert storm. Im not a dance/techno fan. I love soul.

  • @razcazh.. I completely agree with you. She ripped when she sung it then.

  • @razcazh Heard that one here on YT, still not impressed.

  • not liking it at all she start off nice but the upbeat thing she did mangles it.

  • i loved it then loving it better now!

  • 3:50 AND ON who sings like this?

  • Beautiful and at the same time so heartbreaking..This song has so much meaning to it...She's had such a hard life and made some bad choices...I just love that shes back and i find her so inspiring..She went through hell and shes still here. BACK fighting as good as ever..She should be so proud of whats shes accomplished

  • @2010benwooh you know she didnt write this song right?

  • @mileyandmari yeh im not stupid. did i say she wrote it? NO so stop trynna be smart when its clear you're not

  • Da onli reason pple can hear a change in her voice is cz dey lookin for it. Cz if you jus open mindedly listen 2 her new album, her voice sounds so similar to 'Your love is my love' n dat single was out in '98. She still has the voice of an angel and she continues to make music dat can touch pples souls and dats wat it about. Plus, shes not 23/24 nemore, she is 45, her voice will obviously be more mature.

  • At her 46 years old, this

    WOMAN IS UNDEFEATABLE

  • @Undefeated92 Oh my god, is she 46? :O Wow, she's looking really good for her age!

  • @Undefeated92 But Gladys at 66 is better than Whitney at 46. At least this music is better than that Jusin Beiber/Glee/Ke$ha crap.

  • i love donny hathaways version the best.

  • OF COURSE

  • LOVE ITTTTTTTTT!!!!!

  • PEOPLE!!!!

    Its a great song why dont people enjoy it...Thos who have negative things to say about Whitney's voice fine say what you will but someone in the industry thinks she can still blow and they are paying her tons of money to tour and promote that CD, yes her voice has changed for whatever reasons it may be FINE, but that fact that she hasnt given up,she is doing what she loves. Her voice has gotten better since she resurfaced. so be negative cause she singing all the way to the bank.

  • Ditto! We all F*&# up... she's getting her life back together. Don't throw stones.

  • I LOVE this song. one of the best on the album.

  • Comment removed

  • Great!

  • Whitney Houston is the best singer on the world i love you Whitney !!!!!!

  • To be honest I don't like so much this song. Of course in 1991 whe she sang it live her vocals were better because she was younger, but I prefer more this version (fast). Whitney is so good that she gave us two versions of this song and if you don't like one you can listen another one. THIS IS WHITNEY

  • whitney houston is back finnally :)!!

  • FORGET all the NEGATIVEstuff people have to say bout her so doin her thing ,nobody's perfect she bounced back so give tha lady her propz ...i love all her new song n so wat if she sound diffrent im a singer n my voice change ...but so let her do her thing ppl never happy she do drugz yall talk she bounce bck yall talk ..wat yall doin ...nothing sittin there judgein

  • AWESOME

  • I love this version. Its so different than others. So powerful and soulful. You know it's coming from a special place.

  • I agree ThePharaoho!!!!!!!!

  • bottom line is, if you don't like the way she sounds know, then don't listen to her songs, because what you hear in this song and what your gonna hear in all her new songs to come, so you either deal wiht it ! or keep it moving :)

  • What is it with people hating all the time? Give her a break. She's doing her best. Yeah she doesn't sound like she did but she's better than all you lot.

  • if you wanna hear whitney sing this song good look up whitney houston song for you live and yall are gonna be like wtf happened to her voice. she sound crazy in this im sorry

  • Carpenters' version is sooooooo much better

  • i have to disagree with people hatin on whitneys voice, why? people say its not as good as years ago, of course not! she was in her 20/30s then, she 47 now, her voice is matured now and after all the years of abuse i think she is back on her game..love whitney!!!

  • That's BS about her age. She's ONLY 47. That's no excuse. Stevie Wonder sounds nearly exactly the same as he did back in the 70's. Diana Ross started having issues with her voice 3 years ago and she's now 65. She's performed many years before Whitney was even though of. Just get real everybody, the drugs messed her up. If she can admit she took drugs, her fans can admit she doesn't sound as good anymore due to the drugs. She messed up her gift.

  • @macuser5555 okay, but stevie wonder didnt do drugs ! i admit she does sound different but everyone knows why, and if you wanna hold that against her, fine. but thats no reason to hate on her !

  • OMG, I am not at all hating on Whitney. I listened to her ever since she first came out. She's not much different then other stars in terms of making mistakes, everyone does. But I'm not going to pretend that she still sounds amazing like she used to nor am I going to say that she sounds different because of her age, that's just being blind.

  • This version isn't very good. Her voice just isn't good anymore.

  • @macuser5555 This version's great!

  • Whitney fans turn a blind eye. They won't stand for any criticism. Okay, if she was a new singer and was just introduced, then yes this version sounds decent. But this is Whitney. I'm not hating on her but her version at the Welcome Home Heroes concert in unachievable for her now.

  • @macuser5555 I never said she was perfect now, I just said I like this version.

  • Whitney does a great job but if you wanna get goosebumps listen to the Donny Hathaway version! It will literally make u feel the emotion.

  • OMG RITE?!?!?

  • stfu jonathan she this is a great rendition. If you wanna hear this song in its original arrangement check out her 1991 WHH performance of this song

  • I love this song. Go, Whitney.

  • OH welcome back miss whitney!!

    the diva

    is back!!!

    this would be great in a club!! roll on next weekend and whitney on x factor!!

  • I've heard it in the club and the dance floor was packedddddddddddddd!

  • This is a beautiful cover, love it

  • Less than a 100 views a day. This is PATHETIC! :(

  • there is no auto-tune used in this song. Trust me, im a professional.. enough said. The only auto tune in this album is with akon...

  • very true

  • I love you Whitney Houston

  • ilike Donny hathaways OriginAL version bettr////but i love this one 2

  • everything i autotuned nowadays, it makes voices sound spectacularly clear

  • its called a vibrato people.

  • shes awesome

  • Why does her voice sound so electronic?

  • autotune

  • no its not

  • Thanks...is it used for enhancement when an artist can no longer put out?

  • No...it was used ANYWHERE in her voice on this song!!! Know that...don't forget b/c that's just pure asininity!!!

  • Bahhaah Who told you that??!!?? It is NOT!!!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more