At the point when Steve Hackett flips his selector switch to the treble position & the keyboards kick-in, along with both drummers really turning it on... hearing it in any way other than live simply doesn't do it justice
One can discern this from the video but we can only watch & imagine that euphoric feeling from the full power of the music at that point
i just love Steve Hackett's guitar!...mind you they're all "nae bad" (as they say in the north-east of Scotland!) :-) I saw them on this tour at the Caird Hall in Dundee at the start of 1977.....superb!
Chester Thompson and Bill Bruford never played on the same tour with Genesis. Bill Bruford only played on "a trick of the tail tour", then they used Chester as a permanent part time member after that.
As a kid I used to sneak into my older brothers room, when he was out, and listen to his 'Seconds Out' album, Loved it as a kid, still do, and I reckon it's a very under rated album and performance, some wonderful music, great musicians, and Phil Collins was at his best.
Well i used to have the seconds out album back in the days... and you could see in that album, the three drum setups...Bruford wearing the boston bruins jersey, chester, with his double set of pearls, and collins was on a black gretsch, and premiere kit.. So i do think that they all played on the seconds out live album.
@MrYamahaMC Correct6. Collins Bruford & Thompson all played on Seconds Out. The main work being done by Collins & Thompson. Bruford I believe only crops up on the track Cinema Show
@m3zane Good grief, this is the 2nd time I have come across you ever commenting with any sense, shame you don't do it when you troll the UNmanned plane videos...
@PhantomDog666 you are the troll continually posting false information about the a 320 crash & deliberately harasssing other users on youtube as shown by your continued replies to any comment I make on any video. carry on like this and you might find you are in contravention of the protection from harassment act 1997 chapter 40
Firstly, you will find this is a public site open to viewing & commenting from users all over the world.
Secondly, I also share an interest in music,as well as aircraft.
Thirdly, my musical taste includes iron maiden,def leppard,genesis,rainbow,greenday,pulp,oasis,toyah, pink floyd,duran duran,spandau ballet,human league & anything good from the 1960s to modern day excluding rap & hip-hop/dance/rave.
This is why I watch these videos,not to look for you,stop being a prat & sort yourself out.
@m3zane yes - because the album was recorded over 2 tours - Bruford played on the Trick of the Tail tour - so Cinema Show was recorded in UK (Glasgow i think), while Thompson played on the majority of the album recorded in Paris. The album cover will have this on it.
Hi guys im looking for the live version of the cinema show from the seconds out tour, with bill bruford, chester and phil... Does anyone know where i can find that version ? Thanks .
@MrYamahaMC Bill Bruford & Chester I don't think ever played w/Genesis at the same time. With Bill Buford it would be the 1976 Trick Of The Tail tour, with Chester it's the 1977 Wind & Wuthering tour (or if you prefer Seconds Out)
@ClassicRockDVD Except that I saw the Trick Of The Tail Tour and Chester was on drums; at least for the concert I saw which was at the Music Hall (now The Wang Center) in Boston. Wind and Wuthering hadn't come out yet so I'm sure it was the Trick Of The Tail Tour which had just come out a few months earlier.
Ce sont les meilleurs et ce titre le plus fantastique...la quintessence de leur art...j'ai eu la chance de les voir plusieurs fois sur scène (notamment pour "seconds out" j'y étais...et pour un concert à Milton Keynes en 1988 avec Peter Gabriel et Steve Hackett tous réunis...de la magie grave sur scene !!.....et là sur ce morceau Steve assure ...c'est grand .....
I used to live for Genesis back in the day,one of my all time Favorite bands,live and on Record.were talking Seconds out and back,none of the later stuff!
I´ve seen genesis performing live in 1977 with 17 y.o. and it was one of most espetacular experiences in my live, unforgetable. I was totaly envolved with the magic, by the end of the show, with the final part of Musical Box, tears began to roll out, I felt levitating. Too sad they are not doing magic anymore...
I´ve seen genesis performing live in 1977 with 17 y.o. and it was one of most espetacular experiences in my live, unforgetable. I was totaly envolved with the magic, by the end of the show, with the final part of Musical Box, tears began to roll out, I felt levitating. Too sad they are not doing magic anymore...
I saw this tour at the Paramount Theatre in Seattle, April, 1977 - and although I never saw Genesis with Peter Gabriel, this line up did put on an awsome show and certainly one of the best concerts that I was ever in the audience of. What a privilage to have been there -what a great memory to still be with me!
watching so many genesis performances with gabriel and collins i can say these 2 gys were good comedians on stage with great voices but in 2 different styles. collins brought genesis to his style. with more media and popularity
Excellent version...!!!!......this lineup sounded very tight,the best 4 my taste..even w/out Peter........Phil does a great job stepping up.....Genesis 4ever.!!!!!!!!!
Thanks. I love Genesis and if there is something 'out of place'... Thanks for posting, you're a true 'promoter' of progrock, my absolutely favourite music...
This is absolutely Dallas, The Moody Sports arena. Later on the the video he's wearing a Dallas Cowboys shirt while performing The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway.
You must be sure and check your facts before posting on the internet.
@Tommygun1028 I enjoy both. Love old Genesis tunes and I also love shredding bands like Megadeth and Pantera. It's hip hop and rap who are killing music nowadays.
@Tommygun1028 well said my man! If you really think about it, not many shredding songs endure...there are some, yes, but most great songs put musicianship behind composition....and some great songs find a way to use both to great success
and then genesis went on to release their epic 78' masterpiece ' and then tony banks smiled', come on genesis lovers, lets not get too serious, although i am ,too, guilty of analysing every genesis gem!!!
yea i agree but i think wind and wuthering is still an amazing album, at least genesis had some good albums before they got commercial in the 80's. Now bands just are commercial to begin with it seems
Genesis continued to be very creative and original after Hackett and Gabriel, just notin the same vain. Mama was certainly not commercial and Turn It On Again was in 13/8 time!!!
another view would be that though i really wish hackett didn't leave (i saw a concert in kansas city in '77 with pals, us all sharing in the experience - which was truly the most wonderful..) the sound from that time was in fact in important ways the sound and mood of the greatest genesis - but ! - such excelence is this music that mr. collins got to create songs that were not just number one's, but several in a row and for the longest time -
they lost their "englishness" when hackett left after wind and wuthering, which was a quintessential part of the band up until 76'. as dylan said u cant please all of the people all of the time and genesis did regress after that musically but only in the "prog rock" way, whereas they made a couple of fantastic albums, notably duke, after this and gained a whole new audience. only my humble opinion genesis/music lovers!
You hit upon an important point that a lot of people miss--their sound didn't really change when Gabriel left; it changed when Hackett left. Funny how the person that most probably considered the least "critical" to the band had such an impact by his departure.
@capsfans6366 i def agree, but... the 80s changed every band. Even if hackett stayed, their changed was inevitable. To be honest though, they reached such a beautiful peak between the lamb and a trick of the tail.
@capsfans6366 i am with that hackett did make a diffrent but it wasnt the main thing it was more of the impact on songs and onstage performance and present gabriel had and dont forget that all this stuff r from the old albums they kept playing it for few years after gabriel departure till they had there big success in Abacab album in 81.
@capsfans6366 not only a generic "sound" change. when peter left ... did you have listen The Lamia? do you think after there is another song wich value is at least 1/10 of her? :) i think not, from peter gabriel departure the genesis songs became ..cute, not more (ripples i.e. is annoying).
I think that genesis was perfect when five. with the contribute of all members. nobody excluded.
8th October 1977 - Steve Hackett leaves Genesis during the mixing of the 'Seconds Out' live album, while driving to the studio Phil reputedly saw him walking down the street and offered to give him a lift, which he declined, it's only when Phil reached the studio that Phil learned what had happened.
Where is the rest of this concert video? This was the best band on the planet at this era. I would love to see ...In that quiet earth... or supper's ready from this tour. The Landing lights and all. Well, thanks anyway.
You can't blame Collins, they had to sell records/Cd's and that's the way things were going into the 80's. Yet you his solo albums were a cut above most other music at the time, and so were Genesis's 80's LP's. Above all we love the great music they made in the 70's. Despite Gabriel leaving I think 'A Trick of the tail' was awesome. When first heard it thru a good Hifi it just BLEW ME AWAY! Everlasting Music..
It all went wrong when Hackett left. He was the prog rock influence. After that you can't tell what is Genesis and what is collins solo work. I still don't know what is what.
I think that is a fair point when you look at singles alone, but when you consider songs like Home By The Sea and Domino, you know you're listening to Genesis!
I don't think you can call it selling out - they were still making good music, just with a different sound. I happen to like that sound, but fair does if you don't. Level 42 were forced to do the same thing during the mid 80's - a jazz-funk band at heart, they were making pop-based music to survive.
The album "Invisible Touch" was a total sell out. Domino was great, but on an otherwise awful pop album. Not sure about this "survive" idea. Genesis were never a huge band in the Gabriel days, but the fans they had were completely loyal as the band was incredible. They would have survived as a smaller band, they just wouldn't have been on TV commercials for Virgin Air.
It wasn't to "survive". It was a sell-out to get rich, that is what selling out means, giving up what you believe in order to make money. That is why the 80s sucked so bad. Almost everybody sold out.
E' difficile dirlo con certezza, tanta è la quantità di capolavori che hanno composto i Genesis, ma forse questo è il più bel brano singolo della musica contemporanea!
No, non dici una fesseria, purchè tu escluda "Trick of the Tail" e "Wind and Wuthering" dall'era Hackett, perchè c'era ancora, ma soprattuto perchè sono due album strpitosamente belli, sicuramente più di "Trespass", non inferiori, a mio avviso, a "Nursery Crime" e "Foxtrot" e di poco inferiori a "Selling England" e "The Lamb", quest'ultime pietre miliari della GRANDE MUSICA!
Eh beh! Can you tell where my country lies! Fantastico...non erano mica canzoni! Erano favole...poi the musical box è un sogno onirico...però ragazzi Gabriel è stato il 50 percento della band....almeno nel trittico che tu hai citato...Supper's Ready è apocalittica...
Depuis septembre 1972, où j'ai eu la chance de les voir, ET DE LES ENTENDRE, au Marquee Club à Londres, ils restent (à jamais) en vibrante émotion en moi.
Merci Messieurs de GENESIS !!!!!
Reverra-t-on le premier groupe de la génèse, un jour?
is it just me but, after i started listening to the old Genesis , i wouldn't listen to anything else. literally .... had the Second Sides tape in my truck for a solid year , never turned off , friends wouldn't come around ... lol let a lot of good music go by
I like the mellotron (this version) better than the guitar (studio version) at 2:25. It has a nice eerie sound. Phil tears it up on the drums at 3:30. Great live performance.
Actually at the beginning there Hackett is playing a volume-pedal guitar and doubling Banks on that melody (until it gets faster). Yeah, great live performance!
Yeah - and that combined with the 80'ies greed and coldness propelled him into a superstar era where he could walk on water. No wonder Bateman was so fond of him! ;-)
Simply awesome song. I always preferred Peter's voice, and the sound of the band in his time, but there's plenty to love about Collins and the Genesis of the '80's. Hackett's solo is even better live than on the studio version.
He's not got a bird that's why he doesn't like hand gestures the tit
MarcW2209 1 month ago
Who is the idiot that complaint about the hands gesture.....is that all you could find ?
TheDguimond1 3 months ago
Phil kicks ass on the drums!
herbieshirby 4 months ago
I like how Phil sang this, just as good at peter
highgroundstrike 5 months ago
Desde PERÚ, esto es una joya, quiero el DVD Pleaseeeee !!!!!!!!!!!
EliasCoz1 5 months ago
they dont make em like this no more fucking classic
altoidsmit 5 months ago
ClassicRockDVD..where can i buy this DVD?
SDsailor7 5 months ago
At the point when Steve Hackett flips his selector switch to the treble position & the keyboards kick-in, along with both drummers really turning it on... hearing it in any way other than live simply doesn't do it justice
One can discern this from the video but we can only watch & imagine that euphoric feeling from the full power of the music at that point
Chuichupachichi 5 months ago
i just love Steve Hackett's guitar!...mind you they're all "nae bad" (as they say in the north-east of Scotland!) :-) I saw them on this tour at the Caird Hall in Dundee at the start of 1977.....superb!
thelonegroover 6 months ago
Comment removed
thelonegroover 6 months ago
Really nicely sung, but not too sure about the hand gestures. No surprise he gave them up.
TheExcelsior1 6 months ago
steve hackett's solo is amazing like always after all these years still has an amazing sound
pej789 7 months ago
DUKE'S TRAVELS COVER BY PINO LETTIERI wow wow wow Watch and enjoy
tributando 7 months ago
Chester Thompson and Bill Bruford never played on the same tour with Genesis. Bill Bruford only played on "a trick of the tail tour", then they used Chester as a permanent part time member after that.
MarcW2209 7 months ago
Where the hell did they come up with this masterpiece?
SiriusShaun 7 months ago
2:25 Prodigy "Genesis" Sample :)
BanjoXI 7 months ago
Absolut professionell gespielt.
MrBeob8er 10 months ago
Yeah you can recogonize chesters sound... i believe he had to much tone on his sound..
MrYamahaMC 11 months ago
Who's playing drums while Phil is singing?
MegaSeth01 11 months ago
@MegaSeth01 chester thompson
m3zane 11 months ago
@m3zane hey fuckwit, when are you going to start oneying your master and finally shut up?
YTSMalumni2010 10 months ago
As a kid I used to sneak into my older brothers room, when he was out, and listen to his 'Seconds Out' album, Loved it as a kid, still do, and I reckon it's a very under rated album and performance, some wonderful music, great musicians, and Phil Collins was at his best.
Hania454 11 months ago
Well i used to have the seconds out album back in the days... and you could see in that album, the three drum setups...Bruford wearing the boston bruins jersey, chester, with his double set of pearls, and collins was on a black gretsch, and premiere kit.. So i do think that they all played on the seconds out live album.
MrYamahaMC 11 months ago
@MrYamahaMC Correct6. Collins Bruford & Thompson all played on Seconds Out. The main work being done by Collins & Thompson. Bruford I believe only crops up on the track Cinema Show
m3zane 11 months ago
@m3zane Good grief, this is the 2nd time I have come across you ever commenting with any sense, shame you don't do it when you troll the UNmanned plane videos...
PhantomDog666 11 months ago
@PhantomDog666 you are the troll continually posting false information about the a 320 crash & deliberately harasssing other users on youtube as shown by your continued replies to any comment I make on any video. carry on like this and you might find you are in contravention of the protection from harassment act 1997 chapter 40
m3zane 11 months ago
Firstly, you will find this is a public site open to viewing & commenting from users all over the world.
Secondly, I also share an interest in music,as well as aircraft.
Thirdly, my musical taste includes iron maiden,def leppard,genesis,rainbow,greenday,pulp,oasis,toyah, pink floyd,duran duran,spandau ballet,human league & anything good from the 1960s to modern day excluding rap & hip-hop/dance/rave.
This is why I watch these videos,not to look for you,stop being a prat & sort yourself out.
PhantomDog666 11 months ago
@PhantomDog666 well spotted. UNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN
YTSMalumni2010 10 months ago
@m3zane Good grief fancy finding you here
bmwnasher 10 months ago
@m3zane yes - because the album was recorded over 2 tours - Bruford played on the Trick of the Tail tour - so Cinema Show was recorded in UK (Glasgow i think), while Thompson played on the majority of the album recorded in Paris. The album cover will have this on it.
mike516ish 7 months ago
Phil...best drummer ever.
proisle 11 months ago
Hi guys im looking for the live version of the cinema show from the seconds out tour, with bill bruford, chester and phil... Does anyone know where i can find that version ? Thanks .
MrYamahaMC 11 months ago
@MrYamahaMC Bill Bruford & Chester I don't think ever played w/Genesis at the same time. With Bill Buford it would be the 1976 Trick Of The Tail tour, with Chester it's the 1977 Wind & Wuthering tour (or if you prefer Seconds Out)
ClassicRockDVD 11 months ago
@ClassicRockDVD thats right kid fleuve st laurent
jocolope 8 months ago
@ClassicRockDVD Except that I saw the Trick Of The Tail Tour and Chester was on drums; at least for the concert I saw which was at the Music Hall (now The Wang Center) in Boston. Wind and Wuthering hadn't come out yet so I'm sure it was the Trick Of The Tail Tour which had just come out a few months earlier.
spercoco 4 months ago
@MrYam i think my uncle has it
lucasola96 4 months ago
Here Here. Hackett was the single driving force to Genesis' great musical pieces
phkates 11 months ago
Steve Hackett was amazing the best one of them all in this performance
MrJesseG123 1 year ago
opera
supermoschino 1 year ago
Cracking stuff. The only thing that bothers me is at 3.26 where Mike looks exactly like Saruman the White!
snijderjh 1 year ago
WARNING: Don't listen while baked. It may cause sudden leaps to other dimensions.
crackzzz123 1 year ago 6
Ce sont les meilleurs et ce titre le plus fantastique...la quintessence de leur art...j'ai eu la chance de les voir plusieurs fois sur scène (notamment pour "seconds out" j'y étais...et pour un concert à Milton Keynes en 1988 avec Peter Gabriel et Steve Hackett tous réunis...de la magie grave sur scene !!.....et là sur ce morceau Steve assure ...c'est grand .....
hembeset1 1 year ago 3
I've experienced great art and I've experienced great music. This absolutely the most moving experience i have ever had with art and talent. WOW!!!
roach905 1 year ago
frickin brilliant is all I can say Steve Hackettt crankin...love that guy, what happened to him
squonkdh 1 year ago
frickin brilliant is all I can say
squonkdh 1 year ago
Best back up band Hackett will ever get i guess , haha!
klnine 1 year ago
I saw Steve Hackett & Electric Band last weekend in Lisbon. Absolutely fantastic.
alextheprincess 1 year ago
super genial
gabork1965 1 year ago
I used to live for Genesis back in the day,one of my all time Favorite bands,live and on Record.were talking Seconds out and back,none of the later stuff!
Dillboy 1 year ago
Looks like live in Toronto,Canada?
repelghosts 1 year ago
@repelghosts this is live in Dallas Texas 1977 at the Moody Coliseum
Tommygun1028 1 year ago
hackett is one of the best to ever do it
thegarmentroom 1 year ago
alongside YES, these are the greatest band of all time
nintendo64isking 1 year ago
tony banks ftw
vittinlokaun 1 year ago
I never knew Chester did that bit with the tambourine starting at 2:25.
19nywf39 1 year ago
just cannot get ny better
tulipwinesoup 1 year ago
i want Peters flute!! :-( 2:26
melantoriano 1 year ago
Goosebumps...
netmazter 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I´ve seen genesis performing live in 1977 with 17 y.o. and it was one of most espetacular experiences in my live, unforgetable. I was totaly envolved with the magic, by the end of the show, with the final part of Musical Box, tears began to roll out, I felt levitating. Too sad they are not doing magic anymore...
cmtemoacirsilva 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I´ve seen genesis performing live in 1977 with 17 y.o. and it was one of most espetacular experiences in my live, unforgetable. I was totaly envolved with the magic, by the end of the show, with the final part of Musical Box, tears began to roll out, I felt levitating. Too sad they are not doing magic anymore...
cmtemoacirsilva 1 year ago
best genesis-song ever...
badgeraldo 1 year ago
Descomunal...!!!
maurolopespadilha 1 year ago
Deus do Ceu,que é isto,minha gente???Uma das mais lindas melodias em qualquer estilo musical..É de arrepiar.Parabens Genesis
maurolopespadilha 1 year ago
I saw this tour at the Paramount Theatre in Seattle, April, 1977 - and although I never saw Genesis with Peter Gabriel, this line up did put on an awsome show and certainly one of the best concerts that I was ever in the audience of. What a privilage to have been there -what a great memory to still be with me!
HHSEAWAUSA 1 year ago
@HHSEAWAUSA lucky!!!
argoo3 1 year ago
watching so many genesis performances with gabriel and collins i can say these 2 gys were good comedians on stage with great voices but in 2 different styles. collins brought genesis to his style. with more media and popularity
kumatosky 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey, check out Moonlit Knight Genesis Tribute out here on youtube, and if your in the North West of england, come an check us out. Cheers ;-)
SHAKEDOWN72 1 year ago
Best ever
mfbown 1 year ago
My very first concert. Genesis in Munich, 1977. I will never forget it.
jzzct 1 year ago
Excellent version...!!!!......this lineup sounded very tight,the best 4 my taste..even w/out Peter........Phil does a great job stepping up.....Genesis 4ever.!!!!!!!!!
tony40pe 1 year ago 2
i think genesis start sounding better without gabriel
kumatosky 1 year ago
@kumatosky THIS SONG WAS MADE WITH GABRIEL. FIRST 3 LP WERE THE BEST .
massimo900 1 year ago
@kumatosky on live it can be , but I like more the Peter Gabriel Studio Albums
julyvalls 1 year ago
Best song EVER!
sr14225 1 year ago 2
bueno es una buena cancion sobretod cuando le entran de lleno a la bateria o lo instrumental,es uno de mis grupos favoritos
sabueso1273 1 year ago
kunne ikke vært mere enig
balleclorin2 1 year ago
just amazing...would love to have seen this live
welshhibby 1 year ago
@welshhibby Saw it. Words cannot describe..... When I watch and listen to this, I almost have to turn it off. Almost....
recordhead59 1 year ago
@recordhead59 Not to mention we had no idea that Hackett was basically checked out of the band by this time.
recordhead59 1 year ago
they have seen the way he leads
tulipwinesoup 1 year ago
Uno dei momenti più sublimi del progressive e di tutta la musica planetaria !!!
kungfu57 2 years ago
Estava no show no Gigantinho, em Porto Alegre. Phill Collins cantou com a camisa do INTER!! que na época era o atual bicampeão Brasileiro!!
rogerjazzfan 2 years ago
@rogerjazzfan Cara... que inveja. Bem, eu tinha 4 anos à época. Mas vi o Phil Collins em 97, em Miami e Orlando. Faltou o Genesis...
EduLaborne 1 year ago
When I get to the next world,Genesis will be there waiting for me.
trelcious 2 years ago
the river in constant cgange...
genesisinsideme 2 years ago
Classic!!! Collins does a grand performance on vocals
thedaft92 2 years ago 9
Grande show no Maracazinho, vi com o Wagner esse grande show da cadeira de palco...sauda
PPMMRRPP 2 years ago
man oh man, this takes me back 30-some odd years..."Seconds Out"...one of the finest live albums ever...
urlord24 2 years ago 4
Yes, a suberb and totally underated album.
Hania454 2 years ago
I´ve seen they palying life in 1977 in Sao Paulo / Brasil, and they did the same. What a unforgetable show!!! Superb, brilliant!!!
cmtemoacirsilva 2 years ago 2
E eu os assisti 3 dias antes, no Gigantinho, em Porto Alegre. Tocaram "Firth of Fifth" de modo soberbo.
No dia seguinte, Mike saiu correndo do palco lá pela 4ª música, e o show foi abreviado.
GraachAhim 2 years ago
Where is the beginning? It's not the same without this amazing piano solo. (one of many they had in 'Gabriel times')
PrZemek44 2 years ago
Tony abandoned doing the piano intro sometime during the Selling England tour. I think it was early in the tour he stopped.
Tommygun1028 2 years ago
Thanks. I love Genesis and if there is something 'out of place'... Thanks for posting, you're a true 'promoter' of progrock, my absolutely favourite music...
PrZemek44 2 years ago
sorry ripples70...but it can't be in 1976 whit all the set up .....chester...sherglod bouble neck for MIKE...PHIL'S DRUM...SORRY RIPPLES.
SYLVAIN FROM MONTREAL
slypin03 2 years ago
I assure you that this DVD is a mixture together as a best of.car I also thank you both as well ..
70ripples 2 years ago
sorry, this is not the Dallas concert, but that of Paris in 1976 seconds out flags of paris
70ripples 2 years ago
This is absolutely Dallas, The Moody Sports arena. Later on the the video he's wearing a Dallas Cowboys shirt while performing The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway.
You must be sure and check your facts before posting on the internet.
Tommygun1028 2 years ago
I guess this is the most sophisticated guitar solo in Rock-music! Shredders listen to this and maybe you learn to make some music.
gillan5 2 years ago 2
shredding is not music, it's competition. This solo by Steve Hackett is a written piece of art with a melody you enjoy listening to. That's music.
Tommygun1028 2 years ago 40
@Tommygun1028 I enjoy both. Love old Genesis tunes and I also love shredding bands like Megadeth and Pantera. It's hip hop and rap who are killing music nowadays.
rdeyahlxppp 1 year ago
@Tommygun1028 well said my man! If you really think about it, not many shredding songs endure...there are some, yes, but most great songs put musicianship behind composition....and some great songs find a way to use both to great success
jasaggio 1 year ago
I've said it before and I'll say it again. Steve Hackett makes sounds with his guitar unheard anywhere else in rock music.
vcasalnova 2 years ago 4
Yes - prog rock gets a bad press, but all its critics should listen to Hackett's solo first before complaining!
anthonythirteen 2 years ago
and then genesis went on to release their epic 78' masterpiece ' and then tony banks smiled', come on genesis lovers, lets not get too serious, although i am ,too, guilty of analysing every genesis gem!!!
eric15746 2 years ago
Excellent. Phil Collins really sparkles here, on vocals and drums.
perromanchado 2 years ago 2
Bravo!!!!!
42francois 2 years ago
GRANDE !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
annariccio1 2 years ago
woauuu what a nice guitar ejecution !!!
kumatosky 2 years ago
nice to see this. I was there !!!
massage1 2 years ago
miss the flute
Batwing3 2 years ago 2
3:43. Grande, barba. Como revoleas los palos. Sos un genio. Sos el unico.
MICHITO62 2 years ago
It's funny how Collins rushes the tempo during Banks solo. I've noticed it.
enkiitu 2 years ago
So that wasn't just me? I thought it got faster at one point, but sometimes YT screws with it.
kamwrites 2 years ago
Without Gabriel's fab vocals and Hackett's influence Genesis were never the same - becoming too focused on commerciality not creativity.
lordnoggers 2 years ago 3
yea i agree but i think wind and wuthering is still an amazing album, at least genesis had some good albums before they got commercial in the 80's. Now bands just are commercial to begin with it seems
Crimsonphilosophy 2 years ago 2
Genesis continued to be very creative and original after Hackett and Gabriel, just notin the same vain. Mama was certainly not commercial and Turn It On Again was in 13/8 time!!!
RichardMMPs 2 years ago 4
il mio sogno: vederli un giorno riuniti, tutti e cinque!!! non ci spero più!!!
Prigionierodellanott 2 years ago
è il mio stesso sogno... ma ormai mi pare impossibile che si realizzi purtroppo...
liftmedown001 2 years ago
micidiale!!! troppo bella!!!!! :)
hekaitomix94 2 years ago
Potete dire quello che volete sul periodo Gabriel-Collins,ma un fatto è certo...
dal punto di vista tecnico in questo periodo avevano raggiunto la perfezione!
MrMarco1986 2 years ago
(post 2 of 2)
which would perhaps indicate that something these guys have created is immensely valuable - we should embrace all genesis.
theRedPilll 2 years ago
another view would be that though i really wish hackett didn't leave (i saw a concert in kansas city in '77 with pals, us all sharing in the experience - which was truly the most wonderful..) the sound from that time was in fact in important ways the sound and mood of the greatest genesis - but ! - such excelence is this music that mr. collins got to create songs that were not just number one's, but several in a row and for the longest time -
theRedPilll 2 years ago
and the they were three!
masterpiece,imho.........
goaholix 2 years ago
phil collins stuff is really good too, but its sad they didnt stay all together...
sabourinrock 2 years ago
they lost their "englishness" when hackett left after wind and wuthering, which was a quintessential part of the band up until 76'. as dylan said u cant please all of the people all of the time and genesis did regress after that musically but only in the "prog rock" way, whereas they made a couple of fantastic albums, notably duke, after this and gained a whole new audience. only my humble opinion genesis/music lovers!
eric15746 2 years ago
You hit upon an important point that a lot of people miss--their sound didn't really change when Gabriel left; it changed when Hackett left. Funny how the person that most probably considered the least "critical" to the band had such an impact by his departure.
capsfans6366 2 years ago 22
@capsfans6366 i def agree, but... the 80s changed every band. Even if hackett stayed, their changed was inevitable. To be honest though, they reached such a beautiful peak between the lamb and a trick of the tail.
PermanentWave62 1 year ago
@capsfans6366 Wow! Never would have thought that thought. Nicely said..............
gern2000 1 year ago
@capsfans6366 i am with that hackett did make a diffrent but it wasnt the main thing it was more of the impact on songs and onstage performance and present gabriel had and dont forget that all this stuff r from the old albums they kept playing it for few years after gabriel departure till they had there big success in Abacab album in 81.
91schumacher 1 year ago
@capsfans6366 Exactly right sir, well said !
klnine 1 year ago
@capsfans6366 not only a generic "sound" change. when peter left ... did you have listen The Lamia? do you think after there is another song wich value is at least 1/10 of her? :) i think not, from peter gabriel departure the genesis songs became ..cute, not more (ripples i.e. is annoying).
I think that genesis was perfect when five. with the contribute of all members. nobody excluded.
is honest to admit that
honor64 1 year ago
8th October 1977 - Steve Hackett leaves Genesis during the mixing of the 'Seconds Out' live album, while driving to the studio Phil reputedly saw him walking down the street and offered to give him a lift, which he declined, it's only when Phil reached the studio that Phil learned what had happened.
TheUtubesuxass 2 years ago
WOW!! Is that how it really happened!!! That will knock your D in the dirt!!!!
bigwo56 2 years ago
I think at this point Phil Collins voice has grown, the sound and Hacketts guitarsolo have never been better.
Must admit: I do not even miss Peter Gabriel on this one. And I LOVE Peter Gabriel.
If you want another great, not as wellknomn solo. Listen to Camel,"Ice", here on the tube in a 9.40 min.live version.
Matshoppahulle 2 years ago
Where is the rest of this concert video? This was the best band on the planet at this era. I would love to see ...In that quiet earth... or supper's ready from this tour. The Landing lights and all. Well, thanks anyway.
ericslakes 2 years ago
Steve's guitar solo is haunting. I love it.
TheJman2600 2 years ago 6
One of the best songs...all times !!!!!
depeche79 2 years ago 2
wow...without words.
ThisResurrection 2 years ago
I never thought they would replace gabriel but they went pop and survived.but they where never the same
derek6678421 2 years ago
You can't blame Collins, they had to sell records/Cd's and that's the way things were going into the 80's. Yet you his solo albums were a cut above most other music at the time, and so were Genesis's 80's LP's. Above all we love the great music they made in the 70's. Despite Gabriel leaving I think 'A Trick of the tail' was awesome. When first heard it thru a good Hifi it just BLEW ME AWAY! Everlasting Music..
soundspur 2 years ago 2
It all went wrong when Hackett left. He was the prog rock influence. After that you can't tell what is Genesis and what is collins solo work. I still don't know what is what.
eddybaby167 2 years ago
I think that is a fair point when you look at singles alone, but when you consider songs like Home By The Sea and Domino, you know you're listening to Genesis!
beng1lh00ly 2 years ago
I don't think you can compare Home by the Sea to a song like Cinema Show. They are totally different. I guess you could call it selling out.
eddybaby167 2 years ago 2
I don't think you can call it selling out - they were still making good music, just with a different sound. I happen to like that sound, but fair does if you don't. Level 42 were forced to do the same thing during the mid 80's - a jazz-funk band at heart, they were making pop-based music to survive.
beng1lh00ly 2 years ago
The album "Invisible Touch" was a total sell out. Domino was great, but on an otherwise awful pop album. Not sure about this "survive" idea. Genesis were never a huge band in the Gabriel days, but the fans they had were completely loyal as the band was incredible. They would have survived as a smaller band, they just wouldn't have been on TV commercials for Virgin Air.
drunk3director 2 years ago
It wasn't to "survive". It was a sell-out to get rich, that is what selling out means, giving up what you believe in order to make money. That is why the 80s sucked so bad. Almost everybody sold out.
drunk3director 2 years ago
Fantastic song. Awesome group. Great performance.
madbtk 2 years ago
E' difficile dirlo con certezza, tanta è la quantità di capolavori che hanno composto i Genesis, ma forse questo è il più bel brano singolo della musica contemporanea!
francesco31006 2 years ago
Dico una fesseria se preferisco di gran lunga l'era Gabriel a quella Collins?
Floydiano91 2 years ago
No, non dici una fesseria, purchè tu escluda "Trick of the Tail" e "Wind and Wuthering" dall'era Hackett, perchè c'era ancora, ma soprattuto perchè sono due album strpitosamente belli, sicuramente più di "Trespass", non inferiori, a mio avviso, a "Nursery Crime" e "Foxtrot" e di poco inferiori a "Selling England" e "The Lamb", quest'ultime pietre miliari della GRANDE MUSICA!
francesco31006 2 years ago
Eh beh! Can you tell where my country lies! Fantastico...non erano mica canzoni! Erano favole...poi the musical box è un sogno onirico...però ragazzi Gabriel è stato il 50 percento della band....almeno nel trittico che tu hai citato...Supper's Ready è apocalittica...
Floydiano91 2 years ago
Depuis septembre 1972, où j'ai eu la chance de les voir, ET DE LES ENTENDRE, au Marquee Club à Londres, ils restent (à jamais) en vibrante émotion en moi.
Merci Messieurs de GENESIS !!!!!
Reverra-t-on le premier groupe de la génèse, un jour?
jako13000 2 years ago
is it just me but, after i started listening to the old Genesis , i wouldn't listen to anything else. literally .... had the Second Sides tape in my truck for a solid year , never turned off , friends wouldn't come around ... lol let a lot of good music go by
don't regret it at all....
morgancub 2 years ago
UNFORGETTABLE....!
MAYINSANTI 2 years ago
This is my favorite Genesis song. And best I always thought during this era. Awesome!
jhindy500 2 years ago
Phil was great back then. The band was superlative. What happened? The band became one horrific pop act. Sad!
howlhiker 2 years ago
"The sands of time are eroded by the river of constant change"
bakic21156 2 years ago
I like the mellotron (this version) better than the guitar (studio version) at 2:25. It has a nice eerie sound. Phil tears it up on the drums at 3:30. Great live performance.
boringalias 2 years ago
Actually at the beginning there Hackett is playing a volume-pedal guitar and doubling Banks on that melody (until it gets faster). Yeah, great live performance!
kaiserkuo 2 years ago
from 1976 - 1980 Phil was great...
Then I don't know what happened..
pattyheno 2 years ago
He grew an ego after Face Value...
felsner1 2 years ago
he also grew a BIG Bank Balance.
pattyheno 2 years ago
Yeah - and that combined with the 80'ies greed and coldness propelled him into a superstar era where he could walk on water. No wonder Bateman was so fond of him! ;-)
felsner1 2 years ago
All that had to be said has been said here :-) so I'll just add this is maybe my favorite Genesis song... and this live version is superb
cambiarmivida 2 years ago
Simply awesome song. I always preferred Peter's voice, and the sound of the band in his time, but there's plenty to love about Collins and the Genesis of the '80's. Hackett's solo is even better live than on the studio version.
PinkFloydManiac1973 2 years ago 3
Hackett is just amazing....what a maestro
funds450 2 years ago
I had no idea Charles Manson once sang for Genesis!
TheJman2600 3 years ago
Manson never sang for Genesis! He had his own music career (when he wasn't in jail or killing people).
PinkFloydManiac1973 2 years ago
VCASALNOVA HAI PROPRIO RAGIONE!
simopalmiandre 3 years ago
Climb aboard Steve's guitar from 4:44 to 7:30 and be flown to a better place. Awesome.
vcasalnova 3 years ago 5
I wish Steve wouldn't have quit, he could have done his solo stuff and still stay with Genesis.
mrgoodvibrations 2 years ago