林欣彤 - 讓我跟你走

[kennyjaii]

個尾收得好令

[33333poi]

放開嗓子激昂澎湃~至冧心耶~~~~~~~~~

[lnam2012]

一尾淨係識大叫咆哮,有鬼用咩!!

同彭羚真係差天共地...

[magmaglove1000]

情有獨鍾噢.

[silversand168]

鼻音很重

[Tinavvvvv]

@silversand168 你去聽下彭羚唱歌, 她的鼻音更重, 鄭秀文唱歌也是, 上一代來講, 唯獨王菲,林憶蓮等才不會有重NOSE音..

[alexsammylap]

好棒

[33333poi]

澎湃靚聲滿足夠~~~~~~~

[carmenli819]

唱緊乜9?

[yeee781]

歌聲高亢嘹亮繞梁遏雲

前途無限

[lwy1314]

唔知似乜,

把聲明顯唔夠力

[maverick75]

鼻塞甘聲

[sunnylchcyt]

1個新人1個巨星...你5好搵mag同mj比^^

[33333poi]

我至有福氣冧到就識飛~~~~~~~~~

[gkkchui]

有SKILL,但冇FEEL ...

[Lightbulb27]

if this is the best HK can do now, they need to continue the search for more talent!

[kuen0206]

都係個句!咬字唔該努力D!

[33333poi]

佢一po出嚟第一個冧死我~~~~~~~

[MrGuyCheerful]

咁都po 出黎係咪想害死佢

[33333poi]

聽佢唱歌簡直就係享受~將慕與愛郎勇創情路那幸福期盼發揮到漓離­盡至~內心感情經澎湃演繹動我心靡~一次令我難忘的演繹~感動~­~~~~~

[lpy031504]

唔得,,,第一下而經覺得同彭姐姐差天共地,,,可能她的風格我­不喜歡吧,,,,,這樣太浮誇了,,唱不出此歌的味道

[freegirl]

林欣彤唱歌既skill其實唔錯，但係佢成日好用力去唱，搞到無­晒感情！就算唔同彭羚比，同gem比都會好易聽得出邊個有感情d­，有時唱歌唔係淨係skill好就得，最緊要係可唔可以感動到其­他人，對我黎講，依方面佢真係唔係幾掂！

[bidibaby100]

@freegirl 佢而家只不過係可以嗌到好響.... 日後再睇0下點~~ 都係0甘就@@"

[benbenzon]

點同彭羚比....

[d5670825]

我真係覺得係嗌多過有POWER

[magmaglove1000]

聽極do咁鍾意噢.

[s03080]

把聲無彭羚咁靚...

一味用力...要高就無左柔...

彭羚果隻剛中有柔...

咬字清楚...

林欣彤實在不能比擬...



[33333poi]

深信直到我死嗰日，林欣彤磁性獨特歌聲都會深印腦中，實在太鍾意­喇~~~~

[superjoe1214]

如果lee首歌是林欣彤當年第一位唱既話，我相信十幾年後既今日­，唔會有人記得有lee首歌！至起碼林欣彤把聲唔會喺我腦海有印­象！

[superjoe1214]

都ok既！但把聲好似有D嘢塞住咗咁嘅，同原唱彭羚相差九十零條­街到啦！要跟彭羚學吓唱歌勒！

[boooo5136]

0:34_0:54

約定

[horacechung]

techique, control ,pitch, emotions everything is good,a good singer. but i think her voice doesn't fit this song 純粹個人意見

[33333poi]

聽親都起哂雞皮,難得咁正啊!

[toz6san]

哇真係起晒雞皮, 難聽到咁 lol

[uicetful]

歌聲澎湃 雞皮起埋 冧哂

[greekyan]

其實真唔知佢除左靠嗌重識乜..人地彭ling首歌都唔係咁..­(sry,純粹個人意見)

[Tinavvvvv]

@greekyan 我又唔覺她只是識嗌, 她真的是用氣/丹田唱歌, 尤其是很有感情, 動人, 兼有技巧....

[bidibaby100]

@greekyan Agree!!

[magmaglove1000]

首歌太短la.

[andy0055123]

返去聽彭羚 真係差太遠(～o～)

[royalagala25]

始終不及彭羚個種POWER同感動...



[Jiehengs]

@royalagala25 人哋新人來咖扎,唱到咁已經唔錯咖啦.支持下人哋啦..

[appleorange200606]

@royalagala25 一位系天后  一位系系新人 你想點??

[Tinavvvvv]

@royalagala25 你可知道MAG的年齡與CASE唱這歌時的年齡差多遠? MAG比她還年輕很多, 但MAG已經可以唱到這首歌, 還是應付有餘, 她唱得很輕鬆呢, 但CASE唱到面容扭曲 ~

[chloeyu414]

個人覺得Mag比原唱唱得仲好..好有power!!!

而且比起依家自稱係歌手既好好多,仲好有感情~

想多d好歌聽就應該多d support下香港樂壇啦!!

[oookla5]

我起雞皮la~~~

[teefsoh]

she should perform a full version of this song :)

[johnston9898]

比d時間人地啦...一個巨星是需要好多高低潮才能成熟及成長的­,而且不一定有觀眾緣...!!看看李克勤...出道了多少年才­能大紅大紫...

[Cantoner]

高音果種張力好吸引

[magmaglove1000]

首歌短太吊胃=.=

[753928]

把聲都唔到位=.=



[hkkhnyc]

stop hating.

Could you get the first pitch right like she did? and how many singers (current) in HK could really make it?

stop hating.

[Sheryl616]

禁短架！

[magmaglove1000]

原唱最好聽

佢都好鍾意la.

[8humilis]

請聽原唱

[chrisleung2010]

好有實力!

[mcmcmc333333]

high standard performance!!!

[mocha0520]

HORRIBLE..SORRY

[arohating]

==唱到咁,大家重想點??

新人黎姐,比d空間人地進步先得架...下下都話好難聽好難聽想­迫死人咩....

唔好為憎恨而憎恨...

留負面既comment前,問下自己有無用心去欣賞同聆聽先啦.­...

路人甲上(非mag fans)

[chrisleung2010]

@arohating  .....基本上話佢唱得唔好既人都有問題啦,想問除左MAG仲­有邊個歌手唱到呢首歌既副歌位可以有咁既水準? 我之前對MAG一D意見都無,無話覺得難聽唔難聽,但係我一入左­黎聽佢唱左一句已經俾佢嚇親,我好耐再無見過歌手唱現場可以唱到­呢個水準,所以基本上唔係新唔新人既問題,個D批評佢既人跟本就­係對佢有偏見

[ansonwong122]

ansonwong122 可能我唔係咁識欣賞＠＠我都係返去聽彭羚好D

[33333poi]

蠻牛刀客哂粗囗

市民眼底下出醜

真係前世~~~~~~~~~~~~

[magmag54321]

@33333poi

x 2

x 3

x 4

x N

[f0r4ver]

把聲好撚牛 -.-!! 完全無哂f33l

[keanhow1980]

同Cass彭羚比，输几條街啦。。。



[100patchan]

嘩!真係唱得好難聽,唱到好似拉牛上樹咁.

都係呀Cass唱得好聽D!

[lwy1314]

呀Cass好勁多羅

[kloo95]

這位少女歌聲悅耳，確實前途無限。

[yukochanful]

好難聽~~~~~

[etywable]

這位新人當日已能唱出那麼高水準，果然是香港樂壇新希望，讚賞！­

[keanhow1980]

我觉得其实她是喊着唱，而不是用感情唱出来。。。。

[c0c0v33v]

唱得好.

[TheMusicandlyricz]

She is screaming the song....

come on...this is not a yelling contest.

[magmag54321]

@TheMusicandlyricz

嘩!你首首歌O既評語都一樣,

果然係人肉錄音機,

勁..

[TheMusicandlyricz]

@magmag54321

They have the same mistakes and they're all terrible.

[ilikemusic1966]

Only people with low esteem and lack of maturity would use foul language in public forum. Not only it reflects badly on you personally, any decent parents will be embarrassed by your actions!

[kristinhoh]

her mouth is good 4 sucking n licking my dick hihihih

[lovemmiu]

純屬個人意見：我覺得佢「無咁大個頭，就唔好戴咁大頂既帽」。好­似第二個場合唱英文老歌，把聲底沙已經令首歌唔好聽，仲要發音都­唔標準，固然有少少ung耳

而依首歌，比較係無可厚非，彭羚把聲悅耳咁多，連我依個唔係專業­都覺得mag比下去了。若果聲底唔係唱D咁既歌，何苦要故意唱依­D歌用黎表現自己所謂既高技巧呢？

時勢做英雄，如果TBB唔係同四大唱片公司鬧番，mag又點會咁­高曝光率呢？

[CharleneFed]

Shut up! mag lam u sucks

[jason999hk]

為什麼要找一個天后跟一個新人來比?

平心而論, 你們覺得公平嗎?

[asas121212able]

@uicetful

孩兒,勿給面子於我盡情招呼牛生!

[uicetful]

@lammmimm

你悅高音我悅低~~

佢悅高音也悅低~~

[lammmimm]

@33333poi

獨特音飾太罕有***

偏偏遇正大水牛***

[33333poi]

@lammmimm

賤口臭播性如牛~~~

專重欠奉蠻如牛~~~

[chiuhonamz]

d低音真係..... 唔係唱到好高既音就代表有唱功

低音部份完全係用把牛聲黎唱......

[cxcxcx98]

@cxcxcx98

言則歌手不合符心意理應給你狠批??

技巧感情並重方能逃過大爺你的惡意攻擊??

哪位幸運兒得到大爺恩寵那麼走運呢??

倘若大爺開枝散葉樂壇將亡!!

肆意妄為還理直氣壯???

[HFLHenry]

救命. . . 聽到high jor

[33333poi]

@uicetful

無恥爛口低級班???

[brianhihihi]

林欣彤?哈......末夠班



[brianhihihi]

林欣彤?收撚皮啦

[magmag54321]

@brianhihihi

返去同你老豆阿媽講番同一樣o既說話,

記住,一字不漏呀,

OK.

如果唔夠膽,就唔該你喺度收皮.

[goldeybo]

好想聽佢唱我是一隻小小鳥 (叮噹版),吾知出黎效果係惦?

[timmmmmmful]

前輩彭羚當然好啦! 我好希望佢復出!

mag係新人都5錯喇!

[angel32655]

始終覺得彭羚把聲好D同靚D，女性D，林欣彤把聲比較中性，我覺­得彭羚無論高音、低音都carry到，彭羚的嗌有感情D、請出來­唱多D歌滿足一吓我哋D fans。

[kmpiano1]

This is very good! But I think Cass is the best interpreter of the song....

[Ananablee]

唔明D人點解咁嚴厲

我覺得佢潛力好大

一個人係絕對需要有進步空間

佢咬字係有問題 但可以改

有聽佢比賽都知佢其實有辦法唱出感情

呢首歌無頭無尾憑咩話佢無

而且佢尾2句收得幾好

我覺得做人應該寬容D

[lap1031]

@Ananablee

咪係LOR...

假設林欣彤係一個超級靚女,D人仲會咁諗?

佢既聲底唱哀傷歌會好好,而且佢唱歌具感情

我唔明點解一個咁有潛力既人會比人踩到咁

D人眼紅?眼紅佢唱一首AINY就紅左?

[midoriTung]

@lap1031 我吾知道其他人點睇 不過佢有d fans真系自大到好令人討厭.

講到佢天上有 地下無甘勁

arrogant到好令人想踩幾腳.

佢ainy 之前唱成點, 大家都有目共睹

[magmag54321]

乜嘢技巧,乜嘢音色,乜嘢抖氣,乜嘢換氣,乜嘢高低range,­­乜嘢乜嘢又乜嘢,,,,,,,,,,,

我唔係歌唱老師,唔係靚聲大歌星,我唔識評價噃,

但我想問大家,一個歌星唱一首歌,入耳第一個感覺最吸引你去聽,­­,,係乜????

係以上果D所謂技巧,所謂???,真係???

我估,會唔會係感情呢,

真情流露咁去唱一首歌,(當然要有一定唱功)就會吸引同感動到人­­,唔知啱唔啱呢.........

各位高人.



[midoriTung]

@magmag54321 1個歌手唱歌正系有技巧無(or 吾好)感情, 會比人踩

1個歌手有感情無(or 吾好)技巧, 1樣都會比人踩.

呢d都好自然, 請fan 接受

[keungchify]

呀Mag.您唱得好正,..爆得頌靚,..歌迷都＋分之欣賞既!­..

其實,..樂壇係可以容立到更多新進歌手既!..如果當曰你哋既­偶像係出道既時候

同樣受到惡意既攻擊既話,..咁你話佢又點可以係一個良好既氣氛­之下成長呢??

更可況大家本是一家,..係好應該要互相專重,..和諧共處既!­!..係咪???

[Angel7215201314]

ON.9林欣彤...同啊Gem玩?你都未夠班~!

聲又唔係好聽WO~人地啊GEM人靚聲甜啊!!

你收山la~又唔知自己樣9

[hOkInG520]

林欣彤佢唱到個 key, 但唱唔出感情, 唔太動聽,



[sangyui]

@vincy1177  關心胸狹窄咩事

[siudinxd]

@sangyui @hOkInG520 我睇到你打關心妍更加係咩事-_-

[sangyui]

@siudinxd 我幾時有打關心妍.....= =+ 你到底知唔知你講緊咩........

[wongpuiyan2]

獅吼聲

[hwhlabgon]

對,可能真係最大聲那些歌手,但大聲叫唔代表什麼,如果用來跟T­OP女歌手比的話,未免是井底之蛙了

[dmz2668]

@hwhlabgon 大聲叫真係唔代表d咩

但首歌咁大個range就有代表性了

你會不會欣賞人很有技巧地唱有隻雀仔跌落水?

[lap1031]

@dmz2668

咁你都要諗下大聲叫,叫到E個程度

音色上同埋KEY上

係咪真係咁容易?

我相信如果佢唱番一次技巧性既有隻雀仔跌落水的話

迴響一定比E家更大,我咁打賭

[sangyui]

唔識欣賞

[yuengmak]

she will become big big star

[rtyqwe]

試問今時今日香港樂壇有幾多個歌手可以唱到呢類形geh歌?



[f0r4ver]

@rtyqwe  所以mag刀吾例外~_~

[cherrylee0920]

唱得幾好~只可惜我唔太鍾意MAG把聲~

[jaceliang]

@vincy1177

唔係卦?我見過好多歌手都唱得比佢好自然的,而且佢只係人,仲有­好大進步空間,而且JOEY佢唱其他歌都會面容變架啦,我已經見­慣左啦!原唱者鞋然都唱得好激動,但係最自然既一個(CASS)­.(只屬個人意見)

[49101517]

懂得欣賞妳嘅歌聲係我嘅福氣！mag加油!

[pkkwok2008]

以一個新人來說確是不俗

可是我總覺得她聲底太厚 聽起來不太舒服自然

另外唱這歌太過誇張 欠缺了彭羚的優雅

第一句來讓我跟你走就已經太過澎湃 直如男人咆哮一般

[bananachm]

@pkkwok2008 更係la1入就入副歌.你想幾溫柔呀-_-咁勁你去唱lor-_­-

[z258123]

點解啲人話啊Mag 啲歌唔好聽..但又日日聽佢啲歌..之後cm話唔好聽既?



[h119onghong119]

@z258123

Ha~你中晒Point !!!

一擊即中,

叻 !!!

[siukwan88]

pp hate her becuz they love GEM so much and they dont believe there could be someone else who can sing as good as GEM (no offense, i like GEM as well),,,

however,,, Mag does sing pretty well,,, just admit it pp !!!

[cambie9601]

@siukwan88

To be honest, most people hate Mag because of her voice and the way she sings. They do not necessarily love GEM. Mag surely can sing, but she is still too far from being great.

[okboy2011]

@cambie9601

你咁唔鐘意mag把聲, 就唔好日日去聽mag唱歌. 做番個正常人啦. 

[kienez]

no offense, her vocal, if compared to cass phang, still far from acceptable. you can hear that she struggle during the high note and her high note is very "rough". still like joey yung starting, her voice isn't good and proven that with practice in time, you can actually align your voice to perform certains note. good luck maq lam. :-)

[emiltsuimunsang]

聽左十萬次,都係咁正~

[bananachm]

試問有邊1個新人1出泥就係perfect嫁

[catkizzhk]

正到聽完又聽

[uohecc]

i wann see gem do this

[pk19901990]

我愛你

[hoooyuuu]

拎一個新人同彭羚joey比緊係無得比啦- -

[jaceliang]

@hoooyuuu

Joey亦冇得同彭羚比, CASS is the best!!!

[a24067]

fuXk ! u :p

[fx3650]

嗌歌嗌到咁, 字又唔準,

原來咁樣叫爆?

[jacky3800]

@fx3650 Ｘ２。

佢既成功就係幕後推手包裝成功。

[okboy2011]

@fx3650

咁點樣分唱歌同嗌歌? 咁d字點先叫準? 咁點樣先叫做爆?

唔該可唔可以講解下...

[mpvhk2002]

mag果然厲害！唔駛理某d廢話..我等緊你出碟！

[swissperfection]

Mag唱歌最大嘅缺點係感情沒有層次，永遠都是聲嘶力竭.

[tomli8880508]

要時間改善, 不過我關注佢個鼻音問題多啲, 無得搞~

[ycydavid]

@swissperfection 係，佢需要更多歷練，感情先會慢慢有層次；依家實在有太多進步空­間

[marco168888]

我很爱他

[Jiatianval]

一口氣焗到盡咁就當人神咁拜...邊夠呀Cass唱得有情感之餘­仲要畀到人遊刃有餘既感覺呀?

[jaceliang]

@Jiatianval

我 BUY 你！

[jaywithyu]

She ends it so well!

[yoshidasantokyo]

her voice can be really powerful.

however i think she should turn on the turbo only when the circumstances demand.

remember she's equally enchanting while singing softly.

[killyoulaterkill]

Simply gorgeous ! Well-done Mag !

[Kellychan2046]

totally penetrated, those high notes are overwhelming

[lojacky87]

she got a nice vocal reach but she tried too hard. sounds like she was yelling at someone

[bananian]

@lojacky87

you are just too used to lame ass singers in HK.

[lojacky87]

@bananian forgive me if I dun appreciate your idol's "obvious talent". i only saw this video because i was looking for songs by some old "lame ass singer of hong kong", who, by the way, is called Cass Phang.

[bananian]

@lojacky87

dude, I wasn't insulting you or Cass Phang, dumbass. Okay, now I am. I was just saying how most other singers sing lame songs that rarely goes beyond the average notes.

[lojacky87]

@bananian and this girl is just slightly better than average, and yet people like you think she is a star. But i am not surprised. What strikes me though is the presumptions that you made about a random stranger you met on the internet. Stop stalking people, get a life lol

[bananian]

@lojacky87

omg, are you seriously butt hurt over me calling you a dumbass? Sigh.

[bananian]

@lojacky87

also, you are the one assuming that I think she was a star, you hypocrite. It is you who is being overly critical of someone who had just done an amazing rendition that not even Joey Yung could match. This girl's voice was unique and had amazing control of it even in the difficult areas and all you could come up with was that she was screaming? Why are you so bitter?

[safarihk]

都好聽,,不過有少少 "嗌" 歌.



[LapSiLap]

This is super!

[honeytube888]

同意! 我係youtube另一處聽到joey &張信哲唱呢首「讓我跟你走」.... 就覺得joey唱方式比較悶同欠缺感染力, 而buy ah mag. 而原唱版本客觀地講當然好好, 原唱者比較擅長唱抒情慢歌, ah mag 就更多了一份佢個人獨有的感染力, 唱功就已無需懷疑, 因為能夠唱別人的歌都不斷有感染力, 樂壇罕見, 如沒有唱功亦根本談不上有感染力.....

另一首「越唱越強」我以前冇聽過, 冇得分享, 或者會聽返.....