Although it is nice, it's pretty clear Stern was past his prime at this point. It lacks the precision and clarity of his earlier performances and of Szeryng's and Heifetz's renditions, understandably.
moman is so right. stern with ormandy...amazing. after hearing that recording, it made me wonder at the garbage performances of everyone else i've listened to in the past.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
To me this work is second-rate when compared to Beethoven's concerto....except for the Allegro giocoso. It has no thematic identity. That said, Stern's performance seems to be more impassioned than Szerying, but it could just be the age of the recording.
I would rank the Brahms together with the Beethoven but as for thematic identity, I complete disagree. The themes in the Brahms are some of the most beautiful and unique in violin literature. I would say the 1st movement is the highlight, while the Allegro Giocoso sounds like your common everyday joyful dance-like pieces such as the 3rd movement of Bruch 1st.
I thought I was the only one who preferred the Szerying recording. It blew me away. But Stern is an icon. At least he waited til he was old to play out of tune, unlike Perlman.
aw cut perlman a break, he's a really busy guy, what with playing for movies and teaching and running a summer program, not to mention practicing for performances!
@coolsnak3 bad sh.t, there.Can YOU play fiddle, idiot? Is your (left) hand capable of doing what Perlman can do?.From a Vietnam Veteran and former student of Boris Schwarz
this really isn't that good. sorry to be offensive, but szeryng's is a ton better. i'm sure he could play it better when he was young, but its just not good.
Perhaps Stern is not in his prime but each and every note is "Vécu" which comes with age, musically it is extraordinary and inspired up the the highest level. Szeryng had and always had a tendency to be academic with some lack of inspiration. I much rather have a Stern who put everything note as if they are a recreation than perhaps a more perfect technical version.
Beautiful violin..!
travonprince 8 months ago
wel al wat oud, maar vele jonge violisten kunnen er nog wat van leren,!
marinasibila 11 months ago
Is this the Philadelphia Orchestra?
pnolanrn 1 year ago
isaac stern!!! forever the most passionate player. forever the absolute best!
Tarcila62078 1 year ago 2
@Tarcila62078 most definitely!
megakrazydave1 1 year ago
a little too fast...
bckm54 1 year ago
This ouverture is endless ...
violinoamore 1 year ago
i dont like his sound.... he is very rough, scratchy!!! He is not Isaac we loved
crazy77town 1 year ago
Who is the conductor? Looks like Jukka Pekka Saraste, but I could be wrong.
quornholio 1 year ago
The most difficult concerto, Beethoven the other.
Thanks for posting.
I lovely live legacy of our greatest fiddler.
naumandolphin 1 year ago
Beautiful mr. Stern. You make me cry!
dexterspe 1 year ago
Although it is nice, it's pretty clear Stern was past his prime at this point. It lacks the precision and clarity of his earlier performances and of Szeryng's and Heifetz's renditions, understandably.
aPMism 2 years ago
Try listening to his recording with
Ormandy in the 60's. That will blow everything else away...Perlmann, Milstein, not even close!!
moman2067 2 years ago 2
moman is so right. stern with ormandy...amazing. after hearing that recording, it made me wonder at the garbage performances of everyone else i've listened to in the past.
michiganitis 2 years ago 8
I thought it was just me -- that stern / ormandy recording sounds SO good. I cannot listen to any other.
trentdk 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
To me this work is second-rate when compared to Beethoven's concerto....except for the Allegro giocoso. It has no thematic identity. That said, Stern's performance seems to be more impassioned than Szerying, but it could just be the age of the recording.
malbamope 2 years ago
I would rank the Brahms together with the Beethoven but as for thematic identity, I complete disagree. The themes in the Brahms are some of the most beautiful and unique in violin literature. I would say the 1st movement is the highlight, while the Allegro Giocoso sounds like your common everyday joyful dance-like pieces such as the 3rd movement of Bruch 1st.
violinmusicfan 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Fuck u to hell, Brahms is a beast!!!
violin957 2 years ago 3
unique sound
dddj7 2 years ago
This is nice, Too bad he messes up at 6:48 though.
scundoo 2 years ago
na man he jus improvised
temsonx 1 year ago
I thought I was the only one who preferred the Szerying recording. It blew me away. But Stern is an icon. At least he waited til he was old to play out of tune, unlike Perlman.
jbryles 2 years ago
aw cut perlman a break, he's a really busy guy, what with playing for movies and teaching and running a summer program, not to mention practicing for performances!
chicklet3746 1 year ago
@chicklet3746 pearlman does not run a summer program. he rolls one. :D ok that's just mean. sowie!
coolsnak3 1 year ago
@coolsnak3 bad sh.t, there.Can YOU play fiddle, idiot? Is your (left) hand capable of doing what Perlman can do?.From a Vietnam Veteran and former student of Boris Schwarz
outoftunefiddler 1 year ago
magnifico....hace tiempo lo estaba buscando
yayavives 2 years ago
This concerto give me shivers...
The biggest violinist of all time. Maestro de maestros, RIP Stern.
javideleon24 2 years ago
Yes, Isaac is past his prime, but look at
his masterful demeanor and look at his
attack. He still had the heart of a young
lion, though the teeth may have become a little dull over time. He was a true master, one
of the last of his era of great violinists.
robotnik77 2 years ago 21
@robotnik77 How is a master ever PAST his prime?? He only knew even MORE than his "prime", as you put it.
Someone need not be faster, louder, sharper to be great.
Just look at movies, what wins Oscars? The faster louder sharper films? Or the quieter well and subtly played ones?
karrezza 4 months ago
cool:D
sttang77 2 years ago
Yes, this is past Stern's prime--look for his 27 year earlier recording with Ormandy and the Philadelphia Orchestra--yes!
ipmoic 3 years ago
maravilloso, gracias
roberto1957 3 years ago
this really isn't that good. sorry to be offensive, but szeryng's is a ton better. i'm sure he could play it better when he was young, but its just not good.
whitemexnumba1 3 years ago
Perhaps Stern is not in his prime but each and every note is "Vécu" which comes with age, musically it is extraordinary and inspired up the the highest level. Szeryng had and always had a tendency to be academic with some lack of inspiration. I much rather have a Stern who put everything note as if they are a recreation than perhaps a more perfect technical version.
embenadorfinearts 2 years ago
I prefer the sound of Szeryng for this piece as well
dmelkumo 2 years ago
he plays the concert well, to have the age hi has, but i agree with you...sometimes it´s out of tune, and the sound its not clear all times.
I don´t want ot offend anyone, it´s only my opinion.
lidialidia7 2 years ago
just fantastic!!!!! the best version?? i think so.
ri161 3 years ago
conductor looks like krystian zimerman lol
teccomin 3 years ago
Maestro de Maestros,,,,,,,,,
johannmilstein 3 years ago
can someone post kyung wha chung playing this piece?
Fr3derick 3 years ago 2
Is the conductor Sarastro?
lolmanerik 3 years ago
It´s the young Jukka-Pekka Saraste!
niedavgeige 3 years ago
Thanks!!!
iggorr82 4 years ago
dude, thanks so much for posting this! I'm really glad you did! Thanks!
tovinho 4 years ago
Thanks for posting this video of an older Stern playing one of the best violin concerto's.
sherom 4 years ago