First off you need to decide if you are keeping coins for numismatic or bullion. If your keeping them for bullion dont even bother with cleaning your coins, because its is a waist of time. The person or company that is buying your coins for bullion is most likely going to melt them so a bit of dirt or milk spots make no matter. If you are keeping them for numismatic value and you go to sell them i have bad news for you you by cleaning them or touching them up have lost
i heard (sorry if you say this later in your video but i haven't watched it all) that some people rather you just leave the silver alone. So I wouldn't know whether to clean mine or not if they tarnish (which they will i wasn't smart enough to handle them with gloves).
I think it's best, if you're not sure what to do with your silver, to either leave it alone or do more research until you feel confident. In some cases you can reduce the premium value (the value it has on top of simply the metal it contains) of silver items by improperly treating the surface. So if you're not sure, hold off for now.
Thank you for this information. I have place mint looking maples in Air Tite ring type holders. Now Milk spots have appeared. I will try these methods. Will one cleaning do it? I bet not.
awesome vid, i never knew the eraser method. i will have to try it out. since its been a year, have you noticed any changes to the coins you cleaned? either way anything is better then the milk stains. paying $2-3 less for a coin that is easily cleaned is well worth it when your on a tight budget. oh i also like the method you showed for removing tarnish. its like magic. the stuff comes off within seconds with boiling water. tyvm for sharing.
Thanks! No, I haven't noticed any problems over time with coins treated this way. I've been using the eraser method and jewelry cloth method with good results. Tiny abrasions on the silver surface are indeed much better than ugly and permanent milk spots.
Hallo nice video i had some canada grizzly.s 10 pieces all mint when they arrived,after some months the milkspots came i looked u video and u should try hagerty dip u dip m rinse m with water dry them carefull brandnew no schratches no marks nothing
very easy, litlle basket to dip 10 seconds works like a charm try it ...hagerty silver clean liquid saluti
I got a stack of those 2010 hockey maples completely stained, at first there seemed to be only milk spots, but with time (and some handling) the spots covered the whole surface and fingerprints are clearly visible... it's too bad since they have a nice premium.
I'll try the eraser as soon as I can ! thanks for the info !
I have milk spots on my canadain maples, but they weren't there when I bought them as I remember the coins being shiny without any blemishes. I only handled them when I bought them, then I just stored them away. Later down the line I noticed the coins with milk spots all over them...? so are you sure that milk spots can't just appear over time? Because when I first bought the coins they weren't there.
I've recently experienced what I believe is something similar. I think you're right and perhaps there's a certain contaminant that can cause milk spots or at least what appear to be milk spots. I have a Grizzly that was mint when put away and now has milk spots around the edges. At least there's a treatment, but still, too bad silver reacts more than gold, grrrrrr.
I've just tried the jewellery wipe method on a sliver philharmonica which had milk spots on it. And I can confirm that it does work, and it left no damage on the coin visible to the naked eye.....Thank you for this video. very helpful!
've just tried the eraser trick about 10 minutes ago. IT WORKS! In the beginning, it seems like it just smothers the borax to spread a little, but keep redoing the process with erasing than dipping in water and it'll eventually bring you happiness. :)
I tried the ammonia and it didn't work instantly, so I tried the eraser and it worked. I was then able to buff out the eraser's effects with Tarnex and a soft cloth. What are those marijuana leaf coins called?
It's up to you! I think the ammonia or wipes method would work best (would take a long time to erase that much). Also it may depend what the finish of the bar is. It may end up coming off, but leaving tiny abrasions you can see under certain light, so keep that in mind. If you do it, test on a small hidden part of the bar first and see if you like the result.
Alright! Does anyone know or have heard of milk spots being on American eagles? I have a couple American eagles that look almost like they have milky spots; I tried the baking soda hot water and salt normal tarnish removing process, it did not work! has anyone else had this problem with their eagles??
Great tips D! Apmex hosed me about a year ago with an order in which they sent me a tube full of milk spotted maples. I put em in the safe and tried not to let it bug me. Time to pull em out and take another look.
I hope this helps you man. Currently I'm favouring the jewelry cloth method. It's very quick and easy (as you saw) and the resulting fine abrasions are VERY tiny and hard to see. Really does a decent job! Maybe I'm not using the right erasers. They work, but they leave some pretty obvious scuffs after, even when using clean soft erasers. I haven't tried the ammonia trick yet but I'm going to when I get some. I hear it works well and doesn't leave any scuffs, so consider that. :)
@SGTbull07 The same thing happened to me. I got out a tube of Apmex rounds that I bought in 2008. I never opened them. I just put them away. I opened them the other day and they are covered with spots. It made me sick to my stomach and angry.......oh so angry!
So, what I understand is that I should stop cleaning the milk stains on my silver maples by bathing them concentrated sulfuric acid? JK! Great post! :)
Yeah, that's why I sound so different, and don't say "um" at all, and don't take 12 minutes to get through 5 minutes of information. I don't like how my voice sounds when I'm reading my prepared words, but it's necessary for some informational videos.
Stop playing with your silver! You will be hairy palms! lol
When you pile up Maples up on top of each other and dump junk silver, you are scratching them up....... Maples get scratched so easily. When they sit in a tube, the weight is on the edges so its OK though. I have some big 10 oz Perth mint Year of the Tiger and Koala coins that I dont even take out of the capsules. The 5 oz proof Libertads are super nice too!
Also, dont store your coins in PVC plastic like I did. I stored 100 maple leafs in cheap plastic bags and they left the milk spot residue in all of them after a few weeks. They do come off with silver cleaner and jewelery cloth as mentioned, but they will never be as good as they leave ultra-fine scratches. A coin of 9999 purity and proof finish should really leave the mint in its own casing as with the kooks.
Oh drutter, by the way. I noticed you have a lot of 2010 Olympic maples. You should put some on your website for crazy premiums. They fly off the shelf. I don't know why, maybe a lower mintage or more saught after but almost everywhere i go there sold out. Except Ebay.
I managed to grab a handful of the 2010 "hockey" maples today when I was out at the dealers. I think I'll put them up on the site tomorrow, thanks for the suggestion.
I tried the eraser method and it works. But it does leave little blemish marks on it but better than those stupid milk spots. Thanks JezebelDecibel and thanks drutter. Keep stckin to both u guys. And buy Junk Silver when you can.PEACE
Thanks Drutter. I hope you are feeling great and your kids are well. take care + greetings from Spain, Beatriz....PS: it is a great pity that you donnot deliver internationally.
Great review and yes it's great how we can share information through this medium.
I have gained so much valuable knowledge from all the wonderful Silver Bugs. Your all so respectful & helpful & it's almost hard to believe form an investment perspective. Basically I have so much more confidence in surviving the global economic fiat fiasco collapse. I have always love silver, but now I understand it on a deeper level.
Dark spots on silver are almost always from tarnish, a chemical reaction between silver and sulfur from the air. I did a video on how to remove tarnish, about a year ago. Go to my channel and search my videos for "tarnish" and it'll show up. It's the one with 18,000 views.
First off you need to decide if you are keeping coins for numismatic or bullion. If your keeping them for bullion dont even bother with cleaning your coins, because its is a waist of time. The person or company that is buying your coins for bullion is most likely going to melt them so a bit of dirt or milk spots make no matter. If you are keeping them for numismatic value and you go to sell them i have bad news for you you by cleaning them or touching them up have lost
cont in next post
byront37 4 days ago
@byront37 50 to 60% of their value. Cleaned coins are very to spot by knowledgeable coin buyers.
byront37 4 days ago
WOW ERASER IS REALLY NOT EXPECTEDD THANK YOU!!!
Keemm89 1 week ago
thanks for the video man.
Irishsilverstack 3 weeks ago
Thanks for the method, shall give it a go.
BullionData 3 weeks ago
Where can I get those coins at 4:20?
jarjar179 1 month ago
@jarjar179
If you're in the USA, libertyleaf%com. If you're not, canadiansilverbullion%com.
drutter 1 month ago
i heard (sorry if you say this later in your video but i haven't watched it all) that some people rather you just leave the silver alone. So I wouldn't know whether to clean mine or not if they tarnish (which they will i wasn't smart enough to handle them with gloves).
JustABitchyCancer 1 month ago
@JustABitchyCancer
I think it's best, if you're not sure what to do with your silver, to either leave it alone or do more research until you feel confident. In some cases you can reduce the premium value (the value it has on top of simply the metal it contains) of silver items by improperly treating the surface. So if you're not sure, hold off for now.
drutter 1 month ago
Thank you for this information. I have place mint looking maples in Air Tite ring type holders. Now Milk spots have appeared. I will try these methods. Will one cleaning do it? I bet not.
Thanks for the information, Mike.
geekboymike 1 month ago
Cool vid this will help my coins Thanks!
osvaldosdb 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Dude where did you buy marijuana leaf 1oz?!? Pls response
comrade86 2 months ago
Nice video, nice message.
russocollection 2 months ago
awesome vid, i never knew the eraser method. i will have to try it out. since its been a year, have you noticed any changes to the coins you cleaned? either way anything is better then the milk stains. paying $2-3 less for a coin that is easily cleaned is well worth it when your on a tight budget. oh i also like the method you showed for removing tarnish. its like magic. the stuff comes off within seconds with boiling water. tyvm for sharing.
silverandgoldfan 2 months ago
@silverandgoldfan
Thanks! No, I haven't noticed any problems over time with coins treated this way. I've been using the eraser method and jewelry cloth method with good results. Tiny abrasions on the silver surface are indeed much better than ugly and permanent milk spots.
drutter 2 months ago
good vid
ThePjcull 2 months ago
Wow, AuStacker and TestTubeWorld channels are no more.
redmatrix 2 months ago
i bought maples and they look like a cow has orgasmd all over them i will try these tips thankyou sir thumbs up
rolficus 2 months ago
Thanks!!!!!! The eraser thing really works
Yoyoloki888 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hallo nice video i had some canada grizzly.s 10 pieces all mint when they arrived,after some months the milkspots came i looked u video and u should try hagerty dip u dip m rinse m with water dry them carefull brandnew no schratches no marks nothing
very easy, litlle basket to dip 10 seconds works like a charm try it ...hagerty silver clean liquid saluti
hanzxl 2 months ago
Comment removed
hanzxl 2 months ago
I got a stack of those 2010 hockey maples completely stained, at first there seemed to be only milk spots, but with time (and some handling) the spots covered the whole surface and fingerprints are clearly visible... it's too bad since they have a nice premium.
I'll try the eraser as soon as I can ! thanks for the info !
Castorios 2 months ago
vacuum packing silver?
superhawkn 4 months ago
I have milk spots on my canadain maples, but they weren't there when I bought them as I remember the coins being shiny without any blemishes. I only handled them when I bought them, then I just stored them away. Later down the line I noticed the coins with milk spots all over them...? so are you sure that milk spots can't just appear over time? Because when I first bought the coins they weren't there.
lifendsoon 4 months ago
@lifendsoon
I've recently experienced what I believe is something similar. I think you're right and perhaps there's a certain contaminant that can cause milk spots or at least what appear to be milk spots. I have a Grizzly that was mint when put away and now has milk spots around the edges. At least there's a treatment, but still, too bad silver reacts more than gold, grrrrrr.
drutter 3 months ago
@lifendsoon perhaps its the difference in lighting
mikedoles 3 months ago
Canabis coins Vs, canada ..... thehe hippie coin will winn...:)
candon1972 5 months ago
I've just tried the jewellery wipe method on a sliver philharmonica which had milk spots on it. And I can confirm that it does work, and it left no damage on the coin visible to the naked eye.....Thank you for this video. very helpful!
Grichal1981 5 months ago 3
@drutter that was for u and people that u cooperated with ... xD selfish bastard ! ... :P
JackExEck 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
've just tried the eraser trick about 10 minutes ago. IT WORKS! In the beginning, it seems like it just smothers the borax to spread a little, but keep redoing the process with erasing than dipping in water and it'll eventually bring you happiness. :)
Catastraphecdv 6 months ago
Comment removed
Catastraphecdv 6 months ago
Are you a teacher? Cause you sound like one
001MeTaBoLiC100 6 months ago
I tried polish cloth my 13 maple leaf. It removed milk spots easily but left marks on the surface. Hopefully It wouldn't affect the value.
BTW I highly suspect the 25 coin tube would contribute to the minor damage on maple leaf coin. So I bought air-tite holder for my coins.
SleepingSun1985 6 months ago
I tried the ammonia and it didn't work instantly, so I tried the eraser and it worked. I was then able to buff out the eraser's effects with Tarnex and a soft cloth. What are those marijuana leaf coins called?
heat45jc 7 months ago
Hockey Maples FTW!
Torgo1969 8 months ago
thanks drutter, what can you advise for cleaning the ridged edges? Toothbrush and baking soda possibly
scottj719 9 months ago
James Avery jewelry cloth took all the spots off of my coins
lazyboy465 9 months ago
use a kneaded eraser.. best thing on earth.
Skreechchannel 10 months ago
@drutter i got a few. They owe you a commission! :)
hejira11 11 months ago
@drutter Thanks for the cleaning tips and the info!!! :)
hejira11 11 months ago
2010 is gone ;)
lilbromarky1 1 year ago 5
@lilbromarky1
Whoa, you're the first one to notice that and say something! Thanks, I added a corrective note.
drutter 1 year ago
@OfGodsServant
It's up to you! I think the ammonia or wipes method would work best (would take a long time to erase that much). Also it may depend what the finish of the bar is. It may end up coming off, but leaving tiny abrasions you can see under certain light, so keep that in mind. If you do it, test on a small hidden part of the bar first and see if you like the result.
drutter 1 year ago
Alright! Does anyone know or have heard of milk spots being on American eagles? I have a couple American eagles that look almost like they have milky spots; I tried the baking soda hot water and salt normal tarnish removing process, it did not work! has anyone else had this problem with their eagles??
Doublejoe321 1 year ago
Great tips D! Apmex hosed me about a year ago with an order in which they sent me a tube full of milk spotted maples. I put em in the safe and tried not to let it bug me. Time to pull em out and take another look.
SGTbull07 1 year ago
@SGTbull07
I hope this helps you man. Currently I'm favouring the jewelry cloth method. It's very quick and easy (as you saw) and the resulting fine abrasions are VERY tiny and hard to see. Really does a decent job! Maybe I'm not using the right erasers. They work, but they leave some pretty obvious scuffs after, even when using clean soft erasers. I haven't tried the ammonia trick yet but I'm going to when I get some. I hear it works well and doesn't leave any scuffs, so consider that. :)
drutter 1 year ago
@drutter thank you brutha,
I need to get some of those jewelry wipes, I'll have to charge em back to Apmex! :)
SGTbull07 1 year ago
@SGTbull07 The same thing happened to me. I got out a tube of Apmex rounds that I bought in 2008. I never opened them. I just put them away. I opened them the other day and they are covered with spots. It made me sick to my stomach and angry.......oh so angry!
siszam 1 year ago
Silver porn= milk spots?
momentous11 1 year ago
never dull works the best...
Enemyatthegates1 1 year ago
thanks,the eraser method blew me away.
ohyeah10456 1 year ago
thanks Dr. Utter...I've already got my eraser out!
Inhaler42O 1 year ago
So, what I understand is that I should stop cleaning the milk stains on my silver maples by bathing them concentrated sulfuric acid? JK! Great post! :)
HyperReport 1 year ago
Cloudy Ammonia, is that a by product of the human body's beer recycling equipment?
gibbo675 1 year ago
If you turn the volume down you may get milk spots !
Thanks for the vid
FONZED
GuildF40 1 year ago
great to know with the milk spos, didn't know this, thanks
Supratube1 1 year ago
ARE YOU READING FROM A SCRIPT?
nlucctw2 1 year ago
@nlucctw2
Yeah, that's why I sound so different, and don't say "um" at all, and don't take 12 minutes to get through 5 minutes of information. I don't like how my voice sounds when I'm reading my prepared words, but it's necessary for some informational videos.
drutter 1 year ago 2
I have a giant white fingerprint on one of my maples that appeared a few weeks after I bought it. I really want to remove it.
BrutePUNKROCK 1 year ago
"We need a revolution where we change the role of government."
Government is not a problem solver its a problem creator, the people of the nation solve problems not our government.
davincij15 1 year ago
Thanks for the Info!
740roadking 1 year ago
Excellent! Thanks for the info!
Airave 1 year ago
Stop playing with your silver! You will be hairy palms! lol
When you pile up Maples up on top of each other and dump junk silver, you are scratching them up....... Maples get scratched so easily. When they sit in a tube, the weight is on the edges so its OK though. I have some big 10 oz Perth mint Year of the Tiger and Koala coins that I dont even take out of the capsules. The 5 oz proof Libertads are super nice too!
Zwikster 1 year ago
thank you, thank you.
MedicalMarijuanaMini 1 year ago
Its odd, I had a differnt milky white spots after playing with my coins for 5 minutes last night :-0
charlesfuchs 1 year ago
Good video Drutter, I knew the cause, now I know the remedy!
denmason 1 year ago
Great info Drutter about the milk spots on silver coins. Interesting about using erasers to clean the blemish
FreedomMeister 1 year ago
There are 69 "likes" for this video. Now what am i supposed to do.
81silvermj 1 year ago
Thanx to them 3 other folks and to you good buddy,....so much information out there!
qualqui 1 year ago
great coinzzzzz
cankorgbr 1 year ago
When he shows da porn, Dr. Utter is back!
143DREWID 1 year ago
Also, dont store your coins in PVC plastic like I did. I stored 100 maple leafs in cheap plastic bags and they left the milk spot residue in all of them after a few weeks. They do come off with silver cleaner and jewelery cloth as mentioned, but they will never be as good as they leave ultra-fine scratches. A coin of 9999 purity and proof finish should really leave the mint in its own casing as with the kooks.
simonty1811 1 year ago
Oh drutter, by the way. I noticed you have a lot of 2010 Olympic maples. You should put some on your website for crazy premiums. They fly off the shelf. I don't know why, maybe a lower mintage or more saught after but almost everywhere i go there sold out. Except Ebay.
SILVERpeasant1996 1 year ago 2
@SILVERpeasant1996
I managed to grab a handful of the 2010 "hockey" maples today when I was out at the dealers. I think I'll put them up on the site tomorrow, thanks for the suggestion.
drutter 1 year ago
2 dislikes? w t f. People who wanted the secret to stay to buy at a lower price then remove the spots? Dunno. People are whacked out.
ytgv3fc7 1 year ago
@SILVERpeasant1996 Really? Glad I got a bunch when I did (at the same price as regular Maples).
shaurz 1 year ago
Excellent , not that It matters to me personally , if my coin has a spot on it or not, good information for those that do.. later doc!
silverjunky999 1 year ago
I tried the eraser method and it works. But it does leave little blemish marks on it but better than those stupid milk spots. Thanks JezebelDecibel and thanks drutter. Keep stckin to both u guys. And buy Junk Silver when you can.PEACE
SILVERpeasant1996 1 year ago
I like the "on the previous episode of drutter" thing going on in this vid
argentcipher 1 year ago
i dump 2500 oz out on my bed and roll around naked on mine ,,,it feels good ,,try it
mathue7433 1 year ago
Thanks Drutter. I hope you are feeling great and your kids are well. take care + greetings from Spain, Beatriz....PS: it is a great pity that you donnot deliver internationally.
beatrizgf 1 year ago
@beatrizgf
I do ship internationally. I have less options for overseas buyers but I do have some. :)
Thank you for your comment!
drutter 1 year ago 2
good stuff!!!
smasila 1 year ago
Great video drutter! Thank you for sharing!
nmreich 1 year ago
Wow thanks Drutter and all the aforementioned contributors. Helps out a TON!
EdderCMG 1 year ago
Awesome video! Best one so far this year!
ImperfectCitizen 1 year ago
Thanks for making this Vid drutter.
TheSilverWatch 1 year ago
Love the pornyness at the end of the clip lool, thank you for the info btw :)
TheZippoCollector 1 year ago
BTW, my maples don't look as shiny as yours do. just the maple part is shiny.
JimbobOMG 1 year ago
I'm stackin!
JimbobOMG 1 year ago
FINALLY AN ANSWER TO THIS DREADED MYSTERY----THANKS A BUNCH-----I WILL TRY THIS THE NEXT CHANCE I GET
bigpaw64 1 year ago
Very cool video drutter!
stelmorVH 1 year ago
Thanks for the info!
dodoinurpants 1 year ago
Great review and yes it's great how we can share information through this medium.
I have gained so much valuable knowledge from all the wonderful Silver Bugs. Your all so respectful & helpful & it's almost hard to believe form an investment perspective. Basically I have so much more confidence in surviving the global economic fiat fiasco collapse. I have always love silver, but now I understand it on a deeper level.
JezebelDecibel 1 year ago
I've seen silver rounds with dark spots on them...what would that be from?
Great vids :)
MrAnguswangus 1 year ago
@MrAnguswangus
Dark spots on silver are almost always from tarnish, a chemical reaction between silver and sulfur from the air. I did a video on how to remove tarnish, about a year ago. Go to my channel and search my videos for "tarnish" and it'll show up. It's the one with 18,000 views.
drutter 1 year ago 2
NIce!!
And it just goes to show you, its always something.
If its not milky stains on yer silver, its a solution so simple, you'd never think of it.
A life lesson, IMO.
Never give up.
:)
davematherly 1 year ago
That was excellent, both the body of the work and the finale. Well done.
acuriousbeast 1 year ago
Teasing with Sativas! Oh you... you...!!!
:)
Austacker 1 year ago
damn canadian mint! its the only coins ive had a problem with i beleive its a QC problem.
detectingupstate 1 year ago
@detectingupstate due to budgetary concerns, they've eliminated their spot checkers.
davematherly 1 year ago
Nice "END THE FED" coin at the very end :)
endlessmountain 1 year ago 10
@endlessmountain Indeed Bro!
jimbobubbadj 1 year ago
@endlessmountain every coin should have that around the edges. do a video on them I reckon
ricochetVendetta 1 year ago
Excellent video, Drutter. Thanks for the info. Take care.
TheSmooveZ 1 year ago
excellent!
combatjm89 1 year ago
Those wipes work great. It would be intesting to know what they are steeped with.
goedeck1 1 year ago
@goedeck1 They don't say but it is listed as Non Toxic on every brand that I have seen.
JezebelDecibel 1 year ago
sweet !
artdeco101010 1 year ago
First comment! It gets pretty porny at 4:09 !!!! :) VERY porny !
rightsideofhistory 1 year ago 8
@rightsideofhistory LOL, my exact same thought!!! Ya gotta luv drutter's SILVER PORN! ; )
qualqui 1 year ago