Added: 3 years ago
From: HeidiMOfficial
Views: 66,673
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (794)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • it sounds better coming out of a beauty like heidi unlike that monster with a big nose. its sad that people hate her because of her surgeries, just because you cant afford to be beautiful like her <3

  • Way better than that ugly tranny Lady Gaga. Heidi Montag is a flawless goddess sent from heaven but Lady Gaga is an ugly smelly whore who can't even sing. How dare she try to match Heidi's angelic voice. FUCK LADY GAGA. I HOPE SHE DIES AND ALL HER UGLY FAT FANS TOO!

  • @JStamCasual I hope you know that LADY GAGA wrote this song. If Heidi's as good as you say, why has she sung this 'awful' song? Why didn't she write her own song?

    Why can't people be free to listen to the singers they want? This world is so unfair. People are so stupid.

  • What are "stalettos"? 

  • @HarukaLoveBird high heels 

  • @MrSmokeyhell Yes, those are "stilettos", but Heidi is pronouncing the word wrong.

  • i'm gonna give it to Heidi, purely for the fact that she shouts her own name at the start!! hahahahaha genius!!

  • I can't believe Gaga gave this song to Heidi.

  • gaga rulez

  • lady gaga version is the best

    

  • i hate spencer and this song Lady Gaga 4ever

  • @DaneerSauter Haha, well I'm glad to put a grin on a face.

    :)

  • what is this i read a book called gaga and it lead me to this :O she says everything jacked up :P

  • Keep that bitch away from music. She's an untalented mess.

    ... And how dare Spencer Pratt claim that "Lady Gaga is repulsive!" and "Heidi's a far more talented artist, and her version of 'Fashion' kills Lady Gaga's."

    Artist...? Far from. Sorry to break it to you, but you need to get your head out of your ass.

    ;)

  • Comment removed

  • @mooninquirer gaga Did.. heidi is just re-doing it.

  • Who was FIRST with this song, Gaga or Heidi ?

  • @mooninquirer

    Lady Gaga wrote it - Heidi sung it - then Lady Gaga sung it for "Confessions of a Shopaholic".

  • @ChocolateChad127 Did Red One produce the sound ? The lyrics are fine, but it is HOW they are sung that really gives this song its kick, its musical hook.

  • @mooninquirer No idea... I think so...

  • Gaga all the way ;)

    Heidi her french is annoying , and she thinks she is better than gaga :D

    nooo GAGA IS SO MUCH BETTER :)

    ps . im not a heidi hater , i just say what i think ;)

  • To be honest, i don't like this song but oder people might. But, guys, Lady gaga made this song for heidi. heidi didn't...

  • Heidi rocks!!! I like her version better, lady gaga should change her style to something decent.

  • heidi may have sang it first but gaga wrote it

  • My god, autotune cant even help this girl. 

  • heidi sang this song first get a life!!!

  • @GlitterAshlee God you get a life... im not gonna waste my time with you cuz you obviously doesnt have good ears....Heidi version sucks and theirs a lot of people agreeing with me sooo ciao

  • @missfoolosophy yea a lot of people cause they dont liek her but obviously heidi is better than gaga's shit fuck ya hater!!

  • @GlitterAshlee Ehmm, no the fuck she didn't.

    You're a fuckin' dumbass twat and the fact that you're telling people to get a life is HILARIOUS. It's amazing how dumb I know you are by reading a couple comments on youtube. That really says A LOT about your level of intelligence.

  • @CSh311 you did the same :D

  • Are you serious she tried to sang it the same way has ladyy gaga please heidi take some singing classes ... but i love superficial!!!!

  • This is disgusting. By the way, who is she aha?

  • WTF? Dude, it's like you're singing a freakin drunk version of Fashion.

  • Wow. Horrible. Simply horrible.

  • ok let me just start this off #1 gaga is way times 2000 better than heidie number 2 heidie have you ever heard of singing lessons and number three gaga just hit the charts not to long ago and shes way more famous shes had 2 tours and two amzing albums come on hidie oh and by the way 141 people missed the dislike button thats right i went there

  • she tries too hard! guess her boobs werent the only thing that needed professional help! Cudos to who ever made her sound the tinest good!

  • Better than gaga

  • @LibertineLover07 ok loll ... youre right ! can you compare ?! gaga is singing idk what hiedi is doing here .

  • wtfff shes so dumb ,,, taking gaga song and sing it .... we understand you love the song but you didnt need to recorded .......... that really lame

  • @missfoolosophy get a life before comment please just see the history of the song heidi sang this before gaga and its really good like it or not this is the first version and its betters than gaga because heidi's voice its more thin than gaga's.....:@@

  • Comment removed

  • @missfoolosophy i dint fuckin say that gaga has no talent she has a lot more than heidi but i said this was the first version just look at wikipedia the history...i prefer this version gaga is shit she destroed music she is just an insane idiot!!Heidi i love yaa!!!

  • you all hate on it...... it's just a song..... who cares if she's a dumb ho..... it's a cute song & lady gaga's version is good 2. they're both good. neither of them are SPECTACULAR AMAZING SONGS WITH TALENT!!!! I mean for christ sake it's about shoes & clothes & saying you are what you wear and it's the most shallow lyrics i've ever heard. but i like the song cuz it's just a song. like who cares who it's by. If the beat's good, I like it.... & it is & I do.

  • Comment removed

  • GaGa has talent. This person ruined it. GaGa FTW

  • Gaga's version is WWWWAAAAAYYYY better than this crap

  • HEIDI=BEAUTIFULL

    GAGA=TALENTED

    FASHION BY GAGA IS BETTER BUT HEIDI IS HOT!

  • i hate how she says stilettos and her french is bad...i like gaga's better but this one is good too :D

  • like the lyrics

  • HATE GAGA LOVE HEIDI!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @GlitterAshlee DUMB ASS!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @GlitterAshlee wow ur stupid heidi is a plastic barbie gaga expresses herself

  • @GlitterAshlee obviously you don't know good music you retard

  • @islandgirl141 i rather gaga's but it's her opinion we all like different things not everyone's gonna like what you do

  • Wow. With Heidi Montag, who needs Kidz Bop to ruin songs?

  • Ahhhhhhh my ears have been killed.

  • shes just trying her best give her achance gosh

  • @ktarverstudent1 lets not...we all gave kidzbop a chance and look what they've done to good music

  • @missciara323 mmm your right but as long as they had the chance but .... it does not work out

  • Wow, this sucks dick. She's basically having sex with autotune. And her French sucks...

  • @Ravaenia you dont have to say comments like that but its just lady gaga has more experience in singing

  • This song written by Gaga and RedOne for Heidi Montag

  • @Diamond2711 ur wrong its oppisite lady gaga co wrote it

  • @ktarverstudent1 honey, know you facts, this song was written by lady gaga and RedONe! NOT heidi!

  • @DiaN1N1w really 

  • she sucks

  • Not as good as gaga

  • gaga's version is waay better than this..

  • this is her song not lady gaga's song look at wikipedia and you will see thats her song and its great hate gaga's version!!!Heidi's voice is so great love it!!!!

  • @TheAshleelover actually i searched and lady gaga co-wrote it whit khayat nadir. Don't know if you know but Heidi's voice is fixed and by computer is like T-pain you can buy an microphone and sound like them...my dad bought one once and he sounded like T-pain we were all like what the heck happend!!! LOL Take care.

  • she screamed "HEIDI" at mark of 0:13 haha. the song isn't even hers. lol. and she don't have to scream "HEIDI" because this already has her name written all over her. haha who else will make a mess like this? "HEIDI" lol

  • @joshie1226 haahha :P

    no she didn;t she screamed : HEY!!!!

  • LMFAO! ARE U SERIOUS????? LIKE.....REALLY???? OMG! GAGA IS WAAAAAAAAYYYYYYY BETTER THAN THIS PLASTIC BITCH!! @mattzifrom95 I COMPLETELY AGREE WITH YOU....GAGA THIS DISASTER PIECE OF SHIT.....INTO THE MARVELOUS ART THAT WE LITTLE MONSTERS LISTEN TO..... GAGA FOREVER!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @biggsr06 OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i got a headaque literally!! Gaga made it so classy yet fashion, like if she was really walking thru the streets of france and italy etc...Heidi sounds like the popular girl in the shower trying to sing all exited and end up breaking her tea cup..... I would not call myself a little monster but in this ocassion 100% agreed Gaga forever!!!

  • @SherryBlack95 Your arguments would be far more valid if you spelled things correctly. Just sayin'.

  • @Euroniaa well excuse me 'cause i don't fit in your perfect "writing" world...just saying. but to start i don't speek to much english so I'm trying to do as best as I can. Your argument is to tell people what they did wrong whit out knowing them and that's not right...take care and have a good day.

  • Heidi is much better than Gaga

  • @xConverseAllstar no offence but i don't see what you hear better...everyone has different opinion and in my opinion it sounds fake anyways Take Care

  • Actually, to be completely honest, i really like this version also. Yes i agree Lady GaGa sounds MUCH BETTER than Heidi Montag with this song, but I'd like to see you guys get a record deal and sing to this song!

  • @xantam65 Sing me up I'll do it!!!!! but i'll try to sing it like LG cause un my opinion heidi's was bad because to start is all fixed...and i don't like fake things

  • i really like this song, i know she can't sing, but i like it...verry verry much

  • gaga turned this disaster into a masterpeice :)

  • @mattzifrom95 AGREED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!! do i need more exclamation points LOL you are right Lady Gaga actually used voice and made it sound classy (thsi is the example: Gaga= the pretty nerd girl that can sing and amazed everyone......... Heidi= the high school prom queen trying to sing LOL Take Care

  • maybe she should have plastic surgery on her vocal cords? :-)

  • HEIDI CANT SING

  • Lady Gaga is so much better than heidi she cant sing x

  • gaga is 100000000000000000000000000000­000000000000000000x beter. WE HATE SPEIDI! p.s kijk dit clipje; speidi free van parody.;p

  • I LOVE THIS SONG... then I heard this version.

    Its cool when Lady Gaga does it, but when she sings it, its kind of sad because you guys all know this is how she TRULY feels...

  • where did u got the song? where did u download it??

  • this is gagas song

  • Gaga's version is BEAST. this one is so autotune! but i do like the french part

  • lady gagas version is so much better than this shit

  • She sounds like Lady Gaga mixed with Ashley Tisdale. Weird.

    She's not too bad. I definitely liked her looks before she got the

    10 plastic surgeries in one sitting.

  • @MixxelPixxel And whats funny is that she was being interviewed, and was like "If I was addicted to plastic surgery, I would've gotten, like, 10 surgeries at once"

  • i love both versions.

    and heidi is amazing. :]

    people need to stop being such bitches -.- seriously, are we like 12?

  • there are some fucking nasty EVIL harsh people on youtube! why does everyone bitch about her!!! ? she is a fucking person!!!! she has a life family and friends who love her . its absaloutley discusting everyone putting her down and comparing! god get a grip

  • @Khalgourlay but its shit and we have the same rights to share our opinion as people saying 'shes amazing' n shs a person? omg :O i never knew that....

  • I like both versions :l

  • MAKE IT STOOOOPPPP!!

  • @TheCaliforniaboy1 U Saying Make it stop Dont type Her Name Its so simple

    MORON

  • ew.

  • who would do such a thing?!? Dx

    is this rly for real?hahaha this is fuckin HIGHlarious!awh man heidi,stick to what u know best...(nothing)

  • stick to reality tv heidi.

    stop messing up songs

  • OMG! Hate the crazy Barbie Nip/Tuck addict! Screw her! uhuuu lalala me love Miss Gaga! <3 <3 <3 Heidi can got to hell!

  • you butchered the lyricsss

  • i hate her french, its sounds really ugly, gaga has a better flow

  • I dont think there is french in this, i think it sounds french but they are naming designers lol but your right

  • @Tomthestarhartnell yupp hehe you knew what i ment =DDD

  • I like it but Gaga is better

  • aaahhh!!!!! this is goin to kill me if i listen anymore!!!!! GOTTA HEAR GAGA NOW!!!

  • this is sooooo bad! what the hell.

    lady gaga<33333333

  • Heidi ur amazing <33

    I LOVEE YAA

  • heidi sings bad she messed up the song

  • this almost made me cryy D':

    she killed the song hahaha!

    heidi sounds like a badly tuned robot.

    LADY GAGA ALL THE WAY!! <3

  • lmao agreed!

  • check out the dodgy implants on the first picture.. haha

  • LMFAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO. wow. heidi you are retarded. gaga is 10000000000000000x better.

  • @gagamazing couldn't agree more lol

  • i do like this version...

  • i need to hear gaga. now.

  • Ok guys you are very dumb! RedOne & Lady GaGa wrote this song for HEIDI BLAIR MONTAG-PRATT, later in 2008 Lady GaGa covered it for the movie "Confessions Of A Shopaolic" and her version received best criticisms. Honestly I love both versions.

  • omg she even says red wine like lady gaga bitch she is a horrible singer

  • @sandyambersalem

    She says "RedOne" which is the producer of the song.

  • haha seriously "red wine" haha

  • She says "RedOne" which is the producer.

  • Salad Toes.

    Nuff sed.

  • this dumbass should of never covered this song how can she even put herself in the same catagory as lady gaga.

  • What is this shit?

  • gaga's version is wayy better!

  • i actually like both versions of this song. well I like heidi's version a lil better. i could care less how much thumbs down i get, because thats my opinion, and people r too bitchy nowadays to think outside their box. soo thats whoever gives this a thumbs down. payyyceeee

  • what the hell is so special about this song and whoever sings it? it could'v been done in a bar back in the 80s fricken plastic and no soul

  • Comment removed

  • Oh my fuck. She sucks ass.The only reason why this abombination saw the light of day is because RedOne and Gaga gave it her and she took it, listend to the original and tried to copy exactly what Gaga did. Too bad for Heidi anyway, Gaga re-recorded it and it got featured on a soundtrack and film. HAHA BITCH!

  • Gaga owns Heidi sucks ass...

  • Comment removed

  • I think Lady Gaga just gave it to her, because she felt sorry for her dumbass. :D

  • @kaaaaleb100142 i like lady gaga and your stupid lady gaga wrote it and she wasent even famous yet wen gaga gave it to her so

  • i think Gaga only gave it to her b/c she doesn't plan on recording it for herself. just like when she gave fever to adam lambert, her old songs just don't suit her new lifestyle, think you guys all this was before the fame and look what cam out of the fame....the fame monster. Gaga is constantly evolving as artists should, why would she record old music from before her debut album when she has new inspiration.

  • ooh no way.

    she souldn't be singing..

    and if she is singing this is so not the right song for her...

  • dude wtf??? she is TERRIBLE!!!! this is GaGa's song... y did she give it to this bitch??? SHUT THE FUCK UP

  • btw. Lady GaGa/RedOne gave this song to Heidi. So plz shut the fuck up. I also love GaGa, but if she gave it to her you should be bitching about it.

  • I like Heidi, and I don't care. : D

  • the effects on this sounded like they cost 10 pounds!

  • wow she cant sing at all and shes so fukin ugly

  • What the fuck? This is stupid! Heidi cannot sing! Lady Gaga is WAY better! Heidi isn't even fashionable, the tramp look like she shops at Target. &What the fuck is that she says before she shouts her name? She sounds like a fucking dragon, but that's my opinion. Which in most cases, it over rules everybody elses. [:

  • hahaha, LADY GAGA SOUNDS AHELL OF ALOT BETTER.! HEIDI CAN'T FUCKING SING, THATS AUTO-TUNE. LOLZ

  • find herbs yet

  • hey guys lets all go find some herbs hahahahaha

  • bahahahahahahhahah lmao.

  • 0:12 "HEEEEY" is so ugly! jaja

  • actually shes says Heidi haha i think so :P

  • jeje it's okey but it still awfull :P thanks for let me know i speak spanish:P

    y esto es horrible! :P

  • aa jajaj yo tambien hablo español!

  • awful horrible disgusting!

  • lmaoo i am a fan of heidi but LMFAOO she fails at this

  • she obviously doesn't speak french :/

  • at least when lady gaga sings it, it doesnt sound like a dying animal.

  • heidi is just horrible ! idk why she and spencer wrote a book on how to be famous. . .they even said it on t.v that they're wanna bes

  • This SUCKS!!! Lady gaga is 100000000000 times better!. Sorry Heidi but u CAN'T sing!

  • @Bella24745

    well she's Hotter.. can't say miss Germanotta has a better look than her.. no we cant' please..

  • its J'adore vivienne la vie et moi, gucci,fendi et prada, valentino amani too, merde i love them jimmy choo

  • yu got the lyrics wrong!

  • wow. she cant sing. at all. she sounds like a horse. and in the begining why does she say HEIDI! wtf. sounds like such a valley girl.

  • its funny because it must hurt because lady gaga wrote the song for her, but then Lady gaga went and recorded it soooo much better LOL

  • This version is laughable compared to Lady Gaga's.

  • is she the original ?or lady gaga?