I dont like this one at all, typical voice style, kills the mood and the essence of the song. Nothing outstanding to say about the voice either, she doesnt control her volume well and in some parts doesnt even breathe properly.
i get chills still from this, Katie Noonan's cover was our wedding song that I walked down the isle to....means so much to us, i will never tire hearing it
Other than Peter Frampton's cover, this is the only other cover I've heard that is worthy of being listened to. I'm a huge Soundgarden fan, and normally I prefer the loud in your face version with Matt, Kim, Ben and Chris, but this is equally as good if you're in the mood to hear something with a little more mellow feel. Her voice control is amazing and I love her take on the bridge portion around 2:13. All I can say is incredible!
loved her since George days got every album and been told i look alot like her a very big compliment she influences me greatly and shes a fellow brisbanite!!!
first cover of this song (after the one cornell did) that i like, and i guess it's because nobody can get the emotion that chris wanted to give through this song except for her, she's awesome
@Shaung1231 She is pretty amazing hey. She's done some beautiful covers and awesome original stuff. The Captains is her current band. Enjoy finding more of her stuff : )
Very nice! Brava!!
lancethrustworthy 1 month ago
love the "gulp" at 1:19
TopHatDrumming 5 months ago 5
anyone who thinks this is typical or not quite up to par should check to see if they have a pulse at all...this is phenomenal!
TopHatDrumming 5 months ago 2
where can i get this cover?
tinynanobots 6 months ago
@tinynanobots this cover was included on Katie's single CD of "Time to Begin." Haven't seen it for download but you could try iTunes? :)
puscifier11 5 months ago
Comment removed
tinynanobots 6 months ago
I dont like this one at all, typical voice style, kills the mood and the essence of the song. Nothing outstanding to say about the voice either, she doesnt control her volume well and in some parts doesnt even breathe properly.
Hematemesis 6 months ago
@Hematemesis thanks for sharing your opinion, I agree that Katie is an acquired taste. Each to their own :)
puscifier11 5 months ago
@Hematemesis lol
ned2one 3 months ago
@ned2one IKR? Yet another clueless youtube comment (on their part, not you).
solley08 2 months ago
@Hematemesis moron.
gronk007 2 weeks ago
i get chills still from this, Katie Noonan's cover was our wedding song that I walked down the isle to....means so much to us, i will never tire hearing it
kirazstar1 7 months ago 6
@kirazstar1 your wedding song was Black Hole Sun?! That would have been a fucking awesome wedding!!! Glad this brought back some memories for you :)
puscifier11 7 months ago 6
awsome awsome awsome
llewhicks 7 months ago 3
Other than Peter Frampton's cover, this is the only other cover I've heard that is worthy of being listened to. I'm a huge Soundgarden fan, and normally I prefer the loud in your face version with Matt, Kim, Ben and Chris, but this is equally as good if you're in the mood to hear something with a little more mellow feel. Her voice control is amazing and I love her take on the bridge portion around 2:13. All I can say is incredible!
joncooke83 9 months ago 3
jesus christ i immediately get shivers right when this girl starts singing. Special voice and a beautiful version of a classic song.
Kaitamaski 9 months ago 2
WoW how amazing would it be if Chris and Katie did a duet - OMG IMO
cybermob 9 months ago 2
loved her since George days got every album and been told i look alot like her a very big compliment she influences me greatly and shes a fellow brisbanite!!!
jetz84 10 months ago 2
2 people can't hear their names through the cream
puscifier11 10 months ago
@puscifier11 you're right!!
MissSchattig 9 months ago 2
what an arrangement!
samansun 1 year ago 2
Ohmygod this is beautiful. I love the original, but this is great. <3
-Mackenzie xoxoxoxoxo
TheLegionOfSeven 1 year ago 3
first cover of this song (after the one cornell did) that i like, and i guess it's because nobody can get the emotion that chris wanted to give through this song except for her, she's awesome
leajerokerica 1 year ago
im so glad she did this cover. the one she did with glen shorock on rockwiz was pretty terrible... i knew she could do better.
lachlunn 1 year ago
GREAT cover
kajjagoogoo 1 year ago 3
Best female cover I have found on this song
101pumpkin101 1 year ago 9
This is a beautiful cover.
AngelCifuEngasaoM 1 year ago
such a great voice I love the original version and this too!!
this one is very relaxing.... ^_^
meriecurie 1 year ago
@Shaung1231 She is pretty amazing hey. She's done some beautiful covers and awesome original stuff. The Captains is her current band. Enjoy finding more of her stuff : )
puscifier11 1 year ago 4
beautiful voice
samuelpunkska 1 year ago 4
her voice is sooo beautiful
00freakofnature00 1 year ago 3
She is a national treasure
paul55604 1 year ago 20
Katie's voice is a beautiful melodic blanket that keeps my musical soul warm. Love her!!
DolceBesos 1 year ago 4
that looks awesome!!
wildc005 2 years ago 4