The study they cite is very real, but misleading. Since it only accommodated cats who had been rushed into hospital after the fall, it failed to account for any and all cats who fell from 7+ (or indeed any number of floors) and... splashed, or in some other way were too obviously dead to benefit from a hospital visit.
In other words, we don't actually know that the survival graph somehow peaks at seven floors. We only know that, generally speaking, cats can and do survive falling very far.
FYI this video is wrong. The veterinary study he refers to was later proven invalid. The problem was a sampling error. When the veterinaries had fewer instances of dying cats from high floors they wrongly concluded the cats had parachuted. In fact when cats fell from very high floors they typically died on the spot, so they never went to the vet to be counted in the first place! This is a classic example of how to lie with statistics.
alan davies and ben from outnumbered are so alike(they both have curly black hair and are both adorable!)! SECRET LOVE-CHILD is that a possibility??? lol
I'm shocked QI didn't pick up on the major criticism of this study.
This study is based on injury reports taken from vets, but they fail to take in a crucial point; if your cat dies in a manner that is obvious (Let's say it's literally in pieces), you WOULDN'T TAKE IT TO THE VET. So the statistics might just show the level at which cats become so *overtly* dead that their owners don't bother taking them to the vets.
Well, what else can they go on? It's not like they can do a general scientific study where they fly cats up to about 1000 feet or so and chuck them out of a helicopter, is it?
The study they cite is very real, but misleading. Since it only accommodated cats who had been rushed into hospital after the fall, it failed to account for any and all cats who fell from 7+ (or indeed any number of floors) and... splashed, or in some other way were too obviously dead to benefit from a hospital visit.
In other words, we don't actually know that the survival graph somehow peaks at seven floors. We only know that, generally speaking, cats can and do survive falling very far.
OlleLindestad 8 months ago 4
there are 50,000 skydivers in the world going.....I'll cat sit!
00Billy 10 months ago
Perhaps the ground floor?
Craamron 10 months ago
The first buzzer is a song called "kick Mississippi"
TheGamingWaffle 11 months ago
The person that commented about the statistical error is correct. Dead cats don't go to veterinary clinics.
savetheguineaworm 11 months ago
f***ing cat people!
ByteAGig 1 year ago
made the mistake of taking a sip of my tea right before alan began to parachute
Kodetsu 1 year ago 5
I like cats
cyanman123 1 year ago 2
FYI this video is wrong. The veterinary study he refers to was later proven invalid. The problem was a sampling error. When the veterinaries had fewer instances of dying cats from high floors they wrongly concluded the cats had parachuted. In fact when cats fell from very high floors they typically died on the spot, so they never went to the vet to be counted in the first place! This is a classic example of how to lie with statistics.
you12bme 1 year ago 13
*Storey
jacksawild 1 year ago
The title of this video really creeped me out and I was scared to play it! Thank God it wasn't about what I thought it was!
Rachiejane1 1 year ago 3
i live on the 7th floor..
CherryTripping 1 year ago
I still say the first floor would be safer. :)
singedrac 1 year ago
Oh God, I can't stop laughing.
DeliriousGoomba 1 year ago
Not sure John Sessions' hair is terribly convincing...
mwallaby 1 year ago
I am a cat person and I never would harm a cat but when he siad " or pushed" I luaghed my ass off
DekuTreeOfKokiri 1 year ago
"the mad letter i get from $%&£?/^ cat people" haha
lookatwig 2 years ago 17
Great eh?
lennic95 2 years ago
alan's so cute in this
LowSweetChariot 2 years ago 10
has anyone got a cat or maybe one from each floor
chelseylizzie 2 years ago
fucking cat people
crazytosh1 2 years ago 6
alan davies and ben from outnumbered are so alike(they both have curly black hair and are both adorable!)! SECRET LOVE-CHILD is that a possibility??? lol
TVloverXx 2 years ago 3
@TVloverXx
I always thought alan davies and dylan moran were long lost twins, or at least clones. (again, mainly due to their hair and adorable-ness)
MyNoLifeQueen 1 year ago
Anyone else wonder how Clive knew so accurately the behaviors of cats thrown out of windows?
WilliamJazzCat 2 years ago 5
I'm going to have a guess and say that he probably reads things
8GrolschMan8 2 years ago 9
Comment removed
WilliamJazzCat 2 years ago
He reads.. things. Well I certainly hadn't entertained that possibility...
WilliamJazzCat 2 years ago
he's a smart guy, with a bald head?
Galacticmaster 2 years ago
Alan Davies last comment was pretty adorable
miklosh3 2 years ago
I think it was meant cases as in instances,not crates.
teufelstaub 2 years ago
I Love how Alan always acts everything out... Cracks me up
Botation 2 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm shocked QI didn't pick up on the major criticism of this study.
This study is based on injury reports taken from vets, but they fail to take in a crucial point; if your cat dies in a manner that is obvious (Let's say it's literally in pieces), you WOULDN'T TAKE IT TO THE VET. So the statistics might just show the level at which cats become so *overtly* dead that their owners don't bother taking them to the vets.
For shame, QI. General ignorance indeed.
BenjaminBattington 2 years ago
....pardon me?
EvilAtria 2 years ago
Well, what else can they go on? It's not like they can do a general scientific study where they fly cats up to about 1000 feet or so and chuck them out of a helicopter, is it?
aimsme 2 years ago 2
In secrecy at nite, all over the world, cats are parachuting from buildings!
Imagine that lol
metcoNepraC 2 years ago 16
Frighteningly enough, I can see that happening...
LittleBoiFen 2 years ago 4
132 cases of cats?
How'd they get the cats into all of those cases?
And why would someone throw a case of cats out a window?
LittleBoiFen 2 years ago 15
lol XD
spotlitkiss 2 years ago 4
oh har har
pizzafreak54 2 years ago
I see what you did there.
KonijNx2 2 years ago
Schrodinger's parachute. :<
YubiShines 2 years ago 8
Why didn't Clive get any points? He pretty much nailed it. :-/
JahJahDisciple 2 years ago 9
Anyone else notice a high pitched whine in the audio of this clip?
Zbobman 2 years ago 9
yes. its boderline painful if u cnt stand high pitched noises
boredndmad 2 years ago
"fucking CAT people" hahahahahahah
itsashamblesbaby 3 years ago 15
I love the looks on their faces when Stephen Fry begins his long, protracted explanation of cats and terminal velocity.
singinginachurch 3 years ago 7
lol - they look genuinely intrigued!
spotlitkiss 3 years ago 5
Wouldn't you be?
LittleBoiFen 2 years ago
"because of the letters i get of fucking cat people" xD i love him
StarGSB 3 years ago 90
*hiccup* Our cat fell from the 7th floor and survived. Not one injury...just, dirty. She's white :D
kikuilu 3 years ago 8
now i want a cat. (for scientific reasons) =P
SlaptasGokas 3 years ago 86
You can have mine! She's an evil minx.
PheatherP 3 years ago 7
what was with the nokia phone tune at the start?
PaintSniffer07 3 years ago 7
It was the buzzer sound
evilaelf 3 years ago 25
Surely the best would be the first floor.
Mashirafen 3 years ago
Depends on your definition of 'best.' :3
RubyCosmos 3 years ago
Haha , yeah , oh i love QI its soo funny !
whoseliner44 3 years ago
Surely the best would not to be to throw it at all lol.
Raindownuk 3 years ago 9
very funny ep
angs12345 4 years ago
lol
darkdeath666 4 years ago
i <3 QI, i bust a gut at every episode! <33
instantsushi 4 years ago 9