Gerard Butler's voice might not be as "refined" as Crawford's, but IMO, Butler's has more genuine anger/feeling at the climax ("♪You will curse the day...♫").
Just thought I'd add that this scene is one of the only scenes I actually enjoy from the movie/musical - so my opinion is from a non-fan perspective. So basically you ruined the only scene I enjoy in the movie by over-dubbing my favorite part of this scene (which was masterfully done in its original state)...just sayin'
Michael Crawford recorded All I Ask of You thinking his part in Phantom of the Opera was Raoul. Sir Andrew Lloyd Webber told him you are hired as the Phantom.
Comment removed
TTempahsBanginTunes 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Gerard Butler's voice might not be as "refined" as Crawford's, but IMO, Butler's has more genuine anger/feeling at the climax ("♪You will curse the day...♫").
Just thought I'd add that this scene is one of the only scenes I actually enjoy from the movie/musical - so my opinion is from a non-fan perspective. So basically you ruined the only scene I enjoy in the movie by over-dubbing my favorite part of this scene (which was masterfully done in its original state)...just sayin'
LRBScarecrow 3 months ago
Comment removed
LRBScarecrow 3 months ago
Indeed, but still, what a voice at the end!
megabulle 3 months ago
What magic is this?
BarrageofDS 3 months ago
I prefer Gerard Butler to Crawford...to me Crawford's voice is creepy, which I guess is good for Phantom. I still love Butler's voice though.
crosscountrytc 5 months ago
Masterfully done!
Penfoldy90 7 months ago
this video was very artistictly made, the music was outstanding
lori3456 8 months ago
its not micheal crawford. its gerald butler
zeevacat320 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
actually, its not micheal crawford. its gerald butler.
zeevacat320 8 months ago
actually, its not micheal crawford. its gerald butler.
zeevacat320 8 months ago
Michael Crawford recorded All I Ask of You thinking his part in Phantom of the Opera was Raoul. Sir Andrew Lloyd Webber told him you are hired as the Phantom.
caprice6 2 years ago
Michael CrawfOrd>???????
gothpi 2 years ago
@gothpi Yes, Michael Crawford.
TheaterRaven 2 years ago
what charakter dOes he make?
gothpi 2 years ago
@TheaterRaven aam...NOo....it's Gerard Butler!!!!!!
gothpi 8 months ago
@gothpi The movie is obviously Gerard Butler, but I meant the AUDIO is Michael Crawford. It's Michael singing.
TheaterRaven 8 months ago
@TheaterRaven well then this is extremely weird.......cause I have the audioo with gerard butler..hah---anyway...amazing song (L)
gothpi 8 months ago
@gothpi is awesome.
Ikswotnerkop 8 months ago
patrick wilson is ok when he sings in this movie. he is much much better when he sings live.
unclelance 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Patrick Wilson is such a dreadful singer.
TheAntiPleb 3 years ago
:) To each their own. I happen to like him.
TheaterRaven 3 years ago