@MrMcGale So you're still in school, ok good for you, stay in it, I'm done, there's a difference between a mature adult with fact based knowledge and a stubborn child with misconstrued opinions. if you're so mature then go ahead and read up on the facts I mentioned before (like the belief in Separation of Church and State in the original Punk movement) instead of just trying to discredit a proven historical fact with your "because I said so" attitude. Have a good day and good luck.
@MrMcGale Now the only conclusion I can draw from your necessity to mention homosexuality 100x in arepeteadly in a conversation that has nothing to do with sexual preference is that you have issues with your own sexuality, perhaps you have an urge to come out the closet and you feel as if talking about gays with people who simply don't care at all about the topic is your way to reasurre yourself. If that's the case then you might want to look for a video where homosexuality is the ACTUAL topic.
@MrMcGale I have every right to speak however I want. I am just giving you an honest piece of advice. It is obvious that sexual preference is a topic that you seem to be very interested in discussing, but this is obviously not the place to discuss it as no one here cares about it, this video was supposed to be about a good song and nothing more, I hope that the poster of this vid deletes all our comments anyways.
@MrMcGale And seeing as how there are ABSOLUTELY NO PUNK BANDS left in your generation, I have to call your claim of there being "Homosexual Punk Bands" and "punk has changed a bit" A PURE LIE. There isn't anything Punk anymore, but I wouldn't expect a Good Charlotte fan to understand that (no need to deny it, it's right there on your channel).
@MrMcGale Now since I know you have trouble understanding basic English I'll define establishment for you. It's a group that controls governmental, social, or religious institution, such as the U.S. Government and the Roman Catholic Church, which is what Punk Rock protested against. Now stop talking about "how Punk works" and "anarchy", it's obvious you're clueless. Punk was a movement that occurred and died long before you were even born, and there are no longer any punk bands around.
P.S. I'm not trusting the internet with anything, I've provided facts, not hearsay. It's just amusing to discuss Anarchy or Punk Rock with someone who refers to Good Charlotte as the "realest band" he's ever heard. That's like discussing Gangster Rap with Vanilla Ice, no offense but that's just the way it is, and I'm not going to be a hypocrite about it. If that's what you enjoy, then have a good day, lets leave it at that. And out of curiosity, what "Punk Bands" do you know of with gay members?
@twitchmassacres I'm not a huge fan of Good Charlotte, and I never said they are "The realest band" I've ever heard. There are different ways to understand punk, you just have to admit it. And you say you've never heard of a Punk band with a one or more Homosexual people? Man, there's like...A lot.. of Different Punk bands in the world, and Punk has changed a bit.
@MrMcGale In no way shape or form have I mentioned them being against theology MEANING THE BELIEFS WITHIN RELIGION, they stood against the GOVERNING BODIES OF RELIGION which influence political decisions on a worldwide scale. Now I have also in no way shape or form mentioned homosexuality either, so why you brought that up is hilarious.
P.S. If you're getting angry over an argument is cause you're having a hard time admitting you're wrong. This is not about bullying or pissing you off. I'm just telling you what I know from years of study. I have a Masters in business administration, with a minor in finance and MUSIC Entrepreneurship & Production, I'm not throwing shit out of my ass here, I know what the fuck I'm talking about.
@MrMcGale The song "God Save the Queen" is about the separation of church and state, one of the big themes in Punk music, I suggest you read up on that. The lines "God save the Queen, We mean it man, We love our Queen, God saves" is making a mockery out of the inclusion of religion in political affairs. Another line commonly mocked by Punk music under the belief of the separation of church and state is "in God We Trust" as seen in American currency.
@MrMcGale Rude? And 12? Ok, it's ironic how you wanna talk to me about anarchy and have a Good Charlotte song up on your page. This conversation is over. To close this off again I'll repeat it for your sake, the Sex Pistols were an anti institutional punk band, MEANING they were against ALL FORMS OF POLITICS, meaning organized government AND organized religion, meaning religion as a organized entity, in other words, THE VATICAN AND THE ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH WHICH ARE POLITICAL POWERS.
@MrMcGale Are you illiterate or something? I can't do this shit all day kid, I write something in plain English and still you have no ability to comprehend it. Did I say the Sex Pistols were "a screw up band that only follows religion"? Hahaha! No I didn't. Have I talked about "gays must die"? Again, no. My point, and I can't write it any simpler than this, so please try to understand something a first grader would, is that Punk Rock WAS an anti-establishment movement.
@MrMcGale Ok, but this isn't a fight at least on my part. What you don't seem to get is that there is no "Punk music style of today". If you think there is then why don't you go ahead and mention a Punk band? I can tell you this much, Good Charlotte, The All American Rejects, all the bands you mentioned in your original message aren't even 1% punk. Punk is dead, it has been dead for decades, sad but true, and you can thank bands like some of the ones you mentioned for burying it even deeper.
@twitchmassacres If that's what makes you finally silent. Then alright. And I know that "real" Punk died. And yeah, this was really pathetic of us to take over the comment section with our crap.
My point is, listen to what you like, be it good ol' Rock n' Roll or today's overproduced Hot Topic clad clowns, just don't try to Label them with old dead movements that they can't represent even if they had instructions tatted on their bellies. Most of the bands you mentioned that attempt to emulate or are often erroneously labeled with the words "Emo", "Punk", or "Hardcore" are actually just Pop artists.
@MrMcGale As to "Hardcore Punk" that was just a term coined to bands (such as Bad Religion) that were attempting, albeit unsuccessfully, to honestly resuscitate the already dead punk movement. But the term itself is a joke (see the term "Hardcore" prior to the word "Punk" is proof of that, as the real Hardcore movement was a straight-edge movement and totally unrelated to Punk).
@twitchmassacres We have very different ear flows of music, friend. I don't hate you, and I don't even want to. Arguing will get someone angry quickly, and that's the least thing I want right now.
@MrMcGale I propose you do some research next time, you'll come to find that there aren't any Punk or Emo bands left in this world, in fact, the "Emo" never really got enough footing to become a real genre in the first place, the term was coined to describe indie rock bands who sang somewhat obnoxious songs about their feelings, bands like that are still around today (E.g. Bright Eyes) but they have nothing to do with the piece of shit trend that is considered emo nowadays.
@MrMcGale The bands you mentioned have nothing to do with neither punk nor Emo. Good Charlotte is the most grotesque example of a bunch of wannabes that have attempted to emulate Punk Rock but only achieved to turn it into a trend where you play the same 4 power chords and sing meaningless lyrics about being a angst ridden teen in high school (the stereotypical Hot Topic band), FFAF play Post-Hardcore, My Chemical Romance sings Pop Rock, as do the All American Rejects.
Back when emo wasn't just a synonym for bisexual kids in hit topic clothing squealing out bad pop rock songs. This was the real deal, a guitar, bass, drums, voice, and a broken heart. Nothing less... Nothing more...
@MrMcGale "Hardocore Punk"??? Hahahahahahahahahahahaaaaaaaaa... Let me tell you something about punk buddy, IT'S DEAD, and you probably weren't even around by the time it died. PUNK was The Clash, PUNK was The Sex Pistols. Punk was The Stooges, PUNK was a MOVEMENT, not just music, about breaking with the barriers and inhibitions formed by Government and Religion, and most of all PUNK had NOTING TO DO with Emo. In fact if there were any real punk bands left in the world they'd laugh at Emo.
@MrMcGale Wrong religion has everything to do with it. Not because they were interested in theology, on the contrary, it was because they stood against the establishment created by the Roman Catholic Church. Punk stood against all forms of government, and history has proven time and again that the most powerful, enduring, and damaging form of government has been organized religion. So you're wrong there as well.
@MrMcGale You people? Kid, what the fuck do you mean by "you people"? And what the hell are you asking me if I know what Anarchy is for? Do you? Cause you can spit out the dictionary definition all you like, that doesn't mean you know anything about it. As to saying that the Sex Pistols never stood against religion AS AN INSTITUTION, again I laugh at your misinformation.
@twitchmassacres Again, you are as rude an speak as childishly as a 12 years old. The dictionary explains nothing. Sex Pistols never were against Religion, but they weren't against Atheism or Homosexuality either. Don't trust the internet with things like Anarchy, it lies because it's programmed to put famous people under a good light... Could you just stop being so damn rude? When the carrot did I annoy you like that? =/
@MrmcGale and @twitchmassacres
I know that was 7 months ago I guess, but I'm just wondering if you guys have finished writing your novel by now? Holy Hell rofl!!
BuiltToSpill10 4 months ago
that's the real emocore e.e
i love this bands (jimmy eat world, fugazi,mineral...)and i hate the modern
"pop dark XD" bands jajaja
Akurineko 10 months ago
@MrMcGale So you're still in school, ok good for you, stay in it, I'm done, there's a difference between a mature adult with fact based knowledge and a stubborn child with misconstrued opinions. if you're so mature then go ahead and read up on the facts I mentioned before (like the belief in Separation of Church and State in the original Punk movement) instead of just trying to discredit a proven historical fact with your "because I said so" attitude. Have a good day and good luck.
twitchmassacres 11 months ago
@MrMcGale Now the only conclusion I can draw from your necessity to mention homosexuality 100x in arepeteadly in a conversation that has nothing to do with sexual preference is that you have issues with your own sexuality, perhaps you have an urge to come out the closet and you feel as if talking about gays with people who simply don't care at all about the topic is your way to reasurre yourself. If that's the case then you might want to look for a video where homosexuality is the ACTUAL topic.
twitchmassacres 11 months ago
Comment removed
MrMcGale 11 months ago
Comment removed
MrMcGale 11 months ago
@MrMcGale I have every right to speak however I want. I am just giving you an honest piece of advice. It is obvious that sexual preference is a topic that you seem to be very interested in discussing, but this is obviously not the place to discuss it as no one here cares about it, this video was supposed to be about a good song and nothing more, I hope that the poster of this vid deletes all our comments anyways.
twitchmassacres 11 months ago
@MrMcGale And seeing as how there are ABSOLUTELY NO PUNK BANDS left in your generation, I have to call your claim of there being "Homosexual Punk Bands" and "punk has changed a bit" A PURE LIE. There isn't anything Punk anymore, but I wouldn't expect a Good Charlotte fan to understand that (no need to deny it, it's right there on your channel).
twitchmassacres 11 months ago
Comment removed
MrMcGale 11 months ago
@MrMcGale Now since I know you have trouble understanding basic English I'll define establishment for you. It's a group that controls governmental, social, or religious institution, such as the U.S. Government and the Roman Catholic Church, which is what Punk Rock protested against. Now stop talking about "how Punk works" and "anarchy", it's obvious you're clueless. Punk was a movement that occurred and died long before you were even born, and there are no longer any punk bands around.
twitchmassacres 11 months ago
P.S. I'm not trusting the internet with anything, I've provided facts, not hearsay. It's just amusing to discuss Anarchy or Punk Rock with someone who refers to Good Charlotte as the "realest band" he's ever heard. That's like discussing Gangster Rap with Vanilla Ice, no offense but that's just the way it is, and I'm not going to be a hypocrite about it. If that's what you enjoy, then have a good day, lets leave it at that. And out of curiosity, what "Punk Bands" do you know of with gay members?
twitchmassacres 11 months ago
@twitchmassacres I'm not a huge fan of Good Charlotte, and I never said they are "The realest band" I've ever heard. There are different ways to understand punk, you just have to admit it. And you say you've never heard of a Punk band with a one or more Homosexual people? Man, there's like...A lot.. of Different Punk bands in the world, and Punk has changed a bit.
MrMcGale 11 months ago
@MrMcGale In no way shape or form have I mentioned them being against theology MEANING THE BELIEFS WITHIN RELIGION, they stood against the GOVERNING BODIES OF RELIGION which influence political decisions on a worldwide scale. Now I have also in no way shape or form mentioned homosexuality either, so why you brought that up is hilarious.
twitchmassacres 11 months ago
P.S. If you're getting angry over an argument is cause you're having a hard time admitting you're wrong. This is not about bullying or pissing you off. I'm just telling you what I know from years of study. I have a Masters in business administration, with a minor in finance and MUSIC Entrepreneurship & Production, I'm not throwing shit out of my ass here, I know what the fuck I'm talking about.
twitchmassacres 11 months ago
@MrMcGale The song "God Save the Queen" is about the separation of church and state, one of the big themes in Punk music, I suggest you read up on that. The lines "God save the Queen, We mean it man, We love our Queen, God saves" is making a mockery out of the inclusion of religion in political affairs. Another line commonly mocked by Punk music under the belief of the separation of church and state is "in God We Trust" as seen in American currency.
twitchmassacres 11 months ago
Comment removed
MrMcGale 11 months ago
@MrMcGale Rude? And 12? Ok, it's ironic how you wanna talk to me about anarchy and have a Good Charlotte song up on your page. This conversation is over. To close this off again I'll repeat it for your sake, the Sex Pistols were an anti institutional punk band, MEANING they were against ALL FORMS OF POLITICS, meaning organized government AND organized religion, meaning religion as a organized entity, in other words, THE VATICAN AND THE ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH WHICH ARE POLITICAL POWERS.
twitchmassacres 11 months ago
Comment removed
MrMcGale 11 months ago
@MrMcGale Are you illiterate or something? I can't do this shit all day kid, I write something in plain English and still you have no ability to comprehend it. Did I say the Sex Pistols were "a screw up band that only follows religion"? Hahaha! No I didn't. Have I talked about "gays must die"? Again, no. My point, and I can't write it any simpler than this, so please try to understand something a first grader would, is that Punk Rock WAS an anti-establishment movement.
twitchmassacres 11 months ago
Comment removed
MrMcGale 11 months ago
@MrMcGale Ok, but this isn't a fight at least on my part. What you don't seem to get is that there is no "Punk music style of today". If you think there is then why don't you go ahead and mention a Punk band? I can tell you this much, Good Charlotte, The All American Rejects, all the bands you mentioned in your original message aren't even 1% punk. Punk is dead, it has been dead for decades, sad but true, and you can thank bands like some of the ones you mentioned for burying it even deeper.
twitchmassacres 11 months ago
@twitchmassacres If that's what makes you finally silent. Then alright. And I know that "real" Punk died. And yeah, this was really pathetic of us to take over the comment section with our crap.
MrMcGale 11 months ago
My point is, listen to what you like, be it good ol' Rock n' Roll or today's overproduced Hot Topic clad clowns, just don't try to Label them with old dead movements that they can't represent even if they had instructions tatted on their bellies. Most of the bands you mentioned that attempt to emulate or are often erroneously labeled with the words "Emo", "Punk", or "Hardcore" are actually just Pop artists.
twitchmassacres 11 months ago
@MrMcGale As to "Hardcore Punk" that was just a term coined to bands (such as Bad Religion) that were attempting, albeit unsuccessfully, to honestly resuscitate the already dead punk movement. But the term itself is a joke (see the term "Hardcore" prior to the word "Punk" is proof of that, as the real Hardcore movement was a straight-edge movement and totally unrelated to Punk).
twitchmassacres 11 months ago
@twitchmassacres We have very different ear flows of music, friend. I don't hate you, and I don't even want to. Arguing will get someone angry quickly, and that's the least thing I want right now.
MrMcGale 11 months ago
@MrMcGale I propose you do some research next time, you'll come to find that there aren't any Punk or Emo bands left in this world, in fact, the "Emo" never really got enough footing to become a real genre in the first place, the term was coined to describe indie rock bands who sang somewhat obnoxious songs about their feelings, bands like that are still around today (E.g. Bright Eyes) but they have nothing to do with the piece of shit trend that is considered emo nowadays.
twitchmassacres 11 months ago
@MrMcGale The bands you mentioned have nothing to do with neither punk nor Emo. Good Charlotte is the most grotesque example of a bunch of wannabes that have attempted to emulate Punk Rock but only achieved to turn it into a trend where you play the same 4 power chords and sing meaningless lyrics about being a angst ridden teen in high school (the stereotypical Hot Topic band), FFAF play Post-Hardcore, My Chemical Romance sings Pop Rock, as do the All American Rejects.
twitchmassacres 11 months ago
Its so amazing it made me cry. <3
NEVERSHOUTBRI 11 months ago
Super song!
theR528 1 year ago
Comment removed
theR528 1 year ago
Comment removed
theR528 1 year ago
Back when emo wasn't just a synonym for bisexual kids in hit topic clothing squealing out bad pop rock songs. This was the real deal, a guitar, bass, drums, voice, and a broken heart. Nothing less... Nothing more...
twitchmassacres 1 year ago 17
@twitchmassacres
A broken heart isn't always what real emo is all about.
Emotions are also happiness, nostalgia, bitterness, love, hatred.
Emo music is talking about all of these so weird yet so beautiful sentiments.
MoBoRoS 1 year ago 4
Comment removed
MrMcGale 11 months ago
@MrMcGale "Hardocore Punk"??? Hahahahahahahahahahahaaaaaaaaa... Let me tell you something about punk buddy, IT'S DEAD, and you probably weren't even around by the time it died. PUNK was The Clash, PUNK was The Sex Pistols. Punk was The Stooges, PUNK was a MOVEMENT, not just music, about breaking with the barriers and inhibitions formed by Government and Religion, and most of all PUNK had NOTING TO DO with Emo. In fact if there were any real punk bands left in the world they'd laugh at Emo.
twitchmassacres 11 months ago
Comment removed
MrMcGale 11 months ago
@MrMcGale Wrong religion has everything to do with it. Not because they were interested in theology, on the contrary, it was because they stood against the establishment created by the Roman Catholic Church. Punk stood against all forms of government, and history has proven time and again that the most powerful, enduring, and damaging form of government has been organized religion. So you're wrong there as well.
twitchmassacres 11 months ago
Comment removed
MrMcGale 11 months ago
@MrMcGale You people? Kid, what the fuck do you mean by "you people"? And what the hell are you asking me if I know what Anarchy is for? Do you? Cause you can spit out the dictionary definition all you like, that doesn't mean you know anything about it. As to saying that the Sex Pistols never stood against religion AS AN INSTITUTION, again I laugh at your misinformation.
twitchmassacres 11 months ago
@twitchmassacres Again, you are as rude an speak as childishly as a 12 years old. The dictionary explains nothing. Sex Pistols never were against Religion, but they weren't against Atheism or Homosexuality either. Don't trust the internet with things like Anarchy, it lies because it's programmed to put famous people under a good light... Could you just stop being so damn rude? When the carrot did I annoy you like that? =/
MrMcGale 11 months ago
@twitchmassacres that's poetic for my ears XD
im cuming jajaja XD
Akurineko 10 months ago
beautiful.
bchilian 1 year ago
simply amazing
one of my faves now
ratlover35 2 years ago
so awesome and epic!
KoalaBearWarrior 2 years ago
perfect song!!!! thanks for posting
hkpetes 2 years ago
thanks for posting this song! i <3 it!
endearingaudio 2 years ago
Such raw emotion. One of the few truly great bands of our time. Thanks for the memories andyselman.
sunsacrossparades 3 years ago