love h interlude @1.54.john mclaughlin,al di meola and paco de lucia are the few guitarists who play technically perfect and exceptional notes. lets not forget carlos santana.
love h interlude @1.54.john mclaughlin,al di meola and paco de lucia are the few guitarists who play technically perfect and exceptional notes. lets not forget carlos santana
John Mclaughlin is one of few guitar players who, after playing for almost 40 years(at the time of this video) still looks happy to play guitar. So inspiring :D
@guruji1 U are a real piece of shit!! You are calling this classically trained singer out of key??? WTF? What trash bin did u crawl out of? Go back to your shithole
@kalpeshbhumia - may be he is a very good classically trained singer.. bt among the other legends in the band.. he is nothing...there are other legendary singers in from india.. better than shankar mahadevan......
@rhitamd First, I never said that Shankar was the only best singer in India. I am very well aware that there are a lot of other good singers in India. Secondly, Whether Shankar is lesser/greater than other band members in Shakti is a non-issue to me because each member has his own unique instrument/style to bring to the table, and Shankar effectively brings out the vocals. Thirdly, shankar has a wide repertoire in vocals (ghazals, bhaav geet, classical, fusion, rap, etc). So no one like him!
@kalpeshbhumia@kalpeshbhumia - may be he is a very good classically trained singer.. bt among the other legends in the band.. he is nothing...there are other legendary singers in from india.. better than shankar mahadevan......
@kalpeshbhumia - may be he is a very good classically trained singer.. bt among the other legends in the band.. he is nothing...there are other legendary singers in from india.. better than shankar mahadevan......
All commenting should kepp in mind john can play in any genra, and particularily is of the most open minded of musicians, he is open to any sound, he rarely does not acsept what you would consider cheap or cheesy because he is in love with the beauty, the esence of the world.
i agree about the silly DJ scrathing tone. the only chink in his armour. his average tone over the years. i think he uses MIDI to generate a chord for each note he plays, and with the notes whizzing by it ends up souding muddled.
Regarding guitar tone - sometime in the 90's he started using some effect with his johnny smith that sounded sour. What I could figure is that he was trying to sound like Miles' trumpet. Sometimes highly acclaimed artists'egos grow and lead to them losing taste. Taste is everything for an artist. He seems to have lost alot of it in recent years.
Such a horrid guitar tone (W/ the defrancesco group)is a perfect example.
I play guitar/mandolin myself. Having Synth into mix allows one to alter what is called ADSR envelope of guitar and helps play the instrument faster. (One can read about it on the net - there is enough info out there.) That's why I do not like JM using it as he should not have to rely on synths to play fast. Shrinivas on the other hand is quite consistant and plays in sonic speed without any synth gimmicks.
'Tri Atma' used to sound like Shakti also listen to John Handy with Ali Akbar Khan if you can get hold of their album - it's out of this world.Tabla player is Zakir Hussein son of Alla Rakha who used to play with Ravi Shanker
absolutely the greatest guitarist of all time!!!!!toe to toe no one can match john....enjoy him and his music as much as you can.....thanks so much from the bottom of my heart....this is what real musicians should sound like.....not the shit we have had to swallow for the past 20 years.....live on musical god of gods.....i will always look to you for the question and the answer....Frank
This is so beautiful! Very good Intro...I know that JM is a guitarist from the god, but sometimes he uses his fusion in wrong places, i mean that this tune shoudnt be so rock after slow intro, but its my opinion! Thanks!
Full of surprises.I like the second fusion bit when JM comes in completely from a different angle to where the Mandolin player leaves the scene creating a cyclone sound with a heart beat in the background.JMs expressions reveal where he is coming from.You just got to be special to think & create sounds like this.The sound of the cymbals crashing is annoying though...!
Bazonics. Its beautiful! I feel goose bumps every single time i listen to Shrinivas on the mandolin or the bit with Zakir Hussain and Selvaganesh right at the end!
awesome, saw them a few years back. My uncle knows them all personally. He's working with John McLaughlin, producing/engineering his next album and DVD. how cool is that!
I saw this tour here in Vancouver. Incredible show. Shrinivas really stole the show. He was shy at first but midway he just shredded that mandolin. McLaughlin was mindblowing as always.
You are quite a dumb-ass.. John McLaughlin is considered the top 3 Guitarists ever... He has grasp of Classical Musical Theory of all kinds. He composes many of these songs.
When he was 30, John McLaughlin was perhaps the best Guitarists alive. Eric Clapton and Slash are the other two. There are many who come equal and close to these three, these three come to mind along with Carlos Santana.
@sillysahil haha! first time i've heard anyone refer to the great McLaughlin as 'that white guy'. I'm a big fan of Indian classical music, and am yet to see another non-Indian as well versed with the Indian style as him.
Almost everyone in this group seems to have a "check this shit out" or "how do you lik them apples" look before or after they have jammed - look for it.... damn each of these guys is a legend .... hope they get together once more for a tour ....
Was this video taken from the shakti concert in Paris this year? On the french Mezzo tv? I was at the concert and it was wonderful, i love indian music like that. If you have the entire concert i'd like you to send it me can you please contact me, if you want.
could u please send it to me as well? im a great fan of these guys and their concert (last december at bangalore) reminds me of a very special moment in my life.
..so sweet...pulls at the heart and takes me home 2 remember....im looking 4 a piece..called "love gone away"..from album..touch me there ..i think...L shankar?...know it?...and ty hey...missy
I bought the dvd because of this video, thank you! But I expected to find exactly this one on it, and I was disapointed to see that it was not. There's this song on it, but it's the one from Bombay and the takes/editing/stage is far from beautiful as much this one. How did you got this vid bazonics?
Amazing. Were any of you at the Manchester Shakti gig about 3 years ago. It was electric. The most amazing thing ever. They played really loud. Tabla beating off chest. Everything they do is breathtaking
Not Manchester but I did see them at The royal festival hall - London - on that tour. I agree, it was an amazing evening. What was it John said that night? "people are important, not places" :)
Sakhi has never been recorded for CD, in fact no RS studio recordings at all with Shankar MahaDevan, only the live 'Saturday night in Bombay'. I live in hope.
The original Shakti was 30 years ago, again, 30 years. Why should they have to keep the same acoustic guitar/violin format. If music doesn't move on and progress it becomes a museum piece. Love the past shakti and love the new.
uh...they're basically doing traditional indian raga...that's their thing. If they wanted to "modernize" it, *gag* then they should have called it the New Shakti...or Electric Shakti...and not "Remember Shakti," because they certainly weren't the Shakti I remember. I don't want to see a Genesis reunion with them scratching records on turntables either. And besides, the violins were COMPLETELY missing. If they couldn't get Shankar, they should have gotten somebody.
Shakti, 'Reformed' as Remember Shakti, for a series of concerts celebrating the 50th anniversary of India's independence. L.Shankar was asked but refused and was replaced by Hariprasad Chaurasia. IMO 'the wish'off the album is the greatest thing JM has ever played. That was 9 years ago, HC was replaced by U.Shrinivas and then Shankar joined. Point is: it's a fluid progression over time not "lets modernise it"
Anyway, Shakti never did 'traditional Indian raga'. They were always a fusion band, mixing north indian with south, jazz and blues. But of course you could rarely see the joins.
Hi Bazonics. You said : ``The Wish`` off the album is the greatest thing JM has ever played. Well, i really agree with you ! The Wish is speechless. I have the cd in France but i took it here in Canada because i remembered this piece makes me thrilled each time i listen to it ! McLaughlin is simply the greatest living guitarist. Shawn Lane was also a serious competitor but he died...He played things never heard before. And it is no accident Shawn was focusing on indian music just before he died.
I'm with you re Shawn Lane. Sure he could shred, but so much more. Such heart and soul in his playing, 'Savitri' off of G.P.I.T.O.T is just beautiful.
There's something about the acoustic string that evokes the human voice and soul - the qwawali vocals make up for it - but I agree with Anderson2000 - John bends and phrases nylon acoustics amazingly and is much more subdued without them - and the violin is obsessively present in Indian music - he's missed that specific cultural evocation - but this is stunningly beautiful nevertheless - shame about the strings...
what's the name of this song and the artist because I can't find it on itunes
Shahrazad7 1 month ago
Mclaughlin Ripping it! Zakir Follows! What madnesssss!
Akshay8585 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
When and where was this performed?
wordhappyHazel 3 months ago
They are my Gods!!!
abegeo01 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
love h interlude @1.54.john mclaughlin,al di meola and paco de lucia are the few guitarists who play technically perfect and exceptional notes. lets not forget carlos santana.
naiktanish 7 months ago
love h interlude @1.54.john mclaughlin,al di meola and paco de lucia are the few guitarists who play technically perfect and exceptional notes. lets not forget carlos santana
naiktanish 7 months ago
love h interlude @1.54.
naiktanish 7 months ago
tranquil!!
AArora81 9 months ago
John Mclaughlin is one of few guitar players who, after playing for almost 40 years(at the time of this video) still looks happy to play guitar. So inspiring :D
Grunge00125 11 months ago
at the end of the white sahib´s solo there is echo of mind ecology
demikat1 1 year ago
2 Shit heads also watched dis wonderfull song.
nitinvirat7 1 year ago
@nitinvirat7... Yes, one is goirick and the other is guruji1
kalpeshbhumia 1 year ago
very nice indeed but i feel padmasree hariharan wud hv done a ay better job at the vocals though
rheekchak 1 year ago
to play this good you gotta be on LSD or you gotta be really crazy!
aditya2004 1 year ago
The Band is as usual superb,...but it is so heartening to hear the OUT OF KEY Shankar Mahadevan.....not expected from this most pro band.......
guruji1 1 year ago
@guruji1 U are a real piece of shit!! You are calling this classically trained singer out of key??? WTF? What trash bin did u crawl out of? Go back to your shithole
kalpeshbhumia 1 year ago
@kalpeshbhumia - may be he is a very good classically trained singer.. bt among the other legends in the band.. he is nothing...there are other legendary singers in from india.. better than shankar mahadevan......
rhitamd 1 year ago
@rhitamd First, I never said that Shankar was the only best singer in India. I am very well aware that there are a lot of other good singers in India. Secondly, Whether Shankar is lesser/greater than other band members in Shakti is a non-issue to me because each member has his own unique instrument/style to bring to the table, and Shankar effectively brings out the vocals. Thirdly, shankar has a wide repertoire in vocals (ghazals, bhaav geet, classical, fusion, rap, etc). So no one like him!
kalpeshbhumia 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@kalpeshbhumia @kalpeshbhumia - may be he is a very good classically trained singer.. bt among the other legends in the band.. he is nothing...there are other legendary singers in from india.. better than shankar mahadevan......
rhitamd 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@kalpeshbhumia - may be he is a very good classically trained singer.. bt among the other legends in the band.. he is nothing...there are other legendary singers in from india.. better than shankar mahadevan......
rhitamd 1 year ago
Legands
learningtabla 1 year ago
शानदार!
agent9752 1 year ago
they arent using any song..all self composed and terrible inprovised
goirick 1 year ago
i was thr !!live!!...and I met them backstage!!....one of the better days of my life.
mpsanghvi 1 year ago
Remember Shakti is astounding.
JudyZorzi 2 years ago 2
and out standing ^^
asxefv 1 year ago
Thanks John for exposing me a different world I never saw and giving me the ability to see the light in your eyes
goirick 2 years ago
for me is more than music!i looooooove!
elgarrabrachid 2 years ago
Mandolin Shrinivas is simply wonderful!!!
shrinivas08 2 years ago 4
they are using a part of squarepusher's song as sampling pattern! so cool !!!!
skawamoto 2 years ago
Serious..which song are they using?
titanium9000 2 years ago
watch?v=3UzdnCTPi-E
Rustic Raver - Squarepusher
I hope you'll like this !!
skawamoto 2 years ago
Dude they have been around since the 1969 ~ LOL
anandvyasorg 2 years ago
no they are not ~ LOL
anandvyasorg 2 years ago
There is bollywood music, and then there is this.
LulJam 2 years ago 3
Got addicted to it !! Thanks for posting !! Simply great ..don't hv words to describe actually...Thanks !!
surbhimalpani 2 years ago
great....blissful music..
sourabhnayan 2 years ago
Comment removed
chewoo69 2 years ago
What concert is this? I'd love to get a CD
riflepoet 2 years ago
This is from the Remember Shakti DVD. Buy it, you won't regret it!! :)
thescreamingninja 2 years ago
..very devotional ..I <3
springlike108 2 years ago 5
Whew! and you thought the mandolin was just an Italian instrument....Mahadev Shankar's voice sends me to heaven...
lpsling 2 years ago
where can I get this song?
immortalx50 2 years ago
Speechless.... Just beyond words...... it almost hurts......so beautiful
RolandZeldenrust 2 years ago 7
another dimension,come and take me from this ugly world
aycagizem 3 years ago 12
John´s face at 2:30,thats what i want to see.That face is more than even music can ever be.
Shalom to all here :)
TheAnav 3 years ago 2
..you are certainly an enlightened being
titanium9000 3 years ago
ABSOLUTELY BEAUTIFUL MUSIC !!!!!!
i love music that you can meditate to
you can just close ur eyes and feel the music
its like magic lol
Shahrazad7 3 years ago
All commenting should kepp in mind john can play in any genra, and particularily is of the most open minded of musicians, he is open to any sound, he rarely does not acsept what you would consider cheap or cheesy because he is in love with the beauty, the esence of the world.
iasonasdemetriou 3 years ago
i agree about the silly DJ scrathing tone. the only chink in his armour. his average tone over the years. i think he uses MIDI to generate a chord for each note he plays, and with the notes whizzing by it ends up souding muddled.
dnikhilrao 3 years ago
3:57-4:40
JAW DROPPING STUFF!
sharupandlisten2me 3 years ago
one thing was lacking...simplicity..
but that might be because i might not be of a level high enough to comprehend what was going on...
[although i've learnt classical...this stuff takes a LOT more than training]
bhedaviral 3 years ago
abs incredible...touches the heart and soul...god bless these great souls
tirakita 3 years ago
The guitar is a most beautiful sounding instrument. When the tone is bad, there is nothing that you can play that sounds good.
No guitar player is bigger than the guitar itself, including jm. Some people get confused and think it is them we love and not the guitar.
pjjmsn 3 years ago
Then why not just go pluck the strings with a nail and get off on it by yourself. The rest of us here will listen to JM.
funkagent 3 years ago
Regarding guitar tone - sometime in the 90's he started using some effect with his johnny smith that sounded sour. What I could figure is that he was trying to sound like Miles' trumpet. Sometimes highly acclaimed artists'egos grow and lead to them losing taste. Taste is everything for an artist. He seems to have lost alot of it in recent years.
Such a horrid guitar tone (W/ the defrancesco group)is a perfect example.
pjjmsn 3 years ago
I saw this group live in London. I remember this particular song aswell.
sonofthedestroyer 3 years ago
ye aadmi mera bhagwan hai. john is my god.
i love him.
dnikhilrao 3 years ago
great performance. Singer Shankar Mahadevan and mandolinist U. Shrinivas are fantastic. Only I would prefer John playing acoustic giutar.
marcocinisello 3 years ago
i did not like JM's synth sound. does not suit his stature.
heavyatheart 3 years ago
i seem to not enjoy the guitar sound myself...but i guess musicians seem to evolve in their choice of sound...
kothariabhishek86 3 years ago
I play guitar/mandolin myself. Having Synth into mix allows one to alter what is called ADSR envelope of guitar and helps play the instrument faster. (One can read about it on the net - there is enough info out there.) That's why I do not like JM using it as he should not have to rely on synths to play fast. Shrinivas on the other hand is quite consistant and plays in sonic speed without any synth gimmicks.
heavyatheart 3 years ago
Ive seen JM play without a synth sound and believe you me HE IS FAST!!!!!
excusetheaccent 3 years ago
you're really dumb, have you not seen the millions of videos of mclaughlin on acoustic?
shenkstarr 3 years ago
john is lightning fast with or without synth my friend. dont you remember shakti?
SirYellowShark 3 years ago
This is great, can anyone recommend similar bands or songs? As slow, mellow and relaxing like this one. Oh and what is the name of the tabla player?
dercosmopolit 3 years ago
'Tri Atma' used to sound like Shakti also listen to John Handy with Ali Akbar Khan if you can get hold of their album - it's out of this world.Tabla player is Zakir Hussein son of Alla Rakha who used to play with Ravi Shanker
Mojay17 3 years ago
thanks man!
dercosmopolit 3 years ago
wonderful!!
anyone know if there is an audio version of
this item? CD or other?
peace!
kidlets2 3 years ago
There is a DVD out that has this song, but from a different concert. The DVD also contains a nice interview with John.
Circuit7Active 3 years ago
absolutely the greatest guitarist of all time!!!!!toe to toe no one can match john....enjoy him and his music as much as you can.....thanks so much from the bottom of my heart....this is what real musicians should sound like.....not the shit we have had to swallow for the past 20 years.....live on musical god of gods.....i will always look to you for the question and the answer....Frank
cranknflair8 3 years ago
This is so beautiful! Very good Intro...I know that JM is a guitarist from the god, but sometimes he uses his fusion in wrong places, i mean that this tune shoudnt be so rock after slow intro, but its my opinion! Thanks!
nikolaiturva 3 years ago
Baz and still, i return...this is just so good...followed john`s music since `68 and still he astounds me
BongoMadness 3 years ago
Full of surprises.I like the second fusion bit when JM comes in completely from a different angle to where the Mandolin player leaves the scene creating a cyclone sound with a heart beat in the background.JMs expressions reveal where he is coming from.You just got to be special to think & create sounds like this.The sound of the cymbals crashing is annoying though...!
Mojay17 3 years ago
this music can not be written and can not be copied.
heavyatheart 4 years ago
shrinivas rules
heavyatheart 4 years ago
Bazonics. Its beautiful! I feel goose bumps every single time i listen to Shrinivas on the mandolin or the bit with Zakir Hussain and Selvaganesh right at the end!
destiny236 4 years ago 2
just amazing
harry007001 4 years ago
marvelous
shruti2284 4 years ago 2
great music !!!! yeah !
:-)
..you wonna see/hear something innovative - how to improvise classical music ?!
look for video : "bach sarabande jazz guitar"
doublearejazz 4 years ago
U.Srinivas is great here!!
these people are more then people!!
anukasia 4 years ago
this sound in the best of world
umuttheshadow 4 years ago
I really dont dig the vocals at all, It wudve been perfect without the vocs...
nikhilbk1 4 years ago
Absolutely Sublime..thanks baz for all your stuff..Shakti the next generation.
BongoMadness 4 years ago
awesome, saw them a few years back. My uncle knows them all personally. He's working with John McLaughlin, producing/engineering his next album and DVD. how cool is that!
theman2890 4 years ago
can your father let me meet jon becausei made my own music and i think that he s going to love it because he was the source of my inspiration
asxefv 4 years ago
more than amazing! i got chills.
reivilo 4 years ago
Amazing voice that Shankar Mahadevan has
sonofthedestroyer 4 years ago
I came here to watch John McLaughlin, but was completely wowed by the other musicians... Amazing.
SicTransitGloria1982 4 years ago
I saw this tour here in Vancouver. Incredible show. Shrinivas really stole the show. He was shy at first but midway he just shredded that mandolin. McLaughlin was mindblowing as always.
hueseph 4 years ago
that's awesome..
keralazbest2324 5 years ago
this is amazing, even the white guy is great
sillysahil 5 years ago 4
yes mr silly -sahil even the 'white guy' is great. That's very generous of you.
bazonics 5 years ago 5
@bazonics LOL bazonics!!
kalpeshbhumia 1 year ago
@sillysahil hahahah.. The white guy is John McLaughlin .. itna to pata rehna chahiye..
polynomialxyz 1 year ago
@sillysahil
You are quite a dumb-ass.. John McLaughlin is considered the top 3 Guitarists ever... He has grasp of Classical Musical Theory of all kinds. He composes many of these songs.
When he was 30, John McLaughlin was perhaps the best Guitarists alive. Eric Clapton and Slash are the other two. There are many who come equal and close to these three, these three come to mind along with Carlos Santana.
vijayshuna 11 months ago
@sillysahil wow that's probably the dumbest comment i have ever read on youtube...
AbstractMan23 9 months ago
@sillysahil haha! first time i've heard anyone refer to the great McLaughlin as 'that white guy'. I'm a big fan of Indian classical music, and am yet to see another non-Indian as well versed with the Indian style as him.
harishnarayanan 8 months ago
That's damn good, man, I guess there are many Indian classical scales played, awesome, man -- Keep Ruling, Shankar.
rockerguy82 5 years ago
Great Work... Simply Awsome... matchless..
faysalriaz 5 years ago
This video comes from the french culture channel Mezzo, and its from "Jazz à Vienne 2004".
I'm watching it right now, on mezzo ^^
Second time I see it, and I love it...
ElboLeto 5 years ago
This video is JUST TOO GOOD.. So is the song obviously.. Proud to be an Indian Musician!!
neolithicness 5 years ago
Ugh.... listen to some Shakti McLaughlin
lifacvillar 5 years ago
Johns face reminds me of Stanley Lorrell.
osensei2987 5 years ago
Which dvd is this?
lezerpiramis 5 years ago
I love it...from 5:01 to 5:07 John's face says "check this shit out"...gotta love those chords!
titanium9000 5 years ago
Almost everyone in this group seems to have a "check this shit out" or "how do you lik them apples" look before or after they have jammed - look for it.... damn each of these guys is a legend .... hope they get together once more for a tour ....
vsd31 4 years ago
Mandolin srinivas is Mazing man
kakkaface 5 years ago
this is what you hear when you arrive in heaven....
titanium9000 5 years ago
Hello,
Was this video taken from the shakti concert in Paris this year? On the french Mezzo tv? I was at the concert and it was wonderful, i love indian music like that. If you have the entire concert i'd like you to send it me can you please contact me, if you want.
Bye and thanx a lot
bibicromagnon 5 years ago
i have the whole concert. You can find it on Edonkey or Emule. If not, just get in touch with me n i'll try sending it across to you.
AnandSuresh 5 years ago
hey, could you send the concert m8
-Ben
benfernandes8 5 years ago
hey anand,
could u please send it to me as well? im a great fan of these guys and their concert (last december at bangalore) reminds me of a very special moment in my life.
bangalorean999 4 years ago
dude, I couldnt find it on both the links...can you please help me download this..
ashjag 2 years ago
..so sweet...pulls at the heart and takes me home 2 remember....im looking 4 a piece..called "love gone away"..from album..touch me there ..i think...L shankar?...know it?...and ty hey...missy
missyminkx 5 years ago
Exquisite! I too shall buy the dvd as soon as I can afford it. Thanks for this wonderful video!
Vierotchka 5 years ago
I bought the dvd because of this video, thank you! But I expected to find exactly this one on it, and I was disapointed to see that it was not. There's this song on it, but it's the one from Bombay and the takes/editing/stage is far from beautiful as much this one. How did you got this vid bazonics?
vaitrucci 5 years ago
Amazing. Were any of you at the Manchester Shakti gig about 3 years ago. It was electric. The most amazing thing ever. They played really loud. Tabla beating off chest. Everything they do is breathtaking
MarkLown 5 years ago
Not Manchester but I did see them at The royal festival hall - London - on that tour. I agree, it was an amazing evening. What was it John said that night? "people are important, not places" :)
bazonics 5 years ago
Can anyone name what album this is from?
Circuit7Active 5 years ago
Sakhi has never been recorded for CD, in fact no RS studio recordings at all with Shankar MahaDevan, only the live 'Saturday night in Bombay'. I live in hope.
bazonics 5 years ago
What a shame. It is such a beautiful piece. Thanks for responding.
Circuit7Active 5 years ago
he could play a cigar box with strings on it
and it would sound good
hossenff 5 years ago
it's funny, I've come back to listen to this piece over and over...and every time I see your comment, I crack up.
titanium9000 5 years ago
it would be alot more soulful if john would play
his acoustic guitar instead of that midi electric
stuff.... :(
acousticore 5 years ago
There are times when I'd be inclined to agree with you, but in this case I think it works beautifully as it is.
bazonics 5 years ago
Indeed. I felt robbed when I saw them. No acoustic instruments and no violin.
janderson2000 5 years ago
The original Shakti was 30 years ago, again, 30 years. Why should they have to keep the same acoustic guitar/violin format. If music doesn't move on and progress it becomes a museum piece. Love the past shakti and love the new.
bazonics 5 years ago
uh...they're basically doing traditional indian raga...that's their thing. If they wanted to "modernize" it, *gag* then they should have called it the New Shakti...or Electric Shakti...and not "Remember Shakti," because they certainly weren't the Shakti I remember. I don't want to see a Genesis reunion with them scratching records on turntables either. And besides, the violins were COMPLETELY missing. If they couldn't get Shankar, they should have gotten somebody.
janderson2000 5 years ago
Shakti, 'Reformed' as Remember Shakti, for a series of concerts celebrating the 50th anniversary of India's independence. L.Shankar was asked but refused and was replaced by Hariprasad Chaurasia. IMO 'the wish'off the album is the greatest thing JM has ever played. That was 9 years ago, HC was replaced by U.Shrinivas and then Shankar joined. Point is: it's a fluid progression over time not "lets modernise it"
bazonics 5 years ago
Anyway, Shakti never did 'traditional Indian raga'. They were always a fusion band, mixing north indian with south, jazz and blues. But of course you could rarely see the joins.
bazonics 5 years ago
Hi Bazonics. You said : ``The Wish`` off the album is the greatest thing JM has ever played. Well, i really agree with you ! The Wish is speechless. I have the cd in France but i took it here in Canada because i remembered this piece makes me thrilled each time i listen to it ! McLaughlin is simply the greatest living guitarist. Shawn Lane was also a serious competitor but he died...He played things never heard before. And it is no accident Shawn was focusing on indian music just before he died.
BastiatHayek 4 years ago 2
I'm with you re Shawn Lane. Sure he could shred, but so much more. Such heart and soul in his playing, 'Savitri' off of G.P.I.T.O.T is just beautiful.
bazonics 4 years ago
Thank you and what a wonderful piece.
Is there a DVD pack or collection of these ?
vjseelan 3 years ago
thanks for the comment. No 'fraid not.
bazonics 3 years ago
hahaha john plays acoustic at the same speed. so you are wrong
krish108 3 years ago
There's something about the acoustic string that evokes the human voice and soul - the qwawali vocals make up for it - but I agree with Anderson2000 - John bends and phrases nylon acoustics amazingly and is much more subdued without them - and the violin is obsessively present in Indian music - he's missed that specific cultural evocation - but this is stunningly beautiful nevertheless - shame about the strings...
strav12 3 years ago