Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (345)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This is so funny watching now when Rihanna sold both more albums and singles than Beyonce or any Destiny's Child group member solo career :')

  • @HumanitySector that is a negative statement

  • Beyonce is so adorable

  • AMERIE is soo underrated, she is def the best out of the three

  • haha beyonce , you are loooooooooooooser .soo poor ;D

  • They were all so pretty. Out of all of them Rihanna has the most successful career. Surprised Teierra Marie didn't pop. Amerie doesn't have much stage presence or appeal.

  • lol jayz and beyonce smiling face

  • and the most stage presence

    

  • rhianna is the prettiest

    

  • dam! tierra and amerie are so dam gorgeous! beautiful skin wow!!

  • Who ever set this up probably go fired right after this show. This was a mess and how dare you set up some mess like this for the greatest female pop group of all time. Even Michelle is upset because they did worst than her (and we didn't think that was possible)

  • @Bjalexander10 lol thats funny. your right, michelle never gets the dance moves right.

  • All eyes on Rihanna =)

  • And now look at rihanna she used to be so innocent

  • 1:58 fail xD she turns around ..

  • rihanna's vocals are so smooth i love it!

  • Teairra Mari deserves more credit! Amerie too! Sigh.

  • And now Rihanna has surpassed Beyonce, lol

  • @CAYOMluver HOW?

  • @CAYOMluver wtf!? where have u been the past 2 decades??

  • @CAYOMluver In what sense!! If you mean as a singles queen! yes. but as a album seller, as a live performer, as a dancer and as a vocalist!!!! Your dead wrong.

  • rhianna looks really awkard..............like

  • riri 17, here, Tierra Marie 17, here, and Amerie 24 here lmao

  • @Napkid317 lmaoo old ass

  • That's sad how RIHANNA is the ONLY one that is SUCCESSFUL out of that trio debute...

  • This looks like soo much fun! Beyoncé is having a ball,LOL, look at her! Maybe because it´s clear that the background voice is actually B...hahaha!

  • I SWEAR AMERIE LOOKS LIKE KORTNEY KARDASHIAN SOMETIMES!!!!

  • They Picked 3 Flops (RihFlop, Amerie, Tierra) TO PAY TRIBUTE TO DESTINY'S CHILD!

  • @AmericaPoop RIRI is on the list of Best Selling artist How is she a flot ? you fail

  • @RihannaLoverr RiRi is a a best selling artist but she got nuttin on Bey...just saying..

  • @AmericaPoop I love bey but if you look at the best sellers list RiRi has sold more RiRi has more Number 1's & More top 10 Entres & more world wide success. Just Saying don't put down RiRi

  • @RihannaLoverr ooh ok.... :l

  • Comment removed

  • I love the way Rihanna's the only one that made it!

  • Type in Layeeefa Lover Of Arts

  • jay-z is sleeping with them all...ha ha

  • They all sound like fucking shit, wtf?

  • lool seing as ALL OF THEM INCLUDING destiny"s child and Jay Z were all Label mates

  • ALL I CAN SAY: BOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! THIS TRIBUTE IS not shabby! THEY aint all that >....BUT

  • Rihanna looking MADD CUTE. Mentally Flawed. Hooligans. Civilian the Truth. Trust Premium Products LLC.

  • omfg i love this lol

    Beyonce was jamming lol

    so lemme see Amerie was Michelle, Tierra Mari was Kelly and Rihanna was Beyonce right?

  • @SkibopDaSequel nooo rihanna was kelly lol

  • I WANT somebody to tell me that Teairra didnt kill this shit. She channeled her inner bey ! Rihanna didnt even know where 2 look . She had nooo presence. She was xtraaa washed up back then. And she is wayyy overrated now. i do love her songz but its not lie she had anything 2do with the writing process. She is Rihanna the Robot to me. She is a talentless soul who gets told what to do and what to wear. And she fucked alot of ppl to get where she is, believe dat.

  • rihanna and amerie did better than teirra it looked like she was tryinq to out do them!! i love riri and amerie but amerie did sound better teirra tried a little bit to hard!

  • hahahahahahahahaha rihanna makes them look really short

  • teirra and amerie were the best perfomer and rihanna omg her voice.

  • Ameriie was the best performer there it seemed so natural. Rihanna was horrible, but her vocals have improved.

    Tearria Mari was relly good. But she is criminally overrated. The reason why she is not successful is because her songs are mediocre. And one of them happened to be a hit. Plus rnb was extremely popular in the mid 2000's, look at Ciara and more. Tearria flopped because her songs were wack, and don't appeal to a large crowd.

  • Rihanna sounds so good, but young though, her voice has definitely matured.

  • Kelly not pressed.

  • awww i remember this #RihannaNavy

  • Wow, back then when I saw this in 05'-I was like I just know Amerie and Teiarra Mari are going places, but that other gurl is gonna fall off hard..Boy was I wrong. :/

  • Ok im a fan of riri but the damn b1tch is a slut she has on no damn clothes sorry teirramaroe and amerie have clothes on point blank meaning they got to pick what they wore get the fvck outta here jay z fucc that pvssy thats why she got the record deal and not teirra marie what a shame. Far better thn riri honest truth.

  • its pretty ridiculous how ppl say rihanna was bein slutty to get big clearly she got big BEFORE s&m & skin u effin idiots she made a transition froma 16 yr old to a 22 yr old thus her songs & music style changed..u can chart her growth. she sounds amazing here & her voice is gettin much better & stronger. rihanna isn a slut

  • Vocally Rihanna was the best she should of done beyonce part she would of nailed it

  • I think this is cute! I think DC really enjoyed it.  Everybody has their season. This is Rihanna during theirs and before hers.

  • how old was rihanna here?

  • @M2u7D0i6M1u9s9i1c about 17

  • @gumbetgirl2010 hmmm very young

  • this was wen rihanna was nobody then kept tryin new styles nd trends nd actin slutty to get big

  • haha! can tell beyonce is the only one who isn't intimidated :))

  • hahahah it´s like a highschool performance compared to Destiny´s child!

  • idk but the one dat was being maichelle was the BEST!just like michelle was the BEST in destiny child.

  • They messed up for real,The only one that song it right was tierra marie

  • @Macedonian666Boy obviously so much better than rihanna..

  • rihanna singing a song of beyonce!!!!

  • Proof that Teairra Mari is a better PERFORMER than rihanna.! RiRi just has a more pop-ish sound which is why she propelled and Teairra didnt cuz she is real R&B.!!!!!

  • @hiks54 Opinion 

  • @hiks54 Teairra is real R&B?

    LOL. Fucking retards.

  • @hiks54 Rihanna is much more than just a "Pop" sound. 

  • @hiks54 ok , so rihanna still is doing what she loves, whats wrong with pop music

  • jAY z pROBABLY wAS wATCHIN Rihanna The Whole Time . Lol.

  • Comment removed

  • rihanna out doin them all rite now

  • LOL why are Beyonce's vocals used at the end? I know its honoring Destiny's Child...but still haha

  • Teairra, Nice belt, Rihanna, excelent voice and Amerie well, orgasmic voice!

  • i thought Rihanna sounded better back than then now

  • @mzweezy95 you gotta listen to some of her current stuff. Shes grown a lot vocally

  • @DiGGy539 idk.. right here she sound good live but nowadays she so horrible live.

  • @mzweezy95 Have you seen her American Music Awards Performance from 2010? That's far from horrible. And look up plenty of clips from her concert tour last year. She sounds great

  • @DiGGy539 yes i did.. vocals was goin everywhere they didnt know which way to. it was horrible but it wasnt bad either. and no thanks i rather not.

  • @mzweezy95 LOL WOW, what the rass were you watching then? She definitely wasnt all over the place... but alright, sure. HahaAA...

  • @DiGGy539 lol.. yes she was and yu know she was.

  • @mzweezy95 Oh Yeah, that's right! That's why I said she sounds GREAT because I meant she sounded bad...you're so right. How could I have forgotten my own opinion? Props to you for reading my mind & reminding me of my real thoughts! Dont know what I would have done without you...

  • @DiGGy539 lol.. alright quit with the sarcism. thats just my opinion.

  • @mzweezy95 Oh no, I know its your opinion, everyone's entitled to that. Lol, the sarcasm just came from when your opinion somehow became mine too "and yu know she was" haha that's all that was

  • @DiGGy539 lol.. yeah iknow. but she did sound horrible tho.

  • @mzweezy95 Oh yeah you're right...I forgot.

  • @DiGGy539 sarcasm again?

  • Loool Amerie can't dance :p

  • Still think Rihanna is a whore now and i liked her better back in the day.

  • Wow. Is it me or Rihanna sang better than now?

  • Rihanna is the most sucesful just becuase she was the best. Made the best music. Hottest. More likeable. More star power. Harder worker. Simple.

    Remember we buy the music. Doesn't matter what happens behing the scenes.

  • Beyonce was realy felling it cute...XD

  • @beyonceboy100 Rihanna has more worldwide n°1 singles than Beyoncé (solo artist), also on Hot 100, Radio Song, Pop Song, Dance club song, Digital Song on Billboard, also reach n°1 spot five weeks on social 50, Rihanna doubles and triples B' fans on Facebook and Twitter... and yes she's more young ..Who mad?

  • @mrLatorre Beyonce sold over 130 records...16 grammys over 150 awards billboards women of the decade 2000-2010,Bee is vocaly better 2010 forbes 2 most influencial women of the world

  • @mrLatorre Beyonce is a real singer vocaly doesnt need no electronic to stay in..she sings great and better live..rihanna sound shi...rihannas loud sold 207,000 copies first week beyonces iam 482,000 more than double lolXD first week

  • Amerie won this round amongst those other 2 tramps. And when anyone can make Michelle Williams' throw away part of any Destiny Child's song she's been a part of, the best part, well then you know she did some extra super duper CORRECT. Rihanna looks scared and stiff, the nobody in pink look like a whore and Amerie looked like a QUEEN. You Go Gurl! Sing the right songs, leave R&B alone and you could be HUGE!

  • @aampow at the time i think they were but the spice girls came back out and had their tour but idk

  • the only reason why rihanna is so successful now is only because she was closer with jay than them other 2. come on now, all 3 r on def jam, n tierra was on the roc with rihanna, yet only rihanna made it big? their 1st albums both flopped, yet jayz kept rihanna and only pushed her music, though it wasnt doing well til her 3rd album. and tierra is a better sing.

  • Amerie definitely killed the bridge.

  • Rihanna even can't compare with Beyonce,she's nothing

  • RiRi wus amazing here so cute and focus.... Beyoncé never thought this child gonna kick out the n°1 spot, I mean Rihanna is the solo female artist with most n°1 hit and top 10 songs this decade in US

  • @mrLatorre Beyonce is number one on billboard rihanna didnt kick her pleas beyonce has the song of the world in this decade crazy in love look it up pleas rihann will never be 16 grammys beyonce is better dancer vocalist...the end

  • Rihanna sucks,she has no vocal range. The only reason she sell is because she puts out poppy catchy music and have people, like Jay-Z, to turn to.

  • @AlysVideos you should really hear some songs from her apart from the album tracks...watch some live videos. if you would educate yourself a little bit more you would find out she has a great vocal range and very clear and precise too. so even if u dont like her, u have to admit she has a great voice and looks great ;-)

  • i love how excited beyonce is seeing them perform their song.

  • no wonder why rihanna doesn't dance that much she looks like she gets nervous when trying to remember the dance moves but this was a long time ago she probably has gotten better just recently on the AMAs but that was dancing she does all the time i wonder if she can do a full routine 

  • They would be a great detinys child!

  • I wish Rihanna would of never changed her look. She looked so much better w/longer hair. Bc that prince hair style had to go and now this red mess on her hair isnt much better

  • Rihanna is the one that stands out you can see the star power!

  • @OKzs are you serious. she sang like a little girl. amerie stood out she looked like a model.

  • @baby287girl

    Amerie who?? LOL, she looked OK but Rihanna stood out, she is tall, rocked the hell out of that outfit, belly showing, Amerie will always be runner-up sorry. Other than her 1st album Amerie has only sounded good on Chingy's Song, sorry Rihanna wins in every way

  • @OKzs ok so riri is tall then she should go model. that has nothing to do with singing. she may sell but that's because her songs are good. if amerie had riri's songs she would sing them waaaaaaaaaay better. amerie is prettier and the only reason rihanna is on is because of jay z. sorry!!!

  • @baby287girl

    Amerie had 3 chances to make it happen & failed all 3 times, Love & War an EPIC #FAIL Amerie is NOT prettier than Rihanna NO WAY. If JayZ is the reason why Rihanna made it why didn't Tearria Marie? (also on stage) he promoted her just as much as Rihanna, what about others JayZ worked with? Rihanna has that "IT" factor, she has more #1 hits then Beyonce, Amerie, Alicia Keys & Tearrira Marie COMBINED, 60 million sold worldwide, it's not luck, its not JayZ, it's all Rihanna. Sorry!

  • @OKzs please spare me Ri has no it factor. amerie failed because she was not marketed properly. amerie is definately prettier. she has pretty skin and naturally long black hair. teairra marie sisnt make it because of jay because jay dropped her. he left her out to hang for no reason. her first single was a hit and she can sing circles around ri. ri cannot sing and if u dont believe it look up her version of mariah carey's hero. she sounded terrible and had the nerve to say thank you at the end.

  • @baby287girl

    Stop embarrassing yourself. Rihanna MOST CERTAINLY has more #1 hits than Beyonce A LOT more, go look it up on Billboard(.) com or anywhere on the net, it's a well known fact, Rihanna has more #1 hits then the Rolling Stones! JayZ is a business man, he would not drop her if she was selling, Teirra flopped, Rihanna went to the top, her single did not do well, the album tanked, even though Jay spent tons for the best producers! Amerie had lots of Promotion, she even had commercials!

  • @OKzs Rihanna has 2 number 1's because she was featured on T.I. and Eminem tracks.

    If you wanna count vocal additions to number ones then you should count the four number ones Destiny's Child has Plus the Five Beyonce has,and you'll see their even -_-

  • @rtsproductionmanager

    That is really dumb because duets are very different then group #1s, (Think Kelly Rowland in DC vs on Nelly's Dilemma) RIhanna was integral to both of those songs going to #1 & when you get a ringtone or hear a clip of those songs anywhere(commercials soundbytes etc) whose voice do you hear??? NOT TI or Eminem... its RIHANNA. Either way you slice it Rihanna is on top: solo #1s? RIhanna wins and altogether at very best they tie, with Beyonce being in the game longer

  • @OKzs I agree

  • @Grasscone

    Finally someone with some sense!

  • @OKzs she does not have more hits than beyonce. i dont even like beyonce like that but lets get real. SORRY!!!

  • @baby287girl

    1 Thing was on a soudntrack, most artists never get commercials, she got soo many, she had her ticket to success her hit single 1 Thing, and failed after that. Stop making excuses for Amerie and everyone else flopping. They did, deal with it. Hero? Rihanna was a child then, please! Amerie can sound very bad too, I just watched her perform with chingy on Jay Leno and she sounded HORRENDOUS! Like a cat being strangled. Sh sounded like she ate a pound of breadcrumbs & dust!

  • @OKzs amerie cna flop all she wants. there are plenty of ppl moe tallented than both she and ri. a child? people are born with gifts. either you have it or you dint. there are a plethora of kids who can rip ri to shreds. she couldnt sing thne and she cant sing now. you just like her because she's pretty.

  • @baby287girl

    You're right there are people that have better voices than Rihanna... AND Amerie, who are not as successful, its not just singing. If it was just singing everyone decent who tries out for American Idol would be famous. Its a full package of talent, looks, style, image, charisma, you either have THAT or you don't. Rihanna has IT, what she little she lacks in voice she makes up in the rest. Rihanna's voice gets better every year, compare Hero to any performance of What's My Name

  • @OKzs ok well you keep putting money in her pockets while she gets rich. i'm sure she doesnt give a crap about you. i dont buy any of their music. atleast she had since enough to pay homage to Queen Mariah who she would never touch while mariah was in her prime. i'm over it I just think ri should be a model and stick with that instead of making my ears bleed.

  • @baby287girl oh and there's no way you're a fellow lamb and like rihanna. get outta here with that lolololol smh

  • @baby287girl

    You're a lamb?? Ok Ok well then you must EXCELLENT taste in music, but a lot of lambs like Rihanna :) Don't get me wrong Rihanna can't touch MiMi in OR OUT of prime, none of these hoes can. But I like Rihanna 2nd best not for voice but for everything else, but LMAO at your ears bleeding, a little dramatic, give her a chance, listen to What's My Name (studio & Live on X factor) you will like her. And you will see how good she has gotten, Trust a fellow lamb lol :)

  • @OKzs the old ri was better to me like sos but i do like only girl in the world. i just wish she sounded a lil better.

  • @OKzs I know Im madddddd late but yes! I am in agreement with you. Lol! "Sorry!" at the end just had me crackin up. Go RiRi!!!

  • @baby287girl What the hell LOL! This comment is hilarious...how did you do from saying Looks have nothing to do with singing and then go on to say "Amerie is prettier" to back up your argument? LMAO I thought looks were out of the equation. (They're both damn beautiful) But sorry, Amerie could not pull off Rihanna's songs. Especially if you listen to "Rated R". That sure would be a sight though...Amerie attempting to pull off RiRi's West-Indian vibe and accent. HA!

  • @DiGGy539 go from*

  • @DiGGy539 hahahah that's easy...because you brought up looks, not me. rihanna cant sing live. check the yt videos.

  • @baby287girl I brought up looks because your original comment mentioned that. And I check the youtube videos enough to know Rihanna sounds great. Look at "Love the Way You Lie Part 2" at Rock in Rio or in Sydney Australia. Or California King bed... and many many more. I admit, she has had some bad performances, but she has grown a lot from those days

  • @DiGGy539 i agree she has grown but she still sucks compared to others.

  • All I know is Rihanna sounded good & Amerie is cacophony #thatisall

  • I wonder how Kelly and Michelle feels when they think that Rihanna just used to pay tribute to them and now she's more famous than them.

  • @ConcertPrince rihanna is just on fast heffa

    

  • @ConcertPrince rihanna is just on fast heffa

    l,bo

  • Amerie and Rihanna just look so cute and Innocent and Teirra Marie seems so fool of herself...but she sounded good.

  • @feliixa81 I thought the same exact thing!

  • Rihanna is just the cutest thing. Love her -3

    And Beyonce bless her.

  • rihanna was a little famous at that time right?

  • @thebdreamer She was new enough. I think she was onto her second album?

  • @FashionistoIRE idk, because it says that they are new artists but if you compare with the other two girls, they are good but then there were not famous at all right??

  • @thebdreamer Na Amerie had 1 Thing out about then which was a huge hit WW. Tierra Maie was the only one without a hit I think?

  • Rihanna was def. the bestt

  • lol u can tell beyonce is so apprieciative so cute!!

  • i think that Terra should be during beyonce's part

    Amerie should have done kelly's

    And Rihanna should have done Michelle's.

  • Rihanna was good xD.

    And her outfit was cute <3

  • Amerie killed the bridge- she did it way better than Michelle!

    I wonder if they became a group??

  • @kikick123455 Do you see rihanna in a group??

  • @Kn0ck0uTk3n What?

  • @kikick123455 your an idiot.. do yu see rihanna in a damn group?

  • @mzweezy95 Ah bitch reread my comment- asshole I never said she was in one; You're the fucking idiot!

  • @kikick123455 naw bitch i dont have to re-read shit.. that was fuckin stupid of yo dumb ass. did yu ever see rihanna n a fuckin group? no.. yu a dumb bitch.!

  • @mzweezy95 I don't give A FUCK- I DON'T EVEN KNOW WHAT YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT;

    All I said was "What If?" smart ass :P And don't you see her (Rihanna) in this video- singing with the other two girls- like a group!?

  • @kikick123455 bitch can yu read? its rihanna, teairia mari and amerie paying tribute to destiny childs.. do yu know know what that means? fuckin dumb bitch and yu did not say "what if" yu said "i wonder if they became a group" yu said it up der^^ if yu said "what if they became a group" than that wouldve been diffrent. but yo dumbass didnt.. like i said did yu ever see rihanna in a group? umm noo.. im done with yo dumbass.. have a nice day,

  • @mzweezy95 Oh fucking well- fuck face this entire argument was pointless; FUCK YOU, and have a badd Day!

  • @kikick123455 lmao.. somebody mad that they feel like a retarted fuck. like i said have a good day.. life is to short for this, god can see yo ugly ways.

  • @mzweezy95 Fuck you I still I have the highest rated comment; you're meaningless and UGLY!

    You're irrelevant FUCK FACE- My comment makes since- I never knew what the fuck you were talking about anyway..so have a TERRIBLE DAY!

  • @kikick123455 cause your a fuckin idiot thats why and there idiots also. bitch yu dont even know how to spell "sense" gtf yu dumb bitch.

  • @mzweezy95 Whatever Still the highest rated rather it makes "sense" or not Lol :P Fuck you with a sick dick Mz.Weezy95; get off my comments- kidd: you're forever fucking irrelevant!

    - Burn Bitch Burn ;)

  • @kikick123455 lmao.. your sad. god can see how ugly your being. truely sad that yu wanna shorten yo days over a video. ill pray for yu cause yu need it.

  • @mzweezy95 What the fuck are you talking about I have nothing to be sadd or madd about;

    You wrote on my comment talking some other world bullshit- and now you're acting all sentimental talking about God and shxt; "Shorten my days" like WTF! It is just a video young lady- like I said my comment still has 20 likes (which means 20 other people feel how I feel) so go comment on their shit too- YOU'RE STILL IRRELEVANT!

    "God can see how ugly your being..." what the hell- it's a video!

  • i think amerie really put her own emphasis on her part and she was the only classy one to wear a sexy long dress and made the other two look sloppy but i did like teiarra's rendition on beyonce's part.i think it would have been better to spread out the song like the original and work a little harder on the choreography other than that it was great.