Johann Sebastian Bach-Invention 8

[artyfly100]

i must learn it and i know only an half of it good.you are a good player!

[jussipeaceyeah]

Du spielst zwar technisch gut,aber leider ohne Gefühl...es klingt wie von der Leier.. Aber ein bisschen Übung wird das schon noch was:)

[Klangzauberer]

@jussipeaceyeah Das Video ist 4 Jahre alt. Sicherlich würde ich heute musikalischer spielen.

[Flatfoot2282]

I thought it was absolutely perfect. Thanks for posting this !!

[KlausWittemann]

Das erste Klavier, das gut klingt!

[Darkboy2525]

Very NICE playing indeed .. but I would prefer the end a bit difference not really softer but rahter louder and hold the end notes some longer and I would do it a bit more overdo on the ending ,. hard to explain but that would be my playing styl :) but first I should have to learn it my self haha and if I do the piece like you .. well I sure can be VERY proud !

bravo mr!

[brasileiropower]

Excelent. Congratulations from Brazil.

The point is, when you reach the right hand part, turn up the force in the right hand. The same in the other. I see you have the same problem as me, I get too concentrated in the song that I can't smile or look calm. Keep up the good job, this interpretation is awesome.

[TomatoRedCheeks]

I want to play this song so badly X.X I need more practice

[usertyfoon]

классное у тебя пианино)) и звук соответствующий!! а вот игре будто не хватает задора что ли...

[pinkellittle]

it took me almost a YEAR to be able to play this one .... :( but I play it a little faster than you. This is my favorite piece of all!!! I always like Bach's style like two people singing together. Thanks for posting it on youtube

[ThePianoGuy360]

Congratulations! :) This was very nice, I enjoyed this very much. The tempo is just right, I play it at the same tempo myself. The only advice I can offer you is to show a little expression when you play. Move along with the song, smile a little, show that you play because you like to play and that it's something you love to do. Other than that it was outstanding! Keep it up!

[Klangzauberer]

@ThePianoGuy360 I know that there could be more passion and feeling. This is an old video, though. Look for example at my version of the Liebestraum by Liszt und you see that I have developed. Thank you for the constructive critic :-)

[karazh]

@Klangzauberer alter das ist keine konstruktive kritik, das ist nur dumm. Als ob Musikempfinden und gefühl etwas mit bewgungen zu tun hätten. jascha heifetz zum beispiel ,einer der größten Geiger aller Zeiten, hat nie eine Miene verzogen , desswegen wurde auch im dritten reich als " gefühlsloser Jude" hingestellt.

spiel wie du spielen willst und dann ist alles in butter. du spielst übrigens sehr schön! mach weiter so

[meenksellaan1]

Werry well played man, but make use of forte and piano, that would make this peace even better.... but further you did a wonderfull job... at least that's what I think....

[lunyking]

Great Job

Play A little more dynamics and with a little more expression but awesome job. Keep up the good work!!

[BassicStorm]

Bad interpretation

[ColorMeVicious]

I think you could have sped up a little but other than that you executed that performance very well. I admire that. Great work and keep playing :)

[TheMsroxy1996]

Great job! Love the tempo it's perfect but two more things; you got much faster at 0.17 so keep the steadiness, and add MORE dynamics. Otherwise it's great! 4 stars!

[yvonnetran721]

Awesome job!! I would suggest to playing the staccatos a little louder than the 16th notes, because they are the melody.

[avelyra]

I liked it, but playing Bach looking at the sheetmusic?

I couldn't do such thing :P

[clcoolness79]

I would want to hear of the left hand melody more in some places. Also more shaping the phrases.

[kenya1987]

dude, i really enjoyed this!

[LelleI96]

Hey :)

echt cool..ich spiel das auch gerade aber schaff bis jetzt nur den ersten teil xD

hoffentlich krieg ichs auch mal so hin wie du ;)

Lg x3

[Narriz]

cool

[Lorbugoth]

endlich hör ich mal das richtige Tempo. die meisten laufen ja förmlich weg... endlich mal jemand der es nicht eilig hat :)

schön gespielt !

[yeahXOcuzXOweXOrock]

hmmm i do see where you're coming from. i will try it.

[yeahXOcuzXOweXOrock]

lovely. please control the tempo, though, and the volume of your left hand need not be so loud.

[Klangzauberer]

Thanks! Well, I think this piece is meant to be polyphonic, so every voice should have equal volume, in my opinion.

[rashofme]

@Klangzauberer Hmm... not necessarily. While it is polyphonic, there are sections where the right hand has the theme and the left hand does not. Really, to show contrast, there needs to be some dynamic in different places, not just plunking it all out. Please don't take this as me criticizing, though! You did a lovely job on the piece, definitely.

[rashofme]

@Klangzauberer Hmm... not necessarily. While it is polyphonic, there are sections where the right hand has the theme and the left hand does not. Really, to show contrast, there needs to be some dynamic in different places, not just plunking it all out. Please don't take this as me criticizing, though! You did a lovely job on the piece, definitely.

[biigzen]

Marvelous! I applaud you! Very well done!

[Pianodrum95]

quite good. 4*

[Kraviotho]

nice :D

keep doing the good work!

[username1p]

Watch the stacato in measure 18.

[aries4561]

you sped up at points 0:17-18 and 57-59

[dncviorel]

you are correct.

[MrLuckylu102]

EXCELLENT

[abdulalh]

u still must control on ur tempo .

[poetryxpianox95]

i think the tempo's fine.

[nco62292]

no it's not...no offense klang

[noa1232]

Beautiful!

[Hybridstigmatist]

Hey cool guy! Your a cool guy!

[mymind1086]

You should ignore anyone who criticizes you with this song! I tried playing this for a recital a few years ago in high school and bombed it... It was so embarrassing haha. It's a very difficult song that requires a LOT of coordination. You got it, good job!

[Darkboy2525]

well done indeed :) Bach songs are really nice on the piano wish i could play that right now haha ^^ But much more practice before i can play -_- well anyway NICE DID :)

[criseluka]

Good job ! Great tempo! 5***** from me!

[fortune32]

coordination is essential, and at some parts you're not. Make it sounds more spontaneous too, insiting on the melodic line( you were playin both the same all the time). Otherwise good. nice job.

[RubatoNocturne08]

this tempo is good, and you played it well. however, the theme/melody constantly switches from the left hand to right in certain points; that should be clear. still, i'm not one to complain. great job! ;)

[werewethere]

well done!

[posgpm1]

BRAVO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[ColorMeVicious]

BRAVO! Well played :)

[KrazyHyperness]

This is good. [: People try to play this fast, they think they're pro, then mess up.

I like this tempo. Great job!

[MaritxuDom]

enhorabuena!! está muy bien. Gracias por subir el video.

[NTea88]

Nicely played :D

Good tempo

[mosquitomansayspah]

i love this peice, and you play it at the same tempo my mother played it when i was little. other people tend to play it faster, but to me this is perfect, thank you.

[schmutzgreiffer]

I would cut off my own leg to be able to play this well.

Thank you!

[Ricoshady]

You could, practice more.

[grafvondritten]

Eres mi favorito. Me das envidia, sana, pero envidia al fin!. Jetz wir sind spanisch. Zuvor preussen warren wir.

[Kungen930828]

"Klangzauberer" he says, "Now I like your play as you do!. Enhorabuena chaval" in Spanish

[YellowMagi]

Somebody here said anything about "you're forgetting the crescendos and decrescendos", but Bach certainly did not implent that to these pieces! So much freedom is granted there to the performer.

Anyway, well performed, although I prefer the eighth notes to be held a little longer.

[neringaitte]

i played that when i was 8years old

[ddtoots]

i played it when i was born at the hospital.

well, this is fuckiing fantastic! congratulations to you, german guy!

[grafvondritten]

¡Ya me gustaria tocar como lo haces tu!.Enhorabuena chaval.

[Klangzauberer]

Could someone translate this, please?

[64ftContraBombarde]

'I would like to have the touch that you have! Very good.'

I think you played this piece really well too! I have my exams in exactly one week and I have to play this piece as well as some Schumann and Haydn. Thank you for the video!

[QQWEERTTYUUI]

I would like play this as well as you. Congratulations men.

[deceased94]

@Klangzauberer "Wish I could play as well as you! Good job, mate."

[m3li93]

@Klangzauberer the person said they would like to play like you and the other part i don't understand lol

[misanthropia11]

@Klangzauberer It says "yeah! I'd like to be able to play like you! Congratulations kid"



[TheQueenOfWords]

@Klangzauberer ich schreibs jetzt einfach mal auf deutsch ;) also.... er oder sie "würde schon gerne jetzt so spielen können wie du. glückwunsch bursche" ich verlass mich jetzt einfach mal auf meine spanischkenntnisse.

ja, und ich find, du spielst das echt toll, ich erarbeite das gerade und seh, da liegt noch ein weiter weg vor mir :B dass beide melodien in gleicher lautstärke gespielt werden ist totel ok, du hast recht, das lied ist polyphon. weiter so! spielst du eigentlich nur klassisch?

[Klangzauberer]

@TheQueenOfWords Ich spiele auch noch total gerne entspannende Musik, sozusagen mein "Wellness-Programm" neben dem Musikstudium. Einfach Stücke, die nicht so schwer sind, und wunderschön klingen. Vor allem im Moment von Ludovico Einaudi. Gibts auch einige hier bei youtube. Ansonsten bin ich wohl eher klassisch gepolt.

[karazh]

@grafvondritten er sagt , er würde auch gerne so gut spielen wie du! herzlichen gückwunsch oder alles gute mein Kind

grüße

[wmd10]

Very, very nice. Just the right tempo. I also admire your ability to allow your fingers to just dance over the keys, creating a wonderful staccato.

[ari1216]

your forgetting to do the crecendos and decrecendos.

[Klangzauberer]

I think it's more the sound of the recording. When you listen carefully you notice that I highlight certain notes. Getting to them I make a cresendo.

[Persiangulf127]

I love this guy's face, all these adjectives are written over it: solemn, serious, austere, motivated, determined, conscientious, and above all: GERMAN!

[Klangzauberer]

Indeed, it's "Made in Germany" with the good old German qualities ;-)

[JMILLZ2010]

bahahahahahahhaha

[darexb14]

respekt!! das lied ist so schwer !

[rudefilmpundit]

Yeah, I agree, this is way mechanical-but I have played it and it is hard to get it not to be if you know what I mean...although she does kind of plonk out the notes.. The glenn gould version is a lot more interesting.

[SeaStarr1616]

Thats pretty good. Youre kinda old though. I am 12 and learning that song

[Hyardacil]

lol.

Klangzauberer, you just got insulted.

You're old mate! Get outta here. Yer days are over :D

[blueyoyi]

WOW!!

[1199nn]

perfect

amazing

[piano6861]

Good job!

[MartijnHDC]

Ganz gut!

[HUICHOL01]

good!, it's ok, I mean... it doesn't has to be very dynamic or expressive, because is bach, and remember that bach composed for clave, not for piano, but if u want to do it with more feeling you are free to do it

[Iknowyoutwo]

I think that you played this very mechanical... this is music not hanon. Add some more dynamics, go a little faster (optional) and put more feeling into this, do not let this wonderful piece of music sound like a person speaking about the history of.... dental floss. Good job on everything else though.

[icanfly111]

NICE! u could try slurring some of the phrases to make it more interesting tho. it works pretty well for me.

[ArtsB96]

Bravo!!!!!!!!!!! but u should put a little more feeling.

[truebego]

put that in your ass

[Hyardacil]

Bach, feeling? No, for Bach you need rythm.

Well, I guess it helps if you like the piece so you can play it over and over again mechanically for hours and hours.

But I do love this piece. it has enough feeling.

[90210HelloHELLO]

And THAT is how you do it :)

[KrisShred]

wenn du an manchen stellen nicht so schnell kannst, wirst du bei anderen wieder um so schneller (die dir leichter fallen). versuche einfach etwas langsamer zu spielen, um dich dann komplett auf's tempo zu konzentrieren. nicht nur für dieses stück, sondern generell.

und mein persönlicher tip: spiele nach gefühl, spiele 'wie dein gefühl sich ausdrücken will'.

[Klangzauberer]

Das stimmt. Ich werde im Laufe eines Stückes meistens schneller. Da muss ich mich ein bisschen mehr zurücklehnen. Das ich nach meinem Gefühl spielen sollte, brauchst du mir nicht sagen. Das tue ich meistens.

[KrisShred]

Gut :)

[NeoComposer]

Your interpretation is very nice^^!

[Lhumbertocc]

nice!! I love this invention, it's one of my favorites.

[ArchieWW]

Excellent! Another favourite for my playlist!

[maseay14]

perfect

[wurst243]

nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn jooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooo

dolles lied!!!!!!!!!!!!

n jooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooo

[Klangzauberer]

n jauuuuu, n jauuuuuu viiiiiielen dank, n jauuuuuuu n jauuuuuu

[Mooggiee]

That was very very good!