It's 2009!! Give the song a break would ya? The cello is nice, I would even take a rapper on the stage as long as dave approves!! We have seen the original in its best possible versions. You don't like it? Listen to the original. This is a live performance and live rules apply. If you wanna jam and everybody's happy with it then you are the man. If not, the cat's not coming home.
@prandolas hehe .. that was not what I meant. I mean that the Cello is trying to do a great job, but most of the tones are OR too low or too high in Pitch. I don't know the english word... in Dutch it is 'vals' ...
@shenkeey definately not. I do NOT mean dissonance. I mean wrong pitched. Listen to the cello. Most of the time it is just a few Hz too low or too high. When someone plays a C and a D together that is dissonance. But when this C or D is not perfectly pitched it is 'vals' ... and that is what the cello does.
@musicmarius I know what dissonance is, and this is dissonance. He is not too low or high; he's exactly in ''pitch'' in jazz; this kind of dissonance makes the rest sound better and makes for a climax
@shenkeey I don't believe it. When I hear a Jazz singer I do not hear this kind of wrong pitch. A singer and a violin/cello are comparable; both can push up and down there tones in unlimited steps. A piano can't. I have never heard a Jazz singer (the good ones) doing this. Of course one can slide to or from certain notes, and one can emphasize certain tones by doing this (something Saxophones or electrical guitars sometimes do) but this Cello plays certain phrases a few Hz. too high or too low.
@musicmarius Listen to les yeux noirs by the rosenberg trio; they do some dissonant scales too in their playing; its just a form of ''playing around'', to make the piece not as strict.
@shenkeey You don't understand me. Probably something with the English. The movie of Les yeux noirs does not show me this. I am not talking about scales containing 'strange tones' I am talking (again, and i'm not going to repeat it) about the cello that is simply pitched WRONG. When one of my pupils sings too high or too low people can also say: ah one should not take the piece too strict. It is simply "vals" ... and that is how this Cello plays here. It's ugly.
@musicmarius I know exactly what you mean actually. I mean a ''wrong'' scale with the key, but that makes it playful. This is modern classical/jazz; people explore deeper, but lets agree to disagree.
@shenkeey I would love to know in that case why this bloody cello is the ONLY instrument in the combo that plays this way? The sax has the same role, but does not use these 'wrong' pitched tones. It's like putting a big ugly orange stain on a beautiful painting. When everything on the picture is in that style... I'm fine with it... now it simply does not match; at least in my opinion; but I agree: we disagree.
@musicmarius Hey, don't get me wrong! I agree, it's not pretty! I just understand WHY he did it, to make the piece have more dept (if all instruments did it the whole piece it would miss the point)
Im not trying to hate on this but I preferred Paul Desmond. He was a much better saxophonist than the guy here. He had a much softer tone and a very smooth playing style which I think compliments Dave Brubeck's sound better. The solo here isn't very fitting to the style and rhythms of 'Take Five'. Paul Desmond needs to live on! But not like this...
Dave Brubeck has gotten so old :( but music hopefully will keep him alive for quite some while. Nearly all the good ol' boys are dead now. I am feeling old now, too…
@playbeautiful9 While I agree, don't let's forget another Brubeck great master: the inimitable Joe Morello, who died on 12th March 2011 and was thrilling the percussion world almost up to that day.
In the words of Paul Newman from the movie The Hustler.... "Boy, he is great! Jeez, that old fat man. Look at the way he moves: like a dancer. And those fingers, them chubby fingers, it's like he's playin' the violin or somethin'. "
Só as feras!
felipexrj 5 days ago
It's 2009!! Give the song a break would ya? The cello is nice, I would even take a rapper on the stage as long as dave approves!! We have seen the original in its best possible versions. You don't like it? Listen to the original. This is a live performance and live rules apply. If you wanna jam and everybody's happy with it then you are the man. If not, the cat's not coming home.
OKEKOBEB 1 week ago
Tocando el cielo con estos
saxmalvas 2 weeks ago
Thank you Dave Kubrek for giving us such a wonderful, beautifully composed tune. Truely a Jazz standard.
Mrhawklanz 3 weeks ago
That's one bad ass cellist
MrKoala0014 4 weeks ago
wow.... che razza di sassofonista!!!
biccio1967 1 month ago
Great addition , the Cello . Very unusual version , but doen´t beat the original .Thank you for sharing .
maxofish 1 month ago
@maxofish Thanks maxofish. :)
VFAClo 1 month ago
@maxofish Can't beat the earliest versions when Paul Desmond (sax) was still alive.
FirstUsedBooks 3 weeks ago
@FirstUsedBooks Can´t agree more with you !
maxofish 3 weeks ago
Fabuleux !!!!!!
spacelau 1 month ago
The band is great, and this version of this tune is super. But I 'hate' the Cello here. It is terribly out of key/tune.
musicmarius 1 month ago
@musicmarius O.O man...it's jazz, no one is ever playing out of the "key".... ;)
prandolas 1 month ago
@prandolas hehe .. that was not what I meant. I mean that the Cello is trying to do a great job, but most of the tones are OR too low or too high in Pitch. I don't know the english word... in Dutch it is 'vals' ...
musicmarius 1 month ago
@musicmarius yeah I got what your tryin' to say.....honetly, I'm not of the same opinion but...it's ok anyway :)
prandolas 1 month ago
@musicmarius You're talking about dissonance (het nederlandse woord is dissonant, niet vals!)
shenkeey 1 week ago
@shenkeey definately not. I do NOT mean dissonance. I mean wrong pitched. Listen to the cello. Most of the time it is just a few Hz too low or too high. When someone plays a C and a D together that is dissonance. But when this C or D is not perfectly pitched it is 'vals' ... and that is what the cello does.
musicmarius 1 week ago
@musicmarius I know what dissonance is, and this is dissonance. He is not too low or high; he's exactly in ''pitch'' in jazz; this kind of dissonance makes the rest sound better and makes for a climax
shenkeey 1 week ago
@shenkeey I don't believe it. When I hear a Jazz singer I do not hear this kind of wrong pitch. A singer and a violin/cello are comparable; both can push up and down there tones in unlimited steps. A piano can't. I have never heard a Jazz singer (the good ones) doing this. Of course one can slide to or from certain notes, and one can emphasize certain tones by doing this (something Saxophones or electrical guitars sometimes do) but this Cello plays certain phrases a few Hz. too high or too low.
musicmarius 1 week ago
@musicmarius Listen to les yeux noirs by the rosenberg trio; they do some dissonant scales too in their playing; its just a form of ''playing around'', to make the piece not as strict.
shenkeey 1 week ago
@shenkeey You don't understand me. Probably something with the English. The movie of Les yeux noirs does not show me this. I am not talking about scales containing 'strange tones' I am talking (again, and i'm not going to repeat it) about the cello that is simply pitched WRONG. When one of my pupils sings too high or too low people can also say: ah one should not take the piece too strict. It is simply "vals" ... and that is how this Cello plays here. It's ugly.
musicmarius 1 week ago
@musicmarius I know exactly what you mean actually. I mean a ''wrong'' scale with the key, but that makes it playful. This is modern classical/jazz; people explore deeper, but lets agree to disagree.
shenkeey 1 week ago
@shenkeey I would love to know in that case why this bloody cello is the ONLY instrument in the combo that plays this way? The sax has the same role, but does not use these 'wrong' pitched tones. It's like putting a big ugly orange stain on a beautiful painting. When everything on the picture is in that style... I'm fine with it... now it simply does not match; at least in my opinion; but I agree: we disagree.
musicmarius 1 week ago
@musicmarius Hey, don't get me wrong! I agree, it's not pretty! I just understand WHY he did it, to make the piece have more dept (if all instruments did it the whole piece it would miss the point)
shenkeey 1 week ago
@musicmarius And indeed electrical guitars do that; i play both guitar and piano, so i can know haha!
shenkeey 1 week ago
@shenkeey Listen from 3:40 and up. Even father dave takes a look in his eye of "Oh my... use those pitch-knobs son!"
musicmarius 1 week ago
@musicmarius Noooo, thats the face youre supposed to get when youre feeling such part of pieces; thats exactly what its meant to give you!
shenkeey 1 week ago
cool version!
tommieblaster 1 month ago
just....wow!!!
demoleus 1 month ago
i'm in awe definitely inspired thankyou
willtrac 1 month ago
Bobby Militello on sax.
BassmanII 1 month ago
i like!!!!!!!!!!
TheMassimop 1 month ago
Im not trying to hate on this but I preferred Paul Desmond. He was a much better saxophonist than the guy here. He had a much softer tone and a very smooth playing style which I think compliments Dave Brubeck's sound better. The solo here isn't very fitting to the style and rhythms of 'Take Five'. Paul Desmond needs to live on! But not like this...
TheAltoSaxophonist 1 month ago
5/4 beat!~
MrArsg13 2 months ago
hes 91!
AlexBkatzmann 2 months ago
I love the violin when its used in jazz
gds765red 2 months ago
.great..........."
gds765red 2 months ago
The Masters . Great Jazz
airkooled05 2 months ago
I don't get what the cellist is doing there :P when did they started to use cellos in old school jazz? :P
RYANN36 2 months ago
@RYANN36 when the cellist is the band leaders son :)
demoleus 1 month ago
HAPPY 90TH BIRTHDAY MAESTRO BRUBECK!
DrumTchr 2 months ago
An awesome version of his own tune!
janne from Sweden
jazzjanne1 2 months ago
Great version. BTW, that looks like the carbon fiber cello from How It's Made.
rlsimpso 2 months ago
I love Dave Brubeck.
Veerapaj 3 months ago
Holy fuck what a drum solo!
Kochasiech 3 months ago
I was there, in the audience. It was an amazing performance in every respect.
NotAgain90 3 months ago
It was great, but I miss Desmond on the sax anyway :) Soo tender!
Gatokrk 3 months ago
Father, look at me, and what i can do ! -----Giiiiiiz Son you are amazing !...... wow, Aaahhhhhh !.Look at him, his my son ! [i'm happy]
globetroter6666 3 months ago
Yes, they r great :)
ENOELF 3 months ago
Yes ^_^),
ENOELF 3 months ago
NONE OF THE SAX PLAYERS IN THIS VERSION EVEN REACHES PAUL DESMOND'S TOES.
SUCH A GREAT LOSS...
nadav20000 3 months ago
dope version!!
rajeshhamalable 3 months ago
Wow! Those guys could really cook! A great version; thanks for uploading this video!!
keyboardartist 4 months ago 2
@keyboardartist Thx for watching ! ;)
VFAClo 4 months ago
Show Bobby Milatello some love, he plays this version wonderfully!
luvthedrums1 4 months ago
Amazing!
Phrase 4 months ago
If you want to hear it done right, you've got to go to the source!
Do it up Dave and crew!
free2bpoppie 4 months ago
This is magic guys...
fabiocrash11 4 months ago
GREAT !
Geges45 4 months ago
OHHHHH
MY GOD!!!!!
THIS IS A GREAT JAZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ!!!!!!!!!!!
lokimdoidim 4 months ago
Great bunch of old cats!
Syllerud 5 months ago
He looks so happy :)
maurolpereira 5 months ago
unbelievable!
mateosx123 5 months ago
Bobby is not as good as Paul Desmond.. No-one can beat Desmond!!!
Juicefani11 5 months ago
what musical journey...this is the version that should have 5 million hits!!! DAMN, I'm so happy I clicked on this.
slitherlock 5 months ago 4
La leyenda viviente!
leoalpiano 6 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
take a look at this video on youtube 'Sachal Orchestra' it's with a ethnic touch
faizeAslami 7 months ago
Is it just me to hear the cello performance out of tune ... ?
Everything else sounds brilliant !
123ThisIsMe 8 months ago
@123ThisIsMe It's not out of tune, it's dissonance!
ceboluga 5 months ago
Dave Brubeck has gotten so old :( but music hopefully will keep him alive for quite some while. Nearly all the good ol' boys are dead now. I am feeling old now, too…
Oli1974 9 months ago
la cancion favorita de mi mami
oraliax 10 months ago
Großartig!
tabbygizmo 10 months ago
encore la forme. la musique conserve ceux qui n'abusent pas de ses à-cotés
r74816 10 months ago
encore la forme. la musique conserve ceux qui n'abusent pas de ses à-coté
r74816 10 months ago
Proud of him n proud that they honored him so wonderfully ! Thank you for uploading !
ONEDEADLYVENOM 11 months ago 10
@ONEDEADLYVENOM ;)
VFAClo 11 months ago
This is WHY Jazz music is timeless and priceless
Xcelent !
CantolaoTV 1 year ago
SWING.
colourfulwithaU 1 year ago 2
Unbelievable - very, very moving indeed!!
cembalaro 1 year ago 4
this is real groove
sgrave1 1 year ago 4
Dave Brubeck toujours en pleine forme,un pur génie du siècle...Une legende vivante!
Je le place dans le rang des plus grands...Il offre au monde un grand patrimoine musical...Merci
Miousic2000 1 year ago 6
Mil Gracias...por post esta clase magistral....fantastica.....!
pirandello61 1 year ago 3
this guy is ca. 90 years old...and still goes on stage...wtf...
assholeHimself 1 year ago 5
this version of take five is just hillarious!! thanks for posting this!! is a master class
guitargamery 1 year ago
@guitargamery No prob ;) Thx for watching !
VFAClo 1 year ago
nothing in comparison to the one and only: PAUL DESMOND!!!!
what a pity the master isn't here with us anymore :(((
playbeautiful9 1 year ago
@playbeautiful9 While I agree, don't let's forget another Brubeck great master: the inimitable Joe Morello, who died on 12th March 2011 and was thrilling the percussion world almost up to that day.
turnitback 11 months ago 3
@turnitback absolutely- Morello was a "poet" so to say with his subtle swing similar to desmond
and of course his impeccable technique summed up-my favorite drummer, period.
playbeautiful9 11 months ago
VFAClo : MERCI !!!!
laurentlaurent65 1 year ago
@laurentlaurent65 De rien, uploadé avec plaisir ! ;)
VFAClo 1 year ago
wow at 3:51 dave brubeck enjoying his sons solo, that has to be the best thing i have ever witnessed
Cmix1a 1 year ago 26
Beautiful. Thank you for sharing the video of this timeless music.
Cupertino, Ca.
carbon4me 1 year ago 21
Thanks for watching it ! ;)
VFAClo 1 year ago
Ho i brividi..... bellissima.... è con questa canzone che mi sono innamorato del jazz
fkthlf 2 years ago 22
i'm sorry but no one can replace paul desmond=[ but besides that it's great!
dreambig2395 2 years ago
FANTASTIC! :) i coulda been there...........
samsiker 2 years ago 27
In the words of Paul Newman from the movie The Hustler.... "Boy, he is great! Jeez, that old fat man. Look at the way he moves: like a dancer. And those fingers, them chubby fingers, it's like he's playin' the violin or somethin'. "
gnihctawsirehtorbgib 2 years ago 41
THIS is music!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
rcortez911 2 years ago 51