Added: 3 years ago
From: ryam11
Views: 136,385
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (121)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • They sound so complete together. Gave me chills

  • The original still sounds the best, Billy and Syreeta version cannot be beaten

  • @TyroneGH People outside America younger than 40 would have never heard of this song if it wasn't for this cover. People who think this is oversang should know Mariah was suuper subtle here. I mean the woman has a 5 octave range, she barely showed off here. Plus, as i had never heard the original and was NOT used to that version, I didn't find it THAT special. The one you hear first is always the best in ur ears.

  • wow new version ....  :-)

  • I agree with you my friend please see Billy sing this song.....no one else should try to duplicate this.

  • Folks- please look for the original with Billy and Syreeta...I'm afraid Mariah and John chose to grossly oversing a beautifully simple song...

  • @deejay2023jvr You are deaf if you think that Syreeta is better sound than Mariah.

  • @royalconstrictor You sound like a jealous hater, she is not at all overrated, she gets props on her voice more so than her looks, she deserves props for her voice and that is what she gets.

  • Above average, nothin special... Billy & Syreeta had real soul in thier rendition... john was ok, Billy's better, Syreeta's beautiful bird like voice, awsome! Mariah can sing, but she can be annoying also. waaayy overrated, i think. Gettin propps mostly on her looks, once again overrated. Nothing like the OG...

  • Typical of the ego of Mariah Carrey trying to steal the thunder of everything by coming out after the song is started. Poor camera people after the song. She'll ream into them because not every camera lens was focused on her ugly face.

  • @Tony63909 You are just ignorant, she has no huge ego, I met her and that is not at all true. You are extremely blind if you think that she is ugly.

  • @misterbee66 I am not ignorant. How can you say that she hasn't a big ego when you only met her for a brief moment? I base my conclusion about her ego on what I saw on the video. I was definetly out of line with describing her as "ugly". She'a not that bad.

  • @Tony63909 lol. I have met her several times and I work with a woman whose daughter is her hairstylist, she also dated a friend of mine so that is how I know that she doesn't. If I met her for a brief moment then you would be right, I wouldn't know. I grew up obsessed with her, trust me, if she had a big ego then I would not like her at all. :-)

  • @misterbee66 If you met her several times and know people who know her, then perhaps I am wrong about her personally, Perhaps your judgement is clouded because you do admit that you were "obsessed" with her. I do bring out that, in my opinion, her performance in this video is extremely egotistic and it turns me off.

  • @Tony63909 Fair enough, to each his/her own. :-) "Perhaps your judgement is clouded because you do admit that you were "obsessed" with her." That makes sense, however, if she were egotistical after meeting her then I would not still love her. lol

  • @misterbee66 I respect your view.

  • @Tony63909 Thanks, likewise.

  • @rubyriddim Awful, you are extrmely deaf and need 1 billion hearing aids.

  • Comment removed

  • Heaven sent simply magical, you can see & hear the love/emotion best duet hands down!!!!

  • Sorry, but this one is awful. If I compare it with Billy Preston and Syreeta there are worlds between.

  • @rubyriddim this was a their own rendition to the acclaimed classic. they were not in any way trying to compete with the original. they are bringing their own spin to the song with their own unique voices.

  • @briobrandon911 Thank you.

  • Groan. Does she really have to warble so much, every damn song?? Such a drama queen

  • Nah nah nah....! its still the original that made justice to the song. Syreeta is far better than the jumping-like humming voice of mariah!

  • Billy & Syreeta....but mostly bc that stupid audience is screaming the whole time & Mariah is riffing when just holding the note would suffice...but this song...chills. Kudos to the songwriter

  • Almost (repeat... ALMOST) as good as the original Billy and Syreeta version...

  • wow! they sounded good together

  • VIDEO, Y U NO FINISH PROPERLY?!?

  • AMAZING!

  • This is a very good song. I think that Mariah and John Legend did a very good job with this song.

  • I think John Legend had sang this song as well as Billy Preston but Mariah's vocals here were definitely far superior than Syreeta's, this was Mariah's "Forget You" performance after people counted her out.

  • Please watch the original. I still remember exactly where I was when Billy and Syreeta sang the original in 1980. Both John and Mariah decided to over sing it....

  • hahaha GLEE!!!! rachel and finn

  • @renatastarzforeve21 but i don't get why they are considered to be rude and offensive in glee...

  • @xFunkyGirlzx It was offensive because of their costumes. A nun and priest in love is taboo in the Catholic church. Both take a vow of celibacy and a love relationship between the two is wrong, sinful, etc. Sorry Rachel and Finn, but terrible choice of costumes!

  • @5runnergirl But it was intentional,so that they could lose right??

    But to be honest i wish Finn and Rachel could sing this song in full version, cause i love their version of this song. =3

  • wow, when I first saw the title I was skeptical, but damn they hit it!  Would like to see the rest of the video!

  • @james6speed the complete video is posted on youtube ;) I'm not sure why the user only posted a part of the song.. Still amazing though.

  • omg they'r awesome :')

  • Mariah Carey is one of the best vocalist of all time. Whoever said she's a shit singer is retarded. Maybe that's y she has the most #1s of any single artist and 2nd #1s of all time

  • Well, what's more to say? A powerhouse couple rendition for sure. I think that Tom Jones and Lynda Carter could take some lessons. (Make no mistake, I love me some Lynda Cater. As for Tommy Boy, as long as he lays off the R&B and sticks to standards, then then twitching, conniptiously gyrating limmie is all right with me.

  • i love their version... i love john too mariah love u gd...

  • OMGD. this is awesome.

  • Great version, but I prefer the original!

  • amazing,!! million thumbs up

  • Its ok for a remake. Thier voices are perfectly matched but this is not the material for them to sing. Leave this tune to Billy Preston and Syreeta Wright.

  • @RRydnew stop hating damn thats annoying

  • @LADYDIVAA

    Its not hating. Its ok for a remake. Grow up and get musically informed before you make commentary.

  • @RRydnew they did an amazinhg job id rather hear them sing it anyday...i heard the others and it did nothing for me sorry

  • @RRydnew HELL YEAH! BILLY & 'RITA!

  • Comment removed

  • just simply perfect!

  • wow. goosebumps.

  • Great song, nicely sung, but cut short halfway through. Why bother to post it if it's not complete?

  • Are you people serious? This sounds like shit compared to the original. Legend sounds like he got a damn cold and Mariah sounds like she squeezing out a lump of shit. You don't mess with classics!!!!! bottom line

  • john legend sexy but i like this

  • And here is the most ignorant person about music in the whole Earth if you think that she does not sing well....sorry but you are deaf....really really sorry...I am a musician and I've been studying music for years and every single teacher or vocal coach I've had has told me that she is unique and she has an unique tone and range and a perfect control

  • Mariah isan angel

  • i love this which has been san first by Syreeta Wright and Billy Preston in 1979

  • If theres a long note we KNOW mariah will RUN on it!!!! THANK YOU AMERICAN IDOL!!!!

  • 0:55 AMAZING!

  • nice, I wish this was on a CD

  • Love this tune. What an amazing duet, far better than the original!!!!

  • NO WAY!

    This doesn't hold a candle to the original.

    ORIGINAL being the operative word.

  • i am soooooooooooo sorry for you

  • feel sorry for yourself darling!

  • @68shamoa please don't feel baby,my life is great.Happy 2010

  • @Flavio: happy 4 u....

  • poor John! No one cares when he sings but when Mariah puts her foot on the stage they all start screaming! When was this?

  • Well I was listening to John Mariah is just too much.

  • @HildaMcFumble 2005 Save The Music

  • SuperB!! Good singers...

  • 2003 or 2005 ?

  • 05 it was

  • This is my first time hearing this version. This was my wedding theme song.

  • wrong wrong this is such a beuatiful duet but ill wil watch the other one youre talking about!

  • Yucckks?? Thats no way to talk about a musical aspect. Be respectful.

  • haters will always be haters. But Mariah made this song for me. Her tone is soooooo angelic. I'd melt if i heard it in real life ....

  • mariah is a genius in remaking a classic , the woman has a touch of gold !!

    put together with john legend they are on fire !!

  • @kennylondon123

    I soooo agree!!! They sang this......

  • @kennylondon123 please watch the original with Billy and Syreeta and then comment.

  • this song should be a soundtrack..

    love their version..so sexy..specially my man..JOHN LEGEND..

  • mc really did a great job in here..i truly love the rendition she did here...

  • mariah gave justice in every song she is remakin...

  • John Legend's voice is so rich, perfect. Mariah's is great, but not for this song.....too breathy and she makes the notes too ornamental when it would've been better to keep to just a pure sound.

  • this should be an official record

  • ok, i watched it...and i LOVE's some Chante Moore but her whistle CRACKED...not cool and her husband sounds like a F_G. no offense.

    Mariah and John Legend sound Incredible and passionate. This is a sex song....why has this NOT been recorded and released.

  • shut up > original is good but mimi and legend gave a pure justice

  • You have got to be kidding when you say mariah and legend gave this song a pure justice

  • theyre good comparedto ither artist who might sing this together.

  • they should've left this alone.

  • mariah is so awesome! love this song so much.....

  • Mariah whistles like one of those sirens from greek mythology, so beautiful how she is dressed too... amazing

  • shut up the screaming girls..

  • Greeeeeeeat!

  • growing up b4 i knew what love was, this was my greatest love song ever. still feel as though it's the greatest. the original is hot and crazy and this version is as well.

  • perfect

  • It would be great.......if the STUPID noisy audience didn't RUIN it! D:<

  • what are U talking about? the audience was great!!! its not a video clip, its a live performance with energy, with real people =P

  • great performance, both of them are best singers of this time!

  • one classical performance from two of the greatest singer performers of the whole world...justified performance from ms MC and mr. JL

  • Amazing. A perfect duet and they both do the song justice. I love how their voices sound perfect together. It's not often you find a great duet. Usually one outdoes the other vocally. They need to duet again, maybe on John's new album?

  • AMAZING!!!!!!!Their voices are perfectly matched!!!!!!!!

  • does anyone know why the it's like that performance from this event isnt on youtube?

  • watch?v=vm5UnU4OCqw

  • omg thank u ive been lookin for it for a while...

  • This song was sung by Billy Preston and Sireeta long ago.

    Ciao!

  • really nice..very soulful.

  • still got it! love you mariah!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more