hey that happend to me you have to teleport till you get the nuke the game just fucks up but it gives ya lota a time to just get point rebuilding and shit
this happened to me yesterday on solo, it fell through the floor. you could hear it growl when you stand next to the furnace but i watched it fall through floor above the furnace while it was still chasing me. had to restart from round 50 >.<
lol idk if u can call it a glitch but one time i was playing online 2 player shi no numa n a dog appeared behine the glose gate to the fishing hut haha
this happend to me on shi no numa we were doing the dog glitch and no more dogs came we were like :\ but then we found it half way through the unopened stairs juststandin there after teabagging it a pheww times we killed it
this happens when the dog runs through a wall or just doesn't spawn u usually have 2 get a nuke or luckily kill the dog with a grenade/monkey bomb it happens alot with me and if u run out of money/explosives all u can do is restart it
This is Real.. Man we just played got to round 28 and could not find the last dog anywhere we were pissed we had to end the game because we had all the perks and crazy money we could have went for along time.. oh well... I have no i dea why this happens.. you guys wanna play add me gametag MattheartLIVE
Okay, me and my friend were playing on round 20, and we were just running around with no real strategy or plan. He was being chased by a dog and ran into the room with the balcony and ran up the stairs, all while it chased him. He reached the top of the stairs and went to the other balcony with the window and turned around to kill it. When he turned around the dog ran through the wall came out then sprinted off the edge of the balcony and ran in mid-air through the building. We were then stuck
We tried to teleport, each of us had 12k, but we never got a ka-boom. We recored some of it, but when we got camera and recorded you could barely see the back of the hound run into the building. Pretty gay...
that happened to me once but in round 21 we were in the hole of teleporter C and a dog entered the window my friend shot his wunderwaffe and that happened. we didnt have enough money for a teleporter so we ended killing ourselves. And xbox sucks dick :)
@rizzo1811 Ok, dude who cares which console is better? THEY ARE BOTH THE SAME!!!! Whoopdedoo, you have a different controller and different games, I have both a PS3 and an Xbox 360. THEY ARE BOTH THE SAME!
that happened to me too. he just didnt apear or was off the map or something :/ we just kept on teleporting to get max ammo just in case the round ended. but we got the nuke and the round ended.
@KoterzRulez ok ur a fanboy of xbox there r differenses b tween the two i own a ps3 and i go 2 my friends who own an xbox like its not as easy to download things on the ps3 as the xbox but the online is free on ps3 which is better than having to pay for online
@KoterzRulez XBox Live can't be proven to be better than PSN because it's an opinion.Xbox and PS3 are both gaming systems with great online play and many different features.Fanboy console wars are stupid and irrelevant.All it comes down to is personal preferences and opinions.Just play the games and shut up.
yea i kno what u mean fighting over video games is stupid. but i do truly think xbox live is better than psn. and this is coming from a ps3 fan. i think the features from xbox live are way better than psn but as far as games and the system itself, ps3 is better.
@datflyguy215 Yeah,me too.I do believe that XBox Live has a better online experience.And I own a PS3.But when people fight over them live 10 year olds it's just stupid.
By the way,would you hapen to now the name of the song playing in the background of this video?
this happened to me, it spawns out of the map and usually runs around outside, you shoud wait at one barrier until he goes there or, just teleport until you get a nuke
this is true it happend to me nd my friend once...it no clipd threw a wall my friend claimed. we sprayed all our ammo into the wall with mgs nd brownings nd fgs nd thompsons...in the end after running threw out the map we held nades nd started again
that happened to me once, we were looking for the dog, but wen we got 2 the JUGGERNOG* we saw a glowing ball of light that u get wen a dog teleports, but it just stayed there, the dog never respawned lol.
*i lot of people think its juggernaut, but reed the vending machine, its juggernog
@XxJ1MMYxX Does the PS3 have a hard drive or do you still need to buy memory cards? I know the Xbox 360 Elite costs $200, but how much would a PS3 cost plus memory cards (if needed, could I use my PS2 cards?)? And do they have built-in WiFi adapters or are those separate?
@DeidaraUchiha7 You don't have to be rude about it. I don't have either an Xbox or PS3 so I wouldn't know. I only have a PS2 with no online hookup. Is it the same for PS2's? Free?
I think it's pretty sad arguing over Xbox and PS3, they both have there goods and bads. Tbh, I got an Xbox because all my friends had one. If they all had PS3's I probably would have got one. Oh, and nice vid
yellow rings are rare because i play for like 17 hours a day non stop,but on every PlayStation i have the eye(reader) gets broken.I just got my PS3 fixed from DAT.ext
ok so i was getting a perk and it was dogs so i sprinted all the way back to the tunnel where this other guy was camping and when we got to the last dog it NEVER CAME
This happened to me, I was in the glitch in the pit by the quick revive. The dog ran into a wall and diapered. I had just enough money to teleport and i was lucky and got a bomb. I wasted all of my amma though before that so i got screwed over on level 20 lol.
I encountered this glitch twice before. I call it the unending dog round. It's rare, and the only way to get out of it, is to either' down yourselve or back out.
one problem, you forgot the part where osama got shot..
JK47cArNaGe 5 months ago
Well that's 2 minutes wasted
theyburnthesoul 5 months ago
ITS JUST ME OR I WASTE 2 MINUTES WHATCHING THIS SHIT?
vapaponce 6 months ago
its sad how people put fake titles just to get veiws on there videos...
stewie0550 6 months ago
Song?
shadowmourne18 7 months ago
i thought that mw3 wasnt coming out because osama bin laden is dead
909Fletch 7 months ago
Am I the only one who saw that there was no 2:16?
motoholder 8 months ago 2
@motoholder whoa 0.o
Labyrinth96 6 months ago
isnt this world at war??????
jackusa328 8 months ago
This happened to me on round 15
XboxGamerWIGGY33 8 months ago
lol i had this happen i found him outside the map
blakedawg9 9 months ago
dude thats so close you have powers
halofan12ify 9 months ago
how did u know close to the real date
solidsnake30000000 9 months ago
if you were trying the dog barrier it is stuck in the wall
rossie186 10 months ago
if u were in the type 100 balcony the dog jumped out of the map it happend to me
MrSoccerpro84 11 months ago
i had the same
MultiMatrixman 1 year ago
this happened to me 2 days ago
fireorb13 1 year ago
GT: SecretAgentOs0
SecretAgentOso 1 year ago
This has happened to me and my friend on splitscreen.
We had to give up on lvl 14!!!!!!!
SecretAgentOso 1 year ago
a what s your gamer tag add me my is CM ZERO with the number zero
10eduardocruz 1 year ago
@armaniboy13 yeah and the people who have a ps3 are rich and famous :D
TheBuck1997 1 year ago
It happens when you stand on a dogs spawn point it spawns below the map and you are unable to kill it without a nuke
SmallmouthMan756 1 year ago
ps3 much better then xbox 360 360 sux!
jthefart4567 1 year ago
@jthefart4567 shut up fanboy
Comba68 1 year ago
this happened to me.. i shot the dog and it ran into the wall and didnt come out
ExGxSMiiTHYZz 1 year ago
hey that happend to me you have to teleport till you get the nuke the game just fucks up but it gives ya lota a time to just get point rebuilding and shit
Jaidanwaters 1 year ago
That happend to me once
WarfareKid231 1 year ago
puto de mierda retardado prostituto (fuck you) idiotaaaaaaaaaaaaa
123motobomba 1 year ago
thumps up if you think modern warfare 3 should have terrorist zombies.
burn2theground 1 year ago
treyarch made this and you put an infinity ward song?.....makes sense
apiccal34255425 1 year ago 19
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@apiccal34255425 fuk up you retard!
airmax1994 1 year ago
@airmax1994 lol how is it having the OWNER comment have to many negative votes?
Mrjoecreeper 8 months ago
I wonder if theres a "no zombie glitch"
TheProGamingZone 1 year ago
maybe they left a crawler with the dogs lol
Skaterkid41O 1 year ago
sometimes dogs dont go on the fith round aka this was tenth
clone7777 1 year ago
This is not a glitch it is a fault in in the game server
hfisc3 1 year ago
OMFG same happened to me we so we all got in 2 the teleporter and got a nuke
1888devlin1888 1 year ago
lol this happened to me n a bud a while back.. got vid of it. pissed us off
Freaky962 1 year ago
this happened to me yesterday on solo, it fell through the floor. you could hear it growl when you stand next to the furnace but i watched it fall through floor above the furnace while it was still chasing me. had to restart from round 50 >.<
whopass252 1 year ago
lol idk if u can call it a glitch but one time i was playing online 2 player shi no numa n a dog appeared behine the glose gate to the fishing hut haha
cuzMTVsaidso 1 year ago
dude idk about u but no joke same shit happen to me on PSN, waited 10 min than everyone just left..but yeah i think its just an error with the game...
sucks for us cuz when it happen we all had beasty guns... =\
mikeXminion2010 1 year ago
this happend to me on shi no numa we were doing the dog glitch and no more dogs came we were like :\ but then we found it half way through the unopened stairs juststandin there after teabagging it a pheww times we killed it
XxToMmYbOyCxX 1 year ago
whats tha song?
tastezlikechicken 1 year ago
@tastezlikechicken
emm Call Of Duty 4 Rap I Think Mate
airmax1994 1 year ago
@airmax1994 thanx
tastezlikechicken 1 year ago
@airmax1994 I think it's the "Griggs Rap"
L33tHum4n 1 year ago
whats the glitch???
bocat97 1 year ago
this happens when the dog runs through a wall or just doesn't spawn u usually have 2 get a nuke or luckily kill the dog with a grenade/monkey bomb it happens alot with me and if u run out of money/explosives all u can do is restart it
Tecknohazard 1 year ago
lol, you can make crowling dogs, you can make it glitch and go normal but without legs, but nothing special with dogs so far i know :P
chris96her 1 year ago
@darkwolf7202 uhh yes u can ur an idiot! u just cant make crawling dogs
AfterMath428 1 year ago
explain the fog b4 u comments u fucktards
kingdomhearts6455 1 year ago
Yo, what's the name of that song. Send it to xbox360 gamertag ValuableBeast01
ValuableBeast01 1 year ago
its misty its only misty when its a dog round lol
mickeyparr 1 year ago
I had a game where on round like 32 there were no zombies... I was playing with my cousin and he ran around for half an hour looking (I was dead)
There were no zombies...
inuyasha331 1 year ago
whats up with the song
DrumDude0085 1 year ago
What's the songs title?
MRItachiWarrior2 1 year ago
@MRItachiWarrior2
here you go:
its cod4 deep and hard
gurupops 1 year ago
LOL common glitch... dog spawned outside map somewhere. It happens quite often.
Robotros 1 year ago
Dogs I mean
TheJdog26 1 year ago
If you think they have a crawler your stupid because there I only fog when dos come
TheJdog26 1 year ago
This is Real.. Man we just played got to round 28 and could not find the last dog anywhere we were pissed we had to end the game because we had all the perks and crazy money we could have went for along time.. oh well... I have no i dea why this happens.. you guys wanna play add me gametag MattheartLIVE
mattheart07 1 year ago
a dog got stuck in the time machine u used if u did use one...so u gotta use the machine that u last went too
REbP808REP 1 year ago
i no they made a crawler cuz at the end the other guy got points watch the score at the end
543mexican 1 year ago
@543mexican he was repairing a barrier u idiot
TheDawsan 1 year ago
@543mexican he was fixin the window numnuts
airmax1994 1 year ago 8
@airmax1994 hahahahahahaha
mikecdc97 1 year ago
@airmax1994 plus there was dog fog....
mariofan213 1 year ago
@airmax1994 You can tell its a dog round cuz of the fog :)
mariofan213 1 year ago
@airmax1994 but how do we know? u might be lieing
!
pokepal999 11 months ago
@543mexican yea plus its darkor misty out and it only does that for dogs...
igotTHEcookies 1 year ago
@543mexican u cant make crawling zombies idiot
darkwolf7202 1 year ago
@543mexican rebuilding a barier lol
mikeXminion2010 1 year ago
@543mexican yeah. and thats why it has the "dog light."
iJman3350 1 year ago
@543mexican Its also foggy so its dogs
Mrjoecreeper 8 months ago
No look there's fog and only dogs come with fog and its happend to me before
samsjunk1 1 year ago
this is fake i bet you they made a crawer somewhere
ownagesince3756 1 year ago
there was a ray gun in the teleporter
mattysutty 1 year ago 4
@mattysutty it was a zombie hand stupid 1:15
mikecdc97 1 year ago
@mattysutty that was a zombie's arm....
apiccal34255425 1 year ago
@mattysutty no it was a zombie arm
Vilar04 1 year ago
@mattysutty LMFAO its a zombies hand you retard..
ExGxSMiiTHYZz 1 year ago
@mattysutty that was a disemodied hand. not a ray gun.
kboy11100 1 year ago
@mattysutty it was a zombies hand
POPOPOWER5 1 year ago
whats the name of that song??
urielh7 1 year ago
@urielh7 cod 4 rap
its rapped by sum 1 frum IW and plays after the credits of CoD4
MrSuperawesome861 1 year ago
@urielh7 deep and hard by 50 cent
impostirevil 1 year ago
i,v got the same thing onec
awesomeguy1998 1 year ago
41 people just dont know what a description is...
pikafoam2 1 year ago
Okay, me and my friend were playing on round 20, and we were just running around with no real strategy or plan. He was being chased by a dog and ran into the room with the balcony and ran up the stairs, all while it chased him. He reached the top of the stairs and went to the other balcony with the window and turned around to kill it. When he turned around the dog ran through the wall came out then sprinted off the edge of the balcony and ran in mid-air through the building. We were then stuck
jackalops 1 year ago
We tried to teleport, each of us had 12k, but we never got a ka-boom. We recored some of it, but when we got camera and recorded you could barely see the back of the hound run into the building. Pretty gay...
jackalops 1 year ago
no the way you know thare are no normle zombies is cose of the fog the fog only comes when dogs come thes guys really are in a weird glitch
dan38b 1 year ago
problety a crawler
gamefreakm 1 year ago
happened 2 me 2!
MrSharkdude19 1 year ago
that happend 2 me 2
ExpandOS1 1 year ago
that happened to me once but in round 21 we were in the hole of teleporter C and a dog entered the window my friend shot his wunderwaffe and that happened. we didnt have enough money for a teleporter so we ended killing ourselves. And xbox sucks dick :)
rizzo1811 1 year ago
@rizzo1811 Ok, dude who cares which console is better? THEY ARE BOTH THE SAME!!!! Whoopdedoo, you have a different controller and different games, I have both a PS3 and an Xbox 360. THEY ARE BOTH THE SAME!
xRuSHxFaTaL 1 year ago
@rizzo1811 seriously people need to grow up theres nothing special bout any of them..
ultrakill54 1 year ago
@rizzo1811 dont hate
urielh7 1 year ago
Happened to me and my friends only way round it was to teleport and luckily we got a bomb which killed the little bugger! Mwhahahah.
judster999 1 year ago
glitch he is stuck in the basement wall
avicolliman 1 year ago
this happened to me and my friend we looked around and its just a game mess up
jefffery1 1 year ago
this happed to us lately so we muked around then left
OwNeRJoeBoy 1 year ago
that happened to me too. he just didnt apear or was off the map or something :/ we just kept on teleporting to get max ammo just in case the round ended. but we got the nuke and the round ended.
charchuagon 1 year ago
wats the song called
02louison 1 year ago
Near Telaporter B The balcony the dog will jump off happen to me
XboxPuppy500 1 year ago
The dog some how got out of the map. That is why you cant find the last dog
Thepolymaster 1 year ago
its happened to me..u should try and get a nuke,. it ends it. so use all ur money to keep teleporting otherwise ur gonna have to restart..
jltbeyers 1 year ago
That never happened to me but if it ever does (in a high level) I would get pissed off.
Meximinican 1 year ago
this happened to me too and we were on round 34 =(
SilverNachos66 1 year ago
the song ?
Mikkeltheslayer 1 year ago
its because you went in the cave thing and the last dog glitches through the wall and goes under the map sometimes
BMHRJS 1 year ago
yo that happend 2 me 2 on round ten me and my friend couldent find it any were so we just restarted it
codecraker1 1 year ago
xbox is a fag fest, all of you who play xbox need to smash it, go buy the ps3<3
TheAngelo2431 1 year ago
@TheAngelo2431 true that PS3=free online
moparpunk1 1 year ago
@TheAngelo2431 im with u on that
kolew394 1 year ago
@TheAngelo2431
It may be free, but its been proven that Xbox Live is much better then Playstation Network.
Unless you can't afford a small price ofcourse.
So go throw your Gaystation threw your window.
KoterzRulez 1 year ago
@KoterzRulez ok ur a fanboy of xbox there r differenses b tween the two i own a ps3 and i go 2 my friends who own an xbox like its not as easy to download things on the ps3 as the xbox but the online is free on ps3 which is better than having to pay for online
boom3100 1 year ago
@boom3100
I'm not a fanboy, infact I once HAD a Playstation 3 (still have the playstation 2)
But it has been PROVEN by many people that the Xbox Live is the better online experience, and u say its better cause its free?
Thats not true, so ur saying that a NES is better than a Car only because its free?
oh and learn to spell.
KoterzRulez 1 year ago
@KoterzRulez XBox Live can't be proven to be better than PSN because it's an opinion.Xbox and PS3 are both gaming systems with great online play and many different features.Fanboy console wars are stupid and irrelevant.All it comes down to is personal preferences and opinions.Just play the games and shut up.
MakDakProductions 1 year ago
@MakDakProductions
yea i kno what u mean fighting over video games is stupid. but i do truly think xbox live is better than psn. and this is coming from a ps3 fan. i think the features from xbox live are way better than psn but as far as games and the system itself, ps3 is better.
datflyguy215 1 year ago
@datflyguy215 Yeah,me too.I do believe that XBox Live has a better online experience.And I own a PS3.But when people fight over them live 10 year olds it's just stupid.
By the way,would you hapen to now the name of the song playing in the background of this video?
MakDakProductions 1 year ago
@KoterzRulez Gaystation.. the I agreee if your talking Playstation 3 but PS2 no.. don't say that to my PS2
sims2player99124 1 year ago
@TheAngelo2431 Ps3 Is WAY MORE EXPENSIVE Xbox is exactly the same as the ps3 but its CHEAPER!
jazzybbygal2 1 year ago
this happens 2 me every time about just get a nuke add me my psn is zombiefan567
gwinfamily 1 year ago
the dog went in the wall i have experienced this and saw this happened you just have to teleport and try to get a nuke.
XxAssassiNxX089 1 year ago
@XxAssassiNxX089 he dont hve enogh points
CRSra1n 1 year ago
SONG?
callofdutyblack1000 1 year ago
this happened to me, it spawns out of the map and usually runs around outside, you shoud wait at one barrier until he goes there or, just teleport until you get a nuke
woopwoo100 1 year ago
that happened to me to my gamertag is killer77warlord
killerwarlord77 1 year ago
it did it with me it spawnes out the map gay dogs
Somedope98 1 year ago
this is true it happend to me nd my friend once...it no clipd threw a wall my friend claimed. we sprayed all our ammo into the wall with mgs nd brownings nd fgs nd thompsons...in the end after running threw out the map we held nades nd started again
brandan501 1 year ago
@brandan501 all u needed to do was teleport until u got nuke ^^
Lakersfanx21 1 year ago
@Lakersfanx21 wow i diddnt think of that...thanks. ill remember that next time ^-^
brandan501 1 year ago
there was a crawler
gage2768 1 year ago
@gage2768 lmao? a crawling dog???id love to know how that works and by the way this happend yo me yesterday anybody know how to end the round???
kalzone246 1 year ago
@kalzone246 i mean crawler as in zombie
gage2768 1 year ago
@gage2768 but its a dog round. the blue haze and all?
kalzone246 1 year ago
they kept the dog in the barier
Corapman 1 year ago
TESTING MODDED ZOMBIES LOBBY MESSAGE ME FOR INVITE
MY GT: MY 3 DOGZ
HaloPLaYeRToDaY 1 year ago
Wow. Wow. You people who beleive this guy r dumb he just makes you think that by not showing you max ammo
Evz7 1 year ago
They go in prowler mode they wander around intil you find them or they find you.
MegaCheckerz 1 year ago
Comment removed
messyhead4 1 year ago
that happened to me once, we were looking for the dog, but wen we got 2 the JUGGERNOG* we saw a glowing ball of light that u get wen a dog teleports, but it just stayed there, the dog never respawned lol.
*i lot of people think its juggernaut, but reed the vending machine, its juggernog
clubpenguinbbb 1 year ago
PS3 IS BETTER BECAUSE:
1, Online is free
2, The main format of it is soo much better
3, controllers are better, and we dont have to put stupid batteries in them
4, Playstation store is legit
5, No Red Ring
6, AMAZING QUALITY
7, doesnt have halo. because halo is the gayest game of life!
XxJ1MMYxX 1 year ago
@XxJ1MMYxX Does the PS3 have a hard drive or do you still need to buy memory cards? I know the Xbox 360 Elite costs $200, but how much would a PS3 cost plus memory cards (if needed, could I use my PS2 cards?)? And do they have built-in WiFi adapters or are those separate?
ucanttuchdis5678 1 year ago
@ucanttuchdis5678 you don't need any memory cards dude
OLdSchool661 1 year ago
nazi zombies needs dogs
TheAkid24 1 year ago
the only reson u have to pay for xbox live i cuz its worth playing =)
MLG72xx 1 year ago
What?! PS3 online is FREE!!!???
ucanttuchdis5678 1 year ago
@ucanttuchdis5678 Of course.You don´t know it? Omg XBOX 360 isn´t free play online...
Well.Bye...
And remember PS3 online is free. xD
DeidaraUchiha7 1 year ago
@DeidaraUchiha7 You don't have to be rude about it. I don't have either an Xbox or PS3 so I wouldn't know. I only have a PS2 with no online hookup. Is it the same for PS2's? Free?
ucanttuchdis5678 1 year ago
@ucanttuchdis5678 I don´t be rude,I use the English I know...If you think i was rude,I´m sorry...I´m not English I´m Spanish....Sorry again :P
DeidaraUchiha7 1 year ago
@DeidaraUchiha7 Oh, no I should be the one apologizing. Sorry. Is PS2 online free too?
ucanttuchdis5678 1 year ago
@ucanttuchdis5678 I don´t know but It´s possible be free...I never play online on PS2...Sorry for can´t answer you...xD
DeidaraUchiha7 1 year ago
O@DeidaraUchiha7 It's ok.
ucanttuchdis5678 1 year ago
I think it's pretty sad arguing over Xbox and PS3, they both have there goods and bads. Tbh, I got an Xbox because all my friends had one. If they all had PS3's I probably would have got one. Oh, and nice vid
thejawsjunior1234 1 year ago
This happened to me. For me the dog was flying and it went through a building so I couldn't get it.
Gamertag:chinnnnnnnnnnnn
o0JoeMama0o 1 year ago
i can guarentee there is just a crawler that was being distracted while ur friend was not on the screen
obranflakes64 1 year ago
i knw where he is
786isamir 1 year ago
yellow rings are rare because i play for like 17 hours a day non stop,but on every PlayStation i have the eye(reader) gets broken.I just got my PS3 fixed from DAT.ext
PSN :zulusniper
nevermindInc 1 year ago
when you get the red ring. its a free repair from microsoft.
RippinCaliBxtch 1 year ago
this happend to me but on campaing hard landing i could go out side map and evrything
opticpredator99 1 year ago
you probably lied you probably have a crawler and your friend is keeping it busy when hes not on the screen
lonespartan100 1 year ago
@lonespartan100 You can see the fog its in the dog round.
0Nelg0 1 year ago
@lonespartan100 you cant make a crawler on the first dogs. ive done this before too. its a glitch
CallMeMrLennox 1 year ago
SONG?!
coollevi123 1 year ago
@coollevi123 its modern warfare 1 rap credits
bayramkara95 1 year ago
THE SAME THING HAPPENED TO ME OMG
ok so i was getting a perk and it was dogs so i sprinted all the way back to the tunnel where this other guy was camping and when we got to the last dog it NEVER CAME
nygiantsfan17 1 year ago
this happened to me before its wierd
smaho909 1 year ago
wat the rings for like the yellow ring of death
guadalupeserna11 1 year ago
This happened to me, I was in the glitch in the pit by the quick revive. The dog ran into a wall and diapered. I had just enough money to teleport and i was lucky and got a bomb. I wasted all of my amma though before that so i got screwed over on level 20 lol.
sackiesacker007 1 year ago
@sackiesacker007
nygiantsfan17 1 year ago
how do you pass the laevel
destroyer2190 1 year ago
lol This Happend to me too
sakuralepine 1 year ago
I encountered this glitch twice before. I call it the unending dog round. It's rare, and the only way to get out of it, is to either' down yourselve or back out.
Spyash2 1 year ago