Added: 1 year ago
From: TheHumanSlinky
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (6,563)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • the new mariah carey

  • I enjoy it a lot, you are my idol lol, u are the best girl

  • Comment removed

  • She had a good voice but no personality that's why she left

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • i love it !

  • Comment removed

  • hailey sucked so bad lauren or pia sould have won

  • the fact that she got elimitated made her more popular than if she would of won

  • she's beautiful...

  • thumbs up if your watching this after she became almost famous

  • damn.....

    

  • un doux chant de sirene 

  • James and Hailey suck she was the best!!!!!!!

  • she was a beautiful singer. but she was boring on stage. she didn't do anything like james or hailly did

  • @Thestargazer411 This is why america is crumbling. If gimmicks were more important than the singing than the least the show can do is not emphasis that it is a singing competition.

  • Concerteza era pra ela Ter Ganhado esse Programa Inutil,pq ela é a Melhor Cantora q ja vi na minha viida,Quem votou pra ela sair é um F.D.P sem Noção PQP !!!

    Pia Toscano Parabéns vc é D+++ <3 (Linda mais ainda :D) SOU SEU FAN AGORAAAA BBRRASSILLLL

  • great voice!!

    

  • Thats a REAL talent!

  • seriously !!! who wouldnt vote for that

    Thats dumb :[

  • Comment removed

  • What DID happen:

    1.) Scotty McCreery

    2.) Lauren Alaina

    3.) Haley Reinhart.

    What SHOULD HAVE happened:

    1.) Haley Reinhart

    2.) Pia Toscano

    3.) Lauren Alaina

  • @laserbeam898 PIA TOSCANOO é a MELHOR !!!!!!!

  • I 100% percent agree!!!!! I loved her and she's from where I was born

  • @laserbeam898

    not never haely

  • @laserbeam898 what should of happened 1:Scotty McCreery 2:Lauren Alaina 3:Pia Toscano

  • @kayla101010100 No. Scotty has a two note range and takes NO risk. You only like him because you think he's cute.

  • "This is our first standing O." Wanna see the next person come in and be like "Get ready for your second standing O of the night!"

  • you americans have to have great talents ...

    here in austria she would have won definitly

  • @RieserDav that's because you Austrians have a better sense of talent. American Idol has become a popularity contest not a talent show.

  • This is talent. REAL talent.

  • how the hell did she get voted off?!?!

    i didn't watch this season, but i saw that she got elimated, and i do not understand it at all.... good job america, dont recognize talent. way to go.

  • @stephanielynnewoolf don't get me started on the travesty that was AI 2011. this is what happens when you let pre- and teenaged girls the ability to vote. they pick the cute boy over the beautiful and talented girl.

  • i just wanna show to evrybody a clip from vietnam idol 2010 :)

    youtube.com/watch?v=yxWnHwODDM­Q

  • Pia beat every single girl contestant that night by slaying I'll Stand By You!!

  • Yesss.. J. Lo! <3

  • every time i listen to this girl..she gives me the chills!!

  • Can we know the view numbers?

  • i like your username. o.o (

    thehumanslinky) LOL.

  • And now she is famous!

  • cool

  • love Scotty but she should have won

  • SHE SHOULD HAVE WON. I love PIAA!

  • @SoCalBudz188 i agree

  • nice

    

  • sooooooooo generic.

    i don't agree with the idea that all music is improved with continuous vibratos and endless melismas to the vocals. PopIdol has done the music industry a great disservice.

    In my opinion the UK has lost their reputation for quality music, and America has gained a new reputation by being a heard of cuntsumptious sheep.

    Their voice is ugly and generic. It's the same voice that has been polluting the radio waves since the 1990's.

  • @NanoEmpyrean hey agree with you in everything except, the 1990' was the best in music and the 60's in my opinion.

  • she has no class to be a star

  • Pia is amazing. so stunning. killer voice. this is an incredible performance. it gives me chills to hear it. she sang it better than Carrie and better than Chrissy Hines. but I could and will argue that her best performance on the show was when she sang River Deep Mountain High.

  • I'm about to piss some of you off, but I don't care. Numbers and record sales don't really matter. Carrie is stuck in the "I'm a great singer, so hand me a song sheet" mode. She just doesn't connect with a thing she sings. She even air's live interviews that "she isn't like the type of person she's singing about" (I Dont Even Your Last Name). In other words, Carrie sings great, but she can't relate to anything, so some of us cant relate to her. So Pia gets my vote.

  • Believable

  • she sings it better than Carrie!!!!!

  • she has a beautiful voice..reminds me of Celine Dion..wow!

  • Still baffled at how she didn't go further in this contest, but everyone knows who she is because of it. You rock, Pia!!!

  • your amazing!!!!! I LOVE YOU!!!

  • Contest started: goo.gl\nREZL - obtain Modern Warfare 3.

  • how the hell is people saying she should win if this is only her very first live performance? it is a looong way to win American Idol and she didn't played the game well enough. But it doesn't matter anymore, apparently her 6 performances got her a record deal. It's all good.

  • maybe she doesn't deserve to win it ....

    but she is way better than 9th place!!!

  • fun fun fun..

  • I couldn't believe it when she got eliminated. For me, she was the best.

  • @SERStephanie for me too she was the winner!

  • try out for x-factor and kick some ass!!

  • Carrie I think did it better.

  • @moochiwuvschachi

    I love Carrie she's amazing she's the only artist that I like 90 + % of her songs,

    but her version of I'll stand by you vs Pia's she got smoked,ofcourse she sang it a different way but idol to idol versions Pia wins hands down,now if Carrie sang it the same way as Pia which I think she can then it would be alot closer. I want Pia & Carrie to do a duet I even got the song picked out. DOES HE LOVE YOU THAT WOULD BE AWESOME

  • WOW so talented! ;)

  • WHORE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • she is fantastic

  • I didn't watch this season, but my name is Pia too :)

  • Whoa. First time I see her. WhereTF did she come from? Clearly superstar-level already. Doesn't matter one bit if she won or came in last.

  • Pia♥ was too good for American Idol , even though she didn't win she still got a contract.

  • very very good!!

    

  • la mejor interprete femenina en esa temporada, lastima ke no ganara o al menos ke no llegara a la final.

  • How the fuck didn't she win?

  • Still couldn't believe that she didn't win. Unbelievable....Just unbelievable

  • Comment removed

  • she supposed to win american idol. she was robbed and came only on 9th place.

  • @allisandrojhonifer 100% agree no one came CLOSE to Pia at all.

  • she supposed to win american idol. she was robbed and came only on 9th place.

  • How is this not better than the winner?

  • She had the judges on their feet!!! Beautiful young lady and voice! God Bless her!

  • Please like "Toscano Fever" on fb

  • Why didn't she win?

  • If this is a vocal competition, in which it is not, Pia should have won. Honestly. Best, most mature voice on the show.

  • @spacitydrummer4JC If she didnt win by her vocals, she should have won because of her looks... She is hott mann...

  • Pia you are so Beautiful in Person i am so glad I Hugged you You are Gorgeous

  • beautifullllllllllllllllllllll­llllllllllllllllllllllllll woman and song

  • anyone else doing this??

    watch?v=5TNqnaXUkNg

    

  • GO TO X FACTOR RANDY!!! WE NEED YOU!!!!

  • I have not said that soon super.i with вокалом to work it is necessary.

  • get chills every time

  • I got chills...

    She is the Best :)

  • She looks like the Dutch Elize.

  • OH MY GOD!!!! This is sooo.....goood!!!!

  • she makes me chills....

  • I WAS SO PISSED WHEN SHE WENT HOME.

  • typical voice in american idol...

  • The best performance in American Idol ! (:

  • nice!

  • she's talented !

  • Thumbs up if you get the chills from her amazing voice !!:))

  • waooo que tal talento

  • pia is the real american idol winner, just to bad she was robbed but het shes making it further than all of them will, wtg pia..

  • yoo pia is so gorgeous i just wanna kiss her

  • Her nose reminded me Rachel from Glee :D

  • why are their all singing like whitney , houston. churc music chicks

  • why is there no number?

  • Next Kelly Clarkson? =D

  • @eparaggare89 no. next pia toscano :D

  • my farts sound better :D

    thumps up if i am wrong :D

  • @gateilli thumps up you are an idiot!!!

  • Not trying to be a hater, I just don't really like her voice.

  • Wow. I really like her voice. It's different from all the other idols. This I like.

  • Pia, tu sei il migliore comunque!

  • omg shes sooo good and the perfect song choioce, idc what anybody says pr thinks...she is sooooooo goooooooodd!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!1

  • Recommended Youtubesearch : "Laila- this is my life" !

  • This was not that good? :o

  • woah!!!!!!!!!!!

  • If she doesn`t make it through she could still go back to Italy and work as a whore for the italian prime minister XD

  • @ThreeLions89 XD means laughter? You sick piece of human offal, perhaps you are hiding your meds again. Ask Dad to let you out of the Tuff Shed for some sunlight.

  • @Mark6024 lol XD. You`re her psycho stalker aren`t ya? :D

  • @Mark6024 Learn something you ignorant prick. You have no idea whats going on in Italy eh?

  • i done got the chills!

  • cant wait for her album

  • she sounds like a great star. also an actress.

    though her beauty is specific . not from this era.

  • Why is it that everyone on American Idol except Kelly Clarrkson and Carrie Underwood are always better when their on the show then when they get a record deal they sound like crap?

  • 2:06 - 2:14...epic moment!!!i got goose bumps..:)

  • :')

  • damn i started to cry listening to her verison... WOW!!!

  • I'm thinking of auditioning for idol next year! tell me what you think! oh and pia, haley, lauren and scotty are going to go far, i can tell. they have such amazing talents!

  • ive nvr watched this show cuz it seems boring but omfg she is so gorgeous, she shud hav won just cuz of her beauty but besides that her voice sounds incredible, like omg...wtf is wrong with the show

  • Months later and I am still saying.... " WTF "!!!!!  Love you PIA and miss ya girl! YOu so shouldve won!!!!

  • should have won. god.

  • Just goes to show looks aren't everything!

  • ANGEL! We found an angel!

  • she is so typical and boring

  • @Theteehee000 , hey bitch, that performance was head to head with celine dion, amazing vocals and feeling, please go and put a gun in your ass because you dont know SHIT about this performance.

  • PIA KRASOTKA

    

  • beautiful<3 ;)

  • is it me or she really looks like kara dioguardi? :/

  • I love that scotty won but pia should have won the show by a long shot she was the AMERICAN IDOL LOVE YA PIA GIRL MAKE IT BIG :)

  • this isn't a song for her

  • se parece a selena gomez jaja

  • how did she not win?

  • it has around 2.5 mil views

  • she's so beautiful, especially her eyes::))

  • I prefer her body here than now.

  • Honestly I love Rock more than anything, but this, this was the single best performance on AMI. And not just because she is stunning looks wise. What a voice! BAMMMMMMMMMMMMMM! Love it!