Brooke White - I Am I Said - American Idol - Top 5

[GeorgioEA]

I don´t wanto to write a lot of words, i juste want to tell B. W. that I Love her.

[renasurash]

she sang this song really well. and i thought that 'i'm a believer' wasn't too bad. wonder why simon called it karaoke. -.-

[kiemsivn]

she is wonderful singer

[qg6ff]

jason shoulda left before her...so i felt a little bad i think BASED ON THE TOP 5, she should made top 4 then be voted off...however thats only based on the top 5. if carly or michael were there, then no

[Decinerator]

ill always remember your singing hope you make records

[dtyh21]

it wasnt a nightmare for her 1st performance. it was just too blend

[dtyh21]

i love brooke , i hate jason ! jason should be the one going ... i dont blame her for losing her lyrics last week its america votes aft all that carly was out.. carly is great but lack of confidence too

[o0qLa0o]

I agree with Simon this time. This song is better than the first one, but I don't think it'll be enough to save her from leaving.

[ridewind1234]

This is truly awesome.

Easily best performance of the season.

Totally not forgetable!

[bangaw79]

the second song was better... but id still prefer carly.. she shouldve been the one performing on that stage instead of brooke

[EduKVG]

She's pure...she's sweet...she's simple...She sings from the bottom of the heart, that's the diference. Cook is the winner, he will be a great record artist and best seller. Archuletta has a powerful voice, but he is boring after some songs. Brooke is amazing. Syesha it's a good singer but she's a little lost. I don't know why Carly has gone, but Jason...oh my....please...bring Chikezie back...

[imkeith2005]

Agree

[shiherostar]

Shes terrible. Jason David and David!!!

[musiclover462]

I love brooke white as well! =] She's one of my favorites! She has to make it to the next round! Jason has to get cut then syesha.. Top three should be david, david, and Brooke =]

[elizaann11]

shes unique, just because she doesn't have a huge range, doesn't mean she isn't good. She's like Colbie Calliat or Sara Barillies. I love how she changed the lyrics to "Arizona", lol. I hope she stays at least another week!

[miknge]

LOVE!!!

[sonson226]

She's great & she could probably do well (I think like the "I'm not gonna write you a love song" girl Sara B?)....But you can NOT stack her up to Syesha or David C and think she will win??

Best hope...Top 4---maybe Top 3 (but probably not....)

Next cut-Jason (I hope!) and then (I hope) David A or Syesha.

Final 2 David C (for sure) and David A or Syesha....The better final (better music) is with Syesha...

[tallderektoronto]

I voted for her i loved her on the piano

[momoing88]

I LOVE BROOKE WHITE!! :) She's very unique, and of a different league from the rest of the big voice singers! Please vote for her!! I can't, because I'm not from America :(