Actually Bhavatharini's performance in this is much better than the "One Man Show" performance. That's available on youtube too. There the saving grace was Sadhana Sargam.
@92Bremely this is such a beautiful composition, but you're right.. hariharan's improvisation plus bavatharani's HORRIBLE rendition killed it. shreya and sadhnaji are amazing as always, though. and raja sir of course..
No. She is good when they have multiple takes, cut & paste, punch-in punch-out, which is available only in ths studio. Otherwise she is a very ordinary singer.
The irony is Hariharan totally missed the 'layam' (tempo) in the specific line which says 'adharkkEtra layam endhan thandhai enbEn' which means 'the appropriate layam is the father (of music). :-) :-)
to remind you guys...Bhavatharini has won the national award for best female singer. This only shows what a maestro like IR is capable of. Needless to say IR would have soiled quite a bit and the song would have digitally got punched in bits and pieces a million times.
Nice song. Its true that Bhavadharini and Hariharan spoiled the song. Shreya and Sadhana were flawless as usual. Hariharan always tries to unnecessarily experiment with the songs on stage and fails miserably. may be Bhavadharini was nervous on stage b'coz in the original track she sang very well.
bhavatarini ruined the song. other singers are more professional and experienced. just because she is raja's daughter, she can't be allowed to sing. she is just like her dad in the hoarse and shaky voice.
Can anyone help in letting me the line after this line - atharketra layam enthan thanthai enben
...Is it ...anbarku kannai chutrum pathangelellam
..... Such a nice song, they really screwed it... for god's sake, kalyaniya ippadi kollapudathu...Apart from Shreya' humming it was a total flap, but maestro's creativity is phenomenal...Is this from any movie
what??? are you out of your mind to tell that IR is not a good singer..you know what Semmangudi, the pithamagan of Carnatic music has told about IR the singer..
I just made my previous comment before listening to the song. Even if she is Maestro's daughter she can't be excused.fortunately Shreya and Sadana came to rescue.Hari missed the beat at the beginning.Finally finished the song some how on a good note.
Sadhana flawless..awesome
reddyzzzzz 4 weeks ago
Sadhana f
reddyzzzzz 4 weeks ago
shreya goshel!!!!!!!!! rocks
cptAxA 4 months ago
I had an opportunity to spectate this program live. Really, cannot for that moment in my life....
rameshgounder 5 months ago
ALL TIME ILAYARAJA IS BEST
1980kichu 9 months ago
Ilayaraja is the Best
IlayarajaHits2 9 months ago
wow this rockedddddddddddddddddddd I love thissssss!!!!!!!
sarathking1 11 months ago
i love this song
thusanth2010 1 year ago
Actually Bhavatharini's performance in this is much better than the "One Man Show" performance. That's available on youtube too.
sukri0911 1 year ago
Actually Bhavatharini's performance in this is much better than the "One Man Show" performance. That's available on youtube too. There the saving grace was Sadhana Sargam.
sukri0911 1 year ago
Ilayaraja's daughter needs first grade singing lessons ! She is HORRIBLE!!!!
nevertheless123 1 year ago 3
not very well presented,. original is heaven
addieroxrev09 1 year ago
this is beyond terrible
lilacgown 2 years ago
what happened to this group of grt singers..?
mmmvannan 2 years ago
only chitra and sadana sargam can sing perfectly on stage as well
inder19852000 1 year ago
i think shreya ghoshal and kavita krishnamurthy are perfect live too
cricketlover1117 1 year ago
IS the one in pink the actual singer?
tamilshoutcom 2 years ago
Bhavatharini - was totally off pitch - butcher of this song.
Jeez, she will not be anywhere close to music industry if she were not from IR's family.
vivraji 2 years ago
my god...hariharan.....how could he not follow the music?
periana11 2 years ago 6
this song completely collapsed
what a beautiful song
hariharan has to stop this lets improvise on spot with out talkin to the 60 musicians like god!
they just killed his composition
like what a god illayaraja is!
92Bremely 2 years ago 9
@92Bremely
Ilayarajas' daughter has a HORRIBLE voice and needs some basic training before singing in the stage.
arun2010isai 1 year ago 2
@92Bremely this is such a beautiful composition, but you're right.. hariharan's improvisation plus bavatharani's HORRIBLE rendition killed it. shreya and sadhnaji are amazing as always, though. and raja sir of course..
cricketlover1117 1 year ago
who is that horrible singer?!
cricketlover1117 2 years ago
I belive you are referring to Bhavatharini, the pride and joy of the Ilayaraja household :-) :-)
rajaG56 2 years ago
really?? i heard her in the original and she sounded much better.. must've just been a bad day.
cricketlover1117 2 years ago
No. She is good when they have multiple takes, cut & paste, punch-in punch-out, which is available only in ths studio. Otherwise she is a very ordinary singer.
rajaG56 2 years ago 2
ah i see, that explains why she sounded so horrible live.
cricketlover1117 2 years ago
wonderfull song
shobana13 2 years ago
awsum song......
cylobes 2 years ago
actually hariharan somewat little bit exaggerated...Then he catch up the ending note...
Totally Stage collapsed at sometimes...
sudhaman26 2 years ago
The irony is Hariharan totally missed the 'layam' (tempo) in the specific line which says 'adharkkEtra layam endhan thandhai enbEn' which means 'the appropriate layam is the father (of music). :-) :-)
rajaG56 2 years ago 5
Very true.. I was gonna say that..
ramjhan06 2 years ago
Hariharan Rocks...
sudhaman26 2 years ago
bhavatharini was awesome in the original track.. but not in this performance
anume95 2 years ago
when shreya ghosal starts singing, its like the whole crowd is going.."thank god! hope she sings the rest of it now!"
kaavya86 3 years ago
to remind you guys...Bhavatharini has won the national award for best female singer. This only shows what a maestro like IR is capable of. Needless to say IR would have soiled quite a bit and the song would have digitally got punched in bits and pieces a million times.
Penrod101 3 years ago
bhavatharini i supect sings in church shivering like shit if she was in any other state she would not be singing in film songs for sure!
hollyrabbit12 3 years ago
Nice song. Its true that Bhavadharini and Hariharan spoiled the song. Shreya and Sadhana were flawless as usual. Hariharan always tries to unnecessarily experiment with the songs on stage and fails miserably. may be Bhavadharini was nervous on stage b'coz in the original track she sang very well.
Manjuks1 3 years ago
i perfectly agree with you word by word.
Penrod101 3 years ago
Ennama idu! inda alavukku paate mosam pannitaage!
Arasalar 3 years ago
Both Hariharan and Bhavatharini Suck!
f2000357 3 years ago
Comment removed
sudhaman26 2 years ago
bhavatharini has scored music 4 a telugu movie. she is talented. but as a singer her was is ok.
tulasiprasad79 3 years ago
ilayaraja is ok, but his daughter's voice is a horror.
rogram4 4 years ago
bavatharani great............
sabirw 4 years ago
oh gosh thats my reaction
chittu159 3 years ago
Jeez!! Bhavatharini is awful!!!
Why does she sing? I dont like her voice at all. She is completely out of tune.
Does'nt Ilayaraj see that she is'nt singing well?
Such a nice song.....messed up thanks to Bhavatharini.
anirudhn 4 years ago
wat da????mistakes do happen to veryone.but sreya and hari are not suposed to miss beat.because they are known to be good.
how sad...best of luck for next time.
i think they hav to do rehearsal before singing in group
periana11 4 years ago
bhavatarini ruined the song. other singers are more professional and experienced. just because she is raja's daughter, she can't be allowed to sing. she is just like her dad in the hoarse and shaky voice.
rogram4 4 years ago
Can anyone help in letting me the line after this line - atharketra layam enthan thanthai enben
...Is it ...anbarku kannai chutrum pathangelellam
..... Such a nice song, they really screwed it... for god's sake, kalyaniya ippadi kollapudathu...Apart from Shreya' humming it was a total flap, but maestro's creativity is phenomenal...Is this from any movie
rameshrs 4 years ago
This song is from Oru Naal Oru Kanavu.
The lyrics of the second charanam are :
aadara sruthi antha annai andrae
athukeTTra layam endan tandai yenbain
sruthi layangal thannai chuttrum swarangal ellam
uravaga amaintha'nalla isaikuDumbam
thirantha kathavu enDrum mooDaathu
inggu serantha isai virunthu kuraiyaathu
ithu pol illam ethu soll thozhi
deepikageetam 4 years ago
shreya made me crack up with all that messing up in the end!!
sksainath 4 years ago
bavatharini's yucky!!! wat did all the others do to have to sing with her!!!
sksainath 4 years ago
Even IR has to stop singing..That is the main problem. He is a composer but not a good singer. What else?
vensub 4 years ago
what??? are you out of your mind to tell that IR is not a good singer..you know what Semmangudi, the pithamagan of Carnatic music has told about IR the singer..
vimalans 4 years ago
This is called team effort. Every singer contributed towards screwing up the song.
pachaigate 5 years ago 2
haha..very true..
nakukavala 3 years ago
I agree. Bhavatharini struggles. I dont think she belongs on stage. Overall I dont think the song was rehearsed. Pity, its a such a wonderful song!
asdaash 5 years ago
I just made my previous comment before listening to the song. Even if she is Maestro's daughter she can't be excused.fortunately Shreya and Sadana came to rescue.Hari missed the beat at the beginning.Finally finished the song some how on a good note.
zganz78 5 years ago
Just because she is our Maestro's daughter,she can be excused.
zganz78 5 years ago
why does bhavatharini have to sing? god!!
pvatham 5 years ago