i heard sawashiro miyuki (iwasawa's seiyuu) isnt the one who actually sang the original songs, it was marina. someone else named liSA sang yui's songs. i think yui's singer has better singing skills; like, she's more sure of her vibrato and pitch. also, since her voice is all energetic and such, it kinda has more emotion for the more static parts of songs...
both versions are so good though; got em all on my ipod!! :)
i love yui's voice, but the meaning of this song speaks for iwasawa's personality rather then hers, so emotions are stronger in iwasawa's version compared to yui.
@juppiecookies I agree with you. I like Yui's voice better but I still like Iwasawa's too. When Yui sings it sound like she has more confidence in her voice and like you said a more melodic voice
i mean love Yui's versions of songs but I felt Crow Song and Alchemy and My Song were more for Iwasawa bc when she sang it she made me want to grab a guitar, with Yui...idk i mean i like it but the improvising at the end was not nessecary. (not hating on Yui just saying) i still like it overall.
This version fucking sucks, this Yui broad is just belting it out instead of working with the rest of the band, overuses vibrato, and in terms of singing ability doesn't hold a candle to the voice actor/singer for Marina. Anyone that likes this version has no real understanding or appriciation of music.
@Cillranchello LOL LOLL LOLLL, u have no *appreciation* of music either ;) im sure u dont understand either, so yea if your gonna hate, just don't listen x)
As a fellow critic, I considered your opinion. After re-analyzing the music a number of times, I think you are right. People should not go straight into "flaming" that's a bad attitude... the concept of the song is "GREAT" but the way Yui sings is not great at all. That's what he is trying to say
@sasarai95 yeah right whatever that critic crap. I think both versions are good. thay both did well singing this song and even though iwasawa's ver. is better this ver. still rocks. whatever you people talk about...
@Cillranchello didn't really have to say "fucking sucks" but i get your point and i would have to agree with you, btw i am a musician (can play guitar, bass, procussion, trumpet, learning violin)
@Cillranchello I know a lot about music, and understand it really good. And I like it! So what if I like this version, that doesn't mean that I don't have real understanding or appriciation of music.
@scratiegirl What I think happens to be reality. Keep defending shit, I haven't had an idiot to point and laugh at for quite a while, and I think you'll do just fine.
@Cillranchello Why you so angry bra? Everyone loves different music some like rap others hate it, some like country others hate it, some like instrumental and once again others don't. Saying it's shit is your own opinion not a broadcast saying fact.
@obigweyo Because there's a difference between liking different types of music, and thinking that this abomination of a cover is a good song. Oh, and I'm not your "bra." I have no interest in holding your man-tits up, nor will I ever. Now will you keyboard monkeys do the world a favor and shut the hell up?
@Cillranchello Once again that just proves you being a dick instead of a someone just simply saying I can understand your opinions but I disagree I like *insert type of song/music*. You're not being smart about music or anything, instead you're just proving how much of an idiot you are and how you apparently love to just troll.
@obigweyo Props to him though, he just trolled the hell out of all of you. Just to keep the ball rolling, I'd have to say that the original is much better. Iwasawa's voice suits the emotion of the song much better. @Cillranchello, one's thoughts do not display reality. Your thoughts only reflect your reactions to reality. We can not "shut the hell up"; we are typing, not talking. The way to say what you meant would be, "Now, will you keyboard monkeys do the world a favor and stop typing"
@Dastrionix I agree about Iwasawa being more fitting, but still I like Yui's version because it'sdifferent. Also I'm just merely responding to him to see how far I could keep him going until he ran out of steam lol.
@obigweyo Einstein once said "Only two things are infinite: human stupidity and the universe, and we're not even sure about that latter." You have proved him right once again. Go slam your fingers under a piano's keyboard cover before your idiocy continues to spread.
@Cillranchello Really? That's your comeback after a month? That's quite sad... You can't even make anything related to the video so you go to violence instead of coming back to my comment, congratulations I think you just proved both yourself & myself right. Opinions exist and people hate the Iwasawa just as you hate Yui's. Case being facts aren't proven from a clear genius like you that took a month to comeback with an irrelevant topic, go Einstein for being a genius am I right?
@obigweyo Just like this one took a month for me to come up with. Its not like I have a job and thus have the time to sit around and be a keyboard monkey all day... oh wait. Regardless, perpetuating the idea that this even remotely approaches "good music" is the reason singers(and I use the term loosely) like Katie Perry, Lady Gaga, and that insufferable little twat Justin Bieber are fleecing the world of its money. Musical appreciation in this country is dead.
@Cillranchello You say job like you're the one with problems as though you're the only one with one, but hey guess what kid, most people do get them in their life if they want to succeed but that aside. While I agree with you about those singers being bad that doesn't mean others think so lady
gaga is terrifying with her music, does that mean her fanbase thinks so? No it doesn't you're just saying the same thing proving me right in the end, music has different meanings, learn to accept it...
@CutApplesz Only because it was WAY overpriced. I got this album from Anime Expo 2010 in LA and it cost me $70.00! Then the Iwasawa version was not on it. I was kinda sad.
:x:x I love thiis!!!
XCrazyXlau 11 hours ago
i love this song and yui's voice sounds great, but i prefer iwasawa's voice. it sounds more mature and more serious.
AnimeMusicGirl24 3 weeks ago in playlist Angel Beats
this song is awesome! yui's voice is exciting in this song exspeccially near the end! :D
popcornandanime 1 month ago
if i had the chance to become japanese I so would just for the anime and tales game
RedSkyGod999 1 month ago
i heard sawashiro miyuki (iwasawa's seiyuu) isnt the one who actually sang the original songs, it was marina. someone else named liSA sang yui's songs. i think yui's singer has better singing skills; like, she's more sure of her vibrato and pitch. also, since her voice is all energetic and such, it kinda has more emotion for the more static parts of songs...
both versions are so good though; got em all on my ipod!! :)
sorae3580 1 month ago
@sorae3580 You are right about Iwasawa but liSA and Yui's voice actor are the same person believe it or not, look it up :)
sophgirl1 1 month ago
i love this song. reminds me what i stand for x3
whitemoongodess 2 months ago 2
@whitemoongodess so your a alchemist >3
abloodyfate 3 weeks ago
yes this cover is awsime tho be iwasawa in ti
daedae123ful 3 months ago
Keep The Beats!
Kai28000 3 months ago
How do I tell the difference between Yui and Iwasawa's?
anikid0392 4 months ago
@anikid0392 Their voices dont sound alike in the slightest lol its not hard to tell
BlackValleyRequiem 3 months ago
@anikid0392 Yui has a higher sounding voice. When you listen to Iwasawa's voice it sounds a bit deeper and stronger.
drew4614 3 months ago
Both of them are great
lollypop123452 4 months ago
Yui's version is pretty good but Iwasawa's is better
stkmutiny 5 months ago
@stkmutiny i thik so to^^
TheDavidBomberman 3 months ago
2 people experienced Yui's German Surplex.
sakurafran18 6 months ago 2
@sakurafran18 haha... LOL
jamesnidea 6 months ago
2 people are NPCs who transformed into shadows.
inday1724 7 months ago
wow, great version, like iwasawa's voice slightly better though =)
KurenaiKen 9 months ago 2
i love yui's voice, but the meaning of this song speaks for iwasawa's personality rather then hers, so emotions are stronger in iwasawa's version compared to yui.
yumesan87 1 year ago
I really like Yui's voice, but especially for this song I think Iwasawa fits better.
Listen to 3:37 and you'll know what I mean. That part sends chills down my spine when Iwasawa sings it.
HaleyJarvis 1 year ago 5
Comment removed
iOwnYouxP 1 year ago
I think those who perfer a more upbeat confident, rock ver. like Yui's personality would perfer Yui's voice
While those who perfer more softer, mellow, deeper ver. would like Iwasawa's voice, cause it fits Iwasawa's perosonality ^^
EchoKamelot 1 year ago
@EchoKamelot i like both ^.^
i have preferations, and at times i like one, and hate another
pinoyknight8 1 year ago
awesome.. <3
angelicAOIrain 1 year ago
In my opinion...
Both versions are great but i prefer Yui's voice compared to Iwasawa...She have a stronger and more melodic voice.
juppiecookies 1 year ago 2
@juppiecookies I agree with you. I like Yui's voice better but I still like Iwasawa's too. When Yui sings it sound like she has more confidence in her voice and like you said a more melodic voice
AnimeGirlLover012 1 year ago 3
tbh i think Yui fits better than Iwasawa on Alchemy =oo
MrCharaxify 1 year ago
i mean love Yui's versions of songs but I felt Crow Song and Alchemy and My Song were more for Iwasawa bc when she sang it she made me want to grab a guitar, with Yui...idk i mean i like it but the improvising at the end was not nessecary. (not hating on Yui just saying) i still like it overall.
jojofan671 1 year ago 3
The singing at the end was unneccesary.
Overall okay, minus the end.
darkspire91 1 year ago 2
Aaaaaaah, Yui's voice gives me goosebumps in this song!
Migochi 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
This version fucking sucks, this Yui broad is just belting it out instead of working with the rest of the band, overuses vibrato, and in terms of singing ability doesn't hold a candle to the voice actor/singer for Marina. Anyone that likes this version has no real understanding or appriciation of music.
Cillranchello 1 year ago
@Cillranchello both versions r great u suck!
katsupoi24 1 year ago 74
@Cillranchello If by that your saying "I enjoy naked men." then your getting the message across pretty clearly.
RaptorSpiralZebra 1 year ago 7
@Cillranchello LOL LOLL LOLLL, u have no *appreciation* of music either ;) im sure u dont understand either, so yea if your gonna hate, just don't listen x)
noelzelda 1 year ago
@Cillranchello Thatss Just Yourr Opinion Like Youu Can Do Anyy Better Thann Them.! >:P And Dontt Say Thingss Suck If Youu Cant Even Do Itt.
Animelover4ever1540 1 year ago
@Animelover4ever1540 Oh god. Please don't type like that.
Carrotqween 1 year ago
@Carrotqween
Lol
I know its just funny how all the popular people do that xDDD
Just felt random
Animelover4ever1540 1 year ago
@Cillranchello
As a fellow critic, I considered your opinion. After re-analyzing the music a number of times, I think you are right. People should not go straight into "flaming" that's a bad attitude... the concept of the song is "GREAT" but the way Yui sings is not great at all. That's what he is trying to say
sasarai95 1 year ago
@sasarai95 yeah right whatever that critic crap. I think both versions are good. thay both did well singing this song and even though iwasawa's ver. is better this ver. still rocks. whatever you people talk about...
lizzy11af 1 year ago
@Cillranchello didn't really have to say "fucking sucks" but i get your point and i would have to agree with you, btw i am a musician (can play guitar, bass, procussion, trumpet, learning violin)
steel16880 1 year ago
@steel16880 awesome i played violin 4 3 years...havnt actually pikd up 1 n like 3 years
0ddb411416 5 months ago
@Cillranchello I know a lot about music, and understand it really good. And I like it! So what if I like this version, that doesn't mean that I don't have real understanding or appriciation of music.
scratiegirl 7 months ago
@scratiegirl Apparently it does mean that. Amazing how even a year later you people are still trying to defend utter shit.
Cillranchello 6 months ago
@Cillranchello It doesn't, you just think that.
scratiegirl 6 months ago
@scratiegirl What I think happens to be reality. Keep defending shit, I haven't had an idiot to point and laugh at for quite a while, and I think you'll do just fine.
Cillranchello 6 months ago
@Cillranchello Why you so angry bra? Everyone loves different music some like rap others hate it, some like country others hate it, some like instrumental and once again others don't. Saying it's shit is your own opinion not a broadcast saying fact.
obigweyo 6 months ago
@obigweyo Because there's a difference between liking different types of music, and thinking that this abomination of a cover is a good song. Oh, and I'm not your "bra." I have no interest in holding your man-tits up, nor will I ever. Now will you keyboard monkeys do the world a favor and shut the hell up?
Cillranchello 6 months ago
@Cillranchello Once again that just proves you being a dick instead of a someone just simply saying I can understand your opinions but I disagree I like *insert type of song/music*. You're not being smart about music or anything, instead you're just proving how much of an idiot you are and how you apparently love to just troll.
obigweyo 6 months ago
@obigweyo Props to him though, he just trolled the hell out of all of you. Just to keep the ball rolling, I'd have to say that the original is much better. Iwasawa's voice suits the emotion of the song much better. @Cillranchello, one's thoughts do not display reality. Your thoughts only reflect your reactions to reality. We can not "shut the hell up"; we are typing, not talking. The way to say what you meant would be, "Now, will you keyboard monkeys do the world a favor and stop typing"
Dastrionix 5 months ago
@Dastrionix I agree about Iwasawa being more fitting, but still I like Yui's version because it'sdifferent. Also I'm just merely responding to him to see how far I could keep him going until he ran out of steam lol.
obigweyo 5 months ago
@obigweyo Einstein once said "Only two things are infinite: human stupidity and the universe, and we're not even sure about that latter." You have proved him right once again. Go slam your fingers under a piano's keyboard cover before your idiocy continues to spread.
Cillranchello 4 months ago
@Cillranchello Really? That's your comeback after a month? That's quite sad... You can't even make anything related to the video so you go to violence instead of coming back to my comment, congratulations I think you just proved both yourself & myself right. Opinions exist and people hate the Iwasawa just as you hate Yui's. Case being facts aren't proven from a clear genius like you that took a month to comeback with an irrelevant topic, go Einstein for being a genius am I right?
obigweyo 4 months ago
@obigweyo Just like this one took a month for me to come up with. Its not like I have a job and thus have the time to sit around and be a keyboard monkey all day... oh wait. Regardless, perpetuating the idea that this even remotely approaches "good music" is the reason singers(and I use the term loosely) like Katie Perry, Lady Gaga, and that insufferable little twat Justin Bieber are fleecing the world of its money. Musical appreciation in this country is dead.
Cillranchello 3 months ago
@Cillranchello You say job like you're the one with problems as though you're the only one with one, but hey guess what kid, most people do get them in their life if they want to succeed but that aside. While I agree with you about those singers being bad that doesn't mean others think so lady
gaga is terrifying with her music, does that mean her fanbase thinks so? No it doesn't you're just saying the same thing proving me right in the end, music has different meanings, learn to accept it...
obigweyo 3 months ago
Wow, both versions are awesome .
I sorta like Yui's a bit better cus she enunciates a bit better. This makes the anime's lyrics wrong at some partss o;
Tacoz88 1 year ago 4
Great song, although Iwasawa is better than Yui.
savetherocks 1 year ago 3
Comment removed
H0ngPhatBoi 1 year ago
Did the cover for this album make anyone else really sad? D:
CutApplesz 1 year ago 156
@CutApplesz Yeah I hate looking at cause it might bring tears to my eyes
xBmPxD 1 year ago
@CutApplesz T.T
chubakaslilhelper 1 year ago
@CutApplesz Only because it was WAY overpriced. I got this album from Anime Expo 2010 in LA and it cost me $70.00! Then the Iwasawa version was not on it. I was kinda sad.
CadaverousWound 1 year ago
@CutApplesz the album didin't make me sad but i did cry with joy to see that her strong will and passion is still with her band,
5476245 10 months ago
¬¬ recomendacion..... si van a subir videos, suban videos no basura con imagenes y musica
Lurizael 1 year ago
Ahh,
I think I love BOTH VERSIONS.
iheartcobblepot 1 year ago 3
Super sweet =))) Yui voice is Remarkable
Hikarusweet94 1 year ago 4
I LOVE IT!! ^O^ Awesome. thanks for the upload.
shyperson123 1 year ago