Added: 4 years ago
From: boobiieezmum
Views: 177,540
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (549)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • That's really sad. Is this a popular song at your country?

  • i am making a new version of this...one that actually rhymes :3

  • the cat is a dirty bum and needs to go get a job. who goes around random people's houses tryin to get in. and what self-respecting cat protects a mouse? this cat was obviously a smelly occupy protester and deserved her fate.

  • oh, and BTW the reindeer have no ability to cry, and they can' t talk, therefore proving that this song is made up. Oh, and why wouldn't the cat lay down by the house, nearest to a furnace, with the mouse? and why only rhyme once? why even bother to rhyme at all???

  • i listened to this song on the radio... WAHHH

  • This is a song that just shows us all how we could be.... set differences aside.... and that life is the greatest gift of all...... and to remember what others may have done for us in the past. Great song..... powerful.

  • Am I the only one who thought of Luke Skywalker inside the tauntaun on Hoth and thought this was funny? Or am I just a bad person?

  • @christojuice omg lol. you are so........complex

  • This was so sad!

  • i love it

  • BTW, I am not a cat-hater, I just don't get really sad.

  • This song is A) horrible, B) Deppressing, and C) WTF?!?!? It sounds like it was written in the 70's, and has the cheesiest (no pun intended) plot ever. And don't get me started on the lack of proper structure with the verses etc.

  • @blackwatchbandstudio omg you are so right

  • @theappletreeable Thanks.

  • lol wtf. This is actually the worst thing I have ever seen. It's just all around bad. And before anyone says "omggzzz you hate cats and you have no heart," that's not true. I love cats. And, speaking in the hypothetical, I would have let the cat inside both because cats are awesome and because then this song would have never happened.

  • @goatens thank you! i agree. I heard this song on Christmas Eve!!! whats worse is that I live in Minnesota, AND WE STILL AIN'T GOT NO SNOW!! so it was even more depressing. Did you realize that he/she (he?) only rhymed once.

  • awful lyrics. horrible to non-existant music.... ACK!!! gag 

  • to anyone posting about animal cruelty, this is a MADE UP song. With very VERY poorly composed lyrics. This was a terrible song, and I was unable to be saddened by it because the writing was so badly done, and the story is pathetic. There is no such thing as SANTA. And if there was I would imagine he could just as easily bring a dead cat to life again as to change the position of multiple planetary systems to form a cat constellation on Christmas every year. PUKE

  • @fjoris83 i agree, its just that when you first listen to it, specifically on the radio, you have to imagine everything, its just sad. Think, they only rhymed once.

  • COWARDS, LOSERS and SUPREME BOTTOM FEEDERS are those who prey on the innocent. |Anyone who mistreats an animal will graduate to people. Those who treat their pets like this are heartless and may karma find them.

  • @jgskls amen

  • that is sad i wish santa could bring her back to life or something..... poor cat, lucky mouse he must be lonely

  • This wasn't sad at all. And are you people on the comments stupid? Blatantly not real, why are you getting mad at the non-existent owners?

  • @pantscheese hey dued i didn't think this was sad at all till she died. anyway SHUT IT OK?????

  • @icecreampup I'm glad a 12 year old is telling me to suppress my opinions.

  • @pantscheese you have no heart...do you....

  • saddest song ever

  • this is as sad as the puff the magic dragon...or more

  • Q.Q 

  • so sad. but it made me also angry. The people who let the cat outside are horrible. I hope santa gave them nothing. Or a big fine.

  • This was so sad. I started bawling when the cat died and the mouse didnt even realize it....this was very sad....reminds me of my dog. How sweet she was...:...(

  • You can find that song among others if you can get a hold of A Canadian Family Christmas, that's where I first heard it. Sometimes when I look up at a starlit sky I remember this song. Meryn did a great job with it.

  • I didn't cry until the mouse started talking.

    now i still haven't stopped ;^;

  • Oh my god ;-; You're right this has got to be the saddest song ever.

  • The cat must be a Christ figure. Nice she got her own constellation.

  • Comment removed

  • THIS SONG IS HILARIOUS.

  • Well now I want to get hit by a truck..

  • Did anybody maybe think that nobody was home and THAT'S why the cat wasn't let inside? Huh?

  • There is a ninth circle of hell, where you listen to this, over and over and over and over and...

  • @dlc1119 Up to Nyan thousand times !

  • ive never heard this song before.

    and at first i was like "omg, how is this going to be sad?" but i actually had a tear or two roll down my cheek by the end.

    what a beautiful song.

  • Kailynn

  • I couldnt remember what this song was about, until I heard the first line again....was so not in the mood to feel sad today...I guess christmas shoes is next then lol

  • :'(

    

  • I wanna kill myself with this song!

  • mean people ignoring poor animals .. they should all ashamed !! please post on facebook pages to promote awareness !!

  • this is a joke right?

  • @glory1freerider You didn't cry?

  • @davidls11 no haha the pictures make me laugh!!

  • Horrible !

  • i cry everytime i here this song :'(

  • im sorry but i didnt cry i dont know why

    

  • I dont know but i cant stop it , fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu

  • WHY THE FUCK AM I CRYING SO MUCH??

  • I can't even describe the sadness.... I need to go adopt a cat and never let it go. 

  • o no poor cat D: :'()

  • I got to 3:05 without crying! And then... I never stopped...

  • Oh. My. God D:

  • oh i cried too!! that's the saddest song i've ever heard

  • oh, man, i cried so hard.

  • CBC Radio played this years ago, while i was wrapping gifts. talk about "snot and bawl"...it's slowly gaining in popularity in Canada. I mostly have heard it on public, university and country stations. thanks for posting, and thanks for the tears.

  • suck it cat oh wait your dead hahahahahahahah guess ya cant se it!

  • @jhshalo3 Why do bitches like you even comment on these kind of things?

  • I CRIED MY DICK OFF

  • oh ya! 84 ppl dont have a heart at all! the cruelest ppl ever. i mean who would do that!? lock a cat out like that! dumb owners i would never do that to my cat! thumbs up if u agree!

  • omg!!!!!!! 3 of my cats died and when i saw this video, i went into the bathroom and cried my eyes out!!!! it is sooo sad to me cuz i lost 3 of my cats and one dog!

  • OMG I'm crying omg this is so sad and I own a hamster so yeah omg

  • ;-;

  • In the Age of Irony, this song can only be played for laughs. I find that sadder than the song, which is pretty sad.

  • sad

  • This song is pretty sad.

  • I did cried to......

  • Omg, so sad.

  • :(

  • omg that is sooooooooooooooo sad i cried and i still am :'(

  • Bad song to listen to at the office...ugh

  • I cant stop crying i love cats so much this is the saddest song ever I AM SO SORRY POOR CAT!!!

  • @IwuvYou12342 ikr. so sad. i couldn't stop crying. iwas so embarrassed in the car when we heard this song.

  • What a beautiful sad song tears are running down my face

  • I cried and I wonder how the singers can sing without crying...

  • Very sweet, but not very well written. The message still gets through though. :)

  • i freaking cried with this song.... damn beautiful

  • idiot 

  • Where is Cujo????

  • @evan6905 i am cujo...NO I AM!

  • where is Cujo?

  • I can't believe how many people were actually sad at this!

    I thought it was freaking hilarious!

  • there're no enemy in the day of Giving...

    ever the cat still give her life to save the stranger(the little mouse)

  • Im sad that I cant stop crying I wish the cat Still had please tell my that the cat din't die

  • hahahhahhahah

  • i cried )': i bet the mouse was very sad when the cat died 79 people died in the snow i bet i wish the cat was still alive so sad

  • do all good things have to come out from sadness! :( I understand the logic of the story but its too sad!!! :'(

  • ok

  • how sad this I cryed  at the part when the cat died it remains me of my hamster and my simes cat simon my hamster died and simon got taken away

  • What was the point of this story? It was sad and poorly sung and written.  If it were a true story of an animal dying it would have meaning. As is, it has nothing and is just horrible.

  • The first time I heard this song, I was six. My mom saw this song on a CD, and thought that, because I *adored* cats, I would love the song. She could not have been more wrong. Suffice to say that at the end of this song, there was a severely scarred six year old standing there sobbing at the fact that the cat had frozen to death. This song still brings back bad memories... >_> Now that I'm older and actually get the meaning of it, though, it makes more sense. But six year old me did not get it.

  • Why are there so many cunts out there cruel to animals? I can't get that damn song out of my head and wish it was open season on pet neglect, no excuses, no second chances, punishable by death.

    Thinking about it though I wonder if the song is to try and get pet owners to look after their loved ones better.

  • I cried the first time i heard this song, It's so sad and touching.

    How she died for the the mouse and how those people could have saved he cat if they had let her in..let that be a lesson to you all...

  • lOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO­LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOOLOLOLOLOLOL­OLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLLOLOLOL

  • i would let them in my garage cause we has 2 hearters XP

  • Stupid Song!!

  • I found this hillarious.

  • I think you got the story messed up with Jesus, but okaaaayyyyy.

  • This wasn't very sad.

  • I started listening to this song and then my little brother started busting out crying ans hes 6

  • There is a good book on what to do with a dead cat. There are many practical uses eg. oven mitts (you will need two cats for this) so check out the book on amazon. Dont let a dead feline go to waste, ya hear!!!

  • I actually cried.

    The thing is, snow is an excellent insulator so the cat would've lived if the song was scientifically correct.

  • I cried :( God bless the people who will sacrifice their lives for the love of others..

  • I play this every Christmas & shed a tear. I'm owned by two cats

  • My mama played this for me this morning and I cried like a baby.... It's so beautiful and sad!!!!

  • I love this song my sister-in-laws mom played it for me years ago and felt bad for playing it for me cause I started to cry!! For those that think that this song isnt about the real christmas spirt need to look up the true meaning of christmas. Sense the song is about helping others. I also looked up that at one point there was a cat constilation called Felis that is no longer used..

  • I luv this prose about self-sacrifice.

  • Awwww. :(

  • :( i cried

  • this song i love it, i listen to it every year, it gives me hope that someone could be as kind as in the song

  • Meh, didn't find it sad at all. Probably because the prose was bad.

  • As sad as this is, this song speaks the true spirit of Christmas nothing more nothing less and acts as a metaphor for how we treat ourselves and others.

  • Whether it's good or not depends on the listener, I just noticed that some people were wondering why such a depressing song for Christmas. Maybe I'm wrong on the allegory. Personally, I think 99% of the Christmas songs out there sound the same: either orchestral choir, solo with acoustic guitar or piano, or some god awful pop rendition.

  • Thank-you for making this. I heard the song for the first time today driving home in a snowfall listening to the radio. I got home Hugged my two beloved cats and had to find The Cat Carole online. I found it here with your YouTube upload, Thanks.

    How can one not let a meowing cat in when it's that cold out. For Shame on them.

  • ...damn...I actually did tear up a little....geeze...

  • GLURGE!!!!!

  • GLURGE!!!!!

  • I think people dissing the song for its premise are missing the point. It's an allegory: cat = JC; mouse = mankind; Santa = JC's "dad"; constellation = heaven; etc. It's more of an Easter song passing itself off as a Christmas song, which is probably why some find it not in sync with the spirit of the season.

  • @Librarian127 Perhaps, or it really is just a terrible song.

  • theres only like 2 rhymes. wtf?

  • If you do not like the video, then don't say anything. I'm already sick of the comments that say, "This video sucks. I hate it." If it sucks, why did you watch it? Why did you comment? People have their own opinions, so please keep yours to yourself.

  • Cat Carol, what you've just said is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent song were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul.

  • @buniffa You cannot relate to this song because you are a GUY! I've played this in mixed crowds, and inevitably all the women are reduced to tears and the guys look around and don't understand.

    So you can't be dumber for listening it. You just don't have the empathy to understand why it's such a good song. And why so many people love it.

  • @samyruo101...I will call the wambulance for you

  • @flieswithtrout wow, way to be a total douche! let's see your superior singing videos, oh wait! YOU HAVE NONE! The fact you like cats does not change the fact that you rudely commented on this video. "Totally stupid." You sound like a five year old. Why did you even watch this video? Just to be a total troll? same thing to jennyhootoo. Get a life. So you don't like the song. Well 225 people do. It's a Christmas Song that is saddening, don't ruin the holiday cheer even more.

  • I think this is totally lame....and I love cats. The premise sucks, the rhyming....what rhyming. Totally stupid. Anyone who likes this song or...started crying, really needs a life...."Oh thank you Santa for saving us..."...COME ON. And a Cat constellation....Total Schmuckdom...LOSERS!

  • Comment removed

  • Aww soo sad. My cats sleeping on me right now so I'll big her tight

  • This is by far the worst song I have ever heard!! Not only are the lyrics terrible and there is no rhyming but the singer sounds like a pedofile dad. This song makes me angry!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • :,( NOOOOO Kitttty !!! D:

  • What is so sad about this song?, it just makes me want to stick needles in my ears.

  • wow this is a sad song

  • yuck.

    this song contradicts the "merry" in "merry christmas".

    i understand there's morals to be learned................

    but it just sounds bad.

    the tune is boring.

    and nothing rhymes.

    and i hate the artists voice.

    yuck.

    and i adore cats. soooooo....

  • you know wat?? go die in a hole TheCybelegoddess and dirtygirl1984 for not liking this beautiful song and for actually posting that you dont like this beautiful song

  • this is basiclly what happened to my cat but she was in a bag with all of her brothers and sisters and they were left out for the night. My cat was the only surviver. her brothers and sister kept her warm. She was the runt of the family. She died last year february and when my teaher showed this song i remembered her story so baby girl i love you.

    and how can people not like this song, it is beautiful.

  • im gunna leave those assholes out in the snow and not let them in my house.

  • so sad

  • The strong will survive. Welcome to nature. Nobody cries about the cute little Zebra that gets orally molested by the Lion in Africa now do they?

  • this song makes me cry

  • I have two cats and am getting ready to adopt another stray who has been living outside my back door. obw2468, perhaps the odor you smell, that you attribute to cats, is your nasty attitude and inability to bathe properly. I've never had a cat who didn't use the litter box. Apparently, your trailer smells like you.

  • I have two cats and am getting ready to adopt another stray who has been living outside my back door. obw2468, perhaps the odor you smell, that you attribute to cats, is your nasty attitude and inability to bathe properly.

  • this song is stupid. i get it, self sacrifice and blahblah, but seriously.... wtf? how about we think about the REAL reason we celebrate christmas, and not sugar coat it with fuzzy wuzzy bullsh!t.

  • Hilarious!

  • i hate this!!! omg tho it was a lil funny..but i hate it!!! soo annoying!!

  • What make s a good Christmas song these days? Someone dying! Yeah-next Christmas hit.

  • cats are useless, and you cat lovers - your house likely smells of cat feces and urine, so touching....it stings the nostrils.

  • I think obw2468 has a point...If you shit in the house and wait for someone to scrape it up for you.. santa would let you die too..cats are useless

  • I agree with ziloe. It was a selfless act for another. I have always said I would do the same and if placed in such a situation I will. I have much love for all and have always placed others above myself. I love all life, and have always been willing to sacrifice for others. I consider myself blessed with every opportunity I have had to help others.

  • Wow, you guys are missing the entire point of this video. Oh no, a cat died. We all get that. It sacrificed itself to save another; a selfless act for someone else and not even of its own kind.

  • @ziloe : How sad! So many could not understand the meaning of this song! :(

    I too was quite surprised at those who remained focused on the cat dying and not the sacrifice she made. Rather than making a meal out of this mouse to survive the cold night, she instead saved it's life by allowing it to curl up it's it's fur to keep warm. Thank you ziloe for trying to explain.

  • I love this song though it makes me cry so much!! Beautiful song!!

  • @bluediamond694 ur not worth arguing with..

  • yo obw2468 what the heck is ur problem? god...have a heart jerk face...what is sum1 thew u outside in the freezing snow on christmas eve..they should..

  • My neighbors found a kitty outside, brought her in and put her back outside a few days later because she said it was bad, so we brought it in, and it's so soft and white as snow, and it's like a little bulldog, walking around all tough, I <3 that cat! :)

  • This is so depressing. ugh.

  • Great song but.....

    The people that lived in that home that left the cat out should be shot in the face with buck shot!! Then left out to freeze!

  • I CRIED!!!! WAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

    WERES MY KITTY!

  • um....what the hell kind of christmas song is this?!

  • Old Shep is sadder, if only because it really did happen.

  • @TommyGuy1988

    im pretty sure, there were plenty of frozen cats and frozen mice out in the world when there's a blizzard going on. and im pretty sure Santa stops at certain houses, and talks to reindeer mice and cats

  • i hate cats, it should be left outside for the winter, if it dies...it dies.

  • @obw2468 And if you die...you die :] i hope you burn in hell.

  • @obw2468 if i could

    i would beat your ass so hard and you should be left outside for the winter and if you die....you die

    you son of a bitch

  • i cried with tears when i saw that

  • Oh gosh. The ending made me cry :[ I love kitties. WHO THE HECK WOULDN'T LET A KITTY COME INSIDE? I wish I could slep those peopl >.<

  • This is so sad... It was on a CD I borrowed, and just randomly listened to it... I heard the ending and burst into tears.... I'm still crying.... it's just so sad....

  • i say da owners should die!

    whos wit me?

  • @lubyooh15 Yeah... these cats do not have owners..

  • that is so pants

  • We have a grey skinny cat (male) that has not been home for almost three weeks.  I don't know where he is and this song has made me sad for him. I hope he comes home but I don't think he will. I am sad.