I'm not big on this. Not to take anything away from the guy in the video, he done a great job. I just don't think the piece is that great on the guitar. The guitar doesn't really do the piece justice.
I prefer your clean version, closer to Satie's original mood for it, from other ones circulating here on Youtube; those sort of kill the melancholy with pretentious and unnecessary ornaments, faster tempo and deleted silences.
i think we guitarists must resist the temptation to roll any of the chords in this piece. while pretty and a nice idiomatic expression, i don't find it an effective interpretation of satie's work.
I agree 100% nero. It's difficult to avoid adding those little flourishes, but for a piece like this you *have* to stop yourself, or the music suffers.
I would admit if he played it poorly, but kindly eat a dick. The man clearly knows this piece, and played it according to his own instincts, that's what music is meant to be. You are the people who will accept the most horribly made hollywood film with the most empty interpretation so long as it contained all the scenes from the book it was based on. Accuracy is not quality.
I couldn't more strongly disagree. It is our duty as guitarists to render any and all interpretations of the original composer's work. If we never made it our own then we're nothing more than recording machines and all versions would sound the same. I personally add vibrato to some of the notes. The effect was so good as to make my wife (a piano teacher) stop playing the piece on the piano.
very nice! and second... do you play violin, or perhaps viola? because your lefthand's fingers are a bit more curved than most guitar players (in my opinionated observation, anyways). but that's awesome!
I only know a little bit about classical guitar, but this is the finger positioning I was taught for playing classical. It is different from the "normal" way of playing guitar though, where your fingers are more straight.
yes, i can see. unfortunately, i do not know much myself. I wish to learn, but am so busy playing my other instruments i barely have time for guitar! well, it sounds beautiful!
Ah wonderful! Most of Erik's work can be played on guitar, but this is by far my favourite ^_^ If you could play gnossienne on guitar, if you haven't already, that would be a pleasure to hear! Thank you for the music, dear.
Can we leave his hair out of this (you're just jealous because it's shiny and bouncy) and focus on the actual piece? I think the guitar rendition is very good... it can definitely flow better, and with more practice you can achieve that.
Well no, I have to rectify myself Trois Gymnopedie 1, 2 and 3 are by Satie, Claude was just his great fan who orchestrated Satie´s Gymnopedies. Sorry about that! The pice of composition that I saw signed by Debussy was his adaptation of Gymnopedie #3 to orchestra. Once again my appologies for giving wrong information here.
First of all, yeah great ejecution however one tiny well actually big issue and that is that Trois Gymnopedie its NOT by the indiviudal you named there but by a French composer CLAUDE DEBUSSY. Debussy composed impressionist music, which was a musical stream within Modernism. Impressionism was a reaction to 19th century Romanticism.
First of all, yeah great ejecution however one tiny well actually big issue and that is that Trois Gymnopedie its NOT by the indiviudal you named there but by a French composer CLAUDE DEBUSSY. Debussy composed impressionist music, which was a musical stream within Modernism. Impressionism was a reaction to 19th century Romanticism.
First of all, yeah great ejecution however one tiny well actually big issue and that is that Trois Gymnopedie its NOT by the indiviudal you named there but by a French composer CLAUDE DEBUSSY. Debussy composed impressionist music, which was a musical stream within Modernism. Impressionism was a reaction to 19th century Romanticism.
Hey there, you might wanna make your pink finger from your right hand more relaxed or in some years from now you could get hurt. that happened to a very close friend of mine that played many years like that, had a awful tendinitis.
Amazing, You really put your heart into it. :)
MynameisLindsayB 5 months ago
The dude is practically ripped... u cnt play a guitar with beautiful piece of music with a ripped body... this is not right.. :P
lThellRockl 9 months ago
Thank you. That was beautifully done.
Engineerrhodes 10 months ago
Thank you. That was beautifully done.
Engineerrhodes 10 months ago
magnifique!!!!
nordine98 11 months ago
Is this in any special tuning?
nosharpieeyebrows 1 year ago
I knew that by clicking on the video with the asian i'd find a great video
delahouzzzze 1 year ago 14
I'm not big on this. Not to take anything away from the guy in the video, he done a great job. I just don't think the piece is that great on the guitar. The guitar doesn't really do the piece justice.
ByYourCommand 1 year ago 2
absolutely beautiful ! n __ n
cutestrawberryflower 1 year ago
PUKKA BRO ; )
jhighly 1 year ago
Only critique would be the tone and be sure to play the note for the full duration. Great job though!
therookie93 1 year ago
and than he pulls out his katana.
y3k23k 1 year ago 2
Muscular tough guy playing smooth classical piece = win & awesome
wangmsater 1 year ago
very well, but , as a modest advice, try tu keep the tempo when the first voice begins, everything else is good^^
FiatObscuritas 1 year ago
WOW - hauntingly beautiful. And great on the guitar - I would not have imagined.
sandybarefeet 1 year ago
great!
ixovicki 1 year ago
thanks for not rushing. very beautifully played
pppasoliniboa 1 year ago
agree, thanks for not rushing
pppasoliniboa 1 year ago
ahh my favorite song
ThatsaCryinShame 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
gay
ha1801 1 year ago
I prefer your clean version, closer to Satie's original mood for it, from other ones circulating here on Youtube; those sort of kill the melancholy with pretentious and unnecessary ornaments, faster tempo and deleted silences.
Your job is good. keep it up.
elemilex 1 year ago
Excellent job.
LordMgls 1 year ago
Great talent much love to the original and music in gen...
jhighly 2 years ago
even though i prefer to play it some slower, im really really impressed. very nice version of this lovely piece!
Recorne93 2 years ago
***** BEAUTIFUL TOM *****
chsgdss 2 years ago
very minimalist. Satie would be proud.
JackETProductions 2 years ago 4
one of my favourite pieces excellently executed!!!!5****** congrats greetings and respect from Bram D., Holland
beedeetripo 2 years ago
lol some1 tell me how to "kindly eatly a dick" lol explain that !!!!!
Doriii222 2 years ago
nice job man, any tab for this? would be great if u can provide
waves2waves 2 years ago
there are many tabs of this on the net. For example good page :classtab . org.
sammerro 2 years ago
Beautiful. Thank you!
titan164 2 years ago
such a peaceful song, well played and awesome hair!
tobnotch 2 years ago
i think we guitarists must resist the temptation to roll any of the chords in this piece. while pretty and a nice idiomatic expression, i don't find it an effective interpretation of satie's work.
neroadam 2 years ago 3
I agree 100% nero. It's difficult to avoid adding those little flourishes, but for a piece like this you *have* to stop yourself, or the music suffers.
scaffairl 2 years ago
I would admit if he played it poorly, but kindly eat a dick. The man clearly knows this piece, and played it according to his own instincts, that's what music is meant to be. You are the people who will accept the most horribly made hollywood film with the most empty interpretation so long as it contained all the scenes from the book it was based on. Accuracy is not quality.
VariedInterest 2 years ago 33
"kindly eat a dick" ?? wow, that's the first time I ever read that expression. Youtube comments are a world of fun to be enjoyed ahah
PutoEstupido 2 years ago 3
Well, at least he said to do it kindly...
Lymphaticnessicity 2 years ago 3
I know man, I know... I too was touched by the generosity in the choice of words ahahah :)
PutoEstupido 2 years ago 2
@VariedInterest
Best comment ever.
littledarlingsarah 2 years ago
I couldn't more strongly disagree. It is our duty as guitarists to render any and all interpretations of the original composer's work. If we never made it our own then we're nothing more than recording machines and all versions would sound the same. I personally add vibrato to some of the notes. The effect was so good as to make my wife (a piano teacher) stop playing the piece on the piano.
AlbvsDvmbledore 2 years ago
roll chords? what's that?
macoulin 1 year ago
02/09/09 Thanks for this video....great work. Very pleasant to listen to.
dynistys 3 years ago
very nice! and second... do you play violin, or perhaps viola? because your lefthand's fingers are a bit more curved than most guitar players (in my opinionated observation, anyways). but that's awesome!
falconwings7 3 years ago
I only know a little bit about classical guitar, but this is the finger positioning I was taught for playing classical. It is different from the "normal" way of playing guitar though, where your fingers are more straight.
jedimomma75 3 years ago
yes, i can see. unfortunately, i do not know much myself. I wish to learn, but am so busy playing my other instruments i barely have time for guitar! well, it sounds beautiful!
falconwings7 3 years ago
i think every guitarists in the world had its on way to play their guitar...
Kajaena 2 years ago
ok, most cool, now i wanna learn it. hail satie!
mrethrift 3 years ago
This is great.
hsantana91 3 years ago
duuuuuude... !!!!!!!!!!!!! nice!!
ImSlevin 3 years ago
just played this at the office at work, changed the nature of the day for everyone. cheers
spurtfather 3 years ago
Wonderful performance of this piece.
If you have a minute, please give my version a listen.
LeeEisenstein 3 years ago
At first I didn't like the sound of it on a guitar, but I carried on listening and you won me round, it was very nice.
katandanna 3 years ago
Ah wonderful! Most of Erik's work can be played on guitar, but this is by far my favourite ^_^ If you could play gnossienne on guitar, if you haven't already, that would be a pleasure to hear! Thank you for the music, dear.
CaddyCo 3 years ago
q bien!!!!
krajoywea 3 years ago
Very well played. You have done justice to the original piano classic. Keep it up! It is a beautiful song.
ajittffcure 3 years ago
This best of you I've seen so far. 6 strs.
Man 3 years self-taught. You play awesome and some fulte and YOU WILL BE FIRST CLASSICAL GUITAR MAN WHO DO TUMBLING AND DO IT WAY EXCELLENTE
Friendly BlueJazzyClassic
BlueJazzyClassic 3 years ago
¡TÚ SÍ QUE VALES!
LuisSFC 3 years ago
GREAT PERFORMANCE! can i have your own version of gymnopedie in guitar thanks!
wincot2 3 years ago
I loved this, and i love your hair, lol. For clarification, this is by Erik Satie (the shortened name of Alfred Éric Leslie Satie)
blackfireINSANITY 3 years ago
Well done! ...and thanks for not rushing it.
wa0000 3 years ago 8
Thanks!
tominthemtn 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@wa0000 agree, thanks for not rushing
pppasoliniboa 1 year ago
Can we leave his hair out of this (you're just jealous because it's shiny and bouncy) and focus on the actual piece? I think the guitar rendition is very good... it can definitely flow better, and with more practice you can achieve that.
Keep it up!
warmfuzzy1223 3 years ago
sounds like 3. very good either way.
AnotherCompartment 3 years ago
er...i've been listening to 1 and thinking it's 3...sorry about that.
AnotherCompartment 3 years ago
Well no, I have to rectify myself Trois Gymnopedie 1, 2 and 3 are by Satie, Claude was just his great fan who orchestrated Satie´s Gymnopedies. Sorry about that! The pice of composition that I saw signed by Debussy was his adaptation of Gymnopedie #3 to orchestra. Once again my appologies for giving wrong information here.
Ciao Heliana
sapphoetry 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
To serve as a lesson for you in life.
fl4vio 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hi there,
First of all, yeah great ejecution however one tiny well actually big issue and that is that Trois Gymnopedie its NOT by the indiviudal you named there but by a French composer CLAUDE DEBUSSY. Debussy composed impressionist music, which was a musical stream within Modernism. Impressionism was a reaction to 19th century Romanticism.
Greetings Heliana
sapphoetry 3 years ago
Hi there,
First of all, yeah great ejecution however one tiny well actually big issue and that is that Trois Gymnopedie its NOT by the indiviudal you named there but by a French composer CLAUDE DEBUSSY. Debussy composed impressionist music, which was a musical stream within Modernism. Impressionism was a reaction to 19th century Romanticism.
Greetings Heliana
sapphoetry 3 years ago
Hi there,
First of all, yeah great ejecution however one tiny well actually big issue and that is that Trois Gymnopedie its NOT by the indiviudal you named there but by a French composer CLAUDE DEBUSSY. Debussy composed impressionist music, which was a musical stream within Modernism. Impressionism was a reaction to 19th century Romanticism.
Greeting Heliana
sapphoetry 3 years ago
estupendo
mikirod 4 years ago
interesting hair
ykidkwis 4 years ago 2
Stop using the shampoo of ur girlfriend:P Nah, let's leave it with interesting indead!
samuraimacisthebest 3 years ago
Hey there, you might wanna make your pink finger from your right hand more relaxed or in some years from now you could get hurt. that happened to a very close friend of mine that played many years like that, had a awful tendinitis.
Try resting the pink finger on your A finger.
great playing btw, keep up the good work!
cheers
DaGuittarMan 4 years ago 5
beautiful, just beautiful.
sundownxx 4 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
r u male or female?
gnaggwatschn 4 years ago
Gotta love the jelousy.
a08f 4 years ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
female I think
pipaswrc 4 years ago
Personally i tink its better than the piano one !
sdwboi 4 years ago
You're great man. Nice flows and feelings.5/5
tk100 4 years ago 6
not bad. good sound. try playing a little more relaxed. it must swing..
grosucelmic 4 years ago
Why should it swing? It's not jazz. There are a couple of timing issues, but overall I think the playing is great and it sounds lovely on a guitar.
dompflaum 4 years ago
Fantastic Playing
AscendentInLeo 4 years ago 4
very nice!
otakasama2 4 years ago 3
this is really cool. im learning this song on the piano. i should really learn it on the guitar.
abrofl 4 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ur head is like a mushroom
AnnaNRaz07 4 years ago
Buena, esta linda, no es rapida, es precisa al instrumento..
Cesarpotamo 4 years ago 2
nice
jakkypersill90 4 years ago 2
I have found this play aslo on my guitar but it's doesn't sound so good.
this sounds much better!!
moechoeke1912 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
get a hair cut chang
tommy1tit 4 years ago
I LOVE THIS SONG I WAS SURCHING SO LONG FOR THE NAME! finaly i find it!
ScheissLeben 4 years ago
Nice music
5*
stephenlukman 4 years ago
la linea melodica un poco rapida ,lastima!
agelical 4 years ago
nice. also,nice hair.
bakdgreat 4 years ago
i love it!!!!!!!
apparentlynotalone 4 years ago
I've listened to a few versions of this song on here played on guitar. I like this one the best, really nice smooth gentle interpretation. Superb.
PhilMoisey 4 years ago
nice! now try chopin =)
Jackthazipper 4 years ago
Wow!! What a hair!
XMQCWe 4 years ago
fantástica mezcla japonesa, española y francesa, desde la tierra de la guitarra,
felicidades, very good interpretation and good instrument, congratulations from
spain
jjarcos1 4 years ago
Wow, that must have been tough to play! Thumbs up!
teoani 4 years ago
I was wondering if there were any tablature that you can provide so i can learn to play this song on guitar as well? Thank you
DeathButton 4 years ago
I can't believe somebody interpreted this song with acoustics instead, i love it! You did a very great job :)
DeathButton 4 years ago
very beautiful
ophelia219us 4 years ago
i'm impressed...
jtjtjtjt222 4 years ago
Very smooth, a tough thing to accomplish on the guitar playing Gymnopedie, cheers!
twodeadpoets 4 years ago
Great interpretation
pejay89 4 years ago