It's funny how Billie and Tre and Mike respect these people's talent enough to CHOOSE them to sing their songs in THEIR musical, but you can't see what an amazing cast that is. Also, how can you all mistake Billie Joe Armstrong for John Gallagher, Jr.? that's just weird.
I love how everyone is comparing this to JB(who isn't bad live by the way say him in KC last summer and loved it) but honestly if y'all hate Justin Bieber soo much then don't bring him up!! It's not that hard!! Loved this video by the way very good job!!! :)
@abannanna01 seriously? Why is this not as good as auto-tuned Justin Bieber? This is not as good as the album or on the broadway stage, but it sure is better than Justin Bieber and Katy Perry live.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Very very poor intonation. I would expect the cast to be higher quality. As an ensemble, they work well, but as soon as it comes time to solo, it starts to sound like some atonal mess of compressed, lossy audio. Listen to what they have done to the band's sound to fit the vocalists in the mix. Pathetic. The nice thing about the poor intonation is that it assures the listener that what is going on is "real," but i would almost prefer justin bieber-esque pitch correction to this sloppy mess.
@MrBrazilianSensation How are they out of tune? 0.o Of course the studio version is great, but that's obviously because it's studio fancy. They're actually very much in tune, but you can't blame them for small mishaps here and there since they're singing live.
@TheGnomePoker.. YOU need to do your research. Green Day combined some of their songs from 21st Century Breakdown into the stage version of Amercian Idiot.
@VaarVlogs This song, along with many other Green Day songs, is from Green Day's own broadway musical, and this is the cast of the show. It sounds fantastic, and if you were a true fan, shouldn't you know about this?
@cassieinwonderland17 Tony Vincent plays St Jimmy and he's not in this video...the guy with the bluish tint to his hair is Michael Esper, he plays Will.
this is so the best musical ever! I never thought i'd want 2 c a musical until American Idiot hit the stage, tho i wish they they didnt include any 21stCB so they couldda made 21st Centry Breakdown a musical 2! but wtvr this is so cool
Seriously one of the best shows I've ever seen! (based on seeing 50+ different broadway/west-end shows)
Go and see American Idiot if you have the chance!
usemyfullname 1 week ago
that girl has the most bass hair
tanty151 2 weeks ago
It's funny how Billie and Tre and Mike respect these people's talent enough to CHOOSE them to sing their songs in THEIR musical, but you can't see what an amazing cast that is. Also, how can you all mistake Billie Joe Armstrong for John Gallagher, Jr.? that's just weird.
And Rebecca's eyes are beautiful, shut up.
Olina231 3 months ago
too much off pitch, especially from the first guy.
evrekoa 4 months ago
I love how everyone is comparing this to JB(who isn't bad live by the way say him in KC last summer and loved it) but honestly if y'all hate Justin Bieber soo much then don't bring him up!! It's not that hard!! Loved this video by the way very good job!!! :)
ChristiElizabeth10 5 months ago
I saw this live and unexpectedly burst into tears over this song.....this kid can sing
sophie3801 7 months ago
I like how the girl sings but she creeps me out thumbs up if you agree!!!;D
melinajz 8 months ago
@melinajz i was thinking that too
iRunxKnife 7 months ago
gr8 song ruind by those posers
TheDrunkenBirdies 8 months ago
@TheDrunkenBirdies dude. its a MUSICAL!
beingepicisepic 8 months ago
everyone hush. theres no controversy. green day turned american idiot and a few other songs into Broadway. get over it. dont like it? dont watch.
snook89794 8 months ago
guys, he's called BILLIE Joe Armstrong, not billy... --'
matitead 9 months ago 2
the last guy is trying to hard to like billy joe armstrong. lets be honest..
number1lakeboy 10 months ago
Comment removed
MrsTanzfieber 9 months ago
@MrsTanzfieber learn how to speak proper english then come and talk to me.
number1lakeboy 9 months ago
i dont like the second black girl.
number1lakeboy 10 months ago
Amazing vocals excellent music
RohanFilms8258 10 months ago
@abannanna01 seriously? Why is this not as good as auto-tuned Justin Bieber? This is not as good as the album or on the broadway stage, but it sure is better than Justin Bieber and Katy Perry live.
vichewy 11 months ago
@abannanna01 you are a genuine douche bag! Just appreciate it for what it is!
TB300m 11 months ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Very very poor intonation. I would expect the cast to be higher quality. As an ensemble, they work well, but as soon as it comes time to solo, it starts to sound like some atonal mess of compressed, lossy audio. Listen to what they have done to the band's sound to fit the vocalists in the mix. Pathetic. The nice thing about the poor intonation is that it assures the listener that what is going on is "real," but i would almost prefer justin bieber-esque pitch correction to this sloppy mess.
abannanna01 1 year ago
i love this song!!! <3
cca9911 1 year ago
I freakin' love this, I saw them on Broadway before Christmas :)
MarinVillalpando15 1 year ago
How are they flat?
They're not....
msRluvsU 1 year ago
Are you people insane?
This is a great arrangement, so get the stick thats stuck up your ass out.
uniquelike 1 year ago 17
The recorded version is better.
Dillestman 1 year ago
@Dillestman Yeah, the studio version is so beautiful, but in this one they sing so out of tune. Pretty disappointing :(
MrBrazilianSensation 1 year ago
@MrBrazilianSensation How are they out of tune? 0.o Of course the studio version is great, but that's obviously because it's studio fancy. They're actually very much in tune, but you can't blame them for small mishaps here and there since they're singing live.
MarinVillalpando15 1 year ago 4
I love all the ignorant Green Day fans commenting on this.
AmericaDevil 1 year ago 3
this sucks
Radicaljim93 1 year ago
Omg, Lame, weres green day, you guys made this song Lame,get off the stage,sing one of ur own songs ppl
SassyQuinn99 1 year ago
@SassyQuinn99 You want the cast of a Green Day musical to sing one of their "own" songs?
AmericaDevil 1 year ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
FAIL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! BILLIE JOE SHOULD SING IT NOT THIS LADY WHO LOOKS CONSTIPATED LOOKS AT HER EYES WTF?!?!?!??!?!
claton3451 1 year ago
i love this song. i freaking hate advertisements.
MakeupBySav 1 year ago
1:59
HI BILLIE!!!!<3 ...oh wait nevermind O_o
icebearMP3 1 year ago
man i just wanna c billie walk in with his black acoustic and tear there ass's up!!!!haha
MrGreenday1209 1 year ago
0:00
MrsTanzfieber 1 year ago
@TheGnomePoker.. YOU need to do your research. Green Day combined some of their songs from 21st Century Breakdown into the stage version of Amercian Idiot.
versmilitude 1 year ago 20
This comment has received too many negative votes show
1. a guy should be singing
2. fucking 21 guns is not from "american idiot" do ur research
3. she sucks
4. shes a ugly fucker.
5. im done.
TheGnomePoker 1 year ago
1:59 i thought billie walked in
applicoto 1 year ago
SUCKS
applicoto 1 year ago
this.sucks.ass
emogurl0110 1 year ago
what the hell i thought BIllie Joe would walk in that is so messed!
theshadowofafigure 1 year ago
I saw this show last night, this scene made me cry :(
bluesquirellbaby 1 year ago
:( I thought that billie would have walked in at 1:38 lol
bundoranboy1 1 year ago
i love their hand signals :D
Namahoelove 1 year ago
2 American idiots have disliked this masterpiece.
MRresievil310 1 year ago
@VaarVlogs This is the cast of the Broadway show "American Idiot" based on Green Day's album.
MikeNY911 1 year ago
omg one of those guys look like billie joe armstrong!!!!!!!!!!ahh i love u GREENDAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
TheGreenday1999 1 year ago
i dont get why do they do this ??? a group like this needs to make up there own songs ... not steal someones song and make it sound gay....!!
VaarVlogs 1 year ago
@VaarVlogs this is from a GREEN DAY play XD
SHADOWBLAZIKEN1 1 year ago
@VaarVlogs This song, along with many other Green Day songs, is from Green Day's own broadway musical, and this is the cast of the show. It sounds fantastic, and if you were a true fan, shouldn't you know about this?
broadwaybaby6298 9 months ago
That was soo cool!! The guy with the black hair in the front plays St. Jimmy right? He's really cute kinda how I imagined St. Jimmy.
cassieinwonderland17 1 year ago
@cassieinwonderland17 Tony Vincent plays St Jimmy and he's not in this video...the guy with the bluish tint to his hair is Michael Esper, he plays Will.
TreCoolIsMineBetch66 1 year ago
this sucks! only greenday can pull it off
nascarman24 1 year ago
only Green Day can sing this song right!
Byakuya1451 1 year ago
this is so the best musical ever! I never thought i'd want 2 c a musical until American Idiot hit the stage, tho i wish they they didnt include any 21stCB so they couldda made 21st Centry Breakdown a musical 2! but wtvr this is so cool
heartgernadeidiot 1 year ago
i know becca's tattoo is fake, but what does the 5 mean???
zacluvr18 1 year ago
awesome, except for the fact that they are singing it wrong.
silverblood99 1 year ago
Like
Amazingvid101 1 year ago
Broadway Musical
MattCB26 1 year ago
Yay!!!
GaiasBatweasel 1 year ago
@GaiasBatweasel
Whoa wait? Is this the Cast for the Broadway Musical or America's Got Talent?
GaiasBatweasel 1 year ago