It is really hard to master with feeling of this emotional and fast third movement. You just did a wonderful job, Charlie! And you made quite a few improvements in this video.
Bravo, Charlie. Val just learned the 1st movement. I think it will be a couple of years before he is able to handle this one. You did a great job on a difficult piece.
Wow! All I can say is Wow! Such a hard piece and almost no mistakes! I love your clear pedaling and the ornaments! And how do you master the octave trill so easily? I will have rated this 999,999 google plex if it was possible.
An excellent performance, especially for his age. Most pianists tend to play this movement too fast, but Charlie is in total control. The ending was really beautiful. Bravo!
Love this performance! ~ Must learn it myself !
ancientsolar 3 months ago
This performance is awesome, Charlie!!
pcleo123 1 year ago
Is this Charlie's favourite piece?
He plays this in many videos :-)
Whatever It's my favourite part from the Moonlight Sonata!
nico13112008 1 year ago
@nico13112008 2 videos of this piece doesn't seem like "many" to me ...
coffeetea 1 year ago
Charlie, you are so amazing.
You have such talents in music. Congratulations for the wonderful solo recital.
pianolover1004 1 year ago
I am just learning this piece. It is soooo hard!
The C# arpeggio is fairly easy for me, then comes the next part.
Holding the G# in the left hand didn't feel right. Did you do that?
ThePVGS1 1 year ago
@ThePVGS1 Charlie typed this:"I didn't do it since I couldn't stretch without breaking in the middle from G# to A. I would have done it otherwise."
coffeetea 1 year ago
Ahhh..you make it look easy ... you are one bundle of a talent!
blueyoyi 1 year ago
It is really hard to master with feeling of this emotional and fast third movement. You just did a wonderful job, Charlie! And you made quite a few improvements in this video.
OldRabit 1 year ago
Whoever spammed this good-advice, wonderful comment, is trying to criticize this wonderful performance and that will not be the case here!
APRCVG188 1 year ago
Bravo, Charlie. Val just learned the 1st movement. I think it will be a couple of years before he is able to handle this one. You did a great job on a difficult piece.
italco312 1 year ago
Good job!
Kittypiano 1 year ago
It is amazing to see you master such a difficult piece at this age. Besides that, you played so beautifully. Congratulations!
Rayfeng2001 1 year ago
Wow! All I can say is Wow! Such a hard piece and almost no mistakes! I love your clear pedaling and the ornaments! And how do you master the octave trill so easily? I will have rated this 999,999 google plex if it was possible.
When are you turning 10?
ThePVGS1 1 year ago
A beautiful performance. It would be better if Charlie shows some body movement according to the music.
chaingin91 1 year ago
hey charlie.that was so amazing!
maulanazakky 1 year ago
Great Performance Charlie, you are amazing.
davidvlds 1 year ago
Nice!
rsoeyadi 1 year ago
this little guy will never stop to impress me! ARGH! that was beastly
hamelkarl 1 year ago
Wonderful performance, Charlie!
elainemusic369 1 year ago
An excellent performance, especially for his age. Most pianists tend to play this movement too fast, but Charlie is in total control. The ending was really beautiful. Bravo!
abhikmazumder 1 year ago
Wonderful performance, Charlie!
Did you play this in front of your classmates? They must be so impressed!
pianogirl98 1 year ago
A beautiful performance, Charlie. Thanks very much.
gerardbedecarter 1 year ago