I'm learning this song with my choir at the minute for a competition next month and trust me it's a lot harder than it sounds some of the intervals are extremely awkward and it is incredibly difficult to sing this song note for note
It was just okay. I feel like it felt somewhat rushed in the best parts. This song is so great because it's so simple, and I don't think you all captured that all too well, though lots of great things happening as well!
Music cannot be determined by "easy" or "hard", but by how the director, and the performer interprets, and then by how well he or she masters it. I have seen many extremely talented a performer take beautiful music and devalue, degrade, and demean it for their own ego. When done properly, you walk away changed, better, uplifted and it lives on inside you forever. Kudos to the NH allstate!!! As a choir director myself, I loved it. Thank you.
I sang this in my high school choir sophomore year. It's been four years and the song is still my favorite. Not an easy piece, but when done correctly it's absolutely beautiful. Amazing job!
No just saying that the choir I was in I'm more partial to and enjoyed the feel of our interpretation more. Our director showed us this recording when we picked it so it's not that this isn't a moving interpretation. Just different than our. Not bad, just different.
Not to discredit what this group has done with this live but my high school chamber choir did this song for state contest and I personally believe the interpretation we had on it was much better and more moving than this one
One thing i really like about this choir is that you can hear all of the parts.. Good job this song is a difficulty piece were doing at my school ..but very nice sound :)
@motdt81 It's Lauridsen. He doesn't write the easiest stuff, but he writes some damn great stuff. We sung this at AYC this year, and it turned out really well.
with the hel they put you through, how does someone in the guys not have this memorized, i just got it last week, and have it memorized, and thats just cuz its so beautiful, but thats not even for allstate or all county, its for school xD
Nice job! This piece is sneaky difficult. The opening men's part is almost impossible to get just right. We did this piece this year with Pennsylvania's all-state chorus.
I'm learning this song with my choir at the minute for a competition next month and trust me it's a lot harder than it sounds some of the intervals are extremely awkward and it is incredibly difficult to sing this song note for note
Davyross02 1 week ago
It was just okay. I feel like it felt somewhat rushed in the best parts. This song is so great because it's so simple, and I don't think you all captured that all too well, though lots of great things happening as well!
ralphyy1234 1 month ago
oh, p.s. if you want a difficult version look up westminster chorus version!
kingofsng 2 months ago
let's just say "It's easy to sing, difficult to sing well!"
kingofsng 2 months ago
Music cannot be determined by "easy" or "hard", but by how the director, and the performer interprets, and then by how well he or she masters it. I have seen many extremely talented a performer take beautiful music and devalue, degrade, and demean it for their own ego. When done properly, you walk away changed, better, uplifted and it lives on inside you forever. Kudos to the NH allstate!!! As a choir director myself, I loved it. Thank you.
robertdwilhelm 2 months ago
I sang this in my high school choir sophomore year. It's been four years and the song is still my favorite. Not an easy piece, but when done correctly it's absolutely beautiful. Amazing job!
scwooten0510 2 months ago
the men's section is to die for
dipsaucerose 3 months ago
not a fan of the 'ha-ha-ha-ha-ining night" but its realllyyyyy goooodddd other than that
jive0in 3 months ago
Beautifully conducted and sung. Love the slow tempo and beautiful ritardandos....hauntingly beautiful music by James Agee.
kathryncolantonio 4 months ago
@kathryncolantonio The text is by Agee - music by Lauridsen.
HeroicOaf 3 months ago
this piece is so beautiful, my choir is singing this for our winter concert and i am so excited(:
slspartanlvr59 4 months ago
I'm excited! Its one of the all state audition songs and I love it(:
xSimplyGeorgiex 4 months ago
Lovely diction for a lovely piece, sung expressively by wonderful young voices.
ChrissieVin 5 months ago
No just saying that the choir I was in I'm more partial to and enjoyed the feel of our interpretation more. Our director showed us this recording when we picked it so it's not that this isn't a moving interpretation. Just different than our. Not bad, just different.
superduperbeans1234 7 months ago
Not to discredit what this group has done with this live but my high school chamber choir did this song for state contest and I personally believe the interpretation we had on it was much better and more moving than this one
superduperbeans1234 11 months ago
@superduperbeans1234
your point?
kyleklosemusic 10 months ago
@superduperbeans1234
Do you base what you say on any sort of evidence?
I know Dr. Galvan personally through my college work with her, I bet you wouldn't say that to her face, heh.
thepianerist 7 months ago
You guys sound amazing! Thanks for the great music!
kmantexas 11 months ago
One thing i really like about this choir is that you can hear all of the parts.. Good job this song is a difficulty piece were doing at my school ..but very nice sound :)
1413cece 11 months ago
I wouldn't call this song an easy piece. I was in this choir, and it took some work.
motdt81 1 year ago 7
@motdt81 It's Lauridsen. He doesn't write the easiest stuff, but he writes some damn great stuff. We sung this at AYC this year, and it turned out really well.
jquinn57 3 months ago
why would such a prestigious choir perform such an easy piece?
mightymasher19 1 year ago
@mightymasher19
this Is NOT an easy piece. it was premiered by a professional choir.
mothermusic1 3 months ago
We had Dr. Janet Galvan the year before for NY All State Choir. She is really a treat to work with and she taught us so many things. All in 3 days!
Lill1anable 1 year ago 2
You should hear Texas' All State choir!
jdbachman17 1 year ago
This was another of my favorites! i was in this group last spring, and Dr galvan was beyond incredibly good. :)
MorganTheTenor 1 year ago 2
with the hel they put you through, how does someone in the guys not have this memorized, i just got it last week, and have it memorized, and thats just cuz its so beautiful, but thats not even for allstate or all county, its for school xD
jmd10of14 1 year ago
thats an allstate pianist????
10ccsoccer 1 year ago
a poem about what lies beyond this Earth and realm.
It's about longing for a place that must certainly eclipse the seemingly insurmountable beauty and light of this life.
In this poem, Agee is weeping for that place...
"On this night, when the stars are so bright as to leave shadows on the ground, Fate (or maybe a Guardian Angel) had better keep a close eye on me."
"Because, though all is warm and happy around me here on Earth, I long for what lies beyond this life."
terribleswede3 1 year ago
I have to say that I think Dr. Galvan has one of the better interpretations of this piece
yike4 1 year ago 3
Nice job! This piece is sneaky difficult. The opening men's part is almost impossible to get just right. We did this piece this year with Pennsylvania's all-state chorus.
VoiceofReason06 1 year ago
Yeah I was in this group too, learned a lot about vocal technique
matt1163544 1 year ago
I love this piece so much, it's so beautiful
RandomReviewer01 1 year ago
This is great for a high school group!
CDRphoenix 1 year ago 4
@CDRphoenix it is an all state group though hahahaa
ganekelioque 6 months ago
Thanks, for a wonderful recording of this piece. You have an incredible conductor. Kudos to Dr. Galvan.
mattjude371 1 year ago 7
@mattjude371 I was actually in this group and she was an amazing instructor. I've never learned so much from a vocal teacher in such little time
okeydokeyjones27 1 year ago
@okeydokeyjones27 same here
Wuhhhht 1 year ago