[Top 10] Melinda Doolittle - "Heaven Knows"

[1952spencer]

The other girl was OK, but honestly Melinda should of won it hands down. I was so disappointed that she didn't win I stopped watching AI ever since.

[AirKAT08]

The greatest and the most brilliant & amazing idol contestant ever...!

[creolelady182]

Simon Cowell is fed up with the untalented contstants that are now coming in. Great Talents like Melinda Doolittle and Susan Boyle are a rarity. They are classically trained.

[filomango69]

i never thought much about this song. but melinda made it quite memorable, angst-y, longing, loving. bravo!

[JRRDPR]

I sooo love this performance!!!

[Silviumarin]

Absolutely Fantastic.

[54spiritedwill54]

great performance as usual.

[JRRDPR]

She had the best choice od songs in all the shows I have seen.Thank you so much for the pleasure.:-)

[ghbaby08]

and you have negative brain even 2 years later I'm sure

[ajanijam]

this was one of melinda's best performance.

[DarkreveletioN]

season 6 is just pointless =]

they should give her the win right now

[phillyvocalist]

You couldn't have said it better.

[marc1john]

Loved her outfit and yet again, she was the best fish in the water. Just give her the crown...

[nudebeme]

The song didnt show off how fantastic her voice is, but it showed a super side of her too. ( i dont see why the outfit is bad, maybe its the spandex)

[dlfunky]

i liked her outfit i thought it a modern and fit the perfomance. Who knew she had such great legs?! her performance though was a bit preditcable i am sick of the diva songs it wasnt her best i would like to see her strech herself more now - sing something people arent expecting. I think she will be good with the tony bennet stuff though.

[phillyvocalist]

I somewhat agree but in the last 5 seasons have we had many females that can really OWN diva songs like Melinda? I don't think so. Embrace them! :)

[savira]

Like Simon said, it may not be her best performance. But I'm glad she lightens up a bit sings an up-tempo song for a change. And I think the outfit looks cute on her too.

Basically she's amazing. Fuck AI, she should just make a record right now.

[mariahfan444]

Well what can I say...another A+ performance. For those who thought she needed more versatility, there you go. She can also sing up-tempo songs very well. And its not Melinda's fault that it wasn't her best (according to Simon), because she's been PHENOMENAL in all her performances that to top the previous week would be nearly impossible. And another thing...I'm no fashion expert (I'm a guy), but I don't see why Simon hates what she's wearing. I think she looks great!

[MTSMN]

I agree and like you said, I don't see what's wrong with the outfit.

[wallykget]

a minute and a half is too short. great performance as usual.