Fantastic!! I just heard his Mozart's piano concerto when driving, and it was phenomenal! I came home and googled him, this is an interesting musician, and genius!
Negatif yorumlar Fazıl SAY'ın piyano çalışına veya müzisyenliğine yönelik değil; karakterine ve kendini ifade ediş şekline yönelik. Farklılıklara karşı hoşgörüsüz, acımasız, saygısız.. Bu arada, kendisi İyi bir piyanist, ama iyi bir bestekar değil. Notaları kullanarak, zeka ürünü ojinal ve güzel algoritmalar oluşturabildiği pek söylenemez. Nadiren oluşturduğu hoşluklar belli ki taklit veya tesadüf eseri. Ortalama zekaya sahip birinden iddialı yaratıcılıklar zaten beklenemez.
This has long been a favourite of mine, and I grew up with the faster interpretation so I dont see what all the fuss is about. I also play it the faster was myself - to me the concept of a Tempest is storms and rolling seas, so it should be powerful and dynamic. I find Kempff’s interpretation too romantic and “moonlight-esque”.
This is just my personal opinion, but I find it strange that so many people believe there is a “right” or “wrong” interpretation. INTERPRETATION. The clue’s in the word
Fazıl SAY'ın yüz ifadeleri ne kadar itici ve doğallıktan uzak. Her şeyiyle zorlama, yapay bir karakter. Bu şeyin meşhurluğu belli ki Nazım Hikmet vasat şairinin meşhurluğuyla aynı sebepten: ideolojik. Hoşgörüsüz bağnaz bir cahil, nota bilse ne olur, bilmese ne olur? Meşhur olsa ne olur, olmasa ne olur? Kâmil insan olmadıktan, adam olmadıktan sonra...
I love this piece of music! Interesting style; personally I don't like it as much as other versions I've encountered but it's still brilliantly played.
Hani bir hikaye vardır ya; sonu şöyle biter: "Ben sana vali olamazsın demedim, adam olamazsın dedim". Tam o hikayelik bir durum: "Canım Fazılım, ben sana nota bilmiyorsun, meşhur değilsin" demedim. "Adam değilsin." dedim. Neden sana benzemeyenlere karşı bu kadar tahammülsüzsün? İnsanı olgunluğa ulaştırmayan bilgi ne kadar kıymetlidir? Hazır köklerini farketmiş veya arayış içindeyken, nerede bizim ortak yaşama kültürümüz, hoşgörümüz? Ah yavrum ahhh
Phenomenal pianist!!He plays in a very unique style!!His own style!!!As for Kempff,he is also a very good pianist with a completely diffirent temperament!!I don' t think that we have to compare them!!Every great pianist has something to say!!
Anyway: Tempest is storm, tempest is Beethoven. Kempf, Barenboim and others play this like romance. Richter is closer to Say but nor he expresses the very nature of the composition. ... I think so.
(I understand if people dislike the Say´s style - they simply prefer more classical and smooth music. Maybe 386 other prefer tension, emotion, and good show :)
What a sense is there to hear 'a wrong note in 1:43'? what does it have with hearing the internal energy of music?? Can you only speak with people who have all perfect straight teeths? what a silly waste of time
WILHELM KEMPF rocks!!!! there is visionary poetry, here is the energy of a rocket, but indulging in pubertary 'I want more, more...!' weird immature like a child with beart. What said Beethoven? 'read 'the Tempest by Shakespeare' - it is not Star Wars!!.
Another great, superb performance is by Juan Jose Chuquisengo!
@ManiIsVideo I have listened to this several times, and I am unable to hear the wrong note which you mention. Apparently my ears and musicianship are not equal to yours. Would you be so kind as to tell us all exactly which note is wrong?
It's easy to get the score by downloading a MIDI file and opening it in a notation app., so I eagerly await your reply.
I'm sad that people call this horrible. It's surely different but one can catch the flow of melody and appreciate how this man turns it into something completely fresh and original.
@yalnizkarincalar Appena comincia a suonare quelle quartine di semicrome in MI e FA a 1:43 / 1:44. Nello specifico: Prima quartina di semicrome nella mano destra, l'ultima nota invece di suonare MI, suona un RE (e non un FA come ho scritto). Se senti invece qualche secondo prima quando lo stesso motivo è composto da crome alternate sempre in FA e MI, la differenza si sente eccome. Ascolta bene...
Tal vez un poco más de la pasión necesaria para interpretar esta sonata. Pero Wilhem Kempf ya exagera la lentitud y poca pasión. Prefiero esta y por , pero muy por arriba de ésta, la de Barenboim. Gracias.
je truve lui facon est trop confuse, trop nerveusement....je ne vois pas le beute de cette sonata, cette morceau par lui interpretation. Je pense que lui joue sans bien punctuation, sans resonable appuayant...sans GRACE! oui, sans grace. Je suis d´acord avec les autre...
Un fois j´ai écouté quelqueun parla sur un pianiste qui joue "...comme un homme.."....je truve Say ne joue pas comme un homme...
@uhfqacdfkml Je suis d'accord avec vous pour dire qu'il joue ce morceau nerveusement mais c'est fait exprès. Imaginez-vous sur un bateau en pleine nuit au milieu de l'océan quand tout d'un coup, une tempête éclate avec les vagues qui viennent taper contre la coque du bateau et des éclairs dans le ciel... Voudriez-vous (dans ce cas présent) privilégier la grâce ou la nervosité ?... Telle est la question ;)
@33sQV16vP4 Peu importe... Cela reste un morceau écrit par Beethoven et cette sonate ne s'appelle pas "La Tempête" pour rien. Ce que je veux dire c'est que Fazil Say la joue parfaitement (comme une tempête) et c'est tout à fait logique ;)
@MrPianist45 Beethoven n'a pas appelé cette pièce la tempête. Il a dit à Schindler, qui lui demandait des explications, "lisez la Tempête, de Shakespeare", ce qui change tout... C'est une référence à une pièce de théâtre tout au plus, pas à une vraie tempête! Et ce n'est pas une question de tempo seulement, mais d'articulation et de dynamique. Il ne joue pas ce qui est écrit.
I can't possibly understand why he would do this. Too fast!! This is most certainly not Liszt, it's Beethoven...Kempff and Richter perform this piece properly. Beethoven put something magic in this piece, but this performance doesn't have that magical romanticism!
I am sorry but that was terrible..... Technique is just the way to comunicate an idea not the destiny itself, otherwise is just touch keys in the piano. No doubt he has alll the chops(hey is Fazil Say) but next time he wants to play this sonata in particular, he has to leave the piano for a while, listen and read.... and then try it again
Fazil Say will age like a good wino, as for all that body moment, if any one that commented about it knows anything about music and piano, if some don't move around and sit there like a brick-wall then one may get body tension and slowdown of playing.DOOOOOOOOOMeeeeeeeeee.
Quienes hemos escuchado música clásica por muchísimos años escuchando a los grandes interpretes universalmente reconocidos , asolemos tener de cada pieza una memoria grabada en nuestras neuronas ( y por tanto en nuestro gusto estetico) que mas se complace con las interpretaciones "clásicas" . Muchos de los jóvenes interpretes deben recurrir a su velocidad,variaciones y otros extremos para poder sobresalir en un campo cada vez mas competido.Me agrada: ! si, pero como una variación...!.
me too..I prefer this one, though Kempff is more famous, I think it is more passionate, and has a quicker tempo, more Beethovenian. Most versions on Youtube like the Kempff one is too romantic and slow, over-pedalled, although this movement has it's similarities with Für Elise, it should not be played like it...I like Say's style of rendition,
dont you know another pianist but wilheim kempf you people. expand your knowledge there are other pianists not just on youtube...kempff kempff kempff fuck him....
@Julienher I don't think he has to express the same feelings... He is himself... so he expresses himself through the music he makes... If he expressed something other than himself, it wouldn't have been genuine...
I prefer to wilhelm kempff because its perfect.... Wilhelm Kempff,cluadio arrau,elly ney,dame myra hess,horowitz plays this better and without mistakes..But Im really disaapointed with this video because its fast and more energetic and compared this with others.....
@fadethetrade Just because it's the fastest, does not mean it is the best. What if I played this song at 400% normal speed? Would you think it is the best?
@Th3R3M1nd3r sorry,but I agree with a concert pianist and a PHD musicologist who both agree that many beethoven sonatas are performed too slow by too many people because the music publishing companies somehow interpret beethovens works that way.This movement should not be performed Allegretto,this must be vivace..as well as Rondo cappriciossa and the moonlight first movement should be performed a bit faster then most interpret it.The walstein,appassionata,etc. Most pianists are incorrect!
@nmbanana I cant send you message lock for friends only, yes I like this one to, I play piano for long years and 1st leson was never get stif! and my teacher did told me that I was like a metronome but then he was wrong as I got older I put my own feeling in to what I played, I did use to play fugs in C by JSB like a computer would but that changed to his young give him time and I'm sure he will make you guys happy lol.
Everything for this song was great actually. What ruined it (in my opinion) was the speed he played it at. (not his funky moving around on the bench, that was actually entertaining)
Okay playing, but this guy looks more like a rockstar who is having a merry time playing the drums or an electric keyboard. Odd, I need to see more of this guy's videos.
I've noticed that on his other videos. Frankly, it's not ok to speed up classical music. The songs are designed that if that they are speed up, they don't sound too great.
@Prestothemusic That is not true. Some pieces of music can sound good faster than the written tempo provided the pianist has the skill to keep that tempo and deliver a convincing interpretation.
Oops, I forgot that. That is definitely true. Beethoven played a lot of Baroque and Classical exercises way too fast for his teacher or peers, but actually sounded great to real musicians.
Beethoven is well known for his romantizism and for communication great feelings through his music. I can detect these elements within here. ... Fazil is a great technician - but compared to other interpretations (like Wilhelm Kempff did) this one is more weak. Sry Fazil.
@Fischer34 Fazil sayin yavsak meselesi var, Bence cok talihsiz bir aciklama. bence hic soylenmemeliydi. benim nice muhendis arkadaslarim var arebesk dinleyen. bir kere arabesk dinlemek sence geri kafalilik midir ? bence boyle dusunmek ya geri kafalik yada sasirmisliktir. Fazil sayi kimse tanimiyordu simdi herkes piyanist fazil say diye biliyor. bence Reklam icin yapmis kendini bir tarafda yere vurdu bir tarafda ununu yukseltti.
Hangi arabesk? dil yarası, bir teselli var, bir de iğrenç cehennem böğürtüleri var. Aslında arabesk ikincisi... başka yok. Orhan Fencebay ben arabesk değilim dedi. O zaman başka yok. Değil mühendis arkadaşların, ben bile dinlesem iyi demiş, çok talihli bir açıklama.
@kolraob Sen Ben bile dinlesem iyi demis detikten artik banada soyleyecek birsey kalmaz. Belki su denebilir, seni isirmiyorsa sana ne elalemin begendigi muzikten, begendigi renkten, sevdigi kokudan, tutttugu partiten, begendigi yemekten vesaire uzar gider.
I love his approach to this song, the only thing i would change is when the music changes (after the repeat) he should have done something different, like mysterious and slower.. but this dudes so cool..no lie i feel the energy from this performance.. i wanna go sky diving
Fazil looks absolutely retarted when he's playing, but I love his emotions that he expresses when playing. Fazil>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Wilhelm by a landslide. Love his work!!!
@Fischer34 Birader secimlerde akp ye EVET demiyorum, Referandumda Evet diyorum. Ayni anayasa referandumunu CHP veya baska bir parti yapsa sende severek Turkiye adina iyi bir adimdir diyerek evet diyecektin. Simdi ben sana soruyorum Chp secilsin bu anayasa taslagini kanundan onlar gecirsin diye beklersek kim kayp eder ? Elbetteki Turkiye kayp eder. O yuzden Turkiyeyi kayip ettirmeden herkes evet demeli. genel secimlerde akp ye Hayir de o baska bir konu. Adamlar seciliyorsa kim seciyor ? halk
@Fischer34 simdi demissin sunu bunu ele gecirecekler ordu birsey yapamiyacak. oyle sey mi olur. Ordu muzun darbe yapacagi bir ortam olussa kagitta ne yaziyor diye mi bakar sence. tabiki bakmaz yemisim anasayi der :) AKP nin korkulacak hic birseyi yok. CHP ve diger partiler size durmadan korku saliyorlar isin garibi avam takimi da bunu yiyor. adamlarin 8 senede yaptiklari isleri goz ardi edip bunlari boyle ocu gibi gormek cok gariptir. Yur disinda yasanlarin serefi bu adamlar sayesinde arrti.
Fazil Bey, sizinle gurur duyuyorum.Zalimin biri Beylik sürer cevherin degerlisi cöplükte sürter. Tuhaf bir durum daha var, buraya yazanlarin % 99 yabanci , cok yazik. Selamlar.
sometimes i think "no feeling" is used to validate people's preferences for slower renditions. speed does not equal lack of feeling. watch the dude perform and tell me he has no feeling. beethoven sonatas have feeling written into them. nostalgia's cool, and genuine appreciation for past musicians over current musicians is also cool, but making statements like that could be taken as a sign of ignorance.
If one should compare Kempf and Say, they are two different worlds. Both reflect their personality in their performance. Say is an agile impresionist, whereas Kempf is a lyric poet.
i prefer kempff's interpretation only because i like the fact that he plays it at a slower tempo and i feel more emotion from him....fazil plays it well also but his playing style is a bit agressive to me...i did enjoy the stocatto sections of the piece for some reason lol
Insanely fast played! He also hits quite a few wrong keys. If one can play it in that speed, it would be great.
pvn2474 1 week ago
THIS IS THE BEST VERSION. FUCK ALL OF YOU
3732334 1 week ago
Very good pianist, but for me the piece is too fast. When I think of a tempest, it builds up a bit slower and more thoughtfully.
matavidya 3 weeks ago
süpersin abi ya
dddcccssss 3 weeks ago
genius turkish.. great music
muratner 1 month ago
mistake at 03:54 but it makes the piece even more beautiful
atariturkkk 1 month ago
Fantastic!! I just heard his Mozart's piano concerto when driving, and it was phenomenal! I came home and googled him, this is an interesting musician, and genius!
o0o0oo00oo00 1 month ago
what a talented young man
30inventionman 2 months ago
Darüber hinaus, lieber Fazil.
tengizkhan 2 months ago
Höchst persönlich Beethoven
tengizkhan 2 months ago
articulation great, but very fast, unnecessary, Kempff's version much better, besides, he commits some bumps....
lenus1 2 months ago
@nusretcc, dogru fazil, akp'nin elemani degil!
lindasa28 2 months ago
Negatif yorumlar Fazıl SAY'ın piyano çalışına veya müzisyenliğine yönelik değil; karakterine ve kendini ifade ediş şekline yönelik. Farklılıklara karşı hoşgörüsüz, acımasız, saygısız.. Bu arada, kendisi İyi bir piyanist, ama iyi bir bestekar değil. Notaları kullanarak, zeka ürünü ojinal ve güzel algoritmalar oluşturabildiği pek söylenemez. Nadiren oluşturduğu hoşluklar belli ki taklit veya tesadüf eseri. Ortalama zekaya sahip birinden iddialı yaratıcılıklar zaten beklenemez.
nusretcc 2 months ago
This has long been a favourite of mine, and I grew up with the faster interpretation so I dont see what all the fuss is about. I also play it the faster was myself - to me the concept of a Tempest is storms and rolling seas, so it should be powerful and dynamic. I find Kempff’s interpretation too romantic and “moonlight-esque”.
This is just my personal opinion, but I find it strange that so many people believe there is a “right” or “wrong” interpretation. INTERPRETATION. The clue’s in the word
jason0mayer 2 months ago
It sounds like Glenn Gould's version (althought Gould is much better, imho).
Valdenstrom 2 months ago
this is exactly how it should be played imho....@randomtwat you're a massive gay shit
JohnnySegment86 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Fazıl SAY'ın yüz ifadeleri ne kadar itici ve doğallıktan uzak. Her şeyiyle zorlama, yapay bir karakter. Bu şeyin meşhurluğu belli ki Nazım Hikmet vasat şairinin meşhurluğuyla aynı sebepten: ideolojik. Hoşgörüsüz bağnaz bir cahil, nota bilse ne olur, bilmese ne olur? Meşhur olsa ne olur, olmasa ne olur? Kâmil insan olmadıktan, adam olmadıktan sonra...
fikrikilinc 2 months ago
Comment removed
fikrikilinc 2 months ago
AlleGRETTO
sendaitohoku 3 months ago
I love this piece of music! Interesting style; personally I don't like it as much as other versions I've encountered but it's still brilliantly played.
SneverusSnapers 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hani bir hikaye vardır ya; sonu şöyle biter: "Ben sana vali olamazsın demedim, adam olamazsın dedim". Tam o hikayelik bir durum: "Canım Fazılım, ben sana nota bilmiyorsun, meşhur değilsin" demedim. "Adam değilsin." dedim. Neden sana benzemeyenlere karşı bu kadar tahammülsüzsün? İnsanı olgunluğa ulaştırmayan bilgi ne kadar kıymetlidir? Hazır köklerini farketmiş veya arayış içindeyken, nerede bizim ortak yaşama kültürümüz, hoşgörümüz? Ah yavrum ahhh
nusretcc 3 months ago
Phenomenal pianist!!He plays in a very unique style!!His own style!!!As for Kempff,he is also a very good pianist with a completely diffirent temperament!!I don' t think that we have to compare them!!Every great pianist has something to say!!
nicklatinXXX 3 months ago 13
Anyway: Tempest is storm, tempest is Beethoven. Kempf, Barenboim and others play this like romance. Richter is closer to Say but nor he expresses the very nature of the composition. ... I think so.
(I understand if people dislike the Say´s style - they simply prefer more classical and smooth music. Maybe 386 other prefer tension, emotion, and good show :)
youhodkovice 1 month ago
Eahc to there own...this guy is my idol...who cares wht u think nmbanana...wht a shitty name!!!!!!
Benithen1 3 months ago
What a sense is there to hear 'a wrong note in 1:43'? what does it have with hearing the internal energy of music?? Can you only speak with people who have all perfect straight teeths? what a silly waste of time
akroasis10 4 months ago
WILHELM KEMPF rocks!!!! there is visionary poetry, here is the energy of a rocket, but indulging in pubertary 'I want more, more...!' weird immature like a child with beart. What said Beethoven? 'read 'the Tempest by Shakespeare' - it is not Star Wars!!.
Another great, superb performance is by Juan Jose Chuquisengo!
akroasis10 4 months ago
I don't
newFranzFerencLiszt 4 months ago
new interpretation ppl u should try to give it a shot
Agomongo1235 4 months ago
Comment removed
insideoutface 4 months ago
yep definitely hear the wrong note at 1:43
ManiIsVideo 5 months ago
@ManiIsVideo I have listened to this several times, and I am unable to hear the wrong note which you mention. Apparently my ears and musicianship are not equal to yours. Would you be so kind as to tell us all exactly which note is wrong?
It's easy to get the score by downloading a MIDI file and opening it in a notation app., so I eagerly await your reply.
ybravura 1 month ago
I'm sad that people call this horrible. It's surely different but one can catch the flow of melody and appreciate how this man turns it into something completely fresh and original.
elifistanb 5 months ago 9
@elifistanb I think he plays it very fast. I like the WIlhelm Kempff`s version much more.
kartofobelachka 2 months ago
@elifistanb
youhodkovice 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
WAKAKA I STILL LAUGH.......human metronome!!
humorsin312 5 months ago
no more comments to say....
jobinathirampuzha 6 months ago
1:43 he wrongs a note: he plays MI instead a FA
MrSerpico87 6 months ago
@MrSerpico87 when, where?
yalnizkarincalar 5 months ago
@yalnizkarincalar Appena comincia a suonare quelle quartine di semicrome in MI e FA a 1:43 / 1:44. Nello specifico: Prima quartina di semicrome nella mano destra, l'ultima nota invece di suonare MI, suona un RE (e non un FA come ho scritto). Se senti invece qualche secondo prima quando lo stesso motivo è composto da crome alternate sempre in FA e MI, la differenza si sente eccome. Ascolta bene...
MrSerpico87 5 months ago
@MrSerpico87 yeah, i guess you're right...
yalnizkarincalar 5 months ago
@MrSerpico87 Look at you, you don't even know the right name of the note.
Th3R3M1nd3r 2 months ago
I prefer wilhelm kempff interpretation depending on my mood
94jmcorrea 6 months ago
Tal vez un poco más de la pasión necesaria para interpretar esta sonata. Pero Wilhem Kempf ya exagera la lentitud y poca pasión. Prefiero esta y por , pero muy por arriba de ésta, la de Barenboim. Gracias.
alvarito45 6 months ago
What a disaster!! He is out of TEMPO...
gonzalojosevb 7 months ago
Beethoven did not write for the typewriter.
SepiaLatimanus 7 months ago
It's not Bach Fazıl.Sorry but this is a little bit robotic.
aeon2805 7 months ago
He seems to be raping the piano . . . nevertheless, with much success!
langlois1 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
he reminds me of a bobble head doll :) but he is an amazing pianist.
75371 7 months ago
he reminds me of a bobble head :) but he is an amazing pianist.
75371 7 months ago
Great technique but too fast and with absolutely no feeling.
guzmanvillegas 7 months ago
Fazil say jouer toujours aussi bien ! Super !
Pourquoi dites-vous tous qu'il joue ce morceau de façon mécanique ou bien trop vite ?
Une tempête est une tempête... S'il joue ce morceau de façon trop "carrée" et vite c'est fait exprès !
Je vais me répéter mais si l'on joue ce morceau avec lenteur et douceur, ce n'est plus une Tempête mais une Valse...
MrPianist45 7 months ago
@MrPianist45
je truve lui facon est trop confuse, trop nerveusement....je ne vois pas le beute de cette sonata, cette morceau par lui interpretation. Je pense que lui joue sans bien punctuation, sans resonable appuayant...sans GRACE! oui, sans grace. Je suis d´acord avec les autre...
Un fois j´ai écouté quelqueun parla sur un pianiste qui joue "...comme un homme.."....je truve Say ne joue pas comme un homme...
uhfqacdfkml 7 months ago
@uhfqacdfkml Je suis d'accord avec vous pour dire qu'il joue ce morceau nerveusement mais c'est fait exprès. Imaginez-vous sur un bateau en pleine nuit au milieu de l'océan quand tout d'un coup, une tempête éclate avec les vagues qui viennent taper contre la coque du bateau et des éclairs dans le ciel... Voudriez-vous (dans ce cas présent) privilégier la grâce ou la nervosité ?... Telle est la question ;)
MrPianist45 7 months ago
@MrPianist45 Je crois que ce n'était pas Beethoven qui appelé ce sonata "la tempête", n'est pas?
33sQV16vP4 7 months ago
@33sQV16vP4 Peu importe... Cela reste un morceau écrit par Beethoven et cette sonate ne s'appelle pas "La Tempête" pour rien. Ce que je veux dire c'est que Fazil Say la joue parfaitement (comme une tempête) et c'est tout à fait logique ;)
MrPianist45 7 months ago
@MrPianist45 Beethoven n'a pas appelé cette pièce la tempête. Il a dit à Schindler, qui lui demandait des explications, "lisez la Tempête, de Shakespeare", ce qui change tout... C'est une référence à une pièce de théâtre tout au plus, pas à une vraie tempête! Et ce n'est pas une question de tempo seulement, mais d'articulation et de dynamique. Il ne joue pas ce qui est écrit.
godelike 7 months ago
IT;s too fast.
MrWarhead16 7 months ago
white lang lang
cisdolce 8 months ago
@cisdolce lmao.
fuchion15 7 months ago
Actually Glenn Gloud plays this a lot fater. Fazil doesn't add the pedal. Maybe I prefer the "pedal tatse".
glenivice 8 months ago
I can't possibly understand why he would do this. Too fast!! This is most certainly not Liszt, it's Beethoven...Kempff and Richter perform this piece properly. Beethoven put something magic in this piece, but this performance doesn't have that magical romanticism!
L2thaV 8 months ago
This video is most popular with:
Male age 35-64
Being 15 and spending my weekend listening to stuff like this makes me feel kind of old.
Oh well. This is a brilliant performance and I honestly can't decide who I would rather listen to: Fazil Say or Wilhelm Kempff!
TurmoilTom 8 months ago
I wonder how long someone has to practice to play like Fazil?
shinyoung23 8 months ago
W. Kempff almost fall asleep during the performance.. So weak!
As for me Fazil Say is much much better..
kemalista 8 months ago
I am sorry but that was terrible..... Technique is just the way to comunicate an idea not the destiny itself, otherwise is just touch keys in the piano. No doubt he has alll the chops(hey is Fazil Say) but next time he wants to play this sonata in particular, he has to leave the piano for a while, listen and read.... and then try it again
calito44 9 months ago
Barbar!
Borussiasempervictor 9 months ago
Fazil Say will age like a good wino, as for all that body moment, if any one that commented about it knows anything about music and piano, if some don't move around and sit there like a brick-wall then one may get body tension and slowdown of playing.DOOOOOOOOOMeeeeeeeeee.
1Zerotonine 9 months ago
@1Zerotonine horowitz sat still "like a brick" and you don't see him with body tension and slow playing, now do you
nmbanana 9 months ago
like the way he shakes his head :)) hehe
Brahmstein99 9 months ago
Quienes hemos escuchado música clásica por muchísimos años escuchando a los grandes interpretes universalmente reconocidos , asolemos tener de cada pieza una memoria grabada en nuestras neuronas ( y por tanto en nuestro gusto estetico) que mas se complace con las interpretaciones "clásicas" . Muchos de los jóvenes interpretes deben recurrir a su velocidad,variaciones y otros extremos para poder sobresalir en un campo cada vez mas competido.Me agrada: ! si, pero como una variación...!.
JorPove 9 months ago
Ok. Unless this guy is an idiot savant, there's no reason to by bobbing around like a parrot. Jesus that is annoying.
oopalonga 9 months ago
Tony Danza probably always gets asked if this is him playing the piano....
susumu07 9 months ago
Голям талант!
ekvivalent 9 months ago
Flawless!
ppssiihhooddeelliikk 9 months ago
me too..I prefer this one, though Kempff is more famous, I think it is more passionate, and has a quicker tempo, more Beethovenian. Most versions on Youtube like the Kempff one is too romantic and slow, over-pedalled, although this movement has it's similarities with Für Elise, it should not be played like it...I like Say's style of rendition,
iwavns 9 months ago
All pianists start quick then end up slowing down and maturing after a while .. compare Rubinstein etc ..
TheKsk1997 10 months ago
its better to listen to Barenboim,more soul
12345qazx1 10 months ago
harika bir sanatçı.
cCcOsmanlifatihicCc 10 months ago
Fazil is skilful but lacking in emotion. Also, It's Allegretto, not Allegro. But that's just my opinion.
pschymit 10 months ago
Really horrible pearformance. Great technic but totally soulless!
Oliver154678 10 months ago
great,I couldn't find ather word,,,
saxwolf71 10 months ago
dont you know another pianist but wilheim kempf you people. expand your knowledge there are other pianists not just on youtube...kempff kempff kempff fuck him....
blacklords2 10 months ago 2
I don't like this preformance..... I prefer baremboim!
monicapianista 10 months ago
oh great another one that thinks playing it quick will make it better :/
hatatske 11 months ago
Holy crap, its rocky on the piano.
iamzemasta 11 months ago
I love this haha. This is how I play it. I actually kind of copied him...
cinzhe 11 months ago
This is wrong. Just plain wrong. He should listen to Richter, Kempf, or Barenboim, to maybe get an idea of what Beethoven was trying to express......
Julienher 11 months ago
@Julienher I don't think he has to express the same feelings... He is himself... so he expresses himself through the music he makes... If he expressed something other than himself, it wouldn't have been genuine...
Slimarus 11 months ago
@Julienher
I absolutely agree with you! The guy is killing the essence of this piece, imho!
zaza7272 11 months ago
@Julienher ... Also you can listen Gould, and think about name ... "Tempest"
yuriz66 10 months ago
THis video much have mistakes.....
LudwigMr 1 year ago
I prefer to wilhelm kempff because its perfect.... Wilhelm Kempff,cluadio arrau,elly ney,dame myra hess,horowitz plays this better and without mistakes..But Im really disaapointed with this video because its fast and more energetic and compared this with others.....
LudwigMr 1 year ago
Love his sleeves :B
XAnalogmanX 1 year ago 2
Beethoven's Tempest Sonata mvt. 3 -- Wilhelm Ke... KOOOOOOL!
Eridia8484 1 year ago
Glenn Gould wannabe... >.<
JacobRudduck 1 year ago
by god this man is a human metronome, horrible horrible rendition
nmbanana 1 year ago 15
@nmbanana listen to glenn goulds rendition.Its the fastest and the best.
fadethetrade 9 months ago
@fadethetrade Just because it's the fastest, does not mean it is the best. What if I played this song at 400% normal speed? Would you think it is the best?
Th3R3M1nd3r 4 months ago
@Th3R3M1nd3r sorry,but I agree with a concert pianist and a PHD musicologist who both agree that many beethoven sonatas are performed too slow by too many people because the music publishing companies somehow interpret beethovens works that way.This movement should not be performed Allegretto,this must be vivace..as well as Rondo cappriciossa and the moonlight first movement should be performed a bit faster then most interpret it.The walstein,appassionata,etc. Most pianists are incorrect!
fadethetrade 4 months ago
@Th3R3M1nd3r Believe me,beethoven would have agreed.Most performances are a bit too slow.
fadethetrade 4 months ago
@nmbanana I cant send you message lock for friends only, yes I like this one to, I play piano for long years and 1st leson was never get stif! and my teacher did told me that I was like a metronome but then he was wrong as I got older I put my own feeling in to what I played, I did use to play fugs in C by JSB like a computer would but that changed to his young give him time and I'm sure he will make you guys happy lol.
1Zerotonine 9 months ago
@1Zerotonine still and stiff are two different things, and keeping your torso still won't cause your arms to become stiff
nmbanana 9 months ago
@nmbanana
you are absolutely correct!
This is broken and without feeling
Robert
marvanyutca 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@nmbanana WAKAKA I STILL LAUGH.......human metronome!!
humorsin312 5 months ago
@nmbanana clearly you have no idea of "music"!
lindasa28 4 months ago
@nmbanana Coming from a person who probably listens to pop songs like Friday.
Th3R3M1nd3r 4 months ago
His piano face sometimes looks like rocky v.
KratosKidd707 1 year ago
A little fast for me personally, but geez guys it's still played brilliantly.
Gunz42069 1 year ago 3
@Gunz42069 Beethoven usually set his tempo rather high,- and sometimes lower, - depending on his mood that day. Freedom of speed.
metteholm75 1 year ago 12
And wihtout any traces of classicism?
chiehwenwang 1 year ago
Like a modern high-speed train on the brink of losing control? Fortunately, it didn't.
chiehwenwang 1 year ago
26 people don't think a Fazil should be able to use facial expressions while playing an instrument he spent his entire life MASTERING.
(Looks like pleasure depending on if you interpret his face as painful or an orgasm)
TheSakeOfGod 1 year ago 2
@TheSakeOfGod 27, now 28 people have a pair of functional ears and knowledge of much much better renditions
nmbanana 1 year ago
What's with all the criticism and ridicule? I thought this is actually VERY well played.
mike11022 1 year ago 3
@mike11022
Everything for this song was great actually. What ruined it (in my opinion) was the speed he played it at. (not his funky moving around on the bench, that was actually entertaining)
Prestothemusic 1 year ago
It's the "tempest" sonata, you're not actually being tossed about on the bench by gale-force winds...
OriginalBasaliskos 1 year ago
Okay playing, but this guy looks more like a rockstar who is having a merry time playing the drums or an electric keyboard. Odd, I need to see more of this guy's videos.
Prestothemusic 1 year ago
He plays this like he has to use the restroom.......... Like Crap....
Atlantis2184 1 year ago
@Atlantis2184
No, he looks like he's going to have a baby................
SOMEONE CALL THE PARAMEDICS!!! XD
He played a bit too fast for this song once again. :(
Prestothemusic 1 year ago
@Prestothemusic lol,this guy plays everything fast
harry781012 1 year ago
@harry781012
I've noticed that on his other videos. Frankly, it's not ok to speed up classical music. The songs are designed that if that they are speed up, they don't sound too great.
Prestothemusic 1 year ago
@Prestothemusic That is not true. Some pieces of music can sound good faster than the written tempo provided the pianist has the skill to keep that tempo and deliver a convincing interpretation.
OriginalBasaliskos 1 year ago
@OriginalBasaliskos
Oops, I forgot that. That is definitely true. Beethoven played a lot of Baroque and Classical exercises way too fast for his teacher or peers, but actually sounded great to real musicians.
Prestothemusic 1 year ago
te hai qualche problema
1408fenner 1 year ago
Everybody wants to have a brain like this. Todo el mundo querría tener un cerebro como el suyo. Of course he is not retard. not at all.
PianoCussoSFHA 1 year ago 2
He looks like he's mentally retarded, someone had to say
Mendelevium146 1 year ago 2
Over-the-top funny-looking eccentric musicians are the best..
I do prefer this at a slower tempo, but hey, he's the expert, not me.
orphyborphy 1 year ago
I prefer kempffs version
Mendelevium146 1 year ago 2
piacevolissimamente inquietante...una carica di devastante voltaggio...BELLISSIMA performance...empatizzare tanta appassionata energia...dona così tanta vitalità da...perdersiii...
bruccheri70 1 year ago
non c'è motivo di muoversi così brutto pazzo
1408fenner 1 year ago
Beethoven is well known for his romantizism and for communication great feelings through his music. I can detect these elements within here. ... Fazil is a great technician - but compared to other interpretations (like Wilhelm Kempff did) this one is more weak. Sry Fazil.
qnoquai 1 year ago 3
Don't you have some curtains to vacuum? We know you're the boss, but now's not the time to pursue a musical career.
ink245711 1 year ago
well i really like the way he plays, but Wilhelm is sooo much better
A8opi 1 year ago
amazing seemingly Italian taste or influence.
HAPPY2BCYCOTIC 1 year ago
Impressive, talented and unique
benhos 1 year ago
He is amazing, and looks a bit like Sylvester Stallone.
Edarjany 1 year ago 3
@Edarjany looks like Stallone has just smashed the piano with tempest...
Darknf0rce 1 year ago
He looks like a douchebag but he is good at the piano.
yjw9 1 year ago
Did he misread the Tempo text? Its AllegRETTO not Allegro vivace
Jolteon206 1 year ago
I guess this was Tony Danza's fallback from acting.
signinname41 1 year ago
I am proud of him, that we are both Türkish.
Fischer34 1 year ago
@Fischer34 Fazil sayin yavsak meselesi var, Bence cok talihsiz bir aciklama. bence hic soylenmemeliydi. benim nice muhendis arkadaslarim var arebesk dinleyen. bir kere arabesk dinlemek sence geri kafalilik midir ? bence boyle dusunmek ya geri kafalik yada sasirmisliktir. Fazil sayi kimse tanimiyordu simdi herkes piyanist fazil say diye biliyor. bence Reklam icin yapmis kendini bir tarafda yere vurdu bir tarafda ununu yukseltti.
m3hm3tirl 1 year ago
@m3hm3tirl
Hangi arabesk? dil yarası, bir teselli var, bir de iğrenç cehennem böğürtüleri var. Aslında arabesk ikincisi... başka yok. Orhan Fencebay ben arabesk değilim dedi. O zaman başka yok. Değil mühendis arkadaşların, ben bile dinlesem iyi demiş, çok talihli bir açıklama.
kolraob 1 year ago
@kolraob Sen Ben bile dinlesem iyi demis detikten artik banada soyleyecek birsey kalmaz. Belki su denebilir, seni isirmiyorsa sana ne elalemin begendigi muzikten, begendigi renkten, sevdigi kokudan, tutttugu partiten, begendigi yemekten vesaire uzar gider.
m3hm3tirl 1 year ago
I love his approach to this song, the only thing i would change is when the music changes (after the repeat) he should have done something different, like mysterious and slower.. but this dudes so cool..no lie i feel the energy from this performance.. i wanna go sky diving
codycrowder 1 year ago
Comment removed
codycrowder 1 year ago
retard head
mariz2209 1 year ago
lol if he plays all the songs faster like this one,than his concerts last 15 minutes ;)
AjDigiDam 1 year ago
Fazil looks absolutely retarted when he's playing, but I love his emotions that he expresses when playing. Fazil>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Wilhelm by a landslide. Love his work!!!
srrybunny 1 year ago
Harika caliyorsun Fazil abi. Bende piano ogreniyorum , seni ornek aliyorum, fakat 12 eylul de evet diyecem :)
m3hm3tirl 1 year ago
@m3hm3tirl neden evet diyeceksin birader? Görmüyor musun adamlar yargiyi ele gecirip iyice kök saliyorlar memlekete...
Fischer34 1 year ago
@Fischer34 Birader secimlerde akp ye EVET demiyorum, Referandumda Evet diyorum. Ayni anayasa referandumunu CHP veya baska bir parti yapsa sende severek Turkiye adina iyi bir adimdir diyerek evet diyecektin. Simdi ben sana soruyorum Chp secilsin bu anayasa taslagini kanundan onlar gecirsin diye beklersek kim kayp eder ? Elbetteki Turkiye kayp eder. O yuzden Turkiyeyi kayip ettirmeden herkes evet demeli. genel secimlerde akp ye Hayir de o baska bir konu. Adamlar seciliyorsa kim seciyor ? halk
m3hm3tirl 1 year ago
@Fischer34 simdi demissin sunu bunu ele gecirecekler ordu birsey yapamiyacak. oyle sey mi olur. Ordu muzun darbe yapacagi bir ortam olussa kagitta ne yaziyor diye mi bakar sence. tabiki bakmaz yemisim anasayi der :) AKP nin korkulacak hic birseyi yok. CHP ve diger partiler size durmadan korku saliyorlar isin garibi avam takimi da bunu yiyor. adamlarin 8 senede yaptiklari isleri goz ardi edip bunlari boyle ocu gibi gormek cok gariptir. Yur disinda yasanlarin serefi bu adamlar sayesinde arrti.
m3hm3tirl 1 year ago
FANTASTICO!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Wumbo20 1 year ago
Comment removed
AjDigiDam 1 year ago
Fazil Bey, sizinle gurur duyuyorum.Zalimin biri Beylik sürer cevherin degerlisi cöplükte sürter. Tuhaf bir durum daha var, buraya yazanlarin % 99 yabanci , cok yazik. Selamlar.
Akrep32 1 year ago
SLOW DOOWN!!!
rockmuonli 1 year ago
sometimes i think "no feeling" is used to validate people's preferences for slower renditions. speed does not equal lack of feeling. watch the dude perform and tell me he has no feeling. beethoven sonatas have feeling written into them. nostalgia's cool, and genuine appreciation for past musicians over current musicians is also cool, but making statements like that could be taken as a sign of ignorance.
harveythelobsterzbak 1 year ago 2
he is sooo goood..
ChEsTiZzlE 1 year ago
Enjoy it, zum genießen ein Traum wunderbar,i love it.
eyvahlan36 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
klar wie ein kristall! so muss beethoven gespielt werden - toll
DrSchizzle 1 year ago
klar wie ein kristall - so muss beethoven gespielt werden! toll
DrSchizzle 1 year ago
Bitchin!
markcornwell 1 year ago
If one should compare Kempf and Say, they are two different worlds. Both reflect their personality in their performance. Say is an agile impresionist, whereas Kempf is a lyric poet.
kerimun 1 year ago
no feelings
sabn122 1 year ago
Exelente técnica pero no encuentro el sentimiento y la emoción que tendrían que estar expresados...
La expreción de una pieza musical no se basa en hacer gesticulaciónes y movimientos corporales, se trata de transmitir con la melodía...
Luchoadam 1 year ago
Not feeling....Wilhelm Kempff...he has very very feelin in his playing...he looks like a metronome...
Marvin1495 1 year ago
he reached the acme of perfection as a Pianiste
kyung1104 1 year ago
parece q imita a GLenn GOuld
capo980 1 year ago
i like listening to both this and wilheim's one. U cant compare the sunrise and sunset can you now?
mubeensgh 1 year ago 2
@mubeensgh you are truely right... sunRISE and the sunSET
Mischakal 1 year ago
magnifique!
franzifrancaise 1 year ago
iyi iş çıkardın...
sinancans 1 year ago
you cant compare him with kempff
but I also prefer this1
tntalus 1 year ago
hes playing like he wrote the song
Kuerbis626 1 year ago
very modern way of playing. good job fazil!
designandsketch 1 year ago
i prefer kempff's interpretation only because i like the fact that he plays it at a slower tempo and i feel more emotion from him....fazil plays it well also but his playing style is a bit agressive to me...i did enjoy the stocatto sections of the piece for some reason lol
PianoKid1171 1 year ago
Comment removed
1408fenner 1 year ago
@kaaniarmani
aahah wat does that even mean
i doubt my mom knows it
bboymango 1 year ago