Added: 4 years ago
From: DisneyChannleRocks
Views: 45,728
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (248)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I know this isn't the EXACT same thing but I was volunteering with inner city kids and this kind,yet troubled and hardened 11 year old girl asked why I had a huge bandage(stretch out my arm..cerebral palsy) her first assumption was that a boy hit me.this neighborhood is a place where domestic violence is a regular thing..I grew up in the upper middle class suburbs in a loving home..I don't want to know what she,her siblings,and friends and family go through..I'm so lucky..pray for those kids <3

  • This is why the male race should've never been invented.

  • wats up with the super long pause?

  • I just can't stop listening to this song..

  • i wish there was something we could do for them!!!! D:

  • i wish there was something we could do for them!! D:

  • i wish we could do something about this!! ;'(

  • i wish i could bring..back all of them

  • Ha. this ALOMST happended to me. . . TWICE! once by my uncle when I was THREE! AND about a month ago by this van that has been going around picking up kids! wanna talk about something scary!!

    P.S. has anyone thought about doing a video for this song for the movie The Lovely Bones? just a thought

  • Such deep meaningful lyrics. SO BEAUTIFUL. Aly and AJ are now 78violet. Please follow them on twitter. Join in the effort to keep them popular :)

  • there r soo many freaks out there. idk why they do that. but they r takin something thats loved away from the poeple who care most

  • Aly & Aj Wow *-* I love it <3 :)

  • love the song....thinking about abuse is hard...

  • this is really sad!! i'm really scared this could happen to me :( and i'm really sad for all those kids i wish i could or could have saved them :'(

  • Poor children. they are right it could happen to anyone. Stay on alert :)

  • theres lots of poor kids who were kidnapped :( what about Kristin French...Karla Halmolka,paul bernardo...

    yeah she was my relative (kristen) rip

  • i like the song sticks and stones from their rush album too

  • This is so sad, i love aly and aj xx

  • Beautiful song !

  • If you don't like it, don't click on it, don't listen to it if you do by accident, and deffinately don't freaking comment!

  • OMFG IT WAS ON A TAPE NO ONE TOLD ME

  • hi ppl its me katara191 i couldnt figure out my pass so i created a new one i feel sorry that thir kids out there that are being kinapped my dad says llisten to the lyrics and you will understand what they are feeling

  • I love the lyrics, it's great, but I don't like the song. Sorry...

  • i looove this song

  • this song made me cry . it is sooo ssad. aww go aly and aj!

  • whos cARLY

  • carlie bracia...she got kidnapped a while ago. they have it on a security tape.

  • Carlie Brucia is a kid that got abducted..........she died

  • this is good good song

  • Aw man....This is one of the saddest songs that I've heard in a long time. It's true! And even if some people pass me off as paranoid or something like that (which they do) at least i'm informed and safe. They take chances....I don't. I hope I never have to go throuh anything like these poor kids have to...I feel so bad for them! ...I wish I could bring back all of them. :| We are ALL one of them...

  • I am so scared I will get hurt, but this makes me motivated to help out all the kids. :|

  • i sorta cried wen i heard this song cuz i thought of carlie and i think back on the video of her abduction, n its jus wrong tht innocent children get kidnapped

  • i would hate to be carlie brucia but im so sad that had to be her

  • Aw I love this song! It is very touching

  • you ppl are not very supportive

  • great song!

  • THey probably wanted to publicize the issues

  • After watching the news of 11-year-old Carlie Brucia being abducted and murdered, Aly and AJ were so affected that they wrote the song "I Am One of Them" in an hour to raise awareness about child kidnapping.

  • This is a sad and awesome song. Why do people kidnapp inoccent kids???

  • sadly a lot of it has to do with human trafficking.

  • my bff victoria stafford was kidnapped, and she was abused and then killed. this 2, there was a girl on a path, and i knew her, and a guy started stabbing her when she was on her walk and killed her, and i knew the guy who did it and the girl that died, and then my frends where riding by on the trail and saw him doing it, then he droped the dead girl and chased after them and by me while i was on the path with my grandma and then we were walking by and saw the dead girl, i was devistated. :(

  • Are you serious!:((

  • rip victoria Stafford :(

    now theres new laws about what to do when children are abducted, to find the children faster

  • Comment removed

  • Actually you're not "one of them". This song is about KIDNAPPED children, not kids who have fathers that say shit.

  • that was really mean why dont you go away i think this song just made her feel connected so go away you dont understand it.

  • You're right, I dont understand. I dont understand how a girl who is probably spoiled rotten bitches and moans about a father who is basically like any other dumbass father, commenting about stuff he has no right to comment on, when there are people out there who have lost friends. Maybe she should try losing a friend to some psycho asshole, and THEN I'll be supportive.

  • your really bitchy i mean really so what maybe to her that was bad maybe its was more then what she told you i mean i do know where your coming from i lost my cousin to a father and mother like that but i still have enough kindness not to blow up in someones facce about every little thing maybe was wasnt asking for a comment back she may have been just stating for others who know where shes coming from.

  • You have no idea what her life is like, she has no idea what your life is like, so IDT that anyone of you have a right to judge each other on each others problems.

  • you know, verbal abuse is just aa bad as physical... i would know

  • wow this song is really true and good! I was beat by my dad and its really painful and sad you dont know whether to fight back or let it happen and then he calls me names it sux! i just recently got taken away from him by my mom and i a m very thankful i did bc if it kept going on i could hev been beateb to death

  • wow i love this song i man its just amazing the way she said that its just wow and it is true i know someone that got kidnappedits just so true

  • omg is all true this song is awsome

  • this song is beautiful i have their song cd rush and this and sticks and stones are my two favorite songs

  • This made me cry because I was kidnapped its the scariest thing ever. you really don't know if your going to make it . even if the person knows how scared you are and how much you want to go home they won't let you. They laugh at you. All in all its a really good song because its true.

  • :'(

  • omgosh i am sooo sryy. how did u get away??

  • this is a very thought provoking song ...

    i really like it

  • duuude

    when they sang this live it was AMAZING they ended the song with this long bongo solo where they were both playing and slowly all the rest of the instruments faded out and it was just them and then they both ended at the same time and it was just complete silence

    aahh i got chills it was SO amazinggg

  • weird but i looove the song

  • luv this song soooooooooooooo much!!!!

  • LOve it

  • And btw, why is the song 6 minutes and 6 seconds if the song ends at 3:24 ?

  • Because when she made the video,she probably extened the pic longer than the song goes.

  • I love Aly & Aj.

    who cares about Obama and Mccain?

    IT'S OVER.

    Aly & Aj have written the most saddest song in history.

    I was sobbing.

  • I agree with you. This song brought me to tears. Its sad that our youth seem to suffer more than others. The last part of this song where they say "I wish I could bring back all of them" Just rings and sends cold chills down my spines

  • OMG you are a dissgrace she's not talking about that shes a star, she saying about being a regular person not famouse

    nd they think they sometimes feel the exact same way!

    and how do you know that the kids on the street feel great.... wel no!!!

    they feel abbandoned by their own families

    how'd that make ya feel huh??

    all alone inside!!

    ugh you just don't think

    kicknow7

  • she is not talking about being a normal person, she IS talking about all the wrong thi\ngs that are happening to kids around the world, not only getting kidnapping but starving and alone too, the second half of what u say is true, they do feel abandonded and alone

  • hello

  • *ILYnatal1* READ!!

    Ok Its not about it being not fair that they

    don't get kidnapped that is the stupidest thing i heard. Just think about it. Just like lollypoppypets said. It's kind of about being close to being kidnapped. And how much that other child is probably suffering right now. Plus famous people do get hurt and sometimes kidnapped search it on google!

  • Oh my gosh. I never thought of it that way. Now this song has changed the way I look at everything. Why is life like that? Why are there people like that? Why is life not fair? Amazing. I'll never forget this song and what it means. You all rock. Stop talking about obama and bush! UR being rude. This is about a sorrowful topic. Just think about it. Really, really, think.

  • nan21rocks is right, except fr also, when its like

    Reports of the girl

    Makin' me scared

    Led off to die and why was I spared?

    Life is not fair!

    it means like jsut bc its famous no ones killing them, or doing bad things to them, and its not fair.

    and its called i am one of them to say theyre just like anyone else, and if everyone else is getting hurt, murdered, taken away, its not fair that they arent bc they can sing and theyre famous.

    and it truly insnt.

  • This is so true. We are always scared to be alone in the street because we never know when some freak will appear and take us with them. And we never see our family ever again. Poor kids! They're so innocent and then they are taken away. I can't imagine what they must feel. Stupid sick people who do this!!!

    (what's wrong with this people, fighting over Bush and Obama? Do they have something to do with a song about kidnapped children?)

  • now im crying

    awesome

  • if only bad people could understand how wrong kidnapping is......

    Beautiful song

    I ♥ it!

    Awesome Amazing Talented Singers

  • this is a sad song ---it's about Amber Alerts (kidnapped kids alert).

    If you know the story of Amber (and the story(s) about other kids being kidnapped) you just start tearing up!

    i'm glad they wrote this song there are really sick people out there just kidnapping, its stupid this means a lot

    AWESOME SONG CANT STOP LISTENING TO IT!

    {enough with the Bush vs. Obama crap}

  • This song wow... it started making me cry duriing this song I was singing along and I just started to tear up as I sang I don't even know how they sang it with out crying it's just... wow love it love Aly and AJ amazing!

  • oh ya and i <3 ally and aj such great singers and very talented actresses. this is one of the most meaningful songs i have ever heard written by disney channel stars.

  • so true

  • I would never imagine a Disney Star writting a song about the kids that get hurt everyday in this world, for no reason! They are absoloutley amazing! This song ALMOST made me cry ( I had to hold in my tears, because if i didnt, o would not be able to stop crying to write this comment!

  • what SelenaDemiAlysonJenn said (u are so right)

  • hehe thaks, i just think its amazing for them to write this song...

  • oh my god!! same here....i feel da same way

    this song is da best song from disney and ppl stop talking bout freaking bush and obama damn it! they have nothing to do wit da song!

  • people think just because they r disney stars they don't have good songs but this is really good and very sad :(

  • This song is so sad

  • I don't care what others say but I hate Bush. He's a moron and a goddamned lunatic!

    He played with this country like it was just another of his toys and like where it's gotten us! Obama's smarter than this, even though I wanted Hilary but I'll settle for Obama.

  • omg this song makes me rly think abt stuff.

    i mean everyone thinks that this stuff isnt/cant happen to u but it can cause we're one of them

  • OMG! I love this song.

  • this song makes me cry, is so beautiful and sad

  • aww this song is soooo sad but true. i wish i am aloud to walk to my friends house. it sux. but greattt song!!! :]

  • oh.my.god..:'[ why in the world would someone even THINK of doing something like that?! D':

    [(.::this song's absolutely amazing::.)]

  • You probably feel so bad fort lissening to the silence for the kids......

  • people need to understand this is wrong! STOP KIDNAPPING AND EVERYTHING ELSE YOU DO YOU DONT KNOW HOW BADLI YOUR HURTING EVERYBODI AROUND YOU!!!!

  • I love the message this song gives, but I can't help but feel horrible everytime I hear it. It's so sad! It's hard to beleive that all these things happen, but thank god Aly and aj care and want to spread the message. The always have such strong messages in their songs, but this one is very strong!

  • One of my classmates have been missing for a couple months now. I didn't personally know him, but now I am so upset that I might not get a chance to know him. I just can't believe something like this can happen to someone I know...

  • sad!

  • Thanks :( I miss her sooooooooo much

  • They wrote this song for the Kidnapped Kids and murdered kids my sister is 5 years old and she was kidnapped and she's been missing for 5 months :(

  • OMG THATS SOOOO SAD!! I feel so bad for you! i hope they find her!

  • the story is sad... :'(

  • i lovels this song its coolz!!!!!

    IF YOU LOVELS THIS SONG LIKE ME LISTEN TO HANDS HELD HIGH BY LINKIN PARK

    THAT ONES ABOUT HOW GEORGE BUSH IS TAKING US TO WAR AND NOT CARING HOW MANY PEOPLE ARE GETTING HURT!!!

  • THIS IS A REPLY TO SKULLZAFULLZ

    Omg, bush is taking us to war to FREAKING PROTECT US! He does care, being the amazing president he is, and those people going to war are people who WANT TO PROTECT this country! So stop thinking its so bad. I'm really sad that Bush has to go, and.....*screams* the abamanation begins. The end is near, folks. Love the song though.

  • abomination*

    & if bush was so great, why did bring us into recession. he made a mess that obama now has to clean up. the whole 8 years that bush was in office, nothing good happened. didn't you notice that? he barely knew what he was talking about half of the time. he's an idiot. finally we have someone with intellect to run our country the right way

  • lmao how is obama a retard. retards dont get into Harvard. he hasnt even been in office that long. dont judge him yet

  • I never ment it like that i ment hes just gonna lead us in to war

  • we're already in a war genius

  • wow obama's a retard??? lets see you get into harvard. You're the retard if you think bush "rocks."

  • Why r you stalking me? AND BUSH ROCKS r tard

    why dont you stop stalking me?  your really annoying

  • nothing good happend? where the fuck were u this all started with clinton and him taking money from our military that made us weak enough to be victims of the terrorists and now we spend 10 billion in iraq because of it so dont blame bush for having the balls to put an end to the shit that has been going on with the talaban and other terrorists for the last 20 years thank him for it.

  • wow...what a strong message.

  • this song is so true

    i lost my cuzon keisha whizzart and her mum and bro thy got shot and battered in their home know how it feels and there r some really rude pepz who don't care how i feel coz they've never lost any1 thro murder.

  • Tyler<3 R.I.P. ...now down to 83 kids :'(

  • what happend??  :-(

  • Someone was speeding...and Tyler was walking by....the car hit him and Tyler died right away :(..

  • OMG im really really sorry were you related by any chance ive been in that situation too in a similar way with my brother :-(

  • No I'm not by I lost my sister in a car accident. But now theirs only 83 kids/teenagers around here...

    Sorry to hear that happened to your brother

  • oh my gosh im really sorry that must be terrible all the best to you and your family i hope your all okay

  • yea we are thanks

  • this song is so so meaningful. it really makes me think about how often kids get hurt

  • i was one of them

  • what happened to you ?

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • wat happened?

  • this song makes me almost cry becuase me and my neighbor were walking down to walgreens and shes 10 .. this happened about a week ago so goT CRUSHED by a car and went flying it was so scary it almost happened to me she's home now thank god her family is so like.. messed up i guess.. they're almost broke and her dad was a melester and her mom just had a baby who is going on nine months soon and its very sad so i dedicate this song to julian techjman<3

  • I was just reading Seventeen Magazine.And they where talking about kids geting kidnapped,And They where saying how Aly And Aj Felt so deep about that.So they wrote this song to make people realize that kids are getting kid napped everyday!

  • me too. it was in the summer issue.

    inspirational.

  • after i heard this song one of my cousins was kidnapped and beaten and raped and killed by her step father

    it was in the news for a very long time

  • Oh my Gosh Im so sorry!

  • yeah

    that was like in 07

  • i love thier songs my favourite is something more, careful with words and this one :D

  • i have never careful with words

  • i love aly and aj <3 they know how to make meaningful songs :)

  • when they say i am one of them i think theyre talking about how rex metler was planing and kidnapping and killing them but then he got arrested.

  • Ther´s no lyrics

  • in the description

  • This One Is My Fav Aly & Aj Song

  • i know someone who got raped and this song helped her think that shes lucky that she got away and lots of other kids dont get the chance to get away its so sad people really are stupid do things to little kids i call them wannabe micheal jacksons its so wrong i wish they would all just go to h*ll!(sorry about cuzing)!

  • i love this song it makes you think about everything that goes on in the world.

  • i know this song is sooo sad its true i mean so many kids do get hurt and we think that we have such a bad life and look at what hapend to other kids and they r right life isnt fair i wish i could help the boys and girls 2

  • wow this brought me back down to earth. I love how this is song is totally different than the other ones out there about boyfriends and breakups! it makes us really think that we should be so happy that we are spared like it says in the song. Really think about it...

  • oh my god this makes you think wow! and it makes you feel like you have a chance to live and that you should live your life because a lot of people lost theirs.

  • this song  is preety good

    ana_kathern

  • this song has really strong lyrics and its true ppl realy need to be aware of there surroundings. all in all this song is really good

  • its sad this song but really good, but its really weird because theyr saying it could happen to them, but didnt it nearly happen to them once, i mean didnt someone have the intentions of abducting them?, its horrible how these days people cant walk out of their home without being scared of what could happen, its not right.

  • your right. the world has changed alot now

  • great song, but really sad.. :(

  • geez i got major goosebumps listening to this song.

    aly & aj are so right! there are so many kids out there getting kidnapped and hurt and being abused and dying for no reason.

    and a bunch of us dont realize that it could be one of our friends so family members or even yourself.

    i loved the ending of the song "i wish i would bring back all of them"

    because i truly do wish i could help those boys and girls.

  • I totally agree with you!

  • agreed

  • y was it 6 min wen tha song waz only 4?

  • it is greAt but where arethe lyrics

  • in the description

  • love this song

  • amazing song :]

  • this song is about kids getting captured :'( so sad

  • wow thier eyes are like piercing and love this song

  • One of my favorite song of them!!

  • i dont get the ending because it says its 6 minutes but it ends at 3 minutes!

  • i know i accsedntly left the picture on for too long lol

  • I read in Seventeen magazine that they wrote the song and the music in an hour after they saw someone being kidnapped on the news.thats what I call inspiration.They seem so cool and I think its great that they care.Kepp up the good work Aly & AJ.

  • omg so did i, i am signing up for the txt msg thing right now!!

  • yah..i read that to

  • omj i saw it too! i was like wow i think it was really sweet of them to write a song about it.

  • They must reall care. A lot of kids are bing abducted. Thats because a lot of ppl r on drugs. Great job and nobody dare, give this comment thumbs down. You made a good job... I hope I don't. I walk to school for safety patrol at 8:29 evereyday. I becarful I am really street smart!

  • This video tells a lot about their experiences trough out their life!!! If they toke the courage to sing and write this song

  • I LOVE THE LYRICS!!! and sticks and stones -- i really hate songs about relationships and blah blah blah theres millions like those but no many like this!

  • soooooooooooo sad they r so good to other people and them selfs they really care

  • has aly or aj been adopted or sumfin then?