Charlie Mingus? lol, you have no idea what you're talking about, go research something more cut out for you, like rock or crap, Oops! I meant rap... alot of your end people are just not that well known, some of them were not even jazz musicians, Victor Wooten for example as amazing as he is, is not purely a jazz musician
Douche, I know that these kind of greatest list is stupid, but this is beyond human idiocy. DJ in Jazz? When you think Miles in the 80's, Chick Corea, Herbie Hancock's robot tone and all those 2 hours of one chords "funky jams" were bad enough. What the fuck? "Jazz is hip too you know, there's DJ now you can rave to Jazz!". Fuck DJ, "Play button" is not an instrument. What's next? Photoshop in fine art space of Louvre? And yeah, Steve Gadd (drummer...) but no way Art Tatum (God).
dj logic? what are you talking about? how can you put dj logic on a list and omit wayne shorter, freddie hubbard, lee morgan, coleman hawkins, ben webster, clifford brown and all the others i mentioned in my previous post? i guarantee that every single person you put on your list that is alive today would disagree with you putting them on the list ahead of any of the aritsts i mentioned. why? because unlike you, they know jazz.
pat metheny and john scofield before wes montgomery and django reinhardt? really? both scofield and metheny would disagree with that choice. charlie christian? kenny burrell? grant green? all more important guitarists than any you mentioned. also- charlie parker and lester young did not both play the saxophone- bird played alto sax and pres played tenor. miles played trumpet and flugelhorn. coltrane played alto, tenor and soprano sax. mingus played bass and piano. and where is sonny rollins?
this vid is symptomatic of of the failure of our society to teach and have respect for what is arguably americas only signifigant contribution to the world of art. some hits and way to many misses
What about Art Blakey? Paul Desmond? Roy Eldridge? Al Di Meola? To name a few.Not to mention many of the greats that others have named. Lists are very subjective,but any fool can stick a camera in front of their face....
Duke Ellighton, Bud Powell, Thelonious Monk, Ben Webster, Coleman Hawkins, Chet Baker?? They have Wooten and not Jaco Pastorious... I agree with bopguity, it is the most hilariously ignorant video ever!!!
@tiomakeke well you look at kenny g the pentatonic failure that is all he plays, and all that is is a blues scale without the flat3 and a sharp 4 which isnt that hard to do, and yes he leaves out some of the best improvisers from the euro stage,ex. Candy Dulfer, but he also doesnt keep it in cronological order cause alot of these are out of place
I completely agree with every single pejorative comment regarding this list. Although the video's creator aimed to introduce new listeners to the most towering & legendary figures in all of contemporary jazz, I think that he is quite the amateur himself. Before making videos listen to some: Dexter, Sonny, Monk, Wes, Cannonball, Blakey, etc. This will remove your garbage fusion & MMW fetish. (I have nothing against fusion, however it merits no place on a list, when main pillars are missing.)
It's good to know Tatum, Bean, Bud Powell, Clifford Brown, Ben Webster, Teddy Wilson, Paul Chambers, etc., etc., etc., are left out to make room for Wooten, Medeski, Martin, Wood, Metheny and Scofield, all of whom would laugh to puking if they saw this list. All right, no more comments from me.
This is probably the most hilariously ignorant video I have ever seen. I am not sure whether to feel pity for this guy and this production, or unmitigated rage. LOL on 1/3 of the 25 greatest soloists being associates of MMW. LMAO.
I must agree with a good number of the posters here, that this list is at best sorely lacking in a great number of exceptional soloists, and at worst, undermines the narrators credibility as a Jazz "aficionado". A much better title for this list would be 25 of My Personal Favorite Soloists.
This was terrible. He started at louis, and louis is one of my favs BUT no Joplin? the 1st to popularize what we know today as jazz, no jelly roll morton? james p johnson, willie the lion smith and fats waller was the 3 kings on piano but no mention. NO TATUM? how did tyner come b4 coltrane? If you wanna really get at it, wheres buddy bolden, creator of the big 4?
Victor Wooten over Slam Stewart? No mention of many great jazz improvisers like Art Tatum or Wes Montgomery. This video producer needs to do their homework...
"Yes John Coltrain was a great Soloist, but to call him the greatest player of all time to have played any instrument is utter crap! Mozart, J.S Bach, Paganini, Segovia, Jaquelin Du Pret, Django Reinhardt, and the list is so long, of legendary soloists and musicians who many would rate ahead of Coltraine! What Music College did this 'dreamer' attend to come to these nonsensical opinions?! Anyone who attempts a list such as this, is clearly exposed as a Fool, and a Fool he certainly is!"
No he says:The greatest instrumentalist of all time to play any instrument..but of course you are right about the list..no Wes Montgomery,no Tatum,no Bud Powell e.t.c.
"This Guy doesnt know what He's talking about! LouisArmstrong did Add 'Swing' to Jazz, but He was not the person who 'invented it! Buddy Bolden is recognised by Historians as being the 'first to play Jazz'. Also, how can you leave out the Man considered to be the GREATEST Jazz guitarist of all;-Charlie Christian! "Duh".
its hard to make a list of only 25, but this was a poor attempt. How can you have guys like Steve Gadd, Bela Fleck, DJ Logic, Victor Wooten etc(who you could argue are not really jazz musicians) on the list and no Hawk, Monk, Tatum, Brecker, Charlie Christian, Shorter, Rollins, Cannonball, Jim Hall, Wes Montgomery, Freddie Hubbard, Lee Morgan, Jimmy Smith, Joe Henderson!?!? What a joke! Terrible, just Terrible. Kill me now.
ART TATUUUUUUUM!!!!!
theMarsFusion 7 months ago
Charlie Mingus? lol, you have no idea what you're talking about, go research something more cut out for you, like rock or crap, Oops! I meant rap... alot of your end people are just not that well known, some of them were not even jazz musicians, Victor Wooten for example as amazing as he is, is not purely a jazz musician
JHoffTrumpeter 8 months ago
Charlie Mingus? lol, you have no idea what you're talking about, go research something more cut out for you, like rock or crap, Oops! I meant rap
JHoffTrumpeter 8 months ago
where does wynton marsalis come in?!
HeyImJonah 9 months ago
this dude kinda sucks at jazz history. its even better that there isn't even jazz music playing ... godd
mxer6161 9 months ago
Comment removed
mxer6161 9 months ago
Douche, I know that these kind of greatest list is stupid, but this is beyond human idiocy. DJ in Jazz? When you think Miles in the 80's, Chick Corea, Herbie Hancock's robot tone and all those 2 hours of one chords "funky jams" were bad enough. What the fuck? "Jazz is hip too you know, there's DJ now you can rave to Jazz!". Fuck DJ, "Play button" is not an instrument. What's next? Photoshop in fine art space of Louvre? And yeah, Steve Gadd (drummer...) but no way Art Tatum (God).
CroissantOrange 10 months ago
dj logic? what are you talking about? how can you put dj logic on a list and omit wayne shorter, freddie hubbard, lee morgan, coleman hawkins, ben webster, clifford brown and all the others i mentioned in my previous post? i guarantee that every single person you put on your list that is alive today would disagree with you putting them on the list ahead of any of the aritsts i mentioned. why? because unlike you, they know jazz.
letebaguere 11 months ago
pat metheny and john scofield before wes montgomery and django reinhardt? really? both scofield and metheny would disagree with that choice. charlie christian? kenny burrell? grant green? all more important guitarists than any you mentioned. also- charlie parker and lester young did not both play the saxophone- bird played alto sax and pres played tenor. miles played trumpet and flugelhorn. coltrane played alto, tenor and soprano sax. mingus played bass and piano. and where is sonny rollins?
letebaguere 11 months ago
Where is Adam Deitch? He recorded 2 CDs with John Scofield, performed with DJ Logic on and on.....................
bdeitch21 1 year ago
this is nonsens.
trumpetman80 1 year ago
Of course people are going to complain and of course I'm going to be one of those people:
Charlie Christian ?
TampoFTW 1 year ago
Wouldn't Stan Getz be in there?
Borism907 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
WES MONTGOMERY? DJANGO REINHARDT?!
FreeGuitarLicks 1 year ago
sonny rollins?chet baker?lee morgan?freddie hubbard?
basseditio 1 year ago
dexter gordon?clifford brown?kenny garret? niels-henning orsted pedersen?ray brown?joe pass?wes montgomery?jaco pastorius?tom harell?paul chambers?
basseditio 1 year ago
this vid is symptomatic of of the failure of our society to teach and have respect for what is arguably americas only signifigant contribution to the world of art. some hits and way to many misses
mpcguy 1 year ago
What about Art Blakey? Paul Desmond? Roy Eldridge? Al Di Meola? To name a few.Not to mention many of the greats that others have named. Lists are very subjective,but any fool can stick a camera in front of their face....
charles1964 1 year ago
WES MONTGOMERY?
BeatBay 1 year ago
Duke Ellighton, Bud Powell, Thelonious Monk, Ben Webster, Coleman Hawkins, Chet Baker?? They have Wooten and not Jaco Pastorious... I agree with bopguity, it is the most hilariously ignorant video ever!!!
dennis70s 1 year ago
WES MONTGOMERY?
francisco444 1 year ago 2
@tiomakeke well you look at kenny g the pentatonic failure that is all he plays, and all that is is a blues scale without the flat3 and a sharp 4 which isnt that hard to do, and yes he leaves out some of the best improvisers from the euro stage,ex. Candy Dulfer, but he also doesnt keep it in cronological order cause alot of these are out of place
omeganinjasmurf 1 year ago
@tiomakeke stfu kenny g is terrible and i say that with rage....... pentatonic failure
omeganinjasmurf 1 year ago
haha
Finnbiffen 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I completely agree with every single pejorative comment regarding this list. Although the video's creator aimed to introduce new listeners to the most towering & legendary figures in all of contemporary jazz, I think that he is quite the amateur himself. Before making videos listen to some: Dexter, Sonny, Monk, Wes, Cannonball, Blakey, etc. This will remove your garbage fusion & MMW fetish. (I have nothing against fusion, however it merits no place on a list, when main pillars are missing.)
verzelli 1 year ago
Comment removed
verzelli 1 year ago
It's good to know Tatum, Bean, Bud Powell, Clifford Brown, Ben Webster, Teddy Wilson, Paul Chambers, etc., etc., etc., are left out to make room for Wooten, Medeski, Martin, Wood, Metheny and Scofield, all of whom would laugh to puking if they saw this list. All right, no more comments from me.
bopguity 2 years ago
This is probably the most hilariously ignorant video I have ever seen. I am not sure whether to feel pity for this guy and this production, or unmitigated rage. LOL on 1/3 of the 25 greatest soloists being associates of MMW. LMAO.
bopguity 2 years ago
Where the hell is Jaco Pastorius...
zooyork9213 2 years ago 2
To give the guy his credit, making a list like this has to be a bloody hard thing to do, and if I made one I'd not be so bold about it lol
but where's art tatum? not to mention Johny Dods, King Oliver, Kid Ori...
djoutrage18 2 years ago
It would probably help to start by limiting oneself to actual jazz musician's and going from there. DJ Logic? Seriously?
bopguity 2 years ago
Speechless....ignore this nonsense
drumgit 2 years ago
this list is a hoax
3chocolate3clock3 2 years ago
I must agree with a good number of the posters here, that this list is at best sorely lacking in a great number of exceptional soloists, and at worst, undermines the narrators credibility as a Jazz "aficionado". A much better title for this list would be 25 of My Personal Favorite Soloists.
editfreek 2 years ago
How can you make such a "list".This is ridiculous
trying to do this shows your are an ignorant.
daniel72800 2 years ago
you are an idiot, that list was terrible.
maciejgrebowicz 2 years ago
This was terrible. He started at louis, and louis is one of my favs BUT no Joplin? the 1st to popularize what we know today as jazz, no jelly roll morton? james p johnson, willie the lion smith and fats waller was the 3 kings on piano but no mention. NO TATUM? how did tyner come b4 coltrane? If you wanna really get at it, wheres buddy bolden, creator of the big 4?
phillytalented 2 years ago
the guy only knows 25 great jazzplayers ;)
arturo sandoval for me he is nr 1 ^^
grtz
rasta2830 3 years ago
wheres Gene Krupa, Chet Baker, Louie Bellson, and Stan Getz? (just to name a few)
lazydude99 3 years ago
Greg Howe...John Mclaughlin...ect. Times infinity.
OnyxMass 3 years ago
Elvin Jones????? Where's Dexter Gordon?
FatManOWNSatBARI 3 years ago
Where is Oscar Peterson?
maclen44 3 years ago
so right ....what about michel petrucciani,miles davis,kenny garrett,wes montgomery,joe pass,jaco pastorius,marsialis,pat martino and so many
breezee1205 3 years ago
Victor Wooten over Slam Stewart? No mention of many great jazz improvisers like Art Tatum or Wes Montgomery. This video producer needs to do their homework...
swingitjack 3 years ago
YES!!!! Slam is the man!! no wes or charlie christian. no tiny grimes but dont forget dj logic lol
phillytalented 2 years ago
"Yes John Coltrain was a great Soloist, but to call him the greatest player of all time to have played any instrument is utter crap! Mozart, J.S Bach, Paganini, Segovia, Jaquelin Du Pret, Django Reinhardt, and the list is so long, of legendary soloists and musicians who many would rate ahead of Coltraine! What Music College did this 'dreamer' attend to come to these nonsensical opinions?! Anyone who attempts a list such as this, is clearly exposed as a Fool, and a Fool he certainly is!"
beethovenbix 3 years ago
No he says:The greatest instrumentalist of all time to play any instrument..but of course you are right about the list..no Wes Montgomery,no Tatum,no Bud Powell e.t.c.
xatzidakis 2 years ago
"This Guy doesnt know what He's talking about! LouisArmstrong did Add 'Swing' to Jazz, but He was not the person who 'invented it! Buddy Bolden is recognised by Historians as being the 'first to play Jazz'. Also, how can you leave out the Man considered to be the GREATEST Jazz guitarist of all;-Charlie Christian! "Duh".
beethovenbix 3 years ago
Agreed... I'm from New Orleans and we all know where it started, but Louis is the king of jazz..
thomasward00 3 years ago
Coleman Hawkins, Art Tatum, Thelonious Monk, Michael Brecker?????????
jazzyaardvark 3 years ago
its hard to make a list of only 25, but this was a poor attempt. How can you have guys like Steve Gadd, Bela Fleck, DJ Logic, Victor Wooten etc(who you could argue are not really jazz musicians) on the list and no Hawk, Monk, Tatum, Brecker, Charlie Christian, Shorter, Rollins, Cannonball, Jim Hall, Wes Montgomery, Freddie Hubbard, Lee Morgan, Jimmy Smith, Joe Henderson!?!? What a joke! Terrible, just Terrible. Kill me now.
hallmanjon 3 years ago
Bud Powell,Wes Montgomery,Sonny Rollins e.t.c.
xatzidakis 2 years ago
HE DIDN"T MENTION SONNY ROLLINS!!!!
oober349 2 years ago
what about wynton marsalis?
anemeka 4 years ago