mccoy without a doubt.wow, colt brennan had 58 touchdowns, but they werent against good teams.
when they went against a "good team" like georgia he threw 3 interceptions and no interceptions.colt mccoy (against oklahoma's great defense) he had 80% completion, a passing touchdown and almost 300 yards.
not enough evidence? how about the good oklahoma state defense in its prime, when they were undefeated and at #6, he had 377 yards, 2 touchdowns and 84.4 completion percentage.
k....explain away the Redskins preseason. I like people like you, cuz every time you say Brennan can't he turns around and DOES. Every time I'm always right there to tell you I told you so and it feels good :) aloha
A nfl preseason game is better than college football. Yeah brennan did it vs weaker opponents but he didnt have the greatest ppl to work with either. If he played if the offence frienddly Big 12 he would still put up good stats. You cant judge who is better until McCoy gets into the NFL. McCoy shoulda won Heisman and IMO so should have Brennan.
I bet McCoy could hurl 58 td passes too in that conference. Put Brennan in the big twelve and see what happens..... of course Brennnan would be with tech though.
you must have never seen the other dude play then. mccoy has players around him. brennan hurls 58 td passes his junior year with a decent devon bess at reciever and a couple of average joes
but brennan plays against average joes, we all saw what happened when he played a tough georgia defense, i think brennan is a great quarterback but colt mccoy would dominate alot more if he played in the WAC
Brennan is the real mccoy. Anyone who even thinks about mentioning the two in the same sentence has obviously not watched any of Brennan/Hawaii's games.
Anyone who says McCoy obviously has never seen Brennan play. Not many guys can complete 3 out of every 4 passes against a defense that already knows the pass is coming.
brennan played in the wac. enough said
mikeghiassi 8 months ago
You guys with your comments...Good choice with Brennan.....HAHAHAHAH
AndroidHero90 10 months ago
these are my 2 favorite qbs
joedevereaux 1 year ago
umm are u friking kiding me... OF COURSE BRENNAN.... and sorry im just stating tha obvious just to pass by time
BrysonSao101 1 year ago
Definitely not Brennan.
d0861 3 years ago
mccoy without a doubt.wow, colt brennan had 58 touchdowns, but they werent against good teams.
when they went against a "good team" like georgia he threw 3 interceptions and no interceptions.colt mccoy (against oklahoma's great defense) he had 80% completion, a passing touchdown and almost 300 yards.
not enough evidence? how about the good oklahoma state defense in its prime, when they were undefeated and at #6, he had 377 yards, 2 touchdowns and 84.4 completion percentage.
69jewzrcool69 3 years ago
k....explain away the Redskins preseason. I like people like you, cuz every time you say Brennan can't he turns around and DOES. Every time I'm always right there to tell you I told you so and it feels good :) aloha
renshumainichi 3 years ago
when has he ever turned himself around, idiot
69jewzrcool69 3 years ago
guess you didn't watch brennan play with the Skins. Go watch a video of the Hall of Fame Game and then try calling me an idiot again, dumbass
renshumainichi 3 years ago
he didn't turn himself around, dumbass. o my god, he did good in a preseason game. doesn't make him better than colt mccoy.
69jewzrcool69 3 years ago
A nfl preseason game is better than college football. Yeah brennan did it vs weaker opponents but he didnt have the greatest ppl to work with either. If he played if the offence frienddly Big 12 he would still put up good stats. You cant judge who is better until McCoy gets into the NFL. McCoy shoulda won Heisman and IMO so should have Brennan.
clintmclean1992 2 years ago
I bet McCoy could hurl 58 td passes too in that conference. Put Brennan in the big twelve and see what happens..... of course Brennnan would be with tech though.
L0nGhOrN512 3 years ago
McCoy would probably hurl 90 TD's in the WAC...:-)
masterofthestoneage9 3 years ago
Colt 45 is my choice. (The Liquor not the gun)
DonV310 3 years ago
Brennan is terrible and so is hawaii, the football team not the state.
Oz2 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
mc coy is better than the other dude by far...
dammityousuck182 4 years ago
Clueless
WitteZiekte6 4 years ago 2
how did the UGA game feel? the only real opponent the rainbow warriors played all year :))
elprezidentebotella 3 years ago
true, and I think mccoy had to go up against way harder teams then brennan, I mean I'm not dissin him, but he did not play any real teams
ironcladgungrave 3 years ago
haha wow...even some texas fans say that Mccoy sucks
mainlandkid 4 years ago 3
you must have never seen the other dude play then. mccoy has players around him. brennan hurls 58 td passes his junior year with a decent devon bess at reciever and a couple of average joes
blibby712 4 years ago 3
but brennan plays against average joes, we all saw what happened when he played a tough georgia defense, i think brennan is a great quarterback but colt mccoy would dominate alot more if he played in the WAC
Frostilicus51 4 years ago
Maybe we should ask the Georgia Bulldogs that question...
Noles23200 4 years ago 2
lol, yup, im sure they would say MCCOY!!!!
flamebordr777 3 years ago 2
sophomore slump got to him last year. a healthy/experienced line will do wonders for him, even without the star WR's he's used to having
elprezidentebotella 3 years ago
Dennis Dixon would be my choice because he can run just as good as he throws. Even though colt brennan is amazing.
goldlion2 4 years ago 4
omg is that even worth asking??!!!
XxKuranxX 4 years ago 4
that's right mccoy sucks major shit
coltb4heisman 4 years ago 3
Brennan is the real mccoy. Anyone who even thinks about mentioning the two in the same sentence has obviously not watched any of Brennan/Hawaii's games.
scorpionicdna 4 years ago 6
@scorpionicdna Brennan is the real McCoy?
Kamakazi242012 1 year ago
Anyone who says McCoy obviously has never seen Brennan play. Not many guys can complete 3 out of every 4 passes against a defense that already knows the pass is coming.
screamatic 4 years ago 6
i agree, brennan all the way
jeremybloom1115 4 years ago 5
whoohoo, dude!
Kaizen63 4 years ago 2