American Idol Top 12 Girls Review 02/23/2010

[calvininsf]

@musac11 Your comment was incoherent, inaccurate, and illogical. I disagree with some of the commentary, but your response made me lose faith in humanity given the sick, twisted logic you use to prove hotelangel as uninformed.

[1990BJK]

Kelly clarkson never sang a Heart song on Idol, Carrie Underwood did.

[benz881]

You must see THE VOICE OF HOLLAND that are talents!

[MrsSnowboarder14]

LOL he's funny XD

[alisonbigshow]

Wth is wrong with this guy?

[idolfan2117]

Dude Carrie Underwood sing Heart better the Anyone on this show! Janell Sing it Great Too!

[amazingkiddd]

This is so lame.

[Swimminggal340]

I LOVE HER so Stfu She should have stayed.

[elmo2488]

HEY ALEX

[thegodmachine]

I love the pictures you collect of the contestants, they always seem to be making a face.

[astrolifter]

I feel the opposite about sobhan, I just like her, she does her own thing

[EvilAlligator]

WHATTHEBUCK wannabe...

[caloduty24]

paige is goin to win it all bitch....

[lanceand]

Not so much a review as repeating what the judges said, with a big of rambling in between.

[js92every]

who is this guy noone cares about him. He stank and who says cootos. anywasy if he cant sing why is he judging others hes nobody and needs to understand that

[TheHTCHero1]

duh they're looking for a Taylor Swift-like person...they're gonna make a girl a winner and rig the contest

[Kyles45Angel]

Rig it so a girl will win? Most of the guys suck.

[Ianwrym]

Haeley's not that bad, guys. It just depends on the song she's singing. She can only belt it so much before her voice begins to mess up. Crap, even -i- could only do so much as a bass in a choir before my voice would crack and squeak.

I got to hear her perform her own handwritten stuff live and it was great, so...

[TashaOwensbyTV]

Hayley has a good voice but needs to work on it for a little while. And stop SmiLing SOOOOOOOOOOO muCh!!!!! ._.

[ElectrikkPaperClipxx]

that hayley vaughn is so god awful at singing

[zthang]

Simon said out of all the girls you have the best voict? It's "VOICE"! Learn how to pronounce words if you're going to attempt to have a show.

[ghvhcanada]

My top faves are Crystal, Siobhan, Lily and Lacey I love those girls they are great

[lynfendleyfoster]

Who is this guy? I'm from the South, but sorry, you sound like a hick. To quote Kara, you've got ridiculous pipes, but don't mean it as a compliment.

[checkerz982]

Lilly Scott is amazingg, you just wish you could be like these girls, you're not funny dude, shut up and get a life.

[keysadall]

I agree with checererz982

[crazyPAgirl]

Siobhan reminds me of Ally Sheedy in the Breakfast Club (vodka)! LOL

There's something about her I like though.

She's very humble and I don't think she realizes how good she is.

Crystal though... she's great!

Haeley (sp)... noooooooooo ... her smile irritates me. It hurt to look at her.

[keysadall]

her name is - is really weird, and I agree, there is something that I cant put my finger on, Tonight I am looking forward to Lily, Di di, Crystal, and Hayley (because she is terrible. I am also very curious to see what Lacey will choose along with Di di.

[ghvhcanada]

Siobhan is an Irish name and is not so weird.

[keysadall]

Okay first off- the girl hayley (the young african american girl) is terrible. when they picked the top 24, tori should have definitley got in, not hayley. Lacey is a goos dinger but dong choice is her weakness. I really do not think that the girls who went home did not desearve that. I normally dont say that. Michelle's good she needs to do more tho. Crystal is real and raw and I love her. Di di has an awesome voice, The first black girl....nobody is going to remember her. Shavon or whatever

[Samaraizan]

I sorta agree with you except they all are equally bad, worst american idol year so far.. That ive seen

[kahnt]

well, i love siobhan. the first time i saw her on idol, i fell in love right away. great voice, great personality. among those other contestants who are all posers, she's the real deal. she knows her music. she knows REAL music.

there are only four girl contestants to watch: siobhan, crystal, lilly and katelyn.

[jdoe02]

Paige was good and I thought she did great.

U don't really know what ur talking about fag, u are just a Dan Rather-not hear your voice!!

[19DJD]

i agree jdoe02 with u 100%!!!! paige is good!!

[americanidolkid]

Katelyn Epperly is Alania Whitaker 2.0 lol.

[mec21arts]

dnt read your jokes dude ... thx

[topazpoet]

Couldn't stand Haeley. Uggh. Awful!!! B-U-T-C-H-E-R-E-D that song. I don't even like the Beatles much either. Just to be fair I even went back and listened to her on youtube again - only to shudder through it. yikes! Can't believe she didn't make bottom 2! Hello, America? Was sad for Janell. She had potential. Loved Siobahn. Also am a fan of Lilly, Didi, and MamaSox.

[NewYorkYankee25M]

paige miles wasn't that good to me, is it me or are the judges fuckin retarded this year? and is this competition missing anything? hmmm? let's see, tori kelly anyone?

[musac11]

kate epperly would have been big in the old times in front of guys drinking alcohol, you know, during prohibition......prohibition is when alcohol was banned. wow, your just as dumb as your commentary. you have A LOT of time.

[hotelangel]

I said she would have done well in the Speakeasies....its where people went to drink alcohol during prohibition. Pull out your history book.

[ClUbPenGuIn0wNz]

I dont know if you noticed but you went on and on about crystal bowersox. I guess you really like her. I agree about her hair and how it looks like matted up dog hair though =P

[majinbu2town]

I like Bowesox and Lilly Scott at the beginning... but whoa! Siobhan Magnus is hot!! really good performance.

[mssweetart15]

Siobhan magnus is amazing!!!!

[jt89707]

i absolutly love Siobhan lol

[livinginexiletheband]

Siobhan Magnus turned me into a fan with that performance. I'm sure a lot of people agree with this dude, but I hope not.

[kahnt]

yes, i hope not too.

siobhan all the way!!!

[aliceakanewg]

shuddap dude. siobhan is AWESOME.

[Bubblesxoxo95]

i luv didi :)

[MATESWORLD1]

what a wanker!

[americanidolkid]

Ugh Janell was ROBBED.

[lonelytoon101]

Didi <3

[americanidolz2010HD]

oh and when does the judges save come into effect?

[DoYouBelieveInMusic]

oh i forgot about that, i dont think they do that until the top 12

[treemoka]

Haley sound like a mouse giving birth to thumb tacks.....

[Rodrick1990]

dude is the worst teleprompter reader ever...

[jeffreypaulbobrick]

Interesting comments. I have to say I totally appreciate your thoughts on Haeley Vaughn. I think she has her flaws but also is magical!

[6sheldon]

I loved Hayleys preformance! She was sooo goood. I did notice her ptich though bt it was still so interesting ! And lovely !

[treemoka]

Were you watching the same performance?

[6sheldon]

i sure was. Shes sooo goooooooooood!

[hiphopjade]

srry but i disagrre about kaitlyn her even know her outfit was crazy her voice was powerful and sounded good but i am a fan of crystal

[calisouthqueen]

for the most part i agree with him. the ones he said sucked sucked and the ones that did well did well. But i am not that excited this season.

[fanfanz9]

AMERICAN IDOL SEASON 9 = WORST SEASON OF ALL TIME . Tyler voted off , can;t believe , Janell voted off , can;t belive e. DIK TIM URBAN shoud fuking going home now before I burst his face . VOTE FOR THE WORST will BURST ALL OF OUR VOTES this year . They will win this year . VFTWCOM

[americanidolz2010HD]

@fanfanz9 yeah wtf man im thinking the same thing, janell and tyler were the best... janell my favourite girl and tyler my second fav guy wtf is this fucked up shit. now andrew better win... if he dosnt this is worse then last season

[XJustVenusX]

Didi And Crystal r My Fav girls!

For the boys deff Casey and Andrew!

[camtheman1493]

@XJustVenusX agreed 10000%

[DoYouBelieveInMusic]

i do agree with u, i thot this year would finally be the guys year, but after watching yesterday's performances... ugh.. it was even worse than the girls....

john park was my favorite but after that performance i think he let us all down and is going home,, that and tim urban, idk y they chose him of all ppl to come back...

[SteelAVic18]

Go PAIGE MILES!!

[Lou4506]

This guy does not know what he is talking about

[7youfoundme7]

lilly, didi, and crystal. haeley did so bad.

[tksbaskets]

I LOVE your commentaries. Thank you for taking the time to post. I'll be a loyal viewer from now on!

[americanidolkid]

Go Janell! =]

[HippieLife15]

Crystal, Lilly, and Didi are the CLEAR top 3 girls.

[spiegel]

@HippieLife15 I have the same Top 3 girls as you. OF the 3, I think Didi has the looks and personality to go the furthest. The other 2 are kinda indy anti-idol types and Simon doesn't want those. He's said in interviews he would like a Taylor Swift type, so Didi is the closest to that mold. Plus the whole singing for her deceased friend makes her someone you just want to pull for. From the guys I'm going with Andrew Garcia, so it'll be him vs. Didi in the finals. Best performance wins!

[tuamorsita]

wooooo thats exactly what I said... i called them for top two as well!!! :))))

[dud3man6969]

You could mess around with the knobs on a sound board and make anybody sound terrible or they clean up stuff and Idol does that alot. The band had no energy at all that night. By the finals the band and the stage sound will be perfect and a lot of people will think the finalists owe their talent to american idol. I hate that they do that. But I think they already know who they want to see in the final and the others are just there for the top 6 or so to knock down.

[rockon217]

lilly scott was amazing!! definitely one of my favorites so far

[tintin27tube]

I totally disagree with you about Katelyn Epperly. I thought her voice was surprisingly better that anybody else there.

[HiDavidArchuleta]

Wow...look at your new set gurl.

[girrlit]

I think they should be banned from picking their own songs, they all seemed to struggle.

I'm hoping Ashley and Haeley are the ones to go. Lacey Brown has a decent voice - just no song choice or arrangement skills apparently

[linzers124]

I feel the exact same way as you do about Siobhan (sp?). I just don't like her, and I can't figure out why! Good video tonight, love the background!

[ThePeng23]

Get a Job you Dick!

[ippo174]

send haeley home.. it was a REALLY a mess.. she sucked the song and she is very ugly cant afford to watch her face

[drdent7]

I thought I was the only who caught the bullshit Lilly Scot was pulling about living in her car. But I like her but can she sing theater songs? I hope so. Crystal was the best.

[jyokogawa]

How many people are they sending home tomorrow?

[hotelangel]

2 girls and 2 guys

[Literarygrl]

Haeley is one of the most honest people out there...she's original, young, fresh, and her smile lights the room! It was a first night on national tv for everyone and I hope she gets to come back. I KNOW this girl can rock the house and her warmth can melt the polar ice cap....maybe the song wasn't her best, but she's got the talent and she took a great risk to be her own woman! Bravo Haeley!! Keep singing!! LOVE YOU!!!!

[TranceAnton]

Haeley doesent even sing, fuck shes Horrible, the worst ever.

[MrPweezy15]

lacey is gone and i think paige

[jlongen]

I really think Haeley should go home.. What a terrible performance!! It was terrible.. Definitely a guys' year...

[0xTRellyx0]

Thank you for saying something nice about Haley. When I first saw her I didn't like her, but her annoying voice is starting to grow on me. I loved the chorus too, and when she was on, she sounded great. I think her album will sell and kids will love her.

[19DJD]

thank u for not bashing haley also like some of these ahole youtubers she is a really gr8 person

[dpopa15]

I would understand you disliking "I want to hold your hand" but saying its in your top ten least favorite songs of all time is a bit crazy. There are plenty of bad songs out there, and that my friend is definitely not one of them.

[AnatloyChessPlayer]

I like Crystal alot but I am so sick of her talking about her son! Am I overreacting or is it really getting annoying?

[BigBlackTranny94]

The worst performance was by Haley Vaughn. She did butcher the majority of the song and it was hard to listen to. But I doubt she will go home.

Ashley Rodriguez deserves to go home, but I think that she got enough face time that she will get another chance.

Paige Miles was put into a terrible position, and I would not be surprised if she suffers because of it.

And my one lock for going home this week would be Lacey Brown. She was boring, and it would be the biggest shock if she stays around.

[CrazyJamesification]

Thanks for the review Joe. I was at my musical rehearsals today and yesterday so I missed most of the show. everyone sucks! gahh! Adam Lambert and Kris Allen should have ended the show of all seasons to come.

[rayna876]

janelle is going home

[AdamLambertSpears]

Siobhan, Katie, Didi and Crystal are the best girls

and the bottom one are Ashley, Paige, Jannell and Haley - two of them will probably be eliminated

[Eradicator0523]

i think lilly and katelyn

[americanidolkid]

Janell and Lilly are amazing. that would make a great finale. Tonights bottom three : Ashley, Lacey, Haley. Going home : Ashley and Lacey.

[Eradicator0523]

i dont think janell can sing

[garyshoaf]

I would buy a CD of Siobhan Magnus. ( I don't usually buy CDs.) She may not be the best (I think she is), but her voice sends chills up my spine.

[girrlit]

Surely Haeley will be going home??

Paige Miles might be seriously disadvantaged by the lack of screen time leading up to this.

Ashley was pretty bad though.

I kinda like Lacey and hope she manages to get another chance

[CookieLove1983]

Dude you are on something...there was nothing good about Hayley's performance...chorus was bad!  Best performance of the night was Bowersox

[dhedricks]

Totally agree with everything except Hailey's performance. I believe I'd rather shove a red hot fire poker in my ears than have to listen to her the rest of the season. She is absolutely adorable, but something about her sound with her tongue just freaks me out. Like it's way too big or something. Time will make her a better artist, I hope! :o(

[sportsman893]

Haeley Vaughn was an abomination.

[1313fix]

wow i agree with almost everything you said! glad i'm not the only one

[lldeland]

Sure Crystal sounds like Jewel or Indigo Girls, but she looks just like Adele

[GHWHIZ]

going home:

Lacey

Haeley might not could be katelyn or lilly

[basboosa911]

The girls were so bad that I had to turn it off. Kara talks too much. I dont know if I can manage the whole season.  Seems like a dozer...

[dayborne35]

my favorites are Crystal, Janell, Lacey, Siobhan, and Lilly, the others i dont care much about one way or the other. I do agree that they were'nt on top of their game and i also agree that katie is just very annoying and overrated. i really could not care less about her, her voice, or her grandmother. theres no doubt she'll be in the top 12 but i hope she dosent win.

[TheTechTutor]

You are an IDIOT paige miles is absolutely AMAZING! she was so good!!! you have no taste!

[lfgalbraith]

@TheTechTutor Yeah she is

[letsbeefriendsok]

I agree with every thing you said. I think the girl that sang the dixie chicks song was so bad and I used to love that song.

I did think the #11 singer was the best.

[whytemyst32]

dixie chicks song??? oh dear. just.../shakes head. come on now.

[coolsims1234]

the best was definetely didi benami and going home will probably be haeley vaughn and ashley rodruguez

[laurenwuzhere915]

@coolsims1234

oh god i can only hope so

i dont know why everyone likes ashley

i really hate her voice.

[babyinblack]

i don't think any of these girls are ready to be a star so far. some more than others but they all need work. i'm rooting for the guys.

[newyoricannyc]

i am so over crystal, didi, lilly, and the girl with the weird face when she sings

[laurenwuzhere915]

@newyoricannyc

haha that would be siobhan

so am i...the girls arent very good this year. and siobhan makes the worst faces.

[meeshter24]

That detail narrows it down. Which one?

[katgirl347]

First off, someone please just...Tell Crystal to brush the back of her hair.

Lily, Siobhan, and Lacey are my favorites. They're unique. :D

Ashley was horriable. She needs to go. (But no one was really GREAT. Except Lily.)

The judges don't even know what they're talking about anymore. Kara needs to go. I want Paula back! D:

[meeshter24]

Kara seems like she always wants to find a new rival and pick a fight with them. She needs to go.

[lldeland]

Sorry, but Paula's not coming back. She's ugly

[shquib]

i think they didn't show paige on purpose in earlier episodes and they boched the sound on purpose, it's just a little weird that all that happened, I don't want her to win anyway

[MegaMlbtalk]

miles and, rodriquez.

[Shnumenstein]

I could hear her, but I couldn't hear Ashley Rodriguez during the recap of the night.

[chubbaluvva]

Your Janelle, Lacey, Katelyn stills...LOL!

Haeley butchered her song, but shes not going home.

[Megow64]

You know, I love me some Ellen, but for some reason seeing her on Idol just annoys me so badly.

I guess it's like I love cheese and I love coffee, but I sure as heck wont want them together.

[chubbaluvva]

@Megow64 HAHA Agreed.

[Ikurun]

I actually liked Megan Joy last year (not always the singing, unfortunately, but her studio recordings were pretty good), and I like Lacey too. Hope she gets another chance! :o

And I totally disagree about Haeley. There is something about her I can't stand... and she talks kinda weird, which also happens when she is singing. I pretty sure others have noticed that too.

Favorites:

Siobhan (love her. Hope she goes bluesy/rock-ish next time, I think it will suit her), Crystal and.. Lilly. =)

[sinawava42]

I hope the boys are better. The only ones I would keep based on last night's performances are: Crystal, Didi, Katelyn and Michelle. I hope to see more of Paige, Ashley, Lily and Katie.

[rd1999]

send them all home but Crystal Bowersox