i must say i didnt care for nightwish's version, but im not really into there style music, But we can all agree That Gary Rocks the hell outta this song, that man could shred, Rip Gary :(
Didn't know Eric Singer ever played with Gary Moore. Eric is one of the best drummers out there and Gary Moore is one hell of a player but doesn't get enough credit for his heavy/rock playing.
This arrangement is one that I can work with, in terms of both a sophisticated bass line (àu Geddy Lee, or John Entwhistle) and additional percussion (such as a pipe-band drumline); the tempo is consistent with the Jig, a common 6/8 theme in Scots'-Irish music. Moore got the speed dead-on both during the Wild Frontier sessions and in this concert excerpt.
@usernameofnobody just one Finnish band,playing''gothic hard rock'',and covered this song,not even near,but as A finn,had to listen it....Gary is brilliant,one of the best-thanks for sharing!
I like the nighwish version really quite a lot. But it is absolutely nothing on Gary Moore's version. And thats without his erection enducing guitar playing.
i wouldnt say it otherwise, but yeah this is the right time that he used atleast some of the Soldano Prototypes, He Has two i believe one which is pretty modded and one standard, one of them is covered in Grey Tolex
Like many other groups, of Nigthwish has "performed" an existing song after paying or ask the original owner of the copyright to use it, is very common if you had not noticed -.-.
Awesome!!!!! Night wish is full of shit. Their only talent is copying. How can u even compare Gary Moore and Night Wish. Gary is a Legend in his own right. Night Wish????? Is just another band.
2. Fuck you, you jerk, do me a favor and die, NightWish done cover and Tuomas said so in interview, he said that this is not their song, but Gary Moore cover. Tuomas is God of Keyboards and sound of metal and he is a Legend too. Yes, NW can compare Gary, it is not matter how old is band, but what music are they prefer.
3. From your comment I can see that you know nothing about music...
Listen up, I'll say this just this once... NighWish is younger band, but that is not matter, they can compare to Gary, but the most of the people think that they cannot 'cause he is "fucking legend," and they say so because he is simply older than NW...I'm not that good in English,so I won't explain you anything, I'll just say that I am musician to, and I know what it takes to be a legend, I know that secret... It's a long way, and it takes a time, but Tuomas is still young.
Cover is always, and I mean always one level above the original... You would understand that if you were a musician... When you take someone song and do a cover, you are automatically rising that song to a higher level, because you are improving that song.. So cover can be better than original, which means that NightWish done better than this...
A cover NEVER going to be better than the original, dont forget that
I love the Nightwish version, i love the band, Nightwish is one of my favorite band
Gary Moore is the musician behind this song, thats why a cover never going to be better. Even if NW made a great job, you cant compare both versions, because Gary composed this song and he is the one that made all the job, NW just made some changes, thats all that they did
I understand that you don't understand, obviously you are not the musician, are you? When you are composing the song, when you finish it, you have your piece of art... But, when someone takes your song, and do a cover, with his own changes, he automatically rise that song on a higher level... He improved your song... Understand now? To compose song, that is the art, to do a cover, that is much easier, but that is improving of the song...
Just tell me that you play guitar? Than I see why you think that original is always better... I play keyboards and piano, I do a lot of covers with my band, and we play this song too. NightWish done a lot of changes here,maybe not for guitar,it would be stupid to change guitar riffs in this song,this is a guitar song.But there's a lot of changes in harmony... A lot of backing effects that do not exist in original... The song is not the same anymore when it gets to Tuomas. :)
It takes a time to become legend, but if NightWish had more time, they would be legends now, Tuomas would be legend now, and he could compare to Gary... And I like NW version more than this, but we are not talking about tastes of music... It is not matter do you like it or not, a song is improved through the cover, that is the rule of all musicians in this world since the classic music... Sorry on bad English...
It seems that you dont want to understand, i play guitar, im also a singer, i play keyboard, and Toumas just made changes on guitar and of course the voice, but it is EXACTLY THE SAME SONG, i love the nigthwish version, i've made a lot of covers, vocal and guitar covers as well
And if you try to compare Gary Moore to Toumas, your a little bit wrong, i mean, diferent stiles, Gary is more like a Rock/Blues guitarrist, a REAL legend, Toumas is a Synphonic Metal musician...
AND A COVER IS ALWAYS JUST THAT, A COOOOOOVER!!!!!!!
The original song is just EPIC, a cover... is just that, a cover
The same is happenig with Sonata Arctica and their Helloween cover, i love SA more than any other band, but Helloween version is simplhy the best version, is the same with Gary and Nightwish, GARY COMPOSED THIS MASTER PIECE, NIGHTWISH JUST MADE A COVER, AND NOTHING WILL CHANGE THAT, COVER IS ALWAYS JUST THAT, I LOVE NIGTHWISH MUSIC MORE THAN I LIKE GARY
Ok, play keyboards, bass and drums, but I'm asking you which one is your professional instrument, which one do you play in the band and which one do you play the most? It's not just the guitar and voice changes, if you have professional studio monitors, you can hear much more. ;) Yeah, Gary is the Rock/Blues legend but Tuomas is one of the Gods of Metal, which means Legend of Metal... (and it is symphonic, power, melodic, epic metal musician)
And it is not matter what do you like or not, it is just a rule: Cover is the upgrading of the song, improving of the instrumental and vocals... You can hate new version, but the new version is upgraded, improved version of the old one... I do agree that composing is much more difficult, composing is the art, but cover is improving... It is like you make the guitar on your own, and than someone add the belt on it, and your guitar is better than before...
Well, if you dont want to change your mind, then we both wasted our time, anyway, im not someone to change an opinion, like i said, we both wasted our time posting comments, replying, and everything
Theres only one thing to say: you need to calm down, you insulted someone just beacuse he have a different opinion, you cant do that, everyone have his own opinion, and insulting someone for that reason is really stupid
What are you saying, I am friendly minded... I like to talk with other musicians about music... An we didn't wasted time: Sharing your opinion with someone else, that is not wasting of time... I appreciate your opinion and I hope you heard something of all I've said too... I never meant to insult you, sorry about that.
You dont insult me, but you insult someone else, you maybe didt want to insult him, but you did, and we wasted our time, i mean, we said the same in every comment we posted, with other words but we said the same
Anyway, i respect your opinion, and you need to respect the opinion of the one you insulted, anyway, i know you will, or maybe thats what i hope
Sorry to drag this topic up again, but I really disagree with your opinion, or, as I read it, statement. There's no rule saying that a cover is an upgraded version of the original. Nightwish simply played it in their style. They didn't improve anything, they simply adapted it into their way of playing. And even if you make your own guitar, and someone adds a belt to it, it's still the same effin' guitar, it just has a belt on it because someone thought it suited them better.
Gary Moore is a great guitarplayer and the song is leendary. But his is no great singer. So i wish Tarja would sing and Gary will play and it will be marvelous..
@chandika77 and any other band has not covered this song than nightwish? what the fuck are you talking about?!? Nightwish has done the best cover of this song! Gary Moore is the master! And Nightwish has done great cover, so what's your problem man?!? You can tell us what is your talent.... If it's something else than copying.........
@chandika77 and any other band has not covered this song than nightwish? what the fuck are you talking about?!? Nightwish has done the best cover of this song! Gary Moore is the master! And Nightwish has done great cover, so what's your problem man?!? You can tell us what is your talent.... If it's something else than copying.........
@chandika77 Let me guess, that's the only Nightwish song you've ever listened to... right? I agree Michael Moore's original classic will always have it's place, but Nightwish's will too.
Nightwish?? Who da funk is NW???
MsSoulProvider 4 months ago
i must say i didnt care for nightwish's version, but im not really into there style music, But we can all agree That Gary Rocks the hell outta this song, that man could shred, Rip Gary :(
ACDCgunslinger 5 months ago
@chandika77
You're full of shit!Nightwish cover is very good.I like both versions.You're next fanboy and idiot!
Nightwish cover will remind me about Gary Moore,he was GREAT musician .Rest in peace Gary.
wishmaniac1222 6 months ago 3
Nightwish made a really good cover, that doesn't make the original worse
iwontswallow 1 year ago
Gary Moore you where a great musician, i Will always listen to your music, R.I.P gary your music wil be in my heart for ever! Xx
toplul88 1 year ago
So fuckin' awesome!! Gary Moore was the King! Love the clothes!!!!!!!!!
NandeDattebayoo 1 year ago
R.I.P
LasseL 1 year ago
R.I.P!!
jeppe955 1 year ago
R.I.P.
Stauffenburgh 1 year ago
What's the point of HD in this case?
Lardawan 1 year ago
Didn't know Eric Singer ever played with Gary Moore. Eric is one of the best drummers out there and Gary Moore is one hell of a player but doesn't get enough credit for his heavy/rock playing.
Zhaggysfaction 1 year ago
This arrangement is one that I can work with, in terms of both a sophisticated bass line (àu Geddy Lee, or John Entwhistle) and additional percussion (such as a pipe-band drumline); the tempo is consistent with the Jig, a common 6/8 theme in Scots'-Irish music. Moore got the speed dead-on both during the Wild Frontier sessions and in this concert excerpt.
bcschmerker 1 year ago
allright! mr.GARY MOORE is brilliant(only Phil Lynott missing-r.i.p.-)
timris 1 year ago
Odlicna pesma!!!
Marin82M 1 year ago
この顔で・・・なんでこんな格好良いんだろう@@!
永遠の憧れです^^!
manaasa 1 year ago
@manaasa you're right.
GothicJaime 1 year ago
Gary Moore = best guitar legend ever, if u ask me :) 5*
jaggillarpaj1 1 year ago
Who the hell are nightwish?
usernameofnobody 1 year ago
@usernameofnobody just one Finnish band,playing''gothic hard rock'',and covered this song,not even near,but as A finn,had to listen it....Gary is brilliant,one of the best-thanks for sharing!
timris 1 year ago
Gary ROCKS... long live
Thin Lizzy!! ... BLACK ROSE....
gremlinjr 1 year ago
I like the nighwish version really quite a lot. But it is absolutely nothing on Gary Moore's version. And thats without his erection enducing guitar playing.
CommanderNexus 1 year ago
@CommanderNexus cheers :)
usernameofnobody 1 year ago
A Brilliant Guitarist who isn't British, American or Swedish. An Irishman with Exceptional Playing skills and A Talented Singer as well.
perpetual61 1 year ago 4
hes is one the best guitarists in the hole fuckin worl!
EmmyRocker1 2 years ago
I think i can see where Michale and Chris Ammot got some of their influences from the solos in this song and vid.
rockprogmetal 2 years ago
Comment removed
rockprogmetal 2 years ago
such a cheesy song but jasus he is deadly.
tyu198 2 years ago
What amps used he in this gigt?
mendrugo7 2 years ago
Soldano SLO100
Splittail01 2 years ago
are you sure?
mendrugo7 2 years ago
i wouldnt say it otherwise, but yeah this is the right time that he used atleast some of the Soldano Prototypes, He Has two i believe one which is pretty modded and one standard, one of them is covered in Grey Tolex
Splittail01 2 years ago
Like many other groups, of Nigthwish has "performed" an existing song after paying or ask the original owner of the copyright to use it, is very common if you had not noticed -.-.
MEGAX108 2 years ago 3
Awesome!!!!! Night wish is full of shit. Their only talent is copying. How can u even compare Gary Moore and Night Wish. Gary is a Legend in his own right. Night Wish????? Is just another band.
chandika77 2 years ago 16
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@chandika77
1. NightWish done better than this!
2. Fuck you, you jerk, do me a favor and die, NightWish done cover and Tuomas said so in interview, he said that this is not their song, but Gary Moore cover. Tuomas is God of Keyboards and sound of metal and he is a Legend too. Yes, NW can compare Gary, it is not matter how old is band, but what music are they prefer.
3. From your comment I can see that you know nothing about music...
4. Fuck you again!
DonDinasAirey 1 year ago
@DonDinasAirey
He knows about music, Nightwish made a great cover, but a cover never going to be better than the original song
And he's right, You cant compare Nightwish to Gary Moore, i mean, a cover is a cover, just a band playing the song of another band
Even if the Nightwish version is good, the original is way better
But your right in the fact 2, Toumas is a God of Keyboards and a great composer
EdwardAlchemist343 1 year ago
@EdwardAlchemist343
Listen up, I'll say this just this once... NighWish is younger band, but that is not matter, they can compare to Gary, but the most of the people think that they cannot 'cause he is "fucking legend," and they say so because he is simply older than NW...I'm not that good in English,so I won't explain you anything, I'll just say that I am musician to, and I know what it takes to be a legend, I know that secret... It's a long way, and it takes a time, but Tuomas is still young.
DonDinasAirey 1 year ago
@DonDinasAirey
And one more thing:
Cover is always, and I mean always one level above the original... You would understand that if you were a musician... When you take someone song and do a cover, you are automatically rising that song to a higher level, because you are improving that song.. So cover can be better than original, which means that NightWish done better than this...
DonDinasAirey 1 year ago
@DonDinasAirey
A cover NEVER going to be better than the original, dont forget that
I love the Nightwish version, i love the band, Nightwish is one of my favorite band
Gary Moore is the musician behind this song, thats why a cover never going to be better. Even if NW made a great job, you cant compare both versions, because Gary composed this song and he is the one that made all the job, NW just made some changes, thats all that they did
EdwardAlchemist343 1 year ago
@EdwardAlchemist343
I understand that you don't understand, obviously you are not the musician, are you? When you are composing the song, when you finish it, you have your piece of art... But, when someone takes your song, and do a cover, with his own changes, he automatically rise that song on a higher level... He improved your song... Understand now? To compose song, that is the art, to do a cover, that is much easier, but that is improving of the song...
DonDinasAirey 1 year ago
@DonDinasAirey
You need to investigate first, im a musician, or at least i now the musical theory, and what change are you talking about?
Nightwish version is the same, the only difference is the female song, but is the SAME
Gary is a legend now, maybe Nightwish will be a legend in the future, but the cover they made... is not that good
Think... theres a lot of covers out there, even i covered this song, but the original is always better
DONT FORGET THIS, A COVER IS ALWAYS THAT, JUST A COVER
EdwardAlchemist343 1 year ago
@EdwardAlchemist343
Just tell me that you play guitar? Than I see why you think that original is always better... I play keyboards and piano, I do a lot of covers with my band, and we play this song too. NightWish done a lot of changes here,maybe not for guitar,it would be stupid to change guitar riffs in this song,this is a guitar song.But there's a lot of changes in harmony... A lot of backing effects that do not exist in original... The song is not the same anymore when it gets to Tuomas. :)
DonDinasAirey 1 year ago
@DonDinasAirey
It takes a time to become legend, but if NightWish had more time, they would be legends now, Tuomas would be legend now, and he could compare to Gary... And I like NW version more than this, but we are not talking about tastes of music... It is not matter do you like it or not, a song is improved through the cover, that is the rule of all musicians in this world since the classic music... Sorry on bad English...
DonDinasAirey 1 year ago
@DonDinasAirey
When you do a cover, you automatically rise the song on a higher level, keep that on mind...
DonDinasAirey 1 year ago
@DonDinasAirey
It seems that you dont want to understand, i play guitar, im also a singer, i play keyboard, and Toumas just made changes on guitar and of course the voice, but it is EXACTLY THE SAME SONG, i love the nigthwish version, i've made a lot of covers, vocal and guitar covers as well
And if you try to compare Gary Moore to Toumas, your a little bit wrong, i mean, diferent stiles, Gary is more like a Rock/Blues guitarrist, a REAL legend, Toumas is a Synphonic Metal musician...
EdwardAlchemist343 1 year ago
@EdwardAlchemist343
AND A COVER IS ALWAYS JUST THAT, A COOOOOOVER!!!!!!!
The original song is just EPIC, a cover... is just that, a cover
The same is happenig with Sonata Arctica and their Helloween cover, i love SA more than any other band, but Helloween version is simplhy the best version, is the same with Gary and Nightwish, GARY COMPOSED THIS MASTER PIECE, NIGHTWISH JUST MADE A COVER, AND NOTHING WILL CHANGE THAT, COVER IS ALWAYS JUST THAT, I LOVE NIGTHWISH MUSIC MORE THAN I LIKE GARY
EdwardAlchemist343 1 year ago
@EdwardAlchemist343
Ok, play keyboards, bass and drums, but I'm asking you which one is your professional instrument, which one do you play in the band and which one do you play the most? It's not just the guitar and voice changes, if you have professional studio monitors, you can hear much more. ;) Yeah, Gary is the Rock/Blues legend but Tuomas is one of the Gods of Metal, which means Legend of Metal... (and it is symphonic, power, melodic, epic metal musician)
DonDinasAirey 1 year ago
@DonDinasAirey
And it is not matter what do you like or not, it is just a rule: Cover is the upgrading of the song, improving of the instrumental and vocals... You can hate new version, but the new version is upgraded, improved version of the old one... I do agree that composing is much more difficult, composing is the art, but cover is improving... It is like you make the guitar on your own, and than someone add the belt on it, and your guitar is better than before...
DonDinasAirey 1 year ago
@DonDinasAirey
Well, if you dont want to change your mind, then we both wasted our time, anyway, im not someone to change an opinion, like i said, we both wasted our time posting comments, replying, and everything
Theres only one thing to say: you need to calm down, you insulted someone just beacuse he have a different opinion, you cant do that, everyone have his own opinion, and insulting someone for that reason is really stupid
EdwardAlchemist343 1 year ago
@EdwardAlchemist343
What are you saying, I am friendly minded... I like to talk with other musicians about music... An we didn't wasted time: Sharing your opinion with someone else, that is not wasting of time... I appreciate your opinion and I hope you heard something of all I've said too... I never meant to insult you, sorry about that.
DonDinasAirey 1 year ago
@DonDinasAirey
You dont insult me, but you insult someone else, you maybe didt want to insult him, but you did, and we wasted our time, i mean, we said the same in every comment we posted, with other words but we said the same
Anyway, i respect your opinion, and you need to respect the opinion of the one you insulted, anyway, i know you will, or maybe thats what i hope
EdwardAlchemist343 1 year ago
@DonDinasAirey
Sorry to drag this topic up again, but I really disagree with your opinion, or, as I read it, statement. There's no rule saying that a cover is an upgraded version of the original. Nightwish simply played it in their style. They didn't improve anything, they simply adapted it into their way of playing. And even if you make your own guitar, and someone adds a belt to it, it's still the same effin' guitar, it just has a belt on it because someone thought it suited them better.
broedblings 1 year ago
@broedblings
Not again, please...
DonDinasAirey 1 year ago
@DonDinasAirey
sorry dude, just added my opinion since I found the discussion interesting ;)
broedblings 1 year ago
@EdwardAlchemist343
Gary Moore is a great guitarplayer and the song is leendary. But his is no great singer. So i wish Tarja would sing and Gary will play and it will be marvelous..
trollgehirn 1 year ago
@trollgehirn
Every singer is great, dont forget that
But now that Tarja is on her own, maybe that would happen, and that woul be AWESOME
EdwardAlchemist343 1 year ago
@trollgehirn
IMO, as good a singer she is, Tarja's vocal on this song is not my thing. I think someone like Phil Lynott should sing it instead.
KI113RZ11 1 year ago
@chandika77
You are so right!
kalvarsaad 1 year ago
@chandika77
Gary Moore's version is alot better... Nightwish compared to him is just shit :)
Gary Moore \o/
Haregar 1 year ago
@chandika77 Nightwish are fairly good on their own, in their genre. But no doubt that their cover was a mistake.
Lardawan 1 year ago
@chandika77 and any other band has not covered this song than nightwish? what the fuck are you talking about?!? Nightwish has done the best cover of this song! Gary Moore is the master! And Nightwish has done great cover, so what's your problem man?!? You can tell us what is your talent.... If it's something else than copying.........
TheKorhone 1 year ago
@chandika77 and any other band has not covered this song than nightwish? what the fuck are you talking about?!? Nightwish has done the best cover of this song! Gary Moore is the master! And Nightwish has done great cover, so what's your problem man?!? You can tell us what is your talent.... If it's something else than copying.........
TheKorhone 1 year ago
@chandika77 Let me guess, that's the only Nightwish song you've ever listened to... right? I agree Michael Moore's original classic will always have it's place, but Nightwish's will too.
Victisomega 5 months ago
@Victisomega Err.... Gary Moore, geeze I'm tired. XD
Victisomega 5 months ago
@chandika77
"Their only talent is copying"
That would totally explain the multiple albums of completely original material...Honestly, if you're gonna hate, try not to be a jackass about it.
Ygdrasel 3 months ago 5
i think nightwish did a cover version of this song... this is better tho
mogoya 2 years ago 2
what a tune
Pornmanuk 2 years ago 18