Added: 4 years ago
From: johnny576375
Views: 117,109
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (185)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Yes this is so an emotionel song, this is music, this is life man.....!

    There is only one god.... his name is god (for me!).

    TvdE

  • This is great but he has done wonderful work since. Love ya Bruce

  • This is when Bruce made real music. Everything after "The River" is crap

  • Comment removed

  • 3 people watching this were from canada

  • BEST version of this song EVER!!!

  • brings back memories of walking the streets of NYC on a new yrs day at dawn with a girl from the Bronx I met in Times Square,, watching the sunrise over the 59th St bridge

  • This brings tears of joy to me, Thank God for Bruce Springsteen

  • This is Bruce at the peak of his powers. Just compare this street story with the overblown somewhat banal lyrics of Jungleland, which was always overrated IMO. After this album, he became a star, but some of the artistry eroded away, alas.

  • @surfricy which part of jungeleand do you find banal?

  • @surfricy you are to be pitied

  • "Upstairs, the band was playing,

    And the singer was singing something about going home."

    Gets me every time... :')

  • I bought two tickets to Springsteen Gothenburg, Sweden 27th of July 2012. See you there?

    A long shot, but if he plays this version of incident - it wouldn't hurt me at all

  • Incredible song with Suki on the violin makes it awesome...who knew, a 26 year old Springsteen would pull off a live performance like this. The entire show is incredible including the 20 minute version of New York City Serenade

  • this isnt a song, its a stage show set to music thumbs up

  • Just saw Bruce in Pittsburgh last week for a special event. He performed this on acoustic for the first time 36 years after this version. You could hear a pin drop at Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hall during his perofmance. No different than this version. Its still timeless, haunting, and quite frankly a chilling. I feel like I know Spanish Johnny and Puertican Jane . Only Bruce can accomplish this sort of thing. My God!

  • Absolutely the most wonderfully talented songwriter of my lifetime

  • RIP Big man.

  • I always had the memory of hearing this live 10/11/74 (yes, I kept the ticket stub) at Shady Grove, Md, but this stunned me, bringing it all back home in an emotional way I rarely feel anymore. Thanks.

  • It's like watching a movie with your ears.

  • @Triton61 Beautiful analogy :)

  • Bruce played the Naval Academy twice in one year (77-78). He was, of course, awesome. I had graduated from the high school that served the Main Point (Radnor) so I knew about Bruce. One of my bros from the track team flipped pizzas right near the MP. I learned how to flip pizzas and saw Bruce in the same year. Sweet.

  • absolutely stunning!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Springsteen had some awsome powers of observation to have written this song at age 23 or so. The music is the canvas and the lyrics are the brushstrokes that paint the picture. Tom Waits, Dylan, and Woody Guthrie could do this. Maybe a handfull of others as well. This may well be considered his masterpeice one day.

  • I have never liked Bruce, but heard this song a few weeks ago and it has changed me. A real masterpiece...

  • 4:19-4:26. Best eight seconds of my life

  • who in the fuck could have disliked this song?

  • I am a huge Springsteen fan. My College Roommate, who was from New Jersey, at University of Michigan turned me on in 1980. I have been groovin on so much Bruce over the last few months and just rediscovered 'Incident on 57th Street' with my Clarence Clemmons mourning songs.

    Sparse background to Bruce's Whiskey Voice.

    She knew he never be true but she didn't mind.

    Those Romantic Young Boys, all they want to do is fight.

    Fantastic Stuff.

  • @CRS9YT You're right. I discovered Bruce, summer, 78 and listened to almost nothing but BtR and Darkness for several months before seeing him on back-to-back nights at the Fox in Atlanta on 9/30 and 10/1/78. Somehow missed how great Incident is. I think this version, the last time he would play it for 19 years is pretty great: youtube.com/watch?v=2TV7hNxXob­w&feature=related, as is this one at the LA Reunion show on 10/23/99 - full band, I mean really FULL band, which is here, too.

  • Ok, am I the only one that is almost brought to tears by this most excellent and haunting version? There is so much raw emotion, images of years gone by and a feeling of moving through life too fast. I was floored when I pulled this up and listened to it. When those violin strings are being played I feel as if they are tied to every emotion in my body. Thanks Bruce...this is what music is supposed to do to us.

  • Seriously, what kind of sick freak can dislike this track

  • This period when Suki Lahav was with the E Street band was a golden time my friends, a fuckin golden time, RIP Big Man and thank you Bruce for keeping this band together and giving us more and more shows again. The E street will never die, never,

  • Odds are pretty darn good that I was sitting in the Main Point while this was being recorded. I didn't miss too many of these... thanks for the flashback to an awesome chance to sit in the presence of such legends in the making.... goosebumps.... And RIP Big Man... you are, and will be missed. I am not sure how Bruce will be able to be Bruce without you...

  • Springsteen could have ended the show after this song (opening song of the show btw) and crowd would have gotten their money's worth.

  • Rest In Peace Clarence, there will never be a sax player quite like you.

  • This may just be the most beautiful performance in music's long and storied history

    

  • I love this song! very very beautiful version this is.

  • that intro is SO beautiful. i could listen to just the instrumental for the rest of my life

  • Amazing. Just ordered from Amazon UK the whole show. Main Point Live. BRUUUUUCCCEEE

  • hauntingly beautiful!!

  • this classic inspiring tune gives me goosepimples.

  • one of my fav songs and album

    

  • Genio. Unico. Intramontabile. Da studiare.

  • Bruce at his most Romantic. In a few months he would focus on trying to make the greatest rock album of all time (and succeed) but he lost a little something, that he never would recapture, a bit of innocence that gives this song such a beautiful elegiac feel

  • Beautiful song in such a clear version!

  • One of the most moving and poiniet performances in the history of Bruce Springsteen, WMMR and frankly, all of rock music. Nothing has ever been more pure and innocent than this performance at this point in time. I will take this with me for ever!

  • I've always said this'll be the song for my funeral and it still is

  • One of the best storytellers of our time. But outside of the violins i don't care for any versions on youtube, def like the album version the best, esp. how it leads into Rosalita-

  • Is this Suki on violin. I love this. It builds to an amazing emotional end

  • Therre is one person to tell that this song is'nt a mixture of feelings like love, the feeling experienced by people knowing they have no chance ... But the dreams remain at heart ... This one person is unresponsive, it joined the cowardice and stupidity ...And think that I get angry at people like that ...

  • better then the original

  • Comment removed

  • This song. F*%k Yeah

  • crazy cat records has bootleg of this show; titled "Live At The Main Point" Bryn Mawr, PA. 2/5/75...great version of NYC Serenade...19 mins long...sorry it's Great Dane Records from Milan, Italy.

  • crazy cat records has bootleg of this show; titled "Live At The Main Point" Bryn Mawr, PA. 2/5/75...great version of NYC Serenade...19 mins long.

  • Justin Bieber will never have a song as epic as this one. NEVER!

  • I fell years ago into a total fascination and admiration with Bruce Springsteen, thought I know this best songs but I just discovered this one and I'm just without words. Every song he made is sublime. That's incredible. The Boss, yes. Thank you for posting this amazing song...

  • @Milanzar You're right. This is the most amazing song. It is great played slowly, almost acoustically, and even better as a full band rocker. And everything in between.

    He wrote this for his second album, The Wild, the Innocent, and E-Street Shuffle, release in September, 1973, shortly before turning 24. He wrote this at 23. How is this possible. He might as well be channeling God.

    Bruce Springsteen is a genius.

  • @CPSJSMSUUMUGA

    Indeed, how can this be writen by a 23 old kid? Just one of his most legendary songs for sure, just love the outro of this song. So beautifull in my eyes, just something that cannot be described by words, period.

  • Fantastic!! Who is playing piano on this: Bittan or Sancious?

  • @yankeespy3 That's Roy.

  • Whats it realy about ?

  • one word....amazing !

  • Lets see Justin Bieber pull off something as epic and amazing as this!

  • Sublime!!!

  • Stunning and moving

  • oui quois dire de plus ;))

  • come on.. .spanish johnny? oxymoron

  • @BeyondNeptune no... artistic licence

  • i have no fucking clue how bruce thinks of this shit... how he wrote this song.... how

  • I didn't grow up anywhere near the East Coast but this just makes my heart ache. What a masterpiece

  • good night it's.....

  • Quoi dire de plus§

  • Easily one of the greatest, most manly songs ever written....

  • There was a fire house right across the street from the Main Point. Their siren was well known for going off during performances all the time. If you went to the Point enough times you just took it for granted. Does this "police siren" appear on any other Springsteen tapes from this period?

  • @harvey1954 Contrary to myth, the police siren heard at the end is an audio prop that had been utilized at a few of the band's shows just prior to this one.

  • @johnny576375

    Incorrect.

  • @johnny576375 my guess bruce and the band used the prop to indicate that Johnny has been caugh by the police....similar to the album version where the piano at the end of the song kinda shows Jane playing a little music box waiting for Johnny....great version...cheers for posting

  • @harvey1954 Mon anglais est limité mais je pense que wonderfull!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @harvey1954

    Nope. None.

  • thanks for posting,u rock

  • one of the man who never ever come again.........

  • great song!

  • Breathtaking.

  • One of my top favorite Springsteen songs. And in my opinion one of his best albums...

  • Amazingly, he put Incident on the shelf for 19 years. He played it at the Nassau Coliseum on December 29, 1980 and didn't play it again live until September 25, 1999, when he opened with it in Philadelphia.

  • Man, I was almost tearing at the end of the intro, let alone the end of the song! Great; thanks for the upload.

  • blown away!!!!!

  • Thanks for sharing. Just beautiful. Such a part of the Bruce many people don't even know about.

  • BRUCEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!

  • This is utterly beautiful. There is no music like this today This is what we risk losing in humanity if we allow technlogy to make us lazy, this right here.

  • Thank you so much for uploading this, Johnny! Oh, and thank you too, Bruce.

  • To hear this one live, if only one time, would make my life worthwile.

  • No words can describe the depth and beauty of this song. And he was so young ...

  • 23 year old guy w/ not much education is not only wrote this masterpiece...but has a catalog hundreds deep w/ this type of quality material...miraculous...how did this happen?...what a gift...and he didn't waste one ounce of that gift...not for a second.

    "Spanish Johnny drove in from the underworld last night

    With bruised arms and broken rhythm in a beat-up old Buick

    But dressed just like dynamite"...it's like a movie in three lines...amazing depth.

  • @richjh9 the Gods must have opened the windows of heaven for a few minutes.

  • Thank you for this post....from the depths of my being!!

  • extraordinario Brucito

  • bellissima ...

  • This tune is beatiful, but it couldn't be ever such beatiful as you are.

    LOVE YOU. WANT YOU. DESIRE YOU. NEED YOU. MISS YOU. IN LOVE WITH YOU INFINITELY.

    ALWAYS.

  • Just as beautiful as you are.

    LOVE YOU.

    MISS YOU.

    ALWAYS

  • You ever have one of those mornings where you're all wet and you can't shake it off? God bless whoever posted this.

    You (and Bruce) have saved my day...

  • crisp quality. Thank you.

  • no words to describe this one

  • My favourite Bruce song - if I dont listen to it for a while , I ll stick it on and every time my eyes fill up- theres something in this song very very special.

    Great version btw

  • How could I think it was just me? This song has been on me like black on blue...it hurts but yeah it's beautiful too.

  • Saw Bruce for the 1st time at the Main Point on July 8, 1973, & most recent 2 nights ago at the Spectrum. I can't get enough!!

  • for those that go back to the beginning, there's nothing like this. with maybe the exception of the bottom line concerts, the ultimate. raw, fresh, soulful, burning...bruce at his best.

  • Comment removed

  • when i die n go ta heaven i will wake up at the main point in 75 with this song playin infront of me

  • you are very poetic

  • could not be more well said showme1moresign

  • @showme1moresign I've long thought that heaven would be Bruce every night, but different tours, and college football every day. Might and to put some sex in there, too. I'd relive my first date with my wife (my current one, God, if you're setting this up).

    Ya know Bruce played incident on 12/27/80 and not again until 9/25/99. Who else could have a song this good and put it on the shelf for 19 years?

    Or even write this at 22? Hey God, how come he was given so much genius and me so little?

  • @Anna00555

    Grateful Dead and Bruce would only would do something like that.

  • @showme1moresign Sounds like Heaven to me!!!

  • @showme1moresign i couldn't agree more

  • So beautiful.... I was not even born but Bruce´s music has always been with me in good times and bad times... This is so beautiful it brings tears to my eyes.... I think any Bruce fan knows what I am talking about.... Sadly I have never heard him play this song on any of the 9 conserts I´ve seen here in sweden

  • A GREAT, crystal-clear version of a classic boot of one of the best Bruce songs ever, in a legendary performance. I can only bow down to you for posting this. This is what YouTube is for. Yeah? I thank you.

  • No problem :)

  • So beautiful, i think like lapunto.His commentaries  are near of what's i fell:

    "could be sang by heaven's inhabitants..."

  • amazing...the idea that he was approx. 23 or 24 when he was writing and performing this is crazy to me...as famous and popular as he is...I still find him to be highly underrated...one of those rare performers that is so great that you have to "get him"...it's not for everyone...but if you do "get it" you know what i mean.

  • I have lost friends because of this man. I guess they were never my friends if they can't understand him anyway

  • @richjh9

    I feel exactly the same way lol

  • my roommate at Union College had this in 1978 and i haven't heard it since. absolutely unbelievable performance. born to run wasn't out yet even. brings tears to my eyes. god i miss his old stuff....his new stuff.....no thanks. but god bless ya Bruce

  • The problem with this version is that it is so good I don't think I'll ever enjoy any other song ever again, lol. Many thanks for posting. Greetings from Wales

  • Greetings from England.

  • beatiful just beatiful

  • The best - simply great!

  • Beautiful version; the violine ist great!

  • Out of all the boots I've got, this show is at the top of the list. Unbelievable sound, and the songs...what can be said?

  • The general public can text vote there stupid opinions to American Idol and listen to shit generic music, I'll take this anyday. Just downright beautiful.

  • dis is my fav boss track man the best singer songwriter EVER!

  • the opinions of people who watch american idol don't matter anyways

  • @rloebe34 HOW TRUE

  • @rloebe34 AMEN :)

  • @rloebe34 don't hate on idol, it has produced some good artists. its not anyone's fault that nothing can compare to the musical and lyrical perfection that this song attains.

  • beautiful.

  • Thanks for posting this...I don't even have the superlative to describe it!

  • fuck u c blazer u ken nowt

  • Hah, you don't know much about music don't you?

  • orgasmic!!

  • I never heard a song as great as this version is,......

    Thank you Bruce!

  • the best version. period. thank you bruce!

  • The violin and piano on this are killer. Lyrics are ageless.

    Ride on, Bruce...

  • hey Johnny, this is a real great song. I´m still wondering about Bruce - so many versions he made, every one is new - and the song stays: GREAT. Thanks again

  • i'm in heaven....

  • Listening to this, words just fail....

  • such forlorn angst, Bruce sure knows how to express anguished hope.. :) Stupendous performance recorded for all-time..

  • My favorite version of one of my favorite songs.  Thanks for putting this one on Youtube!

  • Fantastic! Great! thanks for the post!

    this is pure Bruce

  • Comment removed

  • Bruce, the greatest poet, story teller, master musician of all time!

  • from Perú: thanks Bruce, for ever

  • was this pic of him taken in Asbury Park?-it looks like it

  • Sunset strip, to promote Born To Run.

  • to johnny576375:

    THANKS! songs like this is what made me (and a lot of other people) like Bruce.

    American Poet, Musician and living Legend.

    simply beautiful song.

    nice post.

  • Thanks for the comment, damn good song.

  • i think i've watched this vid at least 0 times since i found it a week ago lol

    i just play it over and over!!! Bruce is a egend and this song is pre genius!!1

  • beautiful.

    pure poetry.

  • thanks man.... like seein the embers that started some massive bonfire. maybe the sun itself.

  • This is a great historical version. Where did it come from?

  • WMMR radio in Philadelphia on February 5th.

  • And I listening to it that night! And recorded it on my tape machine. And the signal wasn't coming in well from Philly so half my recording is in mono and the other half is in stereo. God, what GREAT memories!

  • I wish you could hear Danny. He helped make this song with Roy into something really special.

  • johnny dude how do u know that it was supposed to be there? i have an arguement with my dad and i want proof

  • He used the siren at a few shows around then. First known appearance was 29/11/74. Check out the link in the video info to download shows where he uses it.

  • And he had a flashing red cop light, too, for awhile.

  • Bravo for getting this up and running for all fans to hear!