This band is pretty good, but there is one slight mistake that most Beatles fans would notice right off. John is the one that starts the song with the feedback and underlying riff and George plays lead off that. Here they have the George character playing the basic riff of the song.
That might come off as a bit nit picky, but if you are going for authenticity then you need to do it right. Just my two cents on that.
@sbbinahee As have i in the same place. The video doesn't do them justice. See them live and its like watching The Beatles. Always an amazing night when i went to see em.
These guys are good. The tempo is a little fast, but don't forget that the Beatles themselves sometimes rushed things live. Check out the first Ed Sullivan show appearance, for instance. Paul starts "All My Loving" too fast, and John and George give each other a look. John had to play that fast triplet rhythm part, so he had the hard work. Paul was just playing a walking bass line...and singing, of course.
there is proof that the stage manager on all of their early ed sullivan shows told the four to keep it fast, edgy, and to keep the excitment. He was later shit canned (fired LOL) for getting the mic levels wrong which is why you cant hear either john's or Paul's harmonys in some of their appearances.
but i agree, these guys are good, and i didn't expect you to know what i just told you!
I stand corrected. I can't believe with me being such a world traveller and speaking 5 languages that I missed this. It WAS recorded in Ireland. The television announcer is speaking (Irish) Gaelic NOT Dutch. It's amazing how similar the two languages are in their phonetics. This band would sound even better if they slowed down the tempo to match the original recording of this song by the Beatles. Go raibh maith agat (Thank-you).
Well,these guys are very good!They look like the Beatles in their mid-thirties!Thanks robdobbler for the video,it helped me very much to learn the song in my electric guitar and now I play it perfectly!!!5 STARS!!!!!
Wow! I just finished watching a video of this song by the real Beatles. And this comes very very close to the real thing. It's really amazing how the singer sounds just like John Lennon.
A bit fast, but the best guitar part-simulation I've heard from any Beatles tribute band. "John" forgot the all-important second guitar part at the end, though...
besides the tempo, there isnt much wrong...the vocalist sounds very similar to lennon, especially live lennon...even with the tempo, they capture the spirit of a live beatles show...in their later days, the beatles shows were hard, fast, and wild. Well done Classic Beatles!!
Good shit for sure...and I'm terribly critical about Beatles covers hahah. So far in both videos I've seen, the Paul and the John have VERY similar voices, which I love. Awesome.
Great sound for a Beatles clone...tempo is a little up but VOx are great and thats what its all about....
candidcomment 1 year ago
Why the one that looks like john is george and the one that looks like george is john
octaviosunland 1 year ago
Looks-wise, George and John are reversed in this band. If those are wigs, just swap 'em out. I do like the energy of the performance actually...
NightGallery 1 year ago
Awsome Cover!
TheColts99 1 year ago
Wait a minute, Paul was left handed!
This must be the fake replacement Paul after he was killed when he was 28 like it said on the Abbey Road album cover!
mavis41558 1 year ago
lolol the "George" is just havin the John-haircut. I like those guys, expect the "john"
VDOSuschi 2 years ago
do they go on tour?? they're greatt!
rockerr12595 2 years ago
This band is pretty good, but there is one slight mistake that most Beatles fans would notice right off. John is the one that starts the song with the feedback and underlying riff and George plays lead off that. Here they have the George character playing the basic riff of the song.
That might come off as a bit nit picky, but if you are going for authenticity then you need to do it right. Just my two cents on that.
Otherwise, its a really good performance.
tsmakungfu 2 years ago 3
Great Beatles cover band!!
retrogamah 2 years ago
Agreed. Saw them many times Olympia Dublin,great stuff. Geat job here.
sbbinahee 2 years ago
@sbbinahee As have i in the same place. The video doesn't do them justice. See them live and its like watching The Beatles. Always an amazing night when i went to see em.
Logikally 1 year ago
I really enjoyed this guys performance... Thanks ;)
xupateresa69 2 years ago
They are brilliant best tribute band of the beatles!
marcus8768 2 years ago
thats my uncle playin paul :)
justdance085 2 years ago 18
seriously!? wow awesome! Paul and George are the best Beatles:)
iLoveJbMcFlYTakeThat 2 years ago
i think they played it really fast cos that wat the beatles actaully did live.... paul admitted that big time
hmsmatthew 2 years ago 6
These guys are good. The tempo is a little fast, but don't forget that the Beatles themselves sometimes rushed things live. Check out the first Ed Sullivan show appearance, for instance. Paul starts "All My Loving" too fast, and John and George give each other a look. John had to play that fast triplet rhythm part, so he had the hard work. Paul was just playing a walking bass line...and singing, of course.
61moonshine 3 years ago 3
there is proof that the stage manager on all of their early ed sullivan shows told the four to keep it fast, edgy, and to keep the excitment. He was later shit canned (fired LOL) for getting the mic levels wrong which is why you cant hear either john's or Paul's harmonys in some of their appearances.
but i agree, these guys are good, and i didn't expect you to know what i just told you!
camerooniepooniepoo 2 years ago
Nice, very nice!!!!
MyllekeBas 3 years ago
this flows, very nice!
Rawego 3 years ago
lead take it easy you're going a little fast but this is the best I heard of this song!
scarletspidey5 3 years ago
1) this was recorded in the Netherlands (Holland) NOT Ireland;
2) the tempo played was way too fast;
3) the guy who played 'George Harrison' actually looks more like John Lennon;
4) otherwise good musicianship and vocals.
You guys need to slow it down though.
AndyBoy63 3 years ago 13
Thanks for the comments, but what makes you think it was recorded in Holland? He is speaking Irish, our national language..
robdobbler 3 years ago 3
I stand corrected. I can't believe with me being such a world traveller and speaking 5 languages that I missed this. It WAS recorded in Ireland. The television announcer is speaking (Irish) Gaelic NOT Dutch. It's amazing how similar the two languages are in their phonetics. This band would sound even better if they slowed down the tempo to match the original recording of this song by the Beatles. Go raibh maith agat (Thank-you).
AndyBoy63 3 years ago
Thee Beatles do Ireland! I love it. My father was a Dubliner and lost the language.
The reason they're going so fast? You can't get a word in edgewise when talking with an Irish person. Take it from one who is!
(Or maybe the show was running late.)
Harrison was one eighth Irish, and I believe Lennon had some Irish in him. (My daughter has his looks.)
Most of us laugh our heads off at life!
prettymom777 3 years ago
@robdobbler english is not your national language gee
jntdavis97 1 year ago
@jntdavis97 Yes, I know.. when did I say that?
robdobbler 1 year ago
@robdobbler above..... :S And he's not speaking irish
viceisthename 1 year ago
@viceisthename What language is he speaking then?
robdobbler 1 year ago
@robdobbler What country are you from???
viceisthename 1 year ago
@viceisthename Ireland.
robdobbler 1 year ago
@robdobbler Can you tell me what he is saying then??
viceisthename 1 year ago
@viceisthename It's on the subtitles.. Irish is our national language but not a lot of us speak it very well.. Unfortunately.
robdobbler 1 year ago
@AndyBoy63 tempo seems fine to me....if it's fast....it's just a bit too fast. maybe...5 bpm difference.
Vavoom09 1 year ago
@AndyBoy63 its defo ireland
TPower2k8 1 year ago
drummer looks like a retard lol
camerooniepooniepoo 3 years ago
Very good! Up to now the best rendition I have heard of any Beatles tribute band.
ideacuccot 3 years ago
This is the best Beatles cover I have ever heard. I'll have to keep an eye out if they come to Baltimore area
thewho6507 3 years ago
almost perfect, pauls gotta be left handed cus with out it they don't have the symetrical look that the beatles had
so start working on your left hand buddy lol jk
natedawghtown22 3 years ago
Yeah,that was great!"John" stood like real John,and the play of ClassicBeatles was very similiar to those who we know :)
Frtiz24 3 years ago
Well,these guys are very good!They look like the Beatles in their mid-thirties!Thanks robdobbler for the video,it helped me very much to learn the song in my electric guitar and now I play it perfectly!!!5 STARS!!!!!
RobbyKrieger92 3 years ago
i like this. very tight nit sound. five stars
stevecherm 4 years ago
That was excellent, a 5 star performance, it's close to the real thing !!!
guitarjed 4 years ago
The Paul in these bands are always good.
babystinky 4 years ago
Wow! I just finished watching a video of this song by the real Beatles. And this comes very very close to the real thing. It's really amazing how the singer sounds just like John Lennon.
marrzipan 4 years ago
is very cool
teposhtopilli 4 years ago
A bit fast, but the best guitar part-simulation I've heard from any Beatles tribute band. "John" forgot the all-important second guitar part at the end, though...
ROCKSTARCRANE 4 years ago 2
that was great ,would have been greater if they took a 'bow' at the end of the song, like the beatles always did!! cant wait to see them!! :)
jamesandfio 4 years ago
This is just great!
manthorne 4 years ago
its off-beat...
i agree the vocalist sounds like lennon, his posture too
eby88 4 years ago
besides the tempo, there isnt much wrong...the vocalist sounds very similar to lennon, especially live lennon...even with the tempo, they capture the spirit of a live beatles show...in their later days, the beatles shows were hard, fast, and wild. Well done Classic Beatles!!
MarkSReinhart 4 years ago
thats cool
walkaboutarts 4 years ago
Good shit for sure...and I'm terribly critical about Beatles covers hahah. So far in both videos I've seen, the Paul and the John have VERY similar voices, which I love. Awesome.
XtopherMonge 4 years ago
COOL!!
laureluploader3000 5 years ago