I've been looking for one of those Fender P-basses with the F hole for years. The only time I saw one for sale it was already sold. Anyone know when Fender made them or what they're called?
@lyghty It´s true. I can not find it now in youtube (but I have seen it in the past).
Anyway, It´s not the great thing. It´s not a live recording (the sound was pre-recorded), but it´s funny to see lefthanded Tommy Iommi playing guitar (or pretending it) with Tull.
You don't see this too often. Cornick didn't leave under the best of terms, but everybody recognized that he had to go his own way, no hard feelings, their bands gigged together over the years and here he is again. And Abrahams, wow. Way to get over all that pettiness that too many others couldn't. I'd like to see anybody this far along after one of their early records do a better job.
@donnpatc I have been an ardent Tull fan since 1972, but I always thought that Anderson's approach as sole song writer was a bit dictatorial. Surely he didn't write the bass line for "Bouree," and (as finally made apparent on the intro to "Minstrel In The Gallery"), little Martin Barre must have come up with a few of his own licks.
As much as I love him (and have throughout the years), his voice has lost much of its timbre over time. This especially came out when they reproduced Aqualung on XM (which they still play on occasion). I guess the up-side would be that he no longer needs to use the EQ effect when performing this song! ;P
having seen Tull and Ian solo this year (YES) their current lineups are amazing, but I'd love to see the originals get together and do a mini tour of a few cities or something like that. their mostly all still able body except for mick recovering from a heart attack. Seeing Ian, Clive, Glenn & Martin do some of the early stuff would be great live. Clive and Glenn both live in California and Ian & Martin still tour together!! It would be nice! ;-)
I don't think there Syncing. The video is out of sync for sure .But i have seen this line up play quite a few times in the early days and they would have know reason to have to fake it .
@TheChiFlows ok then how is it possible to play a flute that hasnt got a bug attached? i saw them too in the early days they are miming to a recording that they probably recorded earlier in a studio.
@Stalicone have you ever played in a band? WELL the bug should have a wire sticking out of the end of the flute, now crawl back in your hole cos they are fucking miming.
Yup - I'm wrong all right...there is no "wireless" bug...it's fully WIRED - look near the mouthpiece at 1:00 and again at 1:24...you can clearly see the wires hanging out of it...and yes to your band question btw... I'm a drummer and I've played in quite a few bands. so as far as holes are concerned, you can now shut yours....
@robertmacisaac For literally like a week or so. Didn't record, but mimed along to this song in "The Rolling Stones' Rock n Roll Circus". He decided that if Tull could make it big, Sabbath could too, and it would be his band that he helped start, not one that was already big.
Thank you Malapersona for posting this. I know that Ian Anderson played the harmonica before he took up the flute but I've never seen him do so except on this video. It's really incredible how, with all the turmoil surrounding Glenn and Mick's departing the band, they all seem to let bygones be bygones and got on playing again after all these years past. Mick and Glenn are true stand up guys and Glenn was and still is the best bass player JT ever had.
these guys are those who recorded "This Was" in 1969. Mick Abrhams left the band immediatly after the exit of the album. Is really amazing to see them to play together.
@Malapersona Iommi plays some uncredited tracks on Benefit. How different rock music would have been if he had stuck around. Glenn Cornick is a brilliant player. Too bad Ian scared this lot off. Oh well, the new punters did a far turn after all.
these guys are those who recorded "This Was" in 1969. Mick Abrhams left the band immediatly after the exit of the album. Is really amazing to see them to play together.
@gunshy9: Malapersona is correct, that's Mick Abrahams. If you'd like to see Iommi at present there is an extensive interview with him elsewhere on YouTube. See: Face to Face with Rick Wakeman for the skinny on the history of Black Sabbath and Iommi's time with Tull.
"This Was" was my first Tull album and still my favorite. Nice to see that line-up together again. Always wondered what became of Glen, Clive, and Mick. Old dudes still got it!
Mick is the original guitar player. This song is on "This Was" thier first album 1968...Iommi filled in when Mick left....Then Martin joined to work on the second album...the rest is history.
I guess I'm nitpicking, but the line-up in The RSRRC vid (w/Iommi) was miming, except for Anderson who sang live. You're actually hearing Mick Abraham's guitar.
Although this is the original band, to me, the "classic" lineup is Ian, Martin, John, Jeffrey and Barrie. This is very cool to see however. Thanks for sharing!
Yeah.. That is the "classic" line up for me too. Even DP's "classic" lineup is MKII and Maiden's "classic" lineup is their fourth(album lineups..). I think this felt great to the guys. Like back in the old dayzz, playing in pubs n' stuff. This is a great video. Tull forever!
lol looks like they are playing at some blokes poker game in between hands. Be there Saturday! $5 buy in, BYOB, free pretzels, Jake's bringing nacho's and Jethro Tull playing intermissions!
Don't get me wrong, I love Tull but I see what the poster below, Arschhobbit , meant.
The whole video made me sad...the guys all looked like they were being held at gunpoint to preform together and the song was sung if by rote, with no heart or spirit behind it.
Ian can't leap and scarper about like he used too, either, something I missed terribly ;~}}....we all gettin' old...
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I fell sad about this bad performance. If the guy`s don`t perform their hits like the original ones, they shouldn`t play the Songs. This one sounds really lousy. The only fantastic live version of this Song is the R`n`R Circus performance.
The choice to play music is a choice the performer /s make. You as the listener also have a choice not to listen to it if you don't lke it. Your about as capable to judge this song as you are a performance that was really a lip sync!
@Arschhobbit If one wants to listen to the original please don't watch a live performance, stick to the albums. This version was made nearly 30 years after the original. The musicianship is actually better.
@Arschhobbit so you think just because the sound sucks it's a bad performance? Well I'm an audio engineer... I the performance is fine... the mix sucks!!!
Yup, this will do nicely! Hadnt realised the original band had reformed to do some early stuff. I liked Mr Iommi's guitar work on this but Mick A. is just so damned underrated. Great to see Glen Cornick.....fab bassist. BRAVO!!
I've always wanted to see a late period Tull rendition of this, so thanks for putting it up. Interesting hearing Ian's "current" vocals juxtaposed with how they were on the original '68 version.
I was 15 - my 1st show at the fillmore west was OCT 69- country joe and fish -Albert King and Bloodwyn Pig with MIck -WOW - my 1st toke also -a month later -2nd fillnore show and 2nd toking - Jethro tull -and MC5 --JT was amazing of course -saw em at Berkely com theater on Aqualang tour -- good show but loved the original sound much much more -saw bloodwyn pig again in 1970 -fabulous show -
This is so cool. Tull produced so much great music through the years, but the early phase, around This Was and Stand Up, are my personal faves. So nice to see Clive, Mick, and Glen together with Ian again. A bit older, grayer, and rounder, but aren't we all at that age, ha ha.
i agree but i humbly admit that's not him, it's mick abrahms the original guitarist from JT, only on the first album. Bassist played on three lps, drummer played on 4, and of course they pumped out singles during those days as well..."17" and "Aeroplane" and the like...
Damn, look at Clive Bunker, this is the first I've seen him in recent years! I know this is from 2001 but are they touring in the original formation right now?!
This concert must be something INCREDIBLE: the original 'tulls together in a foggy pub with lts and lts of goooooooood beer...what could I desire more?
Love it, its so clean
bpurdy305 2 months ago
My god, thats Glen !! ??
twostrokeornill1 2 months ago in playlist More videos from Malapersona
why they don't keep goin like that? it's been 10 years now from that pub feeling!
uburei 2 months ago
It's not the same without his Kermit voice... :(
TsiSiFa 6 months ago
I've been looking for one of those Fender P-basses with the F hole for years. The only time I saw one for sale it was already sold. Anyone know when Fender made them or what they're called?
harvey1954 6 months ago
Comment removed
TheFutureFossil 7 months ago
@TheFutureFossil OK, gluetube won't let me post the google URL for Rock & Roll circus. Try searching
"Jethro Tull Song For Jeffery Rolling Stone's Rock And Roll Circus" & you should get it.
TheFutureFossil 7 months ago
can somebody tell me where I find the video of this song on rolling stones rock 'n roll circus? cant find it in anywhere!
lyghty 9 months ago
@lyghty It´s true. I can not find it now in youtube (but I have seen it in the past).
Anyway, It´s not the great thing. It´s not a live recording (the sound was pre-recorded), but it´s funny to see lefthanded Tommy Iommi playing guitar (or pretending it) with Tull.
Malapersona 9 months ago 3
@Malapersona have you ever tried to smoke and watch ? fucking great xD
lyghty 8 months ago
@lyghty You couldn´t smoke and watch a Jethro Tull concert. Ian Anderson probably kill you. He is now a anti-smoke warrior.
Malapersona 8 months ago
@lyghty It should be on google video
jo366 7 months ago
@lyghty In google videos you can find with this name: Jethro Tull - Rock & Roll Circus - 1968 - Song For Jeffrey. I just finish to saw it. Greetings!
elequilibrista 6 months ago
@elequilibrista found it! thnx guys
lyghty 6 months ago
@lyghty watch?v=Gz5L-n1b4NE
cheers
mahatmacoatmahandbag 5 days ago
They should lose the video effects ... Its a good enough song you could just have a black screen
Sparenberg22 10 months ago
Jurassic Tull
SalemStorm 10 months ago
WOW!!!!!
killcraz 10 months ago
The original players are back together because Ian Anderson ran out of new people to jam with.
5jerry1 10 months ago
Sweet!
jezmundberserker 10 months ago
You don't see this too often. Cornick didn't leave under the best of terms, but everybody recognized that he had to go his own way, no hard feelings, their bands gigged together over the years and here he is again. And Abrahams, wow. Way to get over all that pettiness that too many others couldn't. I'd like to see anybody this far along after one of their early records do a better job.
donnpatc 1 year ago
@donnpatc I have been an ardent Tull fan since 1972, but I always thought that Anderson's approach as sole song writer was a bit dictatorial. Surely he didn't write the bass line for "Bouree," and (as finally made apparent on the intro to "Minstrel In The Gallery"), little Martin Barre must have come up with a few of his own licks.
TheFutureFossil 7 months ago
As much as I love him (and have throughout the years), his voice has lost much of its timbre over time. This especially came out when they reproduced Aqualung on XM (which they still play on occasion). I guess the up-side would be that he no longer needs to use the EQ effect when performing this song! ;P
cliffwalkinfool 1 year ago
Ma dove stanno suonando nella soffitta di quale spelonca????!!!!!....B R A V I S S I M I
PINOSCOGNA 1 year ago
having seen Tull and Ian solo this year (YES) their current lineups are amazing, but I'd love to see the originals get together and do a mini tour of a few cities or something like that. their mostly all still able body except for mick recovering from a heart attack. Seeing Ian, Clive, Glenn & Martin do some of the early stuff would be great live. Clive and Glenn both live in California and Ian & Martin still tour together!! It would be nice! ;-)
mikemacjunkie1 1 year ago
shitty audience!
mothulicka 1 year ago
ian anderson is brilliant
mothulicka 1 year ago
still amazing! ;)
LeonardLi66 1 year ago
wow
ajsplyne 1 year ago
Shit, this is GOLD!
germansolares 1 year ago
wow wow wow wow - So clean... So mature....I saw them when I was a kid and they were great! But raw...organic... These guys are total pros!
Stalicone 1 year ago
is that open E tuning Mick's laying down ?
still my favorite song of JT...love the guitar on the released vinyl.
talpajam 1 year ago
Is that Clive Bunker ?.
TheChiFlows 1 year ago
@TheChiFlows yes it is and it looks like they are miming
zog97xy 1 year ago
I don't think there Syncing. The video is out of sync for sure .But i have seen this line up play quite a few times in the early days and they would have know reason to have to fake it .
TheChiFlows 1 year ago
@TheChiFlows ok then how is it possible to play a flute that hasnt got a bug attached? i saw them too in the early days they are miming to a recording that they probably recorded earlier in a studio.
zog97xy 1 year ago
@zog97xy
The flute HAS a wireless bug...look near the mouthpiece!
Stalicone 1 year ago
@Stalicone have you ever played in a band? WELL the bug should have a wire sticking out of the end of the flute, now crawl back in your hole cos they are fucking miming.
zog97xy 1 year ago
Yup - I'm wrong all right...there is no "wireless" bug...it's fully WIRED - look near the mouthpiece at 1:00 and again at 1:24...you can clearly see the wires hanging out of it...and yes to your band question btw... I'm a drummer and I've played in quite a few bands. so as far as holes are concerned, you can now shut yours....
Stalicone 1 year ago
@zog97xy
and try again at 2:28...dumbass
Stalicone 1 year ago
@TheChiFlows
Yes Indeed - still incredible too!
Stalicone 1 year ago
This is amazing ?.
TheChiFlows 1 year ago
Did Iommi play with these guys?
robertmacisaac 1 year ago
@robertmacisaac For literally like a week or so. Didn't record, but mimed along to this song in "The Rolling Stones' Rock n Roll Circus". He decided that if Tull could make it big, Sabbath could too, and it would be his band that he helped start, not one that was already big.
Germany1111 1 year ago
Finally, I know what the hell he's singing!
catman605 1 year ago
Pretty cool for a bunch of old guys! And, the best yet, I could even finally understand the lyrics!
arklat 1 year ago
It would be great if Cornick and Bunker collaborated more with Ian Anderson. They were the best rhythm section for Tull...in my opinion.
12toedfeet 1 year ago
Thank you Malapersona for posting this. I know that Ian Anderson played the harmonica before he took up the flute but I've never seen him do so except on this video. It's really incredible how, with all the turmoil surrounding Glenn and Mick's departing the band, they all seem to let bygones be bygones and got on playing again after all these years past. Mick and Glenn are true stand up guys and Glenn was and still is the best bass player JT ever had.
I've got to get me this DVD!!
Miatacrosser 1 year ago
these guys are those who recorded "This Was" in 1969. Mick Abrhams left the band immediatly after the exit of the album. Is really amazing to see them to play together.
moflostik 1 year ago
What is this from?
paddyo702 1 year ago
No. That's Mick Abrams. He was on the first album, This Was. Listen to Cat's Squirrel. Better than Cream!!
billyguitar 1 year ago
Great musicians! Thanks!
cantehondo 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Is that Iommi? Who is playing guitar on this track? Please let me know
gunshy9 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Is that Iommi? Who is playing guitar on this track? Please let me know
gunshy9 1 year ago
Is that Iommi? Who is playing guitar on this track?
gunshy9 1 year ago
@gunshy9 He is Mick Abrahams, first guitarist of the band, before Iommi and Barre.
Malapersona 1 year ago
@Malapersona Iommi plays some uncredited tracks on Benefit. How different rock music would have been if he had stuck around. Glenn Cornick is a brilliant player. Too bad Ian scared this lot off. Oh well, the new punters did a far turn after all.
TheFutureFossil 7 months ago
@TheFutureFossil I didn´t know that. Thank you for the information.
Do you know on what Benefit tracks played Iommi?
Malapersona 7 months ago
these guys are those who recorded "This Was" in 1969. Mick Abrhams left the band immediatly after the exit of the album. Is really amazing to see them to play together.
moflostik 1 year ago
@gunshy9
Yeah and Iommi is left handed.
tie32101 1 year ago
@gunshy9: Malapersona is correct, that's Mick Abrahams. If you'd like to see Iommi at present there is an extensive interview with him elsewhere on YouTube. See: Face to Face with Rick Wakeman for the skinny on the history of Black Sabbath and Iommi's time with Tull.
aarfeld 1 year ago
@gunshy9, That is most definitely not Tony Iommi on guitar here. I thinks it's Tull's original guitarist Mick Abrahams.
TIMOTHYSAARINEN 1 year ago
I think this one is his best song
320263 1 year ago 2
For a fish farmer, this guy leaves the current batch of so called superstars in the ditch Take that NO take Anderson
masterclasski 1 year ago
"This Was" was my first Tull album and still my favorite. Nice to see that line-up together again. Always wondered what became of Glen, Clive, and Mick. Old dudes still got it!
GreenManalishiUSA 2 years ago
Just amazing "thru his nose " check out the original dude its the way the song was sung and should be sung.
Cervicconstruction 2 years ago
This is the best man!!
tmothy100 2 years ago 2
amazing
HYPNOTICVIDEO 2 years ago 2
Pure brilliance.
jraia06 2 years ago 7
wish ian wasnt singing thru his nose, other wise, this is fucking tits!
putdownan8dude 2 years ago
thanks for this ! did they do" dharma for one" ? i'd love to see that
drumier 2 years ago
In the DVD there are only three songs of this show, but not that. I don´t know if they played it in the concert
Malapersona 2 years ago
Every past time was better, but..
AN INCREDIBLE DOCUMENT!!..Thank you!!
javitoys75 2 years ago
...who cares about the line up - it's just CLASSIC Tull - love it!
grimyjeeves 2 years ago
PERFECT VERSION !
for1979 2 years ago
Original Version from 68/69 ist very more better
MrBluesforyou 2 years ago
Gli anni passano i musicisti invecchiano ma...la musica............
bibosky53 2 years ago
i just watched the '68 stones/Circus vid. if its the same lineup, these guys are true pioneers! this is a gem.
dictionar1 2 years ago
It's not the same lineup. Tony Iommi of Black Sabbath was in the '68 Stones/Circus video.
mrdudelz 2 years ago
Mick is the original guitar player. This song is on "This Was" thier first album 1968...Iommi filled in when Mick left....Then Martin joined to work on the second album...the rest is history.
classictull1966 2 years ago
I guess I'm nitpicking, but the line-up in The RSRRC vid (w/Iommi) was miming, except for Anderson who sang live. You're actually hearing Mick Abraham's guitar.
skwijeebob 2 years ago
Although this is the original band, to me, the "classic" lineup is Ian, Martin, John, Jeffrey and Barrie. This is very cool to see however. Thanks for sharing!
Hanson913 2 years ago
Yeah.. That is the "classic" line up for me too. Even DP's "classic" lineup is MKII and Maiden's "classic" lineup is their fourth(album lineups..). I think this felt great to the guys. Like back in the old dayzz, playing in pubs n' stuff. This is a great video. Tull forever!
kolmasjarrari 2 years ago
Aging just sucks! Their minds say 20, their boddies scream 65!
p51joe 2 years ago
"Living with the Past"
linus7106 2 years ago
lol looks like they are playing at some blokes poker game in between hands. Be there Saturday! $5 buy in, BYOB, free pretzels, Jake's bringing nacho's and Jethro Tull playing intermissions!
durango950 2 years ago
thatd be one poker table id never leave. id hock the wife and kids for a chair
murf5824 2 years ago
thats funny shit!
stationheretics 2 years ago
que bos son!
manoloturullo 2 years ago
Thanks for posting. A good song is always a good song...
isolationblues 2 years ago
Don't get me wrong, I love Tull but I see what the poster below, Arschhobbit , meant.
The whole video made me sad...the guys all looked like they were being held at gunpoint to preform together and the song was sung if by rote, with no heart or spirit behind it.
Ian can't leap and scarper about like he used too, either, something I missed terribly ;~}}....we all gettin' old...
:(
Still, it was nice seeing them playing :)
TheTickTockGirl 2 years ago
who's the new Bloodwyn Pig singer? don't recognize him...
takacsjim 2 years ago
gotta love glenn!
Champloo321 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I fell sad about this bad performance. If the guy`s don`t perform their hits like the original ones, they shouldn`t play the Songs. This one sounds really lousy. The only fantastic live version of this Song is the R`n`R Circus performance.
Arschhobbit 2 years ago
R`n`R Circus performance is not a live version. It is playback. See again the video, the guitars were not plugged and the sound is the LP song.
Malapersona 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
The choice to play music is a choice the performer /s make. You as the listener also have a choice not to listen to it if you don't lke it. Your about as capable to judge this song as you are a performance that was really a lip sync!
jcordj66 2 years ago
Hey, I've got the Circus Performance!
TheTickTockGirl 2 years ago
@Arschhobbit If one wants to listen to the original please don't watch a live performance, stick to the albums. This version was made nearly 30 years after the original. The musicianship is actually better.
jco5712 1 year ago
@Arschhobbit so you think just because the sound sucks it's a bad performance? Well I'm an audio engineer... I the performance is fine... the mix sucks!!!
chyrd 1 year ago
@Arschhobbit I actually like this one!!!! sounds weird and different from the original song, but I like it!
fermillo65 1 year ago
Yup, this will do nicely! Hadnt realised the original band had reformed to do some early stuff. I liked Mr Iommi's guitar work on this but Mick A. is just so damned underrated. Great to see Glen Cornick.....fab bassist. BRAVO!!
Deebemc 2 years ago
I've always wanted to see a late period Tull rendition of this, so thanks for putting it up. Interesting hearing Ian's "current" vocals juxtaposed with how they were on the original '68 version.
StriderIsAragorn 3 years ago
I was 15 - my 1st show at the fillmore west was OCT 69- country joe and fish -Albert King and Bloodwyn Pig with MIck -WOW - my 1st toke also -a month later -2nd fillnore show and 2nd toking - Jethro tull -and MC5 --JT was amazing of course -saw em at Berkely com theater on Aqualang tour -- good show but loved the original sound much much more -saw bloodwyn pig again in 1970 -fabulous show -
bigbuzman 3 years ago
matafuko,
'Dude you're young!' Ha, that felt good to say. LOL
dictionar1 3 years ago
I last time I saw Jethro Tull and Ian Anderson was at The Isle of Wight Festival in 1970. They came on before Jimi Hendrix. What a great time we had!
bellabinti 3 years ago
they're the first band i ever saw! (not this line up obviously) in 1994 in hereford when i was 10.
matafuko 3 years ago
last time i saw ian anderson he sat in a wheelchair killed the show melb australia still they are a great band
xxshep25xx 3 years ago
This is so cool. Tull produced so much great music through the years, but the early phase, around This Was and Stand Up, are my personal faves. So nice to see Clive, Mick, and Glen together with Ian again. A bit older, grayer, and rounder, but aren't we all at that age, ha ha.
GreenManalishiUSA 3 years ago
Very Cool! I saw them when Aqualung was a hit in Phoenix AZ. They sound great! Thanks for this post!
gandlbass 3 years ago 2
MARTIN BARRE IS THE BEST !!!!!!!
431516o20205 3 years ago
i agree but i humbly admit that's not him, it's mick abrahms the original guitarist from JT, only on the first album. Bassist played on three lps, drummer played on 4, and of course they pumped out singles during those days as well..."17" and "Aeroplane" and the like...
daddysevenpointfiver 3 years ago
2:23 / 3:28
I like that.
Biffandango 3 years ago
Jethro Tull is one of the best bands ever
cesarcifuentes1 3 years ago 18
Why aren't the people rocking out?
pantherfitzgerald11 3 years ago 3
Omega kick-ass..Glen has a fretless bass..
Tengent 3 years ago 3
Damn, look at Clive Bunker, this is the first I've seen him in recent years! I know this is from 2001 but are they touring in the original formation right now?!
MattHatter 3 years ago
Nope, they're not. They're using their current formation.
Kuchenwurst 3 years ago
Its cool to see darts board behind the band!!!
leyo35 3 years ago
Where is it??
leyo35 3 years ago
I would love to see this show complete on disc. Instead of just the couple songs they give you on the Living With The Past DVD.
guitar45hero 3 years ago
great song
thawthepast 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I love Tull but age is a bitch..it takes away your teeth and punch.
toecutterr6 3 years ago
Haha! Sad but true.
Zeitgeist74 3 years ago
ojalá yo estuviera allí...
Aqualung1989 3 years ago
This concert must be something INCREDIBLE: the original 'tulls together in a foggy pub with lts and lts of goooooooood beer...what could I desire more?
Carrydagosinger 3 years ago 2
More beer!
mingeral 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Ian can't sing at all anymore...
hamett91 3 years ago
i think he can, i saw him live a few yrs ago --took my dad for fathers day, but he was so fucking on it was scary!
brothersneakybitch 3 years ago
Wish my son had taken me, your old man is a lucky guy. Thicko is inconsolable.
thicko70 3 years ago
my old man?? im the lucky one...been listening to tull since i was born cus of him...definatley in my top 3!
brothersneakybitch 3 years ago
he can still sing his voise sounds strainted cause he had surgery on it in the 80's.
supercow506 3 years ago
well sergery on his throat
supercow506 3 years ago