When she sings, she keeps her voice for the ornaments later. Somebody told me that she sings bad, because all her sons are "from the throat". Well, if this is very difficult, how I can sing all her songs and they all sounds better?!
it started off okay but then went out of tune and got better and her harmony isnt bad not not great however she has those bad times as her voice does tend to go out of tune and weird
the people throwing shit not just at her but at other bands are a disgrace. Makes me laugh a lot of these rock fans have a go at "chavs" and then act like scum themselves.
if you kids are still complaining about her in 8 years or so after you grow up a little and are a little more open minded, i'd love to have a conversation. Otherwise you trolls can argue with yourselves. she's a true talent.
lol whoever says she screwed up this song well fuck you xD coz try singing really high notes while sitting down its hardd coz it blocks something in ur body :) my music tought me tht ages agoo so stop giving shittt around if you dont like it leave ! :)
what the fuck are you talking about? top comment is such bullshit, you are saying its a little off HOW IS IT OFF? the only thing you have to compare it too is a studio version of HER song, so get real. i challenge anyone to get in front of that many people and be perfect. Prime example of "everybodys fool" look it up.
her drunkness is just so REAL! im seeing them on November the 7th! OMG I CANT WAIT IM suprised i havent ripped out all my hair yet im so excited! u all have to COME! Manchester, Apollo something....
@catgirlclaire i like evanescence too,but you should know that lady gaga(although i know you just used her as an example) is a talented singer.although i dont care much for her music,i will admit shes good.people like katy perry,i agree with you.but lady gaga does,surprisingly,have a voice.not to nit pick,just thought you should know :)
She's off key at times because her voice is worn from the show or touring. It's tough screaming and singing your lungs out without your voice going out in time. I think it show's she's human. Because with a voice as good as hers, it's hard to believe she's of this world.
i don't get why people give her shit for screwing up occasionally...the songs she sings are incredibly difficult and her vocal range is amazing. you rock amy
She sounds like she's tired or doesn't want to be there. Not her best from my perspective. I understand that the people who say she sounds good here are her biggest fans but come on! You have to get real.
When she sounds good I'm the first to admit it and when she doesn't...well, she doesn't.
@CloudsOfEnvy13 she was probably tired. this was towards the end of the show. but hey, she still did pretty dang good in my book. a few sour notes here and there, for sure, but hey, no one's perfect. =)
@meatwarwick I dunno but usually when somebody releases an album they tour afterwards but there are no dates announced yet. Theree should be uk dates :D
@1999surya Same :D I've been a fan since they first came out , i was about 7ish and my dad started listening to them and i loved Amy's voice from the start , she's just incredible
lucky lil bitches seein her live showin her no respect asmy lee is the goth goddess the snow white queen and they look bored lucky lil spoiled bitches
me parece que los fanaaaaticos de Amy Lee.... se tapan un poco los oidos..en estudia esta cancion es increible...pero en vivo....deja harto que desear....escuche un par de desafinaciones...
@kunoichiOneX one of the best things about them is that they really give their all on stage. I went to what is considered to be a bad concert, by their standards, and it was one of the most amazing experiences of my life :)
She wasn't drunk you idiot idk about recovering from being sick and that's not bad she's amazing and you can't expect the live version to be perfect and sound exactly like the album version but have you heard her on the album version? No matter what she's doing she's always amazing I love Amy Lee!
excuse me, no need for language. everyone is saying she was drunk, im a huge evanescence fan, it wasnt rude what i was sayin, i was just sayin what i heard. i know shes not perfect, i didnt say she was. I was just saying to that guy, that she was recovering, and almost everyone is saying she was drunk, so i just assumed it was right, so ppl would get off my back. trust me, i love amy lee, u think my comment was bad, i was commenting nicely to the one who said she sucked, which is what i didntsay
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Everyone sounds good in "album versions" because their voice gets altered to be in tune with the fucking music. Why does everyone want to justify her crappy singing by saying she is either sick or recovering from being sick? Is she sick all the time? Most of her shows sound exactly like this. I refuse to believe she was sick or recovering from being sick from all of them :)
Bitch, please, I can listen to whatever I want and I can say whatever the fuck i feel like saying, and if I think that she sounds like a monkey being raped in the ass, then it's my opinion. If you don't like my opinion then just ignore me, who the hell do you think you are to tell me what to listen to and what not to listen to?
@jessica29406 oh yeah. id give everything i own just to see her singing live. shes so beautiful and creative she makes the butterflies in my tummy take flight ^_^
@94Takato I know.(: I watched her acoustic version of Bring me to life. And I was blown away. I was obsessed with her voice for at least a year. She still fascinates me and I'm glad she'll be making some new music soon.(:
@jessica29406 i watched her accoustic version too and i loved it soo much im still obssessed with her voice and her looks as well. i think im in love with her ^_^ and i cant wait for the end of 2010 coz thats when her third studio album is out. i cant wait to get it. Evanescence is my favorite band. i love them soo much ^_^
beautiful eyes.. beautiful hair..beauiful voice.. beautiful all over.. shes just simply..amazing
shsbdw05 4 days ago
her face in the end... SO DRUNK
victoriasc97 4 days ago
NO ONE CARES ABOUT THE STUPID PLANE!!!! GO BACK TO AMY!!!!
questforpiano777 1 week ago
I have difficulty to conciliate "screwing up" and "Amy Lee" in the same sentence
3939Canada 2 weeks ago
Took less than 15 seconds and I'm crying.. Did you just hear the way she said lithium the two first times...? I'm totally choked.
ningensucker 3 weeks ago
When she sings, she keeps her voice for the ornaments later. Somebody told me that she sings bad, because all her sons are "from the throat". Well, if this is very difficult, how I can sing all her songs and they all sounds better?!
neko777anima 1 month ago
@XfishoutofwaterbabeX She's doing a concert in manchester?! PLEASE send me a link...
123Lolzilla 2 months ago
Swear I saw the guy out of Pendulum? 1:15
0snakebit3 2 months ago
Am i the only one can't see the screwup ?
MrDream996 3 months ago
@MrDream996 Around 1:30 is one.
SelasSolaris 2 months ago
@MrDream996 No man im with you :P
LadyStarAussie 2 months ago
When your singing one day and its crap by yr own standards, but its still good... that's when ya got talent!
bonusbloke 3 months ago 5
@bonusbloke Agreed.
MrNatureboy98 1 month ago
it started off okay but then went out of tune and got better and her harmony isnt bad not not great however she has those bad times as her voice does tend to go out of tune and weird
Brad4life11 3 months ago
i love this song
and shes amazing
if she has haters she must be doing something right
not every1 has love for her, but if you dont be mature about it.
act ur age and not ur shoe size
battousaiblade 3 months ago
the people throwing shit not just at her but at other bands are a disgrace. Makes me laugh a lot of these rock fans have a go at "chavs" and then act like scum themselves.
g00ner4life93 3 months ago 3
if you kids are still complaining about her in 8 years or so after you grow up a little and are a little more open minded, i'd love to have a conversation. Otherwise you trolls can argue with yourselves. she's a true talent.
NewOut1 3 months ago
PLZZZZ come to Billings mt cause well yah ur awesome :DDDDDDDD
SuperMysticAlchemist 3 months ago
anybody who gets to go see evanescence live i am so jealous cause i prabobly never get to go see them live
smokey56265 4 months ago
lol whoever says she screwed up this song well fuck you xD coz try singing really high notes while sitting down its hardd coz it blocks something in ur body :) my music tought me tht ages agoo so stop giving shittt around if you dont like it leave ! :)
lolageegirllxx 4 months ago
@lolageegirllxx plus shes doing a really goood job at itt so shud be proudd !!!
lolageegirllxx 4 months ago
she is nt singing good this time
452ist 4 months ago
what the fuck are you talking about? top comment is such bullshit, you are saying its a little off HOW IS IT OFF? the only thing you have to compare it too is a studio version of HER song, so get real. i challenge anyone to get in front of that many people and be perfect. Prime example of "everybodys fool" look it up.
CorruptWill 4 months ago
which year was this?
Eagle747 4 months ago
her drunkness is just so REAL! im seeing them on November the 7th! OMG I CANT WAIT IM suprised i havent ripped out all my hair yet im so excited! u all have to COME! Manchester, Apollo something....
XfishoutofwaterbabeX 4 months ago 20
Yeah.... the singing is not as RICH as it is on the album. But it's not supposed to be. This is live and REAL.
TimothyADonaghue 4 months ago
7 persons don't understand about music
Sarha1997 5 months ago
Wow only amy lee can sound this good drunk
ilovemusic62499 5 months ago
Lovely !
DavidHill333 5 months ago
I love Evanescence! <3
I´m gonna see them on November 18. *_________*
Rydia96 5 months ago
It's like, she's so good, even when she's live! And then you hear Lady Gaga or someone, and she sucks when they're live!
catgirlclaire 5 months ago
@catgirlclaire i like evanescence too,but you should know that lady gaga(although i know you just used her as an example) is a talented singer.although i dont care much for her music,i will admit shes good.people like katy perry,i agree with you.but lady gaga does,surprisingly,have a voice.not to nit pick,just thought you should know :)
happytamachan 5 months ago
Damn they were in Las Vegas when I was like 5 and I never saw themm!!! dammit...
bluedrew17 6 months ago
what part did the plane in the video play....
stevefromPA2 6 months ago
im gonna see her on Oct 11th here in LA <3 cant wait!
Glamorous323 6 months ago
@Glamorous323 fuk u lucky :L
deathbyroses5242 6 months ago
@Glamorous323 LUCKY LUCKY SOUL!! Have a good time! :)))
BluesguyMcfly 6 months ago
EVANESCENCE COME TO TRINIDAD !!!
loveisgreat41 6 months ago
Amy Lee takes no crap, and is the bestest role model there is on Earth! :D
PenguinChickbeme 6 months ago
I'm going to go see Evanescence on October 18 here in San Antonio!! I can't wait! :DD She's totally amazing!!
AlmaFaith777 6 months ago
@AlmaFaith777 I'm going to see Evanescence on October 22nd in Chicago! I can't wait either!!
Jazzie12ShadowGirl 6 months ago
@Jazzie12ShadowGirl Ahh she's going to be amazing!!! :DDD
AlmaFaith777 6 months ago
She's off key at times because her voice is worn from the show or touring. It's tough screaming and singing your lungs out without your voice going out in time. I think it show's she's human. Because with a voice as good as hers, it's hard to believe she's of this world.
Majorbludd817 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
She sounds like an angel!
TDigs25 6 months ago
3:42 Amy Makes a really Hot Expression On her face. ^.^
zelly51 7 months ago
Comment removed
zelly51 7 months ago
Comment removed
zelly51 7 months ago
somebody said that she was a little buzzed, Is that True?
zelly51 7 months ago
@zelly51 yes,yes she was but at least she isnt lipsinging
yancini 7 months ago
@yancini agree. Yea I know. She still pulled it off great, In my Opinion.
zelly51 7 months ago
OMG theyre coming 2 puerto ricoooo!!HOORAY!XD
Zerofuze100 8 months ago
THE one performer that I have never seen live that I really want to see! She is ACE!
meatwarwick 9 months ago
cant wait to see them this august in winnipeg
cracky2themax 9 months ago
i don't get why people give her shit for screwing up occasionally...the songs she sings are incredibly difficult and her vocal range is amazing. you rock amy
danii3927 10 months ago 51
She sounds like she's tired or doesn't want to be there. Not her best from my perspective. I understand that the people who say she sounds good here are her biggest fans but come on! You have to get real.
When she sounds good I'm the first to admit it and when she doesn't...well, she doesn't.
CloudsOfEnvy13 10 months ago 2
@CloudsOfEnvy13 she was probably tired. this was towards the end of the show. but hey, she still did pretty dang good in my book. a few sour notes here and there, for sure, but hey, no one's perfect. =)
iloveevanescence1795 10 months ago
SHE KICKS ASS
TheHorrorFilmMaker 10 months ago
i love your songs Amy lee
510METROID 11 months ago
She really has balls to do that at a download festival
Amy Lee Respect <3
SinisterNight96 11 months ago
Amy Lee is amazing, voice of an angel and beauty of a goddess!
dynamitedan420 1 year ago
@dynamitedan420 you call this a voice of an angel? this whole performance at download was terrible. its like she didnt give a shit
omfgyourmomsugly 11 months ago
Do they still tour?
meatwarwick 1 year ago
@meatwarwick no.
She was drunk, but it's sound good.
1999surya 1 year ago
@1999surya They've got a new album come out soonish apparently so they'll probably tour after wards , i really hope so :)
shann0ny 11 months ago
@shann0ny Will this include the UK....have you heard?
meatwarwick 11 months ago
@meatwarwick I dunno but usually when somebody releases an album they tour afterwards but there are no dates announced yet. Theree should be uk dates :D
shann0ny 11 months ago
@shann0ny yes, I know. I'm the evanescence's number 1 fan, so I know almost everything about them (:
1999surya 11 months ago
@1999surya Same :D I've been a fan since they first came out , i was about 7ish and my dad started listening to them and i loved Amy's voice from the start , she's just incredible
shann0ny 11 months ago
@1999surya sure.
omfgyourmomsugly 11 months ago
@1999surya lol well she was sure on something, this was terrible
omfgyourmomsugly 11 months ago
at least terry is tere....FTWB !!!!!!! amy and terryyy.....ftw!!!!!! lol 2:51 random person... lol 3;36 LOVE HER BOOTS!
whatzmystr111 1 year ago
liiiithiiiiuuuummm this awsme!!!!
DhoriiHartzler 1 year ago
random airplane ftw! lol
zachcaz91 1 year ago
She is FUCKING AMAZING!
Not one of her best concerts
A little shaky
but amazing(:
She alwways is
MrMsElizabeth 1 year ago 2
lucky lil bitches seein her live showin her no respect asmy lee is the goth goddess the snow white queen and they look bored lucky lil spoiled bitches
missfine257 1 year ago
see video Evanescence - Lithium Live at Rock AM Ring 2007 to heard
thehaker517 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I love: * I invite you to listen to my covers of Evanescence and more:)
JapaneseGirll15 1 year ago
i hate will hunt!!! rocky was better
666Gothika777 1 year ago
@666Gothika777 i think that all the original band members were better. i miss them, its sad.
liz20141 1 year ago
I'd give my life , not my limbs =(
just to see amy once
kaify12 1 year ago
i feel so proud that i get the chance to be one of the 18,700 viewers of this video ^_^
94Takato 1 year ago
@94Takato 18,748 actually.
oFRoZENViPER 1 year ago
@oFRoZENViPER hey! it was 18,700 when i wrote that dude
94Takato 1 year ago
@94Takato Yeah i know lol, i was kidding. It's 18,779 now anyway xD
oFRoZENViPER 1 year ago
@oFRoZENViPER lolz teehee. still feel proud lolz. the number of views keeps rising. i wont be surprised if it reaches a million by next week ^_^
94Takato 1 year ago
me parece que los fanaaaaticos de Amy Lee.... se tapan un poco los oidos..en estudia esta cancion es increible...pero en vivo....deja harto que desear....escuche un par de desafinaciones...
nindetinuvielx 1 year ago
he voice isnt as good as the studio one :( just a lil tho
evilpigeions 1 year ago
evanescence is awesome live! i have yet to go to a evanescence concert. they've gotta be one of the best at performing live!
kunoichiOneX 1 year ago
@kunoichiOneX one of the best things about them is that they really give their all on stage. I went to what is considered to be a bad concert, by their standards, and it was one of the most amazing experiences of my life :)
jdnajes 1 year ago 3
I cant stop listening to her amazing voice....she sounds like an ANGEL!!!
slymluver 1 year ago 2
amo esta cancion y este directo
carlos93s 1 year ago
Me encanta la letra de la canción!!!
lobitoferoz18 2 years ago 3
yeah, even if she has a great voice, her breathing problems are terrible.
evanescence9314 2 years ago 2
guys! shut up and listen!! effin brilliant....this is GOLD!
meatwarwick 2 years ago 7
estoy esperando un cd nuevo
POR FAVOR
EVANESCENCE A CHILE
martirADICTA 2 years ago
en noviembre y esperemos ke en su gira pase por Colombia y Chile¡¡¡
kevinlopez31 2 years ago
Euu amo a Amy ..!!!
TheMarii14 2 years ago 2
lala
4NOTW1 2 years ago
wei bila ang nk wat konsert kat malaysia???
4NOTW1 2 years ago
malaysia? evanescence? jangan haraplah, bang. paramore mainstream gitu pun tak masuk. apa lagi evanescence.
QuikCopper 2 years ago
She sound very good in my country very weel is very awesome in live!!!
Amygirlevangirl 2 years ago 2
AWESOME performance! I gotta see this band Live before I die!
arel3 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Why she swear I dont like it!!!!!!!!!!
Plamka987654321 2 years ago
nie wiem czy dobrze Cię zrozumiałam, bo uczę się angielskiego dopiero od kilku miesięcy ale w którym momencie według Ciebie ona przeklina ?
Werkaaa2008 2 years ago
Bardzo lubię evanescence ale na tym koncercie strasznie przeklinała może akurat nie w tej piosence ale na tym koncercie .
Plamka987654321 2 years ago
w takim razie muszę Ci przyznać rację, bo też nie lubię jak artyści w czasie koncertów czy wywiadów przeklinają :)
Werkaaa2008 2 years ago
Amy is my idol!!! I love her!!! She is the best!! Keep on rokin' Amy!!!!!
vampirestruck 2 years ago
I love Amy !!!!
anetkassss 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
she always sound very fucking bad¡¡¡
but i love this band...
i'm a fan
but her voice almost always sucks.
but i love them... albums specially, not live sucks versions
evanrock89 2 years ago
idk.. her voice sounds a lil off.. but i still love her lots!!
shes awsoome! ♥
vishakha17 2 years ago 18
i think she sounds better than every singer iv'e heard live,she rules!
aliceskatergirl 2 years ago 110
This has been flagged as spam show
Lol no she doesn't, she sounds like a combination of a squeeling mouse and a rusty door opening, her singing i utter wailing crap
SeaKitten00 2 years ago
@aliceskatergirl I guess you haven't seen a lot of metal singers live then
mikinhalingeron 1 year ago
awsome voice!
I love Amy <3
Evanescene rocks !
596Hayley 2 years ago 2
Porque siempre usa piano electrico?
oppysam 2 years ago
debe ser más práctico para este tipo de recitales
nerdddalert 2 years ago
i love Amy....she's my life and her songs are my life expecially Lithium...
90Dili 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
man...and someone says anette can't sing
man this bitch sucks!
Lapsellinen 2 years ago
well shes usually not this bad, but she was drunk, and recovering from being sick so idk
UTbuckeye93 2 years ago
She wasn't drunk you idiot idk about recovering from being sick and that's not bad she's amazing and you can't expect the live version to be perfect and sound exactly like the album version but have you heard her on the album version? No matter what she's doing she's always amazing I love Amy Lee!
polarmlee 2 years ago
excuse me, no need for language. everyone is saying she was drunk, im a huge evanescence fan, it wasnt rude what i was sayin, i was just sayin what i heard. i know shes not perfect, i didnt say she was. I was just saying to that guy, that she was recovering, and almost everyone is saying she was drunk, so i just assumed it was right, so ppl would get off my back. trust me, i love amy lee, u think my comment was bad, i was commenting nicely to the one who said she sucked, which is what i didntsay
UTbuckeye93 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Everyone sounds good in "album versions" because their voice gets altered to be in tune with the fucking music. Why does everyone want to justify her crappy singing by saying she is either sick or recovering from being sick? Is she sick all the time? Most of her shows sound exactly like this. I refuse to believe she was sick or recovering from being sick from all of them :)
freakoffherleash300 2 years ago
Comment removed
aliceskatergirl 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Bitch, please, I can listen to whatever I want and I can say whatever the fuck i feel like saying, and if I think that she sounds like a monkey being raped in the ass, then it's my opinion. If you don't like my opinion then just ignore me, who the hell do you think you are to tell me what to listen to and what not to listen to?
freakoffherleash300 2 years ago
@freakoffherleash300 fag
sTapleEVA 1 year ago
you suck!!
xevanescencex4evax 2 years ago
I love her eyes singing poetry songs and her songs! I love Amy Lee! I also love her hair
rudy1523 2 years ago
i dont think those people realize how lucky they were to see her live! id give a limb to see evanescence :)
jessica29406 3 years ago 78
hell id give two XD
carriekellyfan96 3 years ago 8
oh yeah? well id give my head!
jessica29406 3 years ago 7
ha u wouldnt be able to see her beauty or hear her voice heehee and id give my dick! *not in a perverted way!*
carriekellyfan96 3 years ago 6
oh shut ur face! id give my arms and legs. id have someone push me to a concert in a wheelchair! wut now? :)
jessica29406 3 years ago 4
haha i think we ran outta body parts
carriekellyfan96 3 years ago 2
lolz yeah
jessica29406 3 years ago
@jessica29406 pish posh id sell my soul to meet her for 5 seconds
altNaleyForever 1 year ago
@jessica29406 id give all my limbs to see evanescence ^_^
94Takato 1 year ago
@94Takato Haha I get it.(: We'd give SO much just to see this angel sing live.
jessica29406 1 year ago
@jessica29406 oh yeah. id give everything i own just to see her singing live. shes so beautiful and creative she makes the butterflies in my tummy take flight ^_^
94Takato 1 year ago
@94Takato I know.(: I watched her acoustic version of Bring me to life. And I was blown away. I was obsessed with her voice for at least a year. She still fascinates me and I'm glad she'll be making some new music soon.(:
jessica29406 1 year ago
@jessica29406 i watched her accoustic version too and i loved it soo much im still obssessed with her voice and her looks as well. i think im in love with her ^_^ and i cant wait for the end of 2010 coz thats when her third studio album is out. i cant wait to get it. Evanescence is my favorite band. i love them soo much ^_^
94Takato 1 year ago
@jessica29406 y i would give ur limb 2 , to see evan
Vlaxiti 10 months ago
@Vlaxiti LOL
revilo178 9 months ago
i luv evanescence amy lee is so beautful
metatron2000 3 years ago 6
the drummer is so cool
josehine1983 3 years ago 3