I think that the astronaut isn't river, because i think moffat would be abit more clever than that, i mean if it is her i will be very disappointed because its so obvious.
Does anyone else think River maybe kills Rory in the future and not the Doctor? B/C Amy always talks about Rory and you think she means the Doctor. Maybe it's the same thing.
@princesskalika I too have come to the realization that Rory might be the "good man" that River kills. At the beginning of this episode Amy talks to her daughter about a man coming for them. She even says "and not even an army can get in the way." In other words a man who would go to war for them. We think she's talking about the doctor, but then realize she's talking about Rory. Also, in this clip at 1:53, Rory asks "Where is my wife?" followed by the episode title "A Good Man Goes To War"
@marie4poche Yes, Yes..but think about it in "lets kill hitler" at the very end river signs up for archiology..and says "to be honest proffecor. am looking for a good man!" ...obviesly the doctor XD
The girl in the space suit is River/Melody as a young girl. She doesn't remember because of ... something... xD For some reason she kills the Doctor. I think this because of the evidence in the episode where Amy goes into the room of the girl in the old childrens home and there is a picture of her. It can only link up to the girl being River. That's a definite, but River killing the Doctor is just a hunch, I'm waiting for the next 6 eps to come to decide. :3
cmon, isent it obvious who river kills? the greatest man she had ever known? who is the greatest man in the universe? i figured it out as soon as she said she killed someone
@nayr3195 River said she killed "a very good man, the best man I've ever known." Not quite the same thing as "greatest man in the universe." Based on your inclusion of "in the universe," I'm assuming you believe she'll kill the Doctor. That's too obvious. It'll be Rory, the eponymous "good man" in the title of the episode this trailer was for.
@geri4374 watchseries.eu/serie/doctor_who this website won't give you the exact episode, when you click on the episode you want a new tab will come up giving you a whole list of different websites where you can watch the episode you want.
To be honest I think this is rubbisht. I think Russell T Davies was better because his series were subtle and everything made sense in the end and it really made sense. Also it seemed like every episode was important. But Steven Moffat just raises loads of questions and doesn't even answer all of them.
I really need help, I'm going to the doctor who convention tomorrow, but have NO idea for a costume? Something home made obviously, but ANY ideas would be appreciated xx Thank's x
Wait if Amy and Rory had Melody who is really River song. THAT MEANS Amy and Rory are important to not only to the eleventh Doctor but to the tenth doctor. Think about that River meets the tenth Doctor in silence in the Library and Forest of the Dead.
the doctor that dies in the first episode is not the doctor! It is the ganger from the almost people. And dont forget about the girl that regenerates infront of that homeless person!
@doctorwho1982 no the cracks were cracks in time, two parts of time that should never of touched, they were made because River blew up the TARDIS the silence are aliens that make you forget them sure through series five it gave clues to what the silence was... But I don't think the silence and the cracks are connected
J#sus why do so many ppl hate river. If nothing else her hallucinogens make her interesting. Kind of depressed the very first episode is about Hitler. Seriously you go tthrough all that to...oh yeah ....ive got it...Hitler? The writers can stop making trying to make the show a history lesson. Lets get back to the Time conflicts... Annnd can anyone tell me why Amy could fix the universe and bring back the doctor but no other Time Lords? Thanks
@wvboarder2005 It's not the first. It's the mid-season and make good use of it. I've heard rumors that in series 7, Amy & Rory don't return. And that we will have a new doctor after 7. . .
@theshadowedmaster123 just meant the first after the break... It does seem like their writing off River and or Rory/Amy all at once... Kinda sad I really like them all together-ish.... Maybe Melody becomes the first female doctor. If Smith really does bite the bullet... Maybe its tio stop other races from thinking there are and time lords left at all....
@wvboarder2005 Because it was all about remembering the Doctor that brought him back. Rory came back because there was still some spark of him alive in her deep memory. Amy hasn't met any of the other Timelords, therefore she can't bring them back like she can the people she has known and remembers :)
loathesome creature river and the never-ending storyline. And your right. I found the silence to be a huge let down. I guess some fans expectations are low to begin with, so they are easily impressed. I want to see no river and more interesting alien worlds being explored. Steven is going for style rather then substance. And he is apparently rather fond of his mary sue. lol
here and on facebook are deliberately posting red-herrings, sometimes to mislead and sometimes to irritate people. Anyway, if true then this storyline will be prolonged for another season. Your Lost analogy was a good one. I never watched that show because it looked stupid. So now Steve isn't just stealing a terrible idea from the time travelers wife but lost as well. And I read somewhere that season 7 won't be aired until the fall of 2012. I won't be watching because I'm sick to death of that,
@Drwhofan246 I liked this story. A "good man goes to war" finally returns the series to the quality of RTD era. Of the 7 episodes thus far, only 3 were plonkers "the black spot" and that average rebel flesh episode.
F*cking Idiot! So I won't be able to watch the rest of series 6 or any of 7. Not without vomiting. Moffat has succeeded in turning Dr Who into a full-fledged Soap Opera. He is the biggest loser. What the h*ll is that scum-bag thinking? Even DIE-HARD River fans don't want to see her marry the dr. In fact they don't want to see ANY WOMAN marry the dr. They don't want that sort of soap opera crap invading this science fiction show. And the 2nd half of series 6 is taking place before the 1st half.
SPOILERS!!! I cutting and pasting from a facebook page :People who have been present at the time of filming & make a career of leaking spoilers to the Gallifrey Base forum & twitter confirmed they saw the scenes where River Song says that she is his wife to Amy. That's certain, she is going to b...e his wife, those guys have never been wrong before. And loads more of her in
Series 6 & 7, and Amy & Rory leaving after series 6. So the mystery is over. The fat cow is his wife. VOMIT! Moffat is a
@sallyjosie who the hell didn't see this crap coming? This bullshit is typical of moffy. He thinks his lameass time travelers wife bullshit is all that. What else is new? We've already decided to stop watching his crap because we can't take the aggravation of this sleazy trash being peddled to us. And River will probably be the one in the suit! ZZzzzzz! total yawn. There is no point in watching anymore. There is nothing fresh or original. Thankfully there are plenty of other shows to watch.
@friedasmith I agree with you. Overall, series 5 & 6 have been pretty terrible although i do think that this last episode peaked my interest and i think impossible astronaut 2 parter and the finale were smiths best episodes yet (as well as "the drs wife episode). Still, I wish moffat would drop this cliffhanger shit and go back to the formula RTD did so well. This is dr who, not an LOST. Some good self contained episodes like in RTDs days "blink" "family of blood" "midnight" etc is whats needed
@doctorwho1982 I'm a diehard dr who fan from way back in the Tom Baker era and will always watch it but had I not been a fan, I would have walked away from it after that dismal series 5. RTDs era was awesome. Tenant was awesome as the DR. Only now am i warming to matt smith and Moffat after the series finale but I have the feelin that he cant keep givin us satisfying answers to the cliffhangers he is creating. Its gonna crash sooner or later. What happened to the "silence"?
@doctorwho1982 The silence in series 5 was just a bright light that consumed eveything it touched and totally wiped things from existence, even the angels were absorbed by them. Now in series 6, the silence are presented as actually "aliens" with physical form who only wipe yr memory. Whats goin on? Does anyone else feel unsatisfied with moffats revelation about the silence?
@doctorwho1982 Actually, that 'bright light' as you call it, wasn't the Silence. It was one of many cracks in time created by the Tardis exploding. I feel we have not seen the end of the Silence just yet.
@doctorwho1982 Indeed. It was a 'crack in time' i.e: fall through it and you've fallen through time. You no longer exist. You are beyond time - beyond anything. It's like a big crack in reality - on one side is reality and on the other side is nothing. No existence. Nadda. As the Doctor says 'It'll be like you've never been born at all.' But the Silence have nothing to do with that. They are an alien species - separate from the crack in time. Or so it is right now.
@LittleChocolateChip so the question remains "why did the silence (those aliens) blow up the tardis and how? and whats rivers connection to it all? I'm enjoying season 6 thus far but i worry that Its getting all too much like LOST now. I think moffat needs to pull it in and tie it up before it drags on too long and people stop caring. Go back to the self contained episodes of RTDs era with less of this LOST aspect to the series.
@doctorwho1982 As far as I'm aware, the Silence had nothing to do with the Tardis exploding. They are completely separate from all that. The reason for the Tardis exploding was never properly explained, but the story suggests that it was due to the cracks in time and returning on the day the universe gets destroyed that sends the Tardis into mayhem. River's connection? She has no connection. She's not responsible for the cracks or the Silence. Ha, don't like LOST huh? I've never seen it but -
@LittleChocolateChip um but i thought the silence took control of the tardis and then made it explode? Remember the voice "silence will fall" as the tardis got remote controlled with river in it in pandoricas box? And then at the end the dr said he was gonna find out who took control of the tardis and why the blew it up. Then the silence aliens are seen with the little girl (river) in the spacesuit, housing her in the rundown american orphans home. Whats the connection?
@doctorwho1982 Hmm, if they did take control of the Tardis with River inside then perhaps they wanted River out of the picture (having become a problem for them) I'm not convinced that they did take control of it though. The Silence had River (well, who we believe to be River - it hasn't actually been confirmed that that little girl is her) - but it hasn't been explained why yet. Perhaps they were using her as a weapon. Perhaps they're in cahoots with Eye-Patch Lady. Who knows?
@LittleChocolateChip yes, i believe they in cahoots with eye patch lady which raises another question "who is the eye patch lady?" and "whats her beef with the dr?". Interesting. I hope yr right about yr faith in moffats bigger picture. I want to see dr who carry on for years to come as much as the next fan.
@doctorwho1982 Lots of people have problems with the Doctor. He's destroyed a few races and foiled a lot of plans. He's a saviour to some and a destroyer to others. Eye-Patch lady only wants Melody/River as a weapon against the Doctor. Which means that she must view him as a threat. Hence why River is so adept at fighting. Eye-Patch has trained her up I bet. Trained her to kill the Doctor. Crazy times.
@doctorwho1982 I gotta say I'm seriously loving the complete season story-arcs. I love seeing how everything ties up and looking for the subtle clues to it all that are littered throughout the season. It's not just like a character mentioning something that relates to the ending, Moffat actually makes the whole season point to that ending. Take the Flesh!Amy. There are clues throughout the season that point to her fleshiness - and you don't even notice them when you first watch! Totally clever!
@LittleChocolateChip I like the season arcs to but only to a point. LOST was awesome for the first season but when it dragged on too long it became apparent that the writers were just makin it up as they went along as it got more and more ridiculous. They were more interested in creating questions and less with the answers. It had style but no substance. The finale was a big dissapointment. i hope dr who doesn't go down that route.
@doctorwho1982 I have a lot of faith in Moffat (despite the fact that he's 'killed' off Rory about 20,000 times. PLEASE STOP IT) He has the bigger picture worked out. He sees the ending and works to get there.
@doctorwho1982 Don't look for any conclusion to A Good Man Goes to war this fall. If JamieHewitt something or other is to be believed. He told me that the second half of this season is suppose to be taking place before the first half of this season. So we see the Dr dropping Amy and Rory off on Earth in episode 11. And he gets the stetson in episode 12, if that guy was telling the truth and not just yanking my chain. Trying to spread some false rumors. I sometimes get the feeling that some,
@friedasmith i knew that River was likely to be thier daughter after the astronaut episode. They said river killed a good man (the dr) so its logical that she was the child in the suit and also it showed the baby pics in that room and the fact that amy was pregnant. The question that now remains is "why must river kill the dr in that fashion at that time" and "how does the dr come back to life?" We all know the dr cant die, its his show & there must be a 12th regeneration to come in the future.
Some guy on another post told me that the second half of the 6th season will take place before the first half. He said he has access to all kinds of spoilers. He was right about other "spoilers". So 'lets kill hitler' isn't a continuation of A good man goes to war. And he said that the Dr drops amy and rory off in ep11 and gets the stetson in ep12. So we really have to wait until season 7 to see the conclusion of A good man
hey watch my vid, Doctor Who A Good Man Goes To War Clips, or look up my name (doctorwhofan5567). i hav clips from the episode, i vedio taped from a website
@wsdrwho at the end of "day of the moon" the girl was not in the space suit anymore. So it is possible that some other person was in the suit and killed the doctor. Why should River shoot at the astronaut if she knows, that she is inside?
@Waddler667 well it's great for people in the UK who get to see the episode a week before us in Australia. Please don't go and say major spoilers in the comments
@36chocolas Don'y go onto Youtube videos about the latest Doctor Who episode then. Or if you have to, don't read the comments, because people WILL talk about it.
@JustinBeiberFan132 I watched it on sunday and I am still trying to wrap my head around everything. This is the second time and only the second time that a doctor who episode has confused me. the first being "the impossible astronaut" (first episode of season 6)
@pedro27mumble watch Genesis of the Daleks. The Time Lord who tells the 4th Doctor of his mission to either destroy the Daleks or make them less powerful, talks of a war that is going badly with the Daleks. So they did try to stop the war but the 4th dr overcome with emotions decides not to kill them. So the death of the Time Lords of their being frozen for all time really is the Dr's fault. But never let it be said that some cleaver future writers can't think of a way. Never say never. lol
stopped paying attention to those idiots a long time ago. If some networks hadn't ignored their test audience in some instances, some of the most popular tv shows in U.S history would not have been picked up. So most of us don't pay any attention to them. Most of the dr who test audiences are die hard dr who fans. so they are more easily impressed then just an average group of people.
Oh and by the way guys, I hate to burst your bubbles. But if you just look up this episode in Wikipedia it will give you the entire plot, right down to the name of the baby.
The child is half Time-Lord, except all the time lords are dead. So either there is a stray time lord out there who happens to have slept with Amy, or she slept with the Doctor and gave birth to River Song, who is the Doctor's love interest...... (WTF?)
Or Rory is a ninja and a Time Lord, which is why they keep trying to kill him every episode but he never dies. Because Rory is a BAMF.
@narusteph You don't have to be born from a time lord to become one. The time lords themselves got their abilities from being exposed to things like rifts.
@TheCynthiasramos Then it would be better to catch up than to have someone spoil a bunch of episodes for you. I recommend catching up. This season is amazing so far.
I hate to break your bubble, but the episode was shit. They've made the finales too big in past years they've tried to make it better but just failed. It went downhill after Russell T Davies left.
@ToXiCLTdNM We all have different opinions but im completely against you. That was purely epic. Steven Moffat is such a better writer than RTD, its the best series by far. Okay so the pandorica was a bit on the crap side, but the only really good series of doctor who so far (and i mean epic) is series 2 and series 6. Im not saying your wrong, its interesting seeing different opinions ach, but its more gripping than ever before :D
@Hawandy456 That girl who died? Hmm. But it couldn't be, could it? Because she was younger than River is - and River dies/died in Silence In The Library - so that doesn't work out, does it? And if River can regenerate (which she might be able to) then Lorna would have regenerated then and there. Agreed. There are so many hints that it's going to be Rory - what Amy says, Rory going into battle (going into war) and River's reaction to him in the storm cage. I really think it will be.
@Hawandy456 oooh, unless of course the Doctor had not meant Lorna in his timeline yet (which is why he wouldn't remember her) and she was a later regenerated form of River? That could be plausible :)
@LittleChocolateChip i thought that. But he does say that he met her in the ep. But it could happen in a flashback. or its River's birthday with the two doctors.
Moffat just fucked lady continuity in the A**! River told the tenth doctor that he appeared in "new" not "another" suit and hair meaning there must be a 12 incarnation of the doctor that took her to the singing towers , BUT it couldn't have been because River killed the doctor on the beach in the suit in his 11 incarnation => PARADOX
@Thorrr333 Do you really think the Doctor will die just like that? River has indeed met the Twelfth Doctor, so we know the Doctor will live on. He'll either come back from the dead, or he'll find a way to die and live on at the same time.
@Thorrr333 River said that was the last time before the libary since River saw the Doctor, and seeing as though their relationship works backwords it is likely that the 10th Doctor himself could have been there. Which would make sense seeing as though the Sonic Screwdriver he gives her is a similar design to the one the 9/10th Doctors used. So we will have to put this down as another scene we won't see on screen, which could have took place after Series 4.
way too obvious. It was obvious about the blonde child being amy's daughter (duh), but what I did not expect was river song - melody pond!!! hahaha best twist ever though :)
wow such a great episode.. kind of predictable with the whole river song-melody pond thing though! lol :) anyway i am content with the way they ended this for now and i'm so excited for the fall episodes! :D
just wondering since the "Naked River" clip wasn't in a previous episode and it wasn't in A Good Man Goes To War, then where is that from? is that from a clip from a episode from the fall?
"Can you die?"
"Why"
"Cause you invited us to see it happen."
Which episode is that from?
clarinetyful 4 days ago
YO EYE PATCHED LADY BABIES BELONG 2 THE WOUND THEY CAME OUT SO LIVE WITH IT DUHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
tatertotgirl56 4 weeks ago
@tatertotgirl56 Babies now come out of wounds.
ZombbieRS 3 weeks ago
the baby is river song!
oldgrampa3 1 month ago
has anyone else noticed that madame kovarian must be lying on top of the casket thing amy's in..?
it's a little disturbing
gingaahbooy 1 month ago 2
Why the hell is RIver naked at some point? I bet they just put it to attract our attention. -_-
SpectreICollateral 1 month ago
OMG! go to 2:06 !! River naked!!!
TheDo0octor 1 month ago 2
DEmon's run when a good man goes to war
Paramores30stmktpgir 2 months ago
you absolutely nailed this. Well done!
WannaBeANerd 2 months ago
so does anyone else think amy looks sexy pregnant
camoblackhawk 3 months ago 2
@camoblackhawk Ew! Hell no. what kind of fetish's are you into?
Jayem411 3 months ago
uuuhhh song name?
TheDFB71 3 months ago
Thumbs up for no reason.
unarmedpanda007 4 months ago
When the Amy tells the Doctor that he invited them to see his death, was that the flesh avatar or the real Doctor?
ultamitestarwars224 4 months ago
@ultamitestarwars224 I'm pretty sure it was the real doctor, because they swapped shoes. But I may be wrong.
XDreamHorsesX 4 months ago
@XDreamHorsesX Then I'm surprised that the Doctor did not make a big deal out of it.
ultamitestarwars224 4 months ago
@XDreamHorsesX @ultamitestarwars224 Nah, it wasn't, because during the same episode he was introduced, he died ):
Aldurnamiyanrandvora 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Demons run when a good man goes to war.
Night will fall and drown the sun,
When a good man goes to war.
Friendship dies and true love lies;
Night will fall and the dark will rise,
When a good man goes to war.
Demons run but count the cost;
The battle's won but the child is lost
InsertNameHere297 4 months ago
Wow! Good job!
emsteffi 5 months ago
2:19 eeeecckck
jannicabianca 5 months ago
creepyy
jannicabianca 5 months ago
The Doctor that is killed on the beach is a different flesh copy of The Doctor - notice he is wearing the same bow tie?
RegenerationStorm 5 months ago
I think that the astronaut isn't river, because i think moffat would be abit more clever than that, i mean if it is her i will be very disappointed because its so obvious.
diamonds1997 5 months ago
river is achuley the baby i know i saw in bbc one iplayer got proof
widebart 5 months ago
river is the impossible astronaut that kills the dr i bet
jonhaShel 6 months ago
...what if the best man River ever knew was her father, Rory?
alwaysknowingit13 6 months ago
Does anyone else think River maybe kills Rory in the future and not the Doctor? B/C Amy always talks about Rory and you think she means the Doctor. Maybe it's the same thing.
princesskalika 6 months ago
@princesskalika I too have come to the realization that Rory might be the "good man" that River kills. At the beginning of this episode Amy talks to her daughter about a man coming for them. She even says "and not even an army can get in the way." In other words a man who would go to war for them. We think she's talking about the doctor, but then realize she's talking about Rory. Also, in this clip at 1:53, Rory asks "Where is my wife?" followed by the episode title "A Good Man Goes To War"
marie4poche 5 months ago
@marie4poche Yes, Yes..but think about it in "lets kill hitler" at the very end river signs up for archiology..and says "to be honest proffecor. am looking for a good man!" ...obviesly the doctor XD
TheBigBongProduction 5 months ago
river song is the child and gets sent to prison for killing the doctor
got2bmorethanthis 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@got2bmorethanthis That's what we are SUPPOSED to think.
orbital151 6 months ago
haa 2 haters :L
inkybuilder 6 months ago
nnnyyyyyyc
nehalbakth 6 months ago
I has a theory. Lawl.
The girl in the space suit is River/Melody as a young girl. She doesn't remember because of ... something... xD For some reason she kills the Doctor. I think this because of the evidence in the episode where Amy goes into the room of the girl in the old childrens home and there is a picture of her. It can only link up to the girl being River. That's a definite, but River killing the Doctor is just a hunch, I'm waiting for the next 6 eps to come to decide. :3
Cpds12dePro 6 months ago
MY DAD DELETED BBCAMERCIA FROM MY TV! WHERE CAN I WATCH (TOTALLY BEHIMD)
Alysin123 6 months ago
@Alysin123 pirate?
nayr3195 6 months ago
@nayr3195 i got a loop hole though
Alysin123 6 months ago
this is the doctors darkest hour..he finds out there's no toilet paper and he needs to take a shit...
99fictionfan99 6 months ago
cmon, isent it obvious who river kills? the greatest man she had ever known? who is the greatest man in the universe? i figured it out as soon as she said she killed someone
nayr3195 6 months ago
@nayr3195 River said she killed "a very good man, the best man I've ever known." Not quite the same thing as "greatest man in the universe." Based on your inclusion of "in the universe," I'm assuming you believe she'll kill the Doctor. That's too obvious. It'll be Rory, the eponymous "good man" in the title of the episode this trailer was for.
psychogobstopper 6 months ago
@psychogobstopper i can see your point there but i still think its the doctor, way more likley.
nayr3195 6 months ago
Is this the last episode of the first part of series 6? if so where can i watch it because i missed it and want to watch it,
geri4374 7 months ago
Comment removed
smickersxxx 6 months ago
@geri4374 watchseries.eu/serie/doctor_who this website won't give you the exact episode, when you click on the episode you want a new tab will come up giving you a whole list of different websites where you can watch the episode you want.
smickersxxx 6 months ago
Comment removed
geri4374 6 months ago
THANK YOU! I found this episode shortly after posting the comment but i am looking for others as well so the information was a bit help.
geri4374 6 months ago
matt smith sighned up for another year of being the doctor so we have more episodes coming
coolman1159123 7 months ago
To be honest I think this is rubbisht. I think Russell T Davies was better because his series were subtle and everything made sense in the end and it really made sense. Also it seemed like every episode was important. But Steven Moffat just raises loads of questions and doesn't even answer all of them.
ToXiCLTdNM 7 months ago
@ToXiCLTdNM we're only half way through the series.
dillinger1991 7 months ago
@ToXiCLTdNM
Steven Moffat hasn't finished this series yet. If you dont like it, dont watch the series!
jacbarlow41 7 months ago
in bbc iplayer
widebart 7 months ago
when is gonna be on i waited 3 weeks!
HoneyDollXO 7 months ago
To everyone who's complaining about Moffat: go and write your own successful show.
And to everyone wanting RTD to come back: He's gone. Accept it.
RandomShinigami7 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@animalluvr07 u can watch it on watchseries.eu
hope that helps =]
XbeccaXbX 7 months ago
WHERE CAN I FIND THE WHOLE EPISODE?
waddle16926 7 months ago
@waddle16926 its on dailymotion you can watch all of the first half of series six on there for free.
doctorw2 6 months ago
I really need help, I'm going to the doctor who convention tomorrow, but have NO idea for a costume? Something home made obviously, but ANY ideas would be appreciated xx Thank's x
Michin725 7 months ago
Wait if Amy and Rory had Melody who is really River song. THAT MEANS Amy and Rory are important to not only to the eleventh Doctor but to the tenth doctor. Think about that River meets the tenth Doctor in silence in the Library and Forest of the Dead.
DoctorWriter13 7 months ago
why do u want to know how river is shes amys baby evryone knows that
kieranfthompson 7 months ago
does anyone know where i could whatch this? if you do then please respond
SliMJImsNipe 7 months ago
@SliMJImsNipe Amazon has it for 1.99
scarlethawk 7 months ago
i always thought it was a possibilty that they might do a twist- River may have killed the best man in her life- it could be her father- Rory?
Ladylozzii2008 7 months ago
PEOPLE ARE ALWAYS GOING "OH, WHO DID RIVER KILL? WHY IS SHE IN JAIL?"
River is the kid in the spacesuit. The kid in the spacesuit kills THE DOCTOR.
WHO DID RIVER KILL? THE DOCTOR!
*grumblings* GOD, people are so daft -.-"
MsCatanacmaniac 7 months ago
@MsCatanacmaniac Who's River?
scarlethawk 7 months ago
@MsCatanacmaniac thats just rude, maybe people dont understand, it doesnt make them stupid or daft, all they need is for someone to explane it.
daisies11100 7 months ago
@MsCatanacmaniac Moffat wouldn't use such a predictable plot as that. River is also not American.
JimJamfish 7 months ago
i hate a doctor... note THE doctor... Girls NEVER go with a a guy who happens to work as a doctos
schluie81 7 months ago
i love Rory ideal man :D
schluie81 7 months ago
i honestly didn't know River was Melody stupid?????
schluie81 7 months ago
ive been trying to find that saying that River says in the episode
Undertaker9711 8 months ago
@Undertaker9711
Demons run when a good man goes to war,
Night will fall and drown the sun,
When a good man goes to war.
Friendship dies and true love lies,
Night will fall and the dark will rise,
When a good man goes to war.
Demons run, but count the cost,
The battle's won, but the child is lost.
dieskie2479 7 months ago
@Undertaker9711 The poem is called Demons Run if you meaned this.
Try this on youtube; Doctor Who - Demons Run when a Good Man Goes to War
dieskie2479 7 months ago
@dieskie2479 thanks but i already found it. i appreciate the help though
Undertaker9711 7 months ago
Comment removed
Rosietale 7 months ago
@Undertaker9711 Haha, I'm sorry. ;) But no thanks.
dieskie2479 7 months ago
I hate the BBCA commercials. If this was a BBCA commercial, I'd watch it XD
Plus, I so want them to stop this "Amy telling story to her baby" opening
ianflowforever 8 months ago
the doctor that dies in the first episode is not the doctor! It is the ganger from the almost people. And dont forget about the girl that regenerates infront of that homeless person!
LaxVolcano1214 8 months ago
@LaxVolcano1214 thats a good explanation. I think yr right.
doctorwho1982 8 months ago
@doctorwho1982 :D
LaxVolcano1214 8 months ago
@LaxVolcano1214 a ganger wouldn't begin to regenerate, would he?
but it all makes sense now
the eye patch lady said she would turn melody into a weapon to use against the doctor
and then melody kills him in the spacesuit
at least it's been strongly hinted at that it is in fact melody - what with all the "i killed the best man i ever knew" etc.
AlexRider001 7 months ago
Comment removed
Rosietale 7 months ago
Comment removed
Rosietale 7 months ago
@AlexRider001 Yeah, I think River Kills the doctor to.
But It wasn't her fault because it's just the way THEY raised her. She didn't know better.
And when she grows up she regrets what she did. So she gets back in time to help the doctor where she can. ;)
dieskie2479 7 months ago
Anyone else think that the man River Song kills is actually going to turn out to be Rory, instead of the Doctor?
Ageingrebel 8 months ago
I guessed it. I totally guessed it, but I thought it would be the Doctor's kid, not Rory's.
HiddenWriter22 8 months ago
@HiddenWriter22 same here but i di work out that river song was amy's near the start of the season
mangbat1 8 months ago
@doctorwho1982 no the cracks were cracks in time, two parts of time that should never of touched, they were made because River blew up the TARDIS the silence are aliens that make you forget them sure through series five it gave clues to what the silence was... But I don't think the silence and the cracks are connected
JimmytheDodger 8 months ago
J#sus why do so many ppl hate river. If nothing else her hallucinogens make her interesting. Kind of depressed the very first episode is about Hitler. Seriously you go tthrough all that to...oh yeah ....ive got it...Hitler? The writers can stop making trying to make the show a history lesson. Lets get back to the Time conflicts... Annnd can anyone tell me why Amy could fix the universe and bring back the doctor but no other Time Lords? Thanks
wvboarder2005 8 months ago
@wvboarder2005 It's not the first. It's the mid-season and make good use of it. I've heard rumors that in series 7, Amy & Rory don't return. And that we will have a new doctor after 7. . .
theshadowedmaster123 8 months ago
@theshadowedmaster123 just meant the first after the break... It does seem like their writing off River and or Rory/Amy all at once... Kinda sad I really like them all together-ish.... Maybe Melody becomes the first female doctor. If Smith really does bite the bullet... Maybe its tio stop other races from thinking there are and time lords left at all....
wvboarder2005 8 months ago
@wvboarder2005 Because it was all about remembering the Doctor that brought him back. Rory came back because there was still some spark of him alive in her deep memory. Amy hasn't met any of the other Timelords, therefore she can't bring them back like she can the people she has known and remembers :)
LittleChocolateChip 8 months ago
@LittleChocolateChip Thank you for not answering like im a dumbass...mucho appreciated!
wvboarder2005 8 months ago
@wvboarder2005 Heh heh, of course! Doctor Who is as confusing as hell, us fans have to stick together and help each other make sense of it! ;)
LittleChocolateChip 8 months ago
loathesome creature river and the never-ending storyline. And your right. I found the silence to be a huge let down. I guess some fans expectations are low to begin with, so they are easily impressed. I want to see no river and more interesting alien worlds being explored. Steven is going for style rather then substance. And he is apparently rather fond of his mary sue. lol
friedasmith 8 months ago
@friedasmith I think the silence are involved with the baby.
theshadowedmaster123 8 months ago
@theshadowedmaster123 Agreed. They created that space suit for her at any rate...or did they? ;)
LittleChocolateChip 8 months ago
here and on facebook are deliberately posting red-herrings, sometimes to mislead and sometimes to irritate people. Anyway, if true then this storyline will be prolonged for another season. Your Lost analogy was a good one. I never watched that show because it looked stupid. So now Steve isn't just stealing a terrible idea from the time travelers wife but lost as well. And I read somewhere that season 7 won't be aired until the fall of 2012. I won't be watching because I'm sick to death of that,
friedasmith 8 months ago
In A Good Man Goes to War, it was dramatic....
Drwhofan246 8 months ago
@Drwhofan246 I liked this story. A "good man goes to war" finally returns the series to the quality of RTD era. Of the 7 episodes thus far, only 3 were plonkers "the black spot" and that average rebel flesh episode.
doctorwho1982 8 months ago
@doctorwho1982 i like it too and yes those 3 episodes was average.
Drwhofan246 8 months ago
F*cking Idiot! So I won't be able to watch the rest of series 6 or any of 7. Not without vomiting. Moffat has succeeded in turning Dr Who into a full-fledged Soap Opera. He is the biggest loser. What the h*ll is that scum-bag thinking? Even DIE-HARD River fans don't want to see her marry the dr. In fact they don't want to see ANY WOMAN marry the dr. They don't want that sort of soap opera crap invading this science fiction show. And the 2nd half of series 6 is taking place before the 1st half.
sallyjosie 8 months ago
@sallyjosie Well don't watch it then. Problem solved.
RandomShinigami7 7 months ago
SPOILERS!!! I cutting and pasting from a facebook page :People who have been present at the time of filming & make a career of leaking spoilers to the Gallifrey Base forum & twitter confirmed they saw the scenes where River Song says that she is his wife to Amy. That's certain, she is going to b...e his wife, those guys have never been wrong before. And loads more of her in
Series 6 & 7, and Amy & Rory leaving after series 6. So the mystery is over. The fat cow is his wife. VOMIT! Moffat is a
sallyjosie 8 months ago
@sallyjosie who the hell didn't see this crap coming? This bullshit is typical of moffy. He thinks his lameass time travelers wife bullshit is all that. What else is new? We've already decided to stop watching his crap because we can't take the aggravation of this sleazy trash being peddled to us. And River will probably be the one in the suit! ZZzzzzz! total yawn. There is no point in watching anymore. There is nothing fresh or original. Thankfully there are plenty of other shows to watch.
friedasmith 8 months ago
@friedasmith I agree with you. Overall, series 5 & 6 have been pretty terrible although i do think that this last episode peaked my interest and i think impossible astronaut 2 parter and the finale were smiths best episodes yet (as well as "the drs wife episode). Still, I wish moffat would drop this cliffhanger shit and go back to the formula RTD did so well. This is dr who, not an LOST. Some good self contained episodes like in RTDs days "blink" "family of blood" "midnight" etc is whats needed
doctorwho1982 8 months ago
@doctorwho1982 I'm a diehard dr who fan from way back in the Tom Baker era and will always watch it but had I not been a fan, I would have walked away from it after that dismal series 5. RTDs era was awesome. Tenant was awesome as the DR. Only now am i warming to matt smith and Moffat after the series finale but I have the feelin that he cant keep givin us satisfying answers to the cliffhangers he is creating. Its gonna crash sooner or later. What happened to the "silence"?
doctorwho1982 8 months ago
@doctorwho1982 The silence in series 5 was just a bright light that consumed eveything it touched and totally wiped things from existence, even the angels were absorbed by them. Now in series 6, the silence are presented as actually "aliens" with physical form who only wipe yr memory. Whats goin on? Does anyone else feel unsatisfied with moffats revelation about the silence?
doctorwho1982 8 months ago
@doctorwho1982 Actually, that 'bright light' as you call it, wasn't the Silence. It was one of many cracks in time created by the Tardis exploding. I feel we have not seen the end of the Silence just yet.
LittleChocolateChip 8 months ago
@LittleChocolateChip but that light erased people from time? I dont get it?
doctorwho1982 8 months ago
@doctorwho1982 Indeed. It was a 'crack in time' i.e: fall through it and you've fallen through time. You no longer exist. You are beyond time - beyond anything. It's like a big crack in reality - on one side is reality and on the other side is nothing. No existence. Nadda. As the Doctor says 'It'll be like you've never been born at all.' But the Silence have nothing to do with that. They are an alien species - separate from the crack in time. Or so it is right now.
LittleChocolateChip 8 months ago
@LittleChocolateChip so the question remains "why did the silence (those aliens) blow up the tardis and how? and whats rivers connection to it all? I'm enjoying season 6 thus far but i worry that Its getting all too much like LOST now. I think moffat needs to pull it in and tie it up before it drags on too long and people stop caring. Go back to the self contained episodes of RTDs era with less of this LOST aspect to the series.
doctorwho1982 8 months ago
@doctorwho1982 As far as I'm aware, the Silence had nothing to do with the Tardis exploding. They are completely separate from all that. The reason for the Tardis exploding was never properly explained, but the story suggests that it was due to the cracks in time and returning on the day the universe gets destroyed that sends the Tardis into mayhem. River's connection? She has no connection. She's not responsible for the cracks or the Silence. Ha, don't like LOST huh? I've never seen it but -
LittleChocolateChip 8 months ago
@LittleChocolateChip um but i thought the silence took control of the tardis and then made it explode? Remember the voice "silence will fall" as the tardis got remote controlled with river in it in pandoricas box? And then at the end the dr said he was gonna find out who took control of the tardis and why the blew it up. Then the silence aliens are seen with the little girl (river) in the spacesuit, housing her in the rundown american orphans home. Whats the connection?
doctorwho1982 8 months ago
@doctorwho1982 Hmm, if they did take control of the Tardis with River inside then perhaps they wanted River out of the picture (having become a problem for them) I'm not convinced that they did take control of it though. The Silence had River (well, who we believe to be River - it hasn't actually been confirmed that that little girl is her) - but it hasn't been explained why yet. Perhaps they were using her as a weapon. Perhaps they're in cahoots with Eye-Patch Lady. Who knows?
LittleChocolateChip 8 months ago
@LittleChocolateChip yes, i believe they in cahoots with eye patch lady which raises another question "who is the eye patch lady?" and "whats her beef with the dr?". Interesting. I hope yr right about yr faith in moffats bigger picture. I want to see dr who carry on for years to come as much as the next fan.
doctorwho1982 8 months ago
@doctorwho1982 Lots of people have problems with the Doctor. He's destroyed a few races and foiled a lot of plans. He's a saviour to some and a destroyer to others. Eye-Patch lady only wants Melody/River as a weapon against the Doctor. Which means that she must view him as a threat. Hence why River is so adept at fighting. Eye-Patch has trained her up I bet. Trained her to kill the Doctor. Crazy times.
LittleChocolateChip 8 months ago
@doctorwho1982 I gotta say I'm seriously loving the complete season story-arcs. I love seeing how everything ties up and looking for the subtle clues to it all that are littered throughout the season. It's not just like a character mentioning something that relates to the ending, Moffat actually makes the whole season point to that ending. Take the Flesh!Amy. There are clues throughout the season that point to her fleshiness - and you don't even notice them when you first watch! Totally clever!
LittleChocolateChip 8 months ago
@LittleChocolateChip I like the season arcs to but only to a point. LOST was awesome for the first season but when it dragged on too long it became apparent that the writers were just makin it up as they went along as it got more and more ridiculous. They were more interested in creating questions and less with the answers. It had style but no substance. The finale was a big dissapointment. i hope dr who doesn't go down that route.
doctorwho1982 8 months ago
@doctorwho1982 I have a lot of faith in Moffat (despite the fact that he's 'killed' off Rory about 20,000 times. PLEASE STOP IT) He has the bigger picture worked out. He sees the ending and works to get there.
LittleChocolateChip 8 months ago
@doctorwho1982 Don't look for any conclusion to A Good Man Goes to war this fall. If JamieHewitt something or other is to be believed. He told me that the second half of this season is suppose to be taking place before the first half of this season. So we see the Dr dropping Amy and Rory off on Earth in episode 11. And he gets the stetson in episode 12, if that guy was telling the truth and not just yanking my chain. Trying to spread some false rumors. I sometimes get the feeling that some,
friedasmith 8 months ago
@friedasmith i knew that River was likely to be thier daughter after the astronaut episode. They said river killed a good man (the dr) so its logical that she was the child in the suit and also it showed the baby pics in that room and the fact that amy was pregnant. The question that now remains is "why must river kill the dr in that fashion at that time" and "how does the dr come back to life?" We all know the dr cant die, its his show & there must be a 12th regeneration to come in the future.
doctorwho1982 8 months ago
FUCK THIS SHIT I'M KILLING HITLER
ZKoftherebellion 8 months ago 2
the baby is river song
ariesroxs1 8 months ago
the baby is river song
ariesroxs1 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Some guy on another post told me that the second half of the 6th season will take place before the first half. He said he has access to all kinds of spoilers. He was right about other "spoilers". So 'lets kill hitler' isn't a continuation of A good man goes to war. And he said that the Dr drops amy and rory off in ep11 and gets the stetson in ep12. So we really have to wait until season 7 to see the conclusion of A good man
friedasmith 8 months ago
hey watch my vid, Doctor Who A Good Man Goes To War Clips, or look up my name (doctorwhofan5567). i hav clips from the episode, i vedio taped from a website
doctorwhofan5567 8 months ago
the girl in the space suite is not who you think she is it is river song shes kills the doctor
wsdrwho 8 months ago
@wsdrwho at the end of "day of the moon" the girl was not in the space suit anymore. So it is possible that some other person was in the suit and killed the doctor. Why should River shoot at the astronaut if she knows, that she is inside?
Legomoves 8 months ago
@Waddler667 well it's great for people in the UK who get to see the episode a week before us in Australia. Please don't go and say major spoilers in the comments
36chocolas 8 months ago
@36chocolas Don'y go onto Youtube videos about the latest Doctor Who episode then. Or if you have to, don't read the comments, because people WILL talk about it.
RandomShinigami7 7 months ago
Ack, spoilers!
Fenzito 8 months ago
whats the song at the end with like the bells? Starting at 1:42?
SuperCrazykids09 8 months ago
this is a very gd vid xxx :)
xlaurenANDambarx 8 months ago
river kills the doctor when she was the girl in the space suit. river goes to jail. river watches herself kill the doctor.
dialEforEm 8 months ago
@dialEforEm you don't know that
TARDIS1231 8 months ago
@JustinBeiberFan132 I watched it on sunday and I am still trying to wrap my head around everything. This is the second time and only the second time that a doctor who episode has confused me. the first being "the impossible astronaut" (first episode of season 6)
gigglefruit22 8 months ago
i don't beileve the timelords that travel in time didn't see the last great time war coming and took steps to survive
pedro27mumble 8 months ago
@pedro27mumble watch Genesis of the Daleks. The Time Lord who tells the 4th Doctor of his mission to either destroy the Daleks or make them less powerful, talks of a war that is going badly with the Daleks. So they did try to stop the war but the 4th dr overcome with emotions decides not to kill them. So the death of the Time Lords of their being frozen for all time really is the Dr's fault. But never let it be said that some cleaver future writers can't think of a way. Never say never. lol
friedasmith 8 months ago
ARGH! what was that bell/ticking music at the end?! i must know ive heard it before! PLEASE someone TELL ME!
Falcor43 8 months ago
@Falcor43 I'd tell you but i do not know i think i have heard it too lol i can what for the new episode
creepydollgirl 8 months ago
still a lot of unanswered questions
pedro27mumble 8 months ago
@pedro27mumble I know! Shame we have to wait another 3 months :|
911chez 8 months ago
stopped paying attention to those idiots a long time ago. If some networks hadn't ignored their test audience in some instances, some of the most popular tv shows in U.S history would not have been picked up. So most of us don't pay any attention to them. Most of the dr who test audiences are die hard dr who fans. so they are more easily impressed then just an average group of people.
friedasmith 8 months ago
@JustinBeiberFan132 Thx. And don't feel bad about crying at the end. I cried and started pacing in the living room trying to let it make sence...
gigglefruit22 8 months ago
Oh and by the way guys, I hate to burst your bubbles. But if you just look up this episode in Wikipedia it will give you the entire plot, right down to the name of the baby.
narusteph 8 months ago
The child is half Time-Lord, except all the time lords are dead. So either there is a stray time lord out there who happens to have slept with Amy, or she slept with the Doctor and gave birth to River Song, who is the Doctor's love interest...... (WTF?)
Or Rory is a ninja and a Time Lord, which is why they keep trying to kill him every episode but he never dies. Because Rory is a BAMF.
narusteph 8 months ago 2
@narusteph You don't have to be born from a time lord to become one. The time lords themselves got their abilities from being exposed to things like rifts.
demiser21 8 months ago
what did the doctor to to amy? sorry ive missed alot of episodes
TheCynthiasramos 8 months ago
@TheCynthiasramos Then it would be better to catch up than to have someone spoil a bunch of episodes for you. I recommend catching up. This season is amazing so far.
mowingthefrontlawn 8 months ago
I hate to break your bubble, but the episode was shit. They've made the finales too big in past years they've tried to make it better but just failed. It went downhill after Russell T Davies left.
ToXiCLTdNM 8 months ago
@ToXiCLTdNM We all have different opinions but im completely against you. That was purely epic. Steven Moffat is such a better writer than RTD, its the best series by far. Okay so the pandorica was a bit on the crap side, but the only really good series of doctor who so far (and i mean epic) is series 2 and series 6. Im not saying your wrong, its interesting seeing different opinions ach, but its more gripping than ever before :D
911chez 8 months ago
Whats the thoughts River actually kills Rory?
Hawandy456 8 months ago
@Hawandy456
dm how many times has rory die
vbhalo 8 months ago
@Hawandy456 I have a theory that it will be Rory, not the Doctor, that River kills.
LittleChocolateChip 8 months ago
@LittleChocolateChip same. Because at the start of a good man goes to war, amy says he's a good man. I also think Lorna Bucket is River/Melody.
Hawandy456 8 months ago
@Hawandy456 That girl who died? Hmm. But it couldn't be, could it? Because she was younger than River is - and River dies/died in Silence In The Library - so that doesn't work out, does it? And if River can regenerate (which she might be able to) then Lorna would have regenerated then and there. Agreed. There are so many hints that it's going to be Rory - what Amy says, Rory going into battle (going into war) and River's reaction to him in the storm cage. I really think it will be.
LittleChocolateChip 8 months ago
@Hawandy456 oooh, unless of course the Doctor had not meant Lorna in his timeline yet (which is why he wouldn't remember her) and she was a later regenerated form of River? That could be plausible :)
LittleChocolateChip 8 months ago
@LittleChocolateChip i thought that. But he does say that he met her in the ep. But it could happen in a flashback. or its River's birthday with the two doctors.
Hawandy456 8 months ago
Moffat just fucked lady continuity in the A**! River told the tenth doctor that he appeared in "new" not "another" suit and hair meaning there must be a 12 incarnation of the doctor that took her to the singing towers , BUT it couldn't have been because River killed the doctor on the beach in the suit in his 11 incarnation => PARADOX
Thorrr333 8 months ago
@Thorrr333 Do you really think the Doctor will die just like that? River has indeed met the Twelfth Doctor, so we know the Doctor will live on. He'll either come back from the dead, or he'll find a way to die and live on at the same time.
mowingthefrontlawn 8 months ago
@Thorrr333 River said that was the last time before the libary since River saw the Doctor, and seeing as though their relationship works backwords it is likely that the 10th Doctor himself could have been there. Which would make sense seeing as though the Sonic Screwdriver he gives her is a similar design to the one the 9/10th Doctors used. So we will have to put this down as another scene we won't see on screen, which could have took place after Series 4.
Not the first time, won't be the last
RYCloud92 8 months ago
i have just thought of somthing really mad and crazy
but in the episode "almost people" amy tells what she thinks
is the flesh doctor that she has seen him die but later on we
find out they swaped shoes so that doctor was the original...
THE DOCTOR KNOWS AMY SEEN HIM DIE :O
SpawnAsSpy 8 months ago
@SpawnAsSpy Which makes sense considering the Doctor had to eventually learn he was dying then and there in order to plan it to begin with.
Nemle22 8 months ago
@Nemle22 im sure he will find a way back to are screens next year... i hope!
SpawnAsSpy 8 months ago
@SpawnAsSpy Well yeah. They'll just use the Doctor at a different time line I'm sure. :P
Nemle22 8 months ago
way too obvious. It was obvious about the blonde child being amy's daughter (duh), but what I did not expect was river song - melody pond!!! hahaha best twist ever though :)
blahrandomnessblah 8 months ago
1:59 - Who is that behind the eye patch lady? :D
Doctorwholover10 8 months ago
wow such a great episode.. kind of predictable with the whole river song-melody pond thing though! lol :) anyway i am content with the way they ended this for now and i'm so excited for the fall episodes! :D
jessdt94 8 months ago
just wondering since the "Naked River" clip wasn't in a previous episode and it wasn't in A Good Man Goes To War, then where is that from? is that from a clip from a episode from the fall?
TopherJ316 8 months ago