Salam brothers and sister,i have read more then half of the comments and sadly it is full of insults to eachother.
31:27 And if all the trees in the earth were pens, and the sea with seven more seas added to it (were ink), the words of Allah would not be exhausted. Surely Allah is Mighty, Wise.
when u copy paste this transliteration, then u r doing the same.. 4 sure u r not muslim.. u must be the ppl of the book, who trying 2 be a smart missionary haha.. just Allah's word, TAKE WHATEVER THE PROPHET GIVES U, so just take it, dont ever question.. cant u understood simple as that.. when u born, do u know ABC by heart.. ABC was created by someone and when u grew up, someone else taught u ABC right?? why dont u learn ABC on ur own.. man this proof is enough 4 filthy missionary like u
What Allah has bestowed on His Apostle (and taken away) from the people of the townships belongs to Allah to His Apostle and to kindred and orphans the needy and the wayfarer; in order that it may not (Merely) make a circuit between the wealth among you. So take what the Apostle assigns to you and deny yourselves that which he withholds from you. And fear Allah; for Allah is strict in Punishment
This Ayah is talking about the wealth being distributed equally
this ayah does not only speak about wealth.. its for all the system of life.. see, u cant able 2 grasp the example of ABC.. tell me, did u learn ABC by heart.. it was created by someone else.. and who taught u how to speak n learn?? tell me u missionary?? obviously someone else taught u right?? u claim 2 be a believer but Allah exposed u.. u r indeed a liar.. tell me how do u make Adhan?? tell me.. repent b4 u ended up in the grave..
enough man.. missionaries are just like a trash.. no matter what u ppl do, u ppl cant deceive others.. dont u read surah al kawthar.. for those who hate Muhammad pbuh, will be cut off in this world and in the hereafter.. about the camel urine, it has been proven scientifically.. so dont try 2 be a dumb.. i think u read Qur'aan with AMERICAN EYES haha.. about innovation, then u dont have knowledge about it.. hadith is not innovation but revelation.. clearly shows u dont even understood Qur'aan
If it's not in the quran you disregard, as the Quran is the FINAL revelation, Allah says the Quran is fully detailed and nothing has been left out of the kitab.....Are you doubting Allah's words????.....just becase bukhari mentions maghreb, you think the Quran is not enough.
Allah mentions everything that you need to know about the prophet and all the prophets, which is sufficent enough for me.
The entire Anti Hadeeth ideology is destroyed with this one verse from the Quran: "16:44. (We sent them) with Clear Signs and Books of dark prophecies; and We have sent down unto thee (also) the Message; that thou mayest explain clearly to men what is sent for them, and that they may give thought."
Now Take evidence from the Qur'an (which you claim to follow so perfectly):He who obeys the Messenger, obeys Allah: But if any turn away, We have not sent thee to watch over their (evil deeds). (The Noble Qur'an 4:80)Your Companion is neither astray nor being misled. Nor does he say (aught) of (his own) Desire. It is no less than inspiration sent down to him."(The Noble Qur'an 53:2-4)
If anyone contends with the Messenger even after guidance has been plainly conveyed to him, and follows a path other than that becoming to men of Faith, We shall leave him in the path he has chosen, and land him in Hell,- what an evil refuge! 004.115
Quran says Follow the Prophet.. That mean every True Muslim must Follow the Quran and the Hadith, and if there are Hadith that sounds weird, then it's of course false.. But 90% of the Hadith are true..
Hadeeth is a revelation from Allah.. so it is 100% true.. sahih hadeeth will never ever contradict the Qur'aan.. so, nobody can say that it will sound weird.. so both Qur'aan & Hadeeth are revelation from Allah..
Salam.. Yes it is true.. The Prophet Mohamed talked to Moses, and first it was 50 prayers, then it became 25, then 10, then 5.. That is showing Allah's mercy on us..
if Allah prescribed 50 daily prayers, that would be a prayer evey 30 minutes approx without eating, sleeping, going to the toilet etc etc. which is impossible.
Then the prayers have come down to 5 daily.
But Allah tells us in the Quran that he has prescribed by NAME 3 daily prayers, which has always been Allah's practice.
And Allah's practice never changes.
Who knows what's better for mankind Allah or man??
Allah has always showed his mercy doesn't need man's view
Salam! No the Quran does not say to pray 3 times, it says to pray around the morning around the afternoon and around the night, but that does not add up to 3, it adds up to 5..
Another Christian pretending to be a Muslim by rejecting the Hadith.. Now we have Dabo, GA937, and many more like you....
As I said stop pretending to be a Muslim you are a Christian or even a Jew.. You don't follow the Prophet, the Quran makes it clear to pray 5 times, it did not say 3 times, none of the prayers is mentioned by "name"...
You are explaning the Quran from your own lies, you don't even know more than the Prophet Mohamed.. He's a prophet and he knows more.. So you are a liar..
062.009 [Clearly there IS a weekly day of congregation, and the prayer IS during the daytime, because it mentions leaving business, and as another Ayah (073.007) confirms that the day time is for business.]
YUSUFALI: O ye who believe! When the call is proclaimed to prayer on Friday (the Day of Assembly), hasten earnestly to the Remembrance of Allah, and leave off business (and traffic): That is best for you if ye but knew!(continue)
PICKTHAL: O ye who believe! When the call is heard for the prayer of the day of congregation, haste unto remembrance of Allah and leave your trading. That is better for you if ye did but know.
SHAKIR: O you who believe! when the call is made for prayer on Friday, then hasten to the remembrance of Allah and leave off trading; that is better for you, if you know.
this is just a beginning of my REFUTATION of ur LIES i'll be waiting for ur reply btw my channel is open for ur comment and dont worry i wont delete or block u from commenting
DUMB DEAF BLIND.. U R A LIAR.. U WILL BE EXPOSED TILL THE END IF U DONT REPENT.. go on missionary.. we will crush ur fake claims.. those 3 verse that u quote, it says about ASKING PERMISSION 2 ENTER.. dont simply blindly say it is about prayer.. do u know becoz of whom that verse revealed and why it is revealed?? so dont try 2 deceive the muslims..
DUMB DEAF BLIND is in the Qur'aan.. see u dont even knew that.. haha.. i answered u about adultery, but ur mind cant able 2 grasp what i said.. dont be a hypocrite.. Allah says, those who oppose Allah & His Messenger, kill them, cruxify them, desert them, chase them away.. this is Qur'aan and we have the best example.. so dont be like a christian who quote something from the bible and say with their own desire.. SHOW ME A SINGLE VERSE in the Qur'aan that says OBEY MOTHER & FATHER.. go on :-)
"Qur'aan is unique.. it also, forgives those who commit errors.. what u gonna say about that.. sometimes need 2 be harsh and sometimes forgive them.. muslims that commit crime"........ LOL
What a crap answer, I thought you could do better than that but clearly I was wrong
if u dont know, ask those who knew.. thats true.. a muslim, even if they commit crime, will be punished in the hellfire till their punishment is end and then enter paradise but 4 the HYPOCRITES AND DISBELIEVERS, they will be PERMANENTLY IN THE HELLFIRE.. check ur status now.. which group do u belong.. ur heart wont lie but ur filthy desire will lie.. and u never answer my question.. A SINGLE VERSE THAT SAYS, OBEY MOTHER & FATHER?? bring it on missionary.. u will never ever be successful
" a muslim, even if they commit crime, will be punished in the hellfire till their punishment is end and then enter paradise".......
Surah 2, Al-Baqara Ayah 80
And they say: "The fire shall not touch us but for a few numbered days"; Say: "Have ye taken a promise from Allah for He never breaks His promise? Or is it that ye say of Allah what ye do not know?"
U WILL BE EXPOSED MISSIONARY.. READ THE VERSE B4 AND AFTER.. GREAT LOSER & MISER
[002.078] And there are among them (Jews) unlettered people, who know not the Book, but they trust upon false desires and they but guess.
[002.079] Then woe to those who write the book with their own hands and then say, "This is from Allâh," to purchase with it a little price! Woe to them for what their hands have written and woe to them for that they earn (thereby).
this is not bible brother.. u will never be successful.. coz missionaries like u, they always say, we ONLY FOLLOW QUR'AN, so thats y i am asking, show me a single verse that says, OBEY MOTHER & FATHER.. u will not find it right coz Allah only say OBEY UR PARENTS.. so how 2 obey them?? refer 2 Prophet pbuh.. he will tell u how to obey ur mother and father.. without sunnah, u will be in hellfire coz u r rejecting prophe pbuh man.. wake up missionaries
[002.080] And they (Jews) say, "The Fire (i.e. Hell-fire on the Day of Resurrection) shall not touch us but for a few numbered days." Say (O Muhammad [sal-Allâhu 'alayhi wa sallam] to them): "Have you taken a covenant from Allâh, so that Allâh will not break His Covenant? Or is it that you say of Allâh what you know not?"
TAKE WHATEVER THE PROPHET GIVES U & ABSTAIN WHATEVER HE TOLD U.. that is called SUNNAH.. see, U R EXPOSED MAN.. now u bring transliteration, haha u just deceiving others
You cannot even understand the above Ayah,(reason for transliteration) but that didn't help you.
And then you take a part of a qoute from Surah 59, Al-Hashr Ayah 7, to suit your sickness and to decieve others by not showing the Ayah and then saying it is called SUNNAH.
SUNNAH IS AN ARABIC WORD.
clearly mentioned in the Quran.
So I asked You where does it Say "sunnah of the prophet" in the Quran??...and you reply with Surah 59, Al-Hashr Ayah 7. .GET REAL!!
it proves that u never read the seerah.. go and learn it first, and then come talk over here.. so now u r saying only 3 daily prayer.. woe to every missionaries.. they will perished..
Qur'aan is unique.. it also, forgives those who commit errors.. what u gonna say about that.. sometimes need 2 be harsh and sometimes forgive them.. muslims that commit crime, will enter hellfire and then transferred to paradise.. if u want 2 learn, u will be able 2 see the truth.. otherwise, if u wanna use the Qur'aan to attack hadeeth or others, guess what, it is an action of kufr.. perhaps u should listen what Umar Al-Khattab says about this type of ppl..
No the Hadith is not the word of Allah. The Quran is.. The Hadith is the Word of the Prophet.. But many Muslim lies about the Hadith they say it's the Word of Men against the Prophet, but not all there are 6 authentic books, and I believe those ones, and any other Hadith that does not contradict the Quran.. Salam..
This is another verse which confrim the true shahada:
3:84: Say: "We believe in Allah, and in what has been revealed to us and what was revealed to Abraham, Isma'il, Isaac, Jacob, and the Tribes, and in (the Books) given to Moses, Jesus, and the prophets, from their Lord: We make no distinction between one and another among them, and to Allah do we bow our will (in Islam)."
O Prophet! Truly We have sent you a witness, a bearer of glad tidings, and a warner, as one inviting to God with his permission and as a light-giving torch (33:45-46). We have truly sent you as a witness, as a bearer of glad tidings, and as a warner. That you (O human beings) may believe in God and his Messenger and may aid him and revere him, and celebrate his praise morning and evening (48:8-9).
Here there is an emphasis on our beloved prophet alone
I also believe in these verses. I obey and believe in all the verses of the Quran. As long you'll quote me only verses of the Quran I could only agree with you
no these verses are not pointless because they have permitted to the prophet to be obeyed by any true muslim during this period. The whole Sunnah is contained in the Quran. I obey Allah and the Quran and Muhammad obeyed Allah and the Quran and his companions obeyed Allah and the Quran, but they had the privilege to get their answers from the prophet when they don't understand a verse
Not only did they have the privilege, we also have the privilege to examine what our beloved prophet did in his life, how he performed prayer, what he recited, what he commanded, what he clarified etc
The verse is pointless if you reject the prophetic tradition because it serves no purpose other then to create frustration. Every verse is productive and verse 4:59 is to be implemented even today with aid of the preserved hadith.
18:110: Say: "I am but a man like yourselves, (but) the inspiration has come to me, that your Allah is one Allah: whoever expects to meet his Lord, let him work righteousness, and, in the worship of his Lord, admit no one as partner.
Another verse tells the believers: do not put yourselves forward in the presence of God and his messenger ... lift not your voices above the voice of the Prophet nor shout when speaking to him as you shout one to another, lest your deeds come to nothing while you perceive it not (49:2). Even more, the Qur'an says that the Prophet is to be preferred by the believers over themselves and his wives are like their mothers (33:6)
How is that achievable if you don't know any about him?
Hoy can I lift my voice above the voice of the Prophet today, he is dead. If I have to choose among my wife and the prophet I would choose the prophet, but this choice does not exist anymore. The prophet is gone and my goal is to obey Allah and to meet him in the paradise
It seems you have consciously negated the prophet and his wisdom from your mind. Brother always remember that the Prophetic teachings were always preserved by his sincere companions and as such we must be grateful to those scholars who dedicated their entire lives into venturing in the path of Allah only to compile and gather the sayings of the prophet. Today we are grateful for their contribution and for the Mercy of Allah.
The wisedom is the ability to do the right choice and to adop the right behaviour in any specific situations. I know many hadiths illustrates the great wisedom and knowledge of the prophet, but their context cannot be reproduced in our daily life. We can inspire ourselves from his wisedom but we cannot simply copy it. No need for more debate on that point, you know my view and I know yours. I see you are sincere and I hope you think the same. Let just both pray for the guidance of Allah
The prayer is not told by the hadiths but by the sirah, otherwise quote me a hadiths which details the Salat. Anyway, I do the Salat just like you do because it's fully compliant with all the verses which deal with Salat. Otherwise, why I'll keep on reading the hadiths whereas since Allah guided me I find more answers than I can expect directly from the Quran. All that I want is to obey Allah even if my method does not please to some people
My goal is not to reject all the sunnah teachings. I have been teached for 26 years the sunni islam. When Allah guided me last year, I've read again the Quran and I have corrected the mistakes I've found. I get so much knowledge and wisedom in the Quran directly, I cannot reject the guidance of Allah, sorry Bro. If you live with me you'll see I obey Allah as strong as I can, so I don't see what's my crime
to meet Allah in paradise, one need 2 acknowledge His Messengers.. a person who were teach the sunnah, will never reject it if they are sincere.. i knew alot of deviant websites, anti-islamic websites, n etc but i knew which is truth n falsehood.. there is no contradiction between hadeeth n Qur'aan coz both is from Allah, a revelation.. the prophet is gone but his teachings, his sunnah is still alive till the establishment of Hour..
Allah ordered to obey him, to worship him and to obey his Quran that's the only 100% sure words of Allah. You cannot say that the hadiths are the words of Allah, only the Quran is. You cannot put the hadiths and the Quran at the same level. The Quran is the source of our guidance and as it's easy to be understood it's normal I rely directly on it. Allah opened my brain and he can do the same for anyone who want just to obey Allah and not just to follow leaders supposed to be close to Allah
thats correct, Allah ordered us to obey Him and also, His Messengers.. hadeeth are the words of Allah but u keep on denying.. why then Allah send His Messengers to explain the Qur'aan.. to preach the Qur'aan is one thing and to explain Qur'aan is another thing.. both are not same.. surprise is on the way.. surely hypocrite will be exposed 2 the end.. u lied when u said, "Allah opened ur brain", show me the proof?? u r lucky coz my internet connection has problem.. otherwise i will crush ur claim
u know bro something i found funny about these hadith rejecter is that they rather believe fabricated hadith that is insulting ISLAM AND PROPHET MUHAMMAD(pbuh) than the one that is logical and does not contradict the QURAN
i knew that.. they are missionaries trying 2 destroy the aqeedah of muslims and trying 2 destroy Islam silently but they will never ever be successful.. the word "message" in the Qur'aan, they translate it to "hadeeth".. haha.. even when Allah says idle talk, music etc, they refer that as "hadeeth".. they are the losers.. i have surprise 4 all of u.. internet has problem, cant access for 2 days.. soon i will share that with all of u.. subscribe 2 my channel akhi.. may Allah bless us "MUSLIMS"
thats correct, Allah ordered us to obey Him and also, His Messengers.. hadeeth are the words of Allah but u keep on denying.. why then Allah send His Messengers to explain the Qur'aan.. to preach the Qur'aan is one thing and to explain Qur'aan is another thing.. both are not same.. surprise is on the way.. surely hypocrite will be exposed 2 the end.. u lied when u said, "Allah opened ur brain", show me the proof?? u r lucky coz my internet connection has problem.. otherwise i will crush ur claim
f I use a parable, The Quran is the theorems and the hadiths are a set of bad and good examples of these theorems. It's the same difference between the people who learn by heart things without getting their true sens and the people who try first to understand the key principles and to guess the answers they want by applying these general rules.
Completely wrong and nonsensical. You avoid considering the esteemed people who were the authors of the transmissions. These were the noble trusted companions of our beloved prophet who transmitted what they witnessed. Harmonious testimonies (attestations) account for consistency and reliability. The Companions did not innovate theories, they simply narrated what they were taught by the Prophet and transmitted it unto others for preservation.
Why do you want to relate your fate to the companions of the prophet? They had done their duty and they had gone. Don't you believe in Allah when he says he can give the knowledge to whomever he wants? Are we supposed to depend on the companions of the prophets and their hadiths whereas we have the Quran? It's crazy to see how you are attached to people who cannot save you. Even the prophet cannot save anyone. The only thing which can save you is the the Quran and Allah .
Extracting knowledge is not an easy process yet Allah has chosen people amongst every community to warn and remind people. Scholars who dedicate their lives to Islam are the preserves of Deen including Etiquettes and Mannerisms of the prophet which are derived from the Sunnah of our beloved prophet. Our primary source is extracted from the Both the Qur'an and the prophet. This is not a separate theology, it is a distinction which Allah himself made for clarity and practicality.
Do you think scholars and religious leaders are more intelligent than anyone, that they are more close to Allah than anyone. I am a simple believer and I dedicate my life to God, I don't see what can prevent me from reading the Quran myself and obyeing myself.
I did not say that, I was referring to knowledge and not sincerity. Knowledge without sincerity is worthless. True sincerity from the heart is not achievable when you are in a state of doubt without Knowledge. If you are sincere then wouldn't you further your studies? Wouldn't you investigate out of love for Allah and his Prophet? This is why I say that, to be a scholar is a strong sign of dedication and dedication translates as love and sincerity.
I am sincere and you seem to be. That's why when I was deeply thinking about how to obey Allah more and more, Allah guided me to the Quran. All the results of my search are to be first of all applied on myself and not just as an amount of knowledge. I cannot be wrong as the more I get close to Allah the more I get close to the Quran. I cannot deny the guidance of God otherwise I would be bad. I am sure if you are sincere God will guide you directly and will confirm your faith and your heart
why don't we just speak peacefully? I am not attacking you. You have the right to have you opinion and I have the right to have mine. In which tongue shall I speak to convince you I am sincere and I want just the approval of Allah. Anyway that's not my goal, Allah knows what is inside my heart.
peaceful among the believers and harsh among the disbelievers.. how come u read the Qur'aan and then dont want 2 believe in hadeeth.. the missionary, they claim to be sunni n then suddenly dont wanna believe in hadeeth.. i have seen many missionaries in my life but they knew only 2 lie and deceive other ppl.. 2 all the missionaries, i have a surprise.. when the times come, i will show..
First of all how dare you treat me as a disbeliever? I believe deeply in God and in his Quran, in his angels, in all his prophets and in all his previous books. Is it a crime to accept Allah's book and to reject the human books? Even if I was wrong that don't make me a disbeliever. So brother please don't exceed the limits that's better for all. You don't share my views, I don't share yours, where is the problem? IF you are sure you are right the future will brings us the answer about that.
According to the Quran, a true muslim shall never treat as a Kaffir someone who says "La illaha illa Allah". You believe the fuqaha and the ijma or the words of Allah?
you are a bit boring, always repeating the same stuff. You can repeat it until the end of your life, that would not save you. Get rid off the hatred inside your heart, that's better for you.
"I believe in no God except Allah, I believe in all the prophets of Allah without making a difference between any of them, I believe in the angels and the books of Allah " that's my Shahada and for the short version: "I believe in no God except Allah", because it's the most important part of the shahada
As Muslims we are devoted to Allah, and to love Allah necessitates love of his final messenger. How else can we reach Allah within our individual means and fulfil his commandmentss if we are not to observe and look towards the prophet and his companions?!! As I said before, a person who is devoted out of love will be inquisitive and look towards the best possible source for information.
For Muslims that source is the Prophet who loved Allah more then anyone else!
Allah orders us to love all his prophets without any preference, so I love equally all his prophets and I am not just focusing on Muhammad. Inshaallah, Allah will guide the good people, keep on searching, you'll find the truth by your own and you will be convinced by it. I know my arguments are not here to convince anyone, just to make them ask questions inside themselves. Eahc one have to find the same absolute truth by his own way and thanks to his efforts. Peace on you
Most of my response was directed at the other users and not particularly at you. There was heated exchange of comments for the past several weeks on this video. It seems the entire bulk from the "Submitters" group have arranged some sort of attack on the Ahl Sunnah...
I am not a "submitter" and I am not doing this to bother you. I used to be a sunni muslim until last year and all I want is to show the truth to my brothers. That's normal the first persons you want to help when you reach a truth are your closest ones. As I am arabic and muslims, that 's normal I try to help the muslims. Why are you so afraid about what I say? Have I commanded you to disobey Allah? The only thing I was always repeating is to submit only to Allah and to turn towards the Quran.
1:286 The prophet believes in what has been revealed to him from his Lord, and (so do) the believers; they all believe in Allah and His angels and His books and His apostles; We make no difference between any of His prophets; and they say: We hear and obey, our Lord! Thy forgiveness (do we crave), and to Thee is the eventual course.
you are really limited, this verse contain the true shahada but I will translate it for you as you don't even see it from this verse:
"I believe in no God except Allah, I believe in all the prophets of Allah without making a difference between any of them, I believe in the angels and the books of Allah "
i want you to say it not give me the verse where it is from coz i jolly well know you take it out of context by overlooking the verse b4 and after that verse
2:285 "The prophet believes in what has been revealed to him from his Lord, and (so do) the believers; they all believe in Allah and His angels and His books and His prophets; We make no difference between any of His prophets; and they say: We hear and obey, our Lord! Thy forgiveness (do we crave), and to Thee is the eventual course. "
You are a kafir if you insist on rejecting the Hadith.
"The vanguard (of Islam)- the first of those who forsook (their homes) and of those who gave them aid, and (also) those who follow them in (all) good deeds,- well- pleased is God with them, as are they with Him: for them hath He prepared gardens under which rivers flow, to dwell therein for ever: that is the supreme felicity."
A kafir in the broad sense is a person who does not qualify as being a Muslim. And being Muslims entails you take what the Prophet provided. And to take what the Prophet provided is to acknowledge his tradition, and to acknowledge his tradition is an objective stipulated in the Qur'an by Allah:
"When it is said to them: "Come to what God hath revealed, and to the Apostle": Thou seest the Hypocrites avert their faces from thee in disgust." Surah 4:61
I am arabic and I know kafir means someone who disbelieve in Allah. The proof is Allah calls "ahl al kitab" (people of the book) the christians and the jewish and not kaffir. Christians and jewish are not muslims and are not called Kaffir in the Quran.
Kafir or kuffar which generally means "infidel", "rejecter" or "ingrate". The definition can vary depending on the situation. The literal meaning of term is to "cover", "deny" or "hide " from the truth....
I can apply the same term on the Hadith rejecters who do not acknowledge the prophetic tradition
I am kafir of some of the hadiths (the bad ones) and I am not kafir of Allah or his Quran. The hadiths for me are only a confirmation of the Quran but not a teaching. Like the science is a confirmation and not a teaching, like the history is a confirmation and not a teaching. Now brother, do your way I'll do mine and Allah judge us and not each others.
hey hypocrite you been expose the moment you post that arabic verse i know it is not from surah 1 and u said u are an arab keep on talking Almahdime1 coz the more you post comment the more you expose urself as a liar and a hypocrite btw come to my stream when u get online my arabic speaking fren wanna have a LIVE chat with you in ARABIC
since when first surah has 286 verse.. U R EXPOSED.. u will be humiliated till the end.. even a small child knew first surah has only 7 verse.. hahahaha.. why are u doing this.. why not accept Islam with sincere.. money will get u nothing..
No, You are completely wrong. I posted several Hadith narrating in precise detail what the companions recalled during prayer including the recital of Durood, Salawat, Tashahhud, Takbir, Al Fatiha with complimentary recitals of Ayah proceeding it in moderation and also the moderate duration of each stance in Salah during a congregation....Much much more
Satan has won in convincing sunni's of this evil innovation (paying zakat once a year), and this video shows just how much of a "scholar" (of bullshit) this guy is, having dwelled in books of bullshit and not studying the Quran carefully, the book that calls itself fully detailed and actually happens to give the details of the salat and the zakat. It's only in the hadith books that you will find statements condemning people who follow the Quran. They are the books of Satan.
You are right on all the line. The scholars say that nobody can understand the Quran by himself, so the most of the people read it and interpret it according to the hadiths instead of simply take their teachings from what they read and understand from the Quran. The Quran is clear about everything and it provides to each one who follow it directly to recognize by himself the right from the wrong.
In addition, zakat is the obligatory charity set as 2.5% of the net income, paid year around whenever the person receives an income. It is described in the Quran as a known and obligatory portion of the income. God will not call it known if it was not.
The sunni innovation is to pay this once a year, when the Quran makes it clear that on the day of your crop's harvest, you are to give the zakat. That would include paychecks. The poor cannot survive on charity given to them once a year.
of course the prayer times are given in the Quran but what about the rakaat and what to say in the prayer is taught by Prophet Muhammad(pbuh) and the Allah commanded to OBEY Prophet Muhammad(pbuh)
You have not answered the challenge, instead you have sighted what everyone already is perfectly aware of. We are asking more detailed questions that can only be found if one acknowledges the Prophetic traditions.
"(During war and emergency) if you (are in a state of) fear, then (perform the 'salat') standing up, (walking), or on horseback. Then, as soon as you have peace, remember Allah in the manner He has taught you which you (previously) did not know." (Surah 2:239)
Allah is telling the people to make remembrance (dhikr) of Him the way He taught them which they did not know before. The knowledge of performing Salat had therefore been preserved via tradition in a form of remembrance by imitation
So surely they must have been taught, but by whom? Well the verse says that Allah had taught them, but how did Allah teach them?
Indeed Allah sent the Messenger as a source of guidance to mankind and hence why the companions imitated the prophet in his prayer. We can only conclude that the method of prayer that we implement today as Muslims came from another source besides the Qur'an and that is the authentic Sunnah of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him)
Yes of course the Qur'an is fully detailed, and that is exactly why Allah himself refers to the prophet as a source of guidance. If our prophet was a teacher then teaching requires implimentation, and to implement requires observance and imitation.
The companions observed, witnessed and then imitated what the prophet advised them to imitate as a means of obeying Allah commands with the upper most confidence.
We are not departing from the Qur'an, rather we are using the Qur'an as our bases.
`Umar ibn Al-Khattab (may Allah be pleased with him) said: Almighty Allah sent Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him) with the truth and revealed unto Him the Quran. Among the revelation (brought by him) was the verse stipulating that married adulterer and adulteress should be stoned to death. We read, comprehended and understood it."
No that is not a direct contradiction, are you even aware of the abrogation that took place?? You see if you do not value the context surrounding the Qur'an which are narrated in the hadith then you would never know such things.
The abrogated verse stated that A married man and woman, if they commit adultery, stone them to death.
Textually this was abrogated but in terms of parcticalyity it was still applicable which is why our prophet stoned people.
Bear in mind that the Sunnah of the Prophet is a part of the Divine Revelation, indicating that many things were revealed to the Prophet either through inspiration or instruction. Which is why Allah makes a distinction in the Qur'an!
Allah tells us in the Qur'an that the Prophet (does not speak out of his own fancy. It is all an inspiration sent down to him.) (An-Najm 53: 3-4) Therefore, what the Prophet teaches us is part of our religion It is not something that he has determined by himself
You know just like me that most of the hadiths are not confirmed by the Quran. Some of them are compliant. This mix creates an unperfection and a mess which cannot be from Allah
I challange all hadithist, to show me the hadith explaning the salat (prayers) step by step, rakat for rakat, What to say and when to say the "magic" words as the Hadithist call it
That is not a challenge that is simple searching. All you have to do is search on Google and you will find the answer. Has that become so difficult for you heretics?
And they are not magic words, we praise Allah in our prayers and we ask for forgiveness. You are sound like a atheist, its no wonder since you have no connection to Islam.
GA937 people in your field like to quote the Bible and at the same time apply double standards. On one hand you accuse most Muslim and Islamic scholars (jurists) of being liars and deceivers for implementing the punishment of stoning YET you conveniently forget to sight Deuteronomy or Leviticus which calls for the death of the two people engaged in sexual relationship whilst the woman in married.
I dont follow the teachings in the bible. Dont make a fitnah akhi, My only source of guidance it the book of Allah, the quran. Not the hadith, not the bible
Now you can see it, just open your eyes. Only hadith and the corrupted bible does teach man to stone people to death. Can you see it ? Then repent brother, hadith is the teachings of satan, he wants you to obey him, and to follow his teachings
hmmm you don't like using the Bible and you don't like the Hadith which perfectly brings me on to the following verse:
Allah warns us not to go against the Prophet (peace be upon him), and states that whoever disobeys him will be doomed to eternal Hell.
Allah says (interpretation of the meaning): ...And let those who oppose the Messengers commandment beware, lest some fitnah (trial, affliction, etc.) befall them or a painful torment be inflicted on them. [24:63]
The hadith is not the teachings of Mohammed (pbuh)
Its the teachings of the jews and iranians, satanic teachings is found in the hadith. You dont obey The prophet but you obey jews and iranians. For this God will punish you. Repent before its too late, and pray, pray for guidance
Now Im not gonna waste my time on people who worship a black rock. Come back when you can take my challange, when you can show me the hadith explaning the salat in detail.
May God guide you to the truth, if you are seeking for it. Peace
Go read, value references you stubborn child. I am guessing you speak Arabic or you know something about Shaykh Al Baanee? He is a authority in Arabia for the Muslims living there....his books are valued.
Or are you scared? And do you know anything about the four schools of thought? Salah is performed with slight variations according to different interpretations of the narratives. I am no Scholar to give you a full depth analysis...
Bring the hadith explaning the salat in detail or keep silent.
I challenge all Hadithist, to show me the hadith explaning the salat in detail. You can bring all your shejks, mullahs, teachers, to show me the hadith explaning the salat in detail. This challenge have been here since the hadithist started their religion, and nobody have been able to show the hadith explaning the salat in detail.
can we grow finger nails long like X-MEN?? can we keep long hair like a women?? can we wear womens cloth?? can we eat donkey, snakes, tiger, lion, rat etc?? can ur father marry another guy's father?? if a baby urine on our clothes, can we pray in that?? what do we say during sujood?? what do we say during tasleem?? how to bury u or ur father if already dead?? for how long a baby can drink the mothers milk?? is it till the baby grows and become an old man?? u r exposed missionary..
GA937 We know how to pray BECAUSE of the sunnah which we extract from the prophetic tradition.
I am currently looking at over 40 hadith from Sahih Muslim which explains the Salah from Takbeer (raising the hands) to Tashahud position ALL fully detailed. lol
The question of Salah has always been a problem with the Prophet (hadith) rejecters like you. ^_^
All you have to do is type in Kitab al Salat book number 4, which is a compilation of Sahih (authentic) hadith narrating by Muslim on the topic of the Salat procedure!
Firstly Chapter 7 talks of raising the hands opposite to the shoulders at the beginning of the prayer (and at the time of bowing and when returning to the erect position after the first bow)
Book 4, Number 0758, 0759, 0760, 0761, 0762, 0763.
These are only from Sahih Muslim, there are numerous more from other collections.
Chapter 8 follows on from chapter 7 and focuses on the recital of the Takbir (proclamation) at the time of bowing and rising in prayer with the exception of rising in Ruku where you say: "Allah listened (listens) to him (those) who praises him"
Book 4, Number 0764, 0765, 0766,0767, 0768, 0769 and 0770.
Let me stress, these are only a few narratives compiled in his book...there are many more with more details.
SubhanAllah...
justrational1400 1 year ago
Salam brothers and sister,i have read more then half of the comments and sadly it is full of insults to eachother.
31:27 And if all the trees in the earth were pens, and the sea with seven more seas added to it (were ink), the words of Allah would not be exhausted. Surely Allah is Mighty, Wise.
EliteSwordsman25 2 years ago 8
Al-Baqara Ayah 78-80
cont.......ittakhadhtum cinda 'allaah cahd(an) fa- lan yukhlif 'allaah cahd -hu 'am taqolon calaa 'allaah maa laa taclamon
Beautiful no distortion, no commentary, no opinions and no Bukhari influence, JUST ALLAHS WORDS
BRING IT ON!!!
raj7171 2 years ago 4
when u copy paste this transliteration, then u r doing the same.. 4 sure u r not muslim.. u must be the ppl of the book, who trying 2 be a smart missionary haha.. just Allah's word, TAKE WHATEVER THE PROPHET GIVES U, so just take it, dont ever question.. cant u understood simple as that.. when u born, do u know ABC by heart.. ABC was created by someone and when u grew up, someone else taught u ABC right?? why dont u learn ABC on ur own.. man this proof is enough 4 filthy missionary like u
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
Surah 59, Al-Hashr Ayah 7
What Allah has bestowed on His Apostle (and taken away) from the people of the townships belongs to Allah to His Apostle and to kindred and orphans the needy and the wayfarer; in order that it may not (Merely) make a circuit between the wealth among you. So take what the Apostle assigns to you and deny yourselves that which he withholds from you. And fear Allah; for Allah is strict in Punishment
This Ayah is talking about the wealth being distributed equally
raj7171 2 years ago
this ayah does not only speak about wealth.. its for all the system of life.. see, u cant able 2 grasp the example of ABC.. tell me, did u learn ABC by heart.. it was created by someone else.. and who taught u how to speak n learn?? tell me u missionary?? obviously someone else taught u right?? u claim 2 be a believer but Allah exposed u.. u r indeed a liar.. tell me how do u make Adhan?? tell me.. repent b4 u ended up in the grave..
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
DefenderOfSunnah
You clearly believe in idle tales, did you verify what I said about raj7171...NO.
ABC, is that the best you can do???......what a joke. Clearly you cannot even understand 59:7.
And you say you embarresed raj7171, when you clearly believe in crap, which is an amusement for you ears, a personal gain.
If it's not in the Quran, its innovation, i.e hadith
You guys are SICK.
Enjoy your camel urine U Deciever
onemuslima 2 years ago
enough man.. missionaries are just like a trash.. no matter what u ppl do, u ppl cant deceive others.. dont u read surah al kawthar.. for those who hate Muhammad pbuh, will be cut off in this world and in the hereafter.. about the camel urine, it has been proven scientifically.. so dont try 2 be a dumb.. i think u read Qur'aan with AMERICAN EYES haha.. about innovation, then u dont have knowledge about it.. hadith is not innovation but revelation.. clearly shows u dont even understood Qur'aan
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
Can u tell me how many Rakahs do u pray in Maghreb?
Who was the person with the Prophet in the cave?
Who was the one whom the Prophet frowned at according to Surah Abasa?
saladinswarrior 2 years ago
saladinswarrior
If it's not in the quran you disregard, as the Quran is the FINAL revelation, Allah says the Quran is fully detailed and nothing has been left out of the kitab.....Are you doubting Allah's words????.....just becase bukhari mentions maghreb, you think the Quran is not enough.
Allah mentions everything that you need to know about the prophet and all the prophets, which is sufficent enough for me.
All praises are for Allah alone
onemuslima 2 years ago 6
@saladinswarrior And don't forget that The Prophet did not speak of himself.
MasterNoor 1 year ago
@saladinswarrior Aslamualaykum
We pray 3 rakat fardh and 2 sunnah
The person in the cave with Prophet Muhummad (S.A.W.) was Abu Bak Siddiq (R.A.)
The person who he frowned at was a blind man that came up to him while he was preaching to some of the people of Quraish
hamed24 1 year ago
DefenderOfSunnah LOL
Your ABC example is terrible, go back to school. and try
So did you get a promise from Allah??
or are you just a liar and a filthy Hadith missionary.
So did you get a promise from Allah??........Nah more like from Bukhari!
raj7171 2 years ago 3
The entire Anti Hadeeth ideology is destroyed with this one verse from the Quran: "16:44. (We sent them) with Clear Signs and Books of dark prophecies; and We have sent down unto thee (also) the Message; that thou mayest explain clearly to men what is sent for them, and that they may give thought."
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago 2
Now Take evidence from the Qur'an (which you claim to follow so perfectly):He who obeys the Messenger, obeys Allah: But if any turn away, We have not sent thee to watch over their (evil deeds). (The Noble Qur'an 4:80)Your Companion is neither astray nor being misled. Nor does he say (aught) of (his own) Desire. It is no less than inspiration sent down to him."(The Noble Qur'an 53:2-4)
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago 2
If anyone contends with the Messenger even after guidance has been plainly conveyed to him, and follows a path other than that becoming to men of Faith, We shall leave him in the path he has chosen, and land him in Hell,- what an evil refuge! 004.115
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago 2
Surah 2, Al-Baqara Ayah 78-80
wa- min -hum 'ummeyon laa yaclamon al- kitaab 'illaa amaaniya wa- 'in hum 'illaa yaz.unnon fa- wayl li- 'alladhena yaktubon al- kitaab bi- ayde -him thumma yaqolon haadhaa min cindi 'allaah li- yashtaro bi- -hi thaman(an) qalel(an) fa- wayl la- -hum min maa katabat ayde -him wa- wayl la- -hum min maa yaksibon
wa- qaalo lan tamass -naa an- naar 'illaa ayyaam(an) macdodah qul 'a- ......cont
raj7171 2 years ago
Quran says Follow the Prophet.. That mean every True Muslim must Follow the Quran and the Hadith, and if there are Hadith that sounds weird, then it's of course false.. But 90% of the Hadith are true..
ThaiboxerAikido 2 years ago
Hadeeth is a revelation from Allah.. so it is 100% true.. sahih hadeeth will never ever contradict the Qur'aan.. so, nobody can say that it will sound weird.. so both Qur'aan & Hadeeth are revelation from Allah..
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
Yes, but the Hadith is not the Word of God.. It's the Word of the Prophet.. That is also revelation from God to him..
ThaiboxerAikido 2 years ago
ThaiboxerAikido
Is it true that there were 50 daily prayers prescribed by Allah??????........and then Prophet bought them down to 5 to make it easier for mankind???
raj7171 2 years ago
Salam.. Yes it is true.. The Prophet Mohamed talked to Moses, and first it was 50 prayers, then it became 25, then 10, then 5.. That is showing Allah's mercy on us..
ThaiboxerAikido 2 years ago
ThaiboxerAikido
Salaam,
if Allah prescribed 50 daily prayers, that would be a prayer evey 30 minutes approx without eating, sleeping, going to the toilet etc etc. which is impossible.
Then the prayers have come down to 5 daily.
But Allah tells us in the Quran that he has prescribed by NAME 3 daily prayers, which has always been Allah's practice.
And Allah's practice never changes.
Who knows what's better for mankind Allah or man??
Allah has always showed his mercy doesn't need man's view
raj7171 2 years ago
Salam! No the Quran does not say to pray 3 times, it says to pray around the morning around the afternoon and around the night, but that does not add up to 3, it adds up to 5..
Another Christian pretending to be a Muslim by rejecting the Hadith.. Now we have Dabo, GA937, and many more like you....
ThaiboxerAikido 2 years ago
Salaam,
The Quran NAMES 3 DAILY SALAH,
1, Salat Al-Fajr (Dawn Prayer)24:58
2, Salat Al-Esha (Night Prayer)24:58
3, Al-Salat Al-Wusta (The Middle Prayer) 2:238. Did Allah forget to mention the others by name??.... remember I said "BY NAME" "not by around".
Any logical person will tell you that the 50 daily salah tale is BULL!
Obviously your not a muslim, U Believe that Allah needs a MAN to negociate the prayers. THAT IS A SIN!
A muslim would have just stuck to the facts of the debate
raj7171 2 years ago
As I said stop pretending to be a Muslim you are a Christian or even a Jew.. You don't follow the Prophet, the Quran makes it clear to pray 5 times, it did not say 3 times, none of the prayers is mentioned by "name"...
You are explaning the Quran from your own lies, you don't even know more than the Prophet Mohamed.. He's a prophet and he knows more.. So you are a liar..
ThaiboxerAikido 2 years ago
ThaiboxerAikido
I Have JUST showed you the Ayahs regarding the "3 NAMED SALAH"
(refer to Arabic)....and you call me a LIAR!
There was no Harm for you to check the Ayah's for your own benefit.
NEED I SAY MORE!!!
raj7171 2 years ago
The Middle prayer is the Asr.. There is Dohor before it and Fajr at the dawn, and Meghreb after Asr, and Aishaa at the End..
Salam..
ThaiboxerAikido 2 years ago
030.018 [This Ayah clearly addresses the midday prayers Zuhr and Asr]
YUSUFALI: Yea, to Him be praise, in the heavens and on earth; and in the late afternoon and when the day begins to decline.
PICKTHAL: Unto Him be praise in the heavens and the earth! - and at the sun's decline and in the noonday.
SHAKIR: And to Him belongs praise in the heavens and the earth, and at nightfall and when you are at midday
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago 3
062.009 [Clearly there IS a weekly day of congregation, and the prayer IS during the daytime, because it mentions leaving business, and as another Ayah (073.007) confirms that the day time is for business.]
YUSUFALI: O ye who believe! When the call is proclaimed to prayer on Friday (the Day of Assembly), hasten earnestly to the Remembrance of Allah, and leave off business (and traffic): That is best for you if ye but knew!(continue)
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago 2
PICKTHAL: O ye who believe! When the call is heard for the prayer of the day of congregation, haste unto remembrance of Allah and leave your trading. That is better for you if ye did but know.
SHAKIR: O you who believe! when the call is made for prayer on Friday, then hasten to the remembrance of Allah and leave off trading; that is better for you, if you know.
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago 2
this is just a beginning of my REFUTATION of ur LIES i'll be waiting for ur reply btw my channel is open for ur comment and dont worry i wont delete or block u from commenting
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago
DUMB DEAF BLIND.. U R A LIAR.. U WILL BE EXPOSED TILL THE END IF U DONT REPENT.. go on missionary.. we will crush ur fake claims.. those 3 verse that u quote, it says about ASKING PERMISSION 2 ENTER.. dont simply blindly say it is about prayer.. do u know becoz of whom that verse revealed and why it is revealed?? so dont try 2 deceive the muslims..
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
DefenderOfSunnah
DUMB DEAF BLIND.. .....Don't talk about yourself like that its not nice!!!..........hey who cares.
Stick to facts I asked you about the different laws of adultery..... and not blah blah.
The Ayah mentions the "NAMED SALAHS" (refer to the Arabic)whether asking for permission to enter or not........ and you call me the deceiver,
I can call you plenty of names but not gonna waste my time as only Allah will JUDGE ME
GROW UP!!! and learn how to read.
raj7171 2 years ago
DUMB DEAF BLIND is in the Qur'aan.. see u dont even knew that.. haha.. i answered u about adultery, but ur mind cant able 2 grasp what i said.. dont be a hypocrite.. Allah says, those who oppose Allah & His Messenger, kill them, cruxify them, desert them, chase them away.. this is Qur'aan and we have the best example.. so dont be like a christian who quote something from the bible and say with their own desire.. SHOW ME A SINGLE VERSE in the Qur'aan that says OBEY MOTHER & FATHER.. go on :-)
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
DefenderOfSunnah SAY'S
"Qur'aan is unique.. it also, forgives those who commit errors.. what u gonna say about that.. sometimes need 2 be harsh and sometimes forgive them.. muslims that commit crime"........ LOL
What a crap answer, I thought you could do better than that but clearly I was wrong
VERY GOOD FOR THE VIEWRS
raj7171 2 years ago
if u dont know, ask those who knew.. thats true.. a muslim, even if they commit crime, will be punished in the hellfire till their punishment is end and then enter paradise but 4 the HYPOCRITES AND DISBELIEVERS, they will be PERMANENTLY IN THE HELLFIRE.. check ur status now.. which group do u belong.. ur heart wont lie but ur filthy desire will lie.. and u never answer my question.. A SINGLE VERSE THAT SAYS, OBEY MOTHER & FATHER?? bring it on missionary.. u will never ever be successful
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
DefenderOfSunnah says
" a muslim, even if they commit crime, will be punished in the hellfire till their punishment is end and then enter paradise".......
Surah 2, Al-Baqara Ayah 80
And they say: "The fire shall not touch us but for a few numbered days"; Say: "Have ye taken a promise from Allah for He never breaks His promise? Or is it that ye say of Allah what ye do not know?"
SO DID YOU GET A PROMISE THEN??
OR DID THOSE WHO KNEW??........DID THEY???
raj7171 2 years ago 2
U WILL BE EXPOSED MISSIONARY.. READ THE VERSE B4 AND AFTER.. GREAT LOSER & MISER
[002.078] And there are among them (Jews) unlettered people, who know not the Book, but they trust upon false desires and they but guess.
[002.079] Then woe to those who write the book with their own hands and then say, "This is from Allâh," to purchase with it a little price! Woe to them for what their hands have written and woe to them for that they earn (thereby).
JUST READ THE NEXT VERSE MISSIONARY!!
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
Surah 2, Al-Baqara Ayah 78-80
Yes I have read the verses THANK YOU!!!
Bring it on
This is brilliant stuff for the viewers.
Let them see how deaf dumb and blind you are..WOW
All Praises are For Allah............wow
raj7171 2 years ago 3
DefenderOfSunnah SAY'S
"SHOW ME A SINGLE VERSE in the Qur'aan that says OBEY MOTHER & FATHER.. go on :-) "
TIT FOR TAT EH, TYPICAL
Seems like, you love distorting Allah's words, when you clearly know Allah says be kind to parents
KIND=considerate, friendly, and helpful.
and when talkng about "OBEY"(obey the prophet) is regarding the Quran
"those who oppose Allah & His Messenger, kill them, cruxify them, desert them, chase them away"
THE ABOVE QUOTE REFERS TO PEOPLE LIKE YOU, THANKS!!
raj7171 2 years ago 3
this is not bible brother.. u will never be successful.. coz missionaries like u, they always say, we ONLY FOLLOW QUR'AN, so thats y i am asking, show me a single verse that says, OBEY MOTHER & FATHER.. u will not find it right coz Allah only say OBEY UR PARENTS.. so how 2 obey them?? refer 2 Prophet pbuh.. he will tell u how to obey ur mother and father.. without sunnah, u will be in hellfire coz u r rejecting prophe pbuh man.. wake up missionaries
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
DefenderOfSunnah
Of course its not Bible, You know the Bible is much higher than Books of hadith as it contains Allahs words.
Allah says be "KIND TO YOUR PARENTS" , You use trickery to confuse
When your parents tell you to "sit down", do you need Bukhari to tell you how to do that?? Obviously you do...
You don't even understand when Allah say's "obey" in the Quran
wake up Hadith missionaries!!!
Hadith(sunnah)=HELL
Where in the Quran does it state "sunnah of the Prophet" ???
raj7171 2 years ago 2
[002.080] And they (Jews) say, "The Fire (i.e. Hell-fire on the Day of Resurrection) shall not touch us but for a few numbered days." Say (O Muhammad [sal-Allâhu 'alayhi wa sallam] to them): "Have you taken a covenant from Allâh, so that Allâh will not break His Covenant? Or is it that you say of Allâh what you know not?"
TAKE WHATEVER THE PROPHET GIVES U & ABSTAIN WHATEVER HE TOLD U.. that is called SUNNAH.. see, U R EXPOSED MAN.. now u bring transliteration, haha u just deceiving others
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
Al-Baqara Ayah 78-80
You cannot even understand the above Ayah,(reason for transliteration) but that didn't help you.
And then you take a part of a qoute from Surah 59, Al-Hashr Ayah 7, to suit your sickness and to decieve others by not showing the Ayah and then saying it is called SUNNAH.
SUNNAH IS AN ARABIC WORD.
clearly mentioned in the Quran.
So I asked You where does it Say "sunnah of the prophet" in the Quran??...and you reply with Surah 59, Al-Hashr Ayah 7. .GET REAL!!
raj7171 2 years ago 3
u forgets jinnboy to he is one of them
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago
Lol why do you call him jinnboy?
ThaiboxerAikido 2 years ago
he is a jinn why dont u ask him about the hadith and sunnah ask him does he use IJMA AND QIAS when he use quran translation
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago
Allah yihdee, inchAllah once he will be following the sunnah like a true Muslim..
ThaiboxerAikido 2 years ago
it proves that u never read the seerah.. go and learn it first, and then come talk over here.. so now u r saying only 3 daily prayer.. woe to every missionaries.. they will perished..
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
DefenderOfSunnah
Why is there two different laws on Adultery?
One in the Quran-100 lashes
and the one in the bukharis hadith- stoning to death.????????
raj7171 2 years ago
Qur'aan is unique.. it also, forgives those who commit errors.. what u gonna say about that.. sometimes need 2 be harsh and sometimes forgive them.. muslims that commit crime, will enter hellfire and then transferred to paradise.. if u want 2 learn, u will be able 2 see the truth.. otherwise, if u wanna use the Qur'aan to attack hadeeth or others, guess what, it is an action of kufr.. perhaps u should listen what Umar Al-Khattab says about this type of ppl..
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
No the Hadith is not the word of Allah. The Quran is.. The Hadith is the Word of the Prophet.. But many Muslim lies about the Hadith they say it's the Word of Men against the Prophet, but not all there are 6 authentic books, and I believe those ones, and any other Hadith that does not contradict the Quran.. Salam..
ThaiboxerAikido 2 years ago
This is another verse which confrim the true shahada:
3:84: Say: "We believe in Allah, and in what has been revealed to us and what was revealed to Abraham, Isma'il, Isaac, Jacob, and the Tribes, and in (the Books) given to Moses, Jesus, and the prophets, from their Lord: We make no distinction between one and another among them, and to Allah do we bow our will (in Islam)."
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
O Prophet! Truly We have sent you a witness, a bearer of glad tidings, and a warner, as one inviting to God with his permission and as a light-giving torch (33:45-46). We have truly sent you as a witness, as a bearer of glad tidings, and as a warner. That you (O human beings) may believe in God and his Messenger and may aid him and revere him, and celebrate his praise morning and evening (48:8-9).
Here there is an emphasis on our beloved prophet alone
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
I also believe in these verses. I obey and believe in all the verses of the Quran. As long you'll quote me only verses of the Quran I could only agree with you
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
In that case why don't you act upon the commandment and acknowledge the authentic Tradition of our beloved Prophet and accept the Sunnah?
"But if you have a dispute concerning any matter, refer it to God and his messenger"
Do not passively accept what you can not objectively achieve. Without the Tradition these verses would be pointless.
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
no these verses are not pointless because they have permitted to the prophet to be obeyed by any true muslim during this period. The whole Sunnah is contained in the Quran. I obey Allah and the Quran and Muhammad obeyed Allah and the Quran and his companions obeyed Allah and the Quran, but they had the privilege to get their answers from the prophet when they don't understand a verse
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
Not only did they have the privilege, we also have the privilege to examine what our beloved prophet did in his life, how he performed prayer, what he recited, what he commanded, what he clarified etc
The verse is pointless if you reject the prophetic tradition because it serves no purpose other then to create frustration. Every verse is productive and verse 4:59 is to be implemented even today with aid of the preserved hadith.
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
18:110: Say: "I am but a man like yourselves, (but) the inspiration has come to me, that your Allah is one Allah: whoever expects to meet his Lord, let him work righteousness, and, in the worship of his Lord, admit no one as partner.
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
Another verse tells the believers: do not put yourselves forward in the presence of God and his messenger ... lift not your voices above the voice of the Prophet nor shout when speaking to him as you shout one to another, lest your deeds come to nothing while you perceive it not (49:2). Even more, the Qur'an says that the Prophet is to be preferred by the believers over themselves and his wives are like their mothers (33:6)
How is that achievable if you don't know any about him?
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
Hoy can I lift my voice above the voice of the Prophet today, he is dead. If I have to choose among my wife and the prophet I would choose the prophet, but this choice does not exist anymore. The prophet is gone and my goal is to obey Allah and to meet him in the paradise
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
It seems you have consciously negated the prophet and his wisdom from your mind. Brother always remember that the Prophetic teachings were always preserved by his sincere companions and as such we must be grateful to those scholars who dedicated their entire lives into venturing in the path of Allah only to compile and gather the sayings of the prophet. Today we are grateful for their contribution and for the Mercy of Allah.
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
The wisedom is the ability to do the right choice and to adop the right behaviour in any specific situations. I know many hadiths illustrates the great wisedom and knowledge of the prophet, but their context cannot be reproduced in our daily life. We can inspire ourselves from his wisedom but we cannot simply copy it. No need for more debate on that point, you know my view and I know yours. I see you are sincere and I hope you think the same. Let just both pray for the guidance of Allah
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
The prayer is not told by the hadiths but by the sirah, otherwise quote me a hadiths which details the Salat. Anyway, I do the Salat just like you do because it's fully compliant with all the verses which deal with Salat. Otherwise, why I'll keep on reading the hadiths whereas since Allah guided me I find more answers than I can expect directly from the Quran. All that I want is to obey Allah even if my method does not please to some people
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
I have given detailed references to each individual Sahih hadith which deals with Salah compiled in the Book of "Muslim"
There are many more but if you read them you will notice consistency in the accounts which points to truthfulness.
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
My goal is not to reject all the sunnah teachings. I have been teached for 26 years the sunni islam. When Allah guided me last year, I've read again the Quran and I have corrected the mistakes I've found. I get so much knowledge and wisedom in the Quran directly, I cannot reject the guidance of Allah, sorry Bro. If you live with me you'll see I obey Allah as strong as I can, so I don't see what's my crime
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
to meet Allah in paradise, one need 2 acknowledge His Messengers.. a person who were teach the sunnah, will never reject it if they are sincere.. i knew alot of deviant websites, anti-islamic websites, n etc but i knew which is truth n falsehood.. there is no contradiction between hadeeth n Qur'aan coz both is from Allah, a revelation.. the prophet is gone but his teachings, his sunnah is still alive till the establishment of Hour..
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
Allah ordered to obey him, to worship him and to obey his Quran that's the only 100% sure words of Allah. You cannot say that the hadiths are the words of Allah, only the Quran is. You cannot put the hadiths and the Quran at the same level. The Quran is the source of our guidance and as it's easy to be understood it's normal I rely directly on it. Allah opened my brain and he can do the same for anyone who want just to obey Allah and not just to follow leaders supposed to be close to Allah
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
thats correct, Allah ordered us to obey Him and also, His Messengers.. hadeeth are the words of Allah but u keep on denying.. why then Allah send His Messengers to explain the Qur'aan.. to preach the Qur'aan is one thing and to explain Qur'aan is another thing.. both are not same.. surprise is on the way.. surely hypocrite will be exposed 2 the end.. u lied when u said, "Allah opened ur brain", show me the proof?? u r lucky coz my internet connection has problem.. otherwise i will crush ur claim
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
u know bro something i found funny about these hadith rejecter is that they rather believe fabricated hadith that is insulting ISLAM AND PROPHET MUHAMMAD(pbuh) than the one that is logical and does not contradict the QURAN
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago
i knew that.. they are missionaries trying 2 destroy the aqeedah of muslims and trying 2 destroy Islam silently but they will never ever be successful.. the word "message" in the Qur'aan, they translate it to "hadeeth".. haha.. even when Allah says idle talk, music etc, they refer that as "hadeeth".. they are the losers.. i have surprise 4 all of u.. internet has problem, cant access for 2 days.. soon i will share that with all of u.. subscribe 2 my channel akhi.. may Allah bless us "MUSLIMS"
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
thats correct, Allah ordered us to obey Him and also, His Messengers.. hadeeth are the words of Allah but u keep on denying.. why then Allah send His Messengers to explain the Qur'aan.. to preach the Qur'aan is one thing and to explain Qur'aan is another thing.. both are not same.. surprise is on the way.. surely hypocrite will be exposed 2 the end.. u lied when u said, "Allah opened ur brain", show me the proof?? u r lucky coz my internet connection has problem.. otherwise i will crush ur claim
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
you AlMahdiMe1 said all the hadith are written by the devil is already prove u dont follow the Sunnah teaching
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago
The Salat has been righlty transmitted and the Quran gives many details about how to perfom Salat, but it's spread over many verses.
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
Oh and haha, it true the hadith does not tell you how to pray. It may give some insignificant details, but that's it.
Meteora759 2 years ago
f I use a parable, The Quran is the theorems and the hadiths are a set of bad and good examples of these theorems. It's the same difference between the people who learn by heart things without getting their true sens and the people who try first to understand the key principles and to guess the answers they want by applying these general rules.
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
Completely wrong and nonsensical. You avoid considering the esteemed people who were the authors of the transmissions. These were the noble trusted companions of our beloved prophet who transmitted what they witnessed. Harmonious testimonies (attestations) account for consistency and reliability. The Companions did not innovate theories, they simply narrated what they were taught by the Prophet and transmitted it unto others for preservation.
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
Why do you want to relate your fate to the companions of the prophet? They had done their duty and they had gone. Don't you believe in Allah when he says he can give the knowledge to whomever he wants? Are we supposed to depend on the companions of the prophets and their hadiths whereas we have the Quran? It's crazy to see how you are attached to people who cannot save you. Even the prophet cannot save anyone. The only thing which can save you is the the Quran and Allah .
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
Extracting knowledge is not an easy process yet Allah has chosen people amongst every community to warn and remind people. Scholars who dedicate their lives to Islam are the preserves of Deen including Etiquettes and Mannerisms of the prophet which are derived from the Sunnah of our beloved prophet. Our primary source is extracted from the Both the Qur'an and the prophet. This is not a separate theology, it is a distinction which Allah himself made for clarity and practicality.
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
Do you think scholars and religious leaders are more intelligent than anyone, that they are more close to Allah than anyone. I am a simple believer and I dedicate my life to God, I don't see what can prevent me from reading the Quran myself and obyeing myself.
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
I did not say that, I was referring to knowledge and not sincerity. Knowledge without sincerity is worthless. True sincerity from the heart is not achievable when you are in a state of doubt without Knowledge. If you are sincere then wouldn't you further your studies? Wouldn't you investigate out of love for Allah and his Prophet? This is why I say that, to be a scholar is a strong sign of dedication and dedication translates as love and sincerity.
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
I am sincere and you seem to be. That's why when I was deeply thinking about how to obey Allah more and more, Allah guided me to the Quran. All the results of my search are to be first of all applied on myself and not just as an amount of knowledge. I cannot be wrong as the more I get close to Allah the more I get close to the Quran. I cannot deny the guidance of God otherwise I would be bad. I am sure if you are sincere God will guide you directly and will confirm your faith and your heart
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
InshAllah Allah will guide all those who want the truth, who freedom from their self.
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
Ameen
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
scholars are the heirs of prophet pbuh.. so they knew Allah much more deeper and closer 2 Allah.. u r hypocrite.. u will be defeated and humiliated..
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
why don't we just speak peacefully? I am not attacking you. You have the right to have you opinion and I have the right to have mine. In which tongue shall I speak to convince you I am sincere and I want just the approval of Allah. Anyway that's not my goal, Allah knows what is inside my heart.
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
peaceful among the believers and harsh among the disbelievers.. how come u read the Qur'aan and then dont want 2 believe in hadeeth.. the missionary, they claim to be sunni n then suddenly dont wanna believe in hadeeth.. i have seen many missionaries in my life but they knew only 2 lie and deceive other ppl.. 2 all the missionaries, i have a surprise.. when the times come, i will show..
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
First of all how dare you treat me as a disbeliever? I believe deeply in God and in his Quran, in his angels, in all his prophets and in all his previous books. Is it a crime to accept Allah's book and to reject the human books? Even if I was wrong that don't make me a disbeliever. So brother please don't exceed the limits that's better for all. You don't share my views, I don't share yours, where is the problem? IF you are sure you are right the future will brings us the answer about that.
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
According to the fuqaha and the ijma (Consensus) of Scholars the Hadith rejecters are Kafir.
To transgress Allah's commands and to deny the position of our beloved prophet is sufficient enough for apostasy.
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
According to the Quran, a true muslim shall never treat as a Kaffir someone who says "La illaha illa Allah". You believe the fuqaha and the ijma or the words of Allah?
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
u are a hypocrite and a compulsive liar and i have PROOF of that
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago
you are a bit boring, always repeating the same stuff. You can repeat it until the end of your life, that would not save you. Get rid off the hatred inside your heart, that's better for you.
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
LOL well coz u keep lying and ur hypocrisy is still shining through and you lying and moking Allah words are SURE not gonna save you
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago
where do you live?
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
where i live is none of ur concern
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago
I am ready to meet you personally if you think I am an hypocrite
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
tell me where u live coz i travel a lot who knows i might end up in ur country one of these days
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago
I am in Switzerland between Lausanne and Geneva, you are welcome at any time
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
i keep that btw u still have not say ur shahadah im waiting for it
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago
I've just posted it above
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
my supposed hypocrisy would not save you neither? you have to work on yourself instead of always mocking the others.
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
your hypocrisy will not save me yeah but it will at least SHOW to other people UR TRUE COLOR that is you are nothing but a deceiving hypocrite
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago
you don't even touch me, you can get angry as strong as you want, I have pity for you that's the only feeling I have about you
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
"I believe in no God except Allah, I believe in all the prophets of Allah without making a difference between any of them, I believe in the angels and the books of Allah " that's my Shahada and for the short version: "I believe in no God except Allah", because it's the most important part of the shahada
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
now let see you say the shahadah here
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago
As Muslims we are devoted to Allah, and to love Allah necessitates love of his final messenger. How else can we reach Allah within our individual means and fulfil his commandmentss if we are not to observe and look towards the prophet and his companions?!! As I said before, a person who is devoted out of love will be inquisitive and look towards the best possible source for information.
For Muslims that source is the Prophet who loved Allah more then anyone else!
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
Allah orders us to love all his prophets without any preference, so I love equally all his prophets and I am not just focusing on Muhammad. Inshaallah, Allah will guide the good people, keep on searching, you'll find the truth by your own and you will be convinced by it. I know my arguments are not here to convince anyone, just to make them ask questions inside themselves. Eahc one have to find the same absolute truth by his own way and thanks to his efforts. Peace on you
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
Most of my response was directed at the other users and not particularly at you. There was heated exchange of comments for the past several weeks on this video. It seems the entire bulk from the "Submitters" group have arranged some sort of attack on the Ahl Sunnah...
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
I am not a "submitter" and I am not doing this to bother you. I used to be a sunni muslim until last year and all I want is to show the truth to my brothers. That's normal the first persons you want to help when you reach a truth are your closest ones. As I am arabic and muslims, that 's normal I try to help the muslims. Why are you so afraid about what I say? Have I commanded you to disobey Allah? The only thing I was always repeating is to submit only to Allah and to turn towards the Quran.
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
now AlMahdiMe1 let see you say the Shahadah here
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago
That's the true shahada:
1:286 The prophet believes in what has been revealed to him from his Lord, and (so do) the believers; they all believe in Allah and His angels and His books and His apostles; We make no difference between any of His prophets; and they say: We hear and obey, our Lord! Thy forgiveness (do we crave), and to Thee is the eventual course.
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
do u understand english i ask u to say the shahadah i didnt ask you to give me a verse from the Quran
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago
you are really limited, this verse contain the true shahada but I will translate it for you as you don't even see it from this verse:
"I believe in no God except Allah, I believe in all the prophets of Allah without making a difference between any of them, I believe in the angels and the books of Allah "
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
i want you to say it not give me the verse where it is from coz i jolly well know you take it out of context by overlooking the verse b4 and after that verse
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago
funny aint it surah 1(Al-Fatihah and the Prayer ) only have 7 verse now tell me where u got the other 279 verse
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago 2
آمَنَ الرَّسُولُ بِمَا أُنزِلَ إِلَيْهِ مِن رَّبِّهِ وَالْمُؤْمِنُونَ كُلٌّ آمَنَ بِاللّهِ وَمَلآئِكَتِهِ وَكُتُبِهِ وَرُسُلِهِ لاَ نُفَرِّقُ بَيْنَ أَحَدٍ مِّن رُّسُلِهِ وَقَالُواْ سَمِعْنَا وَأَطَعْنَا غُفْرَانَكَ رَبَّنَا وَإِلَيْكَ الْمَصِيرُ
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
so u confusing surah al fatihah with surah al baqarah huh
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago
:d I've done a copy past from the tool without checking the number of the verse and teh sourate, but I know this verse, it's from the Quran
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
I found it:
2:285 "The prophet believes in what has been revealed to him from his Lord, and (so do) the believers; they all believe in Allah and His angels and His books and His prophets; We make no difference between any of His prophets; and they say: We hear and obey, our Lord! Thy forgiveness (do we crave), and to Thee is the eventual course. "
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
You are a kafir if you insist on rejecting the Hadith.
"The vanguard (of Islam)- the first of those who forsook (their homes) and of those who gave them aid, and (also) those who follow them in (all) good deeds,- well- pleased is God with them, as are they with Him: for them hath He prepared gardens under which rivers flow, to dwell therein for ever: that is the supreme felicity."
The companions were guided and we trust in them
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
a kafir is someone who does not believe in God.
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
A kafir in the broad sense is a person who does not qualify as being a Muslim. And being Muslims entails you take what the Prophet provided. And to take what the Prophet provided is to acknowledge his tradition, and to acknowledge his tradition is an objective stipulated in the Qur'an by Allah:
"When it is said to them: "Come to what God hath revealed, and to the Apostle": Thou seest the Hypocrites avert their faces from thee in disgust." Surah 4:61
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
I am arabic and I know kafir means someone who disbelieve in Allah. The proof is Allah calls "ahl al kitab" (people of the book) the christians and the jewish and not kaffir. Christians and jewish are not muslims and are not called Kaffir in the Quran.
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
Kafir or kuffar which generally means "infidel", "rejecter" or "ingrate". The definition can vary depending on the situation. The literal meaning of term is to "cover", "deny" or "hide " from the truth....
I can apply the same term on the Hadith rejecters who do not acknowledge the prophetic tradition
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
I am kafir of some of the hadiths (the bad ones) and I am not kafir of Allah or his Quran. The hadiths for me are only a confirmation of the Quran but not a teaching. Like the science is a confirmation and not a teaching, like the history is a confirmation and not a teaching. Now brother, do your way I'll do mine and Allah judge us and not each others.
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
hey hypocrite you been expose the moment you post that arabic verse i know it is not from surah 1 and u said u are an arab keep on talking Almahdime1 coz the more you post comment the more you expose urself as a liar and a hypocrite btw come to my stream when u get online my arabic speaking fren wanna have a LIVE chat with you in ARABIC
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago
sorry my soft to do search in the Quran is a bit buggy but I quote you the original verse in arabic, when I'll find its exact position I'll send it
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
since when first surah has 286 verse.. U R EXPOSED.. u will be humiliated till the end.. even a small child knew first surah has only 7 verse.. hahahaha.. why are u doing this.. why not accept Islam with sincere.. money will get u nothing..
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
bro look at his shahadah
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago
No, You are completely wrong. I posted several Hadith narrating in precise detail what the companions recalled during prayer including the recital of Durood, Salawat, Tashahhud, Takbir, Al Fatiha with complimentary recitals of Ayah proceeding it in moderation and also the moderate duration of each stance in Salah during a congregation....Much much more
Go through the comment section
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
Satan has won in convincing sunni's of this evil innovation (paying zakat once a year), and this video shows just how much of a "scholar" (of bullshit) this guy is, having dwelled in books of bullshit and not studying the Quran carefully, the book that calls itself fully detailed and actually happens to give the details of the salat and the zakat. It's only in the hadith books that you will find statements condemning people who follow the Quran. They are the books of Satan.
Meteora759 2 years ago 2
You are right on all the line. The scholars say that nobody can understand the Quran by himself, so the most of the people read it and interpret it according to the hadiths instead of simply take their teachings from what they read and understand from the Quran. The Quran is clear about everything and it provides to each one who follow it directly to recognize by himself the right from the wrong.
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
Well said Meteora759
The Quran's FULLY DETAILED
The Hadith boOks are FULLY BULLSH*T
raj7171 2 years ago 4
In addition, zakat is the obligatory charity set as 2.5% of the net income, paid year around whenever the person receives an income. It is described in the Quran as a known and obligatory portion of the income. God will not call it known if it was not.
The sunni innovation is to pay this once a year, when the Quran makes it clear that on the day of your crop's harvest, you are to give the zakat. That would include paychecks. The poor cannot survive on charity given to them once a year.
Meteora759 2 years ago
God gave us the times for the Salat (contact Prayers) in the Quran :
(1) The Dawn Prayer (Fajr in Arabic) given in 11:114, 24:58
(2) The Noon Prayer (Zuher in Arabic) , given in 17:78 and 30:18
(3) The Afternoon Prayer (Asr in Arabic), given in 2:238
(4) The sunset Prayer (Maghrib in Arabic), given in 11:114
(5) The Night Prayer (Isha in Arabic), given in 24:58
Meteora759 2 years ago
of course the prayer times are given in the Quran but what about the rakaat and what to say in the prayer is taught by Prophet Muhammad(pbuh) and the Allah commanded to OBEY Prophet Muhammad(pbuh)
thetruthprevail99 2 years ago
You have not answered the challenge, instead you have sighted what everyone already is perfectly aware of. We are asking more detailed questions that can only be found if one acknowledges the Prophetic traditions.
Work more harder next time ^_^
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
"(During war and emergency) if you (are in a state of) fear, then (perform the 'salat') standing up, (walking), or on horseback. Then, as soon as you have peace, remember Allah in the manner He has taught you which you (previously) did not know." (Surah 2:239)
Allah is telling the people to make remembrance (dhikr) of Him the way He taught them which they did not know before. The knowledge of performing Salat had therefore been preserved via tradition in a form of remembrance by imitation
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
So surely they must have been taught, but by whom? Well the verse says that Allah had taught them, but how did Allah teach them?
Indeed Allah sent the Messenger as a source of guidance to mankind and hence why the companions imitated the prophet in his prayer. We can only conclude that the method of prayer that we implement today as Muslims came from another source besides the Qur'an and that is the authentic Sunnah of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him)
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
a very simple question: Allah said the Quran is complete fully detailed, do you believe in that or no?
Don't answer me Allah ordered to obey the prophet that's not my question.
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
Yes of course the Qur'an is fully detailed, and that is exactly why Allah himself refers to the prophet as a source of guidance. If our prophet was a teacher then teaching requires implimentation, and to implement requires observance and imitation.
The companions observed, witnessed and then imitated what the prophet advised them to imitate as a means of obeying Allah commands with the upper most confidence.
We are not departing from the Qur'an, rather we are using the Qur'an as our bases.
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
talking like a brainless ppl.. fully detailed coz it is combined with the Sunnah.. how come u r so DUMB missionary
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
Why insults?
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
Notice, I challange all hadithist, even those who made the video, the hadith show, to show me the hadith explaning the salat in detail.
Peace
GA937 2 years ago
`Umar ibn Al-Khattab (may Allah be pleased with him) said: Almighty Allah sent Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him) with the truth and revealed unto Him the Quran. Among the revelation (brought by him) was the verse stipulating that married adulterer and adulteress should be stoned to death. We read, comprehended and understood it."
I trust in him
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
"adulteress should be stoned to death"
direct contradiction to sura 24: 2
Whos words is stronger, Allah´s or mans ?
GA937 2 years ago
No that is not a direct contradiction, are you even aware of the abrogation that took place?? You see if you do not value the context surrounding the Qur'an which are narrated in the hadith then you would never know such things.
The abrogated verse stated that A married man and woman, if they commit adultery, stone them to death.
Textually this was abrogated but in terms of parcticalyity it was still applicable which is why our prophet stoned people.
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
"No that is not a direct contradiction"
God disagree 24:2
You have showed me not that you are a mushrik
GA937 2 years ago
Bear in mind that the Sunnah of the Prophet is a part of the Divine Revelation, indicating that many things were revealed to the Prophet either through inspiration or instruction. Which is why Allah makes a distinction in the Qur'an!
Allah tells us in the Qur'an that the Prophet (does not speak out of his own fancy. It is all an inspiration sent down to him.) (An-Najm 53: 3-4) Therefore, what the Prophet teaches us is part of our religion It is not something that he has determined by himself
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
You know just like me that most of the hadiths are not confirmed by the Quran. Some of them are compliant. This mix creates an unperfection and a mess which cannot be from Allah
AlMahdiMe1 2 years ago
Please Notice !!
I challange all hadithist, to show me the hadith explaning the salat (prayers) step by step, rakat for rakat, What to say and when to say the "magic" words as the Hadithist call it
GA937 2 years ago
That is not a challenge that is simple searching. All you have to do is search on Google and you will find the answer. Has that become so difficult for you heretics?
And they are not magic words, we praise Allah in our prayers and we ask for forgiveness. You are sound like a atheist, its no wonder since you have no connection to Islam.
I quote
"What to say and when to say the "magic" words"
You remind of a Christian Evangelical.
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
Then do your research and come back with the hadith explaning the salat step by step.
GA937 2 years ago
GA937 people in your field like to quote the Bible and at the same time apply double standards. On one hand you accuse most Muslim and Islamic scholars (jurists) of being liars and deceivers for implementing the punishment of stoning YET you conveniently forget to sight Deuteronomy or Leviticus which calls for the death of the two people engaged in sexual relationship whilst the woman in married.
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
I dont follow the teachings in the bible. Dont make a fitnah akhi, My only source of guidance it the book of Allah, the quran. Not the hadith, not the bible
GA937 2 years ago
Now you can see it, just open your eyes. Only hadith and the corrupted bible does teach man to stone people to death. Can you see it ? Then repent brother, hadith is the teachings of satan, he wants you to obey him, and to follow his teachings
GA937 2 years ago
So now you stop quoting the Bible and you reject that this practise ever took place.
So you must be an Atheist
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
وَمِنَ النَّاسِ مَن يَشْتَرِي لَهْوَ الْحَدِيثِ لِيُضِلَّ عَن سَبِيلِ اللَّهِ بِغَيْرِ عِلْمٍ وَيَتَّخِذَهَا هُزُوًا أُولَئِكَ لَهُمْ عَذَابٌ مُّهِينٌ
GA937 2 years ago
hmmm you don't like using the Bible and you don't like the Hadith which perfectly brings me on to the following verse:
Allah warns us not to go against the Prophet (peace be upon him), and states that whoever disobeys him will be doomed to eternal Hell.
Allah says (interpretation of the meaning): ...And let those who oppose the Messengers commandment beware, lest some fitnah (trial, affliction, etc.) befall them or a painful torment be inflicted on them. [24:63]
^_^
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
The hadith is not the teachings of Mohammed (pbuh)
Its the teachings of the jews and iranians, satanic teachings is found in the hadith. You dont obey The prophet but you obey jews and iranians. For this God will punish you. Repent before its too late, and pray, pray for guidance
GA937 2 years ago
Now Im not gonna waste my time on people who worship a black rock. Come back when you can take my challange, when you can show me the hadith explaning the salat in detail.
May God guide you to the truth, if you are seeking for it. Peace
GA937 2 years ago
"The Prophets Prayer Described" by Shaykh al Albaanee
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
Are you deaf ? blind ? whats your problem ? I say, show me the hadith explaning the salat in detail, you leave shejk references, how ignorant !
GA937 2 years ago
Are you a little infidel? You seem like one.
Go read, value references you stubborn child. I am guessing you speak Arabic or you know something about Shaykh Al Baanee? He is a authority in Arabia for the Muslims living there....his books are valued.
Or are you scared? And do you know anything about the four schools of thought? Salah is performed with slight variations according to different interpretations of the narratives. I am no Scholar to give you a full depth analysis...
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
Bring the hadith explaning the salat in detail or keep silent.
I challenge all Hadithist, to show me the hadith explaning the salat in detail. You can bring all your shejks, mullahs, teachers, to show me the hadith explaning the salat in detail. This challenge have been here since the hadithist started their religion, and nobody have been able to show the hadith explaning the salat in detail.
Repent before its to late mostafe
GA937 2 years ago
can we grow finger nails long like X-MEN?? can we keep long hair like a women?? can we wear womens cloth?? can we eat donkey, snakes, tiger, lion, rat etc?? can ur father marry another guy's father?? if a baby urine on our clothes, can we pray in that?? what do we say during sujood?? what do we say during tasleem?? how to bury u or ur father if already dead?? for how long a baby can drink the mothers milk?? is it till the baby grows and become an old man?? u r exposed missionary..
DefenderOfSunnah 2 years ago
GA937 We know how to pray BECAUSE of the sunnah which we extract from the prophetic tradition.
I am currently looking at over 40 hadith from Sahih Muslim which explains the Salah from Takbeer (raising the hands) to Tashahud position ALL fully detailed. lol
The question of Salah has always been a problem with the Prophet (hadith) rejecters like you. ^_^
Your missionary tactics wont deceive the Muslims
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
All you have to do is type in Kitab al Salat book number 4, which is a compilation of Sahih (authentic) hadith narrating by Muslim on the topic of the Salat procedure!
Firstly Chapter 7 talks of raising the hands opposite to the shoulders at the beginning of the prayer (and at the time of bowing and when returning to the erect position after the first bow)
Book 4, Number 0758, 0759, 0760, 0761, 0762, 0763.
These are only from Sahih Muslim, there are numerous more from other collections.
mustafagtgt 2 years ago
Chapter 8 follows on from chapter 7 and focuses on the recital of the Takbir (proclamation) at the time of bowing and rising in prayer with the exception of rising in Ruku where you say: "Allah listened (listens) to him (those) who praises him"
Book 4, Number 0764, 0765, 0766,0767, 0768, 0769 and 0770.
Let me stress, these are only a few narratives compiled in his book...there are many more with more details.
mustafagtgt 2 years ago