nightwish-The Siren (2008)

[theholyflames]

stupid thuomas

[DenSvenskaTjejen]

Greeeeaaat!!!! I love this song and both versions ^^

[AyeeMorgenstern]

Me encanta ! 

[dawoopbanana]

i like this version, seems more alive

[BestRockAlbums]

Anette knows french?!

[GiORGiETTAKAULiTZ]

No:( Tarja the best....

[darkgothic8]

@GiORGiETTAKAULiTZ

omg and Annete sings 10.000 time's better than bill...-.-' stupid th fan

[NwDevotion]

I LOVE THIS SONG WITH ANETTE♥

[DarKiNeZiS]

Ew :'(

[Kulawik619]

No :'(

The Siren whitout tarja is not the same !

Anat is a Wonderfull singer but this song was not made to cover ! :'(

[blackrain02]

Very Scarey. Sorry,but she just butchers the song. I know she is trying to make it her own,but there are some things you shouldn't try to change.

[Agapoulinaki]

omg,so awful :(

[TOTTW]

I like her version too.

[TheMarg0r]

1:07 WHAT THE FUCK, I mean, I wasn't expecting miracles, but... "HEJJAJA"? If anyone says Anette is a better singer, I'd say let them hear Tarja's "Aaaaah" and this abominable, eardrum shattering atrocity of timemankindspace next to each other.

Also, since I'm getting this out of my system, Anette has NO STAGE PRESENCE whatsoever. I saw Tarja live, and she literally seemed to grow to be like eight feet tall as she sang and moved. This is a little girl.

[adriama6659]

Indiscutiblemente Tarja es la unica que siempre interpretara muy bien esta cancion

[johandrea92]

I don't like this version AT ALL

this requires a powerful and -above all- a DARK and deep voice

She tries but it is NOT enough

This is my favorite song of Nightwish

but I'd rather keep listening to it in my mp3, with Tarja's voice, of course

[joshieboy15]

I have to disagree with most of the negative comments on this video by saying that I think Anette has an amazing voice. She is a natural belter, not a soprano, and that is just fine by me. She does an incredible job at belting out those higher notes.

[CarCgey]

she's just below pitch all the time...

but why the band seems dun care at all, not even try to tune the key for her!?

[simonp4636]

4:22-4:30, what was Marco doing ?? :S Other than that, it is not bad

[SuchBrokenx3]

All that they need is another opera singer :/

[hissingatrocity]

shivers run now down my spine. and who wants to understand, will understand. ;)

gawd...

[007prdelka]

Ta fakt musí zkazit na co šáhne.Prostě na Tarju nikdo nemá :-(

[Duncanthedonut]

I know one thing. If a Sailor heard that siren's song he would not be tempted to go into the water.

[AhiNaRaL2]

Ay muxas canciones como Sleeping Sun ke seria mejor ke no la cantara porke... Despues de oirlas con la vozarrona de Tarja no ay comparacion ninguna. La verdad ke la an cagado muxo cambiando a la vocalista. Una voz como la de Tarja no va a estar en este grupo... y yo los sigo escuchando igualmente porke la voz de el no tiene desperdicio ninguno. Pero oir esta cancion con la voz de ella para mi es una ofensa acia mis oidos

[noPeekingAlowed]

this is just.. sad... i mean REALLY sad .. ;((

[Halexus]

Yea...Anette is a good singer, but she should either stay true to the Nightwish songs once sung by Tarja, OR don't sing them at all.

Its all well and good to make a song your own, but you don't need to change up tones so much that we can't even recognize what the song was once, and take away its rhythm.

The Siren was supposed to be a 'sensual' song, but in Anette's version its painful to even listen too. There is "no" feeling and no rhythm.

[MrRDALAL]

sound like a school band..

[grimreaper11114]

HOLY SH** SHE FCKING BUTCHERED THIS SONG marco didnt do to well either just to be fair but if u want the good version of this song watch the end of an era version 100000000x better

[666tedac666]

WTF???? Ruined everything...and Anette looks like a horror-punk o.O

[nellypucka]

Deixou Tarja no chinelo U-U

[xxUltraFreakxx]

In Slovenia she sang this really good, here not so good =/

[cristian15fonseca]

que es esta falta de respeto con the siren que horror parece una cantante de musica pop su voz no esta hecha para manejar el sentido de la cancion que dejo la voz de tarja en ella.......... absurdo anett que pena pero eres pesima en esta cancion no la cantes mas the siren murio con tarja el dia que se fue

[MaulDooku]

@cristian15fonseca , aunque en los ultimos años anette ha mejorado mucho en cuanto al estilo de nightwish y por ello la apoyo mas... tengo q decir que estoy de acuerdo contigo. the siren es ONLY FOR TARJA, cualkier otra persona q la cante se la esta cargando...

[cristian15fonseca]

mira no tengo p`roblema con anette pero la verda es que ella deveria mirar su voz, ella es una contra alto y tarja es una tenora de primero por eso me ofende esto

[MaulDooku]

@cristian15fonseca , bueno si, es normal, a mi tmbn me ha sentado como un ostion en toda la cara, pero ten en cuenta q nightwish tiene muuxos temas, es normal q kieran seguir tocandolos... aunq algunos como este no deberian, y si la vocalista es anette... pues hay que pasar por el aro. en conclusion, yo creo q puede seguir cantando los temas, a su estilo si hace falta, pero q no toke algunos como este, y otros q rekieren una buena voz como phantom of the opera..

[Vaklanil]

WTF? I love this song but c'mon...Anette just screwed it. This is not the songs that you can sing with any voice...you need as marilena6 said a soprano voice.

[aDivineMemorey]

terribble.

[missmetal47]

LOVE Marco's voice!

[liricobarroco]

she sing like a witch, kiling with her voice to the sirens on playback XD jajaja god

[ZombieMarshmallow23]

Marco at the end of this is incredible!

[marilena6]

sorry but Annete is screwing up the song! even in sleeping sun, which is definately suites tarja's voice, she wasn't that bad, she gave another flavour to the song. But here no, I can't stand this version! This song demands a soprano's voice (a siren after all has this kind of voice, enchanting and magical)

[albertopinoncerezo]

@marile

ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZzzzzzzzzz.....

your coment is so boring...

NIGHTWISH

RULES!

4EVER.



[marilena6]

@albertopinoncerezo nightwish ruled in the past, now it's just an ordinary metal band and if my comment was boring and untrue, i wouldn't have 11 thumbs up....

[albertopinoncerezo]

@marilena6

ORIDINARY METAL BAND... hahahaha

you are so funny

Nightwish every cd is better, Tuomas is a genious.

[marilena6]

@albertopinoncerezo you know I love NW too and i'm not the only one who's "funny" just read the majority of the comments here, or in every other NW video, are written by fans who feel that NW without tarja is not the same....After the band's (and mostly Tuomas decision)to dismiss Tarja, the band lost a lot of credit....and these are not only my words, it's almost every NW fan's opinion...

[ae5115]

FUCK YOU ANNET YOU SUCK

[fenixmen6]

ja q tal a mi me parece q la canta bn haci no tenga el mismo nivel de tarja pero x lo menos se esfuerza, y ps si nos les gusta entonces  no la escuchaen y ya sirven pa criticar pero no pa ayudar me gustaria ver a tarja cantando bye bye beautiful haber bobos ¡¡¡¡¡

[liricobarroco]

Tarja canta lo que sea!!! un cantante de bel canto esta apto para cantar cualquier tipo de musica! que pensas que por ser cantante lirico no va poder cantar cualquier cosa! desde rancheras hasta metal! cosa que un cantante pop es limitado! aqui vemos la diferencia!

[Whiplasher777]

Anette you are the best!!!

[akalith86]

lo siento pero esta cancion a perdido todo cantada x anette,no tiene comparacion a tarja,ella la cantaba con emocion y era mil veces mejor en todos los aspectos

[Darklamancha]

I love how u can her the back recordings done by Tarja

[liricobarroco]

good! I can ear the recordings of tarja voice! in ha- ha ha hahaha

[ironheaven]

I Love This Song With Anette <333 it sounds so good!

[ChildoftheSea11]

Amazing how Anette makes a connection to the audience with talking a few words in their native language! And she does a nice job on The Siren aswell :) I still prefer the Tarja-version personally, but that's a matter of taste.

[PortugalDevotee]

Fucking great ... nightwish and anette ... rules !

[Zlatushiq]

omfg!!!

o.O

they just HAVE TO release this version on a new CD *.*

[Evnightlerd]

It's great I like this version! BUT TARJA RULED ON IT! AND anette does it good!

[Zlatushiq]

I´m not saying anything about comparison of these 2 versions...

i just think anette´s interpretation made the song sound totally different ad it´s awesome in its specific way... :)

however, tarja´s version is awesome as well, just in a different way... :)

[TOTTW]

I really like the newly added parts of this song.

[llauriann]

aaargh she's speaking french in the dutch part of belgium

(good song ^^)

[NightDark666]

I was just thinking the same xD

[Isanan]

Anette ruined nightwish... this song is perfectly sung by tarja...this garbage wasted everything...but I still love the guys...

[pelbriks]

she goes often out of tune

[vivatallulah]

Tiene buena voz, pero no para Nightwish. Esta canción me encanta y aquí se escucha horrible...

[Evnightlerd]

jajaja! tienes tanta razón! jajaja me enkanta la vieja versión!

[javideaths]

lo mismo digo

[ItachisHoneycake]

Anette is the best, I love Nightwish!!!

[sendervm]

i love anette but this really sucks....aaaahiaaiaiaiaaaaaaaa­a oh my god!! i hope they dont play this if im there...

[theangelofcroatia]

i agree, she is a good singer,

but NO WAY she can sing the siren half as goood as tarja.

[Evnightlerd]

I do agree But I like this version!

[dxchechexb]

these are the ruins of nightwish...

without tarja's voice this song has nothing especial, anette voice is good but not into this song ,or music style

[poldy19]

pffff

verry no good:)

[brainfreeze11gigge]

Oh I just love her <33

[monep23]

fuck you anette´s fans!!! she´s grate for POP!!! she SUCKS!!!!!

[Puppana]

guys,she ruins the song,there's no way around it -_-

[ForeverYoursTuomas]

fuck you anette haters. She's great! <3

[monep23]

se ve tan patética jajajaja solo hace el ridículo con sus movimientos estúpidos y su voz de mierd@!!!!!!!

[javideaths]

esta es la peor cancion cantada por anette se podria decir, pero ahora escucha Higher Than Hope o Come Cover Me (sobretodo esta) y veras k de verdad vale

[hiskubus]

this version ROCKS!!!! anette is great and so is the rest of nw^^

[angelina696]

WTF is this..? Aaaaaaaiiiiaaaaaiiiiahhahhhaaa­aa... Like a dying... sth. Where's good old Nightwish?! ;(

[hernanferreyra85]

it's the siren...oO with stomach ache :P

[warunba]

una cagada de video la verdad que sin tarja no es lo mismo T_T tarja volve y la vos nio para pedir fiado le da , aparte ese tema en que tiran palaso a tarja esta estupida no se que acota si lo unico que puede cantar es cumbia

[SublimeNightmares]

this simply sucks!

[hiskubus]

i love anette- she has a wonderful voice!!!

[Althea565]

It's cute how she speak french lol

[tarjafan1]

haha eso si que es verdad!

todos de la banda ya estan cambiando nightwish ya no son los mismos que antes. antes cuando la tarja estaba en la banda, nw tenian como un sentido bien fuerte que cuando tocaban y cuando ella cantaba te hacian llorar por felicidad, ahora te hacen llorar por la vos que anette canta

[monep23]

tenés razón jajaja puta si a Marco se le ve una cara que bueno... jajajaja kanta de la pur@ mierda esta cabron@ jajajaja SIII t hacía llorar de felicidad!!! anette me hace llorar de lástima y de lo asqueroso que canta ajajaja TARJA 4EVER!!!!

[tarjafan1]

ya se, no se porque la escojieron. y ella piensa que canta muy bien. haha

[Meg1650]

this is amazing

i loveee anette!!

she's great, nightwish is more amazing than ever now!

(:

[ChildoftheSea11]

Oh well....tastes are different :) But Anette's surely a lovely person.

[ILuvNightwish]

holy crow! this is the best I've heard Anette sing The Siren! She is so gorram amazing!

[DGMfanclub]

Anette sings this song great! She gives this song a whole new life, she really know how to interpret a song that's why i love her

[tarjafan1]

haha she interprets it all right, she intrepets into shit!

[Krzychunightfish]

Nightwish!!!! Anette <3 =D