You just can't beat a broadway production... I was initially excited when the movie came out, but not anymore - now whenever I need a phantom fix I listen to the OST.
Even though Emmy Rosum is supposed to be a Opera singer in real life, she's pitchy (the aria - OMG) and has little expression.
And Gerard Butler? please. He was cast for looks (ironic, as he's playing the PHANTOM) and he had to *learn* how to sing...
WTF, everyone is piangi, i got Andre, i tried out for phantom, but seniors are always better at everything. Our piangi is a kinda goofy guy but we can deal with him.
@zkinsey1 , Yes I would agree Zack you are the best piangi there could ever be. And you have a good point, I love being Andre. By goofy I of course meant you are hysterical.
Oh my gosh. I was cast as Piangi as well! It's such a fun, yet scary part. I definitely think it will help our vocal skills in the long run, though! :) Best of luck to you guys!
All of you that do the phantom of the opera at your school are so lucky! Our High School is so cheap and stupid that they would never think to perform TPOTO. =( My dream is to sing as the phantom himself
Oh my goodness! My schools production of The Phantom of the Opera's opening night is tomorrow! D= I'm soooo nervous! This song is one of the hardest for me. Fingers crossed! I hope all of you who are also in the play are doing fabulous! We need to show the world how truely amazing our high schools are for being able to succeed in this. (= Quite an accomplishment.
Oh my goodness! My schools production of The Phantom of the Opera's opening night is tomorrow! D= I'm soooo nervous! This song is one of the hardest for me. Fingers crossed!
@Dancingfool721 High Cs are horribly difficult for me, even though I'm a tenor ... always end up sounding either falsetto or very thin and squawky haha
If you watched the movie at all, you would notice that the actors casted for Carlotta and Piangi were casted to be terrible ON PURPOSE for humorous effect- Piangi believes he is "all that," and Carlotta even more so, acting the part of the comical diva primadonna. If you watch in the rehearsal scene when she sings for the new owners, she looks somewhat disturbed by their disinterest in her and you can see how it affects her singing. You can also see when she sings her best and believes it is her
best, the managers have these looks on their faces like listening to her is painful.
Their bold, brash, unbearable voices are also supposed to contrast Emmy Rossum's (Christine) timid, delicate, but strong voice, to make her seem like absolute perfection in comparison.
@genmaximus110 They also wouldn't hire horrible actors, which, according to the Phantom, is what Carlotta is. All that matters is that the people love her, which is more publicity and more money for the managers.
@genmaximus110 oh. well Webber and Hart did very well in recreating the romantic style of music, I feel. I think it sounds a lot like something you'd hear in classical opera repetoire!
Im so glad I found this. I lost my CD for Toronto's version of Phantom, and Piangi's solo is my favorite.. Colm Wilinson is possibly my least favorite actor, but almost everyone else in this productions far outshines any other performance of the show.
Thank you for the recording, it's in great quality and it's the second "modification" I made on the OLC cast CD, first was the Music of the Night, I replaced it with the preview one, where Michael sings the whole thing with the lyrics and I like and the second is this, cause I would (could) never put the movie's Hannibal on it, it's.. urgh. I agree with the description box, trough.
You're welcome. This is possibly the best track on the entire Canadian cast CD. I do not like the Phantom they chose for that performance. He's way too dramatic, constantly. Christine, where her voice is good, and possibly even more operatic than Sarah Brightman, also tends to put too much drama in the final scenes when she gets "emotional." But, overall, she was a really good Christine. Her performance was always hindered by the bad ones of Phantom and Raoul.
hey do you know who played mademe giry and meg giry in this cast?
DrinkOmally 2 months ago
I got casted as Piangi in my schools production SOOO FUCKING HIGH!!!
Rcyhdreirst 2 months ago
You just can't beat a broadway production... I was initially excited when the movie came out, but not anymore - now whenever I need a phantom fix I listen to the OST.
Even though Emmy Rosum is supposed to be a Opera singer in real life, she's pitchy (the aria - OMG) and has little expression.
And Gerard Butler? please. He was cast for looks (ironic, as he's playing the PHANTOM) and he had to *learn* how to sing...
The whole movie makes me twitch.
Erik is not pleased.
DragonCellion 3 months ago
i'm playing piangi in my school's production and its mad hard but its so fun !
ohhbrien 3 months ago
I am Piangi as well in a youth production...they are transposing it to a baritone (:
anactornamedseth93 8 months ago
I'm Raul :D
tedipenguproductions 11 months ago
WTF, everyone is piangi, i got Andre, i tried out for phantom, but seniors are always better at everything. Our piangi is a kinda goofy guy but we can deal with him.
jjj5541 11 months ago
@jjj5541 Shut it kyle. You love being andre. And im amazing at it and you know it....
zkinsey1 10 months ago
@zkinsey1 , Yes I would agree Zack you are the best piangi there could ever be. And you have a good point, I love being Andre. By goofy I of course meant you are hysterical.
jjj5541 10 months ago
i wish someone would make this into a full opera.
morbidcurios 1 year ago
@Dancingfool721
@coolmoonguy08
Oh my gosh. I was cast as Piangi as well! It's such a fun, yet scary part. I definitely think it will help our vocal skills in the long run, though! :) Best of luck to you guys!
tromboner1993 1 year ago
All of you that do the phantom of the opera at your school are so lucky! Our High School is so cheap and stupid that they would never think to perform TPOTO. =( My dream is to sing as the phantom himself
BigAl051395 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
haha i got cast as piangi too
coolmoonguy08 1 year ago
haha i got cast as piangi too
coolmoonguy08 1 year ago
hahaha piangi may be high but the tenor ones got it bad too lol
firinmalazor 1 year ago
Oh my goodness! My schools production of The Phantom of the Opera's opening night is tomorrow! D= I'm soooo nervous! This song is one of the hardest for me. Fingers crossed! I hope all of you who are also in the play are doing fabulous! We need to show the world how truely amazing our high schools are for being able to succeed in this. (= Quite an accomplishment.
Peace37897 1 year ago
Oh my goodness! My schools production of The Phantom of the Opera's opening night is tomorrow! D= I'm soooo nervous! This song is one of the hardest for me. Fingers crossed!
Peace37897 1 year ago
OMG im so scared! I got Piangi in my school's production in phantom It's so high!!!!!!!!!!! lol
Dancingfool721 1 year ago
@Dancingfool721 Well, best of luck to you!
genmaximus110 1 year ago 3
@Dancingfool721 not even lying same with me! and i feel you!
kriscan123 1 year ago
@Dancingfool721 High Cs are horribly difficult for me, even though I'm a tenor ... always end up sounding either falsetto or very thin and squawky haha
rossyxan 1 year ago
@Dancingfool721 at University High school? :)
Kumari820 1 year ago
@Dancingfool721 lol Piangi only goes up to a C! Carlotta goes up to an E! I have to be her in my school show. LOLOLOL!
AstridElphieLovegood 11 months ago
@AstridElphieLovegood when I played the role of Piangi at my school I was hitting a D.
maddog8757 11 months ago
@Dancingfool721 How'd you do on the high C? :P
ScrisGaming 1 month ago
I just got cast as Piangi in my school's production of Phantom. Should be interesting, haha. Thanks for posting!
ksyankeejetfan 1 year ago
@ksyankeejetfan Too cool! Break a leg!
genmaximus110 1 year ago
@genmaximus110 And a vocal chord ;D
(I got this role as well. Haha.)
sploopidy 11 months ago
If you watched the movie at all, you would notice that the actors casted for Carlotta and Piangi were casted to be terrible ON PURPOSE for humorous effect- Piangi believes he is "all that," and Carlotta even more so, acting the part of the comical diva primadonna. If you watch in the rehearsal scene when she sings for the new owners, she looks somewhat disturbed by their disinterest in her and you can see how it affects her singing. You can also see when she sings her best and believes it is her
Aethia 1 year ago
best, the managers have these looks on their faces like listening to her is painful.
Their bold, brash, unbearable voices are also supposed to contrast Emmy Rossum's (Christine) timid, delicate, but strong voice, to make her seem like absolute perfection in comparison.
Aethia 1 year ago
@Aethia True, but this is still the Paris Opera. They wouldn't hire horrible singers.
genmaximus110 1 year ago
@genmaximus110 They also wouldn't hire horrible actors, which, according to the Phantom, is what Carlotta is. All that matters is that the people love her, which is more publicity and more money for the managers.
Aethia 1 year ago
is this from or similar to any pieces from an actual opera?
KiyoKenshin 1 year ago
@KiyoKenshin Nope. It's an Webber/Hart original.
genmaximus110 1 year ago
@genmaximus110 oh. well Webber and Hart did very well in recreating the romantic style of music, I feel. I think it sounds a lot like something you'd hear in classical opera repetoire!
KiyoKenshin 1 year ago
@KiyoKenshin Yeah, it certainly doesn't sound modern. I wish he would write more in this style.
genmaximus110 1 year ago
HANNIBAL COMES!! I luv luv luv it
DelilahAmelia 1 year ago
It makes me sad, knowing what happened to poor Carthage after the Punic Wars..... :-(
ABookwormAndProud 1 year ago
Amazing! I wish they had this for the the OLC.
RosesNightengales 1 year ago
Comment removed
fattdug 2 years ago
I wish that ALW would write an opera based on this bit !
newrochellephoenix 2 years ago
Im so glad I found this. I lost my CD for Toronto's version of Phantom, and Piangi's solo is my favorite.. Colm Wilinson is possibly my least favorite actor, but almost everyone else in this productions far outshines any other performance of the show.
liljee16 2 years ago
I agree about Colm. He was just waaaaaay too dramatic.
genmaximus110 2 years ago
Thank you for the recording, it's in great quality and it's the second "modification" I made on the OLC cast CD, first was the Music of the Night, I replaced it with the preview one, where Michael sings the whole thing with the lyrics and I like and the second is this, cause I would (could) never put the movie's Hannibal on it, it's.. urgh. I agree with the description box, trough.
tyagofsantos 2 years ago
You're welcome. This is possibly the best track on the entire Canadian cast CD. I do not like the Phantom they chose for that performance. He's way too dramatic, constantly. Christine, where her voice is good, and possibly even more operatic than Sarah Brightman, also tends to put too much drama in the final scenes when she gets "emotional." But, overall, she was a really good Christine. Her performance was always hindered by the bad ones of Phantom and Raoul.
genmaximus110 2 years ago