A magnificent and most original performance by the great Cortot...and I can see that there are the usual fatuous comments here about 'wrong notes' and 'too fast'....Well, it's par for the course with know-nothings who favor the likes of Pogorelich in Chopin...or who believe they have precise formulas for the timing of each piece by Bach! (;-D) Thanks for this post. I've been gorging on late Cortot today...gorgeous sound.
Thanks Beckmesser for posting this wonderful performance. I've never understood why Chopin considered this piece unworthy of publication. Thank God for his old Polish friend Julian Fontana who who returned to Paris, overuled Chopin's express directive to destroy all unpublished works, and edited the posthumous edition.
This is not one of Cortot's best recorded efforts, IMO. While it is supremely musical, especially in his handling of the famous "tune," there are too many wrong notes and the overall tempo is too fast for me to completely enjoy it. Ah, but that singing line...as if the piano was an extension of the human voice!
undoubtedly a finger slip. the playing while very musical (one of the most musical i have heard) is sloppy in the finger work in the fast passages. also, last but not least, do you get the feeling that he is playing this piece faster than necessary?
clifdavol: Cortot was famous for his fast tempos. Personally, I don't like his playing that much because he just rushed through everything. His finger slips and mistakes don't bother me though, it's just that I generally don't like his interpretations. This one is better than most though. For example, his G-minor Ballade is awful.
Cortot is underrated LEGEND
BassicStorm 3 weeks ago
romantic!
Pollinikrys 6 months ago
A magnificent and most original performance by the great Cortot...and I can see that there are the usual fatuous comments here about 'wrong notes' and 'too fast'....Well, it's par for the course with know-nothings who favor the likes of Pogorelich in Chopin...or who believe they have precise formulas for the timing of each piece by Bach! (;-D) Thanks for this post. I've been gorging on late Cortot today...gorgeous sound.
Noshirm 9 months ago 2
Thanks Beckmesser for posting this wonderful performance. I've never understood why Chopin considered this piece unworthy of publication. Thank God for his old Polish friend Julian Fontana who who returned to Paris, overuled Chopin's express directive to destroy all unpublished works, and edited the posthumous edition.
saunsnaen 1 year ago
@saunsnaen ... this was not the reason. it couldn't have been the reason.
gerardbedecarter 6 months ago
Cortot`s interpretations are so deep and so intense...
This is my favourite interpretation of the piece.
And who cares about "slips"? If you want every notes right listen to a midi file.
ThePianoconcerto 1 year ago 7
@ThePianoconcerto
That's right mate! Interpretation is what matters after all. And that singing line sounds soo sweet..
chouzouris 9 months ago
This is not one of Cortot's best recorded efforts, IMO. While it is supremely musical, especially in his handling of the famous "tune," there are too many wrong notes and the overall tempo is too fast for me to completely enjoy it. Ah, but that singing line...as if the piano was an extension of the human voice!
billyguns2 2 years ago
undoubtedly a finger slip. the playing while very musical (one of the most musical i have heard) is sloppy in the finger work in the fast passages. also, last but not least, do you get the feeling that he is playing this piece faster than necessary?
clifdavol 2 years ago
clifdavol: Cortot was famous for his fast tempos. Personally, I don't like his playing that much because he just rushed through everything. His finger slips and mistakes don't bother me though, it's just that I generally don't like his interpretations. This one is better than most though. For example, his G-minor Ballade is awful.
BachScholar 2 years ago
@clifdavol --- 1. yes; 2. yes.
gerardbedecarter 6 months ago