General question (not intended as a criticism)... Why does everyone keep talking about the latest and lamest pop stars on here (and everywhere else?) Do you not realize that the more you talk about these artists (which are being forced-fed to us whether we like it or not) you are actually promoting their names and giving them greater exposure? I'm starting to think that the people who say "This is better than so and so" actually work for the PR teams that push this stuff on us in the first place
@scottnsuzs Actually, you can only be sued for copyright infringement if you are silent for exactly four minutes and thirty-three seconds. Just make sure you are REALLY careful
hahaha, i actually put my volume on the very highest it could go wondering why i couldn't hear anything...then an airplane flew over, wind blew...hahaha...and only then did i read this is meant to be silent :P don't think my intelligence is advanced enough to appreciate this...
I get what Cage was meaning to convey with this "piece", though it makes me wish people would stop what they're doing once in a while and listen to the world around them. And considering the fact that this was controversial (!!??!!!?) upon its release, it just goes to show that a lot of people are irritable and impatient when it comes to experiencing solitude. In other words, enjoying peaceful silence should be something innate, not something taught or instructed by "music" like this.
This is not music. There is nothing happening. Yes that might be "what it's supposed to be." It still doesn't make it good, interesting, or relevant. It just makes it pretentious and bullshitty.
@flameburst45 Ah, maybe to you it's not music. Have you ever thought that not all music is the same to everyone else? This is art, it can be whatever the artist wishes it to be.
John Cages purpose to this song is to get the listener to note the noise of his/her surroundings and to appreciate the rhythm of life and of the world
La battaglia che l'anima combatte con nessuno - è di tutte le battaglie esistenti - di gran lunga la maggiore - Non se ne ha notizia fuori - la sua campagna incorporea si sviluppa, e termina - invisibile - sconosciuta - Né annali - la registrano - Come legioni della notte che il sole disperde - questa resiste - esegue - e termina -
This is quite an inspiring piece. In its analysis, we see that each of the movements has its own 'feel'. The first can be shown to be confusion of the audience. By the second movement, the audience expects nothing and are thrown into a more elaborate confusion at the performer's apparent nonchalant manner. The third movement shows us an epic ending as the audience is either aggravated by the 'silence' or awakened and utterly speechless and amazed by the awesome 'music' just performed.
Hmm... if this song is supposed to be whatever is in the surrounding, what if there's a copyrighted song playing? Does that count as a copyright violation?
The jokes are getting really tiresome. Yes it is silence. Please take 4:33 to be alone with your thoughts.
I believe in free speech so I'm not going to prevent anyone from posting or saying whatever they want, but please everyone, no more jokes about downloads, ringtones, tabs or whatever. Thank you.
@sydbarrett5 It's not silence. Take in the sounds around you. Even if you're in an entirely silent room, you'll hear two sounds, a high sound and a low sound (the high one being your nervous system working and the low one being the flow of your blood). So good luck hearing silence.
@sydbarrett5 Yes. Silence is not something that is created, it's the absence of sound, which is created. Simple really. It's like saying "is darkness something?". No. It's the absence of light. Light is something, darkness isn't.
As an "art conception" this is really great stuff, art doesn't get better than this: it's just art per se. Because it makes u wondering and u'll quickly realize that u can't get away from world's hum . What's more u can become very scared or even u can become deaf from hearing very loud sound, but u can't overdose silence.
4 minutes is just enough to realize that it's practically impossible for human to experience pure silence for such a long time. The best and the worst music track ever done.
The idea is that the world around you is music. This 4'33", for me, is people talking outside, loading their truck, the dishes downstairs being put away, and my bong, bubbling up a nice fat hit! What's your 4'33"?
I am deeply impressed although I better like acoustic instruments than electronic ones. But the sound-quality is brilliant. Was it mastered digitally?
IS IT ME OR DID EVERYONE WASTE 4:34 MINUITE OF THERE LIFE LISTENING TO ABOUSOLOTLY NOTHING YEAH IM SOOOOOOOOOOO GONNA LISTEN TO THIS AT CHRISTMAS WE MIGHT AS WELL ALL BE MORING ON CHRISTMAS DAY BUT IS IT NOT SAID SOMEWHERE THAT CHRISTMAS IS A TIME FOR HAPPINESS AND JOY AND FOR GATHERING AND TALKING AND CATCHING UP PLEASE EVERYONE WATCH ANNOYING ORANGE ITS SOOOOOOOOOO FUNNY LIKE IF YOU LOLED AT IT!
Omg , is this a joke ? please dont tell me people are actually going to buy this just to get one over X factor ? Whoever buys this is an r-tard. I mean, rage last year was immense, but this? Get a life and stop crying about X factor.
Heard this was being used as this year's anti- XFactor song. Brilliant! Not only will we show Simon Cowel and all the other leeches what for but we'll show them that their "music" isn't even worth using instruments to protest against. Personally prefered last years (I kept screaming METAL IS VICTORIOUS until I couldn't speak on Xmas day but it was worth it) but hey it's more artistic than anything pop has ever contributed!
Been trying to learn this piece for years. It's fucking hard though.
RobbVonZeppelin 1 week ago
What a tune.
tumour 2 weeks ago
Shizune general
Timblesink 2 weeks ago
Beautiful
DxvidXdmtv 2 weeks ago
I know this song by heart.
MbFarah 3 weeks ago
This is my ringtone :D
DekuSmed 3 weeks ago 3
The music starts at 4:34 :p
esgnrjnjgu 4 weeks ago
my ears hurt
rgrannell1 1 month ago
General question (not intended as a criticism)... Why does everyone keep talking about the latest and lamest pop stars on here (and everywhere else?) Do you not realize that the more you talk about these artists (which are being forced-fed to us whether we like it or not) you are actually promoting their names and giving them greater exposure? I'm starting to think that the people who say "This is better than so and so" actually work for the PR teams that push this stuff on us in the first place
sydbarrett5 1 month ago 5
Can't wait untlil its out on itunes!
CaliberVG 1 month ago
@CaliberVG It already is.
br0nc096 3 weeks ago
tyhtyht
xMasterKaix 1 month ago
better than justin bieber
mariutunio 1 month ago
@mariutunio everything is better than justin bieber^^
TheBlackoutstar 1 month ago
@TheBlackoutstar
rebecca black?
mariutunio 1 month ago
@mariutunio I knew I forgotten someone
TheBlackoutstar 1 month ago
check out fake blood's needle drop mix of this. best remix
RedDress 1 month ago
Be careful not to get taken down by copyright.
dwaynebenzie33 1 month ago
One of the few songs I can actually play on piano.
cronojdbass 1 month ago 4
An amazing piece! I am currently learning this on the ukulele!
computerlover0000 1 month ago
This is just brilliant. No other musician can match Cage's genius.
Randomness65535 1 month ago
Incredible.
Amazing peace.
AlfieWilRus 2 months ago 2
so this means if you don't say anything you can be sued for copyright infringment? lol
is there any noise on the track? if so where?
scottnsuzs 2 months ago
@scottnsuzs Actually, you can only be sued for copyright infringement if you are silent for exactly four minutes and thirty-three seconds. Just make sure you are REALLY careful
Ryurei42 2 months ago
does anyone have the lyrics for this?
thorleyc2 2 months ago 5
i can play this...
Hamporkcheese 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
am i right, that he made money with this?
TheMillinger 2 months ago
Cats having sex in the back of a car.
nobleblier 2 months ago
I have to be careful not to crank the volume up too much, or else my neighbours will start complaining!
YoungWolve1 2 months ago
hahaha, i actually put my volume on the very highest it could go wondering why i couldn't hear anything...then an airplane flew over, wind blew...hahaha...and only then did i read this is meant to be silent :P don't think my intelligence is advanced enough to appreciate this...
ObsessedWivMuzik 3 months ago
@ObsessedWivMuzik I think you've already proven that your intelligence is advanced enough to appreciate this.
sydbarrett5 3 months ago 5
Se vuoi, come vuoi, quando vuoi
io sono qui.
Ti voglio bene
0Elisa00 3 months ago
damn vevo blocked sound :|
NaVarioneq 3 months ago
Bad Quality....
Andres5045 3 months ago 2
who is singing part 1:15-2:00 ? please answer me it's very important !!!
MarcinZszafy 3 months ago
I get what Cage was meaning to convey with this "piece", though it makes me wish people would stop what they're doing once in a while and listen to the world around them. And considering the fact that this was controversial (!!??!!!?) upon its release, it just goes to show that a lot of people are irritable and impatient when it comes to experiencing solitude. In other words, enjoying peaceful silence should be something innate, not something taught or instructed by "music" like this.
dimmytreee 3 months ago
perfect video to troll people with
Felicia20412 3 months ago
this isnt what i heard the first time, there seems to be one second more
whalrus24 3 months ago
This isn't the real version guys, this is an obvious remix of the 4'33". You should know this.
teethofghosts 3 months ago 2
I heard mice humping.
Since according to John Cage the music is the background of what you hear, that guy must have been a demented pervert.
iamhungey12345 3 months ago
did you tube remove the sound again.. silly youtube removing sound from videos is probably copy righted too.
LHAnthony 3 months ago
Go to any piano bar and request that he/she play John Cage's 4:33 . I would not be surprised the amount of tips they will be getting!!!
Pookatube 3 months ago
The silence is deafening!!!
Pookatube 3 months ago
This is not music. There is nothing happening. Yes that might be "what it's supposed to be." It still doesn't make it good, interesting, or relevant. It just makes it pretentious and bullshitty.
flameburst45 4 months ago
@flameburst45 Ah, maybe to you it's not music. Have you ever thought that not all music is the same to everyone else? This is art, it can be whatever the artist wishes it to be.
jayriggzy 3 months ago
this is fucking stupid the future generation are gonna watch this vid and think were retarded
royton1992 4 months ago
lyrics?
ReFLeXIOYT 4 months ago 4
I fall asleep listening to this every night.
MySpaceBarsBroken0o 4 months ago
Hehe... I can play this on the piano. :)
IAmTheMohawkWarrior 4 months ago 4
Tab?
TizioRandom77 4 months ago 4
I'm trying to listen to the noise in my environment, all I hear is the computer fan...
Maybe I should get a CD-player or something.
SanityMachine 4 months ago
John Cages purpose to this song is to get the listener to note the noise of his/her surroundings and to appreciate the rhythm of life and of the world
halloway54 4 months ago
.......
totoro9805 5 months ago
Come on youtube, this is copyrighted material. You have to take down the audio :3
grevejp44 5 months ago 10
It's okay, nothing special.
Pretty overrated if you ask me.
iamhungey12345 5 months ago
0Elisa00 5 months ago
240p? Terrible sound quality.
Critdizzle 5 months ago 30
Amazing
TheUszatek 6 months ago
John Cage is one TRUE musician.
AtarisGuy33 6 months ago
There is a FREE audio Bible online! Google Bible Gateway adds audio NASB bible! It is great to listen to! :)
TheNancySikes 6 months ago
This is crap after 4:34
Neopersonageguy 6 months ago
Where can I download the music sheet ?
inesis 6 months ago 5
One of the most spectacular songs. I listen to this all day.
Channelsearcher 6 months ago
This is quite an inspiring piece. In its analysis, we see that each of the movements has its own 'feel'. The first can be shown to be confusion of the audience. By the second movement, the audience expects nothing and are thrown into a more elaborate confusion at the performer's apparent nonchalant manner. The third movement shows us an epic ending as the audience is either aggravated by the 'silence' or awakened and utterly speechless and amazed by the awesome 'music' just performed.
ElTacoNazo92 7 months ago 4
it's so inspiring!
1screamingstars 7 months ago
Lol, its 4 minutes and 34 seconds long!
Pianistrocker101 7 months ago
@Pianistrocker101 Yeah I noticed that too. It actually jumps from 4:32 to 4:34
sydbarrett5 7 months ago 2
The REAL sounds of silence.
GivepeaceachanceJL 7 months ago
Shut Up And Let Me Listern To This
MegaHarris101 8 months ago
Best part 3:56
Edox943 8 months ago
this is library music
YoungWolve1 8 months ago
You can't learn genius like this at Julliard.
EyeShotFirst1 8 months ago 2
cage is amazing
if you are a big john cage fan you have to listen to
gabriel williams - time travel in musc
chiledofthekorn 8 months ago
Why isnt this in 720p?
b3nj4mmin 8 months ago
@b3nj4mmin Yes higher quality please.
GLaDOSsMailerDaemon 8 months ago 3
If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it, is there still music?
Galduke 8 months ago
@Galduke I think this song IS a tree falling with no one hearing it.
Skaarjguy 8 months ago
HOW DIS YOU GET GORDON FREEMAN TO SING THIS???
Jakkinator45 8 months ago
Sadly this may be taken down for copyright.
Fospherous 9 months ago 4
Thank you for the sound of birdsong :)
SormaNo4 9 months ago
I'm constantly performing this song on every instrument int he world. That's how great I am.
GetThisThingCrunk 9 months ago
Oh god I loved the vocals as performed by Grodon Freeman.
Exarian 9 months ago 3
Hmm... if this song is supposed to be whatever is in the surrounding, what if there's a copyrighted song playing? Does that count as a copyright violation?
pyVlad 10 months ago 3
@pyVlad I do remember one rock band put a silent track on one of their albums and got sued for plagiarism.
intigfx 9 months ago
im seriously trying to appreciate this but theres some guy outside with a fucking drum =(
TheRiteOfWinter 10 months ago
@TheRiteOfWinter That's part of the music
GetThisThingCrunk 9 months ago
thx to the LEGEND who uploaded this :)
bakar12345 10 months ago
When it hits the second bridge, this shit really takes off!
RexButtafuoco 10 months ago 3
The jokes are getting really tiresome. Yes it is silence. Please take 4:33 to be alone with your thoughts.
I believe in free speech so I'm not going to prevent anyone from posting or saying whatever they want, but please everyone, no more jokes about downloads, ringtones, tabs or whatever. Thank you.
sydbarrett5 10 months ago 15
@sydbarrett5 Sooo... what am I supposed to say about a video of literally nothing?
Skaarjguy 8 months ago
@Skaarjguy Is silence nothing?
sydbarrett5 8 months ago 16
@sydbarrett5 Please tell me you aren't being serious.
Skaarjguy 8 months ago
@sydbarrett5 Yes.
FastEvilMen 7 months ago
@sydbarrett5 yes.
yashi4000 6 months ago
@sydbarrett5 It's not silence. Take in the sounds around you. Even if you're in an entirely silent room, you'll hear two sounds, a high sound and a low sound (the high one being your nervous system working and the low one being the flow of your blood). So good luck hearing silence.
ziggo3 4 months ago
@ziggo3 Very good point.
sydbarrett5 4 months ago
@sydbarrett5 Yes. Silence is not something that is created, it's the absence of sound, which is created. Simple really. It's like saying "is darkness something?". No. It's the absence of light. Light is something, darkness isn't.
Uzzie101 3 months ago
Where I can download it?
MrPiens 10 months ago 3
i have this as my ringtone
extremeeXrement1 10 months ago
Can I have the tab for it please... Tab toolkit if possible!
birlibis2juggler 10 months ago
damn, I can't seem to find the chord at 2:34 DAAAAAAAAAAAAMN
ChainWasp 10 months ago
Needs more cowbell.....
TheGarethG 10 months ago
Don't hear bass guitar
emaki525 10 months ago
When will youtube learn to count?
SixAndOneThirdTV 10 months ago
WOW
awesome
Where can i download it on mp3??
telewizorzpromocji 10 months ago
Man, the bass line on this track is crazy!
maybenotme1994 10 months ago
Great song! I think I'm going to put this on my iPod.
Crusador19 10 months ago
Bravo!
rod32lop 10 months ago
You say Justin Bieber, I say ...
You say Lady Gaga, I say ...
You say Kanye West, I say ...
You say Nicki Minaj, I say ...
You say Rihanna, I say ...
You say Katy Perry, I say ...
80% of teenagers have switched to pop and rap music. If you're part of the 20% who still listen to exactly goddamn nothing, thumb this up!
TwoCows23 11 months ago 67
@TwoCows23 If pop music is ignored, it eventually disappears.
sydbarrett5 11 months ago 28
@TwoCows23 lol
Neopersonageguy 6 months ago
@TwoCows23 Haha, at least that's creative! You got my thumbs up.
xreddragonx 6 months ago
TUUUUUUNE!
FellPonyz 11 months ago
I just noticed I have an earth loop on my sound system....
brockneyc 11 months ago
This ain't the original.
quashky 11 months ago 3
As an "art conception" this is really great stuff, art doesn't get better than this: it's just art per se. Because it makes u wondering and u'll quickly realize that u can't get away from world's hum . What's more u can become very scared or even u can become deaf from hearing very loud sound, but u can't overdose silence.
4 minutes is just enough to realize that it's practically impossible for human to experience pure silence for such a long time. The best and the worst music track ever done.
FromAlienWithLove 11 months ago 4
Comment removed
FromAlienWithLove 11 months ago
Comment removed
FromAlienWithLove 11 months ago
Comment removed
FromAlienWithLove 11 months ago
Damn you, WMG! I can't hear the audio!
TheiosXaris 11 months ago 5
Does anyone have this in flac?
vihanovich 11 months ago 4
The idea is that the world around you is music. This 4'33", for me, is people talking outside, loading their truck, the dishes downstairs being put away, and my bong, bubbling up a nice fat hit! What's your 4'33"?
TokingSD420 11 months ago 4
Guys I can't hear anything, is this video broken or is it my Internet Explorer 6?
Jadon159 11 months ago 2
this is ridiculous!
ellowlly 11 months ago
My dog is freaking out now
SadMammal 11 months ago
I am deeply impressed although I better like acoustic instruments than electronic ones. But the sound-quality is brilliant. Was it mastered digitally?
Thank you !
villakoecher 11 months ago 2
Pshhh. The National Anthem of Nutopia is better.
Aaron1343 1 year ago
I'm gonna sing this in American Idol the next year, i think it fits my voice
sueellen360 1 year ago
pause this video to listen to my cover of this song!!
cw71017 1 year ago
owww, that's catchy !
Riscotta 1 year ago
Hopefully WMG doesn't mute this song as with so many others
NWG92 1 year ago 13
I can play this song on a church organ! Second movement is a bit tricky at first but can be easily learned.
artman40 1 year ago 5
I love this music. I've never heared music like this. Kiss Kiss Kiss
llav1990 1 year ago
im confused...
annieboooo 1 year ago
this song was stolen by pootie tang!
JackNeroActionHero 1 year ago
The Quality of Audio is Bad!!!
CliffAllEm 1 year ago
@CliffAllEm What are you talking about? You can't find better quality anywhere else on Youtube!
Tyger355 1 year ago
My head is sore from all the banging it's been doing to this song.
EamonGr 1 year ago 2
I don't like the dissonant chords. It could have had more harmony between 2:00 and 2:36.
No, really I like what he did here.
NewsSocial 1 year ago 4
definately my new ringtone :D
yeah1101 1 year ago 3
i was reading some of the comments and didn't notice the video ended about 2 minutes ago
XXXXmrcheesemanXXXX 1 year ago 2
I hope Youtube doesn't remove sound track due to copyright
trallawan 1 year ago 12
@trallawan
On the other video WMG removed the audio !!!
It's just so rediculous!!
RupertDCD27 1 year ago 8
Holy.... too much too maintain at 2:50
georgiemann 1 year ago
should have been christmas number one!
dragonfliesATdawn 1 year ago 4
1:37 is the best part!
SliZe36 1 year ago 2
@SliZe36 nahh 1:49 best bit .... can't you see the jizz face??
georgiemann 1 year ago
Perfect for karaoke!
xabsazx 1 year ago
It's a Christmas number one!
dannyamosflynn 1 year ago
An advantage
You do not hear false notes!
bad song
dnomyar112 1 year ago
whoever wrote the lyrics must have worked on it for a long time
whenstickmeneatcrack 1 year ago
This song is so hard to cover.
TheOverItFellow 1 year ago
This is fucked up, if you think this is music than you are crazy like a motherfocker:S
sammie6885 1 year ago
Never been a fan of orchestral music but this is an exception to the rule!
This is an absolute masterpiece! Let's hope this delivers on Sunday by beating that bloke who won this year's Crap Factor!
ghpg2008 1 year ago
thats funny, this song starts to play every time my battery of my iPod is dead
douwepieter 1 year ago 2
My favorite part was at 1:49
rutgerpiechers 1 year ago 3
IS IT ME OR DID EVERYONE WASTE 4:34 MINUITE OF THERE LIFE LISTENING TO ABOUSOLOTLY NOTHING YEAH IM SOOOOOOOOOOO GONNA LISTEN TO THIS AT CHRISTMAS WE MIGHT AS WELL ALL BE MORING ON CHRISTMAS DAY BUT IS IT NOT SAID SOMEWHERE THAT CHRISTMAS IS A TIME FOR HAPPINESS AND JOY AND FOR GATHERING AND TALKING AND CATCHING UP PLEASE EVERYONE WATCH ANNOYING ORANGE ITS SOOOOOOOOOO FUNNY LIKE IF YOU LOLED AT IT!
cupcake777121 1 year ago
11 people couldn't handle the noise
FantasyLDZ 1 year ago 3
i hate it when the bass line drops
pchurk 1 year ago 3
its so awesome
TheToms3333 1 year ago
my next door neighbours new favorite song.
jackbmx21 1 year ago
@jackbmx21 are they dead?
ieatpeople4breakfast 1 year ago
I can't get this song out of my head >.<
ssmeets 1 year ago 2
Much better than any of Justin Bieber's music!!
vgmaster9 1 year ago 90
@vgmaster9 shhhh
sydbarrett5 1 year ago 23
This song shall be played in my funeral.
ruiolas 1 year ago
lyk if you pressed mute ^.^
farrellyred 1 year ago
Lets get this to Xmas No. 1, it would make me laugh anyway!!!
ayrshireguy7 1 year ago
I seriously hope this beats Simon Cowell's new creation just to wipe that smug smile off his face once and for all!
OptimaxX 1 year ago
Omg , is this a joke ? please dont tell me people are actually going to buy this just to get one over X factor ? Whoever buys this is an r-tard. I mean, rage last year was immense, but this? Get a life and stop crying about X factor.
DominoFelix 1 year ago
what i like about this is that it is 4 minutes and 33 seconds long and yet when you listen to it it seems to go on forever,
flamingbartman 1 year ago
Great song for studying! Helps me concentrate.
felix10271 1 year ago 7
tabs?
TheGrayRevolution 1 year ago 29
@TheGrayRevolution see below
sydbarrett5 1 year ago
The idea that the piece is a time to hear the sounds of the environment is kind of interesting. Still pompous and retarded, though
Lepretr0n 1 year ago
My Parents Told Me To Turn It Down!
TheGaffa99 1 year ago 7
most-played song of 2010
metaserve 1 year ago
Heard this was being used as this year's anti- XFactor song. Brilliant! Not only will we show Simon Cowel and all the other leeches what for but we'll show them that their "music" isn't even worth using instruments to protest against. Personally prefered last years (I kept screaming METAL IS VICTORIOUS until I couldn't speak on Xmas day but it was worth it) but hey it's more artistic than anything pop has ever contributed!
kingkong381 1 year ago
Can you add the music? I can't hear it.
jarblewarble 1 year ago 3
This is equivalent to a painter presenting a blank canvas as a work of art.
wisemeat 1 year ago 14