林憶蓮2011年廣東歌 - 枯榮 (Full Version)

[mildbutcalmless]

Tori Amos !



[HoNgVVW]

好難聽咪唔好聽 有人叫您聽咩

[chan808yuen]

我要睇歌詞先知歌詞

[AERVSDADA]

講真...好難聽 - -



[alanaaaify]

@AERVSDADA

同意,好難聽X2

[nickng81]

@alanaaaify

换你唱，应该更难听X10！

[nickng81]

@AERVSDADA

换你唱，应该更难听！

[zumtang2000]

驟爾 <- 突然的，快速的，没有一点征兆。

[omdyksjhwp]

驟爾既意思係咩??

[zxz4682]

詞又好 曲又好 最重要係唱得好 =好好聽

[hypermonster]

i thought it's Faye Wong when I heard it the first time from the radio....

[kensome]

與"先生"比她這不是抄~

[MrJim1999]

似 Cocteau Twins 的 Alice. 早期 Faye Wong 都似 Cocteau Twins. 冇乜問題丫. 好正呀!

[crazybelieve]

初初我以為係謝安琪唱==



[leochan0723]

講咁多抄乜抄物做咩，你地搵到個而家啲所謂歌手唱到呢隻歌，我即­刻收自己皮，幫你班粉腸挽鞋重得。

[mattck312]

@leochan0723 agree x 10

[s6f318484]

越聽越有味道...

[victorcly1991415]

像林憶連這種實力超班的天后級歌手

才可駕馭這首歌

[Sporty87]

哈哈！真的很好笑！又說似《God》，又說似《Spark》，又­說似《Crucify》，說了一大堆Tori Amos的歌曲，但是沒一首是真正的相似。

如果《枯榮》真的與這三首歌相似，那豈不是Tori Amos自己與自己的歌曲也很相似嗎？哈哈！

[hkgnyc]

好飄 好好聽

[leanhk]

唉, 80% copied from Tori Amo's "Spark"

[bernardchan0301]

@leanhk 80%说得太夸张了吧，这不能说是copy,至多是风格上的致敬­吧

[miruru623]

now it's 11st in 903.com,add oil

[fancycruz]

Faye Wong "闷" MV？so Faye...

[ivososo]

the arrangement is very tori-ish, other the spark, it feels like a slower version of Welcome to England

[TDEVOLI]

Sounds like Faye Wong in the chorus... good one!

[JLprojects]

Sandy, 我打從87年 [ 憶蓮 ] 大碟, 已經成為你的follower, 真的很高興看到你的新嘗試. 從歌詞中聽得到你現在對生命的感受. 長久追隨你的歌迷如我都經歷不少, 人生又豈止只有愛情呢? 這次的內容在你過去的主打歌中是絕無僅有的. 畢竟你和你的歌迷都長大了. 坦白說, 近年來我的耳朵悄悄地被Shirley Kwan吸引過去, 她09年的 [ 山水 ] 給我很大的感受. 我的心問: 為什麼 Sandy 除了愛情的主題外, 很少在主打中流露其他想法呢? 所以很驚訝這次的新曲. 新唱腔方面, 真的給我觸動神經感受, 憶蓮有膽唱, 我就有膽聽呵! 在這裡希望你keep住勇於嘗試的心, 我期待著你的新大碟和9月的演出.  JEFFREY

[AERVSDADA]

好難聽.....好似呼吸咁..........完全...5系­歌~



[MeiMei7086]

無得頂..



[xingxing14]

風格係似,但Tori Amos冇歌同依首一樣喎,定我聽得唔夠多?

[pochiwu2008]

應該係抄 Tori Amos 果首 "GOD" 前奏 9 成似

[puff1015]

@pochiwu2008 是tori amos 的spark吧,歌曲配器和情绪一模一样

[miruru623]

@pochiwu2008 ,@pochiwu2008

you fail

[sun1985]

@pochiwu2008

真係9成似wor!

一樣又用鼓又用琴wor!!



[pochiwu2008]

similar to (or copy) Tori Amos "Spark"

[seanlee101gmailcom]

喜欢林忆莲和王菲的朋友，你一定会爱死林忆莲的新歌“枯荣”。

王菲那种唱腔，林忆莲一早就有。。只是一直都是轻描淡写的。。这­次因应词曲的需要而发挥的淋漓尽致！



[deckwilber]

Love Sandy and Faye...They are all my lovely singer. No one can compare each other.

[1128135]

我想叫林若寧睇下乜野先係填詞...

[puff1015]

林忆莲声音比王菲温暖多了.王菲声音太冷了..

[stgf1080]

@puff1015 對阿.憶蓮最棒



[puff1015]

大家觉得这首歌包括配器和和声像tori amos 的哪首歌?

[lnlo]

@puff1015 Spark? Beekeeper?

[ITEA0919]

@puff1015 Tori Amos - Crucify

[enotsin]

Absolutely breathtaking song.

The composer uses a lot of interesting intervals, and Bb minor is a rather unusual key for a female singer. The way Sandy makes transition from one note to another is a little bit similar to faye wong but with more control, refinement and precision.

Its amazing how she jump from Eb down to G when she sing 枯...榮.

The ending with a dominant below the tonic Bb is really cool.

This the melody and the intervals marries so perfectly with cantonese!

[TDEVOLI]

The high notes in chorus resemble that signature sound of Faye Wong...

[freebryant2004]

扣人心弦, 不自覺地重播. 好!

[zumtang2000]

又係新突破 !!

[alvinshcn]

hey sandy! ditch the stupid taiwanese ballads and do more songs like this!!! whenever sandy sings in cantonese, it's not just a change of dialect - sandy becomes an entirely different and interesting person. mandarin sandy is kind of boring... let's face it - in the music industry of today, sandy will not be able to make money by releasing any new album - no matter cantonese or mandarin. if she has to do a new album, why not do a fun cantonese album??

[willboy024]

這首歌很特別，Sandy的聲音很棒!!!



[shutterwill]

聽電視台條 trailer 頭幾句已經覺得呢首歌好聽.

難得林憶蓮已經成名好耐都繼續尋求突破,真係令人佩服呢.

[kelvolord]

甘低音都唱到個感覺出黎, 而且可以好清楚睇到佢唱咩!!! 感情既含蓄但又有感染力!!正!!



[calvin7651]

歌詞寫得太好了。

[kent007tnek]

我唯一的偶像，就是Sandy.

[6110angie]

太厲害了!每個詞都能用聲音詮釋出來，整體也營造出歌曲主題的氛­圍!

[valleybeneaththesea]

The glittering music arrangment, the poetic lyrics, the designed Sandys vocals and her ghostly beautiful delivery, branded it into a astonishing production.

[melonersg]

赞！赞！赞！