So God send His only Son Jesus, who was perfect and holy, like we should have been. His blood was enough. It was the only way to bring us back to God. Why? We don't really know, because God is God. Be still and know. He does not have to render accounts for His works. He loves us, that's why He gave His Son.
"So God send His only Son Jesus, who was perfect and holy, like we should have been. His blood was enough. It was the only way to bring us back to God."
Why?
"We don't really know, because God is God. Be still and know."
That doesn't answer my question...
You just asking me to believe what you are saying because you want me too...
@Hammersley1967 Because He IS the Master of the universe. He made it! He didn't put it aside after creating it. He made it for Himself, to be glorified. So He is bothering anything that happens. Because He made it. Loves it. He does not want to destroy it - which is His right.
"Because He IS the Master of the universe. He made it! He didn't put it aside after creating it. He made it for Himself, to be glorified. So He is bothering anything that happens. Because He made it. Loves it. He does not want to destroy it"
If He created and loves the Universe, why then would he give human beings the capacity to do evil?
Furthermore, why would he then create a son to be tortured and killed to absolve human evil.
Ummmm... you don't have to know someone status/power to ask them a question. Plus, you have to admit that "God works in mysterious ways" doesn't make sense. When an action is made (by anyone, even a GOD) it must have an end and a repeated use in the same way. That is "how something works". If not, it is know as random, by pure HAPENSTANCE. So god (aka, the Earth/Whatever) just does shit randomly.
it is a moot point bc even if it were spelled out for you..your ears and heart are closed and you wont recieve the truth anyway...no one can explain why, or how to you all we can do is presnt you with the truth, other than that we are wasting breath, but you know this already..right
"Your question wasnt does God exist? because you must assume that the writer of Without blood, there is no remission of sin., actually exists to then ask why that was said."
Given the fact that you have absolutely failed to give a sensible explanation as to why "the only thing that can really remove guilt is the sacrifice of the innocent", I can only surmise that YOU "haven't figured it out yet" - in any way, shape, or form...
Because "god says so" is not an explanation...
Even President Obama has a rationale for, and explains his directives....
"God sets the rules and that is a rule. Sorry so simple, but if you think about it, the only thing that can really remove guilt is the sacrifice of the innocent. Are you in need of something more definitive?"
Definitive? No.
But something that actually makes sense would be good!
"The only thing that can really remove guilt is the sacrifice of the innocent" because "god says so" does not make sense - no matter how much ANYONE "thinks about it".
A man with sin can't take sin away, Jesus was without sin so He could take it away. And why Jesus was a sacrifice to cover our sins is because in the old testament God told us the one way to remove sin is to sacrifice a "clean" animal and He makes that very clear in Leviticus. And it shouldn't be hard to understand that a robber can't tell you not to rob and therefor a sinner can't tell you or take away your sins, only the pure and perfect in spirit can, and that only one is Jesus Christ.
The reason the sacrifice was necessary was because Gods wrath had to be put down, God had to punish us and one of the ways to do it was to sacrifice a clean animal, remember people lived off of animals for a long time. God loves us more than animals so he'd rather punish the animals although people were and still are punished for their sins. Like I can't type out the whole answer to you as it is a complicated topic, but why don't you go as your local pastor, or do you not want an answer.
"The reason the sacrifice was necessary was because Gods wrath had to be put down, God had to punish us and one of the ways to do it was to sacrifice a clean animal"
You're just reiterating the same nonsensical argument and not answering my question: Why?
"God loves us more than animals so he'd rather punish the animals although people were and still are punished for their sins"
Once again, God created the universe, so why bother with the whole sin/redemption circus in the first place?
@Hammersley1967 Everywhere. If you're just willing to see Him. Reed the Bible, chapters 37-41 of Job.
God is the Holy One, He cannot bear our sins. He should have condemned us for eternity and demand our blood, but our blood will never fully pay. Our works will never be enough. In the Old Testament God gave the commandment to sacrifice animals, because He wanted blood to pay the sinners dept. But their blood wasn't enough too. They had to sacrifice over and over.
"He cannot bear our sins. He should have condemned us for eternity and demand our blood, but our blood will never fully pay"
Why?
"Our works will never be enough. In the Old Testament God gave the commandment to sacrifice animals, because He wanted blood to pay the sinners dept."
Why?
"But their blood wasn't enough too. They had to sacrifice over and over."
"It's better to decide than to straddle the fence all your life."
I have heard this cliche from theists and atheists alike all my life. Whenever someone says this to me in regards to theosophical matters I always ask:
"Don't ask your pompous questions without having done your own research. God can answer for Himself"
1) In case it wasn't CLEARLY obvious already, I guess I should point out that I don't believe that god existws...
2) I've done and am doing "the research" by asking Christians (as well as having read the bible) such as yourself this simple question. To date neither your book of fairy tales nor ANY Christian has provided an adequate or even remotely convincing answer.
Rather than engaging in ad hominem attacks on me, hiding behind your "all-knowing" god, and directing me to a book of fairy tales, why don't you actually defend your belief system by attempting to answer this quite obvious and simple question - and then be accountable for that answer?
Either you can answer the question or you can't. Your entire belief system is dependent upon your answer to this straightforward question.
How 'bout it Christian soldier? Not too much of a stretch for ya is it?
With a complete vacuum of evidence for this "truth"?
And this "truth" is "truer" than all those other superstitious "truths" that have fallen by the wayside over the millenia of human existence (such a the Greek and Pagan gods)?
And this "Creator" does not have a creator of its own? It just "is" without a prior cause - thus defying the fundamental "cause and effect" law of the Universe?
No my friend, YOU indeed live a far more miraculous life than I ever will...
God Almighty can do what ever He/She/It likes can't it? It created the Universe and its natural laws didn't it?
It can also intervene and break those laws whenever it chooses - right? So why go to the bother and heartache of conjuring up, torturing, and then extinguishing a "Son" in order to "wash away" the "sins of mankind"?
Why not just "cut to the chase" and wash 'em away in the first instance, and do away with the charade?
If we actually came from Adam and Eve wouldnt we all be a bunch of inbreds?
and why do people look different than others, natural selection doesnt back it up eg asian eyes, it wouldnt hav been shaped like that to adapt to there environment because most environments are the same.
i dont know if i believe in god, i mean i want 2 but theres not enough proof to make me
wat ever u end up doing with your prob if he iz real or not **i believe** if he iz real he will forgive if he'z not idk but yeah...WOOT good movie.... lol :p
The evidence of God is all around us. For those of us who believe, that is a fact that needs no scientific study to make it so. Your argument of 'science tells us otherwise' will never convince a true believer to stop believing, so you may as well stop trying. We are well aware that the existence of God will never be unequivocally proven through science & we're okay with that :-) Think about it - if that ever happened, there would be no need for faith & it is by that faith that we are saved.
although i do agree that god exists. and that science will most likely never prove gods existence, i must say that your argument (we're right because we believe we are) is a bit unreliable. For personal faith, that's a fine reason to believe in god. But when it comes to discussion or debate, you need something a little more substantial.
God is a fairytale, I cannot believe in this day and age that people still believe that a GOD made the world n seven days, science tells us otherwise. we should have by now outgrown the need to believe in gods. stop wasting your money and time and live yourself a good life free from condemnation and fear which is what religion is about. imagine a world without prejudice without war, that is a world without false deities. people are not compelled to fight wars without the fervor of religion.
Had you actually read a bible you would know that time means nothing to God and that a hundred years could be but a day to God. So while science says that it is impossible to create a world in seven days it could very well have thousands of years. Would that not mean that both were correct? You need to spell check by the way.
You believe everything don't you? Just because somebody's name has P.H.D. next to it? Let me tell you something even though you wont listen, you don't have an absolute theory. There are holes in it. You can't explain why life started and even the very first single celled organisms are some of the most complex things on the planet. And Christianity promotes pacifism and same with most religions so if we would all follow religions there will be no war, murder, or crime.
But you know, if we don't believe in religions then we can start wars over land, skin color, money, and pretty much everything else. And lastly I have a feeling that you will call me an unintelligent racist just because I believe in a god. So maybe were racist because thats human nature and not because of a religion. Now Im happy that you were able to make a decision between science and religion but don't say that religion is a bad thing, because its not, it teaches the same morals you are.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
God is a fairytale, I cannot believe in this day and age that people still believe that a GOD made the world n seven days, science tells us otherwise. we should have by now outgrown the need to believe in gods. stop wasting your money and time and live yourself a good life free from condemnation and fear which is what religion is about. imagine a world without prejudice without war, that is a world without false deities. people are not compelled to fight wars without the fervor of religion.
This a a beautiful movie, It made roll my tears. I love the part when they get baptized and also when the girl asks "Does he have a name?" and the Man of God says "Yes, His name is Jesus" :)
sorry... i wasnt JUST talking to you... why do you feel this way about this movie? i find it amazing and truthful about how you feel when you find God
What is with all you people???? have you acually Talked to God???? Well guess what I have I know the joy that comes over you when you speak to god and ask him to forgive you. and there are many others who feel the same. you know, you should really TRY somthing or GET TO KNOW HIM untill you judge
You know, you really suck. Do you even know ANYTHING about this movie?? You obviously havn't read the book. Save your opinions, no matter how itiotic, for all the other crap here on YouTube. This movie trailer is not one of them.
PLEASE DONT READ THIS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT TO AT LEAST 3 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS. NOW UV STARTED READIN DIS DUNT STOP THIS IS SO SCARY. SEND THIS OVER TO 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY BECAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKs
probably because of the killing. although, it's not gory at all. oh well. i suppose religious movies would be more modest in ratings. i loved this movie, it's my fave of all time. :)
i saw the movie, but i didn't read the book, i didn't know there was one. :( i would have read the book first if i had known. o well. the title's the same, right? i'll have to look in my public library.
Don't belive the stupid critics bashing this one, it is indeed a great and touching film. Critics need to grow up, all they want is flashy effects and mindless killing in their movies..well you not gonna find that here just a great story thats all.
i liked this movie a lot. half the time their accents were a little off....but thats okay. GREAT MOVIE anyway. i definitely would recommend this to anyone.
Eventually, we all come to a place of facing our ugly self....alone. It is a very dark, troubling experience for most. If and when you experience this moment in time, watch this movie!! It will be the Gladiator and Braveheart X2 at that point in your life!
oh yeah? we'll YOU'RE an individual with an alternate lifestyle. (gay, lol. this is how my teacher said to say it. she also suggested "dunce-like." haha.)
One of the best Christian movies i have seen! I cried from the start to the end :). May God allow more movies like this to be produced. It was about time! :)
If everything sims not working out and u think der r no hope... then this flicks 4 u. Scripts not critically perfect, but this movies one of the best! Believ me, ill bet my own breath...
WOW...what a movie, what a movie. One of the best i have ever seen, and i don't give a damn shit about what thoese critics said. I'ts HIGHLY RECOMENDED
I love this movie! A lot of critics said it wasn't good, but that's because they don't understand the importance of it. I'm also a fan of Francine's books, so this movie was a special to my heart! I loved it! Graet job!
As a person that has lived their entire life in middle and east Tennesse, Their used to be a very large Welsh Community here. Sad to know that all that way of life is fading away,but alot of it needs to go away too.
As a fan of Peter Wingfield I want to see this film. A friend who already saw it said...
"Yes, I saw it just this week. Great movie and Peter's role in it is amazing. It's about a Welsh tribe of Celtic people in the Appalachian Mountains in the eighteen hundreds. Peter plays the part of the last sin eater. I won't spoil it for you and say any more, other than Peter brought me to tears with his dramatic portrayal of this sad man. Go see it; you won't be sorry."
So God send His only Son Jesus, who was perfect and holy, like we should have been. His blood was enough. It was the only way to bring us back to God. Why? We don't really know, because God is God. Be still and know. He does not have to render accounts for His works. He loves us, that's why He gave His Son.
JoGer1991 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@JoGer1991
"So God send His only Son Jesus, who was perfect and holy, like we should have been. His blood was enough. It was the only way to bring us back to God."
Why?
"We don't really know, because God is God. Be still and know."
That doesn't answer my question...
You just asking me to believe what you are saying because you want me too...
Hammersley1967 1 year ago
@JoGer1991
"He does not have to render accounts for His works. He loves us, that's why He gave His Son."
He's the Master of the Universe isn't he?
Why bother with the corruption of human morality and the subsequent blood bath to atone for it?
Why bother with any of it in the first place?
Hammersley1967 1 year ago
@Hammersley1967 Because He IS the Master of the universe. He made it! He didn't put it aside after creating it. He made it for Himself, to be glorified. So He is bothering anything that happens. Because He made it. Loves it. He does not want to destroy it - which is His right.
JoGer1991 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@JoGer1991
"Because He IS the Master of the universe. He made it! He didn't put it aside after creating it. He made it for Himself, to be glorified. So He is bothering anything that happens. Because He made it. Loves it. He does not want to destroy it"
If He created and loves the Universe, why then would he give human beings the capacity to do evil?
Furthermore, why would he then create a son to be tortured and killed to absolve human evil.
Why not absolve the evil himself?
Hammersley1967 1 year ago
Ummmm... you don't have to know someone status/power to ask them a question. Plus, you have to admit that "God works in mysterious ways" doesn't make sense. When an action is made (by anyone, even a GOD) it must have an end and a repeated use in the same way. That is "how something works". If not, it is know as random, by pure HAPENSTANCE. So god (aka, the Earth/Whatever) just does shit randomly.
Peeples01 2 years ago
"If you cant understand the concept of God, then wondering why he does something is a mute point, is it not?"
Who says "I can't understand the concept of God"? You?
As a raised Catholic, I understand the concept of god - I just don't believe in it...
Why does a non-belief in god make my questioning of Christian doctrine "a mute point"?
Explain?
Hammersley1967 2 years ago
it is a moot point bc even if it were spelled out for you..your ears and heart are closed and you wont recieve the truth anyway...no one can explain why, or how to you all we can do is presnt you with the truth, other than that we are wasting breath, but you know this already..right
j846860j 2 years ago
"no one can explain why, or how to you"
I wonder why?
Because you guys don't even understand your own bullshit...
"all we can do is presnt you with the truth"
If it were the truth, then you would be able to explain it clearly and succinctly...
You cant... Why?
Because it is a myth that doesn't make sense...
Hammersley1967 2 years ago
"First you must acknowledge the power of the president before you can ask why he sent her. Right?"
Nope.
Whether or not I believe in god, it does not follow that I can't question the rationale of the "divine law"...
How does not acknowledging the "the power of the president" relinquish my right to question the his/her policies?
This REALLY is a silly metaphor and line of argumentation you are taking here...
Hammersley1967 2 years ago
"Your question wasnt does God exist? because you must assume that the writer of Without blood, there is no remission of sin., actually exists to then ask why that was said."
WTF? That makes no sense whatsoever...
Hammersley1967 2 years ago
"This is not hard to figure out."
Given the fact that you have absolutely failed to give a sensible explanation as to why "the only thing that can really remove guilt is the sacrifice of the innocent", I can only surmise that YOU "haven't figured it out yet" - in any way, shape, or form...
Because "god says so" is not an explanation...
Even President Obama has a rationale for, and explains his directives....
Sorry, no cigar...
Hammersley1967 2 years ago
"God sets the rules and that is a rule. Sorry so simple, but if you think about it, the only thing that can really remove guilt is the sacrifice of the innocent. Are you in need of something more definitive?"
Definitive? No.
But something that actually makes sense would be good!
"The only thing that can really remove guilt is the sacrifice of the innocent" because "god says so" does not make sense - no matter how much ANYONE "thinks about it".
"God's" (your) argument is a non sequitor...
Hammersley1967 2 years ago
A man with sin can't take sin away, Jesus was without sin so He could take it away. And why Jesus was a sacrifice to cover our sins is because in the old testament God told us the one way to remove sin is to sacrifice a "clean" animal and He makes that very clear in Leviticus. And it shouldn't be hard to understand that a robber can't tell you not to rob and therefor a sinner can't tell you or take away your sins, only the pure and perfect in spirit can, and that only one is Jesus Christ.
huronwarriors 2 years ago
"because in the old testament God told us the one way to remove sin is to sacrifice a "clean" animal and He makes that very clear in Leviticus."
God created the universe didn't he?
So why would he create a universe in which sin existed at all.
(No doubt you will say that "he gave us the gift of "free will" - *yawn*)
Moreover, why would he create a universe in which the "one way to remove sin is to sacrifice a "clean" animal"?
Why bother with any of this circus in the first place?
Hammersley1967 2 years ago
The reason the sacrifice was necessary was because Gods wrath had to be put down, God had to punish us and one of the ways to do it was to sacrifice a clean animal, remember people lived off of animals for a long time. God loves us more than animals so he'd rather punish the animals although people were and still are punished for their sins. Like I can't type out the whole answer to you as it is a complicated topic, but why don't you go as your local pastor, or do you not want an answer.
huronwarriors 2 years ago
"The reason the sacrifice was necessary was because Gods wrath had to be put down, God had to punish us and one of the ways to do it was to sacrifice a clean animal"
You're just reiterating the same nonsensical argument and not answering my question: Why?
"God loves us more than animals so he'd rather punish the animals although people were and still are punished for their sins"
Once again, God created the universe, so why bother with the whole sin/redemption circus in the first place?
Hammersley1967 2 years ago
@Hammersley1967 Why don't you ask Him?
JoGer1991 1 year ago
@JoGer1991
Who?
Hammersley1967 1 year ago
@Hammersley1967 God
JoGer1991 1 year ago
@JoGer1991
Where is he?
Hammersley1967 1 year ago
@Hammersley1967 Everywhere. If you're just willing to see Him. Reed the Bible, chapters 37-41 of Job.
God is the Holy One, He cannot bear our sins. He should have condemned us for eternity and demand our blood, but our blood will never fully pay. Our works will never be enough. In the Old Testament God gave the commandment to sacrifice animals, because He wanted blood to pay the sinners dept. But their blood wasn't enough too. They had to sacrifice over and over.
JoGer1991 1 year ago
@JoGer1991
"Everywhere. If you're just willing to see Him."
Oh I willing to see Him...
Why wouldn't I be?
I've never experienced an omniscient, omnipotent, benevolent, interventional, creative being or intelligence in my life...
I've prayed... meditated... looked...
Nup... Can't see Him...
Hammersley1967 1 year ago
@Hammersley1967 Then I cannot help you, none of us. God has another plan with you.
JoGer1991 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@JoGer1991
"Then I cannot help you, none of us. God has another plan with you."
Why?
Hammersley1967 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@JoGer1991
"He cannot bear our sins. He should have condemned us for eternity and demand our blood, but our blood will never fully pay"
Why?
"Our works will never be enough. In the Old Testament God gave the commandment to sacrifice animals, because He wanted blood to pay the sinners dept."
Why?
"But their blood wasn't enough too. They had to sacrifice over and over."
Why?
Hammersley1967 1 year ago
"I can't type out the whole answer to you as it is a complicated topic, but why don't you go as your local pastor, or do you not want an answer."
Oh, I want the answer...
It's just that you are just incapable of giving to me...
But don't feel badly - I've asked the very same question Catholic priests, Protestant pastors and even Catholic arch bishops...
Like you, they were also incapable of answering this simple question which brings the entire Christain doctrine into doubt...
Hammersley1967 2 years ago
Omg! This movie is awsome!
eliannacullen 2 years ago
"It's better to decide than to straddle the fence all your life."
I have heard this cliche from theists and atheists alike all my life. Whenever someone says this to me in regards to theosophical matters I always ask:
WHY?
Hammersley1967 2 years ago
"Will you listen?"
I'm all ears...
Hammersley1967 2 years ago
"Don't ask your pompous questions without having done your own research. God can answer for Himself"
1) In case it wasn't CLEARLY obvious already, I guess I should point out that I don't believe that god existws...
2) I've done and am doing "the research" by asking Christians (as well as having read the bible) such as yourself this simple question. To date neither your book of fairy tales nor ANY Christian has provided an adequate or even remotely convincing answer.
Nothin', nada, zilch...
Hammersley1967 2 years ago
Rather than engaging in ad hominem attacks on me, hiding behind your "all-knowing" god, and directing me to a book of fairy tales, why don't you actually defend your belief system by attempting to answer this quite obvious and simple question - and then be accountable for that answer?
Either you can answer the question or you can't. Your entire belief system is dependent upon your answer to this straightforward question.
How 'bout it Christian soldier? Not too much of a stretch for ya is it?
Hammersley1967 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
"For God so loved the world that he gave His only begotten Son so that whoever would believe in Him will not perish but have Eternal Life."
I say again...
Why?
No Christian has ever been able to adequately explain this.
Hammersley1967 3 years ago
"Without the shedding of blood there is no forgiveness of sins."
Why?
Hammersley1967 3 years ago
Eh, my friend played a small role in this movie but it looks just lame...
choidj 3 years ago
I just watched (half an hour ago) this ridiculous fucking movie on cable.
At the end, the Welsh hillbillies swap one ludicrous superstition for another.
What a wonderful tribute to the rational liberation of mankind... NOT!!!
Hammersley1967 3 years ago
You live in a life much more miraculous than I do!: That life could be here without a Creator.
I know that life is created and maintained by God, and that Jesus came to earth to make payment for sin.
This is reality.
oneandatwo 3 years ago
Really? And you KNOW this?
With a complete vacuum of evidence for this "truth"?
And this "truth" is "truer" than all those other superstitious "truths" that have fallen by the wayside over the millenia of human existence (such a the Greek and Pagan gods)?
And this "Creator" does not have a creator of its own? It just "is" without a prior cause - thus defying the fundamental "cause and effect" law of the Universe?
No my friend, YOU indeed live a far more miraculous life than I ever will...
Hammersley1967 3 years ago
"Jesus came to earth to make payment for sin."
Why?
God Almighty can do what ever He/She/It likes can't it? It created the Universe and its natural laws didn't it?
It can also intervene and break those laws whenever it chooses - right? So why go to the bother and heartache of conjuring up, torturing, and then extinguishing a "Son" in order to "wash away" the "sins of mankind"?
Why not just "cut to the chase" and wash 'em away in the first instance, and do away with the charade?
Hammersley1967 3 years ago
"This is reality."
I'll inform the editors of the Oxford English Dictionary of this new definition of the term "reality"...
Hammersley1967 3 years ago
Somebody once told me they were putting on Welsh accents in this film. How gullible was I!
jewishcow 3 years ago
Yeah, I guess you actually have to have some taste buds to know whether you are watching a good movie or not. Clearly you are missing yours.
brbird 3 years ago
this movie scared the crap out of me
keduardop 3 years ago
It's a good movie. I really enjoyed it.
mjsmaling 3 years ago
I just watched the movie... That is exactly what a belief in imaginary gods produces...
P.S.
Mythos?!?! ;O)
Katalyzt
Katalyzt 3 years ago
Very very Deep movie.
ThatsDestiny 3 years ago
i think jenna haze is the best sin eater. i like it when she eats more then one sin at a time. nevermind i'm fucking stupid, i know.
XXXninjabladeXXX 3 years ago
If we actually came from Adam and Eve wouldnt we all be a bunch of inbreds?
and why do people look different than others, natural selection doesnt back it up eg asian eyes, it wouldnt hav been shaped like that to adapt to there environment because most environments are the same.
i dont know if i believe in god, i mean i want 2 but theres not enough proof to make me
ekzplicit 3 years ago
wat ever u end up doing with your prob if he iz real or not **i believe** if he iz real he will forgive if he'z not idk but yeah...WOOT good movie.... lol :p
inuyashareallyreal 3 years ago
man that is the best book i've ever read *other than the bible* and i had to read it for school!! ... *goes to an awesomely cool private school*
OmishuKitsuni 3 years ago
this movie is so fucking ghey, if you want to learn more about Sin Eaters, watch The Order!
blinx182 3 years ago
The evidence of God is all around us. For those of us who believe, that is a fact that needs no scientific study to make it so. Your argument of 'science tells us otherwise' will never convince a true believer to stop believing, so you may as well stop trying. We are well aware that the existence of God will never be unequivocally proven through science & we're okay with that :-) Think about it - if that ever happened, there would be no need for faith & it is by that faith that we are saved.
flaminglocks 3 years ago 5
although i do agree that god exists. and that science will most likely never prove gods existence, i must say that your argument (we're right because we believe we are) is a bit unreliable. For personal faith, that's a fine reason to believe in god. But when it comes to discussion or debate, you need something a little more substantial.
blaisewinnebago 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
God is a fairytale, I cannot believe in this day and age that people still believe that a GOD made the world n seven days, science tells us otherwise. we should have by now outgrown the need to believe in gods. stop wasting your money and time and live yourself a good life free from condemnation and fear which is what religion is about. imagine a world without prejudice without war, that is a world without false deities. people are not compelled to fight wars without the fervor of religion.
YHVH 3 years ago
Had you actually read a bible you would know that time means nothing to God and that a hundred years could be but a day to God. So while science says that it is impossible to create a world in seven days it could very well have thousands of years. Would that not mean that both were correct? You need to spell check by the way.
ladyhawke083 3 years ago
And apparently I need to spell check myself. "...it could very will have been thousands of years" is what I meant to type.
ladyhawke083 3 years ago
You believe everything don't you? Just because somebody's name has P.H.D. next to it? Let me tell you something even though you wont listen, you don't have an absolute theory. There are holes in it. You can't explain why life started and even the very first single celled organisms are some of the most complex things on the planet. And Christianity promotes pacifism and same with most religions so if we would all follow religions there will be no war, murder, or crime.
elementaleel 3 years ago
But you know, if we don't believe in religions then we can start wars over land, skin color, money, and pretty much everything else. And lastly I have a feeling that you will call me an unintelligent racist just because I believe in a god. So maybe were racist because thats human nature and not because of a religion. Now Im happy that you were able to make a decision between science and religion but don't say that religion is a bad thing, because its not, it teaches the same morals you are.
elementaleel 3 years ago
omg..tht was such a good movie!!
olivia89ily 4 years ago
don't take the Lords name in vain.
nomad090 3 years ago 2
Cool! 0_0 I'm reading the book and love it..where can i watch the movie?
IluvMoose 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
God is a fairytale, I cannot believe in this day and age that people still believe that a GOD made the world n seven days, science tells us otherwise. we should have by now outgrown the need to believe in gods. stop wasting your money and time and live yourself a good life free from condemnation and fear which is what religion is about. imagine a world without prejudice without war, that is a world without false deities. people are not compelled to fight wars without the fervor of religion.
soahcalm 4 years ago
God bless you all.
SirKerberos 4 years ago
This a a beautiful movie, It made roll my tears. I love the part when they get baptized and also when the girl asks "Does he have a name?" and the Man of God says "Yes, His name is Jesus" :)
SirKerberos 4 years ago 2
is this the sequal to the sin eater movie, released in 2003??
reunat 4 years ago
No it's not a sequel to "The Order"
logistix123 4 years ago
So, a practicing and faithful liberal Catholic? That means you believe what exactly?
robatrhema 4 years ago
I loved it!!!!! Its worth watching
AfterTheRAin 4 years ago
1 of my fave movies. :)
Nita131313 4 years ago
Have you actually seen this movie? I have not.
JeffreyBeanJr 4 years ago
sorry... i wasnt JUST talking to you... why do you feel this way about this movie? i find it amazing and truthful about how you feel when you find God
broadwaygirl1991 4 years ago
What is with all you people???? have you acually Talked to God???? Well guess what I have I know the joy that comes over you when you speak to god and ask him to forgive you. and there are many others who feel the same. you know, you should really TRY somthing or GET TO KNOW HIM untill you judge
broadwaygirl1991 4 years ago 2
It looks like a interesting movie.
usmartine 4 years ago
Yes, the book was definetly better than the movie. They left out so many good parts! And yeah, the accents get annoying. LoL
BGXRFan4eva 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Gay...
Fuck
makens2 4 years ago
You know, you really suck. Do you even know ANYTHING about this movie?? You obviously havn't read the book. Save your opinions, no matter how itiotic, for all the other crap here on YouTube. This movie trailer is not one of them.
BGXRFan4eva 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
PLEASE DONT READ THIS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT TO AT LEAST 3 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS. NOW UV STARTED READIN DIS DUNT STOP THIS IS SO SCARY. SEND THIS OVER TO 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY BECAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKs
funkytime101 4 years ago
Now that I look back on it, they left out a lot of great scenes from the book. But it was still an awesome movie :)
BGXRFan4eva 4 years ago
SO fer real.
I just watched this movie.
I've NEVER cried this much at a movie.
My FAVORITE.
HopelessRomantic09 4 years ago 2
I loved this movie. Amazing story
HennyMusgrove 4 years ago
i love this movie!!!! i love the name CADI!!!
gigirl476 4 years ago
I almost cried when they killed all the Native Americans.
IamCanadian3333 4 years ago
This is an awesome family movie! I don't understand the pg-13 rating.
nashoutreach 4 years ago
probably because of the killing. although, it's not gory at all. oh well. i suppose religious movies would be more modest in ratings. i loved this movie, it's my fave of all time. :)
SilverFeathre 4 years ago
I just read the book, it was awesome!!! And, there's a LOT of Fagan/Cadi moments. I won't tell you what happens in the end....
BGXRFan4eva 4 years ago
i saw the movie, but i didn't read the book, i didn't know there was one. :( i would have read the book first if i had known. o well. the title's the same, right? i'll have to look in my public library.
SilverFeathre 4 years ago
Don't belive the stupid critics bashing this one, it is indeed a great and touching film. Critics need to grow up, all they want is flashy effects and mindless killing in their movies..well you not gonna find that here just a great story thats all.
clickboym2k 4 years ago 3
The movie wasn't exactly how I imagined - but I really liked it. The sin eater (Sim) was my favorite character, definitely.
julianna625 4 years ago
me too :)
SilverFeathre 4 years ago
I have read the book and I cannot wait to watch the movie!!! I hope it is Great!
JackieDawn1 4 years ago
It was awesome!!!!!!! But it's rated PG-13.
BGXRFan4eva 4 years ago
ok I watched the movie and it is a good movie. I really enjoyed it! I thought it was pretty close to the book.
JackieDawn1 4 years ago
Fagan is for FINE!! <33
hotbacon123 4 years ago
oH MY OH MY WOW !!!!
godroks 4 years ago
i liked this movie a lot. half the time their accents were a little off....but thats okay. GREAT MOVIE anyway. i definitely would recommend this to anyone.
pedaltothemetal08 4 years ago
Eventually, we all come to a place of facing our ugly self....alone. It is a very dark, troubling experience for most. If and when you experience this moment in time, watch this movie!! It will be the Gladiator and Braveheart X2 at that point in your life!
freedomringing 4 years ago
the movie looks gay, silly and boring
gandalf117 4 years ago
oh yeah? we'll YOU'RE an individual with an alternate lifestyle. (gay, lol. this is how my teacher said to say it. she also suggested "dunce-like." haha.)
SilverFeathre 4 years ago
I LOVED THIS MOVIE! Definetly worth watching ever second of it was awsome!
DarthElg 4 years ago
tisk tisk
kYMHUUDINH209 4 years ago
Im gonna eat me some sins!!
brbruner 4 years ago
One of the best Christian movies i have seen! I cried from the start to the end :). May God allow more movies like this to be produced. It was about time! :)
LadyD1979 4 years ago
gay!
solidusm88 4 years ago
Well then don't watch it, and stop acting a fool.
DarthElg 4 years ago
If everything sims not working out and u think der r no hope... then this flicks 4 u. Scripts not critically perfect, but this movies one of the best! Believ me, ill bet my own breath...
Chill!
wincelyuancody 4 years ago
WOW WOW WOW
godroks 4 years ago
WOW...what a movie, what a movie. One of the best i have ever seen, and i don't give a damn shit about what thoese critics said. I'ts HIGHLY RECOMENDED
IronRaven91 4 years ago
this movie totally rocks!! at first it was kinda scary..but i really enjoyed it...
devan814 4 years ago
I love this movie! A lot of critics said it wasn't good, but that's because they don't understand the importance of it. I'm also a fan of Francine's books, so this movie was a special to my heart! I loved it! Graet job!
RedeemedByGodsLove 4 years ago
As a person that has lived their entire life in middle and east Tennesse, Their used to be a very large Welsh Community here. Sad to know that all that way of life is fading away,but alot of it needs to go away too.
catbird007 4 years ago
Why does it need to go away?
jewishcow 3 years ago
because her sister died and her parents blame it on her and she feels guitly
o0tayls0o 3 years ago
best movie i have ever seen in my life! i watched it last night! i HIGHLY recommend it!!
Katiezieg246 4 years ago
O, I want to see this movie!!
Araniel84 4 years ago
great trailer!
reeceracer 4 years ago
As a fan of Peter Wingfield I want to see this film. A friend who already saw it said...
"Yes, I saw it just this week. Great movie and Peter's role in it is amazing. It's about a Welsh tribe of Celtic people in the Appalachian Mountains in the eighteen hundreds. Peter plays the part of the last sin eater. I won't spoil it for you and say any more, other than Peter brought me to tears with his dramatic portrayal of this sad man. Go see it; you won't be sorry."
EvanStar4506 5 years ago
GO Liliana!!!
(she went to my church when she was younger ^_^
pigirlisinthehouse 5 years ago
WOw I hope its as good as it lools
spongebobrockz12 5 years ago
this was a good movie. i saw it, today actually, and loved it. i almost cried. almost.
LtRic0 5 years ago
Hi brian this looks liike an amazing movie
Well i saw you talk today in class and i cant wait to
see the movie tonight!
tabbieluvsyou 5 years ago
this is definately a must see movie!! I've watched it today it is great!
gabiccc 5 years ago