people stop complaining about the plot, Japanese games are great but they always lack in plots, like resident evil, so consider this, Metal Gear is great. Besides, it is a good story in comparison with so many Hollywood film. I'm not saying it's great but just... stop compaining
@pzhuwang well , metal gear solid DO have a good story , i started watching the movies of cubex55 from metal gear solid 2 , and i really really like the story , well resident evil , i don't really like , personal choice
i never complained about the stories of game , except for some , who are terrible good , and the ending really ruins the game
i already finish all metal gear solid saga, but i just can't stop playing metal gear solid 4 it's fucking awesome! i just can't explain how awesome is this game, thank you kojima now i can die in peace
@jcdgcrh As far as I remember, there is an optional codec call somewhere in the game that informs you that they were fitted with cow hearts to power their organic parts (mainly the legs) which explains both why shooting their legs hurts them so much, and why chaff grenades don't totally knock them out, like with the mini geckos.
As for why then they actually make the noise of an animal that they possibly have the heart of? I'm not sure, to make them freaky and frightening to PMCs/rebels/etc.?
when i first saw octupus in there i was like aww fuck imma have to fight this thing then after the cutscene i was cool i dont have 2 then i was like FUUUUUUUUUU-
@cubex55 Excuse me, I've been having this problem lately, I'm not sure if its my headphones or the audio from the video. But there have been moments, probably only in the scenes on the airplane/mission briefings, but when the camera moves off center and the audio fades fast. Like I could barely hear it. it only happens with these videos, but I haven't seen any comments related to this issue so it might just be me.
@cubex55 Excuse me, I've been having this problem lately, I'm not sure if its my headphones or the audio from the video. But there have been moments, probably only in the scenes on the airplane/mission briefings, but when the camera moves off center and the audio fades fast. Like I could barely hear it. it only happens with these videos, but I haven't seen any comments related to this issue so it might just be me.
@R thats part of the game... the audio gets lower to make it more realistic or to make it simplier if u were snake thats ho everything would sound to u ... if otocon was talkin and ur in a flashback or lookin at a comp screen during mission briefing.... then its cuhz ur more focused on whats in front of u besides whos talking to you
@Rioku914 thats part of the game... the audio gets lower to make it more realistic or to make it simplier if u were snake thats ho everything would sound to u ... if otocon was talkin and ur in a flashback or lookin at a comp screen during mission briefing.... then its cuhz ur more focused on whats in front of u besides whos talking to you
oh my god, shut up Drebin... I killed a boss, launder her shit for me, just don't give me some bullshit backstory that I didn't ask for whenever I take down a boss, jesus christ...
i wanna see every mgs ever made, startin from its days on the msx, remade to next gen standards, and sold (along with mgs 4 maybe) on the next gens as one big mgs uber collection boxset!!! if you agree, then copy and paste this comment everywhere there are mgs fans, and spread the word, and maybe we can make it happen!!! for mgs fans everywhere!!!!
At certain points, like when the characters speak really low, I wish there could have been subtitles. But, for the most part, it's fine without. Thanks for uploading this.
i'm glad this otacon lad lost his virginity at last,he seemed like he needed to at his late 30s anyway.. but it was worth the waiting if the ride is naomi.
@NYYankees4240 Yeah, Otacon's stepmother seduced him and they had a relationship. When Otacon's father Huey Emmerich, who appeared in Metal Gear Solid Peace Walker, found out about the affair he committed suicide by drowning himself in their pool almost taking Emma with him.
He's only got three months left on the meter; cut the patronizing, oppressive anti-smoking message already and let the man have his fucking cigarette. What difference could it make?
If it can be a Metal Gear Solid .. while I write the script Kojima may be .. no matter what a true hero ... the saga continues Fan protagonist does not matter .. the real fan cares about history
You said it, my friend. The creators all care about MONEY!!!! Big Piles of MONEY. Videos games are really the next way of storytelling. Schools should make students do game reports, by playing a game, and write dow stuff. That way, we can play games and do homework.
@AJ15ist Thats true, Movies a Video Game today no make any distinction, a Game is capable to convert in a Movie with a Good Storylne, There are many examples, like Heavy Rain, mgs3, mgs2, mgs4, etc, I can continues with the list But there are infinite videogame that look like moviez...and you idea of the sutendent make game reports... I hope God will listen
@Cocaine804 I saw the whole of MGS2 and Raiden wasn't total suck IMO. He was slightly annoying and naive, but not terrible. He was different from Snake and that was good in the way of see things from another perspective for once. But there's no denying Raiden became badass here. Although his road to becoming this way seems pretty sad...
@vgman94 "pretty sad" is an understatement referring to his wifes 'miscarriage' and breakup along with him having the upper half of his skull and his spine being removed from his normal body and grafted into a robot. While, iirc, he was kept conscious throughout the process. Or something.
He explains that in an easter egg message to otacon. He didn't use CQC because it reminded him of Big Boss who taught it to him and betrayed him, but when he sees soldiers using it so badly he can't resist.
it won't, if it was going to then it would have been announced already, the game has been out a while now and the developer has moved on to other projects, like mg:raiden and peace walker
naomi: hot!!
FlipKnowlessk8 6 days ago
1:36:52
Naomi: I Demand Sex! Now!
HapitokP 1 week ago
also dont u think the dum octopus is crazy and anoying
karan1681 2 weeks ago
thumbs up ifits too hard so u came here
karan1681 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
JohNNyBcOoL17 1 month ago
jajaja raiden breakdance
lorenzooox 1 month ago
Did anyone call Otacon when Octopus mimic The MK II?
12kevillosociety 2 months ago
Comment removed
12kevillosociety 2 months ago
laugh while ya killl hhhahahahahahahaahahahahhahahahah
xe286 2 months ago
1:28:17 monitor to the right
Ghormac 3 months ago
WOW! GECKO COW MOO!!!
HeavenHellGate00 3 months ago
Comment removed
HeavenHellGate00 3 months ago
s s s s snake, your f f f f fucking eggs are done
deadeyeslave 3 months ago in playlist More videos from cubex55 6
WHY DO THEY MOO!?
deadeyeslave 3 months ago in playlist More videos from cubex55
@deadeyeslave Same reason they bleed. Their biological components are made from cows.
clovernoris 4 days ago
people stop complaining about the plot, Japanese games are great but they always lack in plots, like resident evil, so consider this, Metal Gear is great. Besides, it is a good story in comparison with so many Hollywood film. I'm not saying it's great but just... stop compaining
pzhuwang 4 months ago
@pzhuwang well , metal gear solid DO have a good story , i started watching the movies of cubex55 from metal gear solid 2 , and i really really like the story , well resident evil , i don't really like , personal choice
i never complained about the stories of game , except for some , who are terrible good , and the ending really ruins the game
VerusWiseman 3 months ago
Comment removed
MrEpezone 4 months ago
Go Drebin.. He just drives to the place and saves Snake and Naomi.
MrEpezone 4 months ago
i already finish all metal gear solid saga, but i just can't stop playing metal gear solid 4 it's fucking awesome! i just can't explain how awesome is this game, thank you kojima now i can die in peace
humans34 4 months ago
Naomi pissed me off with the whole "AH WHAT THE FUCK I CAN'T USE MY WEAPONS!!!!!" in MGS1
killernarwhal117 4 months ago
Shit~ Naomi is turn me on
is that the sign i'm become a Otaku?
fong00001 4 months ago
1:42:00 "Snake! Hey Snake, over here! HEY SNAKE!"
gravitica 5 months ago
why hell do hi tech robots sound like cows
81188 5 months ago
why hell do hi tech robots sound like cows ?
81188 5 months ago
i like sunny, "whats one more smoke gonna hurt," UHH UHHH THIS IS A NO SMOKING FLIGHT!!1
Mrzzzwhatupify 5 months ago
otacon put in that work on naomi. otacon finally got some cudii
preetyboy798 5 months ago
man i HAAAAAAAAAATE Naomi, she cant be forgiven after mgs1!!!
kojimapie 6 months ago
Laughing Octopus is the prettiest.
colinsilver105 6 months ago
All I can say is.....%^&$ yeah, Otacon. Knew you had it in ya.
MordvsTheWorld 6 months ago
0:28:08
"Oh hey. This is pretty neat. I'll just stuff this right up my ass.....Aaaah. Just like old times....Okay, let's roll."
MordvsTheWorld 6 months ago 5
@MordvsTheWorld You are a champion.
wilybobonut 6 months ago
otocan you dick :) hahaha lol
bloodblaze1995 6 months ago
I want to have the same nano machines that quickly heal damage to the body!
granadapilipinas 6 months ago
@ 1:12:44 Splinter cell
W4RH0US3 7 months ago
nice game
zaya567 7 months ago
Why is otocan so awkward
xXOlSkool7SqXx 7 months ago
what is the second bar underneath his health? The one that is split up.
xXOlSkool7SqXx 7 months ago
@xXOlSkool7SqXx that's the PSYCHE gauge
HeavenHellGate00 3 months ago
A quick question, why do these Gekko's sound like cows or bulls?
jcdgcrh 7 months ago
@jcdgcrh As far as I remember, there is an optional codec call somewhere in the game that informs you that they were fitted with cow hearts to power their organic parts (mainly the legs) which explains both why shooting their legs hurts them so much, and why chaff grenades don't totally knock them out, like with the mini geckos.
As for why then they actually make the noise of an animal that they possibly have the heart of? I'm not sure, to make them freaky and frightening to PMCs/rebels/etc.?
RichPlaystation 7 months ago
ohh, yeah.. hehe.. i was playing against Laughting Octopus for the 1st time... and i saw MK2 flying around... it was like.. "WTF?! O.o" ;D
paulosbruzzi 7 months ago
when i first saw octupus in there i was like aww fuck imma have to fight this thing then after the cutscene i was cool i dont have 2 then i was like FUUUUUUUUUU-
crashyboi 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
thumbs up if you were looking to naomi's tits all the video
gvallef 8 months ago
Comment removed
gvallef 8 months ago
Why does it feel like Raiden is herding cattle? Wonder why im thinking that...
MsGhoulz 8 months ago
@MsGhoulz Maybe cuz the Gekko sound like cows? lol O_o
RavenSolidus 8 months ago
hah johnny is amusing XD
xxxanimelovahxxx 8 months ago
atleast he finally got it.
LaDouchey6 9 months ago
Haha, That was the longest period of sexual tension I've seen in a lifetime. Otacon and Naomi were ridiculous.
Rioku914 9 months ago in playlist G A M E S 2
@Rioku914 i think otacon is in love with snake
MrPs2masters 8 months ago
@cubex55 Excuse me, I've been having this problem lately, I'm not sure if its my headphones or the audio from the video. But there have been moments, probably only in the scenes on the airplane/mission briefings, but when the camera moves off center and the audio fades fast. Like I could barely hear it. it only happens with these videos, but I haven't seen any comments related to this issue so it might just be me.
Rioku914 9 months ago in playlist G A M E S 2
@cubex55 Excuse me, I've been having this problem lately, I'm not sure if its my headphones or the audio from the video. But there have been moments, probably only in the scenes on the airplane/mission briefings, but when the camera moves off center and the audio fades fast. Like I could barely hear it. it only happens with these videos, but I haven't seen any comments related to this issue so it might just be me.
Rioku914 9 months ago in playlist G A M E S 2
@R thats part of the game... the audio gets lower to make it more realistic or to make it simplier if u were snake thats ho everything would sound to u ... if otocon was talkin and ur in a flashback or lookin at a comp screen during mission briefing.... then its cuhz ur more focused on whats in front of u besides whos talking to you
SolidSmurf91 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Rioku914 thats part of the game... the audio gets lower to make it more realistic or to make it simplier if u were snake thats ho everything would sound to u ... if otocon was talkin and ur in a flashback or lookin at a comp screen during mission briefing.... then its cuhz ur more focused on whats in front of u besides whos talking to you
SolidSmurf91 8 months ago
why dont people call me and say how to use somethin' when i pick it up? :(
Laeviatin 9 months ago
24:05 camel toe
VasherPC98 9 months ago
That helicopter must see it's fair share of white stains: Raiden bleeding and Otacon havin his world rocked in it....
comicblondie 9 months ago
wait a sec what do the four thin bars belown snake's life act as?
TheSuperGamefreak 10 months ago
3 cheers for badass raiden
TheSuperGamefreak 10 months ago
that laugh from octopus is gonna haunt me...
He11buster 11 months ago
Nothing but respect for u taking the time to play an upload but u do suck..appreciate the effort but u oughta work on ur skills bud
fashonblyl8 11 months ago
is snake a virgin?
Kipiloji 11 months ago
oh my god, shut up Drebin... I killed a boss, launder her shit for me, just don't give me some bullshit backstory that I didn't ask for whenever I take down a boss, jesus christ...
Nixel85 11 months ago
what difficulty are you playing on
lucyteale 11 months ago
hehe at 58.58 :D Hideo realy has it going...
Dirkdzentli 1 year ago
Greatest fighting scene in a video game
131093720 1 year ago
Is it just me, or does Niaomi HUNTER look like Zoey from Left 4 Dead?
cccaymol 1 year ago
Snake ANSWER ME SNAKE!! SSNNAAKKKEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!
InuyshaThug 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i wanna see every mgs ever made, startin from its days on the msx, remade to next gen standards, and sold (along with mgs 4 maybe) on the next gens as one big mgs uber collection boxset!!! if you agree, then copy and paste this comment everywhere there are mgs fans, and spread the word, and maybe we can make it happen!!! for mgs fans everywhere!!!!
D0S81 1 year ago
that's how you do it, hold out until the little whore makes the 1st move herself.
good show otacon.
KMFCM 1 year ago
i KNEW IT, Raiden does have a gun. 500 bucks in the bank for meXD
prylprylen 1 year ago
i dont get it did she die or fall asleep?
prylprylen 1 year ago
does anyone know if there is a walkthrough where the whole game is played by young snake
saydsidi223 1 year ago
At certain points, like when the characters speak really low, I wish there could have been subtitles. But, for the most part, it's fine without. Thanks for uploading this.
IcedCandies 1 year ago
is it worth buying this game?? is it larg enough n does it take time to finish????could anyone tell me this plzzz...
bjking007 1 year ago
@bjking007 you'll enjoy it . I never played the other MGS games (shame on me) and I enjoyed this one *thoroughly* !
Rizzy786 1 year ago
wat was Otacon goin 2 say 2 snake after he began fightin' Laughing Beauty?
patrickriley360 1 year ago
weird guess they chose to look her Accent in this game.
BMan100 1 year ago
Otacon got laid :P
MrSuperpanjames 1 year ago
"you sound like a ninja"
"exacly!"
Katzonaza 1 year ago 3
1:40:00
Civil disobedience. That's a no smoking area.
Suzaku000 1 year ago
i'm glad this otacon lad lost his virginity at last,he seemed like he needed to at his late 30s anyway.. but it was worth the waiting if the ride is naomi.
jitsuX 1 year ago 3
@jitsuX id wait for her
welshwizy 1 year ago
@jitsuX Didn't he, you know... Have sex with Emma's mother?
NYYankees4240 1 year ago
@NYYankees4240
Yes. And Emma drowned in a pool while Otacon was having sex with her.
Suzaku000 1 year ago
@Suzaku000 Yeah and wasn't it because his dad and and basically committed suicide? I forgot to be honest.
NYYankees4240 1 year ago
@NYYankees4240 Yeah, Otacon's stepmother seduced him and they had a relationship. When Otacon's father Huey Emmerich, who appeared in Metal Gear Solid Peace Walker, found out about the affair he committed suicide by drowning himself in their pool almost taking Emma with him.
ScarPredator040365 1 year ago
@ScarPredator040365 Yeah I thought so. I was mostly trying to prove the person wrong who said something about Otacon finally losing his virginity.
NYYankees4240 1 year ago
@ScarPredator040365 naise ...
MrSuperpanjames 1 year ago
@ScarPredator040365 wait doctor strangelove seduced huey
doodlemanthethrid 1 year ago
@ScarPredator040365 wait mean't to say otacon
doodlemanthethrid 1 year ago
He's only got three months left on the meter; cut the patronizing, oppressive anti-smoking message already and let the man have his fucking cigarette. What difference could it make?
ThatGuyWithTheHat 1 year ago
The obsessive soda drinking is retarded and unnecessary.
frankm5150 1 year ago
Telling Snake he cant Smoke here hurts his psyche as much as telling him he will be al walking biological weapon in 3v Months?XD
Okami531 1 year ago
Why Is Every One Posting Comments Of Naomi And Her Boobs? >:O *A Few Mins. Later* DID YOU SEE NAOMI'S BOOBS?!?!
GrimSkey 1 year ago
HAHAHA....Git'r done otocon. 1:36:54
TheRunningComedian 1 year ago
Thats odd... i just noticed that Sunny doesn't studder when she sings, only when she talks.
TheRunningComedian 1 year ago
1:07:18
marbenjamen 1 year ago
they could of made naomi boobs bigger
31bank 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
what do the beauties do to you if you do nothing?
Reik45 1 year ago
"ironic, you've become a doomsday device" Yeah thanks to your shitty virus Naomi, don't go making Snake feel like shit you cold-hearted bitch >=(
NickStedmon 1 year ago 17
@NickStedmon ..damn
killernarwhal117 4 months ago
I never really looked at her in that light. But Naomi looks damn good. :XD
outlawstar15a2 1 year ago 7
Damn, that look he gives her when she calls him Old Snake...fucking ice cold. I love the chemistry all the characters have with each other in this.
tsubodzuka 1 year ago 4
1:07:18
iamboythegirl 1 year ago
so wait.....the system went down....and then when the soldiers got up they were zombies? or at least acting like them?
Vailhaveblueskin 1 year ago
Comment removed
ArcturosMengsk 2 years ago 2
He smokes "The Boss" brand.
AlphaOrigin 2 years ago 4
@AlphaOrigin like a boss^2?
ridjf 1 year ago
Dang Otacon did she need to club you on the head? Well at least he finally joined the mile-high club I hope he didnt do a Forrest Gump!
kejaris 2 years ago
1:13:55 that's one of the boss'es in metal gear2
Jason7745 2 years ago
something i like about raiden is hes kickass now
USAlover6 2 years ago 5
The songs are the same... Sunny's melody is the same as the song the member of the resistance is whistling.
AceGikmo1990 2 years ago
ew that's a lot of throw up there...
camel toe at 24:05 lol
evice 2 years ago 6
Naomi has nice cleavage. hehe.
Trcls 2 years ago 20
@Trcls
In MGS, everyone does. Except Rose and Olga. Especially Olga.......eww....armpit hair. But Naomi........I'd tap that. Just kidding.
HankJKennyton 2 years ago
hey @ 1:00.00 that's was better than ninja assassin lol
jamewoong 2 years ago
so what happens if the beauties get to u ?
gogetemson 2 years ago
they hug you to death.
no really
Kiyosuki 2 years ago 4
hehe somehow i figured STDs that killed u after the game was over
gogetemson 2 years ago
Metal Gear Solid without Snake is not Metal Gear Solid
DankillerGTAhero4 2 years ago 15
If it can be a Metal Gear Solid .. while I write the script Kojima may be .. no matter what a true hero ... the saga continues Fan protagonist does not matter .. the real fan cares about history
MGSSolidRaiden 2 years ago
You said it, my friend. The creators all care about MONEY!!!! Big Piles of MONEY. Videos games are really the next way of storytelling. Schools should make students do game reports, by playing a game, and write dow stuff. That way, we can play games and do homework.
AJ15ist 10 months ago
@AJ15ist Thats true, Movies a Video Game today no make any distinction, a Game is capable to convert in a Movie with a Good Storylne, There are many examples, like Heavy Rain, mgs3, mgs2, mgs4, etc, I can continues with the list But there are infinite videogame that look like moviez...and you idea of the sutendent make game reports... I hope God will listen
MGSSolidRaiden 10 months ago
mgs shud b only for ps !
Devilikg 2 years ago 6
Comment removed
Devilikg 2 years ago
ppl was sayin some time in 2011 or in tha late 2010..but is it really comin out 4 xbox??
BigB51974 2 years ago
What about the Metal Gear game for X360 starring Raiden, any idea when its gonna be released?
KonChul 2 years ago
supposedly next year
IndianHawk34 2 years ago
Ok. Thank you for replying,. :)
KonChul 2 years ago
ähm ....1:46:59 ???? lol
ridi5852 2 years ago
it likes showing her but alot
8492troop 2 years ago
i thought naiomi was british ?!
allanoliver1690 2 years ago
Why do they run away when the boss makes the Black cloud? Does it hurt them?
chingvang559 2 years ago
no idea at all dude
allanoliver1690 2 years ago
Raiden is a noob, he can not fight... see MGS 2
Yuramasaki 2 years ago
YOUR WAY BETTER AT THIS GAME THEN PORTABLE OPS xD
littleaskater137 2 years ago 9
I love how raiden went from total suck to Holy Shit its Raiden! lets go in that dark room and breathe heavy until hes gone. lol
Cocaine804 2 years ago 53
lmao so trueee
chuckn11 2 years ago
@Cocaine804 I saw the whole of MGS2 and Raiden wasn't total suck IMO. He was slightly annoying and naive, but not terrible. He was different from Snake and that was good in the way of see things from another perspective for once. But there's no denying Raiden became badass here. Although his road to becoming this way seems pretty sad...
vgman94 1 year ago
@vgman94 "pretty sad" is an understatement referring to his wifes 'miscarriage' and breakup along with him having the upper half of his skull and his spine being removed from his normal body and grafted into a robot. While, iirc, he was kept conscious throughout the process. Or something.
=P
SatsugaiKaze 1 year ago
@SatsugaiKaze ... That must've sucked.... Although we won't know if he was conscious or not until Rising comes out.
vgman94 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Really disappointing that you don't even try for the stamina kills, takes me out of it.
Nictusempra 2 years ago
OMG snake kicks so much ass
Errorcode55 2 years ago 9
Hurray for unnecessary cleavage! :D
LoNgShOt5250 2 years ago 72
i hear that lol EVA's in snake eater is by far the best so far lol
frankyh101 2 years ago
@LoNgShOt5250 No such thing
robzored 1 year ago
why doesnt snake use the CQC stuff in MGS1 & 2 ?
CALIBUROUS 2 years ago 2
He explains that in an easter egg message to otacon. He didn't use CQC because it reminded him of Big Boss who taught it to him and betrayed him, but when he sees soldiers using it so badly he can't resist.
Manofaction0 2 years ago
@CALIBUROUS he does
allmet2 1 year ago
i want this game in PC games, many people dont have the ps3 to play it, we knows that Sony pays the exclusivity of this game in his ps3 plataform.
the game is only debeloped for the motor graphics of a ps3...but maybe in a future, MGS4 cames to the games for windows.
trinch17 2 years ago 8
it won't, if it was going to then it would have been announced already, the game has been out a while now and the developer has moved on to other projects, like mg:raiden and peace walker
nayte23 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
PS3 IS THE KING OF ALL CONSOLS
littleaskater137 2 years ago
damnit woman, just let him smoke
trammelant 2 years ago 2
serious its funny to see that evrytime snake wants to smoke som1 else comes to stop him :P
trammelant 2 years ago 6
every mgs is filled with at least one really (!) hot chick.
Xkl1 2 years ago 10
dis game is 20 bucks in futureshop should i get his or 007
akaniger 2 years ago
this one!
Xkl1 2 years ago
because the gekko is part horse
joshuaprado1 2 years ago
@joshuaprado1 really? i thought they were half-kangaroo half-Mac computer
Vailhaveblueskin 1 year ago 2
OLD SNAKE!!!!OMG!!!XD
quellechit 2 years ago 2
Why is blood coming out of the gekko?
kingofcupcakes 2 years ago
It's probably either fuel or hrdraulic fluid
xlxbigcat95xlx 2 years ago
its fuel.
jordancayco 2 years ago
1:45:53
GrayFox932 2 years ago
OTACON 'S GETTIN POONED!!!!!
ALEXTHEALEXNATOR2 2 years ago
i wish i had mgs4
MegaHodhod 2 years ago
Lol at 145:53
She hurt his Feelings
wedgeboy 2 years ago
I wonder if in a japanese movie someone shows a finger everyone else has to explain that it is a finger and why it was shown for half and hour?
hhhhhhyy 2 years ago
And Otacon Gets Laid!!! :P
xemnus950 2 years ago 5
I just realized you can see Octo-pussy's... pussy... I think they threw it in as a James bond reference/
LawietStandard 2 years ago 2
Didn't Naomi have a British accent in MGS1? Oh well, she got much hotter atleast.
SeeeeeeeeeK 2 years ago 12
haha ya!
thxnola 2 years ago