Scottish republican socialist Peter Dow, author and protester

[mccrie407]

interesting

[IYukonI]

If you're a Scottish Republican why do you carry around the Scottish Royal Standard?

[ScottishRepublican]

@IYukonI Why could not a Scottish republic decide to use the Lion Rampant as its state flag? No reason not to. So I am suggesting we could. Indeed I am claiming as a Scottish republican we are right to claim all symbols of the Scottish state as properly in the hands of republicans who are better for Scots than royalists.

I have sent you a link to my web-page "The functions and duties of a Scottish National Standard Bearer" on my Scottish National Standard Bearer website at "SCOT. TK"

[ScottishRepublican]

@IYukonI Although I did ask you a question, actually I don't want to have a debate here. Instead I would invite you to register a username in the For Freedom Forums and discuss these matters with me there.

Web address of the For Freedom Forums -

"FIGH. TK"

[theshark2005]

GREAT VID FIGHT MY FRIEND FOR YOUR COUNTRY AND ONE DAY IT WILL BE FREE!!

[MrGoofySkull]

the new william wallace

[GrinningSceptic]

Peter, I think you should be the President of Scotland.

[MrScottishJamie]

if snp loses Labour wins and that is worse some independence for scots is better than none at all

[ScottishRepublican]

@MrScottishJamie Scots always lose elections rigged in favour of the Queen who always wins.

The good news is that we Scots can gain some independence but only if we don't surrender to the Queen's First Minister or Prime Minister.

If Scots use our independent mouths to ask our Scottish military to kill the Queen and any Winsdor coming to Scotland then the Scots can win and the Queen will lose.

[ScottishRepublican]

@MrScottishJamie Discuss all this in the For Freedom Forums - figh. tk

FIGH. TK

Register a username for the forums and join in the debates in the "The Shite Paper" forum.

[scottishchap2008]

scottish independence sounds great but real independence not fake EU style independence were unelected beurocrats rob us of our wealth

[ScottishRepublican]

@scottishchap2008 The real robbery is by the Queen's kingdom whose officers rob us of our freedom, civil and academic, to create the wealth in the first place.

OK the EU bureaucrats don't help any but we need to see the Queen as the number one enemy and fight for a Scottish republic.

Anyway, don't discuss it here. Instead register a username with the For Freedom Forums - figh. tk - and discuss it there. Your invite message is on its way.

[uweregreat]

i was in the "British" army and i have never felt so wrong in joining! i joined because Scots were dieing and i felt it was my duty to help my fellow Scots - ill be your sniper! lol

Salmond is a joke. SNP is a joke!

there is no need to have a Queen that shouldnt be there in the first place, if there was to be a royal family then follow the stewart line to Italy!

But there is no need, im sick of being LIED to!

[ScottishRepublican]

@uweregreat Excellent James - with two snipers we can set up a crossfire that should keep the royal family pinned down for a wee while anyway. lol

There's a real need for Scots to elect a Scottish president and that must be someone who is up to the job of president as head of state in place of a monarch.

I have a lot more to say about that in the For Freedom Forums - your invite to register a username at figh. tk and post your comments there is on the way.

[SNIPERSTEVE23]

A Scottish republic has been a dream of mine for years but the British goverment just doesn't care about Scottish independence they just brush away our peoples dreams and lie bully and bribe us every chance they get.When comes down to it all the Uk goverment cares about is the money and the armed forces that Scotland can give them i feel like our national identity is being slowly taken away from us. FREE SCOTLAND to hell with the scottish political patries like the snp we need something new

[ScottishRepublican]

@SNIPERSTEVE23 Ah just the man I was looking for.

I have long asked myself - "where is a republican sniper when I need one?" lol

[kilomeister]

lion rampant. the monarch's flag. aint no lions in scotland.

[ScottishRepublican]

@kilomeister Well the Scottish head of state has always been a monarch because Scotland has always been a kingdom.

But now is the time to modernise ourselves and elect a president of a republic - then the head of state can keep the same flag if the constitution says so - the lion rampant - and the Windsors will have no right to the flag, if they ever did which I doubt since we Scots never voted for the Windsors, not once.

[dutchrepublican64]

Tiocfaidh àr là !

Soar Alba

[RemeberLoughall]

Keep up the good fight , Lad.

TAL

[RemeberLoughall]

More power to you. Why did you hide the faces of the two peelers who took you to the pen?

[ScottishRepublican]

@RemeberLoughall Thank you my friend. The video was initially recorded by me from a TV broadcast - BBC2 Scotland, December 2008. The hiding of the faces of the police officers was done by the BBC prior to broadcast.

The director's original cut shows the police faces, as does the version on DVD.

More worryingly the UK police are taking actions like arresting people who film police brutality so as to hide the evidence of police wrong-doing. It is a royalist, fascist police state.

[ScottishRepublican]

@stiffmajjthegiant However, OTHER people organising a bigger anti-monarchy demo with their choice of speakers BUT REFUSING TO INVITE ME ONTO THE PLATFORM TO SPEAK has been tried already in 2004 on Calton Hill for the Declaration of an Independent Scottish republic.

So numbers alone cannot win a republic. I offer the needed republican INTELLECTUAL leadership which is NOT to be found in Scottish political parties NOR on Scottish university campuses at the moment, sadly.

[ScottishRepublican]

@stiffmajjthegiant If you watch this video carefully from about 7:42 you should be able to spot a large banner behind me and a few people holding the banner upright, and a few smaller placards as well.

So I was not the only demonstrator who was penned in on the day. Yes I would have liked to organise more people and had even more of an impact but although I offered leadership other supposedly "republican" groups refused to follow my lead and were doing other things on the day.

[Ulitedify]

(soz, run out of space), I support a free, independant scotland and a united island, and allow england to be rid of a fasicist dictator (who as it happens is more german than english). I am considering leaving the labour party but that is a different story. I've enjoyed talking to you, good luck.

[Ulitedify]

I agree with you, I'm too a socialist and a repuclican, but im english so maybe that should be taken with a bucket of salt

[ScottishRepublican]

Ulitedify - You agree with what I, Peter Dow, said in this video, with my ScottishRepublican comments here or with what?

You didn't seem to agree with my DumpPalin comments about Harriet Harman. So you can't just "agree" with me always.

Well English socialists and republicans should be taken equally seriously but obviously the English have the final say over what happens in England not Scotland.

Please register with the For Freedom Forums - figh. tk - link in the video's (more info).

[NEG2009]

Monarchy been gone. you don't even realize it. no body cares about the Buckingham palace occupants. they aren't passing any legislation. gosh. you all act as if there is a problem... but there isn't much of a problem. this isn't a dictatorship.. get over yourself.

[ScottishRepublican]

NEG2009 - Wrong. Monarchy is gone in the United States where you are and you get to elect a president as head of state.

Where I live, Scotland, we are ruled by the United KINGDOM which has a monarch as head of state.

The video is specifically complaining about who occupies the head of state role in the Scottish Parliament, Holyrood, Edinburgh.

There's bad legislation and courts ignoring good laws because we don't have any president to stop them.

It's a royalist fascist dictatorship.

[Offtofott]

I do believe that Scotland will be Independent. Why? Among other things, because my children and my grandchildren believed too.

[cuimhnichbasalpin]

You do believe in the good in human nature. I would say that corruption and failure is more rampant in republics than in constitutional monarchies.

I do respect your effort and beliefs.

That is what democracy is about.

Shame the way you were treated by the old Bill. They are a brainless lot.

Take it as a sign that they fear you.

Good luck with your struggle though.

The act of union was a coup. I doubt Scotland will ever truly be independent.

[ScottishRepublican]

cuimhnichbasalpin - It is for ME to say what I believe in. It is for you to say what YOU believe in.

I believe Hitler was human and there was no good in him.

What "constitutional monarchy" There is only a CONSTITUTION FROM HELL and the Queen's officers do whatever the hell they want to do to people.

Monarchy - rule by one. Democracy - rule by ALL the people. CHOOSE!

You country is Sweden? Thank republican Finland for defending Sweden's borders from Russian/Soviet empires then.

[ScottishRepublican]

cuimhnichbasalpin - When the enemy is at the border it takes more than A DANCING QUEEN to stop them!

[ScottishMTB]

Can i ask why you were banned as a student and threatened with life Imprisonment?

[ScottishRepublican]

ScottishMTB - Oh you can ASK without getting jailed for life imprisonment. The Queen's judges want you to think Scotland is a free country so they don't stop YOU asking.

It is only ME who gets jailed for life if I ANSWER your questions.

The best I can do is refer you to the public record - newspaper clippings which you can read on my website. I can email you a link to click to the correct web-page if you tell me your email address in a YouTube message.

[ScottishMTB]

So how often do you protest/demo and where abouts do you do it?

I'm down at the Scottish Parliament often and i have to say i have never seen you.

When is the next time you're going to hold a protest/demo?

Thanks

[ScottishRepublican]

ScottishMTB - Since I have been able to afford a home internet connection for nearly two years, I now demonstrate my politics mostly on the internet - in my own website & forums and in other public forums where I am allowed to post.

I have a 24/7 home front window display advertising my website too.

Before then when I only had limited internet access via the local library and college, I used to strap an advert board to my back with bells whenever I was out - again to promote my website.

[ScottishMTB]

Ah okay. That's good. I'm in support of Independence myself and i'm in support of MSP Alex Salmond. I've met Alex on several occasions.

I believe Alex Salmond has Scotland at his heart and really cares about Scotland and our people. I don't know why you dislike Alex Salmond as i have only seen three of you're videos. I will continue to watch more of you're videos.

[ScottishRepublican]

ScottishMTB - I attended a Stop-the-cuts protest in Aberdeen in 2008.

My protest against the Queen at Holyrood shown in this video was in 2007.

Before that I attended the anti-G8 Auchterarder/Gleneagles protest and the Make Poverty History demo in Edinburgh 2005.

In 2004, I protested at the Aberdeen Council Town House against a proposed NF march.

In 2004, I protested against the attendance of the Queen for the opening of the Holyrood parliament building and at the Mound in 2003.

[ScottishRepublican]

ScottishMTB - In 2003, I protested at R.G. University, Aberdeen at being banned as a student.

In 2002, I protested at the Aberdeen Sheriff Court House about being required by a Sheriff to attend for a compulsory examination by a court appointed psychiatrist.

Before 2002 I protested against the royalist fascist police state.

Before being threatened with life imprisonment at the Supreme Courts of Scotland in Edinburgh in 1995, I protested at being banned from Aberdeen University.

[ScottishRepublican]

jaguarclaw - That was nothing. The police get away with treating you much worse when there is no camera there, then they can tell lies about it. It is not just the bad police here it is the way the courts and the politicians back up the bad police.

Well look we can widen out the discussion but not here on YouTube.

Please register and post your comments in the For Freedom Forums (4ff. co. cc click the link to the right of the video) which is a better forum for a wider debate.

[Emergency739]

Continue the good work Peter

Perseverance counts!

[ScottishRepublican]

Emergency739 - Thanks Daniel. Check your YouTube Inbox for a long message from me inviting you to register with the For Freedom Forums.

Or click the 4ff. co. cc link to the right of my video and then click on "Register" in the For Freedom Forums menu.

[EquusFerrarius]

I fail to see how this republic will be all that different from our current system. We currently vote for elected officials to run our country. We also have a Royal family who play an entirely ceremonial role, getting rid of them is merely a change of wall paper. I'm not sure the Queen is quite the fascist dictator you think she is, and as far as I am aware the TV channels in the UK do not promote a "royalist" agenda.

[ScottishRepublican]

EquusFerrarius - Democratic republics are very different because the head of state, an elected president, is NOT entirely nor even mostly ceremonial but heads the state ensuring that it is democratic, dismissing Prime Ministers and their governments who allow the rise of a fascist police state which enslaves the people.

So PM Thatcher, Major, Blair & Brown would have been sacked in a democratic republic. Likewise with the rotten Scottish First Ministers.

The royal family are always on TV

[EquusFerrarius]

They are on TV, but not displayed in an overly flattering light. I am not so naive as to not know what a Republic is, I just don't think a democratically Elected Government with a figure head is all that different to a democratically elected government without one. There is nothing to stop the UK adopting a presidential figure into it's government system. The presence of the Queen is not the problem, the Problem is the lack of a President. There is nothing to stop us having both.

[ScottishRepublican]

EquusFerrarius - Now you are beginning to annoy me. I already said the job of elected president is not a just a figure-head who rubber-stamps the parliament's choice of Prime Minster but someone who sends fascists like PM Thatcher back to parliament as ordinary MPs.

Now unless you can get the simple point that every prime minister of the UK you have ever heard of would have lasted no more than a few days in office and then would have been sacked by a good president I am going to end this.

[ScottishRepublican]

EquusFerrarius - Electing members of parliament does not make for a democratic government.

Hitler's regime was rubber-stamped by a rigged referendum when all opposition was in concentration camps or dead.

Now take note of this - you had better start thinking laddie or you are out of here.

[ScottishRepublican]

EquusFerrarius - Wrong. The existance of the UK is the problem. It is called a kingdom and kingdoms have kings and queens as head of state.

You want to get a republic you need to get rid of the kingdom and the easy way to do that is to remove, execute, send into exile the monarch.

[EquusFerrarius]

I am sorry if my humble opinions have annoyed you, and I don't understand what you are saying about presidents "rubber stamping", I never claimed this was a presidents role. The existence of the UK is not a problem, it's just a state, a name given to a land and it's people. We can have a president as well as a Queen and parliament. We need to add a president to our system. The removal of a monarch is not necessary, so long as the monarch has no actual say in the government.

[ScottishRepublican]

EquusFerrarius - If you were truly sorry you would not keep annoying me by repeating wrong points in a forum which is unsuitable for a lengthy debate.

You don't understand because you don't have a political education worthy of the name.

There is much for you to read in the For Freedom Forums and I will answer your points there.

The name "United Kingdom" is exactly the problem and if the state were called "The Republic of the Britain" you can be fairly sure we wouldn't have a monarch.

[timalloy67]

your spot on with your beliefs, there are far too unionists in scotland, fuck the queen, ALBA GU BRATH

[ScottishRepublican]

What a mess! I deleted a comment by mapmanic by mistake. Here it is!

"Come on, man, you're supposed to know your place. Scotland is England's lapdog. As long as the Scots are loyal cannon fodder, they'll get the crown's table scraps. Be satisfied with your lot, man. Don't rock the boat."

Then I replied to his comment as "WeLoveCondi". Oops!

[WeLoveCondi]

mapmanic - Well the English get the same wrong end of the cannons and table scraps as we Scots by and large.

Neither Scots nor English should be satisfied with our lot as subjects of the UK crown.

It was a King's captain who "rocked" the Titanic and cost British and American lives.

Yet American presidents keep inviting monarchs to the White House.

These days we are dying because Arab monarchies who Obama bows to have set their Jihadi dogs loose.

Do you like your scraps Yank?

[mapmanic]

Ah, yes, I didn't realize the English are victims of monarchy too. I usually think of them as being perpetrators. What's the stats on public support for the monarchy these days south of Hadrian's Wall?

[ScottishRepublican]

mapmanic - 100% of the English watch similar TV to the Scots.

Telly tells us to support the monarchy so most do. Same as American TV tells you the Queen is nice and harmless so heck why not invite her to the White House?

However, if TV your side of the pond told the truth to our American friends that monarchy and monarch-like dictators which rule absolutely in Arab lands are fighting an undeclared war against us via their secret agents Al Qaeda the stats in America would change.

[Basit30111986]

The reorganization of British Isles:-

England

Wales

Scotland

Eire (Northern Ireland & Republic of Ireland)

Manx (Isle of Man)

Cornwall (For Cornish people)

[EquusFerrarius]

Why is Cornwall not part of England? And why should the two Ireland's be forced together against their will?

[conr16]

Its not "against their will" - The majority of people in the "Republic" want a United Ireland through peaceful means, and the majority of ULSTER which includes Donegal Monaghan and Cavan do too (They funnily enough arent included in the illegal statelet that is "Northern Ireland" - ask yourself Why? Lots of REP's perhaps?) Would you be "OK" if i took 30,000 Irish people and smacked them down in your area, then claimed that where-ever you live is now part of Ireland - ? I doubt it mate.

[EquusFerrarius]

No, that would not be fair. But Blaming the people of Northern Ireland for the crimes of their ancestors is not fair either. If the people of the 6 counties want their independence from the Republic of Ireland, then that is their entitlement, their right as human beings.

[PrincePloppy]

This video shows the absolute disgrace that is, this occupation of not just Scotland, but all the countries of the Uk, including England, by these murdering stealing unelected heads of states, the royalty!

We do not even have the right to peacefull protest, as this video clearly demonstrates. Please don't get independance from England and leave us with the Queen and her disgracefull family. She's not English!! We don't want her!!

[ScottishRepublican]

PrincePloppy - My beloved English brother, far from leaving you with the Queen I have invited you to the For Freedom Forums as a friend and as the best place, better than comments here anyway, to discuss how together we can rid ourselves, Scotland and England of the evil Queen.

The For Freedom Forums is better than commenting here my brother. I am extending my hand to you - grasp it please and register with the For Freedom Forums!

[CountryQuestion]

gaun yersel peter!

[realzoomy]

I have written to the Queen and told her about the institutional child abuse and the forced adoption industry. I am also an author and I am fighting for the human rights of children, the right not to be stolen from people who love them and be given to child abusers, using the secret family courts.

The Queen doesn't seemj to be that bothered about children, judging from the apathetic reply I recieved to my letter.

I am a survivor of the Staffordshire Pindown child abuse scandal.

[ocean3da]

I support you mate, your a Scottish republican alright!

More people with your thought is needed.

[Wyrdtimes]

Good luck with independence. This is one Englishman who thinks it can't come soon enough. You'll have to have those shysters Brown, Darling and Bliar back though.

Home rule for England.

[ScottishRepublican]

Wyrdtimes - What "independence"?

Hey good luck with that lottery win! Oh, you aren't going to win the lottery, necessarily? No, and the Scots are not going to get our independence soon necessarily either.

Not with the UK state backing the SNP on TV 24/7 we are not.

The SNP's fraudulent scheme for a referendum to cement the Queen and Windsors in place as head of a "Scottish" state denies us national independence.

Back? Brown etc are on the Scots' backs NOW but only BECAUSE of the UK.

[ScottishRepublican]

Pander8874 - Well you must have twisted and sick sense of humour if you find all the death, disaster and missed opportunities which happen in this country and around the world "fun".

The state fails to protect people and as head of state, the Queen is responsible. She appoints rotten failing PM Brown and FM Salmond for example.

You are typically ignorant and you need to get a proper education to be a responsible member of society by reading my Scottish National Standard Bearer website.

[EnglishRepublican98]

The excellent channel. But i don't agree with you when you speak that Queen would need to give 48 hours what to leave the country.

In my opinion that Queen and all her family need to be executed having hung up on a scaffold for all sufferings of Englishmen. WITH US THE GOD.

[ScottishRepublican]

EnglishRepublican98 - Kirill my Russian friend, your English is good enough to understand but not good enough to pass for an English person.

Also why do you wish to be an honorary Englishman? Would you not prefer to be an honorary Scotsman? We would be pleased to have you join us Scots.

After all, Russians like Robert Burns the Scottish poet and your navy shares the St Andrew's cross in their flag do they not?

You could have dual Russian-Scottish nationality. Would you like that?

[bayyoumi]

What a joke?

Protesting against the Monarchy with the royal standard on your shoulder and using the symbols of Monarchy such as William Wallace!

William Wallace himself recognized the Monarchy of Scotland at least. Scotland has the Monarchy in her veins.

[ScottishRepublican]

bayyoumi - Yes I am claiming the Lion Rampant, a flag of ANY Scottish state, for republicans and our future democratically elected president of a Scottish republic.

My website explains why republicans have a better claim that modern traitor royalists.

Scotland is a land and its veins are rivers and roads.

If the Queen or any royalist successor is banned from Scotland's roads and rivers, and shot on sight for defying a ban then Scotland SHALL be free of monarchy from its veins.

[ScottishRepublican]

Edit:

... better claim THAN modern ...

[ArsenalClubForever]

ScottishRepublican- And why you are assured that after revolution the authority will be received by fair people?

Recently interrogation of British in which majority of people was spent apporoves a monarchy.

[ScottishRepublican]

ArsenalClubForever - Whenever authority is not exercised by fair people then MORE revolution and / or extensive and intensive political reform is required.

If one revolution does not bring fairness then clearly another revolution is required.

There is no final "AFTER".

The majority are brainwashed by television broadcasting. If TV told them to oppose the monarchy they would.

Anyway, no majority supporting the monarchy justifies enslaving the minority who oppose the monarchy.

[TheWvvd]

haha funny vid you alone vs the queen thats hard !! my respect!!

[TheSpiaire]

No mention that Peter is in a fact a Unionist and waves the Union jack.

No mention he accused Alex Salmond of being a Fascist and condones the use of nuclear weapons.

But thankfully people like him are just a noise and no more.

[ScottishRepublican]

TheSpiare - There is mention and more in my Scottish National Standard Bearer website and For Freedom Forums of my detailed politics.

I am not "a Unionist". I wave the Union flag representing the British nation and not the oppressor United Kingdom state which enslaves Britons as well as us Scots .

Nor would I support a Scottish Union-of-the-Crowns state proposed by Unionists like Alex Salmond and other Windsor royalists in the SNP.

[ScottishRepublican]

TheSpiare - Salmond, as the Queen's First Minister and assistant butcher-of-Scots simply wants to offer the butcher Queen a Saltire apron to change into when she rules Scotland.

So it turns out Salmond is the one waving a butcher's apron but his shame is that he uses the Saltire as a butcher's apron.

Republicans want both the Saltire and Union flag to be flags of freedom which rally a fight to remove the Queen and her oppressor states from this land delivering national independence.

[TheSpiaire]

Salmond is not a 'butcher-of-Scots', it's very absurd to say so and you have nothing to back it up.

Salmond supports Scottish sovereignty, your acting like he's supports an absolute monarchy for Scotland.

Maybe you should try to learn the difference between absolute monarchy and constitutional monarchy because the power the monarch holds is very different.

If anything it's the Westminster government who oppresses Scotland, denying her sovereign rights.

Salmond is rightfully opposing it.

[ScottishRepublican]

TheSpiare - Salmond is the ASSISTANT butcher-of-Scots. The butcher is the Queen herself.

I have plenty to back that up in the Scottish National Standard Bearer website and the For Freedom Forums.

Take the butchery of the Dunblane Primary School Massacre when the Queen's United Kingdom gave a firearms certificate to Hamilton and warrants to courts and judges which denied a free press to expose Hamilton before it was too late.

[TheSpiaire]

Yes, and it was the US presidents' fault to allow Seung-Hui Cho to 'bear arms' to commit mass murder at Virginia Tech :P

Or was it some 'royalist fascist elite'?

[ScottishRepublican]

TheSpiaire - Yes ultimately the head of state (president in a republic, monarch in a kingdom) is Head of Shit Happens.

So the US President, George Bush, head of the federal US state and Governor Timothy Kaine the head of the state of Virginia share the blame for the Virginia Tech massacre.

It WAS their fault that a mentally-ill person was armed on campus while his victims were unarmed and defenceless.

[ScottishRepublican]

TheSpiaire - President Bush invited Queen Elizabeth to the White House and therefore he supported royalist fascism.

The US constitution is somewhat fascist or undemocratic in that a member of Congress requires the support of 1/3 of the chamber of to be allowed to speak and to avoid the threat of being removed for "disorderly" behaviour.

US TV broadcasting is controlled by an elite.

US public meetings are not democratic - remember that student who was tasered for heckling Kerry?

[ScottishRepublican]

TheSpiare - Just recently we had 16 dead in the North Sea Helicopter crash served up in Aberdeen by the deputy butcher Prince Charles with Salmond as assistant butcher by his side.

You can read daily in your newspaper how the Scots suffer from avoidable murders, crashes, fires, botched medical care and so on - a daily diet of Royal disasters, courtesy of a terrorist killer Queen, the butcher of Scots.

[TheSpiaire]

Seriously, you need help if you actually think the crash was orchestrated by Salmond and the Queen.

Your just like those who think the 9/11 attacks were orchestrated by the US government.

[ScottishRepublican]

TheSpiaire - Who said anything about orchestration?

I have played in a school orchestra and I have sat in a classroom when the teacher was out and the class bullies played "Hammers On" when the first person to speak was beaten up.

The UK is not an orchestra - it is "Hammers On".

How come you can spell "Seung-Hui Cho" but not "you're"?

[ScottishRepublican]

TheSpiare - Salmond opposes Scottish national sovereignty and independence and instead supports the enslavement of Scots by a Queen's state which is independent of Westminster yes but not democratically accountable to the Scots via a democratic republican constitution with rights for citizens and a head of state, a president whom we elect to defend us.

Salmond's constitution would be essentially no different than the UK's constitution from hell - rule by a royalist fascist elite.

[TheSpiaire]

A sovereign Scotland under a constitutional monarchy wont give the monarch absolute power, infact it gives the monarch virtually no power.

Look and at Belgium or Norway, it's the same thing voer there.

When Scotland is Independent, look through the constitution then, and tell where it gives the monarch absolute power.

Salmond is currently trying to get fiscal autonomy for Scotland, which is another step to sovereignty.

No republican revolution needed there.

[ScottishRepublican]

TheSpiaire - When royalist fascists like Salmond say a "Sovereign Scotland" they mean a sovereign state enslaving the nation, rubber-stamped by the monarch.

Whereas real Scottish nationalists talk about the sovereignty of the Scottish people to which the state is made accountable by a republican constitution with rights for the people including electing the president as head of state.

Constitutional monarchy is a "Constitution from Hell" under which the state has all the power.

[ScottishRepublican]

The truth about Belgium is Marc Dutroux it is not Hercule Poirot.

The truth about Norway is Vidkun Quisling.

The truth about the Danish monarchy was the whole 2 hours they resisted Nazi invasion.

etc.

It IS the same thing over here; incompetent royalist fascists in charge getting innocent people killed and competent republicans trying to have a revolution to introduce real democracy to save lives and stop the butchery.

[ScottishRepublican]

TheSpiaire - Strictly speaking "lands" cannot be independent. Lands are geology they do not go anywhere independently of the tectonic plate.

It is the people on the land who can be independent or they can be enslaved.

With regard to the Scottish nation in Scotland, Salmond does not propose Scottish national independence - in fact he is 100% opposed to the nation being independent - he wants independence specifically for the state ministers under the crown to enslave the Scottish people.

[ScottishRepublican]

TheSpiaire - The difference between absolute monarchy and so-called "constitutional monarchy" is that absolute power rests with the state and not with the monarch.

Fascists like Salmond support absolute power by the state, especially when he is the minister of the state giving the orders.

Democrats like me oppose absolute power in the hands of the state - we support government by all the people - power to the people - for example, power to elect the head of state.

[ScottishRepublican]

TheSpiaire - You keep writing about "Scotland" as an actor whereas it is a place.

If you trust a place with your money then go and scatter your pounds over the land instead of banking them.

If a royalist fascist state controls your money that is bad. If it controls your life that is worse.

We need fiscal and other types of autonomy for the people, not for the state.

We cannot trust the state with our money when the head of state is Queen Elizabeth or any monarch.

[TheSpiaire]

Scotland is a Nation.

The monarch doesn't set up the limited Scottish budget, the political parties do.

The budget is published on the internet for everyone to see.

[ScottishRepublican]

TheSpiaire - Wrong. The Scots are a nation and our national homeland is Scotland and so strictly speaking "Scotland" is not a nation, just our national homeland.

There is a Scottish nation, the Scots, but our land is called "Scotland" our nation is "The Scots".

[TheSpiaire]

Therefore Scotland is a Nation.

Just a Nation that is not currently Independent.

[ScottishRepublican]

TheSpiaire - "Scotland" can mean many things to different people. To some it means "a football team".

But to be precise, "the Scots" are a nation. We ARE a nation but "Scotland" is our national homeland. "Scotland" is not the name of our nation.

Consult a dictionary to discover the true meaning of words. Look up the word "land" to begin with.

The people most responsible for enslaving the Scots and denying us independence is the Queen and her ministers such as Salmond.

[ScottishRepublican]

TheSpiaire - The monarch ensures that most of the budget is wasted, used inefficiently by ensuring that as a kingdom with no president as head of state, the state runs its affairs incompetently and unaccountably.

For example, the political parties, agree a budget spending so much on policing, prisons and the courts, but that does not make us safe in our homes, on the street or at work or at school or university.

Instead the money for "law and order" is spent so as to enslave us.

[TheSpiaire]

Look at the budget.

[ScottishRepublican]

TheSpiaire - The Nazis had a budget for their concentration camps as well. What with all the gold, jewellery and money confiscated from the victims and working them to death as slaves, the camps were a profitable exercise, if all you looked at was the budget for the camps.

Now I am not saying Salmond is that evil but my point is if all you look at is the Scottish budget and you neglect how that money is often spent to make Scots SUFFER, you are looking at the wrong thing.

[Patrick1844]

I agree. Someday Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland will be a republic. There should not be British rule in them. The people of the 3 countries should have there own democracy. No British power in them.

[EquusFerrarius]

They are British countries you know.

[conr16]

free ireland free scotland free wales, fuck the brits! (goverment & queen & elite - not BRITISH people!)

[EquusFerrarius]

Irish, Scots and Welsh are British people, British is just a term derived from the names of this Island group.

[CountryQuestion]

Keep at it! one day we will have a Scotland free from foreign rule.

[TheBritishWatcher]

Lmao, "foreign rule" get real

[KirillMockowRussia]

Each Person has the right to the opinion.

[CondiFan]

In my opinion Spain and Great Britain should be republics.

PEOPLE SHOULD BE FREE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[ScottishRepublican]

CondiFan - I agree!

You would be very welcome to register with the For Freedom Forums.

The For Freedom Forums have quite a number of Scottish and British republicans (though we could do with more) and we have a Spanish republican who has registered and posted but we do not yet have a Russian republican who has registered on the forums.

So you would be the first Russian - and most welcome!

I will send you a message with links to the forums.

[ScottishRepublican]

CondiFan - Oops no I can't send you a message because you have closed your account - what a shame since all the Condi Rice - Sergey Lavrov videos you uploaded have gone too. :(

Please come back CondiFan - and stay the next time!

Why is the carnival over?

"The Seekers - The Carnival Is Over.(1968)"

watch?v=nze8B39OB0k

[CondiFanSite]

My account was removed by my cousine.

Because she harmful.

I was in hospital for six days on treatment.

now i shall load again my videos.

[ScottishRepublican]

CondiFanSite - My friend, I am sorry to learn that your health is not good and that you have to be in hospital so much.

What is your illness? Have you been poisoned while drinking tea with Andrey Lugovoy?

[ScottishRepublican]

CondiFanSite - Protect your account by being sure to log out before you go off line.

Also do not tell your cousin your password!

Be assured that your work of uploading Condi videos has not been wasted because I have enjoyed watching them and I have even downloaded some of them.

Thank you very much my friend.

[KirillMockowRussia]

I am not " CmdiFan".

[RadicalWhig]

There is a very strong case for a Scottish Republic. The President should not be an executive (like in the USA or France), but a mainly symbolic figurehead with some check-and-balance powers (like in Ireland, Iceland, Austria, Finland).

[ScottishRepublican]

RadicalWhig - Hmm. I am not sure that the presidents of Ireland, Iceland, Austria and Finland would like to be described as "symbolic figureheads".

If any of those countries was threaten by invasion for example, and the president ordered that country's miltary to defend the nation, "symbolism" won't do the job.

The army needs to follow the orders of the head of state.

[ScottishRepublican]

Damn! YouTube won't allow me to post an edited version of the above comment and so I can't correct my spelling of "military".

This forum is useless for a proper debate therefore this discussion needs to go to a proper forum like the For Freedom Forums.

[ScottishRepublican]

RadicalWhig -

Scots and Britons rights have already been abused by officers of the state, and our rights denied (because we are afforded no rights by the courts under the UK with its "constitution from hell") all in the name of a symbolic head of state - Queen Elizabeth.

We need constitutional rights actually defended by a good president, if necessary by commanding the military to defend our rights against attacks on our rights.

Commanding the military is an executive function.

[ScottishRepublican]

Debate this in the For Freedom Forums!

[EquusFerrarius]

That's essentially the system we have now, but rather than a president as a symbolic figure head we have a monarch.

[CAZG09]

am with you on the FUCK THE QUEEN policy!

[Medeasbiggestfan]

If Scotland ever became independent, it would be cheaper to keep the Queen than have a President.

[ScottishRepublican]

Medeasbiggestfan - The true cost of the Queen to the Scots are disasters, deaths and missed opportunities.

The Queen is to blame for

- the Dunblane Primary School massacre, Piper Alpha and numerous other accidents and murders

- the ruination of the Scottish universities as key wealth generation institutions.

A good Scottish president who could avoid these terrible costs of a rotten head of state would be worth his or her pay.

[Medeasbiggestfan]

How is the Queen to blame for Dunblane, Piper Alpha or anyother tragedy?

[ScottishRepublican]

Medeasbiggestfan - In brief, the state which the Queen is head of, enables those disasters instead of preventing them.

I have written a detailed explanation in my website the links to which can be found in this video's (more info) details, to the right of the page.

Click on (more info) and scroll down to "ADDITIONAL LINKS" and you will see two links I added just now (1) The Royal Disasters & (2) Dunblane.

Read it then discuss it in the For Freedom Forums.

[DundonianFilmMakers]

can say i agree with him on everything, but he has a good point.

[Kane9378]

lol this guy's funny

[sookitandsee]

oor Pedro is quite a hero

[papaKarloBurateeno]

Peter. Queen very old. What sense to protest against her?

[ScottishRepublican]

papaKarloBurateeno - The monarchy and the Kingdom is even older and all are in the way of republics for the nations.

Old or young, do nothing or actively doing the wrong things - in every case, the monarch must go and be replaced by a good president.

I write and protest because that is all I can do. Still I am often prevented from doing my duty.

If I were in a Scottish republican army I would fight to remove the Queen from Scotland and establish a republic.

A kingdom makes no sense.

[papaKarloBurateeno]

And on What money there will be a Scottish republic??????? On What there will live inhabitants of Scotland?? In your country there is no enough gas and oil. And poor people happy cannot be.

[ProAmericanBriton]

papaKarloBurateeno - Certain economies like Saudi Arabia, Iran and Russia make most of their money from oil and gas exports.

Most developed economies are not so dependent on oil or gas.

The skills of the Scottish people to produce a variety of products and services are enough.

papaKarloBurateeno if you want to discuss Scottish or international issues, here is not the right place.

Please register for the For Freedom Forums and discuss there. Links in this video's (more info) details.

[papaKarloBurateeno]

Well. OK. Queen a witch. Right. And why u dont protest against Toni Blair and Gordon Brown? Blair the supporter of a monarchy.

And why all dung shoud clean Elizabeth.

[ScottishRepublican]

papaKarloBurateeno - Monarch, not "witch".

The UK state prevents effective high-profile protesting against the Prime Minister of the day but PM's are appointed by the Queen - it is HMG - Her Majesty's Government.

I do what I can against the PM in my website - see (more info) for links.

You Russians did not clean the Tsars with dung but killed them with bullets. Good move.

I would agree with giving the Queen a one-way ticket to an Ekaterinburg cellar. LOL..

[TheBritishWatcher]

lmao this video made me laugh. The bit at 6:30 is very good.

Atleast you are honest about your intentions unlike the separatist SNP who are closet republicans but dont have the guts to take on the monarchy and union at the same time.

All you separatists will be stopped =)

[ScottishRepublican]

TheBritishWatcher - You are quite wrong on many counts.

The SNP under Salmond are honestly supporting the monarchy and the union of the crowns and they do not support separation from the UK monarchy any more than the Australians or Canadians are separated from the Queen as their head of state.

The dishonestly of the SNP is when they describe their union-of-the-crowns referendum plan as an "independence" referendum when it does not offer genuine national independence - that's the SNP lie.

[ScottishRepublican]

TheBritishWatcher - The only sense in which the SNP are separatists is when they support separating Scottish intellectuals like myself from mainstream institutions like universities and political parties so as to silence criticism of their mismanagement.

In this video, I was separated from the crowd and it is gagging like this, or more oppressive suppression involving arrest, torture and imprisonment which is the only kind of separation the SNP support.

[ScottishRepublican]

TheBritishWatcher - Separatists have never been stopped - they have always ruled the UK.

Whether Conservative, Liberal, Labour or SNP government - all have separated intellectuals from the national discourse and this video of my first speaking appearance on British TV in my 47 years of life was a rare exception to the separation rule.

All royalists fear open debate. All use violence to impose a mono-culture of support for the monarchy.

[DeepSixed300]

A triumph.

[bcnsco]

No mention of Mr Dow's love of the union flag... some republican.

[ScottishRepublican]

bcnsco - Oh just call me "Peter" LOL.

I didn't edit the film. I have a UF in my home front window but in the scene showing my front-light going off at night 03:21 the director chose the angle which obscures it.

I have already explained why republicans should take a relaxed attitude to the UF in my video "Peter Dow (on radio) re: Union flag in Scotland".

So long as the UK is dead the UF is no threat.

I am not relaxed about FM Salmond using the Saltire as a new Butcher's Apron though.

[bcnsco]

The UK isn't dead though Peter - it is very much alive and well. So THAT flag remains a symbol of Scotland in the union - a symbol of unionism!

"FM Salmond using Saltire as a new Butcher's Apron..." that rag the union jack is called the butchers Apron as it was flown by Britain around the world as it oprresed and killed people in the name of the empire - in India, Ireland or in our very own highlands. As far as I'm aware our FM is not engaging in such activities under the Saltire.

[ScottishRepublican]

bcnsco - The UK is not dead but blame supporters of Queen Elizabeth and the Union of the Crowns such as FM Salmond.

The SNP continue the UK but try to put a kilt on it by using the Saltire as a new apron for the same old butcher, Queen Elizabeth.

Scots have been oppressed or butchered by that cunt Queen and her state. I have been tortured, jailed and terrorised.

The Queen's FMs are forcing freedom-lovers to display the union-flag in order to rally Britons against royalist fascism.

[vickskedoedoe]

Alba needs a woman, mo charaidh ;-)

Not another man.

[ScottishRepublican]

vickskedoedoe - And that's the official view from Belgium is it? So is Belgium offering to send us a woman then?

Aye well maybe that is what Alba needs but Alba is not the only one who needs a woman considering my single and looking status.

That is not an invitation to discuss my sex life here - any woman curious or offering should send me a private message.

[GlobalPunditOrg]

awesome work. awesome awesome work.

[ScottishRepublican]

Happy Christmas everyone.

You can download this video from my website - see this video's (more info) details for the link.