So I Thought - Flyleaf

[RobbiesaurusRexx]

People are so immature... I'll be honest. I dont beleive in god. Yet i love his song, so what she says jesus? At least it sounds good :|

[79beastman]

This song gives me goose bumbs every time!

[vampirexknight123]

I love her so much... If she actually would have said yes,this would have been our song... :/

I always have to cry when i hear it... but it kinda heals my heart <3

[Sillilesshells]

correct me if i'm wrong but i swearr theres another evrion of this song that i like much better. is there another version?

[s1rmarcos]

@Sillilesshells theres another version from when the bands name was "passerby"

[catycat19]

I had I guy who make me fall in love of him and he just broke my heart and found another girls... that is his actually girldfriend... but now I'm happiedr than I was before... this song makes me want to cry... but tears don't fall....

[TronicaTheHedgehog97]

I had a boyfriend who had passed away because of a car crash. I listen to this song. I never forget him.

[brandym7891]

This is beautiful! My boyfriend and I are going through a rough time and I feel this song says exactly what I feel.

[raicas11]

This is song is beautiful. It kind of reminds me of people I miss...all our memories. It kind of makes me cry but when I'm sad this kind cheers me up...I love this song.

[kityyslam]

kiss the stars with me..

[HumanBassCannon]

The harmony in the middle makes it so much more powerful. <3

[zanderpearce]

i love this song, except the jesus part ruins it. not because of my beliefs about jesus or anything, just because it automatically turns the whole thing corny.

[XalonewaitingKairiX]

@zanderpearce Same. I also think that it just suddenly stereotypes the song, and transforms it to a song restricted to being a god-believer even though I know its not meant to be, but to me it just feels that way. It sort of ruins the song for me because there are people with other religions out there too.

Like, you hear this beautiful song, then out of no where you where "and jesus fell in between!"

btw not trying to bash or anything, just saying.

[xohollisterchic]

we say to those who are in love, it can't be true cause we're too young. i know that's true because so long i was so in love with you, so i thought.

deep shit man.

[crazyisgood4u]

i couldnt understand half the words she said! c:

[DarkwaveDuck]

@crazyisgood4u lol at first i didnt either

[RandomEmoGirlLovesU]

it reminds me of him

the man who ruined my life

but then I look at the man beside me

and I'm so happy that I have him by my side.

[DeathcoreSoftie]

@RandomEmoGirlLovesU

It reminds me of her

The girl who sent me into depression

But I look at the woman beside me

and now I'm happy I have her by my side.

[Pterotrochej]

I'd listen to this song again and again few months back, when my girl left. It's funny. She found a new place in town, found a new man and I fell for my long time best friend. It feels like it's been forever since the break up. Hope you'll find what you're looking for, dear. I do. I'm gonna miss your smile

[JesicaYesicaRosa]

I really hope I'm not coming here in the near future to listen to this because of breaking up with my boo :/ God, I love that boy to death.

[alliewebbs]

This song.. <3

[TBndr]

i am singing the male line , then i woke up ! fuk ! :)

[youknowyourrite1]

does the intro riff sound sort of "asian" to anyone else here?? i've listened to this song for years but that's all i can think when i hear it.

[ryanpet266]

@youknowyourrite1 Nothing can ever sound "Asian"

[youknowyourrite1]

@ryanpet266 someone give this guy a gold star and a pat on the back.

[electricrose2468gir1]

:(



[henj38]

Wow. its been a week since anyone has written a comment...

NOT ANYMORE! GO FLYLEAF!!!! LACEY, KEEP ON SINGING, BUT ESPECIALLY SCREAMING!

[BigAwesomeSexiBeast]

Thank you flyleaf. You're making me cry all over my keyboard!

[Zeldamarzii]

Oh god this song makes me wanna cry who is singing the male line???????

[tgiemilee03]

This Is So Beauitful!! :'( </3

[Lyanias]

Can't stop myself listening to it on repeat.. beautiful song <3

[bgf1992]

"the times werent right" i miss my ex. we were just together at the wrong time but at least it was GREAT while it lasted. :) hopefully one day... :)

[TheASB37]

<I3 10.13.2008 :( 

[Parkstuhh]

I'm a Atheist and i LOVE Flyleaf, and also The Devil Wears Prada, i just like the powerful lyrics involved in christian music, all i listen to is Post Hardcore, but this is the ONLY band that's a exception, because they're simply the best.

[bennysbar]

beautiful song!!!

[ddffmmaanngguuyy]

for so long i have been listening to a different version of this song

[Emmeroo7]

I wanna cry

[AlexVonVanity]

"hurt the first,the last, between" </3

[UniteInPurple]

this song is so powerful. o_o

[creeper2176]

I love to listen to this song but everytime i listen i cry no matter how hard i try i cant forget that person that meant so much to me :(

[thegreatabiss]

I love this song...it's nice (:

[N3CR1S]

absolutely fantastic song, with the best guitar solo I have ever heard. I have loved this since the first time I heard it.

[pjonsonfilms]

Mine and my ex-girlfriends song, makes me cry cause I miss her

[totallyspazzedout]

where's the love button? this is one of the best songs by flyleaf. :)

[adamwelshlovesjesus]

@totallyspazzedout dont u mean this is one of the best songs by anyone!

[totallyspazzedout]

@adamwelshlovesjesus YES! lol(:

[chubbycrow]

i love the guitars for this song. that intro is what makes the song and my teen years for me. memories.

[metamorphisis94]

the lyrics of this song are wrong...

[mckennacullen]

well like back in april my bf cheated on me and stuff and denied it all right? so now thats its july he finally says hes sorry. like shud i take him back but i kinda dont think its a good thing cuz he goes out with any scene/ emo girl and im emoish and stuff and i dont wanna get huert again :/

[2reckless4you]

the people that thumbs down this song are assholes!!!!!!!

[2reckless4you]

i hope this song isnt telling the future of the girl i like. cuz if it does ill be heartbroken....... this song tells about what sooooo many ppl have gone through. but fucking chick flicks always make these kinds of things have a happy ending. NOT EVERYONE HAVE A HAPPY ENDING

[17candysweety]

75% of your lyrics are wrong bro.

[BoredemxXx]

Love this song,but it reminds me of my ex.. Who i now hate :)

[sexypanda50]

this is one of the best songs in the world this song literally saved my life

[IvanShitsPonys]

I love this song. Its really good.

[MissUnique97]

ive replyed this song 50 times , now and it reminds me of what i had with my boyfriend FMYLIFE .

[Pedraocmb]

it seems paramore..

[OMGiTSrazZY]

@Pedraocmb It's not. haha(: Paramore is good but not THIS great, if you ask me.

[PerryNae]

I love this song i remember the first time i heard it i was around 14, it has a complete different meaning now.

[PerryNae]

I love this song i remember the first time i heard it i was around 14, it has a complete different meaning now.

[beansontoast15]

wow.. thats some strong messages in that <3.. i miss my best friend</3

[emoraine]

when i made this video i was so so so inlove with her

but my ex-girlfriend has other boyfriend

i dont know it

and then the time has come

she broke-up with me

i didn't cry i dont know why

i listen to this song repeatedly

but still i can't cry :(

[emoraine]

i just love her so much :(

but now i've moved on

i have now a special someone that i know

that i can have eternaly *blush*

and that she love me so much

[tabbyque]

@emoraine Someday someone will walk into your life and make you realize why it never worked out with anyone else~

[Fmalover41]

@tabbyque

That is so sweet.Thank you for that quote for everyone.

[Munchers1991]

@emoraine good for u. ☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺

[Imissyoucupcakegir]

@emoraine

If you can't cry it's because you miss her so much...Don't let your break-up cloud your mind...talk about it with someone and you might cry then..

[Munchers1991]

@emoraine thats how i feel bro its like im invisible

[THRBIGFLIRTT]

@emoraine i feel your pain:/ i wish you best of luck with this girl or anyone else.. if she cheated on you then she isnt worth your time anyway.. things will get better<3

[fantagegirl255]

@emoraine i think i have your answer. since u cant cry i think either you are VERY in love with her or u arent in love with her at all. you need to try to move on and if u cant you should tell her.

[Pedraocmb]

@emoraine what if i told you I can help you get your ex-girlfriend back??

I'm a trained pickup artist.. if I just discover three things about her I can tell you exactly what will make her completely fall in love with you.. send me a message.. good luck brow

[Raskar485]

I can relate this song to my failed marriage. I listened to this song so many times and it got me through. I was young and in love with the idea of being in love, now I know better.

[frukna01]

this song helped me make my decision to leave my friends and family and move on

[ParamoreFreakje]

I wanna marry her, seriously.

[FakeSmiles4U]

flyleaf is always there for me. </3

[superhuman295]

is it weird that music like this helps me feel better about writing movies?

[hopeallstar13]

its such a good song.it says that watever happens i will always love u and take care of u. it reminds me of the past present and future so much. it makes me wish i could love

[ParamoreLover1901]

She's such a inspiration.

She gives people hope, and strength.

I feel God's love when I hear her.

She is an Angel from God, that's for sure.

I

[LiveYourselfOut]

i cry ...everytime i listen to this.. just makes me think of my dad, he was my bestfriend and now hes gone ..he died a year ago and im 14.. its rough but i know hes looking down on me smiling so imma just smile back , i love you father <3

[Ejisqx]

This song gives me an iron taste in the back of my throat and reminds me of the days when nothing seemed to get better and the lives of the friends that have been lost along the way. I'll remember you forever, thought I never knew you as well as some did.

RIP Joe and Ian.

[SeanUrrutic]

i love that song i can so relate that to my shattered soul that still crying in the corner

[siltahmatari]

This song makes me believe that there is still hope for my shattered soul.



[5456hsb]

This song shows how much Love there can be in a relationship that has been lost and broken. Whenever you miss that person that you belonged to and you think of them all the time, it explains at the last two verse (4:05) In all these twisted thoughts I see, Jesus there in between. <3 That Completes Me.

[Leone982]

My favorite song from Flyleaf.

[RubyBearCub3]

Flyleaf and other bands like this have inspired me to create my band... ^_^

[xRGmw2clan]

my band are new.. we have two or three gigs lined up two of which in the next two weeks one of which on friday... my first gig crapping it... were covering this first ... then monsoon by tokio hotel 2nd then core of my addiction by fireflight 3rd and in the dark 4th... 1st and last are the best songs... both flyleaf... gona get a pit on in the dark :) wish us luck

[cyclonescythejutsu13]

this song is so happpy.

[franylikespurple]

i dont think i could talk about it.. :/ 

[inferno233]

Sooo much emotion is in this song....I just love it...Best song ive heard in a long time

[Brea2luv]

what is this song even about?

[Ejisqx]

@Brea2luv What does it make you think of? That's what it's about.

[xHeMakesMyHeartSmile]

Who Is The Guy Singing With Lacey ?? Is It Pat Or Sameer?

[hist0ry0fthish3art]

this song has been in my head all day(:

[telephonepaparazzi]

i love love love it. i'm a huge fan of flyleaf. flyleaf's music is so real <3

[SpySaysMentelgen]

13 people cant talk about it...

[Freddy3740]

Anyone know who the guy is singing in the chorus?

[posionqueen]

this song reminds me of some thing else

[helladerrick]

sike! they rock with satan for jesus lol

[ChublumpVer92]

this song is amazing! They Rock For Jesus!!!!!!!

[SerinaRawrz]

This song is so beautiful, if wish i could sing like her... :)

[omgwtcurgay]

me && my ex use to sing this song togeder.... D: i guess we were 2 young.

[CoheedAndCalcium]

@JOLLYJOEY101 Flyleaf has a EP album where its just different versions of songs off there Flyleaf album, and i think that's why you heard 2 different versions

[NicoleLivesForever]

this song gives me really noticable goosebumps

[razisaspaz]

I'm not religious in the slightest, but this song never fails to cause emotion everytime i hear it...it's truely beautiful.

[PigSandwhich]

If you took this song, and interpreted the meaning so it wasn't about God (whom I do love) it would describe my feelings.

[creeper2176]

This Brings Back So Many Memories From The Past..

[shezadreambandit329]

i listened to this song the day my best friend died....i've always used flyleaf's music to fall back on...they remind me there is a god....♥

[heroineadict]

@shezadreambandit329 Is there? tell him, or her/it if you prefer, I said hi when you get the chance.

[poptropica747]

@shezadreambandit329 but there isn't a god...soo....awkward

[xxhollydaniellexx]

@poptropica747 That reply makes me wonder if you're ten.

[poptropica747]

@xxhollydaniellexx nope. thirteen. how does that make me seem ten???? it's true there is no god. well that's what I believe. crazy christians can believe whatever they want. whatever helps them sleep at night. lol :D

[xxhollydaniellexx]

@poptropica747 It's not that you don't believe in God, I couldn't care less. It's just what you commented to one who does believe in God. Bite your.. fingers.

[poptropica747]

@xxhollydaniellexx ok well i'm sorry. i'll keep my opinions to myself next time :)

[Calvin0135]

I love the instrumentation of this song, the delay/reverb/chorus/flanger in the guitars make it so atmospheric. Melodic yet ambient.

It makes me feel like I'm soaring gracefully through a night sky lit by streaks of aurora, or in space with supernovas in the backdrop.

Can anyone recommend any other songs like this? It's almost like Space Rock.

[joebrospwnsall]

Thumbs up if you ever lost the one you love, and turned to God for support.

[jesusmusicaholic]

Honestly, this song fits me perfectly. I went through a rough spot, and then found out that through it, I found God all the stronger. Jesus was there, in between.

[MyPancakez]

Its weird how all the memories can be made into this one single song </3

[xxDiiamondisHerexx]

Some of The Lyrics are Wrongg....

[XxForgottenBulletxX]

"Fight the tears with pretty smiles and lies about the times..a year goes by and i cant talk about it"  soo relates to me.

[mariamabdulle]

omg...i never heard such a beautiful thing in my life

[iiShadowLunatic]

.....I ....♥

[CapeCookieTV]

Flyleaf is the first band (and i know a LOT of bands) that has songs with such beautiful and emotional lyrics..

[rocketpowersss]

@CapeCookieTV srsly? lol. the first band in the world to have beautiful lyrics? wow....

[AznTwilight]

I'm pretty sure this song, in the meaning of love, is to be interpreted by someone going through something difficult with someone else and then looking back upon it. The song simply deals with the feelings of nostalgia, melancholy, regret and how people try to deal with it, e.g. the memories. Thus the 'a year goes by, and I still can't talk about it.' Nonetheless it's especially for young love, because it's your first and you'll always remember it. 'I was so in love with you, or so I thought.'

[NinjaBananaMonkney]

I love lacey :) she sings with so much emotion and she's always just herself. <3

[CanadianIdiot13]

My ex showed me this song when we were together. Reminds me of how fast "a year goes by".

Yeah, don't miss that cunt. But this is still a clever song

[sadsatan13]

i love flyleaf this song is the best song in the world

[theonekari]

this song is about LOVE .. weather its religeaus or not.

and it reflects love, all the hurt and beuty in it.

that is wat makes this song so unequally emotional, beautiful and soul-touching!

... said by only a child ... (goes to show how deep this song is)

[shelbyrhodes44]

This song has many meanings to me :) i love this song so so so much...

[NeadyNerdAwesomeness]

<3 :D A year goes by and I can't talk about it. :'(

[zahralioness]

This song reminds me of someone crying and trying to get her feelings known, and then, when the guy joins her, she realizes she's not alone, and that he understands her.

[MissPsychadelic]

It's about whatever it means to you.

For me, it's talking about lost love, and she's trying to find her loved one again. Not Jesus.

[drummerboy41096]

@MissPsychadelic alright, how can you say that this doesnt have anything to do withe god. It says Jesus in the song, like twice

[cookiessaymoo]

This Is me and my best frends song he always sings this to me ['; i LOVE him to death buh he has a gf T_T

[zahralioness]

My favorite song... I love the mood, the message, the lyrics... it all just makes me want to curl up and cry (a good, healthy, cry) <3 So powerful <333

[Regis305]

Its all about Jesus

[txlivenlocal]

choris romance was a dallas band. some are in a band called bravefellow and some are in a band called pale horse.

[velicitygirl321]

Where the hell do i get this version no one has it, all i can find is the live sounding one i dont like it

[boonaga911]

@velicitygirl321 ikr

[Chiricescu]

this indeed is a song for the one's that where left behind by their girlfriends / boyfriends

[theonekari]

my favourite song by flyleaf...

and the lyrics r sorta difficult 2 understand the meanin bhind, witch just makes it bettr <3 love everything bout this song...

[pakzemo]

ths is the 1 of my fav. song :)

everytime i play ths song ..

i remember my ex gf :(

damn ..

[fuckyousoomuchRAWrr]

THIS SONG REMINDS ME TO LOVE JESUS MORE DAN ANTHING , EVERYTHiNG :)

[PainStation3]

is jesus singing background vocals in the end?

[theonekari]

@PainStation3 lol... jesus dosnt sing background vocals in any songs, not this one eather ... lmao...

[piedraespumosos]

great song....but u got the message wrong. it's about leaning on Jesus.

[MimichiThatMe]

This is about Jesus ..

[KoshiroTheWolf]

The message is that Jesus helps you in tough times. Not what was put at the end of the video. -.-....

[izzabellful]

Oops 10 silly youtubers clicked the wrong thumb 

[nogiexz]

-this song is amazing thumbs up ^_^ :D

[GinaAmnesia]

I listened to this song for the first time on the same day my boyfriend broke up with me.

Needless to say, I was in tears.

[Athlete1990]

@GinaAmnesia yeah. emotional song. keep your head up though. :)

[chelstarheartful]

good job love this song!

[kyuubilinkinpark]

This song really makes me realise how much I truly love my girlfriend. (:

I never want to give her up - EVER.

I love you, Madison!!

-Skye

[DeidaraArtExplosions]

Good job un

[jolderon2]

End of 14 month relation ship yesterday

God im 16 male list time a cried was when i was 5...

ARGH the pain god i love her, this song is helping :)

[fightersanime]

This is a good song! ^_^

[sidable123]

when i hear this song it makes me want to cry. not because anything is wrong but to let out everything that went to hell in the past when i wouldnt let the tears out.

[aidens31]

Whats font called I want it xD LOVE THE SONG!!!!!

[Cindizzlee]

this is my new favorite song!! its so beautiful. <3 <3 <3 <---- thats right, it gets 3 hearts not just 1

[ferarilover]

dont hope that i like it

coz i love it

[NiqiNinjette]

That's not the message of the song. It's that she THOUGHT she was inlove with a guy, but realized later on, her real true love was Jesus. (;

[kentericson14]

nice song..!

so excellent..!

i love it..!

[1Allyne]

One of my favorites!

[sabrinag95]

absolutely beautiful *wipes away a tear*

[HomonousNocturna78]

Dis iz amazing yet it makez me depressd i listen 2 it wen i lyk sum1 or wen im jus rly sad kuz i kan never get sum1

[shalke08]

@HomonousNocturna78 dont feel like that there is someone for everybody out there sometimes tho we look for what we cant have and leave what is there....think

[JRRVampire]

(looks at comments below) OH MY GOSH I LOVE YOU ALL! -group huggels- no debates on any religious views just comments about the song

[GloomyBearsOfDoom333]

beautiful *starry eyes* : )